5S Made Easy - A Step-By-Step Guide To Implementing and Sustaining Your 5S Program PDF
5S Made Easy - A Step-By-Step Guide To Implementing and Sustaining Your 5S Program PDF
5S Made Easy
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Implementing and Sustaining
Your 5S Program
“ 5S Made Easy is a simple, easy-to-follow guide for 5S in manufacturing. It nicely explains how 5S
has a greater purpose than simple housekeeping. It is about standardizing and improving—often
overlooked points in a 5S deployment.”
—Drew Locher, Change Management Associates, Shingo Prize-Winning Author of
Lean Office and Service Simplified and Value Stream Mapping for Lean Development
“Hurray to Dave Visco for 5S Made Easy .... The stability created through an effective 5S process is
critical to every other best practice, from set-reduction and TPM to kanban and standardized work.
Dave’s book offers a step-by-step primer for any change leader who wants to get this foundational
improvement method right the first time.”
—Bruce Hamilton, President, GBMP
“Anyone can begin a 5S program in their department or business by following this book’s
easy-to-understand steps. In addition, Visco has provided checklists, forms, and resource guides.
Almost everything you need is right here.”
—From the Foreword by Mike McCarthy, Lean Consultant and Author of Sustain
Your Gains: The People Side of Lean-Six Sigma
For decades, 5S practitioners have struggled with exactly how to implement and sustain a 5S
program in their workplaces. While there are many books available on the organization meth-
ods suggested by 5S, few provide easy-to-understand, step-by-step guidance on how to set
up and sustain successful 5S implementations. 5S Made Easy fills this need.
Written by an expert whose focus for the last decade has been nothing but 5S, the book
supplies in-depth guidance on how to implement and sustain each of the 5S pillars—sort, set
in order, shine, standardize, and sustain.
The book uses an easy-to-follow format that was designed for use during 5S events. It
provides color images of real-world 5S solutions, including before and after pictures from the
field. It also supplies readers with online access to all of the forms and documents needed for
an effective 5S program. All the forms and documents are provided in an easily editable format
to fit any operation.
K25513
ISBN: 978-1-4987-1982-7
90000
9 781498 719827
5S Made Easy
A Step-by-Step Guide to Implementing
and Sustaining Your 5S Program
5S Made Easy
A Step-by-Step Guide to Implementing
and Sustaining Your 5S Program
David Visco
This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and
information, but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and
publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission
to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any
future reprint.
Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic,
mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or
retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers.
For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact
the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides
licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment
has been arranged.
Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation
without intent to infringe.
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at
http://www.taylorandfrancis.com
and the CRC Press Web site at
http://www.crcpress.com
Contents
Foreword............................................................................................................ ix
Preface................................................................................................................ xi
1 What Is 5S and Why Do It?................................................................. 1
What Is 5S?.......................................................................................................... 1
Benefits of 5S.................................................................................................. 1
Summary of Each of the 5 Pillars................................................................... 1
How Is It Implemented?...................................................................................... 3
Action Items.................................................................................................... 4
Parking Lot Items............................................................................................ 4
2 How to Use This Book........................................................................ 5
Action Items.................................................................................................... 6
Parking Lot Items............................................................................................ 6
Notes................................................................................................................ 6
3 Develop Your Plan.............................................................................. 7
Develop Your Plan: Summary of Steps.........................................................11
Action Items...................................................................................................11
Parking Lot Items...........................................................................................11
Notes...............................................................................................................11
4 Train the Team.................................................................................. 13
Tips for Launch Success.................................................................................15
Train the Team: Summary of Steps...............................................................16
Action Items...................................................................................................16
Team Ideas.....................................................................................................16
Parking Lot Items...........................................................................................16
5 Sort 17
Benefits.............................................................................................................. 18
Materials Needed...............................................................................................19
Pre-Event Tasks..................................................................................................19
Red Tag Event Steps...........................................................................................19
Lessons Learned for Future Red Tag Events................................................ 21
Sort: Summary of Steps................................................................................. 21
v
vi ◾ Contents
Action Items.................................................................................................. 22
Parking Lot Items.......................................................................................... 22
Notes.............................................................................................................. 22
6 Set in Order and Shine..................................................................... 23
Summary........................................................................................................... 23
Benefits.............................................................................................................. 23
Materials Needed.............................................................................................. 24
Pre-Event Tasks................................................................................................. 24
Set in Order and Shine Steps........................................................................... 25
Team Ideas.................................................................................................... 28
Some Idea Examples..................................................................................... 28
Some Shine Idea Examples........................................................................... 38
Some Idea Examples..................................................................................... 39
Set in Order: Summary of Steps................................................................... 47
Action Items.................................................................................................. 47
Team Ideas.................................................................................................... 47
Parking Lot Items.......................................................................................... 48
7 Standardize....................................................................................... 49
Benefits.............................................................................................................. 50
Materials Needed.............................................................................................. 50
Pre-Event Tasks................................................................................................. 50
Standardize Steps.............................................................................................. 50
Benefits...........................................................................................................51
Benefits of 5S Audits......................................................................................... 52
Standardize: Summary of Steps.................................................................... 56
Action Items.................................................................................................. 56
Parking Lot Items.......................................................................................... 56
8 Sustain.............................................................................................. 57
Summary........................................................................................................... 57
Benefits.............................................................................................................. 58
Materials Needed.............................................................................................. 58
Pre-Event Tasks................................................................................................. 58
Sustain Steps..................................................................................................... 59
Sustain: Summary of Steps........................................................................... 64
Action Items.................................................................................................. 64
Parking Lot Items.......................................................................................... 65
9 The Ideal Conditions to Implement Lean......................................... 67
Know What Your End Goal Is...........................................................................67
Make Sure Leadership Is Onboard................................................................... 68
Prepare Your People......................................................................................... 68
Contents ◾ vii
Mike McCarthy
Lean Consultant
Author of Sustain Your Gains: The People Side of Lean–Six Sigma
ix
Preface
David Visco
5S Expert
xi
Chapter 1
What Is 5S?
5S at its core is about removing non-value-added processes by developing stan-
dard methods for doing the necessary work. An effective 5S program therefore
improves efficiency, quality, workflow, and employee safety.
5S is based on the Japanese words that begin with the letter “s.”
◾◾ Sort (Seiri)
◾◾ Set in Order (Seiton)
◾◾ Shine (Seiso)
◾◾ Standardize (Seiketsu)
◾◾ Sustain (Shitsuke)
Benefits of 5S
◾◾ Saves time wasted searching for tools.
◾◾ Reduces the amount of walking to complete tasks.
◾◾ Increases safety by eliminating stretching, bending, and tripping hazards.
◾◾ Increases equipment reliability.
◾◾ Standardizes steps for easier and more accurate cross-training.
◾◾ Frees up valuable floor space.
◾◾ Helps lay the foundation for a continuous improvement culture.
1
2 ◾ 5S Made Easy
How Is It Implemented?
This outline is just a summary. We will go in depth on implementing each of the
5 pillars in the forthcoming chapters. The pillars are generally implemented in
order with one pillar following after the other.
Once a company decides to move forward with 5S, it is important to plan appro-
priately. Some items to consider are choosing the right project leader, 5S champion,
team members, the size of the area to address, timeframe, and ultimate goal.
Project Leader—It is important that the project leader is someone who has
a thorough understanding of 5S and significant experience managing and
implementing process change.
5S Champion—This is typically the person responsible for the area. They will
be in the trenches while also giving guidance and instruction to the team.
Team Members—Make sure to get everyone that works directly in the area
involved with the 5S implementation. Additionally, it is a good idea to have
one or two people from outside the department, for some “fresh eyes” on
the situation.
Size of the Area—Some companies opt to implement 5S across the entire plant
all at once. This is generally a bad idea. It is much more effective to choose
an area around 1000 sq. ft. so that all of the necessary work can be com-
pleted. Ideally, choose an area where a set of work processes begin and
end. 5S should help the work to flow through this set of processes.
Timeframe—There are two options with regard to the timeframe for the ini-
tial 5S event. Option 1 is to close down the area for 3 to 4 days and have
the team dedicated to this event. Option 2 is to roll it out for a few hours a
week or one day a week until the event is complete. Many companies find
this option easier to manage, as it is less disruptive to the operation.
Ultimate Goal—As with any process change, it is important to determine the
overall objective before proceeding. Some companies use the first three pil-
lars, Sort, Set in Order, and Shine to simply clean up the place. While this
gets the area cleaned up, it will not be sustainable without the other two pil-
lars, Standardize and Sustain. The company needs to decide upfront whether
this is just a quick cleanup project or an overall change on how to manage
their work process. A true 5S program never ends, as it is always making the
workflow easier, safer, and faster.
4 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Chapter 2
There are many books available on the subject of 5S. While some of them are
good on content, they all fail at providing an implementation plan that is easy to
follow—until now. In 5S Made Easy we have provided you with an easy-to-use,
systematic, step-by-step workbook for implementing a successful 5S program that
is effective and sustainable.
This book is written for the project leader and the team members responsible
for implementing the 5S program in the area.
For the process to be effective, you must follow the book in the order it is
presented. Do not skip right to Set in Order to clean up your workspace. If you
are just looking for some ideas on ways to prepare an area for an upcoming tour,
I suppose you could focus on Chapter 6: “Set in Order and Shine.” But trust me,
all the hard work will disappear within a few short days or weeks along with all
of the goodwill and positive feelings generated during the cleanup.
If, however, you are serious about finally learning how to implement a 5S pro-
gram that will help your production and be sustained over the long term, follow
the book in order. Do the steps as suggested. Do not skip a thing. The guidance
in this book is built on over a decade of proven methodologies and hands-on
experience from the author. 5S is a system that will not function properly without
all of the pieces. Similar to a house of cards, remove one card and the house just
might hold, but remove just one more card and you will likely have a mess on
your hands.
I suggest that you create a 2-inch three-ring binder to keep all of your 5S doc-
uments to use in the future as a reference guide. All documents and worksheets
throughout the book can be downloaded from the 5S Made Easy category on our
website, The 5S Store, at: www.the5Sstore.com/5SMadeEasy.
Ok, now, let’s get to work.
5
6 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Notes
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
Chapter 3
Before jumping into your 5S program, it is absolutely critical that you develop
a plan. While most of us prefer to not think of 5S as a project, there is still an
initial project-like component: planning. Where 5S differs from most projects is
that projects have an end date. 5S, for lack of a better term, is a journey with
no end date. The initial implementation of the 5S pillars will have an end date.
However, there is a routine to establish that will sustain all that has been accom-
plished. Like brushing your teeth, there are 5S procedures that have to be done
as a daily routine.
With that said, let’s begin this journey by creating a project plan using the 5S
Project Charter form (Figure 3.1). See the “Forms” section at the end of this book,
or as with all the forms, go to The 5S Store at: www.the5Sstore.com/5SMadeEasy
to download the forms for use.
Step 1: Get a 2-inch three-ring binder to store all of the project documents.
Also, if you have access to your company computer server, create a shared
folder to store all pictures, documents, action items, parking lot items, and
so on.
Caution
Do not lose sight of the need to include these other shifts and inform
them of what changes were made and why. Otherwise they might
7
8 ◾ 5S Made Easy
5S Project Charter
Project Authorization
Organization: Coach: Project Lead:
Project Objective:
Project Team
Name Role E-mail Address Phone
Scope
Is this area one where you can really make a big splash—a showcase
area—a best practice 5S area? Choose your area wisely.
Try and keep the area under 1000 square feet and make it an area or
department where a sub-process starts and stops (before handing off the
product to another department).
Will you shut down the area for 3 to 4 days and complete the implemen-
tation, or will you do the implementation in pieces spread out over several
weeks? If you have the slack in your production schedule to do it all at once,
then you have the advantage of a quicker and smoother transition. If you
cannot shut down, then you need to spread the implementation out over
several weeks. Progress will be slower, but you can continue with produc-
tion. A benefit of spreading the implementation out over several weeks is
that people can stay focused on 5S during the training and not worry about
the workload that may be building up back at their desk or workstation.
Step 3: Complete the Project Charter. Some tips for creating your 5S Project
Charter follow:
Develop Your Plan ◾ 9
Step 4: Make a list of the tools and supplies you will need. Order them and
stage them in the area you chose for your 5S event.
Caution
Keep in mind that you need to order Set in Order materials prior to
your Set in Order event. You should plan on at least a 2-week lead time
to receive all of your items. You will find a suggested “5S Materials
Checklist” at the end of this book. You can also contact one of the
experts at The 5S Store at: www.the5Sstore.com or (978) 842-4610, and
tell them you are following the 5S Made Easy workbook and could use
some help determining which products you need. A great idea is to
take some pictures of the area and send them to The 5S Store expert
and arrange for a free 30-minute consult. The staff are very happy to
help you on your way. This preparation and going to an expert first
who knows the 5S Made Easy methodologies can also save you a lot of
time and money.
Step 5: Inform all the other departments about your implementation plan.
Make it clear that you and your teammates are not to be disturbed during
the implementation times.
Tip
Get a “5S in Session” sign (Figure 3.2) and put it in the area when you are in the
midst of the event. Make sure everyone understands what this sign means.
10 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Figure 3.2 “5S IN SESSION” Sign Pal (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA, and
Accuform Signs, Brooksville, FL.)
Caution
The leader of the team absolutely has to set this precedent and lead by
example. Stay off your smartphone and laptop during the event and do
not let anyone pull you away.
Tip
Contact the facilities department in particular. Ask for their help. This group can
prove extremely beneficial if equipment needs to be moved or power needs to be
disconnected or sign hanging is required. Keep them in the loop, invite them to
lunches, and notify their manager. This level of inclusion will garner respect and
the support you need—while also keeping your team safe.
Step 6: Before you begin the Sort process, make sure to take plenty of before
pictures.
Tip
Try and take the pictures from positions that you can use in the future for your
after pictures. The “before and after” pictures are more effective if the viewpoints
are identical.
Develop Your Plan ◾ 11
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Notes
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
Chapter 4
It is critical to the success of your 5S program that you properly train the people
that will work in the area. Do not rush through this initial training. This will
likely be all new jargon and strategies for the group. The unknown scares people
and can put them on the defensive. As the leader it is imperative for you to listen
with sincere empathy. Additionally, make sure the team understands that most of
these steps will require their ideas and hands-on effort from them, not you, and
not the Lean manager. This is a team effort. It is up to the team members. It is
your responsibility as the leader to make this point abundantly clear, as well as
to hold yourself to this standard.
Tip
Have a mind-set that if you were away for several months after the 5S implemen-
tation, the area would look even better when you returned because the team and
you put in a standardized process (the fourth S) that the team owned and took
pride in.
Step 1: Use the What, Why, Where, When, and How format to explain what 5S
is all about:
◾◾ What—5S at its core is about removing non-value-added processes by
developing standard methods (one best way) for doing the daily work. An
effective 5S program therefore improves efficiency, quality, and employee
safety. All of us will do the work this standard way. 5S is roughly based
on the Japanese words that begin with the letter “s.”
– Sort (Seiri)
– Set in Order (Seiton)
– Shine (Seiso)
– Standardize (Seiketsu)
– Sustain (Shitsuke)
13
14 ◾ 5S Made Easy
◾◾ Why? (Benefits)
– Saves time wasted searching for tools.
– Reduces the amount of walking to complete tasks.
– Reduces non-value-added steps thereby improving efficiency.
– Increases safety by eliminating stretching, bending, and tripping
hazards.
– Increases equipment reliability by making malfunctions easier to spot.
– Standardizes steps for easier and more accurate cross-training.
– Frees up valuable floor space.
– Helps make production flow more smooth and continuous.
◾◾ Where—The area where the event will take place.
◾◾ When—What implementation plan have you chosen? A little bit each
week or shut down the area for several days?
◾◾ How—Show the project plan. Explain that there will be some classroom
style training but that most of the learning will be hands on out on the
shop floor. Explain that you will follow a step-by-step format provided by
author and 5S expert, David Visco, president of The 5S Store.
Tip
Ask for examples about how you can use the ideas in your area and write them
into the “Team Ideas” section at the end of this chapter. Refer back to these ideas
during the Set in Order step.
Step 3: Following the PowerPoint slide show, we suggest the team watch a brief
video. Studies have shown that learning through a few different methods
helps solidify the learning. There are several videos on the market today.
We suggest the Fundamental Principles of 5S video course. Use the coupon
code “5SMadeEasy” during checkout to receive 10% off this video. You can
find the video at: www.the5Sstore.com/5S-video-course.html.
Step 4: Play the 5S Nuts & Bolts Game developed by GBMP (Figure 4.1). This
game’s simple format will help drive home how 5S can remove stress and
confusion with staff members while also improving product quality and
customer satisfaction. Simulation games are a great way to learn concepts
while also having some fun in a team setting. You can find this game at:
www.the5Sstore.com/nuts-bolts-game.html and as with the video mentioned
above, use the coupon code “5SMadeEasy” to save 10%.
Train the Team ◾ 15
◾◾ 5S ideas that the team thought of during the PowerPoint and the video.
◾◾ A running list of action items.
◾◾ Team ideas.
◾◾ Parking lot items (ideas or concerns that surface but are out of scope).
◾◾ Materials list.
◾◾ Lessons learned.
◾◾ Take plenty of before pictures prior to beginning the event.
◾◾ Capture a team picture.
◾◾ Get everyone on the team to sign the Project Charter.
Note: There are also areas in each chapter to capture action items, parking lot
ideas, and general notes.
16 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Never forget that this is new for most if not all of the trainees. Be empathetic
to their concerns and listen with sincerity. They are learning something new, and
all learning curves start slowly.
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Team Ideas
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Chapter 5
Sort
By now if you have followed the steps in the other chapters you should have:
If you have skipped any of the above items, I strongly suggest completing
them in full prior to starting the Sort step.
Assuming those items are all done, let’s move forward.
Imagine if you will, going through the utensil drawer in your home kitchen.
Along with several spatulas, spoons, corn holders, corkscrews, and whisks,
there is something sharp in there. But you are in that drawer digging, looking,
searching for a bottle opener and, oops! You just sliced your finger on a knife.
Stressful and unsafe—that is the type of situation that Sort helps eliminate for
your employees.
Sort is the first of the five pillars of 5S. During this step you will go through
the chosen area and remove everything not needed for current production. The
more clutter you remove, the easier the next step, Set in Order, will be. Plus, it
just simply makes the area easier and safer to work in. The tool most often used
during the Sort process is a 5S red tag (see Figure 5.1a). The tag is used as a
means to depict the status of an item that may or may not be needed in the area.
17
18 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Date Tagged By
Item Description
5S RED TAG
Department Action to Take:
Item Type: Trash
Raw Materials Tools Hold
Finished Goods Instruments Move to
WIP Equipment Contact
Machine Parts Other Other
Other
Reason Tagged:
Manager’s
No Longer Used Unknown Owner Date Initials
Doesn’t Work Other Tag No.
Other www. the5Sstore.com 50T5SP
(a)
(b)
Figure 5.1 (a) Red Tag and (b) Red Tag Area Sign (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell,
MA, and Accuform Signs, Brooksville, FL.)
The tagged items are then moved to a predetermined red tag area often labeled
with a red tag area sign (see Figure 5.1b).
Estimated time to complete this step—1 to 3 hours, depending on the size of
the area.
Benefits
◾◾ Removes clutter
◾◾ Saves money by finding missing tools, office supplies, and inventory
◾◾ Improves safety
◾◾ Improves space availability
◾◾ Improves workflow
◾◾ Improves productivity
◾◾ Reduces searching
Sort ◾ 19
Materials Needed
The materials needed are red tags, pens, red tag area sign, material handling
carts, trash barrels, dumpster, safety glasses, and gloves.
Pre-Event Tasks
Develop a plan for what will be done with the material put in the red tag area.
Some things to consider:
Throughout the event remind the team that all unnecessary items are to be
removed from the designated area. This means every single item must be con-
sidered. Go through the entire area, left to right, top to bottom.
20 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Step 2: Review the benefits of the Sort process with the team. Determine the
length of the event. Explain that the plan is to go through the entire area,
opening all drawers, cabinets, shelves, and so on, and remove and tag
everything that is not needed to do their daily tasks. Remind them that if
they have duplicates of items, those should be removed too. For example,
many people have several of the same screwdriver at their workstation when
they really only need one. Remind the team to practice safety guidelines
regarding bending, reaching, and lifting. It is also a good idea to wear safety
glasses and gloves during the event.
Step 3: You will use preprinted blank red tags with fields to be filled in dur-
ing the event. There are many areas on the form to be filled out. Make sure
everyone has one form in their hands while you are discussing this step.
Decide as a team what sections must be filled out. Take a tag and circle with
a Sharpie those areas the team has decided are important. Keep that tag
aside and handy for future reference.
Step 4: Begin the red tag event. Hand everyone a handful of red tags. Make
sure you have an ample amount of red tags available. The last thing you
want is to run out of tags. Be available to answer any questions that may
arise.
Tip
After the initial event, place unused red tags in a 5S Red Tag Center (Figure 5.2)
strategically placed throughout the facility (Figure 5.3).
For large facilities, place several of these red tag areas and 5S Red Tag Center
signs throughout the plant to help reduce wasted travel time.
5S RED
TAG CENTER
Red Tag Procedure:
TIME TO •Identify items — Unnecessary,
REORDER Unneeded, or Misplaced
•Fill out Red Tag
5S RED
•Attach tag to item for evaluation
TAGS
•Move item to Red Tag Area
•Remove, relocate, or discard item
after designated holding period
Figure 5.2 “5S Red Tag Center” Figure 5.3 Red Tag Area after a Sort Event
Sign (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, (Courtesy of Macresco, Boston, MA.)
Pepperell, MA, and Accuform Signs,
Brooksville, FL.)
Sort ◾ 21
Step 5: Once the event is done, take after pictures from the same view as the
before pictures as well as a picture of the now filled red tag area. Also, make
sure to take a picture of the team in front of the area that the team just
sorted through.
Step 6: Reconvene as a team in front of the red tag area. Discuss any thoughts
and lessons learned for future red tag events. Capture action items and park-
ing lot issues.
Estimated value of items removed: $_______
Estimated square footage saved by removing the unneeded items?
_____ sq. ft.
Next Step—Set in Order and Shine. During this step you will arrange the tools
and equipment at point of use, arrange visual controls, and set up daily 5-minute
5S routines.
Action Items
Things that still need to be done:
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Notes
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
Chapter 6
Summary
Have you ever lost your keys? You were ready to leave your house in a rush only
to realize you cannot find your keys. Initially, you check all the normal areas and
then concern sets in as the keys continue to elude you. You cannot find them.
You get stressed; you start double and triple checking the same spot. If someone
speaks to you, you are likely to respond somewhat harshly. Then, voila, the keys
show up and all the stress and anxiety goes away. Life is good again except now
you are late. Similar occurrences happen all day, every day on the manufactur-
ing floor. The average worker spends 30% of his/her day searching, looking for
tools and materials, or wondering what to do next. There is so much time wasted
simply due to a lack of order. This is where Set in Order, the second pillar of 5S
comes in, combined with the third pillar, Shine.
Set in Order is basically the process of arranging the work area so that tools,
equipment, and materials are kept at the point of use, at the most appropriate
distance with visual controls (labels and shadow boards) in place to make non-
compliance (anything out of place) easily noticed. During these steps, you will
go through the chosen area and arrange items such as tools, equipment, and
supplies at the point of use and label them so anyone knows where the items
belong. Moreover, you will clean up the area while putting processes in place to
keep it looking clean and orderly.
Estimated time to complete this step—6 to 14 hours depending on the size and
condition of the area.
Benefits
◾◾ Puts everything you need to do the job in plain sight just where you need it.
◾◾ Removes clutter.
◾◾ Reduces wasted time searching for items.
◾◾ Improves safety by removing tripping hazards.
23
24 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Materials Needed
The materials needed are red tags, scissors, floor tape, pallet corners, trash barrel
signs, tool shadow tape, pegboards and hooks, cable ties, Sharpies, label printer,
magnetic 8 × 11 ticket holders, parts bins, sign maker, paint, paint brushes, clean-
ing supplies, brooms, dustpans, vacuum, rags, masking tape, material handling
carts, trash barrels. (See the “5S Materials Checklist” at the end of this book.)
Take a Minute—Discuss some examples of where searching for an item has
wasted time and hampered production.
Pre-Event Tasks
◾◾ Take plenty of pictures of the area before you begin the event.
◾◾ Have your 5S materials already in stock, organized, and laid out for ease
of access. (See the “5S Materials Checklist” at the end of this book.) Some
plants have a “5S Cart” with all of the 5S supplies on it.
◾◾ Determine what colors will be used for certain material status. These col-
ors are considered your 5S Color Visual Standards. (See an example of “5S
Visual Standards” in Figure 6.1 and also in the “Forms” section at the end of
5S Visual Standards
Color Standard Category Description
Red Hold/Quarantine Rejects/Hold/Issues
Yellow Warehouse Materials Outgoing/Incoming
Materials/Palletizing Areas
Green Signals/Triggers Kanban Locations
Blue Tools & Accessories Trash Cans, Pallet Jacks
Black/Yellow Safety/Caution Fire, PPE, Doorways
Black/White Electrical Electric Panels
Red/White Warehouse Lanes Walking Lanes/Travel Lanes
Figure 6.1 5S Visual Standards (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 25
this book. You can also download a template from the 5S Made Easy page
on The 5S Store website at: www.the5Sstore.com/5SMadeEasy.)
◾◾ Speak to the facilities department and explain what you are doing.
Review any heavy equipment or machinery that may need to be discon-
nected, moved, and de-energized for safety. Ask someone from facilities/
maintenance to review lock-out/tag out safety procedures with your 5S team.
◾◾ Determine if anything would require recalibration or re-leveling if it was
moved and decide how that will be handled.
Tip
Keeping outside departments involved in your 5S implementation is a great way
to improve buy-in for future expansion of the program.
Figure 6.2 Current State Spaghetti Diagram (Courtesy of Macresco, Boston, MA.)
26 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Step
3
Step Step
4 2
Step Step
5 1
Figure 6.3 The Ideal Process Flow (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 27
The other idea is that if workers were standing at workstations on the inside
of this upside-down “U,” they would be using their dominant right hand to
begin the work that flows to them from their right side. Again, this is the 5S
idea of making the work easier.
Here is another example of a “before and after” spaghetti diagram to
improve flow in a shipping and receiving area in a tight, low ceiling, industrial
building (see Figure 6.4a,b).
Notice the difference in the two images. We actually removed some
walls. All too often people do not think about the fact that walls can
SLS QA Release
Incoming
Inspection
(a)
QA Release
SLS
Incoming
Inspection
Shipping
and
Receiving Docks
Staging
Finished
Goods
Cardboard
Compactor Dumpster
(b)
Figure 6.4 (a) Before: Set in Order and (b) After: Set in Order
28 ◾ 5S Made Easy
5 WHYS
The most basic form of root cause analysis involves asking why five times to
get to the root of a problem.* For example:
usually be removed. They were there for some other reason that no lon-
ger makes sense. This company just kept using existing space as they grew
without making it fit their true needs thus imposing significant flow con-
straints. Once the walls came down the material and people flowed much
more smoothly.
Brainstorm ideas for removing barriers to flow. Money is not an issue,
time is not an issue. Simply get all the ideas written down and discussed.
Also consider ways to improve ergonomics and reduce twisting, turning,
bending, and reaching as much as possible.
Team Ideas
1.
__________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
7.
__________________________________________________________________
8. __________________________________________________________________
9.
__________________________________________________________________
◾◾ Adding windows
◾◾ Adding power outlets
◾◾ Replacing old, worn-out equipment
◾◾ Adding retractable air hoses
Tip
Make sure to capture these ideas on paper and save the information in your binder.
Step 3a: Once you have designed a new layout of the work area, determine
how and where to locate your tools, supplies, dies, documents, work in
progress (WIP), inventory and anything else that needs to be in the area.
Once you have decided the how and where, you will use visual controls to
communicate the new standards. Some examples:
◾◾ Mount durable pegboard so you can hang tools and get them off of bench
tops.
◾◾ For tools that are vertically mounted, utilize tool shadow tape.
◾◾ For tools that will be stored in drawers, use tool foam shadow boards.
◾◾ Use floor tape or floor corners to mark where the trash cans should
go. Make sure to put a label on the floor as well, that says “Trash” or
“Trash Can.”
◾◾ For documents that must be visible, hang them in a magnetic, adhesive,
or plain 8 × 11 job ticket holder.
◾◾ In Figure 6.5, we not only completely refinished the tabletop but also put
tools at point of use.
◾◾ Store items in the sequence that they are used.
◾◾ Use retractable cords for suspending tools from the ceiling.
◾◾ Replace bolts requiring a wrench with hand-turned grip bolts, thus elimi-
nating the wrench.
◾◾ Color coordinate tools with where they are used on the equipment.
Tip
When labeling items and producing signs or notices, set a standard and make
sure that the same font, color, and type of holder is used everywhere.
Tip
As we discussed in Chapter 4: “Train the Team,” it is important that the people
that are working in the area be the ones to Set in Order and Shine their area.
30 ◾ 5S Made Easy
(a)
(b)
Figure 6.5 (a) Before: Set in Order and (b) After: The Tabletop Was Not Only Refinished But
the Tools Were Also Put at Point of Use (Courtesy of Macresco, Boston, MA.)
Tip
You can find hundreds of Set in Order pictures and ideas at: www.5SBestPractices.
com.
Figure 6.6 Set in Order: Numbered 3 Figure 6.7 Aisle Marking for Clear Travel Lanes
Wheeler Matched to Numbered Space and Improved Safety (Courtesy of The 5S Store,
for It (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, LLC, Pepperell, MA.)
Pepperell, MA.)
Figure 6.8 Aisle Marking for Clear Travel Lanes and Improved Safety (Courtesy of
Aerodyne Alloys, South Windsor, CT.)
32 ◾ 5S Made Easy
(a)
(b)
Figure 6.9 (a) Floor Signs and (b) Aisle Marking for Clear Travel Lanes and Improved
Safety (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA, and Accuform Signs, Brooksville, FL.)
(a)
(b)
Cleaning
brush
Lobby
dust
pan
Drain
brush
Figure 6.12 (a) Visual Tool Drawers: Tool Shapes in the Foam Show Where Each Tool Belongs;
(b) Visual Boards for Cleaning Tools; (c) Visual Boards for Personal Protective Equipment
(Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA, and Accuform Signs, Brooksville, FL.)
34 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Personal Protective
Equipment
(c)
Eye Protection
Body Protection
Foot Protection
Figure 6.12 (Continued) (a) Visual Tool Drawers: Tool Shapes in the Foam Show Where
Each Tool Belongs; (b) Visual Boards for Cleaning Tools; and (c) Visual Boards for Personal
Protective Equipment (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA, and Accuform Signs,
Brooksville, FL.)
Figure 6.13 Organized Mobile Tool Control (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell,
MA, and Triton Products, Solon, OH.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 35
Figure 6.15 Visual Recycle Area: Color Coding for Where Each Bin Belongs (Courtesy of
Fuss & O’Neill, Boston, MA.)
36 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Figure 6.16 Floor Marking for Setting Standards (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell,
MA, and Ergomat, Lorain, OH.)
#1 Before
#1 After
Figure 6.17 Before and After Shine Event (Courtesy of Western States Envelope & Label,
Milwaukee, WI.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 37
(a)
(b)
Figure 6.18 (a) Before and (b) After (Courtesy of Southwest Cheese, Clovis, NM.)
Step 3b: During this step, you will also focus on Shine whereby all equipment
will look as good as new when you are done. You need to scrub all equip-
ment, walls, floors, doors, windowsills, cabinets—everything.
Tip
Have Opportunity, Maintenance, and Repair Request tags available. When your
team sees oil leaks, broken parts, or frayed wiring, they can write up a Repair
Request on the spot (Figure 6.19).
Figure 6.19 Opportunity Tag (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA, and used
with permission of TheVisualMachine.com, Columbus, NC, 2015.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 39
Figure 6.21 Walls: Before and After (Courtesy of Macresco, Boston, MA.)
Before After
(a) (b)
Figure 6.22 (a) Before and (b) After (Courtesy of Inland Packaging, Lauderhill, FL.)
Tip
If you foresee a lot of maintenance work, ask that someone from the plant main-
tenance department be a part of your 5S team.
(a)
(b)
Figure 6.23 (a) Gauge Marking Label and (b) Zebra Card (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC,
Pepperell, MA, and used with permission of TheVisualMachine.com, Columbus, OH, 2015.)
Step 5: Collect whatever 5S materials are remaining and store them in a desig-
nated location. Set up kanbans for all of these materials as well as anything
you ran out of but may need again.
Step 6: Once the event is done, take after pictures from the same view as the
before pictures.
Step 7: Create a “5S Before and After” template and upload the files to your
folder on your company’s server as discussed in Chapter 3: “Develop Your
Plan.” Print this out and put it in your binder in the Set in Order/Shine sec-
tion and post the improvement images on your 5S Communication Board
(see a few 5S board examples in Figures 6.29 and 6.30).
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 41
Before
After
Figure 6.24 Example 1—Set in Order: Before and After (Courtesy of Hexion, www.hexion.
com.)
Step 8: Reconvene as a team in front of the new clean and organized area.
Discuss any thoughts, concerns, or ideas. Capture action items and parking
lot issues.
Next Step—Standardize. Make everything you have done into a habit to help
ensure the operation does not go back to the way it used to be.
42 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Before
After
Figure 6.25 Example 2—Set in Order: Before and After (Courtesy of Hexion, www.hexion.
com.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 43
Before
After
Figure 6.26 Example 1—Set in Order and Shine: Before and After (Courtesy of Southwest
Cheese, Clovis, NM.)
44 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Before
After
Figure 6.27 Example 2—Set in Order and Shine: Before and After (Courtesy of TREMCO,
Beachwood, OH.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 45
Before
After
Figure 6.28 Example 3—Set in Order and Shine: Before and After (Courtesy of Collins Bus
Corporation, South Hutchinson, KS.)
46 ◾ 5S Made Easy
5S Board
Work Area: Activity Date:
Before After Scheduled Current Activities
5S Evaluation Review 5S Evaluation Review 30 Day 5S Action Log
5S Evaluation Review 5S Evaluation Review
Photos Photos
Comments:
Visual Management
“Organize” Machine
Cleaning Schedule
Housekeeping
Improvements
Audit Audit
Criteria Results
All rights reserved VIPGroup
Figure 6.30 Example 2: 5S Communication Board (Courtesy of the VIP Group, Lake
St. Louis, MO.)
Set in Order and Shine ◾ 47
Tip
Implement a kanban card system for the 5S supplies. One of the quickest
ways to kill momentum of a 5S initiative is to run out of 5S supplies. If you
need help with this, just contact The 5S Store at: (978)-842-4610 or e-mail:
[email protected].
Action Items
1.
__________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Team Ideas
1.
__________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
7.
__________________________________________________________________
8. __________________________________________________________________
48 ◾ 5S Made Easy
1.
__________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
Chapter 7
Standardize
Standardize is the fourth pillar of 5S. During this step you will set up processes
that help make non-compliance obvious.
This is a significant step that should not be taken lightly. Without sufficient
standards, people will not know what is expected of them. Setting clear expecta-
tions is the only way to have a successful 5S program.
This may seem like an obvious standard to put into place; however, I have seen
this one simple standard missed countless times. Make it easy on everyone and
remove ambiguity by posting your color standards throughout the facility.
Note: I have been asked often if there is a set color standard for 5S. The
answer is no. Many companies follow OSHA (Occupational Safety & Health
Administration standards) for their safety requirements; however, this misses the
mark for kanban, equipment, trash, and so on. See our suggested color standards
in Chapter 6 “Set in Order and Shine” or in the “Forms” section at the end of
this book.
Estimated time to complete this step—3 hours.
49
50 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Benefits
◾◾ Problems of the past will not resurface.
◾◾ Develops consistency for where and how items should be stored.
◾◾ Provides a foundation for clear expectations.
◾◾ Reduces uncertainty about how the area should look.
◾◾ Provides a foundation so all documents, signs, and labeling are consistent in
appearance.
◾◾ Allows the workers to know what is expected (absolutely key for 5S success).
◾◾ Makes abnormal conditions obvious at a glance.
Materials Needed
The materials needed are a 5S Area Audit form, 5S Shine Map, 5S Maintenance
Chart, How to Develop a Successful 5S Audit Program, Weekly 5S Audit Score
sheet, and Opportunity tags.
Pre-Event Tasks
Make enough copies of the 5S Audit form and 5S Maintenance Chart for the
entire team being trained.
Standardize Steps
Step 1: Develop your 5S Shine Map. To do this, draw a quick and easy map of
the area showing major lanes and equipment for reference points.
Step 2: Break your 5S Shine Map into quadrants and assign each team member
that works in that area a quadrant to keep clean and orderly and to inspect
the equipment daily. The key here is to make sure to hold each member
accountable for their area. We will discuss how to do this shortly.
Step 3: Discuss and develop a 5S Maintenance Chart* (see Figure 7.1). This chart
helps to standardize and sustain the previous 5S pillars along with improv-
ing equipment productivity.
Area/Equipment Name:
5S Maintenance Program
Equipment No:
Authorized: Ownership:
Type of
Maintenance Adjustment Inspection Vacuum/Sweep/Dust Lubrication Clean/Scrub
January February March April May June
1/15/2015
1/22/2015
1/29/2015
2/12/2015
2/19/2015
2/26/2015
3/12/2015
3/19/2015
3/26/2015
4/16/2015
4/23/2015
4/30/2015
5/14/2015
5/21/2015
5/28/2015
6/11/2015
6/18/2015
6/25/2015
1/1/2015
1/8/2015
2/5/2015
3/5/2015
4/2/2015
4/9/2015
5/7/2015
6/4/2015
Daily
Activity Description of Activity/Material Used
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
Form 20090119 Rev:B Signoff on Weekly, Monthly, Quarterly, Bi-Annual, or Annual Maintenance Items When Completed
Benefits
◾◾ Clarifies expectations
◾◾ Empowers employees
◾◾ Provides a method for organizing necessary activities
◾◾ Provides feedback at a glance
◾◾ Helps to ensure the proper maintenance is conducted on machinery and
workspaces
◾◾ Fill in the following for each quadrant:
– Name of team member responsible for that quadrant
– List the areas to be cleaned
– List equipment maintenance tasks
◾◾ Categorize all activities into one of five categories:
– Adjustment
– Inspection
– Vacuum/Sweep/Dust
– Lubrication
– Clean/Scrub
◾◾ Determine how often each activity needs to occur
52 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Tip
Consider ways to eliminate the need for cleaning in the first place. For example,
if wood shavings are getting on the floor, install a vacuum nearby that automati-
cally collects the shavings as they are produced.
Benefits of 5S Audits
◾◾ Clarifies expectations.
◾◾ Empowers employees.
◾◾ Provides feedback on the areas and processes that do meet or exceed
standards.
◾◾ Provides feedback on the areas that have fallen below expectations.
◾◾ Provides a forum to capture root cause and corrective actions that will help
your team make continuous improvement a part of their daily work.
Step 5: Review the 5S Audit form with the team (see Figure 7.2). Make sure
everyone has a copy of the 5S Audit form.
Rating # of Non-
Status Level Conformities
Poor 1 5 or More
5S Audit Checklist Fair 2 3–4
Good 3 2
Very Good 4 1
Best Practice 5 None
Audit Date:
Area:
Auditor(S):
Category
Objective: Determine What Is and Isn’t Needed Score Comments/Observations
No unneeded equipment, tools, paperwork, etc., are present in area
All necessary items are clearly labeled
Sort No unneeded inventory, supplies, parts, or materials (WIP) present in area
Personal items are not cluttering work area: tripping dangers are removed
Red Tag system is in place and unecessary items are tagged and stored
0
Objective: A Place for Everything and Everything in Its Place
Designated areas are visually identified for finished, WIP, and pending jobs
Tools are at point of use and storage is visual (easy to see, retrieve, return)
Set in Order Aisles, work areas, benches, equipment are clearly and consistently marked
Storage is above knees and below shoulders: work is at correct height
Paperwork and documents are properly organized and labeled
0
Objective: Clean to Inspection
Floors, walls, stairs, surfaces, equipment are free of dirt, oil, grime and clutter
A maintenance system is in place to ensure periodic equipment inspection
Shine Cleaning materials are well organized and easily accessible
Area is well lit and ventilated, labels and signs are legible/in good condition:
Shine responsibilities are clear and monitored regularly
0
Objective: Standards to Keep the First 3 S’s from Deteriorating
5S Maintenance Schedule and Checklist are posted in the area
5S Visual Color Standards are posted and followed
Standardize Standard Work Instructions are posted
5S and continuous improvement results are posted and clear
Processes exist to monitor previous Audit Action items
0
Objective: Make It a Habit
5S Audits are conducted regularly
Supervisors are actively involved in 5S activities
Sustain
Management conducts regularly scheduled gemba walks
All employees are trained in 5S and engaged to maintain the 5S Standard
Communication Boards are up to date
0
Step 6: Conduct your first audit as a team. Have everyone walk along the same
path and write down their scores for each section. Then, discuss everyone’s
score and how they determined them. This is a critical step for making the
audit objective and fact based (versus subjective and opinion based). There
is always some unavoidable subjectivity between a score of a 2 or 3, 3 or
4, and so on. This is a critical step for beginning to set standards. Talk as a
group and determine the various scoring results.
One easy way to standardize this process is to create a scoring matrix
that is based on the number of non-compliances (see Figure 7.2, a sample
“5S Audit Checklist”). If any two people on the team disagree on the number
of non-conformities, stop and talk about it. See the potential scenario that
follows, which helps explain the need to talk among the group:
Team Leader: Fred, you called this grease fitting a non-conformity, but
Mary did not. Why?
Fred: It has excess grease smeared all over the machine cover. When I
close the cover after my inspection, grease gets on my hand and then
gets on the units I’m assembling. Grease on the units means they’ll be
rejected by Quality Assurance. Then they’ll be sent back to be cleaned
up. That’s rework.
Team Leader: Mary, what do you say?
Mary: I did not know the grease would cause rework. I now agree with
Fred. Excess grease at the grease fitting is a non-conformity.
With the team now in agreement about how to score the grease fitting,
your audit scores will all turn out the same. Moreover, making notes of these
non-conformities will help drive corrective actions.
A sample of this Audit form is shown in Figure 7.2 and can be down-
loaded on the 5S Made Easy page on The 5S Store website. This first audit
should take at least an hour to allow for discussion about making sure
everyone scores the same way. Take your time. Going forward, audits will
likely take under 30 minutes.
Step 7: Once your audit is complete, agree as a team what the final score is for
each section and update the Audit form. This score will be your baseline for
future audits. Your score will likely be low, as you are just beginning. Every
time the score improves, give the team some positive recognition. Let them
know you have noticed their work has paid off with higher 5S Audit Scores.
Step 8: Add that score to the Weekly 5S Audit Score Graph which should roll
up to the Monthly Dept. 5S Scorecard (see Figure 7.3). Post the graph on
the team’s 5S Communication Board in the area. A graph allows you to see
progress and trends. The team will take satisfaction in seeing improving
Standardize ◾ 55
4.5
Goal 4.0
4
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
Work Work Work Work Work Work Work Work Work
Area 1 Area 2 Area 3 Area 4 Area 5 Area 6 Area 7 Area 8 Area 1
Score Goal
Acme Manufacturing
5S Score Plant Average
5
4.5
Annual Goal 4.0
4
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
January February March April May June July August September October November December
Score Goal
Note: Another key aspect that needs to be standardized is your 5S training pro-
cess. This book has been created to give you an easy-to-duplicate 5S implemen-
tation plan and therefore standardize your training. You may choose to do things
a little differently than the book suggests. This is absolutely fine: just make sure
to make those changes the new standard.
Next Step—Sustain. Building the daily routines needed to follow through
on all the improvements. Sustaining makes following the standard procedures
a habit.
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Chapter 8
Sustain
Summary
Sustain is the fifth and final pillar of 5S. It incorporates the disciplines needed
to maintain the improvements. Sustaining makes the process of maintaining
standardized procedures engrained in the normal operation of the business. Be
forewarned that it is considered to be the most difficult of the 5S pillars.
Most companies succeed with the first three of the 5S pillars: Sort, Set in
Order, and Shine and some companies do okay with Standardizing their pro-
cesses. However, many have trouble sustaining the improvements. Ironically, it
is actually a lot easier than most think. However, what is easy is not always put
into practice. Moreover, as self-improvement guru Jim Rohn says, “What’s easy to
do, is also easy NOT to do.”
Many companies struggle with Sustaining due to a lack of a true “why.” They
must decide why they want 5S to succeed in the first place. Many use 5S to orga-
nize and clean the area. This reason misses the intent by a long shot. While a
successful 5S System certainly results in a cleaner, more organized workspace, it
more importantly helps to solidify a culture of improvement and empowerment.
What do I mean by empowerment? Instead of saying, “somebody ought to...,”
your team says, “let’s try this...” 5S puts the power of improvement in the hands
of the workers. It allows them to try, fail, react, and improve, which are the steps
of learning. 5S develops their capacity to experiment with improvements system-
atically. Regrettably, many senior-level managers do not understand how valuable
this benefit truly is. If they did, they would make 5S a priority. The 5S process
allows people to teach themselves how to improve the workflow.
With that said, this chapter will focus on methods to systematically Sustain the
improvements your team has made with their 5S program.*
* My thanks to my colleague Michael McCarthy, author of Sustain Your Gains, for his contributions to this
chapter.
57
58 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Benefits
1. Improvements will last and deliver the gains—the cost reductions and
quicker production times that give you a competitive advantage.
2. Equipment will remain running efficiently (greater percentage of uptime).
3. The workforce will realize that the management team is serious about con-
tinuous improvement and follow their lead.
4. Morale will improve, because people prefer to work in an organized and
clean workspace.
5. Safety improvements will remain intact.
6. Employees will feel empowered and realize they have some control over
their work environment.
7. Now that tools and supplies are not misplaced, there will be a reduction of
replacement spending.
Materials Needed
The materials needed are a 5S Newsletter, 5S Management Walk Cards, 5S Message
Board, 5S pens, 5S posters, 5S team shirts, and 5S banners.
Pre-Event Tasks
Schedule a monthly 5S program review with 5S team leaders. As the leader,
you need to create the right conditions to help sustain your improvements.
Developing these conditions is covered in detail within each Sustain step below.
The necessary conditions are:
Keep these ideas in mind while developing the Sustain steps below.
Sustain ◾ 59
Sustain Steps
Step 1: Now that the 5S reorganization is complete, one useful idea is to get
everyone to sign a 5S banner (see Figure 8.1) as a commitment to maintain-
ing the 5S Audit standards that everyone has agreed to. You can find these
at: www.the5Sstore.com/5SMadeEasy. At checkout, use the coupon code
“5SMadeEasy” and get 10% off your purchase.
Step 4: Develop and maintain 5S status boards showing the 5S team members
along with “before and after” pictures and activities (Figure 8.5).
Figure 8.1 5S Team Commitment Banner (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA,
and Accuform Signs, Brooksville, FL.)
60 ◾ 5S Made Easy
5S + SAFETY
4S - Create standards
SUSTAIN 1S - Only keep needed
so that anything 5S - items in the work
unusual becomes area. When in doubt
obvious to sort it out
everyone
ZE 1S
DI -
SO
AR
RT
ND
5S RED TAG
STA
4S -
SAFETY SAFETY
3S -
ER
SH
RD
E
IN
O
N I
S ET
2 S-
3S - Clean the 2S - Keep items
machines, floors, and that are needed
walls, looking for sources organized so that they
of filth. eliminate these 5 S - SUSTAIN can be found quickly
sources
LEAN WORKPLACE ORGANIZATION
(a)
(b)
Figure 8.2 (a) 5S Poster and (b) 5S T-Shirt (Courtesy of Lean Posters, www.leanposters.com,
and The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA.)
Sustain ◾ 61
Figure 8.4 Management Walk Cards (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA and
GBMP, Newton, MA.)
If you want to reward and celebrate achievement of Sustain goals on 5S
standards, McCarthy recommends:
Caution
Do not simply give out these items. They must be earned by achieving
the stated goal. For example, “When we sustain our 5S standards at 95%
for 6 out of 8 weeks, everyone on the team will earn a ‘5S Sustainers’
pin.” When earned, these items have value and will be respected. If
given out un-earned, these items will be considered freebies that do not
mean anything and lose their value.
62 ◾ 5S Made Easy
Figure 8.5 5S Board (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA, and Enna Products,
Bellingham, WA.)
You need more recognition when: You need less recognition when:
There are fewer visual cues for the new Visual cues lead you through every step of
standard work the new standard work
There are no posted checklists to follow Checklists to follow are posted
The new assembly sequence is not obvious The shape of the parts make the new
assembly sequence obvious
The new work sequence is significantly The new work sequence is not that much
different than the old different than the old one
Certain steps are frequently missed or done Most steps are done consistently
incorrectly
A new person or outsider cannot perform the A new person or outsider can perform nearly
new work steps without being told or guided all new work steps without being told or guided
Figure 8.7 Reward Pins (Courtesy of The 5S Store, LLC, Pepperell, MA.)
Sustain ◾ 63
Caution
Setting up contests that “reward” for quantity of improvements can
cause people to spend an inordinate amount of time doing the things
that help them win the contest. You get what you reward. This can also
cause tension in the department, as the one pushing to win the contest
may be seen as not contributing to his/her regular duties. Generally
speaking, we do not recommend contests that reward one individual for
doing the “most” or being the “best.” This destroys teamwork, as indi-
viduals keep their good ideas to themselves so that they can win over
the others. You want teamwork and sharing of good ideas. Therefore,
group rewards for group achievements usually work better, and with-
out the unintended consequences mentioned above. For example:
“When the entire team sustains 95% 5S standards followed for 6 out of
8 weeks, everyone on the team earns a 5S Sustainers t-shirt.”
them score the audit and say positive things to your team members for their
adherence to 5S standards. In this way, you can coach them gradually in the
skills that will help you and them to Sustain your 5S standards.
Tip
For training resources for sustaining 5S, including Michael McCarthy’s Sustain
Your Gains training delivered via the Internet to your plant conference room,
contact Mike McCarthy at: [email protected]. Also, to learn
about improving communications skills, Scott Gauvin has a fantastic 3-day course
on “People Centric Leadership,” for more information contact the author at:
David.Visco@the5Sstore.com.
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Sustain ◾ 65
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
5. __________________________________________________________________
6. __________________________________________________________________
Chapter 9
67
68 ◾ 5S Made Easy
begin with departmentally related goals, they will not be sustainable without
organization-wide support and longer-term vision.
Action Items
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
1. __________________________________________________________________
2. __________________________________________________________________
3. __________________________________________________________________
4. __________________________________________________________________
In Closing
In closing, much has been made about how difficult 5S is to implement and
sustain. I believe 5S success is attainable if you just follow the steps provided in
this workbook and maintain momentum and vigilance. Once the initial training
and implementation is in place, 5S is relatively straightforward if you just stay
on course by not allowing complacency to settle in simply because you or your
team is too busy. You will succeed if you stay on course, maintain your audits,
keep your 5S materials stocked, recognize accomplishments, course correct
where necessary, hold people accountable, and celebrate the successes.
Please make sure to contact me and let me know how your 5S program is
going and if you need any help. I look forward to hearing from you. Best of luck.
David Visco
5S Expert
[email protected]
71
5S Launch Guide
73
74 ◾ 5S Launch Guide
All of the items in the checklist can be sourced from The 5S Store at: www.
the5Sstore.com. One suggestion is to order one of the 5S Made Easy Starter Kits.
5S Materials Checklist
Suggested
Quantity Items
1 5S Fundamental Principles of 5S Video
1 5S Nuts & Bolts Game
1 2” Vinyl Tape—Yellow, Green, Red, Blue, Black/Yellow, Black/White, Red/White
1 1” Vinyl Tape—Yellow, Green, Red, Blue, White, Black
20 Pallet Corner Markers
1 Pack of Red Tags
1 Red Tag Area Sign
TBD 5S Message Pens (One for each team member)
1 5S Poster
1 7 Wastes Poster
1 Roll of Tool Shadow Tape
1 Pegboard Kit
1 DIY Tool Foam Kit
1 Pack of 1 x 4 Dry Erase Magnets (white)
3 Gauge Marking Labels—One Green, Yellow, and Red
Copies of 5S Made Easy (1 book for each team member)
75
Forms
77
5S Project Charter
78 ◾ Forms
Project Authorization
Organization: Coach: Project Lead:
Scope
Achievements (list things that the team or team members did well with regard to 5S)
Audit Scores
Poor 1 5 or More
5S Audit Checklist Fair 2 3–4
Good 3 2
Very Good 4 1
Best Practice 5 None
Audit Date:
Area:
Auditor(S):
Category
Objective: Determine What Is and Isn’t Needed Score Comments/Observations
No unneeded equipment, tools, paperwork, etc., are present in area
All necessary items are clearly labeled
Sort No unneeded inventory, supplies, parts, or materials (WIP) present in area
Personal items are not cluttering work area: tripping dangers are removed
Red Tag system is in place and unecessary items are tagged and stored
0
Objective: A Place for Everything and Everything in Its Place
Designated areas are visually identified for finished, WIP, and pending jobs
Tools are at point of use and storage is visual (easy to see, retrieve, return)
Set in Order Aisles, work areas, benches, equipment are clearly and consistently marked
Storage is above knees and below shoulders: work is at correct height
Paperwork and documents are properly organized and labeled
0
Objective: Clean to Inspection
Floors, walls, stairs, surfaces, equipment are free of dirt, oil, grime and clutter
A maintenance system is in place to ensure periodic equipment inspection
Shine Cleaning materials are well organized and easily accessible
Area is well lit and ventilated, labels and signs are legible/in good condition:
Shine responsibilities are clear and monitored regularly
0
Objective: Standards to Keep the First 3 S’s from Deteriorating
5S Maintenance Schedule and Checklist are posted in the area
5S Visual Color Standards are posted and followed
Standardize Standard Work Instructions are posted
5S and continuous improvement results are posted and clear
Processes exist to monitor previous Audit Action items
0
Objective: Make It a Habit
5S Audits are conducted regularly
Supervisors are actively involved in 5S activities
Sustain
Management conducts regularly scheduled gemba walks
All employees are trained in 5S and engaged to maintain the 5S Standard
Communication Boards are up to date
0
5S Visual Standards
Area/Equipment Name:
5S Maintenance Chart
Equipment No:
Authorized:
Type of
Maintenance
Adjustment Inspection Vacuum/Sweep/Dust Lubrication Clean/Scrub
January February March April May June
Daily
Owner
1/2/2015
1/9/2015
2/6/2015
3/6/2015
4/3/2015
5/1/2015
5/8/2015
6/5/2015
1/16/2015
1/23/2015
1/30/2015
2/13/2015
2/20/2015
2/27/2015
3/13/2015
3/20/2015
3/27/2015
4/10/2015
4/17/2015
4/24/2015
5/15/2015
5/22/2015
5/29/2015
6/12/2015
6/19/2015
6/26/2015
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
5S Best Practices
www.5SBestPractices.com
5S Virtual Coach
www.5SVirtualCoach.com
Scott Gauvin
[email protected]
www.macresco.com
GBMP
www.gbmp.org
Mike McCarthy
Author: Sustain Your Gains—The People Side of Lean–Six Sigma
Sustain Training via the Internet, delivered to your plant conference room
[email protected]
www.SustainLeanGains.com
David Visco
Author: 5S Made Easy
[email protected]
Supplies
The 5S Store
www.the5Sstore.com
83
Acknowledgments
85
86 ◾ Acknowledgments
87
Business Management / Productivity Improvement
5S Made Easy
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Implementing and Sustaining
Your 5S Program
“ 5S Made Easy is a simple, easy-to-follow guide for 5S in manufacturing. It nicely explains how 5S
has a greater purpose than simple housekeeping. It is about standardizing and improving—often
overlooked points in a 5S deployment.”
—Drew Locher, Change Management Associates, Shingo Prize-Winning Author of
Lean Office and Service Simplified and Value Stream Mapping for Lean Development
“Hurray to Dave Visco for 5S Made Easy .... The stability created through an effective 5S process is
critical to every other best practice, from set-reduction and TPM to kanban and standardized work.
Dave’s book offers a step-by-step primer for any change leader who wants to get this foundational
improvement method right the first time.”
—Bruce Hamilton, President, GBMP
“Anyone can begin a 5S program in their department or business by following this book’s
easy-to-understand steps. In addition, Visco has provided checklists, forms, and resource guides.
Almost everything you need is right here.”
—From the Foreword by Mike McCarthy, Lean Consultant and Author of Sustain
Your Gains: The People Side of Lean-Six Sigma
For decades, 5S practitioners have struggled with exactly how to implement and sustain a 5S
program in their workplaces. While there are many books available on the organization meth-
ods suggested by 5S, few provide easy-to-understand, step-by-step guidance on how to set
up and sustain successful 5S implementations. 5S Made Easy fills this need.
Written by an expert whose focus for the last decade has been nothing but 5S, the book
supplies in-depth guidance on how to implement and sustain each of the 5S pillars—sort, set
in order, shine, standardize, and sustain.
The book uses an easy-to-follow format that was designed for use during 5S events. It
provides color images of real-world 5S solutions, including before and after pictures from the
field. It also supplies readers with online access to all of the forms and documents needed for
an effective 5S program. All the forms and documents are provided in an easily editable format
to fit any operation.
K25513
ISBN: 978-1-4987-1982-7
90000
9 781498 719827