Lecture 5F - SAARC PDF
Lecture 5F - SAARC PDF
• Despite the relationship between India and Pakistan, it is still a useful tool for
smaller countries to promote understanding and cooperation at the bilateral level.
Since 1985 SAARC has evolved slowly but continuously both in terms of institutions
and programs.
• But today this region is facing many issues like terrorism, poverty, deprivation of
food, drug trafficking, extremism, and economic crisis. These core issues cannot be
resolved at bilateral level. It is significant to have a joint effort and close
coordination among the member countries to solve these threatening issues.
Reasons of Failure of SAARC
• Weak Cultural Identities -The South Asian Region comprises countries
sharing common history, heritage and culture. The horrors of divisions and
sub-divisions have however created fissures. These fissures are commonly
articulated through the ideas of distinct cultures. Pakistan wants to assert
itself as Islamic State and calls India a Hindu State. The debates regarding
identity are similarly going on in Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. The pursuit of
maintaining distinct cultural identity by every country has not allowed the
region to come together.
• Rivalry between India and Pakistan, the two largest members of SAARC,
has hovered hugely on SAARC. The rivalry continues to restrain SAARC
from functioning as a sub-regional organization.
• SAARC Charter Article X(2) of the SAARC Charter mandates that decisions,
at all levels in SAARC, are only of multilateral issues, and only those issues
are for inclusion in the agenda in a SAARC summit meeting on the basis of
unanimity. The SAARC platform thus cannot be used to resolve bilateral
issues; this has undermined the scope and potential of SAARC.
Reasons of Failure of SAARC
• India is a preponderant country – both in terms of size and economy, in
the SAARC Region. India’s neighboring countries have often felt insecure
about India’s ambitions. Thus, any attempts to secure free trade area are
met with the concerns of Indian businesses disrupting the indigenous
business of countries. This in turn leads countries to use SAARC as an
anti-India platform.
• The region is still beset with many unresolved border and maritime issues.
These unresolved borders have led to problems of Terrorism, Refugee
Crisis, Smuggling, Narco-Trade. The unresolved issues continue to mar
cooperative relations.