Role of Firewall, IPS

&
IDS Model
NAVNEET
Scientist `B`
CERT-In, DIT

1
Firewall

• A firewall is a hardware or software system that

prevents unauthorized access to or from a network.
• Implemented in both hardware and software, or a
combination of both.
• Sits between two networks
– Used to protect one network from the other
– Places a bottleneck between the networks
• All communications must pass through the
bottleneck – this gives us a single point of
control
2
Firewall Functions

• Filtering
• Inspection
• Detection
• Logging
• Alerting
• Allow Address Reuse

3
Securing DMZ

• Single/ Dual
Firewalls is
used in
creating DMZ

4
Types of Firewall

• NETWORK LAYER FIREWALLS

• APPLICATION LAYER FIREWALLS

(Proxy firewall)

• UNIFIED THREAT MANAGEMENT

• WEB APPLICATION FIREWALL

5
Network layer firewall
• Not allowing packets to pass through the
firewall unless they match the established filter
rule set.
• Firewall administrator may define the rules
• Filtering rules is based on source and
destination address and ports.
• Operates very fast.
• Network layer firewalls generally fall into two
sub-categories, stateful and non-stateful.
6
Stateful Firewall

• State of Connection: Open or Closed

– State: Order of packet within a dialog

– Often simply whether the packet is part of an open

connection

7
• Stateful Firewall Operation
– For TCP, record two IP addresses and port
numbers in state table as OK (open)
– By default, permit connections from internal
clients (on trusted network) to external servers (on
untrusted network)
• This default behavior can be changed with an ACL

– Accept future packets between these hosts and

ports with little or no inspection
8
 2.
Establish
1. Connection 3.
TCP SYN Segment TCP SYN Segment
From: 60.55.33.12:62600 From: 60.55.33.12:62600
To: 123.80.5.34:80 To: 123.80.5.34:80

Note: Outgoing
Stateful
Internal Connections
Firewall External
Client PC Allowed By
60.55.33.12 Default Webserver
123.80.5.34
Connection Table
Internal Internal External External
Type Status
IP Port IP Port

TCP 60.55.33.12 62600 123.80.5.34 80 OK

9
 6. Stateful 4.
Internal
TCP SYN/ACK Segment Firewall TCP SYN/ACK Segment External
Client PC
From: 123.80.5.34:80 From: 123.80.5.34:80 Webserver
60.55.33.12
To: 60.55.33.12:62600 To: 60.55.33.12:62600 123.80.5.34
5.
Check Connection
OK
Connection Table

Internal Internal External External

Type Status
IP Port IP Port

TCP 60.55.33.12 62600 123.80.5.34 80 OK

10
• Stateful Firewall Operation
– For UDP, also record two IP addresses in port
numbers in the state table
Connection Table
Internal Internal External External
Type Status
IP Port IP Port

TCP 60.55.33.12 62600 123.80.5.34 80 OK

UDP 60.55.33.12 63206 1.8.33.4 69 OK

11
Port-Switching Applications with Stateful
Firewalls

2.
To Establish
1. Connection 3.
TCP SYN Segment TCP SYN Segment
From: 60.55.33.12:62600 From: 60.55.33.12:62600
To: 123.80.5.34:21 To: 123.80.5.34:21

Internal Stateful
Client PC Firewall External
60.55.33.12 FTP Server
123.80.5.34
State Table

Internal Internal External External

Type Status
IP Port IP Port
Step 2 TCP 60.55.33.12 62600 123.80.5.34 21 OK 12
Port-Switching Applications with Stateful Firewalls

6. Stateful 4.
Internal
TCP SYN/ACK Segment Firewall TCP SYN/ACK SegmentExternal
Client PC
From: 123.80.5.34:21 From: 123.80.5.34:21 FTP
60.55.33.12
To: 60.55.33.12:62600 5. To: 60.55.33.12:62600 Server
Use Ports 20 To Allow, Use Ports 20 123.80.5.34
and 55336 for Establish and 55336 for
Data Transfers Second Data Transfers
Connection

State Table Internal Internal External External

Type Status
IP Port IP Port
Step 2 TCP 60.55.33.12 62600 123.80.5.34 21 OK

Step 5 TCP 60.55.33.12 55336 123.80.5.34 20 OK 13

Stateful Inspection Firewalls

• Stateful Inspection Access Control Lists (ACLs)

– Primary allow or deny applications
– Simple because probing attacks that are not part
of conversations do not need specific rules
because they are dropped automatically

– In integrated firewalls, ACL rules can specify that

messages using a particular application protocol
or server be authenticated or passed to an
application firewall for inspection

14
Network-based application firewall Proxy Firewall

S: Host A: port:1024
D: Proxy:port:8080

S: Proxy: port:3000
D: Server:port:80
Host A

Proxy
Fire
WALL Server x
Host B

S: Proxy: port:3001
D: Server:port:80

S: Host B: port:1027
D: Proxy:port:8080

15
Web Application Firewall

• A web application firewall (WAF) is an appliance, server

plugin, or filter that applies a set of rules to an HTTP
conversation.
• These rules cover common attacks such as Cross-site
Scripting(XSS) and SQL Injection.
• Customizing the rules according to your application.
• Many attacks can be identified and blocked. The effort to
perform this customization can be significant and needs to
be maintained as the application is modified.

16
Web Application Risks
• Potential damage:
– Defacement
– Client attacks
– DoS/DDoS
– Data manipulation / retrieval / deletion
Attack techniques:
– SQL / Command injection
– Cross-site scripting (XSS)
– Cookie poisoning
– Session hijacking
– More….

17
Unified Threat Management (UTM)

• Unified Threat Management is a firewall

appliance that not only guards against intrusion
but performs content filtering, spam filtering,
intrusion detection and anti-virus duties
traditionally handled by multiple systems.

18
Free Firewall software packages

• IP Tables
– comes with most linux distributions
• SELinux (Security Enabled Linux – NSA)
– comes with some Linux distributions
• Fedora, Red Hat
• IPCop – specialized Linux distribution

19
Intrusion Detection/Prevention
System

• Intrusion
– A set of actions aimed to compromise the security goals,
namely
• Integrity, confidentiality, or availability of a computing
and networking resource
• Intrusion detection
– The process of identifying and responding to intrusion
activities
• Intrusion prevention
– Extension of ID with exercises of access control to protect
computers from exploitation

20
Components of Intrusion Detection System

Audit Records
system activities are
observable
Audit Data
Preprocessor

Activity Data

Detection normal and intrusive activities

Detection Engine have distinct evidence
Models
Alarms
Action/Report
Decision Decision Engine
Table
Types of Intrusion Detection

Based on the sources of the audit information

used by each IDS, the IDSs may be classified
into
– Host-base IDSs
– Distributed IDSs
– Network-based IDSs
• Host-based IDSs
– Get audit data from host audit trails.
– Detect attacks against a single host
• Distributed IDSs
– Gather audit data from multiple host and possibly
the network that connects the hosts
– Detect attacks involving multiple hosts
• Network-Based IDSs
– Use network traffic as the audit data source,
relieving the burden on the hosts that usually
provide normal computing services
– Detect attacks from network.
Host-based Intrusion Detection

Anomaly detection: App

allowed
traces
• IDS monitors system call
trace from the app
• DB contains a list of
subtraces that are IDS
allowed to appear
• Any observed subtrace
not in DB sets off alarms
Operating System

24
 Network IDSs

• Deploying sensors at strategic locations

– E.G., Packet sniffing via tcpdump at routers
• Inspecting network traffic
– Watch for violations of protocols and unusual connection patterns
• Monitoring user activities
– Look into the data portions of the packets for malicious command sequences
• May be easily defeated by encryption
– Data portions and some header information can be encrypted
– The decryption engine still there.
• Other problems …
Architecture of Network IDS

Policy script Alerts/notifications

Policy Script Interpreter

Event control Event stream

Event Engine
tcpdump filters Filtered packet stream

libpcap

Packet stream

Network
Firewall Versus Network IDS

• Firewall
– Active filtering
– Fail-close
• Network IDS
– Passive monitoring
– Fail-open

IDS

FW
Requirements of Network IDS

• High-speed, large volume monitoring

– No packet filter drops
• Real-time notification
• Mechanism separate from policy
• Extensible
• Broad detection coverage
• Economy in resource usage
Intrusion Detection Techniques

• Misuse detection
– Catch the intrusions in terms of the characteristics
of known attacks or system vulnerabilities.
• Anomaly detection
– Detect any action that significantly deviates from
the normal behavior.
Misuse Detection

• Based on known attack actions.

• Feature extract from known intrusions
• Integrate the Human knowledge.
• The rules are pre-defined
• Disadvantage:
– Cannot detect novel or unknown attacks
Anomaly Detection

• Based on the normal behavior of a subject.

Sometime assume the training audit data does
not include intrusion data.
• Any action that significantly deviates from the
normal behavior is considered intrusion.
Anomaly Detection Methods

Method
Statistical method
Machine Learning techniques

Time-Based inductive Machine

Instance Based Learning

Neural Network

…
Data mining approaches
Anomaly Detection Disadvantages

• Based on audit data collected over a period of

normal operation.
– When a noise(intrusion) data in the training data, it
will make a mis-classification.
• How to decide the features to be used. The
features are usually decided by domain
experts.
Misuse Detection vs. Anomaly Detection

Advantage Disadvantage

Misuse Accurately and Cannot detect

Detection generate much novel or unknown
fewer false alarm attacks

Anomaly Is able to detect High false-alarm

Detection unknown attacks and limited by
based on audit training data.
Difference between IDS & FIREWALL

• IDS are a dedicated assistant used to monitor the

rest of the security infrastructure
• Today’s security infrastructure are becoming
extremely complex, it includes firewalls,
identification and authentication systems, access
control product, virtual private networks,
encryption products, virus scanners, and more.
All of these tools performs functions essential to
system security. Given their role they are also
prime target and being managed by humans, as
such they are prone to errors.
• Failure of one of the above component of your
security infrastructure jeopardized the system
they are supposed to protect
• Not all traffic may go through a firewall
i:e modem on a user computer
• Not all threats originates from outside. As
networks uses more and more encryption,
attackers will aim at the location where it is
often stored unencrypted (Internal network)
• Firewall does not protect appropriately against
application level weakenesses and attacks
• Firewalls are subject to attacks themselves
• Protect against misconfiguration or fault in other
security mechanisms
 iptables

• iptables is a user space application program that

allows a system administrator to configure the tables
provided by the Linux kernel firewall.

• Iptables requires elevated privileges to operate and

must be executed by user root.

• On most Linux systems, iptables is installed as

/usr/sbin/iptables.

37
38
39
40
Iptables commands

• iptables –t filter –A INPUT –s 192.168.0.1 –j DROP

Where rule checked the match part of the rule The target
part of the
rule

• iptables –t filter –A INPUT –s !192.168.0.1 –j DROP

41
• Example: Default Policy Deny everything that is
not explicitly permitted
#iptables -P INPUT DROP
#iptables -P FORWARD DROP
#iptables -P OUTPUT DROP
• Permit everything that is not explicitly denied.
#iptables –P INPUT ACCEPT
#iptables –P FORWARD ACCEPT
#iptables –P OUTPUT ACCEPT

42
• Allow ssh login to firewall host from outside

#iptables –A INPUT –i eth0 –p tcp -–dport ssh –j ACCEPT

#iptables –A OUTPUT –o eth0 –p tcp -–sport ssh –j ACCEPT

• Allow pings from all interfaces

#iptables –A INPUT –p icmp –-icmp-type echo-request –j ACCEPT
#iptables –A OUTPUT –p icmp –-icmp-type echo-reply –j ACCEPT

43
Stateful Inspection with Linux Netfilter

• Allow replies on outbound TCP packets

#iptables -A OUTPUT –o eth0 -p tcp -m state --state NEW,
ESTABLISHED, RELATED - j ACCEPT

#iptables -A INPUT -i eth0 -p tcp -m state --state ESTABLISHED,

RELATED -j ACCEPT
• Allow replies on outbound UDP packets

#iptables -A OUTPUT –o eth0 -p udp -m state --state NEW,

ESTABLISHED, RELATED –j ACCEPT
#iptables -A INPUT -i eth0 -p udp -m state –state
ESTABLISHED, RELATED -j ACCEPT

44
DNAT/SNAT Example

• INBOUND
iptables –t nat –A PREROUTING –p tcp –dport 80 –j DNAT --to-dest
192.168.0.20
• OUTBOUND
iptables –t nat –A OUTPUT –p tcp –dport 80 –j DNAT – -to-dest
192.168.0.200:3128

MASQUERADE
iptables –t nat –A POSTRUTING –o eth0 –j MASQUERADE
SNAT:
iptables –t nat -A POSTROUTING –j SNAT –to-source 1.2.3.45

45
References

• http://searchnetworking.techtarget.com/tutorial
/Introduction-to-firewalls-Types-of-firewalls
• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Application_firew
all
• http://security.hsr.ch/lectures/IntSec1-
Firewalls.pdf
• http://www.csh.rit.edu/~mattw/proj/nf/

46
Question &Answer

47