Scribd
Upload
65 views2 pages

AD9 - Grading Sheet - 1st Defense PDF

This document outlines the requirements and evaluation criteria for a capstone design project proposal defense. It includes sections on the problem statement, client, objectives, design process, site justification, and presentation requirements. Students will present their proposed capstone project and site to a panel who will evaluate and provide feedback.

Uploaded by

Nicole Verosil
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
65 views2 pages

AD9 - Grading Sheet - 1st Defense PDF

This document outlines the requirements and evaluation criteria for a capstone design project proposal defense. It includes sections on the problem statement, client, objectives, design process, site justification, and presentation requirements. Students will present their proposed capstone project and site to a panel who will evaluate and provide feedback.

Uploaded by

Nicole Verosil
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

TECHNOLOGICAL INSTITUTE OF THE PHILIPPINES – QUEZON CITY

ARCHITECTURE DEPARTMENT

ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN 9 (AR 511S4) CAPSTONE DESIGN PROJECT


1st DEFENSE : DESIGN PROJECT PROPOSAL DEFENSE
(PROJECT AND SITE JUSTIFICATION)
(To be filled out by the student)
PROPONENT/S : ____________________________________________________________________________
PROJECT TITLES :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
(for the jury, please check :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
the approved Project) :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
ADVISER : ____________________________________________________________________________
(To be filled out by the panelist)
ITEM
DESCRIPTION WEIGHT P LS S VS E SCORE
NO.
THE PROBLEM AND ITS SETTING 45
THE PROJECT & PROBLEM STATEMENT
(Rationale of the Project, Background of the Project, Funnel
the topic from global to national perspective to the specific
issues that the study intends to address)
20 1-4 5-9 10 11-15 16-20
THE CLIENT
(Discussion on the issues and/or aspirations of the client as
to why the project is needed. Briefly discuss the
1 background/profile of the client)
PROJECT OBJECTIVES, SCOPE AND
LIMITATIONS
(Objectives must be SMART: Specific, Measurable, 15 1-3 4-6 7 8-12 13-15
Achievable, Realistic, and Timely. Discussion on the extent of
the study; items/issues not included in the Study)
DESIGN PROCESS
(the systematic approach using diagram or series of steps 10 1-2 3-4 5 6-8 9-10
that the student will follow in developing their project)
SITE JUSTIFICATION 45
SITE / DEVELOPMENT SELECTION CRITERIA
(General and specific criteria applicable to the 20 1-4 5-9 10 11-15 16-20
Site/Development)
MACRO-MICRO SITE ANALYSIS
2 (CLUP and Zoning, Development restriction, Constraints, and
Trends, Lot Plan, Physical Determinants that could assess 20 1-4 5-9 10 11-15 16-20
the capability and suitability of the site, SWOT analysis, Site
Zoning)
INITIAL SCHEMATIC DESIGN
(Initial Site Development Plan that will emphasize the best 5 1 2 3 4 5
possible layout in the site)
ARCHITECTURAL PRESENTATION 10
PRESENTATION REQUIREMENTS 5 1 2 3 4 5
(Completeness and Quality of Presentation Materials)
3 MASTERY AND DELIVERY
(Thorough Knowledge of the Project, Organization and
5 1 2 3 4 5
Analysis of Data, Manner of Presentation, Ability to Defend,
Oral & Written English Proficiency)
LEGEND:
P – Poor VS – Very Satisfactory TOTAL SCORE
LS – Less Satisfactory E – Excellent
S – Satisfactory

PANELIST: _____________________________________________ DATE: ___________________________________


(Signature over printed name) TIME START : _________ TIME END : _________
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN 9 (AR 511S4) CAPSTONE DESIGN PROJECT
1ST DEFENSE : DESIGN PROJECT PROPOSAL DEFENSE
COMMENT SHEET
(To be filled out by the student)
PROPONENT/S : ____________________________________________________________________________
PROJECT TITLES :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
(for the jury, please check :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
the approved Project) :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
ADVISER : ____________________________________________________________________________
(To be filled out by the panelist)
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, AND OTHER CONCERNS DURING PRESENTATION
INSTRUCTIONS TO THE PANELIST:
 Please be guided by the attached guide questions corresponding to the grading sheet criteria being evaluated.
 Kindly list down all additional questions, comments and other concerns that may strike you during the presentation, also in accordance to the
criteria being evaluated, to be used as a guide during the panel discussion.
 Place a check mark on all questions successfully answered by the proponent/s.

Use the back of the paper for additional questions, comments and other concerns

FINAL COMMENTS AND OTHER CONCERNS


INSTRUCTIONS TO THE PANELIST:
 Kindly list down all comments and other concerns that may arise during deliberations as well as any other questions not answered
successfully by the proponent/s during the panel discussion.
 This shall serve as the justification / basis of the grade given to the proponent/s for this particular defense.

Use the back of the paper for additional comments and other concerns

PANELIST: ______________________________________________________ DATE: ____________________


(Signature over printed name)

You might also like