Moses Kotane Lecture by Ibbo Mandaza
Moses Kotane Lecture by Ibbo Mandaza
LECTURE
By
Ibbo Mandaza
Presented at
University of Johannesburg,
By Ibbo Mandaza
recall that his life coincided with the most tumultuous events and processes
that shook the world of the twentieth century and beyond. We refer here to
upon the emerging anti-colonial struggles across Africa, Asia and Latin America.
about the enormous gains made on the back of the revolutions of the
while reminding his fellow citizens in Nigeria on the need to revisit that which
economic enterprises’’:
1
For example, the Soviet Union moved from Third World status in 1918
to First World and Super Power status in 1958 on the basis of state
began with the devastations of the First World War and the massive
neglect of the economic and political yearnings of its people within and
Similarly, China which is this year celebrating the 70th anniversary of its
revolution, had in twenty years, 1949 – 1969,
2
It is presently seriously challenging for the number one economic
power position. The 2019 Forbes Fortune 500 Global List of the world’s
So, the Moses Kotane Memorial Lecture today provides us with another
independent Africa, on the nature and content of the State, and the class and
social dynamics therein; in doing so, highlight the fact that, so far, the post-
failure, particularly on the economic front, a living nightmare for the mass of
the African people; and propose herein that the imperative for an organised
turn-around must begin with the State reform and transformation project,
including a return to, and focus on, the public sector – and state economic
development in Africa.
3
ZIMBABWE: A STATE ON THE BRINK OF COLLAPSE?
Both the subject and context help to inform the debate on the State in Africa,
providing also as it does the opportunity for replacing ‘‘quiet diplomacy’’ with
resolute action on the part of such regional bodies as SADC or the African
on the brink of collapse, with all the consequent implications for its
But Blade Nzimande, the SACP General Secretary, is also a Cabinet minister in
the Government of South Africa. Accordingly, we hope that this marks a radical
shift in South Africa’s position on its northern neighbour, from that of ‘‘quiet
4
regime that has over the period since 2000 become a Securocrat state and
devastation of its economy and the consequent diaspora that includes almost
70% of all skilled and professional Zimbabweans; and adopt a deliberate and
structured initiative in which South Africa mobilises both the region and the
especially now that there is a growing consensus in that country, for a national
dialogue and transitional mechanisms through which to institute political and
economic reforms before the next election.
All this is true except that the situation is one difficult to imagine, unless one
descended into one which Tendai Biti, the current chair of the Parliamentary
during which the President would simply call and demand that the Finance
Minister, or the Central Bank Governor, disburses, out of the state coiffeurs
5
into his personal account abroad, any amount of money, in a number of cases
no less than $100 million. So, only two days ago on 8 October, 2019, the
‘‘The Party noted that there has been state capture as evidenced by cartels
comprising top state players and a politically connected elite. It is these
cartels that are stealing tax payers’ money through illegal deals and other
nefarious activities that have brought the economy to its knees.’’
Likewise, the Zimbabwean Heads of Christian Denominations stated the
corruption, shortages of fuel, prices going out of control and collapse of the
health sector needs to be built from the ground with everyone’s support. As
we are meeting, doctors are on strike and other workers such as teachers are
threatening the same as they find it difficult to make ends meet with their
education may have both immediate and long-term negative impact. When
this is combined with high levels of unemployment, stagnant salaries and loss
of buying power of salaries for those who are still employed, one can
conclude that Zimbabwe needs an urgent and holistic solution in which the
6
Last month, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) confirmed that the
annually at least more than $5 billion from exports, including gold and other
mineral resources alone, was imploding. But, coincidentally, the IMF witnessed
during its visit to Harare a sudden spike in the exchange rate from 10
which the cartel (comprising “top state players and a politically connected
elite”) had commandeered, USD$366 million out of state coiffeurs, and, in the
course of dealing on the parallel market, also landed itself in an even stronger
position as central in the fuel, mining (especially gold) and banking sectors.
CIVIC SOCIETY?
former liberation movement in Zimbabwe could have been the anchor – or the
driving force – around which to build a national economy, let alone a coherent
and sustained national project. Even the reputation of the struggle itself lies in
liberators have long served their purpose. The fears and suspicions that the
7
struggle was more about militarism than politics appears confirmed in reality.
Not surprisingly, under the vain ‘‘Restore Legacy’’ slogan that accompanied the
coup of November 2017, the military and its surrogate cabal of politicians have
inform us, a state which seeks to survive through sheer violence and brute
coercion, is one destined to crash, sooner rather than later. Therefore, the
garnered 66%’’).
completely, with all the consequent implications and ramifications for the mass
8
of its citizens in particular; or an urgent rescue plan is instituted, involving a
Three years ago in 2016, a group of us, the Platform for Concerned Citizens
an analysis which demonstrated that the State was both unwilling and unable
growing violence and predicted the coup which, as the period since it occurred
(NTA), a body to replace the Executive, work with Parliament and the Judiciary,
for a period of two years before elections in 2018, and during which political
of technocrats and/or prominent citizens. Neither the ruling party nor the
opposition welcomed the NTA idea: the main actors within the state were
already in coup mode by 2016; and the opposition MDC naively believed they
So it is that the events since November 2017 have brought Zimbabwe to this
urgency. Two weeks ago on 24th September, the Zimbabwe National Citizens’
9
Convention made ‘‘A Call to put Citizens, Country and Constitution First in
representatives from civic society, be part and parcel of both the National
Dialogue process and its outcome that should be Transitional Authority.Two
days ago on 8th October, the Zimbabwe Heads of Christian Denominations
(ZHOCD) implied the same, proposing that the Southern African country
suspends general elections for 7 years, ‘‘to give Zimbabweans time to heal
from past political wounds, recover economically and adapt to a fresh culture
for Zimbabwe, and thereby seek regional and international support for this
National initiative. Hopefully, South Africa will take the lead by engaging, in the
first instance, both Emmerson Mnangagwa and Nelson Chamisa, but not to the
exclusion of Zimbabwe Civic Society – including the diaspora – which has taken
● The Transitional Authority will be responsible not only for driving the
constitutional and political reforms before the next election, but also
economic recovery.
10
Clean up of the judiciary
● A concerted attack on corruption,beginning with a lifestyle audit
of leaders in both public and private sectors
11
from the export of mineral resources, mainly gold, diamonds and
chrome.
This indeed is a tall order, but with the requisite political will, it can be
accomplished.
intellectuals and activists alike, about the political and economic realities,
immediately succeeding the end of the struggle for national liberation, have
even in South Africa wherein the term was coined in 1988 through the work of
Joe Slovo and his comrades in the South African Communist Party (SACP).
12
Worse still, the former national liberation movements of Southern Africa have
failed miserably to act as the anchor factor – or the driving force – around
long served their purpose and, in many cases, now run the risk of inviting
ridicule and cynical commentary, not only on the part of the part of our
has been found wanting in terms of both capacity and political resolve, there is
international capital and (white) bourgeois interests have for decades reigned
fledgling black middle class. In the Southern African context, this has
which vested interests of old have not only remained largely intact, but even
the case of the former with respect to the Land Question, or Black Economic
13
Empowerment (BEE) as with respect to the latter, have yielded only scant
success; and, in the final analysis, just adding numbers to that group called the
A lot has been said recently about the ‘‘Land Reform’’ issue in Zimbabwe,
including a claim that Mugabe delayed the process until 2000, in deference to
particularly the need not to scare the whites who would have become more
intransigent in the face of the kind of aggression and ruthlessness with which
many of their counterparts across the Limpopo lost their farms under the fast
track land seizures. As one who was close to the process in Zimbabwe, I can
with confidence state that this version of events is far from the truth. Suffice it
to state for the time being that, not only was the imperative of resolving the
which lacked the capacity and political resolve to do so; but, more important, it
was a process which was prompted belatedly in 2000, less on the basis of the
an election outcome in which Mugabe and his party would have lost to the
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) in the June elections of 2000. In fact,
14
largely disorganised fast track land reform programme. So, while the latter was
is being resolved in Zimbabwe, it is also a fact that it has yielded new questions
about property rights, not least the spectre of a black minority having replaced
a white minority, to the extent that the ruling elite - composed of politicians
from the ruling party and the state, the top brass in the military,
police, security and public service – inherited, gratis, the best of those 4000 or
challenge in Southern Africa in general. In this regard, South Africa itself should
not think that it is immune to the problems that have caused ‘’forced
migration’’ from both the sub-region and beyond. For as long as the structure
of the economy remains as it has been, it is inevitable that the growing army of
restless and foot loose as their counterparts across the border. The question is
Southern Africa, beyond into the continent, or across the seas, as is happening
in the case of the many African citizens seeking succour in Europe, while
15
hundreds perish in the Mediterranean or even in the Sahara Desert, long
before they reach their unknown destinations. The more reason why there
in the period since the end of apartheid : for example, the expansion (and
externalisation?) of South African (white) capital into the rest of the sub-
Africa itself. Therefore, for example, would it not help if, instead of exporting
Historically, the national bourgeoisie has been touted as the anchor class
(through the requisite interaction – such as trade and laws of rapidity – with
16
other national bourgeoisies in the international bourgeoisies in the
Africa itself, Samir Amin and other economists have explained why, in this era
feasible. Whatever, the case the reality is that Africa has succeeded only in
capital, as the class which now straddles both the public and the so called
private sectors, and has increasingly captured the State in our countries, in
For the record, Mao Tse Tung, in his ‘‘Analysis of the Classes in Chinese
‘‘A comprador, in the original sense of the word, was the Chinese manager,
served foreign economic interests and had close connection with imperialism
17
outlined in some detail the historical origins of the comprador bourgeoisie in
Southern Africa in particular and Africa generally, including the role such
with the extractive industries , and will have ‘‘compradorized’’ even some of
extractive industries…. that the comprador bourgeoisie has grown during this
comprador bourgeoisie cannot and will never serve as the engine of the
itself and for itself; it is bereft of a national vision nor national interest, mainly
that lives for today, uncertain about tomorrow and hence the looting of the
coiffeurs becomes a frenzy. These are nothing less than thieves, says my late
18
THE FUTURE OF AFRICA: THE REFORM AND TRANSFORMATION OF THE STATE
ON A CONTINENTAL FRAMEWORK
So, fifty years since Amilcar Cabral raise the question in 1969 (in Revolution in
Guinea), we are back to it today: since post-independent Africa does not have
an anchor class such as the national bourgeoisie in the capitalist state, who
should play that central role as the driving force for economic independence
and development?
The history of post-independent Africa has been largely an account of the state
itself. It continues to be the theatre and centre of power and its attendant class
fruits of independence. It is almost the very heart of society, the latter can
hardly survive without it. Regrettably, there has been the tendency to
distinguish between the political from the economic, forgetting that the two
are dialectically related and hence political economy. For example, there has
the State – whether it is democratic enough and its conduct with respect to the
rule of law and human rights – than the economic issues which have been
has grown the notion that the state exists only to facilitate economic activity
but not be involved in it. All this against the stark reality that democracy,
19
human rights and the rule of law are most threatened when the economy is in
which the false dichotomy between the public and private did not exist. As
Nnoli has asserted, the ‘Founding Fathers’ of our struggle for independence in
highlight this point is not to ignore the private sector nor to have elements
through Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). As Nnoli points out with respect to
Nigeria:
The truth is that in the world economy, around 80% of the required FDI went
to six countries of the USA, China, Japan, Germany and France. The remaining
20% was dominated by India, Brazil, the Netherlands, Ireland and Singapore.
How much does anyone seriously think that Nigeria can get from this cut
throat competition for investment? For this reason history will judge
Obasanjo and Atiku very harshly for their ignominious role in dismantling the
nation’s fledging public sector instead of fighting the corruption within it.’’
20
As weak and vulnerable as the private sector is in most of Sub-Saharan Africa,
21
THE WAY FORWARD
Accordingly, the Reform Agenda of the State in Africa must be both political
and economic.
22
these and the African Union itself. The provisions designed to
markets.
23
development, human development and social security, and
- The African Economic Community : the provisions for the AEC are
clearly spelt out in the Abuja Treaty; what’s required now is the
CONCLUSION
Kwame Nkruma’s clarion call – ‘Seek ye first the political kingdom and all else
will be added unto it’ – still rings hollow for the majority of Africa’s citizens. As
24