Experimental analysis of various communication

technologies in AMI systems

Ching-Yi Hsueh Wei Huang Wu-Chieh Wu Chin-Yao Chang
Internet of Things Laboratory, Internet of Things Laboratory, Internet of Things Laboratory, Internet of Things Laboratory,
Telecommunication Laborateries, Telecommunication Laborateries, Telecommunication Laborateries, Telecommunication Laborateries,
Chunghwa Telecom Chunghwa Telecom Chunghwa Telecom Chunghwa Telecom
Taiwan, R.O.C. Taiwan, R.O.C. Taiwan, R.O.C. Taiwan, R.O.C.
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

Ming-Feng Dong Chien-Tang Chiu

Internet of Things Laboratory, Internet of Things Laboratory,
Telecommunication Laborateries, Telecommunication Laborateries,
Chunghwa Telecom Chunghwa Telecom
Taiwan, R.O.C Taiwan, R.O.C
[email protected] [email protected]

Abstract—The low-voltage (110V and 220V) AMI (Advance plan energy management, and achieve the purpose of energy
Metering Infrastructure) test site of various building (four types) and saving and carbon reduction[1].
floors (B2-4F, 8F and 18F) in CHTTL (Telecommunication
Laborateries, Chunghwa Telecom) have been established. The effects AMI network includes Wide Area Network (WAN) and
of various communication technologies (RF( Radio Frequency ) Local Area Network (LAN). LAN usually use PLC(Power
Wireless, PLC(Powerline Communication) and Cellular) on the Line Communication) and RF (Radio Frequency) technologies
communication performance in CHTTL test site were investigated. to transmit meter data. The PLC communication technology
The results indicated that the HES(Head-end server) successfully has been studied by several investigators. The communication
obtained the meters data through various communication modules performance of the DCU(Data Concentrator Unit) connected
(RF, PLC and Cellular) on different building types and floors, with 14 PLC communication modules was examined
especially the basement of stairs and power distribution room. experimentally by Kim et al. [2]. The results showed average
However, the results also revealed that various external factors such operating rate of DCU is 99.3 percent and average operating
as the power line distance, the surrounding wireless signal and the rate of modules is 98.5 percent. González-Sotres et al.
integration of meter and communication module play a significant established a PLC communication model to study the
effect on communication performance and must be considered. These communication performance in the scenarios with 108 or 144
test results provided an efficient way to characterize the users [3]. Numerical simulation results predicted the time of
communication performance for AMI; the results will benefit the
received data to read all nodes has been always lower than 5
future construction of AMI for Taiwan and other countries.
minutes. A NB-PLC(Narrowband PLC) which performed over
Keywords—AMI; communication technologie; communication a week on an extremely power noisy test site simulated the
performance worst case scenario and was conducted experimentally by
Mishra et al. [4]. The results showed data loss rate is less than
1%. Sheikh et al. [5] developed a test site to verify
I. INTRODUCTION communication performance of NB-PLC(Narrow Band-PLC).
In the global climate change, many countries promote The results indicated that the places for high connection
various policies for smart grid. AMI (Advance Metering density, noise inducing loads, residential consumers and
Infrastructure) is the infrastructure for the development of special distribution network have a lower communication
smart grid. AMI is an information system for collecting, performance for NB-PLC. There have appeared a number of
storing and analyzing power data. AMI consists of three parts, RF communication technologies in the published literature. A
namely, smart meter, communication system and model of the RF communication to explore the communication
MDMS(Meter Database Management System). MDMS performance in a typical rural area with an extension of
receives power data from smart meter by communication 240km2 was developed by Malandra et al.[6]. The results
system to analyze and manage data, and further integrate with showed the data (1 collector, 114 routers and 3300 smart
other application systems. meters) can be received within 342.52(s) as soon as possible.
Mafra et al.[7] developed a hybrid communication module
AMI also can apply to home energy management. AMI which can work as well as a bridge between RF and PLC
can help to reduce the cost and manpower for manual meter communication technologies. They found optimal the
reading, and provide power information for users or utilities to transmission rates and data payload to prevent network traffic
jam.

978-1-5386-2910-9/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE

 Ratasuk et al. [8] discussed NB-IoT design targets that functions to simplify AMI Head-end server(HES) receiving
included low-cost devices, high coverage , long device battery meter data, and achieve decentralized management.
life (more than 10 years), and massive capacity. Wenjie Yang
et al. [9] indicated that the low-power wide-area network Power Line Communication (PLC) or Radio Frequency
(LPWAN) is supporting massive IoT with limited radio (RF) are the Common techniques in AMI field. PLC is a
spectrum which included LTE-M and NB-IoT. communication method that uses power line to carry data, but
the communication quality may be affected by power line noise
As for the communication protocol and information or the impedance which does not match at load change, and the
security for AMI, the literature survey has existed in the past long transmission distance may cause signal attenuation.
decade. Huh et al. [10] studied the Zigbee, WiMax and PLC Therefore, RF technology is another LAN communication
communication/transmission technologies. They found option, each country has its own RF channel to choose RF
Datagram Protocol (RUDP) for the Transmission Layer has a specification. The general RF technology use in open areas and
better transmission speed and reliability for the PLC networks need meter concentration, and the data transmission have high
over TCP and UDP. Lekshmi et al. [11] investigated various success rate. The big challenge of LAN communication
protocols such as AODV, DSR, DSDV and AOMDV for AMI technology is complexity environment and communication
network by using simulation. They successfully simulated the interference at present, It may be the reason that
best communication protocol for various data types. The communication technology can’t be applied in all
security mechanism is also a very important issue for AMI. environments. And DCU to AMI Head-end or meter to
Ozgur et al. [12] employed ECDSA and OpenSSL certificates AMI Head-end WAN communication that usually is wired or
to investigate AMI information security. The results showed wireless, wireless solution often Apply Cellular
that appropriate security mechanism can improve the communication technology , and wired solution is the optical
throughput, packet delivery ratio and average completion time. fiber.
From the literature presented above, it was found that some NB IoT technology emerges in recent years. NB IoT
literature is available on communication technologies of RF, include low power consumption, wide coverage (18 ~ 21km),
PLC and cellular, but little information is available on low cost of construction, stable data transmission advantages
developing real test site to verify communication technologies for long time Monitoring and applications.Telecom operators
performance, specially similar to the building environments of do not have to rebuild the cell cite, but through upgrading the
Taiwan, which has many meters are installed on the basement existing 4G cell cite to provide NB-IoT service. It promote the
and high floors. Therefore, the objective of this paper is to telecom operators to actively build NB-IoT cell cite, thus
establish a AMI test site to investigate communication opening the first trend of NB-IoT applied to smart meter which
technologies performance for various building conditions in also contain huge business opportunities, so this experiment
Taiwan. also included NB IoT solution to validate the transmission
performance of NB IoT.
II. COMMUNICATION ARCHITECTURE It can be seen that the AMI can be composed of different
The meter communication system refers to meter data heterogeneous transmission technologies, to use in different
transmission path, which ranged from meter communication communication environments such as cities, suburbs,
modules to AMI Head-end server(HES). Therefore, meter mountains, islands and other environment, so this study use
communication system consists of three parts: communication RF, PLC, and cellular communication to test, as shown in
module, network and HES, the architecture is shown in Fig. 1. Table I. The module A, module B, and module C are used RF
communication technology, frequency band are 840 MHz, 920
The meter communication needs to be chosen the MHz, 920 MHz, respectively; transmit power are 60 mW, 20
appropriate communication technology in different mW, 500 mW, respectively. The module D and module E are
environment. Meter data is transmitted back to the control used PLC communication technology. Module D is broadband
center through one-stage (only WAN) or two-stages(WAN and PLC, used in home network and home AV entertainment, high-
LAN), and the two-stages architecture uses concentrator as a frequency signal is not susceptible to household appliances.
relay point. The LAN communications contain PLC and RF, The module E is narrowband PLC, narrowband PLC is not a
and the 3G/4G/BPL/Fiber/NB-IoT are adopted for WAN new communication technology, but it grow with
communication. communication technology, whether communication rate or
The selection of communication architecture depends on anti-noise modulation technology has grown significantly. And
the area of meter, such as rural areas transmit meter data by module F is used Cellular technology, it directly transmitted to
Wide Area Network (WAN) communication technology to Head-end server by NB-IoT communication standard. This
AMI Head-end, the meter data in the cities and towns study analyzes above six kinds of communication modules in
(centralized) use Local Area Network (LAN) to the DCU, then Taiwan, supply the resolved and notice of AMI communication
DCU via WAN sent the meter data to AIM Head-End. network architecture planning.
Therefore technology of the communication system involve
LAN, DCU, WAN, and AMI Head-end. The DCU integrates
LAN side and WAN side communication module, and plays an
important role in connecting meters and AMI Head-End. DCU
may provide temporary meter data and management meters
 Fig. 1. Architecture of AMI

TABLE I. SPECIFICATION OF VARIOUS COMMUNICATION MODULES Fig. 2. Architecture of AMI

Communication
module A B C D E F
Communication
Wireless RF Wi-Sun
Wireless
HD-PLC G3-PLC NB-IoT
B. Test scenarios
technology RF
RF
60mW 20mW 500mW -- -- --
This test area planned 32 testing point, set up at Building A
transmit power
RF
(13 testing points), Building B (2 testing points), Building C (4
frequency band
840MHz 920MHz 920MHz -- -- --
testing points), and Staff dorm (9 testing points) as shown in
PLC
Carrier -- -- -- 2-28MHz
150-490
--
Fig.4 and Fig.5. To test the effects of distance between DCU
kHz
frequency and RF module on communication performance (ex. R12), the
PLC
maximum -- -- -- 240Mbps
300
--
effects of cubby room between DCU and RF module on
kbps
transfer rate communication performance (ex. R5, R6 and R12) and the
4G Telecom
operators
-- -- -- -- -- CHT effects of the number of DCU on RF module communication
Meter type
Simulation
meter
Real meter Real meter
Simulation
meter
Real
meter
Real
meter
performance and the effects for communication module
replacing in steel box on communication performance. This
paper placed took turns A-C (RF module) and F(Cellular
module) on R1-R18, as shown in Fig.4. This paper placed took
III. TEST SITE AND SCENARIOS turns D and E (PLC communication module) and F(Cellular
In Taiwan, the urban buildings are fairly dense and module) on P1-P14, installed place of power line as shown in
complex, and the meters are usually installed in the top floor of Fig.5. Through those test point above, it can analyze that the
the building or the basement of stairs and power distribution effects of voltage on PLC communication performance(ex.
room. The meters may not be able to transmit data by single P1,P3,P5,P7,P9,P14), the effects of voltage on PLC
communication technology. Therefore, The low-voltage (110V communication performance, the effects of DCU over different
and 220V) AMI (Advance Metering Infrastructure) test site of transformer on PLC communication performance(ex. PLC5
various building (four types) and floors (B2-4F, 8F and 18F) in and PLC6), the effects of distance between DCU and PLC on
CHTTL (Telecommunication Laborateries, Chunghwa communication performance(e.g. Whether it effects on data
Telecom) have been established. transmission while DCU installed in B1 and PLC
communication module installed in 8F or 18F), and the effects
A. Test site of PLC communication on home electricity.
According to low-voltage AMI of metropolitan area in
Taiwan, this paper planned Da-an Dist. of CHTTL (Located in C. Test method
Taipei, Taiwan) to test area, including Building A (B1/1F/ 8F), The aim of this study is stability and accuracy of AMI. The
Building B (B1/1F) and Building C (18F) and Staff dorm (1F ~ test item is included availability, success rate, alarm/power cut
4F), as shown in Fig. 2. It can simulate community types in message of HES to AMI, mesh testing, RF interference testing
Taiwan by test area above, such as apartment, house, condo. and etc.
To provide testing of PLC communication and power supply of
RF, PLC and cellular communication modules, this study • Availability testing aims to confirm communication of
prepared power distribution(power-line position, phase 6 communication modules placing different place.
sequence, voltage, number of receptacles, etc.) and six steel Above all, this study run AMI system for 2 hours, and
boxes before testing. This study used 4 power meters, 6 use HES reading real-time data from the smart meter
communication modules and 3 HES for this experiment. data by the communication module.
• Success rate testing is used HES to receive historical
data in 24 hours from 32 communication modules, and
confirm whether it can receive data completely.
• While device occurred unusual event or alarm, HES
can receive unusual event and power cut message.
• Mesh testing is used HES to confirm whether the
network can re-establish the network connection, after
removing one RF/PLC module at random.
 • RF interference testing is testing whether the
communication module interfered each other in
placing multiple RF communication modules.

(c) Building B (d) Building C

Fig. 5. Schematic diagram of PLC communication modules position

IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

In order to analysis the influences of AMI communication
technologies (RF, PLC and Cellular) in Taiwan, we used varied
communication technologies on various building types and
Fig. 3. Photograph of the power distribution and steel boxes floors (B2-4F/8F/18F) and investigated the influences of those
communication technologies.
(a) Building A(B2F-8F) (b) Staff dorm (1F-4F)
For RF, all of the communication modules A, B and C were
R11 using RF communication technology. First of all, we installed
Room 14 communication modules A in R1 to R18 area, and using a
DCU to receive the data of those meters. The results is shown
4F
Steel box
R17 Office
in Table 1, the DCU could receive all the meter’s data
(including real-time and historical data) successfully. It is also
window
Steel box
R18 R10
R4 Stair 8F shown that covered by an steel box, tests of alarm and power
Room
off messages, signal interference, and RF mesh test could be
Door
3F received successfully. Secondly, we also installed 14
Lobby
Exit
communication modules B in R1 to R18 area. The results
R9 shown that HES couldn’t receive both the time data and
historical data by using single DCU neither the signals from
R3 Stair 1F
Room
Power room Steel box
R13 Exit
the building C(18F).
2F
Steel box
R5
R14
Parking area
The results are shown in Fig6. This is because the LoRa
B1
R8 transmission band in Taiwan is 920MHz, and the module
emission power was only 20mW, which probably led to the
R2 Stair

Room
signal be sheltered. Therefore, each building placed a DCU to
Door
Steel box
R15
Parking area
Exit 1F
avoid the signal being covered, it is found that the HES could
Steel box
R16
receive all the meter’s data (including real-time and historical
R1 Stair B2 Exit data) successfully(except for R12). The results also shows that
the alarm messages, power off messages, signal interference,
(c) Building B(B1F-5F) (d) Building C(B2F-18F) and RF mesh test could be received successfully. Finally, we
installed 14 communication modules C in R1 to R18 area. The
results had shown that both real-time and historical data could
be collected by single DCU, and LoRa masking effect didn’t
happened. It is because that the module communication
transmission power was 500mW. Besides that, we found that
the signal which integrated module B and meter of brand X
couldn’t transport to faraway distance (1F~18F), but the signal
Fig. 4. Schematic diagram of RF communication modules position integrated with the meter of brand Y would not have this
phenomenon. It probably caused by the meter and
(a) Building A (b) Staff dorm communication module integration model. The defect of
integration model led to lack of power supply, which
influenced the maximum transmission power. And the tests of
alarm message and power cut message, RF mesh test were
passed successfully. In term of reading data speed, module B
was the fastest among all modules. It probably both module B
and module C were the same brand products, which let HES
read the data from meter quickly.
In term of PLC communication technology, both module D
and E were used PLC communication technology. Module D
used broadband PLC and Module E used narrowband PLC. We
installed 14 modules D in P1 to P14 area, and the results were
shown as Table II. The results shown that the both real-time
data and historical data could be successfully received by HES,
other such as tests of alarm message and power off message,
mesh test could also be received successfully. Next, we
installed 14 modules E in P1 to P14 area. The results shown
that the data from building A(P1~P6) couldn’t be received. So
we tried to move the DCU(building A) to other places. When
the DCU installed in P2 area, the data of P1~P6 could be
Fig. 6. Potograph of the spectrum analysis
received successfully. This is due to the length different
between S-phase and earth wire for The original preset device
placement, which led to unsynchronized phenomenon during V. CONCLUSIONS
communication. Besides that, although module E used NB
In this paper, the effects of various communication
PLC and there were lot of appliances in the dormitory. It worth
technologies (RF, PLC and Cellular) on the communication
to mention that both the real-time data and historical data could
performance in the low voltage AMI test site of CHTTL in
be received successfully. It probably that there were no air
Taiwan have been investigated experimentally. According to
conditioning and dehumidifiers in this area, so the commission
the present measurements, the following conclusions can be
signal wasn’t be influenced. In term of reading data speed,
drawn.
module D was faster than module E. Because the fastest
transmission speed of module E was 240 Mbps. • HES successfully obtained the meter data through
In term of Cellular communication technology(NB-IoT), various communication modules(RF, PLC and Cellular)
module F was installed in R1 to R18 area. The results had on various building types and floors(B2-4F, 8F and
shown that the historical data could be received by HES 18F).
successfullye. In the future, when the NB-IoT communication • The effects of power line length and diameter which
module is commercialized and the telecom operators are communication module of narrowband PLC is installed
officially negotiated. We can expect that cellular in have a significant impact on the communication
communication technology will be replaced by NB-IoT. performance. The communication performance
decreases due to communication transmission is not
TABLE II. SPECIFICATION OF VARIOUS COMMUNICATION MODULES synchronized.
Communication • It is important to note that a better integration with
A B C D E F
module communication module and meter will provide a better
R1 O O O -- -- O
R2 O O O -- -- O
communication performance. It is found that the
R3 O O O -- -- O communication performance decrease as a poor
R4
R5
O
O
O
O
O
O
--
--
--
--
O
O
integration with communication module and meter due
R6 O O O -- -- O to the transmit power decrease.
R7 O O O -- -- O
R8
R9
O
O
O
O
O
O
--
--
--
--
O
O
• In Taiwan, communication module of RF using 920
R10 O O O -- -- O MHz band requires a higher transmit power due to the
R11 O O O -- -- O signal may be masked by LoRa, which decrease the
R12 O X O -- -- O
R13 O O O -- -- O communication performance.
R14 O O O -- -- O
R15 O O O -- -- O
R16 O O O -- -- O References
R17 O O O -- -- O
R18 O O O -- -- O [1] Stanislav Chren, Bruno Rossi and Tom´aˇs Pitner, “ Smart grids
P1~P14 -- -- -- O O -- deployments within EU projects: The role of smart meters,” Smart Cities
Symposium Prague (SCSP), 2016.
[2] Y. I. Kim, S. J. Park, N. J. Jung, M. S. Choi, B. S. Park, "Design and
implementation of NMS using SNMP for AMI network device
monitoring," IEEE International Conference on Power System
Technology, pp. 1-6, Oct. 2016.
[3] L. González-Sotres, C. Mateo, P. Frías, C. Rodríguez-Morcillo, J.
Matanza, "Replicability Analysis of PLC PRIME Networks for Smart
Metering Applications," IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, Issue: 99, pp.
1-9.
[4] A. Mishra, H. Tayal, M. A. Khan, M. RaZa, "Suitable PHY Layer of
Narrow-band Power Line Carrier Communication in Emerging
Advanced Metering Infrastructure Scenario,"IEEE Conference on
Standards for Communications and Networking (CSCN), pp. 235-239,
Oct. 2015.
[5] A. A. Sheikh, Q. Idrees, M. Ahmad, M. A. Arshad, I. Mahmood, U. U.
Fayyaz, I. E. Rana, and N. A. Zaffar, "Feasibility of NB-PLC in LT
Power Distribution Network of Electric Utility in Pakistan", Power
Systems Conference (PSC), South California, USA, pp.1-7, 2016.
[6] F. Malandra, B. Sans`o, "Analytical performance analysis of a large-
scale RF-mesh smart meter communication system," IEEE Innovative
Smart Grid Technologies Conference (ISGT), pp. 1-5, Feb. 2015.
[7] J. Mafra Jr.,M. Hosami, L. Freitas, M. Martinelli, A. Almeida, "Hybrid
Communication Module – Motivations, Requirements, Challenges and
Implementations," Innovative Smart Grid Technologies Latin America
(ISGT LATAM), Montevideo, Uruguay, pp. 25-29, Oct. 2015.
[8] Rapeepat Ratasuk, Benny Vejlgaard, Nitin Mangalvedhe and Amitava
Ghosh, "NB-IoT System for M2M Communication" Workshop on
Device to Device communications for 5G NETWORKS, 2016.
[9] Wenjie Yang, Mao Wang, Jingjing Zhang, Jun Zou, Min Hua, Tingting
Xia and Xiaohu You, " Narrowband Wireless Access for Low-Power
Massive Internet of Things: A Bandwidth Perspective" IEEE Wireless
Communications, pp. 138-145, Jun. 2017.
[10] J. H. Huh, K. Seo, “Smart Grid Framework Test Bed Using OPNET and
Power Line Communication” 8th International Conf. on Soft Computing
and Intelligent Systems and 17th International Symposium on Advanced
Intelligent Systems(SCIS&ISIS)., Sapporo, Japan, pp.736-742, 2016.
[11] S. Sree Lekshmi, P. Sivraj and K. K. Sasi, “Selection of routing
protocols for advanced metering infrastructure,”Int. Conf. on Advances
in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI)., Jaipur,
india, pp.1335-1339, 2016.
[12] U. Ozgur, S. Tonyali, and K. Akkaya, “Testbed and Simulation-based
Evaluation of Privacy-preserving Algorithms for Smart Grid AMI
Networks”IEEE 41st Conf. on Local Computer Networks
Workshops(IEEE LCN 2016)., Dubai, UAE, pp.181-186, 2016.