Extended Essay Final Draft
Extended Essay Final Draft
Management
1|Page
Introduction
Estee Lauder is one of the most successful companies and one of the market leaders in
the cosmetics industry. Since it was founded in 1946 by Estee Lauder and her husband the
company expanded across the world further developing new brands or purchasing new ones
The company started as a small business in New York, The United States and was originally
The 1960s especially marked a crucial growth period for the brand. During this decade the
company started the construction of three manufacturing facilities and expanded overseas
starting from the United Kingdom which will soon become a core market. Furthermore, the`
company developed two major brands which proved to be revolutionary. Hence, Aramis became
the first prestigious man fragrance brand and Clinique revolutionized the industry by introducing
fragrance-free skincare products that were anti-allergenic. The brands and products
implemented by Estee Lauder helped the brand revolutionize the industry and become one of
Methodology
This essay will focus on the analysis of the strategy that was used by Estee Lauder to recover
after the recession and reinforce its position as one of the top cosmetics companies worldwide.
First, the performance of the company will be calculated using the financial ratio analysis for
2010 and the following years. Next, the market competition will be evaluated using Porter’s Five
Forces analysis.
2|Page
The market mix and market segmentation of the company will be as well discussed.
Furthermore, important aspects such as the branding strategy and the expansion strategy of the
business will be explored in order to determine to what extent are they contributing to the
The essay will also take into consideration the internal and external factors that have an impact
on the development of the company. For the evaluation of these factors, PESTLE, SWOT and
The company expanded tremendously in the past 60 years and Estée Lauder Co. is now a huge
empire of beauty, owning 25 major brands such as Bobbi Brown, MAC, Jo Malone, Clinique,
Creme de la Mer, Tom Ford and Origins and selling their products in 150 countries. Up until the
Great Recession in 2009, the company has registered a constant growth of sales and revenue.
During the Great Recession in 2009 and 2010 the company experienced a drop in the net sales
for the first time in its history. This period was followed by 5 years of accelerated growth when
the company closed 10 acquisitions adding them to the list of the 21 brands previously owned. It
was interesting to research the implementation of such bold strategic decision, to buy new
businesses and try to rise again, despite the decline in sales. To focus more, only the
acquisition of one business will be taken into consideration. That is why, this essay is going to
answer the question Why did Estee Lauder acquire Smashbox cosmetics in a year of reduced
financial performance?
3|Page
Analysis
1. RATIO Analysis 1
In order to provide a background information for the activity of the company, ratio analysis can be
performed. It will show historically the financial position of Estee Lauder before the acquisition of
Smashbox Cosmetics. Profitability, liquidity and efficiency ratios are going to be used to evaluate the
performance of the business.
Liquidity Ratios
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
The liquidity ratios graph shows how the current ratio registered a minimum point in the year 2012
followed by a more accelerated growth in the two following years. A low value of the current ratio
indicated that the company may find it more difficult to pay for the short term debts. In 2013 and 2014
the value of the ratio significantly increased reaching values of 2.22 and 2.43. Although the growth may
be beneficial for the company as it indicates high liquidity and capacity to pay short term debts in a
short period of time a higher value can implies that the company holds too much liquid money or stock
that could be otherwise used more efficiently. The quick ratio presents more constant values as opposed
to the current ratio suggesting that the discrepancies registered in the current ratio are caused by
inconsistencies in the amount of stock owned by the company.
4|Page
REVENUE
GROSS PROFIT
12,000.00
10,000.00
8,000.00
6,000.00
4,000.00
2,000.00
0.00
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
5|Page
Profitability Ratios
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
0 10 20 GPM 30
Series 3 40
Return 50
to asset 60to equity 70
Return 80 90
The profitability ratios show how the performance of the business increased gradually up until the year
2012 as all the ratios recorded higher values. In 2013 and 2014 the values of the ratios stagnated
registering very little change. The net profit margin especially, shows a bigger difference in values
growing from 6.47 to 8.99 between the 2010 and 2012. The growth is relatively larger than the growth
of the gross profit margin fact that indicates that the values of taxes and interest decreased during the
given time period.
Calculate % difference.
Leverage
6|Page
The Debt-to-Asset ratio shows an increase in the company’s ability to pay off debts by selling assets.
Before 2013 the company was more reliant on debt. However, in the last two years all the ratios
recorded a significant decrease proving a more efficient functioning of the company.
Activity
The ratio analysis shows that even though the company purchased companies after a period of financial
decrease, the performance of the business improved, all ratios indicating a positive development over
the years proving a good and efficient development of the business.
1. Competitors
Estee Lauder currently operates in a multitude of different branches of the cosmetics industry
fighting against well established companies. In the makeup segment the most important
7|Page
cosmetics market is quite wide presenting a somewhat limited range of products the competition
products that essentially serve the same purpose but are produced by different companies. For
this reason, in order to keep the stable position on the market, Estee lauder has to rely on
innovation and good marketing. Another important aspect is the presence of really old
companies. Brands such as Colgate-Palmolive which have been operating on the market for the
of loyal customers around the globe. Furthermore, one important disadvantage the company
has is that the majority of the competition offer range of products which are more affordable and
accessible to the average consumer. In order to keep the prestigious image of the company
Estee Lauder only presents more expensive products targeted at customers with medium to
existing cosmetics market is a quite competitive one. In the past decades the competitively
highly increased as many new brands appeared on the market. Estee Lauder had to adapt
throughout the years to the new trends, demographics and competitive brands.
As Estee Lauder markets its name as prestigious and only sells high priced products, the
competition, brands such as Loreal and Revlon are able to take advantage and introduce similar
products at lower prices. Taking as an example foundation, the products offered by Estee
Lauder and Loreal perform similarly but have completely different price points. Estee Lauder’s
catalog/makeup/face/foundations/double-wear/stay-in-place-makeup#/shade/0N1-Alabaster---Neutral-
(https://www.lorealparisusa.com/products/makeup/face/foundation-makeup/infallible-24-hour-fresh-
8|Page
wear-foundation-lightweight.aspx?shade=390-snow) These aspect has helped L’oreal to be a
market leader for many years, surpassing the sales of Estee Lauder. (https://www.loreal-
finance.com/en/annual-report-2018/cosmetics-market-2-1/)
In the past decade the cosmetics market has been an intensively competitive one. New firms
enter periodically trying to penetrate the market and attract customers. Brands such as Lush,
The Body Shop or Skin foods can represent a threat to the already established company
affecting their sales and profits. The new brands are often more appealing to the customers as
they enter with innovative ideas, lower prices or better quality products. A common
phenomenon is that once the customer is satisfied by the new product they will continue
Another threat is represented by old brands entering new markets where Estee Lauder is
operating. These brands that are already well known in other market segments will attract some
customers determining a decrease in the sales of Estee Lauder. Give an example of that.
In spite of the new threatening competition Estee Lauder manage to remain relevant on the
market by acquiring new brands under its name that appeal to the younger generations such as
MAC cosmetics or GlamGlow. Moreover, the company’s method of using celebrities to market
their products has also determined good sales performance. To write later on that perhaps this
was why estee lauder became successful again, because they acquired companies, which can
be added to their product portfolio, thus satisfying different price ranges and different needs.
9|Page
4. Bargaining power of consumers
Consumers play an important role on the market and the main goal of the company should be to
satisfy their needs. Estee Lauder is constantly doing market research in order to be able to
predict the products that the customers will search for in the future. In the past the company
predicted a drop in the number of young people interested in Estee Lauder products. For this
reason, the company purchased brands that attracted the younger generations such . Thus,
Smashbox was purchased in 2010, followed by Glamglow in 2015 and Too Faced in 2016.
The suppliers represent an important factor that determine the performance of the business in the
market as they can determine the quality of the products and the time of the production, one important
benefit of Estee Lauder is that it owns manufacturing facilities as well as its own delivering service in
some of the most important countries it operates in. This allows the company to have control over the
quality of their products and reduce the involvement of third party companies that may affect the
customer’s experience.
https://www.inc.com/news/articles/2010/05/estee-lauder-acquires-smashbox.html
10 | P a g e
The acquisition of Smashbox
The figure 1.1 shows all the brands owed by Estee Lauder as of 2015. Smashbox was the first
brand to be acquired after the great recession in 2010 when the company was experiencing a
decrease in net sales. Smashbox was well established on the market if you can write something
about the position of Smashbox on the market; for how much they bought it and Estee Lauder’s
acquisition further facilitated its growth. Smashbox’s position on the market and its entry-point
prices allowed Estee Lauder to develop the range of brands with are less luxurious appealing to
younger demographics. Furthermore, the company covered the market’s need for slightly
cheaper products due to the economic problems which were unfolding at the time.
Smashbox fitted into the Estee Lauder company, being a high-potential brand with a unique
identity and purpose which is conserved by the company. Throughout the years they managed
to spread evenly on the position map, their uniquely-positioned brands targeting a wide range of
customers. Estee Lauder’s main disadvantage is that unlike its most important competitors such
as Avon, L’oreal or Colgate-Palmolive, the company markets its products and brands as
prestigious, setting higher prices. Having in mind this aspect acquiring brands with a lower price
point but with a high quality that doesn’t affect the brands image was most probably an
adequate strategy. Perhaps they wanted to appeal to another market segment, plus to widen
their product portfolio.
11 | P a g e
Additionally, Smashbox’s position on the market was probably improved because of the enhanced
channels of distribution, like (or such as) furthermore favorable for Estee Lauder as the brand has fast
growing retail channels such as TV shopping and open-sell store formats such as Ulta or Sephora. This
retail method is more appealing to the younger demographics a market segment which is not attracted
by the most of Estee Lauder brands such as Clinique that has a very traditional products or Bobbi Brown
or Tom Ford Beauty that have more luxurious products and high prices. 2
Also, the company’s biggest competitor is MAC cosmetics a brand owned by Estee Lauder. The two
brands have a similar target market but have a different vision and approach to their products.
Therefore, the acquisition of Smashbox was advantageous as Estee Lauder could monopolize the sales in
that market segment.3
Estee Lauder’s branding strategy is based on prestige the company only selling high quality products and
working with well-known suppliers. The fact the company owns it one manufacturing facilities as well as
shipping services allows it to have total control and ensure the best quality of their products. Estee
Lauder owns manufacturing and/or production facilities all over the world in the most economically
developed areas of the geographical regions such as the western countries in Europe, Hong Kong, South
Korea or Japan in Asia and Rio de Janeiro in South America.
2
https://wwd.com/beauty-industry-news/beauty-features/estee-lauder-cos-to-aquire-smashbox-3075862/
3
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-esteelauder-smashbox/estee-lauder-to-buy-smashbox-makeup-brand-
idUSTRE64G4PN20100517
12 | P a g e
13 | P a g e
https://www.elcompanies.com/en/who-we-are/global-operations#/Manufacturing/Est%C3%A9e
%20Lauder%20Companies
To say something like, on this position map can be observed that Estee |Lauder has products in every
segment and give examples
14 | P a g e
Estee Lauder's Market Segmentation
By
By
By Category Distribution By Gender
Geography
Channel
Figure 3
As presented in Figure 3 Estee Lauder’s brands offer a wide range of high quality products, covering all
the cosmetics branches, and satisfying all the needs of the average customer. The products are
marketed as versatile and are presented in high quality packaging giving the customer the impression of
a good investment and raising the chances of people to by their products again and become loyal to the
company.
The company wants to position itself as The company insists on using only the most prestigious retailers
such as Sephora or Jo Malone in order to be associated with the highest standards and quality of
products4. The company also possesses websites for all their brands and runs multiple social media
accounts. Unlike its competitors such as L’Oréal, Estee Lauder does not sell its products in drugstores
and has higher prices that start from $25.
Finally, Estee Lauder operates in countries all around the world its main markets being The Americas,
Europe and the Middle East and Asia and Pacific. The company adapted to the different markets
acquiring specific brands from the area that are familiar to the demographics and satisfy the people’s
needs.
4
https://www.elcompanies.com/en/who-we-are/retail-channels/in-store-experiences
15 | P a g e
Furthermore, most of their production facilities are based in developed countries such as The
United States or Europe. In Africa, Asia and South America the company effectuates the
production process in the most economically developed countries of the area such as Chile,
South Korea and South Africa
Throughout the years Estee Lauder kept expanding the possessed range of brands following
the example of other strong competitors in the market. In the past decades L’Oréal was the
number one company on the market as it includes a high number of brands and incorporating a
wide range of prices targeting customers of all ages and wage level.
Much of Estee Lauder success is determined by the company’s ability to adapt to the ever-
changing market. An important strategy that helped Estee Lauder keep its relevancy are the
regular acquisition the company is making. Out of the total of 31 brands the company
possesses, ten, 32%, were purchased between the years 2010 and 2015. The brands
acquisitioned were Smashbox, Ermenegildo Zelna, Aerin, Osiao, Marni, Tory Burch, Rodin. All
of the brands purchased are producing high quality or luxurious products and were rising in
sales at the moment of the acquisition. Thus, Estee Lauder relies on external methods of growth
preferring to acquire the brands they are interested in taking control over their operations and
profits. This method of expansion is advantageous for the company as it can be done in a short
16 | P a g e
period of time. It seems they are acquiring well developed, profitable companies, which
immediately will bring more revenue and help in the growth and strength of the company.
PESTLE Analysis5
Estee Lauder benefited from a wide range of favorable factors since the beginning of the
company. The business started in New York, United States, an area with powerful economy
where the relatively high wages received by the average individual allowed them to invest on
more luxurious products. The economy of the countries where Estee lauder operates is
generally characterized by stability. The company’s profit dropped during the 2009 recession
marking the first time since the launch in 1946 when the company didn’t have a growth of net
sales. In 2011, after the recession passed and the economy retook its normal values the profits
of Estee Lauder started to grow again surpassing the highest point reached in 2008. Moreover,
the company had a possibility to put a patent and copyright over their products preventing the
competition from launching similar products increasing the competition on the market for Estee
Lauder.
capitalist economy of most of the states where the company operates is favorable for the
development of the business. After the expansion to Asia, the company introduced the business
to socialist economies. The expansion to these countries was further profitable as the
demographics and the already achieved brand recognition facilitated high sales.
Taking into consideration the social aspects, Estee Lauder benefits from a favorable
demographics all over the world. As the company has a very broad range of products many
generations of both women and men are targeted by the marketing campaigns and are loyal to
the business. As social media represents an important element of today’s society the publicity
brought by people with high numbers of followers further increased the sales. Social media has
5
http://fernfortuniversity.com/term-papers/pestel/nyse4/639-the-estee-lauder-companies-inc-.php
17 | P a g e
although certain disadvantages as people are able to bring bad reputation over some products
that may not satisfy their needs. In spite of the fact that the company is not vegan 6 or cruelty-
free, attributes requested in today’s American market Estee Lauder continues to support social
causes such as the most recent Viva Glam campaign started by the affiliate brand MAC
cosmetics that is raising funds for research regarding the development for AIDS treatment.
Finally, Estee Lauder had always been trying to keep up with the new technology. The
company was a pioneer in e-commerce, launching their first websites for the brands Clinique
and Bobbi Brown in 1996. Two years later a website containing all the company’s brands was
also introduced. The rapid adaptation to new technology has made the products more appealing
to the new generations. Over the last decades the rapid growth of technology represented a
challenge for the old, already established company. Estee Lauder however managed to remain
relevant purchasing new revolutionary brands (EXAMPLES) that kept the company relevant and
active on social media. Additionally, further technological advancements simplified the process
of production allowing the company to gain economies of scale and reduce the manual labor.
This process enhanced the profits as the company was able to spend less money on production
SWOT Analysis
An essential requirement for keeping the business on the top of the market is to constantly
consider the SWOT analysis making sure that the weaknesses don’t put the business at risk
and that the threats don’t create hazardous situations. Furthermore, the strengths and
Strengths Weaknesses
6
https://veganrabbit.com/brands/estee-lauder/
18 | P a g e
strong brand equity products portfolio is
distribution channels
techniques
reliable dealers
Opportunities Threats
Firstly, one essential aspect is that the company is benefiting from a wide range of strengths
that outnumber the weaknesses. The strong brand equity has been one of the most powerful
factors that determined the company’s success across the decades. The good quality products
marketed in an effective way with the support of celebrities provided the company with a
constant number of loyal customers. The company controls both the manufacture and the
distribution of their products which enables them to have a wider range of control and not rely
on third-party companies do deliver the products. This advantage decreases the margin of risk
as the company can ensure the means and conditions of transportation of their products making
sure they maintain the highest quality when reaching the customers or the retail stores. All these
aspects reflect in the company’s finances as Estee Lauder shows constant growth since it was
founded in 1946. The company is hence acknowledged by both competition and customers as
being at the top of the industry. Additionally, the brand has further gained recognition as it was
7
https://www.swotandpestle.com/estee-lauder/
19 | P a g e
associated with different public figures and started multiple humanitarian campaigns tackling
Moving forward to the weaknesses of the company, Estee Lauder demonstrates a significantly
low number of weak points that are managed adequately. Firstly, although the business is solely
specialized in the cosmetics industry, it has managed to spread its products across many types
of different clients. The brands owned by the company offer skincare, haircare, and makeup
products and are targeting a wide range of consumers both male and female and of different
generations. Therefore, although the company limited itself by operating only in the cosmetics
industry this clear focus has enabled them to master the market and to aim for the top.
Another aspect that may be considered a weakness is the fact that Estee Lauder remained a
family business for many years. in spite of the fact that this has allowed the owners to have
increased control over the company’s operations and finances, it has deprived them of external
points of view and ideas that could have revolutionized the company, as well as external
sources of finance. Although Estee Lauder was indeed a private limited for many years, the
company went public in 1995 the decision further accelerating the growth.
Furthermore, over the years the company managed to take advantage of its opportunities. The
expansion to Europe and later to Asia proved as highly profitable and marked turning points in
the history of the business. The company quickly adapted to the needs of the new market and
Conclusion
Estee Lauder is a really successful global makeup company that performed extremely well
throughout the years continuing to expand their existing brands but also acquiring new
20 | P a g e
companies that would expand its target market. The company has as its main disadvantage the
fact that unlike its most successful competitors such as L’Oréal it has a prestigious image to
keep restraining from selling cheap products or being involved exclusively with esteemed
retailers. In order to start being more appealing to the younger demographics the company
acquired brands such as Smashbox or GlamGlow that sell quality products that don’t affect the
company’s image but have lower prices than other cosmetic brands of the company such as
Bobbi Brown or Estee Lauder. Conclusively, the Smashbox acquisitions and the ones made in
the following years were favorable for the company that owns companies evenly distributed on
the position map (Figure 2). The acquisition of Smashbox help Estee Lauder to position itself in
a different quadrant in the Position map, thus appealing to a different market segment. It started
variation and it widened the portfolio of the company. Additionally, it helped in spreading the risk
of failure. In case some of the products or brands are not that successful, others might be, so
anyway they can bring revenue, which can cover some of the losses of other products or brands
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/marketing/a-strategic-analysis-of-estee-lauder-marketing-
essay.php
https://www.elcompanies.com/en/news-and-media/newsroom/press-releases/2009/08-13-2009
REFERENCES
Liquidity Ratios
21 | P a g e
Current Ratio: 2.03 1.98 1.89 1.81 2.22 2.43
Current assets /
current liabilities
Bicliography:
“The Estée Story.” – The Estée Lauder Companies Inc., 25 July 2017,
www.elcompanies.com/en/who-we-are/the-lauder-family/the-estee-story.
The Estée Lauder Companies Inc. Annual Report 2010 . 2010, The Estée Lauder Companies Inc.
Annual Report 2010 , www.elcompanies.com/en/investors/earnings-and-financials/annual-
reports.
22 | P a g e
“Estee Lauder SWOT Analysis / SWOT Matrix.” Essay48, Dec. 2018, www.essay48.com/term-
paper/12868-Estee-Lauder-Swot-Analysis.
23 | P a g e