Energy Efficient
Energy Efficient
192
After reviewing the main principles of the Eco House, this chapter will present examples
of best practices in Eco-Houses both at the international and local levels in order to study
how these principles were applied and how were their outcomes. On the International
level, experiences from India, Israil and Tunisia were chosen because they applied lots of
eco design concepts from using low embodied materials, low cost construction techniques
and climatic design tools.
On the local level, experiences of pioneer architects such as Hassan Fathy and Ramses
Wissa Wassef , together with the house constructed in Toshka and the Ecolodge of Siwa,
were chosen for the local case studies. Along with these examples, efforts like: producing
Egypt's map of available raw building material and its industries, enhancing building
bricks to come with new types of bricks with insulation materials and bricks from
industrial wastes- construction and demolition wastes- agricultural wastes, producing
Egyptian residential energy code, had to be mentioned as a serious step towards
accomplishing the Eco-Eco house.
193
5.1. INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE TOWARDS ECO HOUSING
5.1.1 MONAMA
LOCATION : Hyderabad, India
CLIMATE : Inland composite
This house relies on energy efficient design to reduce loads and, where possible, reverts to
renewable energy to meet them. The house was completed in 2001.
5.1.1. A Low environmental impact:
The underlying ideology behind the building design was to generate as low an
environmental impact as possible, within the limits of site and budget. Environmental
impact resulting from both embodied (from materials) and operational (in use)
considerations were assessed.
194
specially oriented such that these pressure differences, in combination with the prevailing
wind direction, may be utilized for continuous ventilation. There is also a ventilation shaft
to exhaust hot air located in the central part of the house, which is based on the principles
of buoyancy and venturi's effect. The open plan design supports this process by
eliminating any internal resistance to the full movement of air (Fig. 95).
125
Roaf , op cit, pp.304-309
195
Figure 91
Figure 92
Figure 93
Figure 94
196
Figure 95
Figure 96
Evaporative cooling
(Ref.: Ibid)
Figure 97
Buried pipes.
A: Inlet to circulate air 2m underground
B: Outlet for living area, with adjustable
"trunk" (Ref.: Ibid)
Figure 98
197
5.1.2 REDEVELOPED PROPERTY AT CIVIL LINES
LOCATION : Civil lines, New Delhi, India.
CLIMATE : Composite
This project explores the challenges of designing and building a house in a dense urban
setting. This eco-project includes four courtyard houses built on a street. The houses on
the north face of the street are courtyard houses leading towards gardens on the south side;
whereas the houses on the south side of the street have their gardens on the north side and
are linear. These are all large single family houses, two to three storey high.
5.1.2. A Orientation:
The general orientation of the buildings is aligned east-west, with most window openings
in the north and south faces. The courtyard houses, because of their square proportions in
plan, also face towards the east and west. The windows on these faces look into narrow
protected alleys or the small courtyard between the houses. The alley space on the west
side is shaded by retaining the wall of the original double-storey building that had
previously lined the side street. For the linear houses on the north side, the width of the
driveway that separates the two row of houses is just sufficient to enable winter sunshine
to enter the first floor windows. Terraces on the second floor have skylights that again
admit winter sun into the first floor rooms on the north side of the house.
198
5.1.2. C Courtyard roof:
The roof courtyard of the two courtyard houses is intended to be the main climate
response device. The hipped steel frame roof is cladded with a 20mm glass sandwich with
a reflective film and frosted underside for the most part, with a panel of transparent glass
on the south slope. This is under slung by a pair of razais (quilts), which can be pulled
across to cover the underside of the roof (for insulation) or allowed to hang down
vertically (to allow heat transfer). Above the roof is another frame in chicks (bamboo
severs), which can similarly be opened to shade the roof or rolled up to catch the sun.
The ridge of the roof is a water channel from which water overflows on to the thin roofing
membrane of stone and glass. Some water evaporates and excess water is collected at the
foot of the slope and re-circulated. This makes the roof a large evaporative cooler over the
central space of the house. All rooms communicate directly with this central space (Fig.
103, 104, 105).
199
Figure 99
Figure 100
Figure 101
Figure 102
200
Figure 103
Figure 104
201
5.1.3 MEIR HOUSE
LOCATION : Desert Highlands, Israel
CLIMATE : Arid, with hot and dry
summers, cold winters.
202
5.1.3. C Summer cooling and stack ventilation:
Although the higher windows provide solar access to the northern parts of the plan
(necessary in winter), the different height of spaces and operability enhance stack
ventilation and exhaust hot air from the upper strata (during the summer).
North and south facing windows enable cross ventilation during summer nights.
5.1.3. D Xeriscape
An intense post occupancy project was carried out to reduce by landscaping the amount of
wind driven dust. By laying stone paving, pebble ground covering, and planting drought
and salinity resistant plants, airborne dust is trapped and kept on the ground. Plants are
drip irrigated by a computer, providing a relative humidity sensor by-pass to the automatic
operation mode126.
126
Roaf , op cit, pp.330-343
203
5.1.4 TUNISIA SOLAR HOUSE\ PAVILION
LOCATION : Tunisia
CLIMATE : Pretty warm
204
5.1.4. C Underground duct
A cooling chimney is integrated by way of an underground duct which pulls air from a
shaded area about 30m from the pavilion. The air crosses under the garden about 80 cm
below and is refreshed by the cold and humid soil above. The inlet into the pavilion on the
north side and an air flow was added later to blow air near the ceiling of the sitting room,
with the aid of a 30 W fan. However, operation of the underground duct when night
ventilation is active has shown to be disadvantageous. This is because room air in the case
of night ventilation is cooler than blown air from the underground duct.
The actual trombe wall with its thickness of 35 cm is a bit excessive. For this wall, double
glazing is of little help and is not cost effective. Thermal insulation is decisive for the
average level of room temperature but thermal capacity allows for the temperature to
remain stable127 (Fig. 110).
Figure 108
Ground Floor Plan
(Ref.: Ibid)
127
Roaf , op cit, pp.388-393
205
Figure 109
A: East side
B: West side
(Ref.: Ibid)
Figure 110
206
5.1.5 OSBORN CLAASSEN HOUSE, TUSCON,
Figure 111
Construction materials View of Osborn house (Ref.: Wilhide, op cit)
The rammed-earth construction of the house further emphasizes the site sensitivity and the
architect’s exposed intention to create a building that was rooted in the context and culture
of its surroundings. The soil used to construct the house was not drawn from the site, but
from three different sources in the immediate area-soils chosen for their color and
structural integrity. These were slightly moistened, mixed with a small amount of iron
oxide pigment and 3 percent Portland cement, and compacted into thick forms. The
unreinforced exposed rammed-earth walls sit on concrete stem walls and spread footings.
The north and south walls are 2 feet thick. The softly warping ‘butterfly’ roof is made of
weathered steel, extended out over the rammed-earth walls to serve as weather protection
and to shield the veranda from heat and sun. Interior walls, where they are not made of
exposed rammed earth, are of painted drywall on steel studs, and the floors are of polished
natural gray concrete and the windows are double-glazed128.
128
Wilhide, op cit, pp.52
207
.
Figure 112
View of the house with its background
(Ref.: Ibid)
Figure 113
The guest room is located on the north
side of the house. (Ref.: Ibid)
Figure 114
The main living space of the house comprises an open eating, cooking, relaxing area.
The rammed earth construction of the wall can clearly be seen
(Ref.: Ibid)
208
5.1.6 PALMETTO HOUSE, MIAMI
LOCATION: FLORIDA, USA
CLIMATE: Warm humid
The plan is in the form of a cross, with the longer sides of the building aligned north-
south, and the living space aligned east-west and raised up a level to catch the cooling
southeasterly breezes. On the south side, deep eaves keep the sun off exterior walls in the
summer; awnings shade the windows so they can be kept open, even during storms. At
either end, screened porches shield interior spaces from the sun; inside, there are few
partitions or walls so that air flows freely-the main living space is an open plan
kitchen/living room/dinning room. The floor of the loft space is metal grating, which
allows air to circulate and permits light to filter through and the walls are lined in louvered
windows. Lush subtropical undergrowth shades the house at the lower level.
129
Wilhide, op cit, pp.74
209
Figure 115
Detail of vented wall (Ref.: Ibid)
Figure 116
View of the house with its surrounding
(Ref.: Ibid)
210
Figure 117
The loft space on the top level is floored with metal grating to allow air and light
through. The walls are lined with louvered windows. Plexiglas on the ceiling
diffuses fluorescent light. No supplementary lighting is needed during the daytime
in any part of the house.
(Ref.: Ibid)
211
5.2. LOCAL EXPERIENCE TOWARDS ECO HOUSING
The first Chairman's Award (which was established to honour special acheivments) was
given in 1980 to Hassan Fathy, an Egyptian architect, artist and poet in acknowledgment
of his lifelong commitment to architecture. Early in career he began to study the
preindustrial building systems of Egypt to understand their aesthetic qualities, to learn
what they had to teach about climate control and economical construction techniques and
to find ways to put them in contemporary use. In his lifetime he designed more than 30
projects including several villages for the poor and modest private residences shaped by
his profound understanding of vernacular design130.
5.2.1. A Courtyards
One of his most distinguished projects is the village of "New Bariz" in kharga oasis.
In this project, Fathy decided to employ a system of internal courtyards as a primary
means of climate control in his design, along with shading. In his initial presentation, he
stressed that thermal comfort in the housing design he proposed depended on the natural
control of air temperature, air movement, relative humidity and radiation. Air movement
was to be generated by creating a pressure differential and by convection, utilizing the
basic physical principle that hot air rises and is replaced by cooler air to best advantage.
130
FISA and Aga Khan, (1996), “Architecture for a Changing World”, Graficas Urania, Malaga
212
His refinement, also used in the market, where cool temperatures were essentials to
preserve agricultural perishables awaiting shipment to larger markets, consisted of two
shafts. One of these has an opening facing the windward side, and the other face the
leeward side with a metal-bladed funnel pointed downward, which ensures suction by
Venturi effect. This second stack and funnel have been painted black to draw air from
below as they are heated by the sun. To add to their cooling capacity the windward towers
had straw mats hanging inside them which were damped by a hand pump at regular
intervals during the day
A shortage of viable building materials indicated a repetition of the same vault and dome
system in mud brick, used at New Gourna, with paraffin and bitumen emulsions used as
stabilizers, since the soil at Kharga Oasis is of poorer quality than that near the Nile.
The housing, had it been built, would undoubtedly have functioned equally well, but we
only have his working drawings to show us what it would have looked like.
Rather than the domes that predominate in New Gourna, he relied mostly on a "Barasti"
truss system; a lighter reed and wire frame roof that was easily built and helped to
promote better convection. The repetitive, triangular forms of the Barasti roof, topping off
the linear, two-story housing blocks, would have been as visually distinctive as the
Badgirs of the market131.
131
Steel, op cit, pp.79-84
213
Figure 118
Ground Floor
First floor
Figure 119
214
Roof plan
Figure 120
Figure 121
215
5.2.2 ART CENTER BY RAMSES WISSA WASSEF
Near the pyramids of Giza, the centre was founded in the early 1950s by the late architect
Ramses Wissa Wassef as a weaving school. It has since evolved to comprise workshops
and showrooms, a pottery and sculpture museum, houses and farm buildings, constructed
entirely of mud brick. For Wissa Wassef, vaulted and domed brick structures represented
something quintessentially Egyptian as these forms had been adopted in turn by
Pharaonic, Coptic and Islamic civilizations. The choice of this traditional technology also
reflected his desire to transmit the values of handicraft to succeeding generations in a
rapidly industrializing country. The jury commended the centre for "the beauty of its
execution, the high value of its objectives, the social impact of its activities as well as the
power of its influence as an example"132
Scale 1:200
Figure 122
Section and plan for the art
center in Haraneya
(Ref.: FISA, op cit)
132
FISA, op cit
216
Figure 123
Different shots for the
art center with its
background
(Ref.: Ibid)
217
5.2.3 TOSHKA HOUSE
A house in Toshka was built as a prototype through which several passive systems were
applied to reach an acceptable thermal performance in this region through out the whole
year using the most convenient construction method in this area and the available local
building materials. The house was built on an area of 200m2
133
ΔϴϠϛˬϩέΎϤϋϢδϗˬ"ϰϧΎΒϤϟϰϓϪϗΎτϟΪϴηήΗϰϠϋϰΟέΎΨϟϑϼϐϟϰϓϪϣΪΨΘδϤϟ˯ΎϨΒϟΎϴΟϮϟϮϨϜΗήϴΛ΄Η"ˬ(˻˹˹˼)ˬϢϴϠγΎηέ :ήϴΘδϴΟΎϣϪϟΎγέ
˺˺˺-˺˺˽ιˬϩήϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγΪϨϬϟ
218
Figure 124
Figure 125
Figure 126
219
Figure 127
Foundations and the steel reinforcement in the middle of the walls
Figure 128
221
5.2.4 ECOLODGE IN SIWA
LOCATION: SIWA-EGYPT
CLIMATE: HOT ARID
The ecolodge is a hotel located in Siwa, and it was chosen to be presented in our case
studies although it is not a residential case study and does not use electricity at all because
it has adopted a no. of eco design principles which we can learn from.
Built on the edge of the Sahara, at the foot of a mountain and next to a mirage-like lake
(that is as salty as the Dead Sea and great for the skin).134
The hotel was built using the traditional Berber techniques and architecture used in Siwa
for centuries. It is completely made out of mud, wood, straw, and salt.
The locals made everything in the hotel from the doors to the furniture by hand. There is
no electricity but night ventures are enjoyed by candlelight135. There is no telephone or air
conditioning136. The lodge even has its own organic garden where the food for all meals is
grown137.
Figure 130
Interior spaces are lit using natural day
lighting in the morning and candle
lights at night
134
http://greenthenewblack.blogspot.com
135
http://community.iexplore.com
136
http://greenthenewblack.blogspot.com
137
http://community.iexplore.com
222
Figure 131
Exterior views for the Ecolodge with its background
223
5.2.5 EGYPTS MAP OF AVAILABLE RAW BUILDING MATERIAL AND ITS
INDUSTRIES
224
AREAS
RAW
North of South of East of Delta Suez Gulf Nile valley Toshka Western Oasis and
BUILDING
Sinai Sinai – East of and Red region – Northern Coast East of
MATERIAL
Tafreea Sea South of and West of Oaynat
S
the valley Delta
Qualified for Qualified for Qualified for Qualified Qualified Qualified Qualified for use Qualified for
use in use in use in for use in for use in for use in in manufacturing use in
manufacturin manufacturin manufacturin manufacturi manufacturi manufact clay brick and in manufacturing
g clay brick g clay brick g clay brick ng clay ng clay uring clay general it needs clay brick ,it
1.CLAY and cement brick brick brick and addition of sand could also be
cement due to its used in
sensitivity to manufacture of
drying light weighted
brick(Lica )or
cement
2.LIME Qualified for Un qualified Qualified for Qualified Qualified Qualified Types of lime Aggregate of
STONE use as blocks for production of for use in for use in for use in stones in lime stones is
225
, building production of quick lime constructio lime blocks manufact northern west not qualified
stones and in concrete and lime n works works,also uring clay coast could be for use in
manufacture aggregate blocks. Also either in some of the brick and classified as concrete
of lime. since it qualified for production produced cement follows: works.Most
In case of deviates from use in of aggregate 1.Dolmite lime samples are
using the specs of concrete aggregate could be stones qualified for
aggregate in Egyptian works. Lime or lime used in 2.SlisilicϪϴδϴϠϴγ use as blocks
concrete, it standard. blocks could bricks. concrete lime stones except for
should be Best of these also be used works. 3.Sand lime those of El
taken into stones are in stones Farafra which
consideration those located construction 4.Clay lime stone could be used
that the at El Toor works but 5.Chalk lime in manufacture
increte metal area. It could away from stone. of quick and
present in be used in water sources Studies showed slaked lime
some of the manufacture due to its the following:
lime stones of quick and high ability 1.Qualification of
might react slaked lime of water first type to use
with the absorption. as lime blocks.
alkaline of Those stones 2.Qualification of
the cement could also be second and third
226
which could used in type to use as
cause cracks manufacture aggregate in
in concrete of quick and concrete works
structure. slaked lime and cement
bricks and as raw
material in
manufacture of
cement and as
stones for
construction.
3.Fourth type
could be used in
manufacture of
clay bricks
4.Fifth type
could be used in
production of
quick and slaked
lime
3.MARBLE There are There are two Qualified Of good
227
different types of for use in mechanical
types of marble:white constructio and natural
marble such with black n works. qualities.
as :El Feleto- veins and
El selsela – black with
El shabah and white veins.
they are all They are of
qualified for good quality
use in for use in
cladding and wall cladding
decorative ,entrances,
works and in stairs and in
production of decorative
blocks. works.
Of good Abundantly Qualified Qualified for
mechanical found in for cladding works
and natural Aswan and cladding and facades.
4.GRANITE
qualities. Quina ,it is works and Aggregate
red in color facades. produced from
and of very natural
228
high climatic ctors
resistivity to and found in
pressure ,it valleys , could
is not be used in
easily manufacture of
affected by concrete bricks
chemical and tiles.
factors.
Standard Unqualified Qualified for Unqualified Qualified Used in Found in areas Unqualified
specs for use in use in for use in for use in manufact of west and east for use in
deviates from construction construction constructio construction ure of banks of Cairo – concrete
specs of works and works, taking n works works. clay, Alexandria desert works, but it
aggregate concrete. into due to the concrete road and it is could be used
used in consideration deviation of and sand qualified for use in plaster and
5.SAND
concrete particle its particle bricks. in construction mortar works
works, but it gradation and gradation works such as: or as additives
is suitable for avoiding mud from concrete works- in manufacture
mortar and and soft standard mortar and of other
plaster works, substances. specs, plaster- as an construction
or as an But in besides additive in materials such
229
additive in general it containing manufacture of as clay ,
manufacture could be used high clay, concrete concrete and
of clay,sand in mortar and percentages and sand bricks. sand bricks.
and concrete plaster works of mud and
bricks. White or as soft
sand is additives in substances
abundantly manufacture which may
found and it of concrete reach 11%.
is known for ,sand and
its high purity clay bricks.
which
qualifies it
for use in
glass
manufacture.
Qualified for Un qualified Qualified for Needs to Qualified Salisilic gravel
6.GRAVEL
use in for use in use in redo its for use in is qualified for
AND
concrete concrete concrete particle concrete use in concrete
GRAVEL
works, except works due to works, except gradation works, works,but the
SOIL
that in its deviation that in since it except that carbonic
230
general it from standard general it deviates in general it gravel is not
needs Egyptian needs from needs ,but ,it could
improving its specs except improving its standard improving be used in
particle for those particle Egyptian its particle paving works.
gradation. samples in El gradation. specs of gradation.
Toor of concrete
granite aggregate.
origin, those Rest of
samples are properties
qualified for are
use in qualified
concrete for use in
aggregate. constructio
n works.
Aggregate is Bazalt of Abu Qualified Qualified Qualified for
produced zabal is for use as for use in use as
from bazalt qualified for aggregate in plane and aggregate in
7.BAZALT
use as concrete reinforced concrete works
aggregate in works and concrete and in road
concrete in works and paving works
231
works and in manufactur as or it could be
manufacture e of aggregate cut down to
of tiles, concrete for natural stones
concrete bricks and concrete in order to be
bricks and in in road bricks. used in
road paving. paving. construction
works.
Qualified for Qualified Qualified for use
use in wall for use in in manufacturing
cladding with manufacturi gypsum boards
plaster o paris ng gypsum and plaster of
and in boards and paris
manufacture gypsum
8.GYPSUM of gypsum walls.
boards ,
paints and
used as
additives in
manufacture
of cement .
232
Percentage Percentage of
of iron iron oxide in
oxide in raw steel
9.STEEL
raw steel reaches 74%
exceeds by weight
80%
Contains an Could be used
acceptable in production
percentage of stone blocks
of minerals. and in
Its rocks are construction
10.SAND of high works.
STONE resistivity to
decaying
and of good
mechanical
and natural
properties.
233
Figure 133
Raw building material sites in Egypt
ϖΑΎγϊΟήϣˬ˯ΎϨΒϟϭϥΎϜγϹΙϮΤΑΰϛήϣ
234
Figure 134
Building material manufacture sites in Egypt
ϖΑΎγϊΟήϣˬ˯ΎϨΒϟϭϥΎϜγϹΙϮΤΑΰϛήϣ
235
5.2.6 ENHANCING BUILDING BRICKS
5.2.6.A Studies and experiments have been held in order to find a way to combine
building materials with thermal insulation material, and the results of those studies
confirmed the importance of using thermal insulation materials with building materials.
Those special bricks have passed through laboratory experiments using five different
walls with five different types of bricks and hot box to show the heat flow and U-value
of each type of brick and results came as follows (Fig. 135):
First wall:
Was built from hollow clay brick with thickness of 25 cm.
Results showed that heat flow reached 60 watt / m2 which confirm the ability of the
brick to prevent heat flow and creating thermal accumulation in outer crust of the brick
which causes reduction of heat flow and consequently reduces the U- value and increase
the thermal resistance of the brick. Also the thermal accumulation resulted in increasing
temperature difference between layer of brick facing the hot room and middle of the
brick which shows capability of this brick, with addition of thermal insulation material,
to reduce heat flow.
Second wall:
Was built from hollow concrete blocks with thickness of 25cm.
The brick contains two consecutive voids. Results showed that heat flow reached 120
watt / m2 which indicate that it is not suitable for use in hot climates due to the increase
of U-value and its low thermal resistance which makes it incapable of creating thermal
accumulation thermal accumulation on the outer crust of the brick.
236
Third wall:
Was built from concrete bricks insulated with extruded polystyrene with thickness of
7.5cm and at 4cm away from the outer surface of the brick, it is also has two separate
voids. Results showed that this brick is suitable for use in hot dry regions since it has
low U-value due to presence of insulating material.
Fourth wall:
Was built from hollow concrete blocks with thickness of 12.5cm.
The brick contains three consecutive voids, but it was taken into consideration, when
building a wall of 25cm thickness, to alternate the void locations in order to create two
separate alternating voids of 4cm apart. Results showed that heat flow reached 29
watt/m2, which clarifies the effect of the two voids in comparison to hollow concrete
blocks in second wall. And so therefore one can say that using two voids in a brick has
good effect on decreasing the U-value, it also decreases the thermal storage capacity of
the brick.
Fifth wall:
Was built from concrete bricks made from light weighted Lyca as a substitute of
aggregate with thickness of 30cm.
This brick has three defensive lines of thermal insulating material from extruded
polystyrene, it was taken into consideration in this brick to distribute the insulating
material in a way to prevent the heat transfer through thermal bridges in the brick.
This type of bricks is constructed b interlocking without using any mortar.
The wall was reinforced by steel horizontally and vertically through leaving voids
without thermal insulation every 80cm to place the steel bars. Results showed that heat
flow reached 18 watt/m2. This type of bricks is considered very suitable since its
manufacture depends on clay Lyca, also it does not contain high percentages of cement.
The outer layer of Lyca facing exterior climatic conditions store heat during day and
expel it during night, this is due to the role of the thermal insulating material in creating
thermal accumulation.
237
Conclusion
From previous study, the following findings can be concluded:
1. Usage of building materials available in the hot dry region alone is not enough and
does not fulfill the thermal needs of the building, and therefore thermal insulation
materials should be used with those building materials in order to increase its thermal
resistivity and decrease its thermal capacity. Thermal insulation layer must be placed in
the outer surface of the wall in order to create a layer capable of storing heat during day
and expelling it during night.
2. Usage of several consecutive air voids in walls give positive results in decreasing the
U- value, it also decreases the thermal capacity of the structure and therefore the
building structure becomes convenient during night. Reflective thermal insulation
materials could be placed on the outer layer139.
139
˼˹˼-˻̂́ιˬ"ΔϓΎΠϟΓέΎΤϟ˯ϮΟϷϰϓΓέήΤϠϟΔϟίΎόϟΩϮϤϟ "ˬ˯ΎϨΒϟϭϥΎϜγϹΙϮΤΑΰϛήϣ:ΚΤΑ
238
Figure 135
Different types of bricks and its corresponding walls
"ΔϓΎΠϟΓέΎΤϟ˯ϮΟϷ ϰϓΓέήΤϠϟΔϟίΎόϟΩϮϤϟ "ˬ˯ΎϨΒϟϭϥΎϜγϹΙϮΤΑΰϛήϣ:ΚΤΑ
239
5.2.6.B Other bricks were created by HBRC in order to make good use of solid wastes
in its different forms because solid wastes are considered one of the most important
environmental problems and according to statistics of environmental ministry, the total
amount of solid wastes in Egypt reached 60 million tons annually and that included:
Industrial wastes- construction and demolition wastes- agricultural wastes…etc.
Examples of industrial wastes are:
• Wastes of ceramic tiles during manufacture.
• Wastes of clay brick industry
• Wastes of by-pass cement dust
Figure 136
Different types of bricks made from industrial and construction- demolition wastes:
First one from left is cement block that contains 25% of cement dust
Middle one is clay brick made of clay brick manufacture wastes
Last one is clay brick that contains ceramic wastes
240
Figure 137
Various types of bricks made from
demolition wastes and ceramic
wastes…etc
241
One of the most important examples of agricultural waste in Egypt which caused a lot of
troubles is “rice straw”, where the amount of rice straw reaches 2 million tons per year.
The peasants have tried to get rid of it by burning it but this caused what is called “the
black cloud” which caused lots of illnesses besides, the burning process raises the soil
temperature and emits the ammonia present in the soil and so the soil loses a great
amount of one of its most important elements.
So studies were made and the results came out as follows:
• Production of low density construction units using rice straw
• Production of thermally insulated construction units which contain rice straw
• Production of gypsum boards that contain rice straw 140
Figure 138
Thermally insulating clay bricks that contain different percentages of rice straw
Figure 139
Thermally insulating cement bricks that contain different percentages of rice straw
140
ϪϨϜϤϤϟΐϴϟΎγϷϭήμϣϰϓϪΌϴΒϠϟϪΛϮϠϤϟ˯ΎϨΒϟΩϮϣΕΎϋΎϨλϭϰϧΎΒϤϟϝΎϤϋΕΎϔϠΨϣήϳϭΪΗΓΩΎϋ"ˬ ˯ΎϨΒϟϭϥΎϜγϹΙϮΤΑΰϛήϣ:ΚΤΑ
ΎϬϨϣϩΩΎϔΘγϺϟ
242
5.2.7 Egyptian Residential Energy Code
The Housing and Building National Research Center (HBRC) and the Organization for
Energy Planning (OEP) were engaged in an effort to produce an Egyptian Code for the
residential buildings. The project intended to improve the efficient use of electrical
energy. The Egyptian Residential building code gives minimum performance standards
for building envelope, windows and openings, natural ventilation and thermal comfort,
natural and artificial lighting. A great effort has been made to ensure its applicability in
our buildings here in Egypt specifically to the general climate conditions of the two
cities, Cairo and Alexandria. For example, the exterior building envelope must comply
with the following requirements141:
244
meet the SHGC requirement.
These SHGC values are calculated including window frames
0.27 = reflective single glazing CLR 20%
0.75 = clear single glazing
SGR = percentage of glazing surface shaded from 9 am to 5 pm on 21 September.
245
R value 0.4: equivalent to: 12 cm clay brick 2cm of Plaster on both sides
R value 0.6: equivalent to: 25 cm clay brick 2cm of Plaster on both sides
R value 0.8: equivalent to: 38 cm clay brick 2cm of Plaster on both sides
(c) R value for typical insulation material without R si & Rso, are equivalent to:
R value 0.59 = 2 cm expanded polystyrene insulation with k= 0.032 W/m°C
R value 1.18 = 3 cm expanded polystyrene insulation with k= 0.032 W/m°C
R value 1.75 = 6 cm expanded polystyrene insulation with k= 0.032 W/m°C
R value 2.35 = 8 cm expanded polystyrene insulation with k= 0.032 W/m°C
If insulation is placed to the inside of the wall the R value is reduced by 30%
R value of 100 mm non vented cavities in the wall is considered 0.16 m2 °C/W
Outdoor surface thermal resistance = 0.04 m2 °CW
Indoor surface thermal resistance = 0.123 m2 °CW
246
Conclusion
This chapter reviews international and local case studies of eco houses.
It is also concerned with the local efforts made as an approach for achieving an echo
house. Those efforts were as follows:
247
6. Gravel and gravel soil:
Located in all areas except in Toshka region, South of the valley, Western Northern
coast and West of Delta.It is qualified for use in concrete works in all areas except in
South of Sinai.
7. Bazalt:
Located in all areas except in: North of Sinai, Delta - East of Delta - East of Tafreea,
Western Northern Coast and West of Delta.
It is qualified for use as aggregate in concrete works and in manufacture of concrete
bricks and in road paving.
8. Gypsum:
Located in South of Sinai – Suez Gulf and Red sea – Western Northern Coast and
West
of Delta. It is qualified for use in wall cladding with plaster of paris and in
manufacture of gypsum boards.
9. Steel:
Located in the Nile Valley, Oasis and East of Oaynat.
10. Sand Stone:
Located in the Nile Valley, Oasis and East of Oaynat. It is qualified for use in
construction works.
248
2. Usage of several consecutive air voids in walls give positive results in decreasing
the U- value , it also decreases the thermal capacity of the structure and therefore
the building structure becomes convenient during night. Reflective thermal
insulation materials could be placed on the outer layer.
New types of bricks were created in HBRC in order to make use of solid wastes, such
as:
• Wastes of ceramic tiles
• Wastes of clay brick
• Wastes of by pass cement dust
Also other bricks were made from agricultural waste such as rice straw.
After reviewing all the principles concerning the Eco Eco house, a cost analysis system
is established to help designers through out the design process and decision making.
249
CHAPTER 6
250
Studies have shown an urgent need for establishing a cost analysis system in order to
help designers reach a trade off between cost and ecological aspects during the different
phases of housing development. This earned a top priority because of all what has been
stated before in addition to the coming two factors:
1. In Egypt, buildings in general are responsible for 60.18% of the total electricity
consumption in all sectors. Energy demand has reached about 69.2 Billion kWh with an
annual increase of 7%, where the industry takes about 43%, Residential and commercial
buildings share is 42.6%, Governmental buildings and services consume about 16.7%
while Agriculture use only 4%. The two major consumers of electricity are households
and industry, followed by Government and public utilities. In order to reduce the energy
consumption in buildings, the Housing and Building Research Centre in collaboration
with UNDP&JEF. Has produced a building code to provide designers with know how
but we need to provide them also with cost effectiveness evaluation tool to help them
making decisions related to the market, the client affordability and the developments
plans drawn by the government.
142
Prof. Dr. Suzette Michel and Eng. Hend Elsayed, (2006), “Examples of low energy design at Urban scale in
Egypt”, PLEA2006
251
The thesis recommends a thorough cost analysis system for ecological houses helping
designers to decide according to checklists and choices available in each design phase.
The following is a proposal for a total approach followed by examples of detailed
modules supporting the total system that needs further development and completion in
future studies.
6.1 An integrated approach to achieve trade off between the ecological and
economical aspects of housing design
The designer is constantly making decisions as he goes through the design process.
Each decision has a cost impact that should be analysed and in order to achieve eco-
cities, eco-districts and eco-houses, additional costs might be required, therefore, a
comparison should be done between eco-design cost and the regular or traditional
design solutions in terms of costs taking into consideration all the advantages listed
previously from eco-design and the pay back that may not be instantly felt but on the
long run. The following chart proposes an approach of cost analysis following the
design phases to help defining the costs of eco-house. This system is composed of steps
following design process:
252
SITE
SELECTION
If contaminated If found
SITE DESIGN
253
SHELTER DESIGN
Choice of species sh
Choice of irrigation system w
N
COST Avoid using insecticides
Compost organic waste matter
CONSTRUCTION
GARDENING AND
LANDSCAPE Choice of species
Choice of irrigation
system
COST
ADDITIONAL
COSTS TO
ACHIEVE ECO
DESIGN
254
6.2 Cost Effectiveness Modules for ecological measures
As explained in the above mentioned system, cost analysis modules integrated with the
proposed system are needed to help designers decide about cost effectiveness of specific
design measures aiming at ecological and environmental improvement and preservation.
These modules varies from environmental impact assessment (EIA) to evaluation of
Energy performance in residential buildings, as well as evaluation of appropriateness of
different construction systems and different building materials used in residential
buildings regarding their availability and suitability to local natural conditions.
Following are some examples of cost effectiveness modules of ecological measures.
As part of developing the building energy code, the energy performance of new
prototypes of residential buildings and urban planning in Egypt was investigated
theoretically and experimentally taking into consideration the climatic conditions in
Cairo and Alexandria aiming to:
- reduce the energy consumption in buildings
- improve the comfort of the inhabitants in outdoor urban areas as well as in
indoor spaces.
- enhance the building energy efficiency leading to the quality of architectural and
urban environment.
The research used the following methodology in two stages:
First:
A field survey was conducted in both Cairo and Alexandria regions where construction
activities are very high. The survey aim was to evaluate design, construction, and energy
use in typical new residential buildings with a view to improving current building
practices and introducing new energy - efficient features through comprehensive
building code.
255
In order to have a sample representative of new construction, building selection was
carried out according to predefined sampling scheme based on primary and secondary
variables. The sample was designed to cover:
- Different zones in Cairo (Maadi, Nasr City, New Cairo …) and Alex (Agami, borg El
Arab City...).
Types of building heights (high rise: higher than 6 floors, middle: 5-6 floors, low rise:
villas of 2 floors).
- Income level (high income, middle income and low income level).
- A number of 140 buildings were surveyed, analyzed and classified into two main
patterns:
A) Introvert looking onto internal courts attached and semi detached as shown in table
23.
B) Extrovert with different shapes totally detached with low density arrangements in
sites as shown in table 24.
Table (23) Attached and semi detached introvert units143
- Rectangular
- Two units per floor
Pattern A
- Rectangular
- 4 units per floor
- 2 closed light-wells
- Buildings are attached from
the sides
The Base Case Plan
143
Ibid
256
Table (24) Detached extrovert units144
144
Ibid
257
The base case is a housing unit in an apartment building at the top floor. The total area
of the unit is 125 m2 and the floor has 4 units (see Base Case in table 20, pattern A).
Each unit has two 0.25 m thick external walls on different orientation built in cement
bricks. Windows are of single glazing, transparent and 3mm thick.
The results of the simulation can be summarized in table (25) and are shown in figures
140 to 149.
Table (25): Results of the simulation145
Cairo Alex.
50 mm poly. 39.5 37.16
Insulation
150 siliton 37.3 34.28
Light color & solar
Absorbance 31.64 33.7
Roof
absorbance= 0.3
25 mm Poly.+
Insulation 48.9 42.47
Absorbance 0.3
Shading Optional 20.67 26.76
Insulation
25 mm Poly.+ Shade 42.9 41.4
+Shading
Hclay_25 mm 8.8 7.81
Construction
Silt_brick_25mm 8.1 7.02
Insulation poly 25 mm _Mid 10.5 8.09
Wall
145
Ibid
258
Energy simulation for performance analysis was conducted using DOE2, Visual Doe
and Life cycle cost (LCC)146.
45000
40000
35000
Total Electricity (KWh)
30000
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
Base Case
Poly_25m m
Poly_50m m
Poly_75m m
Celt_100mm
Celt_150mm
Verm_25mm
Verm_50mm
Perlit_25mm
Perlit_50mm
Cairo Roof insulation Alx.
Figure 140
40000
35000
30000
LCC (LE)
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
Base Case
Poly_25mm
Poly_50mm
Poly_75mm
Celt_100m m
Celt_150m m
Verm _25m m
Verm _50m m
Perlit_25m m
Perlit_50m m
Figure 141
146
Ibid
259
1P_Clear 1P_GreyTint 1P_Blue
1P_ReflD-Clr 1P_ReflB-ClrH 1P_ReflC-TintM
38500
38000
37500
Total Electricity (KWh)
37000
36500
36000
35500
35000
34500
34000
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
PF
Figure 142
41000
39000
37000
LCC (LE)
35000
33000
31000
29000
27000
25000
Poly_25mm_Out
Poly_50mm_Out
Poly_25mm_Mid
Poly_50mm_Mid
Poly_25mm_In
Poly_50mm_In
Base Case
Wall Insulation
Cairo Alx.
Figure 143
Studying LCC and the impact of wall insulation on energy consumption shows that the
optimum wall insulation is 25 mm polystyrene mid
38000 260
37500
h)
37000
Figure 144
8300.00
8200.00
8100.00
LCC (LE)
8000.00
7900.00
7800.00
7700.00
7600.00
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
PF
Figure 145
Impact of projection factor and SHGC on life cycle cost ( LCC) in Cairo
Studying LCC and the impact of projection factor and SHGC on energy consumption in
Cairo shows that the optimum PF is 0.5m with 1P_ref B-clr H or 1P_ref C-Tint M
39000
37000
lectricity (KWh)
35000
Worest Oriantation for Cairo
261
33000
31000
Figure 146
The best orientation for Cairo and Alex is N but the worst orientation for Cairo is SW and for
Alex is SE
41000
39000
37000
Total Electricity (KWh)
35000
33000
31000
29000
27000
25000
12cm_SClay
25cm_SClay
12cm_HClay
25cm_HClay
12cm_CMU
25cm_CMU
Base Case
25cm_SiltBrick
12cm_RoseBrick
25cm_RoseBrick
12cm_HCement
25cm_HCement
12cm_SCement
25cm_SCement
Figure 146
The simulation shows that using 25 cm of wall construction is better than 12 cm and using silt
or hollow brick better than cement brick
262
1P_Clear 1P_GreyTint 1P_Blue
1P_ReflD-Clr 1P_ReflB-ClrH 1P_ReflC-TintM
43000
42000
41000
Total Electricity (KWh)
40000
39000
38000
37000
36000
35000
34000
Base 0.05 0.1 0.13 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4
Case
WWR
Figure 148
32000
31000
Total Electricity (KWh)
30000
29000
28000
27000
26000
25000
Base 0.05 0.1 0.13 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4
Case WWR
Figure 149
263
In conclusion, one can state that building energy performance is a trade off between
different design factors to achieve a target level of energy consumption that varies
according to the climatic conditions of the city. The impact of the different design
elements and measures evaluated for both Cairo and Alexandria climates show variation
giving relative importance to the different passive solutions.
6.2.2.1 Payback analysis for adding thermal insulation layer to the roof
264
Payback period = cost of insulation / energy savings
= (500*0>06*300)/ (56250*0.1) = 1.6 years
Previous studies have calculated payback back periods for adding a 7cm insulation layer
to a 500 m2 roof in different climatic regions to assess the impact of each climate. It was
found that payback period is 1.6 years in Alexandria, decreases to 1.2 years in Cairo and
0>9 year in Aswan147. According to theories, a payback is tolerable until a period of 7
years. It is obvious that the harsher the climate, the shorter the payback period.
6.2.2.2 Payback analysis for increasing glazing thermal resistance by using double
glazed panels
Calculation are made for a building envelope with 200 m2 glazing . Single glazing have
a U value of 5.6 watt/m2.C while double glazing U value decreases to 2 watt/m2.C.
Assuming the cost of 1 m2 in double glazing exceeds the cost of 1 m2 of single pane by
200 LE, and the cost of electricity is 0.1 LE/ Kwh.
For Alexandria:
¨E = 15 *200 * (5.6-2)*2500 = 27000 kwh/year
Payback = (200*150)/(27000*0.1)= 14.8 years
The payback is high and is rejected for Alexandria and Cairo (11.6 years). It is
acceptable in Aswan (8.8 years).
The thesis has reached a set of technical and strategical conclusion and
recommendations based on the literature review and the analysis of the best local and
international practices. These are summarised as follows:
147
˺˺̀ιϕΑΎγϊΟέϣˬϡϳϠγΎηέ
265
CONCLUSION:
In order to achieve an eco eco house, cost analysis chart should be applied through out
all the design phases.
266
RECOMMENDATIONS:
• Necessity of applying cost analysis for ecological design frame work through
out all the design phases.
• Directing future studies towards designing cost effectiveness modules for cost
analysis studies to help out the planners and designers evaluate the economic
feasibility and take the decisions needed.
• Providing the eco tech needed such as the double and triple glazing with
reasonable and affordable prices.
267
LIST OF REFRENCES
ENGLISH BOOKS
268
construction", Mc Graw-Hill,Inc.,New York
• Sadat city planning study group,(1986), "The Planning of Sadat City"
• Sue Roaf ,etl (2003)."ECOHOUSE 2:A DESIGN GUIDE". Architectural
Press.Oxford
• Sydney and Loan Baggs, (1996), "The Healthy House", Thames and Hudson, London
• Timothy Cochrane Ali and Jane Brown,(1977), "Landscape Design for the Middle
East", RIBA, London
• Victor Olgay, (1963), "Design with climate, bioclimatic approach to architectural
regionalism",Princeton University, New Gersey
• Yuanhui Zhang,(2005),"INDOOR AIR QUALITY ENGINEERING", CRC PRESS,
FLORIDA
INTERNET RESOURCES
http://www.lhc.org.uk/members/pubs/books/sbs/sbs04.htm
http:// www.efficientwindows.org/gtypes.cfm
http://www.habitat.org/ap/news/2004/12_02_2004_forty_students.aspx
http://community.iexplore.com
http://greenthenewblack.blogspot.com
ENGLISH PAPERS
269
ϪϳΑέόϟϪϳϣϠόϟϝΎγέϟϭϊΟέϣϟϭΙΎΣΑϷ
270
APPENDIX
271
6.Cork products
1 Boards 110-130 0.033-0.039
2 Cork granules 100-115 0.039-0.052
7.Various materials
1 Rigid rubber 1190 0.016
2 Cotton 1500 0.042
3 Textile wool 110-330 0.036-0.063
4 Hand saw 145 0.08
Thermal
Density Specific Heat
Material Conductivity
kg/m3 Joule.kg deg C
Watt\m.deg C
First :Construction bricks
1 Hollow foam 530 0.20
2 Solid foam 800 0.25
3 Hollow gypsum 750 0.41
4 Solid gypsum 950 0.39
5 Hollow lyca 1200 0.39 1000
6 Hollow clay 1790 0.60 840
7 Solid clay 1950 1.00 829
8 Solid concrete 1800 1.25 880
9 Hollow concrete 1140 1.60 880
10 ΖϤμϣ ϲϧΎγήΧ 2000 1.40 840
11 ξϴΑϑΎϔΧ 985 0.33 850
12 ΖϤμϣϱΩέϭϲϠϣέ 1800 1.59 835
13 Hollow sand 1500 1.39 811
Second :Tiles
1 PVC tiles (Canaltex) 1350 0.16
272
2 Elastic tiles 1700 0.40
3 Ceramic tiles 2000 1.20
4 Concrete tiles 2100 1.10
5 Mosaic tiles 2450 1.60
Third :Wood
1. Natural wood
1 Beech 700 0.17
2 Spruce 415 0.105
3 Oak 770 0.16
4 Mahogany 700 0.155
5 Pitch pine 660 0.14
2. Artificial wood
1 Plywood 530 0.14
2 Chip board 400 0.17
3 Conter 0.212
Fourth :Metals
1 Lead 11300 34.8 129
2 Stainless steel 7830 45.3 500
3 Zinc 7130 110 390
4 Aluminium sheets 2740 221 896
5 Red copper 8780 150 400
6 Yellow copper 8310 120 400
Fifth : Gypsum and cement materials
1 Gypsum 320 0.15
2 Gypsum boards 950 0.39
3 Portland cement 1335 0.12
4 Thermal cement 1406 0.175
Sixth : Aggregate and stones
1 Sand 1520 0.33 800
273
2 Gravel 1750 0.42
3 Lime stone 1650 0.93 900
4 Sand stone 2000 1.3
5 Marble 2600 2.6 880
6 Granite 2650 2.9
Seventh : Various materials
1 Bitumen 1055 0.16
2 ήϴΠϟΎΑϦϴθΨΗνΎϴΑ 1440 0.7
3 Cement plaster 1570 0.9-1.0
4 Gypsum plaster 1200 0.42
5 Ordinary glass 2470 1.00 750
6 Plain concrete 2460 1.44
7 Vapour barrier 70-120 0.038-0.047
Numbers shown in this table are guidance and not obligatory, they are the most frequently
used in local market.
Table (13) represents selected list of useful plant material located in northern Egypt
including Cairo and Suez area.
D/E
Classification Name Type (Deciduous
or Evergreen)
Acacia spp. Shrubs D
Agaves Succulents E
Aloes Succulents E
Drought resistant Eucalyptus citriodora Large trees E
plants ( R ) Euphorbia schimperi Succulents E
Lantana camara Shrubs E
Nerium oleander Shrubs E
Opuntia dillenii Succulents E
274
Parkinsonia aculeate Small trees E
Pithecellobium dulce Small trees E
Prosopis juliflora Small trees E
Tamarix articulate Small trees E
Yucca gloriosa Succulents E
Zizyphus spini-Christi Small trees E
Acacia spp. Shrubs D
Atriplex halimus Shrubs
Dodonea viscose Shrubs E
Eucalyptus citriodora Large trees E
Eucalyptus rostrata Large trees E
Hyphaene thebaica Palms E
Parkinsonia aculeate Small trees E
Salinity tolerant
Pithecellobium dulce Small trees E
plants ( S )
Prosopis juliflora Small trees E
Ricinus communis Foilage plants E
Schinus Small trees E
terebinthefolius
Tamarix articulate Small trees E
Taxodium distychum Large trees E
Zizyphus spini-Christi Small trees E
Azadirachta indica Large trees D
Bauhinia variegate Small trees D
Bombax malaburicum Large trees D
Cassia spp. Shrubs
Shade trees Delonix regia Large trees D
Jacaranda acutifolia Small trees D
Mangifera indica Small trees E
Peltophorum Large trees E
africanum
275
Terminalia arjuna Large trees E
Acacia spp. Shrubs D
Cupressus Large trees E
sempervirens
Screen trees
Ficus retusa Small trees E
Lawsonia inermis Small trees E
Pithecellobium dulce Small trees E
Acacia spp. Shrubs D
Acalypha wilkesiana Shrubs E
Bougainvillea spp. Ground cover E
Casuarina equisetifolia Large trees E
Dodonea viscose Shrubs E
Duranta repens Shrubs E
Hedging plants
Ficus retusa Small trees E
Hibiscus spp. Shrubs E/D
Lantana camara Shrubs E
Lawsonia inermis Small trees E
Nerium oleander Shrubs E
Pithecellobium dulce Small trees E
276
ιΧ˰˰˰˰˰˰Ϡϣϟ
ΩΑϭˬϡϟΎόϟΎΑΙΩΣΗϰΗϟϥϣΎϫέϳϏϭϪϳΧΎϧϣϟΕέϳϐΗϟΎΑέΛϛϪϳέΩϰϠϋϡϟΎόϟΑλˬϩέϳΧϷΩϭϘόϟΙϼΛϟϝϼΧ
ϥϣέϳΛϛϟϪϳΟϭΗϪϧϋΞΗϧΎϣϣϥΎγϧϹΔΣλϭϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϹϰϠϋϪϳϋΎϧλϟϩέϭΛϟϭΎϳΟϭϟϭϧϛΗϟέϳΛ΄ΗΑέΛϛϡΗϬϳ
ϰϓ˯ΩΑϟϰϟϥϳϳέΎϣόϣϟϪϳΟϭΗϡΗέΎλΗΧΎΑˬΎϫέϳϭΩΗΓΩΎϋϥϛϣϳΩϭϣϭϩΩΩΟΗϣϭϪϔϳυϧϪϗΎρΩΎΟϳϰϟΙΎΣΑϷ
ϝΛϣέϬυΗϰϧΎΑϣϠϟΕΎϳϣγϣΩΟϧΎϧΩΑϭˬΦϟ...ϪϳόϳΑρϩ˯ΎοϭϪϳϭϬΗϭ ϪϳΑϠϟϪϘϳΩλ˯ΎϧΑϕέρϭ˯ΎϧΑΩϭϣϡΩΧΗγ
ϭΎϛϳέϣϭΎΑϭέϭϰϓϥϵϝόϔϟΎΑϩΩϭΟϭϣϰϧΎΑϣϟϥϣωϭϧϷϩΫϫˬϪϳΟϭϟϭϛϳϭϪϣΩΗγϣϭϪϗΎρϠϟϩέϓϭϣϰϧΎΑϣ
ϭνέϷΏϛϭϛΫϳϥϋϑϗϭΗϧϡϟΫϩέϭρΧϙΎϧϫϥΏϋϭΗγϳΩΑϡϟΎόϟϥϷϪϣΩϘΗϣϟϝϭΩϟϥϣϡϫέϳϏϭϥΎΑΎϳϟ
.ϪϣΩΎϘϟϝΎϳΟϸϟϪϳϠϋυΎϔΣϠϟϕέρϟϯΩΣϰϫΎϳΟϭϭϛϳϹϰϧΎΑϣϟϥ
έϳϏΕϭϳΑϟϩΫϫΕϧΎϛΫϩέϳΑϛϪϣΩλϥϭϛΗγϰϟΎΗϟΎΑϭˬΎϧΗΎϳΣϰϓέΑϛϷέΎϣΛΗγϹϝΛϣΗΑΎϧϧϛΎγϣˬαΎϧϟϡυόϣϟϭ
.ϪρϳΣϣϟϪϳΑϟΎΑϭϪϳϧϛΎγΑϪϣΗϬϣ
.ϙϟΫΑϡϠϋϰϠϋϥϭϛϧϥϰΗΣϥϭΩΑϪΑέηϧϯΫϟ˯ΎϣϟϭϪϘηϧΗγϧϯΫϟ˯ϭϬϟϭΎϧΗΣλέϣΩΗϥϥϛϣϳΎϧΗϭϳΑ
.ϪρϳΣϳΎϣΑέΛ΄ΗϳϭϰϓέΛ΅ϳϪϧϛϟϭϰϣΎϣϷΏΎΑϟΩΣΩϧϋϑϘϳϻΕϳΑϟ
˯έΟϭΩΑϪϳΑέϐϟΎϳΟϭϟϭϧϛΗϟΩέϭΗγϧΎϧΩΑϰΗΣΎϳΟϭϟϭϛϳϰϧΎΑϣϰϧΑΗΕϧΎϛΎϣΎϣΩΎϧϧΩΟϧγέλϣΎϧέυϧΫϭ
ϕέρϰϓϡϟΎόϟϝϭΩϰϗΎΑϥϋϥϳέΧ΄ΗϣϥϷϥΣϧϓϰϟΎΗϟΎΑϭΎϧϳΩϟϪΣΎΗϣϟ˯ΎϧΑϟΩϭϣϭΎϧϭΟΏγΎϧΗϟΎϬϳϓέϳϳϐΗϯ
.ΎϧΗϭϳΑϭΎϧϧΩϣϟΎϧΎϧΑ
ΏϠρϟΓΩηϟϯΩΎλΗϗϹϥΎϛγϹΎΑΕϣΗϫΎϬϧΎϣϛϩέϳΑϛϪϳϣϫϥϣϪϟΎϣϟϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϹϥΎϛγϹΎΑΕϣΗϫϪϟΎγέϟϩΫϫ
ϥϣϪϣϳϳϘΗϭϯΩΎλΗϗϹϥΎϛγϹϰϓέλϣΏέΎΟΗϭΎϳϟΎΣϕΑρϣϟϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϹϡϳϣλΗϟ˯ϯΩΎΑϣεϗΎϧΗϰϬϓˬϪϳϠϋ
.ϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϹϡϳϣλΗϟ˯ϯΩΎΑϣϝϼΧ
ϰΗΣϭϊϗϭϣϟέΎϳΗΧΎΑ˯ΩΑϪϔϠΗΧϣϟωϭέηϣϟΕϭρΧϝϼΧϪΗΩϋΎγϣϟϪϳΩΎηέρϭρΧϯέΎϣόϣϠϟϡΩϘΗΑϪϳΎϬϧϟϰϓϭ
ϰϠϋυΎϔΣϟϰϓϯέΎϣόϣϟΔϣϫΎγϣΔΑΎΛϣΑϥϭϛϳϟϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϯΩΎλΗϗϥϛγϣϰϠϋϝϭλΣϠϟϙϟΫϭ˯ΎηϧϹϡΎυϧ
.αΎϧϠϟϯΩΎλϗϭϳέϣˬϰΣλϥϛγϣϕϠΧϭΎϫΩέϭϣΑϭΎϬΑέέοϹϥϣϝϼϗϹϭνέϷ
ϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϯΩΎλΗϗϥΎϛγ
ΩΩϋ
ϡϳγϧϰϣίϋϥΎϳέΎϣ
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛϰϟϪϣΩϘϣϪϟΎγέ
έϳγϳΟΎϣϟΔΟέΩϰϠϋϝϭλΣϟΕΎΑϠρΗϣϥϣ˯ίΟϛ
ϰϓ
ϪϳέΎϣόϣϟϪγΩϧϬϟ
ϰϳΑϟϡϳϣλΗϟϭρϳρΧΗϟ
ϥϳϧΣΗϣϣϟΔϧΟϟϥϣΩϣΗόϳ
ϭοϋ ϥγΣϰϠϋϰϟϭΑΩϣΩϳγΩ.
ϰγϳέϟϑέηϣϟ ϥϳΩΑΎϋΎοέΩϣΣΩ.
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛ
ϪϳΑέόϟέλϣϪϳέϭϬϣΟˬϩίϳΟϟ
˻˹˹̀
ϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϯΩΎλΗϗϥΎϛγ
ΩΩϋ
ϡϳγϧϰϣίϋϥΎϳέΎϣ
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛϰϟϪϣΩϘϣϪϟΎγέ
έϳγϳΟΎϣϟΔΟέΩϰϠϋϝϭλΣϟΕΎΑϠρΗϣϥϣ˯ίΟϛ
ϰϓ
ϪϳέΎϣόϣϟϪγΩϧϬϟ
ϰϳΑϟϡϳϣλΗϟϭρϳρΧΗϟ
ϑέηΕΣΗ
ϥϳΩΑΎϋΎοέΩϣΣΩ.
ϪϳέΎϣόϣϟϪγΩϧϬϟϡγϗ-ϰϳΑϟϡϛΣΗϟϭϩέΎϣόϟΫΎΗγ
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛ
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛ
ϪϳΑέόϟέλϣϪϳέϭϬϣΟˬϩίϳΟϟ
˻˹˹̀
Figure 54
Shows
different
examples
ϰΟϭϟϭϛϳϯΩΎλΗϗϥΎϛγ
ΩΩϋ
ϡϳγϧϰϣίϋϥΎϳέΎϣ
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛϰϟϪϣΩϘϣϪϟΎγέ
έϳγϳΟΎϣϟΔΟέΩϰϠϋϝϭλΣϟΕΎΑϠρΗϣϥϣ˯ίΟϛ
ϰϓ
ϪϳέΎϣόϣϟϪγΩϧϬϟ
ϰϳΑϟϡϳϣλΗϟϭρϳρΧΗϟ
ϩέϫΎϘϟΔόϣΎΟˬϪγϧϬϟΔϳϠϛ
ϪϳΑέόϟέλϣϪϳέϭϬϣΟˬϩίϳΟϟ
˻˹˹̀