Level 4 Dynamic and Collaborative Teams: Your Road To Success
Level 4 Dynamic and Collaborative Teams: Your Road To Success
LEVEL 4
DYNAMIC AND
COLLABORATIVE
TEAMS
BE •
• A
OF
IDE
FICI
GU
L
STUDY
abeuk.com
A
© ABE 2017
Every attempt has been made to ensure the accuracy of this study guide;
however, no liability can be accepted for any loss incurred in any way
whatsoever by any person relying solely on the information contained within
it. The study guide has been produced solely for the purpose of professional
qualification study and should not be taken as definitive of the legal position.
Specific advice should always be obtained before undertaking any investment.
ABE cannot be held responsible for the content of any website mentioned in
this book.
978-1-911550-15-0
Reviewer: Jacqui Bishop BA (Hons), MA, PGCE, Dip M, Dip MRS, MCIM
Every effort has been made to trace all copyright holders, but if any have
been inadvertently overlooked, the Publishers will be pleased to make the
necessary arrangements at the first opportunity.
The rights of Caroline Foster to be identified as the author of this work have
been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Design and Patents
Act 1998.
Acknowledgements
The publishers gratefully acknowledge permission to reproduce the following
copyright material: p6 Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock; p14 Tiko
Aramyan/Shutterstock; p19 Creativa Images/Shutterstock; p26 XiXinXing/
Shutterstock; p31 ESB Basic/Shutterstock; p40 Monkey Business Images/
Shutterstock; p44 iofoto/Shutterstock; p48 Creativa Images/Shutterstock; p49
Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock; p59 Pressmaster/Shutterstock; p63
nd3000/Shutterstock.
ii © ABE
Contents
Using your study guide iv
Glossary 66
© ABE iii
Using your study guide
Welcome to the study guide for Dynamic and Collaborative Teams, designed to
support those completing an ABE level 4 Diploma.
Below is an overview of the elements of learning and related key capabilities (taken from
the published syllabus), designed to support learners to assess their own skillset in terms
of employability and to develop their own personal development plans.
This study guide follows the order of the syllabus, which is the basis for your studies.
Each chapter starts by listing the syllabus learning outcomes covered and the
assessment criteria.
iv © ABE
L4 descriptor
Knowledge descriptor (the holder…) Skills descriptor (the holder can…)
• Has practical, theoretical or technical • Identify, adapt and use appropriate
knowledge and understanding of a cognitive and practical skills to inform
subject or field of work to address actions, and address problems that
problems that are well defined but are complex and non-routine while
complex and non-routine. normally fairly well-defined.
• Can analyse, interpret and evaluate • Review the effectiveness and
relevant information and ideas. appropriateness of methods, actions
and results.
• Is aware of the nature and approximate
scope of the area of study or work.
• Has an informed awareness of
different perspectives or approaches
within the area of study or work
‘Over to you’: activities for you to complete, using the space provided.
Case studies: realistic business scenarios to reinforce and test your
understanding of what you have read.
REVISION
on the go
‘Revision on the go’: use your phone camera to capture these key pieces of
learning, then save them on your phone to use as revision notes.
Examples: illustrating points made in the text to show how it works in practice.
Tables, graphs and charts: to bring data to life.
Reading list: identifying resources for further study, including Emerald articles
(which will be available in your online student resources).
Source/quotation information to cast further light on the subject from
industry sources.
Highlighted words throughout and glossary terms at the end of the book.
Note
Website addresses current as at June 2017.
© ABE v
Chapter 1
The Nature of Teams within
Modern Organisations
Introduction
The business environment is becoming ever more global and, as a consequence, the workplace is
changing. Hierarchical organisations are generally a thing of the past; structures are usually flatter
and the people within them are often required to work cross-functionally and with people at
other locations, rather than as part of one department based in the same office.
Modern organisations present additional challenges to team work, including flexible and
remote working, operating across time-zones and embracing different working and cultural
practices. While diversity generally improves team working it does require team members to
show more open-mindedness on the part of all concerned to find the best solutions.
This chapter introduces you to the nature of teams within modern organisations and the difficulties
associated with team working within different organisational structures.
Learning outcomes
On completing the chapter, you will be able to:
1 Describe the nature of teams within modern organisations and the difficulties associated
with team working within different organisational structures
Assessment criteria
1 Describe the nature of teams within modern organisations and the difficulties associated
with team working within different organisational structures
1.1 Explain what teams are and how the nature of teams has changed as the structure and
nature of organisations have changed in recent years
1.2 Explain using relevant concepts and theories, how teams form and become effective;
the common pitfalls, and how effective working can be established
1.3 Identify the additional challenges and potential difficulties that teams face given the nature
of modern organisations, including virtual environments
© ABE
Level 4 Dynamic and
Collaborative Teams
Background
Teams are an essential part of organisational life. Team performance can have a positive or negative
impact on the overall performance of the organisation.
The world of work is rapidly changing and fast-moving owing to innovations and changes in
the wider environment caused by political, economic, social and technological factors. This has
increased the requirement for individuals to be able to work effectively within team structures in
order to deliver objectives. Individual performance is affected by and affects those people with
whom an individual has to collaborate with as part of their day-to-day working life.
However, working in an effective team does not just happen by accident. There are many different
factors that lead to a team being successful. If you can understand the nature of teams, different
structures and challenging factors that impact the effectiveness of teams, it will enable you to
pinpoint areas where you can contribute to team effectiveness.
Over to you
Activity 1: Self-interest versus team interest
Reflect on situations where you have worked with teams in the past. Can you think
of any examples where individuals have put the team’s interest before their own self-
interest? Given your experience, can teams ever be truly effective? Give reasons for
your answer.
© ABE 3
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Teams, therefore, differ from groups because of member behaviour and the reason for an individual
to be part of, and remain, a member of the group.
Over to you
Activity 2: Team composition
Thinking about your own experience of working in teams and as part of a group, how
would you explain the differences between teams and groups?
4 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Common A common purpose is the glue that holds the team together. It provides the
purpose direction that the team have committed to travel. Each team member knows
why work needs to be done, and this helps them to focus on the end goal.
Interdependency For the purpose to be achieved, every team member will need to deliver
their work to the right standard. Sharing information and working to
achieve success for each other are part of a collaborative culture that
helps make teams effective.
Sense of Team spirit doesn’t happen overnight. However, the sense of belonging
membership and and individuals feeling as if they are contributing to a bigger purpose
contribution helps to develop morale, motivation and a united team front.
Over to you
Activity 3: Team composition
Evaluate a team you have been part of in terms of its size, composition and
characteristics compared to those of an ‘ideal’ team.
© ABE 5
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Action: A leadership development programme was used to develop the cohesiveness of the
team as well as to develop the country managers as individuals. As part of this programme,
several support activities were introduced including;
• Purposeful endeavour focus to help the country managers contribute to, and understand,
the shared purpose of the organisation.
• Communities of practice to develop cross-functional exchange of best practice and to
work on problems that all areas had a common interest in resolving.
• Learning buddies to develop an interdependency between area country managers and
keep them accountable for their personal learning and development commitments.
• Day in the life where individuals spent time with other country managers to understand
them and their areas with a view of increasing team spirit and a sense of beloning.
Result: The participants reported an increased level of networking, not just at country manager
level but throughout the regions. ‘One organisation’ thinking in the management team, and
mechanisms being included in personal development plans (PDPs) throughout the Middle East
were also developed. Several hundred thousand dollars of improvements in productivity were
recorded in six months. Some communities of practice resulted in opening up future streams of
revenue generation and this had a strategic impact upon the organisation as a whole.
Nature of teams
Teams are an important feature of organisational life. Team members must work together and
collaborate with other teams in order to meet the objectives of the organisation. The influence
that the manager and team members have on each other affects the effectiveness of team work,
individual behaviour and quality of work performance.
Traditional structures
Traditional organisational structures are designed to enable the senior leadership within the
organisation to command and control the way tasks are managed. A hierarchical organisation
structure helps to ensure that people keep to the rules and required behaviours that individuals are
expected to follow.
6 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Size
Complementary
Accountability
roles
Characteristics
of an effective
Sense of
membership team Common
purpose
and
contribution
Collective Interdependency
responsibility
Senior management
© ABE 7
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Formal teams are identified as part of the organisational design, often depicted by an
organisational chart. A formal team may be part of a division, department, section or a formal
project team, which has been formed to deliver a particular task.
Informal teams are not part of the formal organisational structure, but form due to special interests,
talent specialisms, personal relationships or a shared hobby. These teams tend to be cross-functional
and can have a powerful effect on the organisation due to the influence of the members.
Over to you
Activity 4: Purposeful endeavour
Evaluate a team you have been part of in terms of its purpose and how the team
developed and was organised to achieve its objective(s).
Modern structures
Globalisation, a highly competitive market place, and technological advances have changed the
way business is done. Modern organisational structures have moved away from the traditional
pyramid shape toward a flatter hierarchy. Matrix working has resulted in less formal structures
and the changing nature of work has led to cross-functional and multi-disciplinary working.
Modern structures
8 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Reporting lines
Matrix working means that individuals may work for more than one manager and be part of more
than one team, especially where project work is the norm. This can lead to an individual being
moved to a project team for a short period, while still performing their usual tasks, and therefore
having multiple roles within the same organisational setting.
The chain of management determines reporting lines and means that decision making can track
across horizontal or vertical team structures:
Vertical teams have a tall structure and hierarchy, with senior managers passing authority down
the organisation through a series of management layers; the lower level managers are responsible
for task-orientated work and higher level managers are responsible for strategy and direction.
Vertical teams are more likely to be found in larger organisations which work along functional
lines.
Horizontal teams are flat in structure and have fewer levels of management. This means
that even senior managers will be more involved in the day-to-day tasks needed to deliver
organisational performance. Horizontal teams are likely to work cross-functionally and have more
loosely defined job responsibilities.
There are different types of organisational practices which have contributed to and evolved from
the growing use of modern structures. These include the practices shown in Table 2.
Flexible working Flexible working can take a number of forms, which may be
flexible start and finish times, working different shift patterns and
working in other locations, e.g. from home. Flexible working needs
to suit the needs of the employee and the requirements of the
organisation for it to be effective.
Experience The value placed upon technical skills and experience in a specific
job role and tasks are being replaced with a requirement for
transferable skills. This allows individuals and teams to be flexible and
move easily in response to the needs of the organisation.
Project/temporary Different groups will come together within the organisation either
teams for the delivery of a specific project or an interim period, in order to
achieve a particular need or outcome which must be delivered.
© ABE 9
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Virtual teams Virtual teams have arisen due to the global nature of multi-national
enterprises (MNEs) resulting in team members being located in
different geographic regions. This has been made possible by the
improvements in communication technology.
Over to you
Activity 5: Communication systems
Discuss with a study partner, if possible, the use of modern technology and its impact
on communication at work, especially the use of email, social media, mobile phones and
instant messaging. Have these new systems improved communication in the workplace?
Give reasons for your answer.
10 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Team development
In 1977 Tuckman and Jensen introduced what is now one of the most popular models of team
development. This model identifies five main phases of group development, as shown in Table 3.
Forming The initial stage of group formation brings together individuals who attempt
to provide the relationship framework of the group, such as structure, roles
and responsibilities. At this point, individuals are on their best behaviour and
seeking to create a good impression.
Norming As the conflict from the storming stage leads to established guidelines, norms
of accepted behaviour become rooted into ways of working. Co-operation
and planning increases as members move forward toward an agreed purpose.
Table 3: The five main phases of group development (after Tuckman and Jensen) Revision
on the go
© ABE 11
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Adjourning
Performing
Norming
Storming
Forming
In their book The Wisdom of Teams, Katzenbach and Smith (1993) provide rules for creating
high performance teams. They suggest that for team development to be successful, a group needs
a clear performance challenge.
Katzenbach and Smith recommend that a specific purpose is developed to give meaning to a
team’s work. Team members should commit to clear, consistent performance criteria for which they
are mutually accountable. Finally they suggest that team members should possess complementary
skills. They offer a J- shaped curve for the development of a group into a real team. The stages
include those shown in Table 4.
12 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Working group Team members share information but as yet have no common
purpose or performance goals have not been set. No mutual
accountability.
Pseudo team The group is yet to begin performing as a team, and is therefore at
the bottom of the performance curve. Individuals are risk averse and
avoiding accountability.
Potential team Movement toward a common goal, performance levels begin to rise
but team members need to agree to mutual accountability.
Real team Team members begin to move towards a shared purpose. Their skills
are complementary and they begin to share accountability for team
results.
High-
performance
Real team
team
Performance impact
Working
group
Potential team
Pseudo
team
Team effectiveness
© ABE 13
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Sub-groups appear
At the next meeting individuals began to get more
vocal, expressing opinions about priorities and next
steps and views of sub-groups which seemed to
have formed based on who worked in the same office building: “we think…” Over the course of
the meeting the discussion became heated and there was intense disagreement about particular
actions, including accusations of individual suggestions being “ridiculous” and “not based in
reality”. Kim was taken aback by the hostility displayed by certain members of the team.
No resolution
The meeting eventually finished when three people left early, commenting, “this project won’t
work…” and “this isn’t what I signed up for…”. No decisions were made that day, and there
were accusations of people being “controlling” and “out of control.”
This was the first time Kim had been a member of a project team and she was surprised at how
comfortable other team members felt expressing their dissatisfaction and challenging other
people within the team.
Next meeting
At the next meeting there seemed to have been some conciliatory conversations between
various members of the team. The motivation team members had to achieve the goal of the
team appeared to outweigh the differences of opinion.
Over to you
Activity 6: Where are you on the curve?
Think about a team that you are part of. Map where your team is in regard to team
development using Tuckman and Jensen’s stages of team development and Katzenbach
and Smith’s J curve. Given your analysis, what steps can you take to improve the
performance of the team?
For example: The team appears to be storming. Everyone is arguing about who is to blame
when things go wrong, and whether people are working as a team or for their individual
interests. Need to agree team specific performance goals, especially on sticking to agreed
delivery deadlines.
14 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Common pitfalls
The models described provide a tool for which you can analyse the progress of team development.
However, in every organisation there are common pitfalls that beset many teams, at all
organisational levels, and that impacts on the ability to achieve effective performance levels.
Perhaps the most common complaint from managers is that teams and individuals work in silos.
This means that information, knowledge and best practice is not shared across the team or with
other teams, and people are working in isolation. Breaking down silos is difficult to do, often
because people do not have time to share or because performance criteria results in people being
rewarded for their individual contribution.
Group think happens when pressure for the group to remain friendly is so great that individual
members of the group will not voice their own concerns, leading to dysfunctional decision making.
Challenging the lack of questioning takes courage and a willingness to recognise why this might be
happening and discuss these within the group.
The planning of team workload is perhaps the greatest danger to effective team work. Poor
planning of team tasks can result individuals being unaware of what work is in the pipeline, and for
blockages to occur because of lack of co-ordination, or a breakdown in communication. This will
result in a lack of agreed priorities and missed deadlines.
Opportunities to bring in new team members can vary. If there is a vacancy on the team then
one option is to find a new full-time member to join the team. In addition to finding someone
who has the right skills and experience needed, another dimension to consider is the needs and
personalities of each team member. To help develop an effective team, choosing individuals who
can complement each other is part of the process; for example a dominant individual will work well
with someone comfortable with a subordinate individual role.
The social structures of a team will also affect productivity. Temporary contractors or specialists
can be used to provide expert advice or skills for particular tasks or projects which will give the
team increased flexibility and agility. Taking time to support the team to progress quickly through
the stages of team development is important if the temporary assignments are going to be
effective in the short-term.
© ABE 15
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Common goals Establishing clear common goals helps team members to co-operate on
the basis of shared values and priorities.
Clear timelines Clear allocation of work with timelines for completing tasks gives
direction to the team and helps the team to function as a unit focused on
achieving key priorities.
Reporting and Establishing a clear reporting process and accountability allows the team
accountability to operate effectively within the organisation structure.
Purpose and Maintaining purpose and motivation requires sharing information about
motivation team activity and celebrating progress and achievement.
Offshoring Offshoring can increase access to skills and help teams to increase or
decrease capacity in response to fast-changing demands on the team.
Understanding different cultures, keeping the offshore team involved
and regular reviews contribute to effective offshoring practices.
Outsourcing Outsourcing can offer a team access to expertise in technical areas that
close skills gaps and increase productivity.
Over to you
Activity 7: Theory versus reality
Learning about building an effective team in a textbook can ‘gloss over’ the reality of
working in teams in real-life organisations or situations. What is your experience of the
reality of team working, and what factors do you believe contributed to an effective
team performance?
16 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Common
goals
Roles and
Outsourcing responsibilities
Clear
Offshoring timelines
Effective
team working
Reporting and
Technology accountability
Purpose and
Support
motivation
Flexible working
Flexible working can offer opportunities for employers to tap into talent while giving employees
work-life balance. Types of practice can vary, but include part-time or term-time working, job-
sharing, flexitime, compressed or annualised hours or remote working. However, from a team
perspective flexible working practices can present a significant challenge to team work. Something
that might suit one individual can have a significant impact on how the team operates in practice.
For some job tasks, it might be necessary to be in a particular location at certain times and flexible
working may result in other team members having to take on extra responsibilities and work to
compensate. This can lead to resentment as some team members try to manage the priorities of
the team. Flexible working arrangements can be managed but there needs to be clarity about
roles and responsibilities and clear communication between the team members in order to manage
tensions and pressures.
© ABE 17
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Over to you
Activity 8: Theory versus reality
Consider how flexible working could work in your own job role, or one with which you
are familiar. What would some of the positive effects be of such an arrangement? How
would you address the challenges that such an arrangement would cause your team?
Remote working
Remote working can take a number of forms, including home-based working, mobile working or
remote working. This allows team members the flexibility of working in a different location from an
organisation’s office or even from home. Where work has to be carried out in a specific location,
remote working may not be possible but, where it is possible, one of the greatest challenges is the
lack of time to build effective relationships, which provides the lifeblood for information sharing and
communication processes for the team.
Although remote working benefits individuals by reducing their time commuting to a centralised
office location, and offers the benefits of reducing interruptions, it also presents challenges. So the
individual team member may miss the friendship that comes from frequent contact with the team,
resulting in feelings of isolation. For the team, lack of personal contact can lead to reduced levels of
trust, compromising knowledge sharing and the loss of body language and non-verbal cues which
are an essential element to effective communication.
18 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
© ABE 19
Chapter 1 The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations
Over to you
Activity 9: Examining virtual teams
Think about the information technology that you use for communicating with people
you may work with in a team. This may be a team from work, study group, sports team
or group with whom you share a hobby. What are some of the pitfalls of electronic
communication you have encountered?
Offshoring
As we have discovered, developing an effective team is challenging at the best of times.
Offshoring magnifies the challenges of developing effectiveness. Team members who are part of
an offshore group may experience difficulties caused by differences in culture, time and language.
Whether essential information gets lost in translation or time lags delay time-critical action,
problems can become crises and misunderstandings can sidetrack projects.
Outsourcing
Outsourcing can add additional layers of complication to team work. The biggest issue relating
to outsourcing is the communication between permanent team members and those who are
outsourced workers. Outsourcing reduces the personal and day-to-day interaction that sustains a
team’s cohesiveness. The reliance on external experts to fill knowledge and skills gaps may result
in essential capability never being transferred into the permanent team, reducing the possibility for
growing internal organisational expertise.
20 © ABE
The Nature of Teams within Modern Organisations Chapter 1
Reading list
• Castka, P., Bamber, C.J., Sharp, J.M. and Belohoubek, P. (2001) “Factors affecting successful
implementation of high performance teams”, Team Performance Management: An
International Journal, Vol. 7 Iss: 7/8, pp.123–134.
• Henttonen, Kaisa, Johanson, Jan-Erik and Janhonen, Minna (2014) “Work-team bonding and
bridging social networks, team identity and performance effectiveness”, Personnel Review,
Vol. 43 Iss: 3, pp.330–349.
• Piña, María Isabel Delgado, Martínez, Ana María Romero and Martínez, Luis Gómez, (2008)
“Teams in organizations: a review on team effectiveness”, Team Performance Management:
An International Journal, Vol. 14 Iss: 1/2, pp.7–21.
Summary
A team is a group of people who work together to achieve a common purpose whereas a group
consists of people who depend on each other in order to complete a task or achieve a goal.
Teams are an essential component of the organisational environment and exist at all levels, from the
most senior to the most junior employees. Regardless of the work environment, teams enable work
to be organised.
Modern organisational structures introduce dimensions to team working such as flexible and
remote working, virtual teams and embracing different working and cultural practices. These
practices help deliver opportunities for teams to be more flexible and agile. However, increased
levels of globalisation, a fast-moving competitive environment and technological advances present
specific challenges to team working.
© ABE 21
Chapter 2
The Principles and Benefits
of Effective Team Working
Introduction
There are many benefits to team working, both commercially and personally, but working in
teams does not in itself equate to success; as a minimum, effective team work requires a balanced
selection of members, careful planning, ongoing participation and collaboration, tenacity and the
mutual support of each other, in order for the team to achieve its desired goals and to contribute to
those of the organisation.
Modern organisations present additional challenges to team work including flexible and remote
working, operating across time-zones and embracing different working and cultural practices. While
diversity is generally enriching, it can introduce dimensions to team working that require open-
mindedness on the part of all concerned to find the best solutions.
This chapter will address how to build effective working relationships within different types of teams
and business structures, including virtual environments.
Learning outcomes
On completing the chapter, you will be able to:
2 Describe the principles and benefits of effective team working and how collaborative
working can be fostered
Assessment criteria
2 Describe the principles and benefits of effective team working and how collaborative
working can be fostered
2.1 Explain the commercial and social benefits of effective team working
2.2 Recommend how collaborative working could be fostered to overcome the potential
difficulties that teams face working in modern organisational structures, including virtual
environments
© ABE
Level 4 Dynamic and
Collaborative Teams
Background
For an organisation to achieve its goals and objectives, it is essential that individual
employees are bought together in order to develop a coherent, aligned response to the
competitive environment. The sum of the individual parts mean that a team is able to provide
a more comprehensive, efficient and effective response to organisation challenges and
opportunities than can be achieved when individuals operate alone. It is the combination of
team member skills, knowledge and experience that is beneficial.
Human co-operation and group effort is valuable to individuals, teams, organisations and
society at large. Individuals benefit from being a member of an effective team, contributing
to feelings of satisfaction and achievement. The team as a whole benefits from positive
interaction, sharing work and workload, and the positivity gained from the development of
team spirit. Finally, organisations benefit from increased levels of creativity, innovation and a
supportive environment.
Richard Hackman
However, the modern organisational structure can reduce team performance by developing
barriers to the effective deployment of group dynamics and team behaviour. Being aware of
the common mistakes made when building a team and taking steps to confront issues will
ensure that effective team working can be nurtured within the organisational setting.
© ABE 23
Chapter 2 The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working
Over to you
Activity 1: Part of an orchestra or a soloist
Consider the role of the soloist in the orchestra. How important is the orchestra to the
soloist’s performance? Based on your answer, what parallels can you draw between
individual and team performance?
Commercial benefits
The commercial benefits of teams are many and varied. Wickens (1995)1 stated that the strength
of an organisation is in its people, declaring that if an organisation values its people, people will
bring the organisation value. When team working is part of the organisational culture, individuals
have shared values, and a strong sense of purpose, which is clearly communicated and grasped
by employees. Likert (1967)2 noted the importance of participation in decision-making, which
is evident when the strength of teams is used fully. This in turn contributes to organisation
productivity and profitability.
By effectively organising their people, organisations can ensure in turn an effective use of
organisation resources – resulting in higher levels of efficiency. Increased responsiveness and
flexibility is achieved by focusing teams on problem solving leading to a cycle of continuous
improvement, harnessing the energy of the enterprise.
1 Wickens, P.D., (1995). The Ascendant Organisation: Combining Commitment and Control for Long term, Sustainable
Business Success, Macmillan, Basingstoke.
2 Likert, R., (1967). The Human Organization: its management and values, McGraw Hill.
24 © ABE
The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working Chapter 2
Increased levels of group loyalty result in more responsiveness and flexibility, allowing the
organisation to respond positively to competitive pressures and changes in the market place.
Katzenbach and Smith (1993)3 noted that shared commitment from groups results in a powerful unit
of collective performance, helping teams to achieve specific performance goals.
The significance of personal relationships as recognised by Maslow (1970)4 is captured in the idea of
self-actualisation which is the ideal of human fulfilment. This results in reduced absenteeism and
staff turnover and has the double benefit of reducing the costs of the organisation and increasing
engagement. The greater levels of innovation that result contribute to increased revenue for the
organisation.
Katzenbach and Smith (1993) noted that the difference between teams and other groups is
performance. Collaborative decision-making is a consequence of performance challenges and
takes place when individuals are provided with opportunities by the team to make a distinctive
contribution. Therefore it could be argued that team working contributes to higher levels of
individual performance, collaborative working and consequently organisational performance,
leading to commercial success for the organisation.
Over to you
Activity 2: Team work and work performance
3 Katzenbach, J.R. and Smith, D.K., (1993). The Wisdom of Teams: Creating the high-performance organization. Harvard
Business Press.
4 Maslow, A. H. (1970). Motivation and Personality. New York: Harper & Row
© ABE 25
Chapter 2 The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working
The result
The focus on creating an environment where the team could work together on their
performance goals resulted in Guoliang and his team members, making a genuine effort to
build trust and support each other to meet the team goals. There was a real interest in how
the team was progressing and the emphasis on rewarding good performance meant that
every individual in the team was committed to delivering his or her best. The team was able
to highlight work practices which could be done more efficiently and also recommended areas
where the organisation could save money, which resulted in reductions in costly inventory levels
and resolving longstanding issues with a particular supplier.
Social benefits
The social benefits of effective team work can be linked to the commercial benefits enjoyed
by organisations in that they result in greater levels of motivation among team members to
achieve goals.
Likert’s System 4 Management Model (1967) highlights the importance of group participation on
satisfying the psychological and social needs of employees. The participative system
contributes to team decision-making and problem solving; however, it is the non-economic
motives that Likert (1967) highlighted as contributing to team support and motivation. These
include the individual’s sense of responsibility, personal worth and importance as their contribution
26 © ABE
The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working Chapter 2
is recognised. A sense of belonging results from combining the needs and desires of both the
individual and the team. This leads to increased levels of trust, sharing influence and effective and
efficient communication.
Over to you
Activity 3: Team work meets human needs
Conduct your own research into motivation and social identity theories. What evidence
can you provide that supports the assertion by Likert that group participation satisfies
the psychological and social needs of employees?
For example: Guirdham (2002)5 argues that we categorise ourselves as a member of specific
groups based on our own concept of self. Acceptance by the groups develops our own
concept of self, influencing our behaviour at work.
Maslow (1970) developed the hierarchical pyramid of human needs to demonstrate the necessity
of physical needs being met and the significance of personal relationships. His theory of self-
actualisation demonstrated how important human relationships are in helping individuals to
develop confidence and release their full potential. He emphasised how personal relationships
resulted in creativity in things that are done, said or acted. Acceptance within a team contributes
to the individual having their psychological needs of safety being met, resulting in the individual
feeling confident and realising they have unlimited room for growth. Maslow (1970) used the term
self-actualising to describe the point where an individual is able to make full use of their talents and
capacities to become all that they are capable of doing and being.
Therefore the social benefits of team work have links to motivation and the creation of an
environment where individuals can experience fulfilment of their potential.
© ABE 27
Chapter 2 The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working
Self-
actualisation:
achieving full
use of
talent and capacities
Psychological needs:
self esteem and feelings
of belonging
Physiological needs:
basic needs of food, water and shelter
Over to you
Activity 4: Working together
Think about a team you have been part of. How effectively did the team work together
and did it manage to achieve its objectives?
28 © ABE
The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working Chapter 2
Over to you
Activity 5: A great question to get to know someone
If you search online you can find lots of web pages offering lists of questions to ‘get
to know your team better’. The truth is that no single question will work for everyone.
Finding a good question to really get to know someone means avoiding general, broad
or philosophical questions. Instead you need to do your homework and ask a question,
which is simple and specific to that person. The purpose of this activity is to craft a
question that will help illuminate a person’s real self.
• Think about your team members and decide which member you know least well; they
will be the subject of your inquiry.
• Write down what you already know about that individual and also perhaps areas
where you are curious to know more.
• Based on what you understand now, what question would help you get to know this
person better?
© ABE 29
Chapter 2 The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working
Communication
Regular communications and meetings are essential for collaboration to become a reality. In
addition to communicating about team roles and goals, it is necessary to communicate about
organisation and team expectations. Communication can take place virtually, using any number
of information technologies, or the team can meet face to face periodically or in daily team
huddles. Where members are part of remote or virtual teams, meetings may have to take place at
rotating times to respect different time zones. The essential element of communication is that team
members are clear on what needs to be accomplished, have information regarding current work
flows and that they are given a forum to collaborate with each other.
Using technology
Technology can help teams to overcome the difficulties of differing locations and time zones.
As well as aiding the sharing of information, such as the use of shared drives to enable access
to documentation, technology can remove barriers of time and geography. The advent of
teleconferencing and video-conferencing has opened the doors to real-time meetings which
can take place regardless of where in the world the participants are located. Technology enables
team members to improve communication and freely exchange ideas, which can contribute to
knowledge development, innovation and creativity within the team.
Clearly defined
goals: Communication:
Ensuring team efforts Creating the forum
result in desired for collaboration
outcomes
30 © ABE
The Principles and Benefits of Effective Team Working Chapter 2
Reading list
• Daspit, Josh, Tillman, C. Justice, Boyd, Nancy G. and Mckee, Victoria (2013) “Cross‐
functional team effectiveness: An examination of internal team environment, shared
leadership, and cohesion influences”, Team Performance Management: An International
Journal, Vol. 19 Iss: 1/2, pp.34–56.
• Gohil, Udityasinh, Carrillo, Patricia, Ruikar, Kirti and Anumba, Chimay (2011) “Value‐
enhanced collaborative working: case study of a small management advisory firm”,
Construction Innovation, Vol. 11 Iss: 1, pp.43–60.
• Palethorpe, Rob (2014) “Collaborating for Results: Silo Working and Relationships that
Work”, Development and Learning in Organizations: An International Journal, Vol. 28 Iss: 3,
pp.39–40.
Summary
Effective team work can deliver both commercial and social benefits, but working in teams does
not in itself equate with success. As a minimum, effective team work requires a balanced selection
of members, planning, ongoing participation and collaboration, tenacity and the mutual support
of each other, in order for the team to achieve its desired goals and to contribute to those of the
organisation.
Co-operative ways of working can be used to complete tasks and reach organisation goals.
Leveraging the power of effective teams in the workplace does not happen without effort.
Fostering collaborative work requires individuals to combine their talent towards the achievement
of a clearly defined team goal by getting to know each other, regular communication and the use of
technology to remove barriers of time and geography.
© ABE 31
Chapter 3
The Principles of Effective
team Management
Introduction
Managers play an important role in ensuring that teams deliver high performance outcomes.
Effective team management requires the manager to bring together the strengths of each team
member and ensure that they are able to contribute to delivering the team’s goals. Whether a team
manager is building a new team or managing an existing team, they need to help team members
develop challenging team goals, define team roles and ensure that obstacles to performance are
removed so that the team members can operate effectively.
This chapter will explore how teams need to be led, motivated, managed and monitored in order to
be maximally effective.
Learning outcomes
On completing the chapter, you will be able to:
3 Explain the principles of effective team management and why it is important for the work of
teams to be led, organised and monitored
Assessment criteria
3 Explain the principles of effective team management and why it is important for the work of
teams to be led, organised and monitored
3.1 Identify the advantages and limitations of different approaches to the management of
teams
3.2 Recommend practical ways that teams working in modern organisations should be
managed so that they work collaboratively to achieve team objectives
© ABE
Level 4 Dynamic and
Collaborative Teams
Background
The principles of effective team management rely on more than hard work and the determination of
team members. Effectiveness can be linked to the approach that a manager takes to a given team
and the management style employed in managing the team.
Watson (1986)1 said that management has been characterised as Art, Science, Magic and Politics.
Management has been described as art – suggesting that some individuals are able to manage
teams effectively and can develop their management talent over time.
Koontz (1964)
Management has also been described as magic, suggesting that it is less about skill and ability and
more about a potent power, which enables some managers to successfully manage a team by some
unknown force. Furthermore, management is presented as science, which can be learnt, by building
upon a body of knowledge and specific techniques and skills which when correctly applied result in
effective teams.
Finally, it has been suggested that management requires political cunning: a game to be played
whereby the winners are effective and the losers fail to perform.
1 Watson, T. (1986). Management, Organisation and Employment Strategy: New directions in theory and practice.
Routledge.
© ABE 33
Chapter 3 The Principles of Effective team Management
Over to you
Activity 1: Describing approaches to management
Management has been described as an art, a science and the politics of magic. Which of
these perspectives do you consider to be true and why?
Scientific management
The industrialisation of the economy at the beginning of the twentieth century led to new
innovations in production techniques such as Henry Ford’s automotive assembly line. Frederick
Taylor’s (1917)2 principles of scientific management offered an approach to management, which
breaks down work tasks into different parts of the production process. Every job was analysed,
tasks were standardised and workers were selected and trained to fit specific requirements in order
to co-ordinate the production process. The process was designed to ensure that barriers to efficient
working were removed and workers themselves were rewarded for productivity.
34 © ABE
The Principles of Effective team Management Chapter 3
Over to you
Activity 2: The bureaucratic approach
What are the advantages and disadvantages of the bureaucratic approach? Consider
how management would be practised using this approach.
Principles of management
Fayol4 proposed an administrative theory of management (published in English in 1949), which
offered a more flexible approach to the principles of organisation. Offering 14 principles of
management, Fayol (1841 to 1925) suggested that managers could use their intuition and
discretion to adapt the way the principles were used to support managerial planning. The 14
principles are described in Table 1.
3 Gerth, H.H. ed. (1947). From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. Translated, edited and with an introduction by H.H. Gerth
and C. Wright Mills. Kegan Paul.
4 Fayol, H., (1949). Industrial and General Management. Pitman, London.
© ABE 35
Chapter 3 The Principles of Effective team Management
Authority and Managers need authority to give order to employees, but that authority
responsibility must come with responsibility.
Unity of Employees will be given orders and will be answerable to one manager
command to avoid confusion and conflict.
Unity of Plans of action must be owned by one manager and must be delivered
direction by one team who are responsible for delivering the associated activities.
Scalar chain Management structures should provide a clear line of authority from the
top of the organisation to lower levels so that hierarchy remains in place
even in emergency situations.
Order Based on the idea that safe, clean and tidy work environments represent
social order, organisations must ensure that adequate resources are
available to ensure an ordered functioning of the organisation.
Esprit de corps Developing the idea of employee involvement and unity among
employees to increase morale.
36 © ABE
The Principles of Effective team Management Chapter 3
Division
of work
Esprit de Authority and
corps responsibility
Initiative Discipline
Stability of Unity of
tenure command
Principles of
management
Unity of
Equity
direction
Subordination
Order of individual
interest
The 14 principles of management are still likely to be recognisable in management practices today.
They are in many ways a common sense approach to the management of people within organisations.
However, although many of these principles appear to be common sense in traditional organisation
structures, it could be argued that they perhaps are out of touch with the needs of modern
organisation structures.
Over to you
Activity 3: Principles of management for today
What principles of management would you develop for a modern organisation structure
(see Chapter 1, section 1.1)? What does this tell you about how context impacts
approaches to management?
© ABE 37
Chapter 3 The Principles of Effective team Management
Functional approach
Adair (1997)5 argues that a healthy team requires a shared purpose and clear goals and that
management has a functional approach, which is related to the efficient use of resources, great
communication and developing an open environment. He also argues that the monitoring of
performance and learning from experience are important characteristics of a team manager. With
regard to effective team management, Adair identified several functions that a team manager must
execute while also being aware of team needs, including the understanding of what function must
be applied when, and being skilful in exercising each function when required; these functions are
shown in Table 2.
Identifying
team
objectives
Setting Planning
standards
Functional
approach to
team
management
Evaluation Communication
Organisation
Figure 3.2: Functional approach to team management (after Adair, 1997) Revision
on the go
Autocratic The team manager makes a decision without any consultation with the
team. Often perceived as the team manager having control.
Democratic Team members participate in discussions and contribute to the final decision
when a consensus is reached. The manager is seen as supportive of the
team’s decisions.
Directional The team manager directs the team with regard to the right things to do,
plans next steps and concentrates on how to take action. The team’s actions
are monitored against set targets and measures.
Facilitation Team members are given support in exploring possible solutions and
answers. The team manager helps to engage the team members in
deciding what they are going to do next.
Over to you
Activity 4: An appropriate team management approach
It is argued that for a team to be effective, a team manager will need to be able to flex
their approach based upon the situation. In the table below consider and note down in
what situations different team management approaches might be thought appropriate.
For example: When the manager identifies a situation to be dangerous, for example
Autocratic a fire.
Autocratic
Democratic
Directional
Facilitation
© ABE 39
Chapter 3 The Principles of Effective team Management
Quinn (1980)8 adopts a coactive approach to the strategy development process. He argues that
although managers need to adopt a rational strategy process they also need to recognise that they
must act as a guide to gain consensus for action. Since decision making and external factors evolve
in a messy emergence of strategy, managers need to co-ordinate feedback in a process of logical
incrementalism.
The Hawthorne studies (conducted in the 1920s in the USA) led Mayo to conclude in 1949 that
formality and the strict rules advocated by scientific management approaches failed to take into
account the importance of human behaviour and interpersonal skills in managing effective teams.
Developing informal approaches to drive human relations, alongside technical efficiencies, will
increase job satisfaction, standards of output and communication, with resulting performance
outcomes.
A new approach
Andrea invited an organisation development consultant to work with the team to facilitate
their journey toward a shared strategy. This required Andrea to take a democratic approach
to strategy development, and being part of the team rather than having the final say on any
decisions being agreed.
Over a period of couple of months the team worked together on ‘their’ strategy, developing a
shared mission statement, strategic pillars and a strategic plan.
6 Mayo, E. (1949) ‘Hawthorne and the western electric company’. Public Administration: Concepts and Cases,
pp.149–158.
7 Follett, M.P. (1920) The New State: Group organization the solution of popular government. Penn State Press.
8 Quinn, J.B., (1980). Strategies for Change: Logical incrementalism. Irwin Professional Publishing.
40 © ABE
The Principles of Effective team Management Chapter 3
The result
To begin with the senior team carried copies of the mission statement and pillars with them.
Andrea reported that time and again the strategic plan was referred to when decisions need
to be made, meaning that a number of decisions that would have once been agreed to were
rejected because the action would have taken the team away from the strategic plan. The team
self-reported higher levels of satisfaction and were highly motivated to achieve the plan to
which they had agreed.
Over to you
Use your own research to investigate different management styles, then analyse the
advantages and limitations of different management styles in relation to team working.
You can use the chart below to record your findings.
© ABE 41
Chapter 3 The Principles of Effective team Management
Hackman (1990) argued that specifying challenging team objectives can lead to successful
collaborative working, but this can falter if key organisational support systems are not in place. For
example, if teams do not have the training and development that they need or lack access to the
expertise and knowledge required to complete tasks, then team performance suffers. Furthermore,
the reward system needs to support collaboration and team work not just focus on rewarding
individual contribution.
Finally, the manager must maintain a balance between support in engaging the team in the
direction of travel and empowerment. If the manager sets no direction the team effectiveness
may suffer from uncertainty about what is expected. At the same time, if the manager exerts too
much authority in how a task is completed the team can feel suffocated and lose motivation to
progress.
Openness
Once a group begins operating as a team, a team manager can sometimes assume that the team
building work has been done. However, team effectiveness is not linear and at times the team as
a whole, or individuals within the team, may experience performance issues. Team managers and
team members must remain open to discussing difficulties that may be occurring either in regard
to the way the team is working, or the performance of individual team members. At different times
within the lifecycle of the team, individuals may benefit from more experienced members providing
support or mentorship, especially where individuals are new to the team or less experienced
in the task that needs to be achieved. Collaborating on improving team capability through team
coaching interventions can result in greater performance effectiveness.
42 © ABE
The Principles of Effective team Management Chapter 3
Regular reviews
Regular reviews provide the context to provide support and reinforce effective collaborative
working. Regular review meetings enable the team to manage accountability for different tasks
and priorities to be delivered in line with key milestones within the plan. This requires the team
manager to plan and prepare effectively for team meetings. Turning up to a team meeting and
expecting people to give an update will be seen as a waste of time. A clear agenda which focuses
on ongoing actions, tasks and key milestones allows the team to spend the time pooling their
resources and sharing key information to keep the team plan moving forward. It is also important
for the manager to update the plan based upon the new information so that every team member
has a clear line of sight as to where the team is performing against the agreed team goal. Where
teams operate remotely and rely on virtual meetings as their main form of contact, it is important
to include some face-to-face meetings to ensure that team relationships are maintained and
remain strong.
Celebrating success
A business environment moves so quickly on to the next problem or task to be achieved, that
managers often miss taking the time to celebrate achievements, which is essential in keeping
motivation levels high and to recognise the progress that the team is making. Noting the personal
progress of individuals as well as celebrating the achievement of key milestones must be seen
as essential ingredients in celebrating success. There are different ways that success can be
celebrated, including those shown in Table 4.
Food and At the end of a long project or having achieved an important outcome,
drink invite the team together for a meal. If getting people together after work
is difficult, consider a team lunch.
Wall of pride Document the work of the team and publicly share the story of success
either on a physical board or on the organisation’s intranet.
A minute of Start a team meeting by congratulating the team for the work they
appreciation have done and the extra effort put in. Recognising where people have
gone beyond what is expected will help them know their efforts are
appreciated.
Perks Provide rewards that are tailored to the team. Gift cards, vouchers or
being able to leave work early are all perks which can be offered.
Thank you Some individuals get embarrassed if a big fuss is made but, whatever
the success, remembering to say thank you for a job well done is
essential.
© ABE 43
Chapter 3 The Principles of Effective team Management
Over to you
Activity 6: Managing for collaboration
Reflect back on the team that you thought about in Activity 4: Working together on
page 28. Recommend how the team could have been selected, developed and managed
differently to improve collaboration and productivity.
Reading list
• Flory, Marja (2005) “Management fads: the case of the self-managed team”, Benchmarking:
An International Journal, Vol. 12 Iss: 3, pp.275–282.
• Follett, M.P., 1949. “The essentials of leadership”. Urwick L., Freedom and Coordination,
Lectures in Business Administration by Mary Parker Follett, Management Publications Trust,
Londres, pp.47–60.
• Harung, Harald S. (1996) “Total management: integrating manager, managing and
managed”, Journal of Managerial Psychology, Vol. 11 Iss: 2, pp.4–21.
• Piccoli, Gabriele, Powell, Anne, Ives, Blake (2004) “Virtual teams: team control structure,
work processes, and team effectiveness”, Information Technology & People, Vol. 17 Iss: 4,
pp.359–379.
44 © ABE
The Principles of Effective team Management Chapter 3
Summary
The basis of any successful organisation is that of effective teams working collaboratively to achieve
objectives. Regardless of whether a team manager is building a new team or managing an existing
team they need to help team members develop challenging team performance goals, define roles,
responsibilities and accountability and ensure that obstacles to performance are removed so that
the team members can operate effectively.
Although there are many different management theories and a continuum of management
approaches, the primary focus of management is to support individuals and teams in reaching their
objectives. Modern management theory argues that workplace problems are best solved through
human rather than technical means. If team members are given freedom over decision making and
problem solving then job satisfaction, co-operation and group cohesion should result.
© ABE 45
Chapter 4
Why Team Working can
Become Dysfunctional
Introduction
As a minimum, effective team work requires a balanced selection of members, planning, ongoing
participation and collaboration, tenacity and the mutual support of each other, in order for the team
to achieve its desired goals and to contribute to those of the organisation. However, team working
is not always easy or successful.
This chapter explores the difficulties that might be faced in different settings, and how to recognise
and diffuse the conflict that may arise.
Learning outcomes
On completing the chapter, you will be able to:
4 Outline the main reasons why team working can become dysfunctional and what can be
done to re-establish collaborative working
Assessment criteria
4 Outline the main reasons why team working can become dysfunctional and what can be
done to re-establish collaborative working
4.1 Identify the main reasons why team working breaks down and the early signs that can
indicate this is happening
4.2 Recommend practical ways that collaborative work can be re-established given the
additional challenges of modern organisations
© ABE
Level 4 Dynamic and
Collaborative Teams
Background
Enhancing team performance and team building is big business. You can search for team-building
activities, social bonding or team training, but there is a wealth of organisations and consultants
offering solutions to help your team develop their interpersonal relations, improve efficiency and
increase operational success. There are thousands of books, websites and courses offering advice,
tools and techniques to create a happy and productive team.
It could be argued that knowing what helps to make teams effective and work collaboratively is just
one piece of the puzzle. The other piece is having an understanding about what makes teams break
down and become ineffective. Why is it that a team can go from achieving performance goals one
year and descend into farce the next? What causes team members to go from working together
synergistically to falling into opposing camps who refuse to work with each other? Perhaps most
mystifying of all are those groups made up of seemingly highly qualified, capable individuals who
fail to come together, are unable to collaborate and end up performing significantly worse than the
individuals performing on their own.
Over to you
Activity 1: Signs that all may not be well
Think about experiences you have had working in teams. What signs can you identify
that indicated that the team was not effective or was becoming dysfunctional?
For example – certain team members not being given access to information that they
needed to do their job.
© ABE 47
Chapter 4 Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional
Lack of clarity
Not knowing what is expected of you is detrimental to individual performance. In a team environment,
a lack of clearly defined allocation of tasks and responsibility amplifies confusion and lack of action.
The poem “Everybody, Somebody, Anybody and Nobody” perhaps sums up the confusion of lack
of clarity in this respect: “It ended up that Everybody blamed Somebody, when Nobody did what
Anybody could have done”. It may be that an individual is not clear on what tasks they are supposed
to have responsibility for; perhaps one individual assumes that another team member is getting on
with a task, while the other team member is assuming the first individual is responsible.
Disunity can arise if team members do not understand what others contribute to the overall task.
This may lead some team members to think that particular individuals are not contributing enough,
due to a misunderstanding about the work an individual is doing. Also, because some activities may
be behind the scenes or take a while to show tangible outcomes, team members may assume that
nothing is happening.
Perhaps the biggest complaint from team members is if there is a belief that someone in the team
is not working as hard as the other team members. If there is a lack of planning, expectations in
terms of key milestones and failure to enforce delivery standards, then projects can begin to slip
and individuals may fail to meet the needs of other team members who may be more disciplined or
be focused on different priorities. For example, if an individual is delivering work of a poor standard
or is missing a deadline the whole team may suffer as a result. This can lead to friction, frustration
and conflict if team members begin to feel that their reputation is being damaged because of the
actions of one person.
When individuals are drawn into a group and told that they are a team, it does not mean that they
instantly get on well and everyone becomes good friends. Sometimes personality clashes can
happen and interpersonal relationships can become fraught. If the team manager does not deal
with interpersonal friction, and provide clarity on expected norms of behaviour, the result can be
disastrous for the team health in the long run. Conflict can occur, with individuals fighting to get
other team members to be on their side of the argument. Battle lines are drawn and squabbles can
escalate quickly, especially if they become serious or personal.
Therefore, a lack of clarity in different areas can result in loss of efficiency for team members as
meetings and team processes can drag on and become more time consuming than if individuals
were allowed to work independently.
Group think
Janis (1972)1 suggested that team decision making can be negatively impacted by group think
which is where a group fails to test the reality upon which they are basing group decisions. This
can result in teams failing to weigh decisions based upon what is acceptable morally or ethically
1 Janis, I.L. (1972, rev. 1982). Victims of groupthink: a psychological study of foreign-policy decisions and fiascoes.
Houghton Mifflin
48 © ABE
Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional Chapter 4
because of group pressure, which can lead to individuals relying on others to make important
decisions without discussion or question. Teams who succumb to group think are prone to down-
playing negative feedback, rewarding conformity and suppressing unpopular ideas or information
that contradicts the group’s perceived truth.
A pre-determined outcome?
When the committee met for the first time, the chief executive set out his plan for the new shift
patterns. The job of the committee was to investigate possible options but the chief executive
made it very clear that he had a preference for a particular shift pattern.
Several members of the committee were sceptical about changing shift patterns, and were
uneasy about the effect that the preference highlighted by the chief executive would have on
productivity in the mine.
Different options were explored, with the committee analysing advantages and disadvantages
of different shift patterns, but despite different viewpoints and opinions being expressed, the
committee remained aware that the chief executive’s desire meant that independent thinking
was discouraged. Petrov found that although the committee was supposed to be empowered
to make a decision, the focus tended to be on the group’s recommendation aligning to the
chief executive’s preferred pattern.
The supposed unanimous decision of the committee was in fact a symptom of group think since
many members of the committee apologetically expressed reservations privately about the new
shift patterns but willingly self-censored themselves in public.
© ABE 49
Chapter 4 Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional
Over to you
Activity 2: Ground rules
What ‘ground rules’ would you recommend to be put in place for your own team to
prevent an individual team member ‘going rogue’?
For example – team members should ensure that their communication is clear, accurate,
open and honest.
Taking responsibility therefore is not simply about an individual taking ownership for their own
behaviour and actions, but rather a distributed responsibility for the team behaviour and delivery of
tasks. Breakdown can therefore occur when team responsibility conflicts with individual responsibility
and where an individual’s preference for self-management is incompatible with team self-management.
Over to you
Activity 3: Overcoming barriers to success
Consider any type of team of which you have been a part. What were the main challenges
and barriers to success? Were they overcome successfully? How was that achieved?
2 Graen, G.B. and Uhl-Bien, M. (1995). ‘Relationship-based approach to leadership: Development of leader-member
exchange (LMX) theory of leadership over 25 years: Applying a multi-level multi-domain perspective’. The Leadership
Quarterly, 6(2), pp.219–247.
50 © ABE
Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional Chapter 4
Re-establish roles
Giving clarity and transparency in the team dynamic requires the team manager to meet with
individuals concerned and the team as a group to re-establish roles, responsibilities, deadlines and
effective working. This involves:
• stating the final performance goals of the team;
• setting deadlines for tasks to be completed, and expected standards;
• defining each individual’s role and agreeing the tasks they are responsible for.
Over a period of time, a team may not notice that there has been slippage because the original
psychological contract of the team has remained static while the situation and circumstances that
the team is operating in has moved on. Ideally the conversation about roles and responsibilities
remains a dynamic and live conversation within the team. However, speed of change and time
pressure may lead to these discussions being put on hold.
Over time, teams will move backwards and forwards along the stages of team development (see
Chapter 1, section 1.2) as a result of changes happening within and to the team. Taking notice and
taking action will be essential to getting the team working collaboratively again sooner rather than
later. Team members themselves may be operating outside their originally agreed roles due to changes
in the scope of the task or speed of change, meaning that new tasks have been badly defined.
Highlighting communication breakdowns and taking some time to talk, even in the maelstrom of an
unrelenting business environment, will quickly enable the team to discuss what people are working on
and highlight areas where tasks are unassigned or duplication is taking place. Even if an individual or
team performance issue cannot be addressed immediately, it is still possible to get project milestones
and deadlines back on track by revisiting plans and revising them in line with the new reality. The
important thing is to have a commitment from all team members to achieve team performance goals.
© ABE 51
Chapter 4 Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional
Team members were reporting a frustration at “running to stay still” and having to work extra
hours because there was “too much work to do”. This resulted in individual team members
feeling that the new ways of working were less effective.
Re-establishing roles
Given the growing conflict in the team, the team manager organised a team event to explore
roles and responsibilities and re-establish what was expected of each team member. The team
revisited their job descriptions and agreed what tasks fell within their area of responsibility
and what they did not do within their role. A review of the day-to-day work of individual team
members revealed a number of surprises relating to the assumptions that other team members
were making about who was doing what. The team also examined what tasks and service areas
each individual member was best suited to deliver for particular aspects of the service.
Mohammed found that the team event was the first time he felt the team had worked
collaboratively since he had joined. He left the event with an explicit understanding of what role
other members had and where the boundaries of different responsibilities began and ended.
The team had also worked through different areas where they felt the team needed to work
more efficiently.
Over to you
Activity 4: What is your role?
Think about the role you play within your team. Write down two or three significant
aspects of your own role. Consider whether your team members have an accurate
understanding of your role. Who needs to know more about your role?
Adair (1997, see above) argued that team managers have to balance the need to maintain team
working (people) with the process to achieve the outcome (task); this can be achieved by paying
attention to all three interdependent variables with an emphasis on managing the needs of each
area.
52 © ABE
Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional Chapter 4
Task
Individual Team
Furthermore, the team manager must also acknowledge that individual team members may require
additional support, either in terms of other team members coming alongside them to provide
assistance in hitting a tight deadline or completing a task or ensuring that the individual team
members have the skills and training they require to competently accomplish the tasks they have
been set. This support requires the team manager to work with each team member on a one-to-one
basis to identify any development needs and work on a personal development plan to close any gaps.
Early intervention
Since conflict arises from difference, it is hardly surprising that, from time to time, a group of
different individuals working together will experience conflict. Differences, which contribute to
conflict, include:
• Differences in views and beliefs with regard to how individual members understand how the
world works.
© ABE 53
Chapter 4 Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional
These differences can make collaboration complicated. It is essential that team managers address
difficulties and signs of conflict at an early stage. Destructive conflict may occur because of an
individual member making a power play to exert their priorities above those of their colleagues;
this can then lead to a destructive cycle of competition and negativity. It is essential that when
difficulties arise they are dealt with quickly and constructively. Recognising that there is a difficulty,
and working through and reviewing the differences that are at play, will enable the team to manage
criticism, evenly distribute power and harness diversity to make the team stronger and deliver
greater levels of performance.
Therefore, it is necessary to monitor team relationships and proactively resolve any conflicts when
they arise.
Mediation
Sometimes conflict cannot be resolved within the team, despite attempts to counter any negative
behaviours. On occasion, where dysfunction threatens to be destructive, it is advisable to engage
specialists temporarily. Involving specialists may include individual coaches for specific team
members or a full team intervention, in the form of team building to increase team co-operation
and air any grievances that are unresolved.
If the conflict is between two members or factions of the team, mediation may be necessary to find
a solution to move the team forward. This is perhaps the most difficult type of conflict to manage,
because it requires the team manager to remain impartial and avoid siding with a particular party.
Celebrate progress
In corporate life, celebrating success is often considered to be an activity that would be good
if the team had time for it. Furthermore, success is usually left to a celebration at the end of a
journey, a future prize to be won but which has little relationship to the day-to-day work of the
team. However, an end-of-year bonus will not be a source of motivation when the team is facing
difficulties ten months before the end of the project, whereas paying a percentage of the bonus
on delivery of key milestones will support ongoing motivation. Hackman (1990, see Reading list)
suggests that team managers should plan ways to celebrate progress and maintain motivation.
This is especially true in the difficult places, where progress is a hard-fought battle and it is easy to
lose sight of what the team are working towards.
Creating meaningful rewards at key milestones, and being consistent in recognising the
contribution of individual team members with appropriate praise and reward, will ensure that
celebrating progress in in line with the team’s actions. This might include a celebratory team meal
at the end of a key phase of a project or ensuring that all achievements are celebrated and shared
in some way by the team as an appreciation of the work they are doing.
54 © ABE
Why Team Working can Become Dysfunctional Chapter 4
Reading list
• Braun, Frank C., Avital, Michel, Martz, Ben (2012) “Action‐centered team leadership
influences more than performance”, Team Performance Management: An International
Journal, Vol. 18 Iss: 3/4, pp.176–195.
• Eaton, Jack (2001) “Management communication: the threat of groupthink”, Corporate
Communications: An International Journal, Vol. 6 Iss: 4, pp.183–192.
• Hackman, Richard (1990) Groups That Work (and those that don’t) Wiley.
• Perry Jr, Emmett E., Karney, Dennis F. and Spencer, Daniel G., (2013) “Team establishment
of self‐managed work teams: a model from the field”, Team Performance Management: An
International Journal, Vol. 19 Iss: 1/2, pp.87–108.
Summary
There is a belief that teams have the potential to perform significantly better than the sum of
individuals working on their own. However, research evidence and the personal experience of
many employees is that teams regularly encounter obstacles to working well. Therefore, team
effectiveness not only requires an ability to build teams who can work together collaboratively but
also the management of ineffective and broken teams, which can be found in most organisations.
Responding appropriately to teams who get stuck, lack purpose and seem incapable of working
together is essential if team dysfunction is to be corrected.
The reaction that different team members will have to the dysfunction will be mixed, from
attempting to avoid conflict to placing blame. Neither approach will be successful in returning the
team to effective team working. Instead, taking steps to re-establish collaborative team working
requires a rediscovery of team cohesion and managing for effective performance.
© ABE 55
Chapter 5
Your Own Team Working
Skills and Traits
Introduction
As well as needing to be qualified, soft skills have become increasingly important as people
may be required to work as part of different teams on a variety of projects. Having business
awareness, being responsive and having a ‘can do’ attitude is essential, as is a willingness to work
collaboratively with different people.
This concluding chapter will provide tools and techniques for you to evaluate your own skillset in
relation to team working in order to optimise your input to the teams in which you work. This will
ultimately maximise those teams’ contributions to meeting business objectives.
Learning outcomes
On completing the chapter, you will be able to:
5 Analyse your own skills and team working traits in order to understand how you can
contribute effectively to team working
Assessment criteria
5 Analyse your own skills and team working traits in order to understand how you can
contribute effectively to team working
5.1 Analyse your own skills and team working traits in order to understand the roles you are
likely to be most effective at performing in a team context
5.2 Evaluate the challenges you might face, and present to others, when working as part of a
team, and what action you can take to minimise the negative impact of these factors on
collaborative working
© ABE
Level 4 Dynamic and
Collaborative Teams
Background
Team work has the potential to contribute strength through a collective effort to be productive and
open, providing the environment for which organisational problems and issues can be tackled.
Researchers have discovered that there are a number of complementary skills and team working
traits which can contribute to effective team working, Understanding your own team working
traits and those of your team members can enable you to utilise the qualities of individuals for
the advantage of the team. It is important to remember when exploring human traits that it is not
about a specific trait being better or worse than another, rather it is helpful to identify and explore
how each trait can be used to deliver the best outcomes for the team. It is worth noting that
classifications of different personality traits are not without their critics, who argue that it is not
possible to quantify something as unique as an individual personality.
By planning work, allocating tasks and reviewing performance it is possible for the team manager to
structure the team in a way that will release the full potential of each team member to enhance the
performance of the team as a whole. Therefore, delegating responsibilities can be a targeted effort aimed
at building and maintaining the team based on who they are, and what they can achieve for the team.
Over to you
Activity 1: Explore personality traits
You can find a number of personality tests online which will provide you with some
information about your personal traits. Search for a personality trait test online.
• What do the results confirm about what you already know about yourself?
• What surprised you about the results?
• B
ased on the results, what one action can you take that will help you to utilise your
traits and contribute more to your team?
© ABE 57
Chapter 5 Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits
Team roles
In 1993, Dr Meredith Belbin, a British researcher and management theorist, identified nine possible
team roles that individuals play within a team, based upon different types of behaviour and
performance. Understanding and developing the behaviours and team roles within the team can
improve a team’s performance. Belbin proposed that if a team is constructed of individuals who
exhibit all nine types of behaviours then the team will be highly successful. The nine roles identified
by Belbin are shown in Table 1.
Resource Seeks out and finds new ideas, opportunities and resources for the team.
investigator Enthusiastic but can lose interest and be over-optimistic.
Team worker The versatile diplomat of the team, who encourages the team to co-
operate and gets work done on behalf of the team. Avoids conflict and
can be indecisive.
Co-ordinator Keeps the team aligned to its goals and delegates tasks to meet
objectives. However, might over-delegate and not take their full share of
the workload.
Plant Creative and will find novel solutions to problems. Generates ideas but
can be forgetful and fail to communicate effectively.
Monitor The impartial judge who is strategic, logical and weighs all options.
evaluator Dispassionate but can be uninspiring and at times critical of others.
Specialist The specialist who has expertise in a key area, however their focus is
narrow and can produce information overload.
Shaper Provides the drive to keep team momentum moving forward. Overcomes
obstacles but can sometimes offend in pushing to get things done.
Implementer Practical and strategic, turning ideas into action and organising work.
Reliable but can hold tightly to the plan demonstrating inflexibility in the
face of change.
Completer Effective at finishing work off and checking for errors. Conscientious
finisher quality controller but can let perfect get in the way of good.
58 © ABE
Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits Chapter 5
Over to you
Activity 2: Belbin team roles
What team role(s) do you play? Search online for a free Belbin team role assessment.
Completing the test will increase your self-awareness and provide a useful start point
for discussing your personal development.
Team development
A decision was made to address the issues that the project team was having; part of the
development involved the use of the Belbin tool to understand the different team roles. It was
discovered that the project team lacked some specific roles in the team but had too many of
other team roles. Franco was one of three specialists on the team. A decision was made to
restructure the team, swapping some team members to close gaps in team role types in order
to make the team more productive and ensure that the working styles of team members were
balanced across the team. Aldo, a shaper, was bought into the team at this point.
A balanced team
The introduction of new team members to balance the team roles in the project team was
combined with further team development to improve communication. The team began to work
productively together which meant the project got back on schedule and led to a successful
product launch.
© ABE 59
Chapter 5 Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits
Resource
investigator
Completer Team worker
finisher
Co-ordinator
Implementer
Belbin Team
Roles
Plant
Shaper
Monitor
Specialist
evaluator
Being a This requires the team members to have a shared task, clearly stated
real team boundaries and stable group membership.
Compelling The team requires clear, challenging goals. Team members need to
direction understand their own contribution to the overall mission of the team.
Enabling Although many of the structural aspects of the team will be determined by the
structure organisation, the team can exercise control over the aspects of task variety, so
who will carry out the task and the way in which the task is accomplished.
Supportive The framework of support is the result of reward structures, training and
context development and access to information. These elements require co-operation
between team members and guidance from the team manager in order to be
a positive influence.
Expert The day-to-day management of the team will help to identify the support
coaching required by individual members with regard to skills, knowledge and
capability development. The team manager may also identify what stage of
team development in which the team is operating, as discussed in Chapter 1,
section 1.2.
1 Hackman, J.R. (2002). Leading Teams: Setting the stage for great performances. Harvard Business Press.
60 © ABE
Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits Chapter 5
As an individual team member, the five factor model helps you to ensure that you are contributing
your skills and capabilities appropriately to the success of the team. This can be achieved by
reviewing the five factors against the current situation of the team, ensuring that an appropriate
team structure is in place and that you are contributing to a supportive environment in which your
colleagues are able to develop their own skills.
Over to you
Activity 3: Five factor model analysis
Consider a team that you are currently part of and think about the following questions.
Then add your answers to the third column.
Being a real Who is involved in the team?
team
Do they have complementary skills and
experiences?
Compelling What is the purpose of the team?
direction
How well do they achieve team goals and aims?
Enabling What team processes and activities work well?
structure
What does not work so well?
Supportive What are the positive features of the
context organisational context?
What are the negative features of the
organisational context?
Expert What training and development do the team
coaching members engage in?
Compelling Enabling
direction structure
Real team
Expert coaching
Different personality traits highlight that a group of people will all see the world differently. These
unique perspectives result in individual paradigms being brought into the team environment. This
can be both a positive and negative thing: positive because the diversity of perspectives opens
up new possibilities and innovative thinking and negative because it increases the opportunity for
dysfunction if individual perspectives are suppressed.
Minimising the impact of the flip-side of personality traits means that the team manager and team
members must work together to offset bad personality traits and utilise good personality traits in
order to achieve synergy. Including personality trait analysis as part of the recruitment process can
help to increase your understanding of whether a new hire is a good fit for the team. Additionally,
personality traits can be used to help team members support each other, by taking into account
personalities that are supportive of each other.
Over to you
Activity 4: Your role in improving team effectiveness
Consider the team that you evaluated in Activity 6: Managing for collaboration on
page 44. Reflect on your own role in this team in order to identify how you could help
improve team effectiveness if the same project was to be repeated.
62 © ABE
Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits Chapter 5
Awareness of others
Focusing on issues can become habitual in a team environment, especially if the team is under
pressure. It can also be easier to focus on the things that annoy you about someone rather than
paying attention to the things that they do well. After all, problems demand our immediate
attention a lot more than anything that goes well. But if team members are to minimise challenges
to collaborative working it is essential that individuals commit to being aware of what people
contribute to the team. This includes placing a spotlight on the strengths and talents that each
individual brings to the team and placing a high value on enabling individuals to play to those
strengths. High levels of performance are much more likely to occur if individuals are able to be
their best, rather than being maligned for the potential issues they might present to others.
Team profiling
The leadership team development programme included the use of team profiling and
exploration of team behaviours to increase team members’ self-awareness and the awareness
of the strengths of others in the team. Dana found the programme challenging as it pushed
her and the other members of the leadership team outside their comfort zone. But, however
uncomfortable the process, Dana found that getting to know the strengths of other members of
the team helped to improve her relationship with them.
© ABE 63
Chapter 5 Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits
the wider organisation. Evaluating your contribution, both in terms of individual performance and
in working collaboratively with others in the team, is an essential component of maximising team
effectiveness.
You are responsible for identifying gaps in your knowledge, skills and capabilities that affect your
ability to contribute to team performance goals. You will need to acknowledge areas where you
need support or training and take responsibility for learning and skills development. Openness to
giving and receiving feedback is part of this process.
You also need to be accountable for delivering the tasks you have been given, holding other
team members accountable for their contributions and working together with the team to deliver
performance goals.
Finally, working collaboratively with others requires that you celebrate success: your success,
individual team members’ success and the success of the team as a whole. Recognising others,
giving verbal feedback for a job well done or acknowledging progress are as important as the
celebrations that occur when your team finally achieves its goal.
Over to you
Activity 5: Personal development plan
• C
onstruct a self-development plan for the next 6 to 12 months to improve your
contribution to team working.
My goal:
Development goal – How? What action What resource or When are you going
What are you going will you take? support do you to do it by?
to do? need?
64 © ABE
Your Own Team Working Skills and Traits Chapter 5
Reading list
• Manning, Tony, Parker, Richard and Pogson, Graham (2006) “A revised model of team roles
and some research findings”, Industrial and Commercial Training, Vol. 38 Iss: 6, pp.287 –96
• Prichard, Jane S., Stanton, Neville A. (1999) “Testing Belbin’s team role theory of effective
groups”, Journal of Management Development, Vol. 18 Iss: 8, pp.652 – 665.
• Rao, M.S. (2016) “Collaborate to build effective teams to achieve organizational excellence
and effectiveness”, Industrial and Commercial Training, Vol. 48 Iss: 1, pp.24–28.
Summary
Working collaboratively requires that you evaluate your own skillset in relation to team working
in order to optimise your input to the teams of which you are a part, and maximise the team’s
contribution to meeting business objectives. Developing an awareness of your personality traits,
strengths and weaknesses, and understanding the contribution made by your team members, are
an essential part of team effectiveness.
There are several different models that identify team traits and each model defines traits in different
ways. However, regardless of the definitions used, what makes a team successful remains the
same: how the team members relate to complete a task; a sense of belonging; finding meaning
in the team performance goals they have set; and individual team members developing their own
capabilities.
© ABE 65
Glossary
Glossary
Accountability Being responsible and Formal team A team identified as part
accountable for your own actions and decisions. of the organisation design, depicted by an
organisational chart.
Agility The ability of a team to move quickly
and respond to changes. Functional lines Organisation structure
divided into functional areas such as IT, Finance,
Autocratic The team manager who makes
HR or Marketing.
a decision without any consultation with the
team. Often perceived as the team manager Group Individuals who depend on each other
having control. to complete a task, but do not work as a team.
Although they may have a common interest
Co-active power Where genuine power is
they do not share a common purpose.
shared with team members.
Coercive power Where the team manager Group think Decision-making in a group
where thinking is unchallenged and of poor
has power over the team members.
quality.
Collaborate Join forces with others to work
jointly.
Hierarchical A succession or order of rank.
66 © ABE
Glossary
© ABE 67