David Yonggi Cho's Theology of The Fullness of The Spirit PDF
David Yonggi Cho's Theology of The Fullness of The Spirit PDF
21-34]
William W. Menzies
1. Introduction
1
An earlier version of this study was presented in the Second Youngsan
International Theological Symposium, May 2003, Hansei University, Goonpo,
Korea.
22 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)
2
Changsoo Kang, “An Analytical Study On the Life of Woon-Mong Na,
Indigenous Korean Pentecostal” (Th.M. thesis, Asia Pacific Theological
Seminary, 2003), p. 34.
Menzies, Cho’s Theology of the Fullness of the Spirit 23
I prayed for an experience with the Holy Spirit whom I had studied and
learned about. I asked the Holy Spirit to come and fill me with His
power, His ministry and His message for a sick and hurting world….So
daily I prayed for the filling of the Holy Spirit…. And then it happened.
One evening while I was asking the Lord for the filling of the Holy
Spirit, I felt His presence draw near. It was a wonderful experience. I
was worshipping and praising Jesus aloud, telling Him audibly again
and again how wonderful it was to know Him and how much I loved
Him…. As I worshipped, I felt a warm glow touch my face, then my
tongue, then my body, and without realizing it I began to speak new
words that came to my mind and my tongue at the same time…. My
heart was overflowing with praise and worship to Jesus in a new
language…. That was my initial experience when I was baptized with
3
the Holy Spirit.
3
The Holy Spirit, My Senior Partner (Altamonte Springs, FL: Creation House,
1989), pp. 8, 9.
4
Kang, “An Analytical Study,” p. 2.
24 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)
5
A. J. Gordon, The Ministry of the Holy Spirit (Philadelphia, PA: Judson Press,
1894; reprinted in 1949), p. 69.
6
Robert P. and William W. Menzies, Spirit and Power: Foundations of
Pentecostal Experience (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2000), pp. 18, 19.
Menzies, Cho’s Theology of the Fullness of the Spirit 25
7
J. R. Williams, “Baptism in the Holy Spirit,” in The New International
Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements, eds. Stanley M. Burgess
and others (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2002), pp. 355, 356.
8
Williams, “Baptism in the Holy Spirit,” p. 357.
9
Williams, “Baptism in the Holy Spirit,” pp. 358-60.
10
Williams, “Baptism in the Holy Spirit,” p. 358.
26 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)
11
“Minutes of the 49th Session of the General Council of the Assemblies of God,
Convened in Kansas City, Missouri, August 7-10, 2001, with Revised
Constitution and Bylaws,” p. 92.
12
William W. Menzies and Stanley M. Horton, Bible Doctrines, A Pentecostal
Perspective (Springfield, MO: Gospel Publishing House, 1993), pp. 135-38.
13
The Holy Spirit, p. 114.
14
Kang, “An Analytical Study,” p. 2.
15
Kang, “An Analytical Study,” p. 2.
Menzies, Cho’s Theology of the Fullness of the Spirit 27
16
Prayer: Key to Revival (Waco, TX: Word Books, 1984), p. 10.
17
Prayer: Key to Revival, p. 14.
28 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)
of the Korean churches. And, certainly this is what Cho has taught for
many years!
Cho has provided a personal glimpse into his own prayer life. He
describes the way he prays, how he prays, and how this impacts the
course of his day. It is through this connection with God that the flow of
the Holy Spirit rests upon his life.18 He reports, “How do we get to know
the Holy Spirit? We only become aware of His nature as we enter into a
life of prayer.” 19 He spends time fellowshipping with the Holy Spirit,
being renewed spiritually, mentally and physically. “Out of the one hour
that I spend in prayer every morning, much of that time is spent in
fellowship with the Holy Spirit.”20 Cho says, “The measure of our faith is
in direct proportion to our communion with the Holy Spirit.”21
There is an intimate connection between prayer and faith. In his
book, The Leap of Faith, Cho illustrates how God works. In 1969, God
told him to build a church that would seat 10,000 people. In the
providence of God, space for one church had been allotted on Yoido
Island, at the edge of Seoul (now it is not too far from the center of the
metropolis). From the beginning of construction, many things seemed to
go wrong, including the devaluation of the currency and skyrocketing
inflation. Many people lost their jobs and the church income suffered.
About this time, Cho had felt led to initiate his prayer mountain. Deeply
discouraged, Cho joined the group at the prayer mountain. The people of
his church had been interceding for Cho. He sensed, all at once, a change
in the atmosphere. One poor woman offered all she had—a rice bowl and
a pair of chopsticks. Cho, weeping, said he did not want to take these
items from the woman, since she had so little. She insisted. One man in
the rear of the room heard the conversation. He spoke up and said, “I will
buy the bowl and the chopsticks for $1,000.” Others joined in the spirit
of sacrificial giving. Cho and his wife sold their home and put the
proceeds into the building fund. Miraculously, the church was saved
from disaster and the new building was completed. Prayer was the key
that produced faith, and faith prevailed!22
It is appropriate to acknowledge the legacy of the great revival in
Pyongyang in 1906. The Presbyterians had established the practice of
18
Prayer: Key to Revival, pp. 15-17.
19
Prayer: Key to Revival, p. 43.
20
Prayer: Key to Revival, p. 45.
21
The Holy Spirit, p. 18.
22
The Leap of Faith (South Plainfield, NJ: Bridge Publishing, 1984), pp. 56-59.
Menzies, Cho’s Theology of the Fullness of the Spirit 29
23
Prayer: Key to Revival, pp. 13, 14.
24
YFGC, Ordeal and Glory through the 30-Year History of Yoido Full Gospel
Church (Seoul: YFGC, 1988).
30 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)
need for a balanced presentation of truth so that God’s desire for the
prosperity of believers is not construed to mean that faith will guarantee
paradise here and now with no suffering to be encountered by those with
sufficient faith. However, an equally strong case can be made for the
need to raise the horizons of deeply-discouraged people to dare to believe
for God’s divine intervention into dark circumstances. It is in this context
that Cho’s teaching on “the five-fold message of the gospel” must be
understood.
The influence of Oral Roberts is clearly evident in the teaching of
Cho. One theme of Roberts with which Cho resonates is “God is a good
God.” In a animistic Buddhist culture, in which works-righteousness is
mixed with fear of the supernatural, Cho preached that God is a God of
love, a God of grace, and that he intends for good to happen to those who
will trust him. Jesus came to bring life and that more abundantly!25
Based on 3 John 2, Cho sees three dimensions of God’s intended
blessing for his people. The first is “as your soul prospers.” His primary
focus is on the salvation of the individual, new birth. However, Cho
moves beyond entrance into the family of God to the fullness of the Holy
Spirit.
The prosperity God wants to see in our lives applies to the whole
picture of living: child-rearing, our jobs, businesses, human
relationships, the necessities of life, the stability of life, joy and so on.
Consequently, if we are made whole in our spirits, souls and bodies, the
25
Salvation, Health and Prosperity (Altamonte Springs, FL: Creation House,
1984), pp. 11-18.
26
Salvation, Health and Prosperity, p. 49.
Menzies, Cho’s Theology of the Fullness of the Spirit 31
God’s Word does teach great truths such as healing, provision for need,
faith, and the authority of believers. The Bible does teach that a
disciplined mind is an important factor in victorious living. But these
truths must always be considered in the framework of the total teaching
28
of Scripture.
Cho did not allow his teaching to descend to that level of abuse. One
must remember that his mission was to pull discouraged people out of the
depths of despondency.
27
Salvation, Health and Prosperity, p. 55.
28
“The Believer and Positive Confession,” in Where We Stand (Springfield, MO:
Gospel Publishing House, 1997), p. 144.
32 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)
I once thought that poverty had great moral value. In Korea ministers
used to preach that poverty was a blessing, that the poor were those
who reaped the most from life’s experiences. However, these same
ministers were also continually asking their congregations to give more
and more money to the church. Teaching the value of poverty, they also
preached the merit of increased contributions. This contradiction
bothered me. When I became a minister myself I volunteered to pastor
in a slum area of the city of Seoul. People in that community lived lives
of poverty, mostly eating only one meal a day. Children were sick from
malnutrition, and many were starving to death. It was then that I read
the Bible anew, searching for a solution. I wanted to know God’s will
29
about poverty.
It is clear that Cho was addressing a very definite crisis need in the
Korean situation. Certainly he emphasized strongly one dimension of the
Christian faith—the possibilities for a better life. He should not be
faulted for not tempering his message with all the qualifications that can
be cited in a balanced message, since in the crisis of that time, he
understood what emphasis was most desperately needed.
In Cho’s understanding of 3 John 2, he also saw implications for the
Christian and physical health. Categorically he states, “God desires that
we may live in good health.”30 He taught that healing is not only in the
atonement, but that the Holy Spirit has been given to the church by Jesus
Christ to bring healing to the nations.
The Holy Spirit, the other Comforter who dwells among us and
continues Jesus’ work, enables us to understand and receive
forgiveness because of Jesus’ work on Calvary. As an evidence that we
have been forgiven, He heals us. Through the Holy Spirit we have the
31
grace of salvation with healing as its sign.
29
Solving Life’s Problems (Plainfield, NJ: Logos International, 1980), p. 27.
30
Salvation, Health, and Prosperity, p. 115.
31
Salvation, Health, and Prosperity, p. 141.
Menzies, Cho’s Theology of the Fullness of the Spirit 33
guarantee that all will be healed, but that the Christian who desires
healing has the responsibility to cultivate a life of prayer and belief.32
The American Assemblies of God has from its beginnings held a
strong conviction that divine healing is an essential component of the
gospel message.
As we observe the ministry of both Jesus and the apostles, it is
evident that divine healing was not something peripheral. It was an
important witness to Jesus, as the revelation of the Father, as the
promised Messiah, and as the Savior from sin (see John 10:37, 38).33
The position paper does acknowledge that, in spite of the strong
affirmation about the privilege of all believers to enjoy the blessing of
divine healing, there remain mysteries.
In humility we recognize that we do not understand all that pertains
to divine healing. We still see through a glass darkly. We do not
understand why some are healed and others are not any more than we
understand why God permitted James to be martyred and Peter delivered.
Scripture makes it clear, however, that our part is to preach the Word and
expect the signs to follow.34
The American Assemblies of God position paper on divine healing
resonates closely with the teaching of Cho, except for the reservation
made in the concluding paragraph that acknowledges the mystery
pertaining to the fact that not all for whom prayer is offered are, in fact,
healed. I do not think that Cho would teach anything contrary to this,
although this qualification does not appear to be explicitly stated.
5. Conclusion
32
Salvation, Health, and Prosperity, pp. 144-56.
33
“Divine Healing: An Integral Part of the Gospel,” p. 45.
34
“Divine Healing: An Integral Part of the Gospel,” p. 54.
34 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 7:1 (2004)