Research Status of Self-Healing Concrete: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science
Research Status of Self-Healing Concrete: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science
Abstract. Through collecting, sorting and analyzing the domestic and foreign references of
self-healing concrete research, this paper has summarized the experimental research methods
and results of different types of self-healing concrete in recent years, and expounded the
mechanism of its action. Self-healing concrete types include self-healing concrete based on
concrete itself, self-healing concrete based on permeable crystal repair technology, self-healing
concrete based on shape memory alloy, self-healing concrete based on bionic self-repair and
self-healing concrete based on microbial. Finally, the existing problems of self-healing
concrete are put forward, and the shortcomings of self-healing concrete need to be further
strengthened.
1. Introduction
Concrete structure is the most important civil engineering structure. Since it appeared, engineering and
technical personnel have continued to conduct research, and concrete materials have been developed
in the direction of high strength, high performance and versatility, and the structure has become more
complicated and larger. But concrete, as a brittle material, has a very low tensile strength. During
construction or during use, cracks may occur in the structure due to the nature of the material itself, the
construction method, environmental conditions and load effects, and even cracks that are clearly
visible to the naked eye may occur.
There are many ways to deal with concrete structures that have cracks. Epoxy resin reinforcing
grouting is a method that is widely used at present. It has strong bonding force, small shrinkage after
curing, high mechanical strength, heat resistance and stability. However, these repair methods are
mostly used in the case of wide cracks, and the autonomy is poor. It is difficult to repair very small
cracks or micro cracks inside the structure. In this context, along with the development of modern
science and technology, people began to have great interest in the new technology of concrete
self-healing to repair cracks. The research on self-healing concrete has become one of the research
hotspots for processing and controlling cracks. After the concrete has cracked, it can self-repair
without the influence of external human disturbance. And then the process of healing the crack is
called self-healing of concrete.
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd 1
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037
out that this naturally occurring crystallization aggregation self-repairing concrete generally has a low
strength recovery rate, and the concrete under different conditions is highly different.
Gao et al. conducted a self-healing performance test on the crack of the reinforced concrete pool
wall[1]. The results show that the crack width of the concrete slab in the environment in contact with
the water gradually decreases. The self-healing properties of cracks are related to the composition of
the concrete, the age of the damage, the degree of damage, the environmental conditions such as the
temperature and humidity during self-healing, and the healing time. Finally, it was found that the
cracks of the concrete tested can heal 0.1mm in a short-term in a still water environment. It is
suggested that the crack width limit of basically intact tank and the degree of minor damage can be
increased by 0.1mm.
Fang et al. studied the mesostructure of cement-based materials in crack-hardened cement pastes,
mortars and concrete specimens[2]. The results show that the infiltration process of cement-based
materials leads to the dissolution of calcium ions in the hardened cement paste. When the penetration
rate is small, the crack surface of cement-based material is rough and easy to adhere to CaCO3 crystal,
the calcium ion may combine with CO32- dissolved in water to form CaCO3 crystal. It is one of the
reasons for the self-healing of concrete cracks.
Yao et al. studied the natural healing phenomenon of damaged concrete of different ages after the
same curing period[3]. The damage degree of concrete bauxite after compression and cracking was
characterized by the change of ultrasonic velocity, and the relationship between concrete damage and
healing condition was established. The results show that there is a damage threshold for concrete
materials. When the damage of concrete is lower than the damage threshold, the self-healing rate
increases with the increase of the damage amount. when the concrete damage exceeds the damage
threshold, the self-healing rate decreases with the increase of the damage amount.
Schlangen et al. used the self-repairing principle of the concrete structure to make self-healing
contrast tests of different widths. The result is that the narrower cracks are more easily healed by the
inherent self-repair of concrete[4].
However, it should be pointed out that this natural crystallization accumulation has a certain effect
on the crack repair of concrete, but the self-repaired concrete has a low strength recovery rate, and the
number of unhydrated particles in the concrete is limited. At the same time, the self-healing effects of
different concretes based on their own materials vary greatly. In a drier environment, the self-healing
effect may be very small, so in actual engineering, it is unrealistic to play a large role in controlling
cracks according to such self-healing phenomenon.
2
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037
Shi et al. rely on the deep foundation pit project of a square project in Hangzhou to compare and
analyze the technical and economic benefits of infiltration crystallization self-healing concrete and
traditional deep foundation pit materials[6]. An alternative to self-healing waterproof concrete has
been obtained, which can save nearly 700,000 yuan. In particular, it has the effect of reducing cracks
in the plastic state and the curing stage, and the function of automatically repairing cracks (width ≤ 0.6
mm) in the presence of water will save the owner about 10% of the maintenance cost in the latter
stage.
Liu et al. studied the effect of Canadian XYPEX penetrating crystalline materials on the
self-healing properties of concrete[7]. By analyzing the characteristics of self-healing products under
different cracking time, curing mode and crack width, it is concluded that curing mode has influence
on self-healing products. The microstructure is loose under dry conditions, and the number of crystals
and gels formed is small. More crystals are formed in a humid environment, and the structure is more
dense. The larger the crack width, the larger the size of the self-healing product produced, and the
larger the number, but at a larger crack width, even a lot of self-healing products are not enough to
offset the large effect of the crack width itself. From micro-viewing, the self-healing products are
criss-crossed and distributed in a spatial network, blocking cracks and pores. Not only played a role in
repair, but also effectively played a waterproof role.
Liu et al. examined the self-healing ability of XYPEX blending agent in concrete through six
groups of concrete impermeability experiments of different ages[8]. It was found that the XYPEX
blending agent can form crystals by utilizing the migration of moisture in the cement hydration,
blocking the permeation passages generated by the damage in the concrete, thereby improving the
self-healing ability of the concrete. After the XYPEX blending agent is added, the self-healing ability
at early age is stronger than that in the later stage. Mainly because the hydration of XYPEX admixture
in concrete is directly related to the migration of water, the activity of XYPEX admixture can only be
activated during the process of water migration, and there is more free water in the early age concrete
which is not involved in cement hydration.
Of course, in addition to the use of permeable crystalline materials, the pore structure of the
concrete members and the overall porosity, crack size, and many other factors that may not be
considered affect the self-repairing effect. The self-healing properties of concrete based on infiltration
crystallization repair technology are not effective when the crack width is greater than 0.6 mm.
According to the research results of the predecessors, it is not difficult to find that the self-healing
performance based on the infiltration crystallization repair technology is still open to question for the
cracking of concrete in dry area.
3
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037
allowable range, the microprocessor will issue a command based on the signal picked up by the fiber
to electrically heat the SMA wire at the crack, causing it to shrink and deform, causing the crack to
close or restrict further crack propagation.
For the specimens in which the shape memory alloy is embedded in the concrete structure, the
presence of the longitudinal ribs has a certain influence on the mechanical properties and self-repairing
properties of the SMA concrete structure. Yan et al. conducted a comparative analysis of SMA
concrete specimens and SMA concrete specimens with tensile reinforcement[11]. They found that the
reinforcement in the tension zone can improve the bearing capacity of the beam; the SMA rib is
energized by the test piece after unloading, and the recovery force of the shape memory alloy causes
the deflection of the beam to recover and the crack width to decrease. However, the magnitude of the
recovery is smaller than that of the SMA concrete specimen of the same configuration. This result is
consistent with the intuitive imagination, and it is obvious that the deformation of the tensile
reinforcement inhibits the shrinkage of the memory alloy.
Previous investigations have explored the use of shape memory alloy (SMA) bars to replace
traditional pre-stressing tendons [12-15]. Whilst these materials have been shown to be effective at
providing pre-stress in concrete elements, their relatively high cost makes their use unviable for all but
the most specialized of applications. Jefferson presents an original crack-closure system [16]. The
system involves the incorporation of unbonded pre-oriented polymer tendons in cementitious beams.
At low stress level, it is feasible to use oriented shrinkable polymer tendons to achieve fracture
closure.
At present, there are many researches on shape memory alloys. Although there are good results,
there are still some deficiencies in the research work on SMA concrete. At present, the study generally
uses alloy wire with a small cross-sectional area, and there are few applications in large-scale concrete
structures. There is little research on the bonding properties of SMA and concrete, and this work
should be strengthened. This is the key to working together with SMA. In order to make SMA
concrete structures widely used in engineering, it is necessary to establish corresponding theoretical
formulas and corresponding rules to guide the design of structures to ensure the rationality of its
structural structure.
4
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037
Zhao et al. embedded a liquid core glass fiber containing a acetal polymer solution in a
cement-based composite material reinforced with steel wire short fibers[19]. Next, the layers were
poured, solidified and watered for 4 days, and then subjected to a bending test. When the structure is
cracked and the external force is removed, it is found that some of the liquid core fibers are broken,
and the repairing agent inside penetrates into the crack, and the crack is filled and solidified soon. In
addition, Zhao also pointed out that when injecting the repair agent into the glass fiber, there should be
a certain pressure, which is conducive to the spread of the repair agent.
In addition, there is a tube-based self-repair in which the repair agent is placed in isolation into a
hollow tube that connects the inside and the outside of the concrete structure, and the tube like a
biological tissue generally passes through the concrete. Lark et al. used a cyanoacrylate adhesive that
reacted with air and put it into a glass tube[20]. After the concrete cracked, the pipe also ruptured, and
the repair agent in the pipe flowed out, repairing the crack. When the crack is wide, the repair agent in
the tube is exhausted, and the crack can be healed by transporting an additional repair agent to the
damaged portion through the tube inside and outside the connecting structure.
The most critical of this self-healing concrete based on bionic self-healing is how to control the
time to release the repair agent and how to determine the reasonable distribution of the fiber tube or
capsule in the concrete. First, the fiber tube or capsule must be matched with the elastic modulus and
stiffness of the concrete to ensure simultaneous cracking with the concrete. At the same time, whether
it is factory prefabricated or cast-in-place concrete, it is necessary to ensure that the container remains
intact during production. In addition, the repair agent container arranged in the system should not be
too much or too little, and must satisfy certain repair effects without affecting the strength and
macroscopic performance of the concrete. In short, to be widely used in practice, the research is still
insufficient.
5
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037
At present, the self-healing concrete based on bacteria is still in the experimental research stage.
Before the actual application, several problems need to be solved, such as the cost of the new types of
self-healing concrete based on bacteria and the bacteria still have activity and repair function within
several decades after pouring. In additional, since the type of microbial mineralization reaction
products is largely dominated by the environment, the key points of this technology are the selection
of microorganisms, the protection of microorganisms, the concentration of calcium ions, the
concentration of inorganic carbon, and the Mineralized environment pH value, etc.
4. Conclusion
The crack treatment of concrete structures is a research hotspot and has caused long-term problems for
the development of the engineering community. At present, the research on self-healing concrete
technology at home and abroad has been carried out in a variety of ways, and good progress has been
made in different research directions, but most of the research is in a state of theoretical feasibility and
laboratory feasibility. There are few proposals for projects that can make use of a large amount of
self-healing concrete. Many key issues need to be addressed, such as the compatibility of new
materials with concrete matrices, the optimal choice of materials to be incorporated, and the optimal
choice of blending amounts, long-term work stability of repair materials, reliability of multiple repairs,
and inspection standards for repair effects. At the same time, due to the non-uniformity and
randomness of cracks in the concrete matrix, it is difficult to determine the actual repair effect in the
experiment.
Although many key technologies are still in the state of research, in the general trend of green
buildings and green materials, self-healing concrete technology has great potential, which can save the
high cost of artificial repair, improve the service life of concrete materials and further ensure the safety
and durability of the building. The technology from the self-healing concrete will be an important part
of intelligent buildings and green buildings in the future.
Acknowledgments
This study is sponsored by the Science & Technology Research Development Project of China
Railway (Grant No.2012G013-G, Grant No.2007G030).
6
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037
References
[1] Lin Gao, Endong Guo, yin Zhao, et al. (2016) Experimental study on development, self-healing
and leakage of curved cracks in reinforced concrete pool siding. Journal of Civil Engineering,
2016(03):98-104.
[2] Yonghao Fang, Pubin An, Wei Zhao, et al. (2008) Permeation and erosion of crack-containing
cement-based materials and their self-healing. Journal of silicate, 2008(04):451-456.
[3] Wu Yao, Wenhui Zhong. (2006) Mechanism of self-healing of concrete damage. Journal of
Materials Research. 2006(01):24-28.
[4] Schlangen E, Heide N T, Breugel K V. (2006) Crack healing of early age cracks in concrete.
Measuring, monitoring and modeling concrete properties. Springer Netherlands,
2006:273-284.
[5] Tittelboom, K. V., Belie, N. D., Muynck, W. D., & Verstraete, W. (2010). Use of bacteria to repair
cracks in concrete. Cement & Concrete Research, 40(1), 157-166.
[6] Yuewei Shi, Tongliang Ge, Chunxiao Sun, et al. (2017) Technical and economic analysis and
application prospect of crack self-healing concrete. Construction Technology,
2017(S1):296-298.
[7] Tengfei Liu. (2011) Analysis of function and component action of cement-based permeable
crystalline waterproof material. Tsinghua University.
[8] Penghui Li, Nan Dong, Fengqi Chen. (2009) Experimental study on self-healing properties of
XYPEX blending agent: Seminar on anti-seepage and anti-freeze technology of irrigation
districts and hydraulic structures nationwide. Dalian, Liaoning, China.
[9] Choi E, Cho S C, Hu J W, et al. (2010) Recovery and residual stress of SMA wires and
applications for concrete structures. Smart Materials & Structures, 19(9):094013.
[10] Baoqi Tao, Dakai Liang, Ke Xiong, et al. (1998) Research on self-diagnosis and self-repair
function of shape memory alloy reinforced intelligent composite structure. Journal of
Aviation, 1998(02):123-125.
[11] Shi Yan, Jing Sun, Wei Wang. (2010) Self-repairing characteristics test of shape memory alloy
concrete continuous beam. Journal of Shenyang Jianzhu University (Natural Science
Edition), 2010(06):1080-1084.
[12] Ortegarosales, J., & Eltawil, S. (2004). Prestressing concrete using shape memory alloy
tendons. Aci Structural Journal, 101(6), 846-851.
[13] Saiidi, M. S., Sadrossadatzadeh, M., Ayoub, C., & Itani, A. (2007). Pilot study of behavior of
concrete beams reinforced with shape memory alloys. Journal of Materials in Civil
Engineering, 19(6), 454-461.
[14] B. Aïssa, D. Therriault, E. Haddad & Jamroz, W. (2012). Self-healing materials systems:
overview of major approaches and recent developed technologies. Advances in Materials
Science & Engineering, 2012(1687-8434).
[15] Yin, K., & Yu, Z. (2014). Research on properties of a shape memory alloy (sma) concrete
"two-way beam" applied in underground engineering. Modern Tunnelling Technology, 51(2),
36-42.
[16] Jefferson, A., Lark, R., Isaacs, B., Dunn, S., & Weager, B. (2010). A new system for crack
closure of cementitious materials using shrinkable polymers. Cement & Concrete
Research, 40(5), 795-801.
[17] Araújo, M., Chatrabhuti, S., Gurdebeke, S., Alderete, N., Tittelboom, K. V., & Raquez, J. M., et
al. (2018). Poly(methyl methacrylate) capsules as an alternative to the ‘’proof-of-concept’’
glass capsules used in self-healing concrete. Cement & Concrete Composites.
[18] Perez, G., Gaitero, J. J., Erkizia, E., Jimenez, I., & Guerrero, A. (2015). Characterisation of
cement pastes with innovative self-healing system based in epoxy-amine adhesive. Cement
& Concrete Composites, 60, 55-64.
[19] Xiaopeng Zhao, Benlian Zhou, Chunrong Luo, et al. (1996) Smart material model with
self-healing behavior. Journal of Materials Research. 1996(01):101-104.
7
2018 International Conference on Civil, Architecture and Disaster Prevention IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 218 (2019) 012037 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/218/1/012037