Piping Design Part 2 PDF
Piping Design Part 2 PDF
Piping Design,
Part 2 —
Flanges
W. M. Huitt
W. M. Huitt Co. The engineer or designer must choose among
several flange options. Additional decisions involve
P
ipe flanges are used to me-
chanically connect pipe sections
to other pipe sections, inline facing and surface finishes, and the appropriate
components, and equipment.
Flanges also allow pipe to be assem- gaskets, bolts and nuts
bled and disassembled without cut-
ting or welding, which eliminates the Flanges are available with various and that the end of the pipe be reason-
need for those two operations when contact facings (the flange-to-flange ably close to the mating surface of the
dismantling is required. In providing contact surface) and methods of con- flange. Note that the term “reasonably
a breakable joint, however, flanges necting to the pipe itself. The flanges close” is taken, in context, from Annex
unfortunately provide a potential leak under B16.5, a standard widely rel- A of ASME B16.5; it is not quantified.
path for the process fluid contained in evant to the process industries, are In order to achieve this “reasonably
the pipe. Because of this, the usage of available in a variety of styles and close” requirement, the flange thread
flanges needs to be minimized where pressure classifications. The differ- has to be longer and the diameters of
possible, as with all other joints. ent styles, or types, are denoted by the smaller threads must be smaller
The most prevalent flange stan- the way each connects to the pipe than that indicated in ASME B1.20.1.
dards to be used in the process in- itself and/or by the type of face. The When installing threaded flanges
dustries are based on those of the types of pipe-to-flange connections Class 600 and higher, ASME B16.5
American Soc. of Mechanical Engi- include the following: recommends using power equipment
neers (ASME). These include: • Threaded to obtain the proper engagement. Sim-
B16.1 – Cast Iron Pipe Flanges and • Socket welding (or socket weld) ply using arm strength with a hand
Flanged Fittings • Slip-on welding (or slip on) wrench is not recommended.
B16.5 - Pipe Flanges and Flanged Fit- • Lapped (or lap joint) The primary benefit of threaded
tings (NPS 1/2 through NPS 24, • Welding neck (or weld neck) flanges is in eliminating the need for
where NPS is nominal pipe size; see • Blind welding. In this regard, these flanges
Part 1 of this series, CE, February, are sometimes used in high-pressure
pp. 42–47) Flange types service in which the operating temper-
B16.24 – Cast Copper Alloy Pipe Threaded: The threaded flange (Fig- ature is ambient. They are not suit-
Flanges and Flanged Fittings ure 1), through Class 400, is connected able where high temperatures, cyclic
B16.36 – Orifice Flanges to threaded pipe in which the pipe conditions or bending stresses can be
B16.42 – Ductile Iron Pipe Flanges thread conforms to ASME B1.20.1. potential problems.
and Flanged Fittings For threaded flanges in Class 600 and Socketweld: The socketweld flange is
Large Diameter Steel Flanges (NPS* higher, the length through the hub of made so that the pipe is inserted into
26 through NPS 60) the flange exceeds the limitations of the socket of the flange until it hits
B16.47 – Large Diameter steel flanges ASME B1.20.1. ASME B16.5 requires the shoulder of the socket. The pipe is
(NPS 26 through NPS 60) that when using threaded flanges in then backed away from the shoulder
Class 600 or higher, Schedule 80 or approximately 1/16 in. before being
*NPS, indicated above, is an acronym for Nomi-
nal Pipe Size. heavier pipe wall thickness be used, welded to the flange hub.
56 Chemical Engineering www.che.com March 2007
3 3
0
0
5ISFBEFE
4MJQPO
Figure 1. Threaded flanges need not be welded Figure 3. Slip-on flanges offer an initial lower cost
9 9
# #
%
$
5
S $ 5
#
3
0 0
4PDLFUXFME -BQKPJOU
Figure 2. Socketweld flanges have been commonly used Figure 4. A lap-joint flange can yield savings in material
for small pipe sizes costs
If the pipe were resting against the room to make the internal
shoulder (this is the flat shelf area fillet weld without damag- -FOHUI -FOHUI -FOHUI
depicted in Figure 2 as the differ- ing the flange face. UO UO UO
ence between diameters B and B2) of The slip-on flange is a pre-
the socket joint during welding, heat ferred flange for many appli-
0% 0% 0%
from the weld would expand the pipe cations because of its initial
longitudinally into the shoulder of the lower cost, the reduced need
socket, forcing the pipe-to-flange weld for cut length accuracy and S S S
U U U
area to move. This could cause the the reduction in end prep - - -
weld to crack. time. However, the final in- 5ZQF" 5ZQF# 5ZQF$
The socketweld flange was initially stalled cost is probably not
developed for use on small size, high- much less than that of a
pressure piping in which both a back- weld-neck flange.
side hub weld and an internal shoul- The strength of a slip- "/4* "/4*
der weld was made. This provided a on flange under internal 4MJQPO MBQKPJOU
GMBOHF GMBOHF
static strength equal to the slip-on pressure is about 40% less
flange (discussed below), with a fa- than that of a weld-neck
tigue strength 1.5 times that of the flange, and the fatigue rate 5ZQFT#BOE$ 5ZQFT"
slip-on flange. is about 66% less. The slip- UZQF$TIPXO
9
"
# : $
$ 3
3 0
0 #MJOE
8FMEJOHOFDL
Figure 6. Weld-neck flanges are highly versatile Figure 7. Blind flanges are commonly used to cap off pipe-
line ends
is used to accommodate the slip-on loading, either cryogenic or elevated sification was changed to the class
flange or plate flange as a back-up temperatures, the weld-neck flange designation. These designations have
flange. is essential. no direct correlation with pounds of
Type C is fabricated from pipe using Blind: While the blind flange (Fig- pressure. Rather, they are a factor in
five suggested methods indicated in ure 7) is used to cap off the end of the pressure rating calculation found
ASME B31.3. The most prevalent a pipeline or a future branch con- in B16.5. In a subsequent part of this
of these is the machine flare. This nection, it is also used for other pur- series, we will discuss how these des-
method consists of placing a section poses. It can be drilled and tapped ignations are factored into the design
of pipe into a flaring machine, flaring for a threaded reducing flange or of the flange.
the end of the pipe and then cutting machined out for a slip-on reducing Flanges, whether manufactured to
it to length. flange. The reduced opening can be ASME, API (American Petroleum In-
As you can see in the assembly de- either on-center or eccentric. stitute), MSS (Manufacturer’s Stan-
tail of Figure 5, stub-end Types B & C dardization Soc.), AWWA (American
have no radius at the flare, while Type Flange pressure ratings Water Works Assn.) or any other stan-
A does. This allows Type A to conform ASME B16.5 flange pressure ratings dard, are grouped into pressure rat-
to the lap-joint flange. Due to the ra- have been categorized into material ings. In ASME, these pressure ratings
dius of the Type A stub end, a slip-on groupings. These groupings are for- are a sub-group of the various mate-
flange would have a poor fit, creating mulated based on both the material rial groups designated in B16.5.
non-uniform loading of the flare face composition and the process by which Tables 1 and 2 in this article break
as well as an undesirable point load at the flange is manufactured. out information from the Table 2 se-
the radius of the flare. The available pressure Classifica- ries in ASME B16.5. The Table 2 se-
Weld neck: The reinforcement area tions under ASME B16.5 are: 150, ries is a series of tables that list the
of the weld-neck flange (Figure 6) dis- 300, 400, 600, 900, 1500 and 2500. The working pressures of flanges based
tinguishes it from other flanges. This correct terminology for this designa- on material groupings, temperature
reinforcement area is formed by the tion is Class 150, Class 300, and so on. and classification.
added metal thickness, which tapers The term 150 pound, 300 pound and There are 34 such tables, segregated
from the hub of the flange to the weld so on is a carryover from the old ASA into three material categories: carbon
end. The bore of the flange needs to be (American Standards Association) and low alloy steels, austenitic stain-
specified in order to obtain the same Classification. ASA is the precursor to less steels, and nickel alloys. These are
wall thickness at the weld end as the the American National Standards In- further segregated into more defined
pipe it will be welded to. This will give stitute (ANSI).* material sub-groups. Tables 1 and 2
it the same ID bore as the pipe. Development of ASME B16.5 began of this article show Table 2-1.1 from
The weld-neck flange is the most in 1920. In 1927 the American Tenta- B16.5, which indicates, in reverse
versatile flange in the ASME stable tive Standard B16e was approved. sequence, Subcategory 1 of Material
of flanges. Much of its use is for fit- This eventually became what we group 1 (carbon and low alloy steels).
ting-to-fitting fabrication, in which know today as ASME B16.5. Until the If you had an ASME B16.5, Class
the flange can be welded directly to a 1960s, the pressure classifications, 150, ASTM A105 flange, this is the
fitting, such as an elbow, without the as addressed earlier, were referred table you would use to determine the
need for a short piece of pipe, as would to as 150 pound, 300 pound, etc. It working pressure limit of the flange.
be required with a slip-on flange. It was at this point the pressure clas- To find the working pressure of the
can be used in low-pressure, non-haz- *ANSI was founded as a committee whose responsibility was to coordinate the development of stan-
ardous fluid services as well as high- dards and to act as a standards traffic cop for the various organizations that develop standards. Its
basic function is not to develop standards, but rather to provide accreditation of those standards
pressure, high-cyclic and hazardous Originating as the American Engineering Standards Committee (AESC) in 1918, ANSI had, over
fluid services. its first ten years, outgrown its Committee status and in 1928 was reorganized and renamed as the
American Standards Association (ASA). In 1966 the ASA was reorganized again under the name of
While the initial cost of the weld- the United States of America Standards Institute (USASI). In 1969 ANSI adopted its present name.
neck flange may be higher than that While the B16 and B31 Standards have previously carried the ASA and ANSI prefix with its vari-
ous standards titles, ASME has always been the administrative sponsor in the development of those
of a slip-on flange, the installed cost standards. In the 1970s the prefix designation changed to ANSI/ASME and finally to ASME.
Referring to ANSI B16. or ANSI B31. is no longer correct. Instead, it is correct to refer to a standard
reduces that differential. And for as ANSI/ASME B16. in that it indicates an ANSI-accredited ASME standard. Or one can simply refer
conditions of possible high thermal to the standard as ASME B16. or ASME B31.
surface finish with an average rough- C-Si A 105 (1) A 216 Gr. WCB (1) A 515 Gr. 70 (1)
ness of 125 × 10–6 in. to 250 × 10–6 C-Mn-Si A 350 Gr. LF2 (1) A 516 Gr. 70 (1)(2)
in. The cutting tool used for the ser- A 537 Cl. 1 (3)
rations will have a 0.06 in. or larger Notes: (1) Upon prolonged exposure to temperature above 800°F, the carbide phase of steel may
be converted to graphite. Permissible, but not recommended for prolonged use above 800°F.
radius, and there should be from 45 to (2) Not to be used over 850°F (3) Not to be used over 700°F
55 grooves per inch.
Table 2. Working Pressures by classes, psig
Bolts, nuts and gaskets Temp., °F Class
Sealing of the flange joint and the 150 300 400 600 900 1,500 2,500
hygienic-clamp joint (as discussed -20 to 100 285 740 990 1,480 2,220 3,705 6,170
last month in Part 1) is paramount 200 260 675 900 1,350 2,025 3,375 5,625
in providing integrity to the overall 300 230 655 875 1,315 1,970 3,280 5,470
piping system. This is achieved with 400 200 635 845 1,270 1,900 3,170 5,280
the use of bolts, nuts and gaskets. 500 170 600 800 1,200 1,795 2,995 4,990
Making the right selection for the 600 140 550 730 1,095 1,640 2,735 4,560
application can mean the difference 650 125 535 715 1,075 1,610 2,685 4,475
between a joint with integrity and 700 110 535 710 1,065 1,600 2,665 4,440
one without. 750 95 505 670 1,010 1,510 2,520 4,200
ASME B16.5 provides a list of ap- 800 80 410 550 825 1,235 2,060 3,430
propriate bolting material for ASME 850 65 270 355 535 805 1,340 2,230
flanges. The bolting material is 900 50 170 230 345 515 860 1,430
grouped into three strength catego- 950 35 105 140 205 310 515 860
ries — high, intermediate and low 1,000 20 50 70 105 155 260 430
— that are based on the minimum
yield strength of the specified bolt adequate strength to maintain joint • Fluid service compatibility will help
material. tightness.” B31.3 additionally states in determine the most suitable gasket
The high-strength category in- Paragraph 309.2.3, “…If either flange material.
cludes bolt material with a minimum is to the ASME B16.1 (cast iron), ASME The critical nature of the fluid will
yield strength of not less than 105 B16.24 (cast copper alloy), MSS SP- determine the degree of integrity re-
kilopounds per square inch (ksi). The 42 (valves with flanged and buttweld quired in the joint. This requirement
intermediate-strength category in- ends), or MSS SP-51 (cast flanges and will help determine bolt strength
cludes bolt material with a minimum fittings) specifications, the bolting ma- and material as well as gasket type
yield strength of between 30 ksi and terial shall be no stronger than low • Environmental conditions (corrosive
105 ksi. The low-strength category in- yield strength bolting unless: (a) both atmosphere, wash-down chemicals,
cludes bolt material with a minimum flanges have flat faces and a full face other) will also help determine the
yield strength no greater than 30 ksi. gasket is used: or, (b) sequence and best bolt material
As defined in ASME B16.5, the torque limits for bolt-up are specified, In short, all of the variables that come
high-strength bolting materials “. . . . with consideration of sustained loads, together in making up a flange-joint
may be used with all listed materials displacement strains, and occasional specification have to do so in a com-
and all gaskets.” The intermediate- loads (see Paragraphs. 302.3.5 and plementary fashion. Simply selecting
strength bolting materials “. . . . may 302.3.6), and strength of the flanges.” a gasket based on material selection
be used with all listed materials and In specifying flange bolts, as well as and not taking into account the pres-
all gaskets, provided it has been veri- the gasket, it is necessary to consider sure rating requirement could provide
fied that a sealed joint can be main- not only design pressure and temper- a gasket that would get crushed under
tained under rated working pressure ature but also fluid service compat- necessary torque requirements rather
and temperature”. The low-strength ibility, the critical nature (if any) of than withstand the bolt load and cre-
bolting materials “. . . . may be used the fluid service, and environmental ate a seal.
with all listed materials but are lim- conditions, all in conjunction with one Selecting a low-strength bolt to be
ited to Class 150 and Class 300 joints,” another. To aid in understanding the used with a Class 600 flange joint with
and can only be used with selected relationships among these criteria, proper gasketing will require the bolts
gaskets as defined in ASME B16.5. some clarification follows: to be torqued beyond their yield point,
ASME B31.3 further clarifies in • The design pressure and tempera- or, at the very least, beyond their elas-
Paragraph 309.2.1, “Bolting having ture jointly determine the pressure tic range. To explain this briefly, bolts
not more than 30 ksi specified mini- class of a flange set. That in turn, act as springs when they are installed
mum yield strength shall not be used along with flange size, will deter- and loaded properly. In order for the
for flanged joints rated ASME B16.5 mine the number and size of the flange joint to maintain a gasket seal,
Class 400 and higher, nor for flanged flange bolts. The flange class will it requires dynamic loading. Dynamic
joints using metallic gaskets, unless also determine the compressibility loading of flange bolts allows expan-
calculations have been made showing range of the gasket material sion and contraction movement in and
60 Chemical Engineering www.che.com March 2007
XXXDIFDPN
5IFXFCTJUFGPS$1*1SPGFTTJPOBMT
The Flow-Sentry Crusher is a
XXXDIFDPNPGGFST versatile heavy-duty, in-line
M"DDFTTUPUIFNPTUSFDFOUJTTVFPG$& machine designed to reduce
oversized lumps as they travel through
M$&"SDIJWFToFWFSZBSUJDMFQVCMJTIFE liquid, slurry or powder piping systems.
JO$&GSPNUIFQBTUZFBST The patented design works well in pressure,
M$&/FXTMFUUFST
gravity or pneumatic applications.
M$&8FCJOBST
Visit us at www.gocrushers.com or contact an ACC representative for additional
information on our complete line of standard crushers or to discuss a custom
M*OEVTUSZFWFOUJOGPSNBUJPO design suitable for your company’s unique requirements.
M"OENVDINPSF CHEMICALS & PETROCHEMICALS • FOOD PROCESSING • PULP & PAPER
PHARMACEUTICALS • PLASTICS AND MORE
'PSNPSFJOGPSNBUJPODPOUBDU+PIO4USB[[B
BU
KTUSB[[B!DIFDPN
XXXDIFDPN
ATLANTIC COAST CRUSHERS, INC
MANUFACTURERS OF PROCESS MACHINERY
128 Market Street • Kenilworth, New Jersey 07033
Phone: 908-259-9292 • Fax: 908-259-9280
www.gocrushers.com
Circle 35 on p. 78 or go to adlinks.che.com/6893-35
#% 7EB (OUSE !DINDD
Chemical Engineering www.che.com March 2007
!-
61