Language & Humanity
Language & Humanity
and
Humanity
S.G. Punchihewa
S.G.Punchihewa
Attorney - at - law
1
LANGUAGE AND HUMANITY
2
FOREWORD
We were embroiled in a devastating war for thirty
long years. Our habit of not honouring the Tamil
Language deems to be the cause for such war. At
the beginning , due to the suppression of demands,
demonstrations and agitations, the resolving of the
problem was assigned to gun powder. Through
this, we have destroyed the human, material and
intellectual resources which belonged to all races of
our country is an unusual way. But the worst of all
is that we have eliminated our humanity.
S.G.Punchihewa.
3
4
CONTENTS
Language and Humanity 7
British Rule 11
The habit of neglect and its history 23
Discrimination as reported by the Soulbury Report 31
Kandyan Convention – 1815 (2nd March) 33
Fundamental Rights 36
Official Languages 38
Language of the Judiciary 45
Implementation of the Official Language Policy 47
A few Circulars issued for purpose of implementation of
Official Language Policy 51
The Ministry for implementing the Language Policy 56
66
Filing a case before the Magistrates Courts
Human Rights Declaration and Language 69
5
6
PART I
7
like ‘Amma’ and ‘Home’ . When we are ill or
unhappy, it is the mother who suffers.
Through her suffering we are healed. When
we felt insecure or frightened, we used to
hide in her bosom for protection.
8
have grown up along with the language.
Hence it is through this language we express
all that is needed for our growth. Our
humaneness is expressed in our own
language. If we could discern the fact that
while humanity is a common factor for all
of us but the languages are different from
one another, then we will understand that
we have to honour another’s language as
his humaneness is inseparable from his
language. Only then his humaneness will be
expressed. To honour another’s language is
the right owned by him to use and practice
that language. The satisfaction we get by
honouring that right is really the right of that
other person. Every one will get entitled to
peace and prosperity only when such an
environment prevails.
Honouring his
When such right of honouring is denied, language is
what will be felt by the person, who speaks honouring him.
Disrespect
that language ? He will feel that his mother,
towards his
his self and the fact that he is a human being language is
has been disregarded. When he is obstructed disrespecting
or hindered, his emotional world gets him.
9
disturbed. It hurts his soul. It instigates anger
and hatred. So, is it a wonder that solving of
this problem created by pushing a certain
group of the community through a span of
a large number of years( even up to date )
towards a language grievance, got assigned
to gun powder ? That is how our country
had to face a prolonged war of thirty years,
the cause of which was a language issue. It
is true that the war has now stopped. But
no one has won. If we are to win, we have
to start with the language issue in the first
We have place. If any further discrimination happens
faced a thirty to either Sinhala or Tamil languages by
year long war,
the cause for
implementation of administrative or
which was the executive actions, it will be another act of
disrespect for collecting gun powder. That is how an
a language. administrative or executive act, a word or
War has something neglected, will eventually get
stopped. But
there are no
converted to explosives with the passage of
victors. Both time.
parties can win
if the language
is honoured.
10
British Rule
11
Even though British administration agreed
to change the cruel administration by
Lankan aristocrats, with the passage of time
people were of the view that they should
be rid of British rule. By that time British
in 1948 , we domination had spread in to all the spheres
got a certain
in Lanka. The Media of language in some of
degree of
Independence. the spheres is as follows.
Until then ,
English Before After
Language was
1948 1948
the official
language of Official Language English English,
the country. Sinhala
After the
Independence, Administration English English,
we were freed Sinhala
from the
Executive English English,
English
language too. Sinhala
Then the Law English English
Sinhala and
Tamil should Higher Education English Sinhala
have been Military rule English English,
declared the Sinhala
official
languages. Did Police English English
that happen ?
12
According to Colebrook Commission Report,
Lanka came under a single central
administration in 1831. Accordingly,
administration throughout the country was
done in English Medium. English was the
only Official Language.
It was stated that the purpose was to make
it easier in administration. Due to this,
Sinhala and Tamil languages were driven
away from the government and got cornered
in the villages. British rule extended for 117
years up to 1948. due to the domination by
Though we
British and their language, we the natives
became
lost more than what we gained. The attitude independent of
for recognition of language is one such loss. British
The natives, both from Sinhala and Tamil domination , we
communities who were educated in English did not become
Language were found suitable for independent of
administration. As the use of English domination by
language was convenient to them, even in English
politics, Sinhala and Tamil languages got language.
isolated. Executive and Legislative Councils Hence both the
Sinhala and
established after the Colebrook
Tamil
Commission, functioned in English. Whilst languages were
the proceedings of the State Council was neglected.
13
carried out in English, in 1932 a new
resolution was submitted by the Mr. G.K.W.
Perera, Member for Matara –
“ In accordance with the Standing Order 105,
the proceedings of the Council should be in
English. But a member could speak in Sinhala
or Tamil with due permission.”
The committee appointed to review this
resolution, rejected it. However, on the
second reading it was adopted with a
majority of votes. But this concession was
used very sparsely by Sinhala or Tamil
Members.
Mr. G.K.W.Perera, Member for Matara
even though a submitted a number of resolutions that are
resolution was very much appropriate for today, even after
adopted in the
50 years.
State Council
to say that They are :
speeches
could be made “ No person should be appointed to civil or
in Sinhala or clerical service without an advanced
Tamil knowledge in Sinhala or Tamil language”
language, it
“ Promotions should not be granted to
was used very
officers in civil and clerical services if he has
rarely.
14
failed to obtain the Sinhala or Tamil
Language proficiency. “
“ No person should be appointed as a judge
in the Police Courts or in any Higher Court if
he cannot conduct or report the court
proceedings in either Sinhala or Tamil
Language “
“Permission should be granted to lawyers
to engage in courts activities in either Sinhala
or Tamil Language “
These resolutions were submitted to the
Secretary General and Attorney General. But
in 1935, the State Council was dissolved.
Hence these issues were avoided. The art of Though there
avoiding important issues which prevails at were
present, started then with avoiding of the resolutions for
proficiency in
above resolutions.
national
A new State Council was elected in 1936. The languages and
next person to raise the issue regarding the for conducting
use of Sinhala – Tamil Languages was court
Mr.Philip Gunawardane, Member for proceedings in
Avissawella. His resolutions is as follows, national
languages ,
“ To avoid the inconvenience and injustice they were not
caused to the people in Courts when implemented.
15
questions and answers are translated
erroneously, the proceedings in the
Municipal Courts and Police Courts should
be conducted in native languages” (1937)
That is :
16
The third attempt to use the native
languages was made by Mr.J.R.Jayawardane,
then Member for Kelaniya. The resolution
submitted on 22.06.1943 in as follows :
“ Due to the objections raised for adopting
Sinhala Language as the official language
within a justifiable period of time, the
following resolutions are submitted :
∗ Sinhala should be the medium of
education in schools.
In 1944 ,
∗ Sinhala Language should be compulsory
another
for all government examinations.
resolution was
∗ Legislation should be adopted to carry adopted. It was
on the proceedings in the State Council that the State
in Sinhala Language too. Council
proceedings
∗ A Commission should be appointed to
should be in
select the books written in other national
languages to be translated in to Sinhala languages. The
Language. national
· A Commission should be appointed to languages
decide on the steps needed to change should be the
medium of
from English language to Sinhala
education in
language. schools.
17
Mr.C.W.W.Kannangara proposed the
amendment that the words “Sinhala
Language” should be replaced by ‘Mother
Tongue’.
The amendment proposed by Mr.V.Nalliah
to include ‘Tamil Language’ along with the
Sinhala language was accepted by the
Council. The resolution with the amendments
was adopted on 04.05.1944. A select
committee was appointed with Secretary
General of the State Council, Mr.Philip
Gunawardana and Mr.J.R.Jayawardana. The
select committee proposed as follows :
∗ Sinhala and Tamil should be Official
Languages.
the resolution Thereafter State Council adopted are
that Sinhala following resolutions(1945)
and Tamil
languages ∗ Mother tongue should be the medium
should be of education in the primary schools and
official English should be a compulsory subject.
languages was
adopted in the ∗ In the post primary schools, the
State Council medium of education could be English,
on 04.05.1944. Sinhala or Tamil or bilingual.
18
The proposal put forth by Mr.J.R. Jayawardana
in this regard was defeated. It says :
19
freedom that was accomplished could have
been more meaningful to achieve such
freedom. Even now, it is quite clear that the
change which took place was very much
superficial and has no depth. However, who
toiled hard to get this ‘Freedom’? They are
the Sinhalese, Tamil and Muslim population.
They had the idea of ‘Swaraj’ or
‘Independent State’ within them. As a
Who were result, a limited freedom was granted in
those engaged 1948. It was the duty of the Sinhalese Tamils
in the struggle and Muslims to complete the freedom they
for limited
got. But a very unfortunate thing happened.
independence
in 1948 ? it was Sinhalese who had more power tended to
the Sinhala , forget that the administration should be
Tamil and done through both Sinhala and Tamil
Muslim
Languages. They were keen to show that the
population. But
the Sinhala Sinhalese have acquired all the powers.
language got Accordingly, the idea that Sinhala Language
the place held should be the official language emerged. The
by English power and status enjoyed by the English
language. Tamil
language under the British rule was legally
language was
forgotten. transferred to Sinhala Language after 1948.
20
Accordingly Sinhala Language was legally
adopted as the official language by the Act
No : 33 of 1956. Tamil and Muslim leaders
who were together with the Sinhala leaders
in their struggle against British rule and the
domination of English language, were
deeply hurt and disgusted to see how
ungrateful the Sinhala leaders were. If this
situation was understood by Sinhala leaders
both the Tamil and Sinhala Languages should
have been declared Official Languages. We
are still facing the unpleasant consequences
of this default. Even though Sinhala
the problem
Language was legally adopted as the official which exists up
language, it was subservient to English to date is that
language for many more years. The no action was
domination acquired by over the Sinhala taken to allay
the feeling of
Language gave certain powers to Sinhala hurt in the
Language. In turn those powers of Tamil and
domination were exerted over the Tamil Muslim people
Language. This is the problem that exists caused by
forgetting the
even today.
Tamil
language.
21
However much there could be legislations,
Regulations, Circulars, they will not get
implemented correctly in the absence of
required willingness, intent or discipline. As
a nation, such quality should be a
component of our national culture. For this
to happen, the usage of our language should
be popular in the spheres like education, law
and politics. If it does not happen, the
violation of the usage of language is not
considered as a fault. If the state
administration does not consider the non
provision of necessary resources and
concessions to the using of a language as a
even if there
are plenty of
severe fault or stress, could there be a
laws and national unity in such a society?
regulations and
circulars,
without the
concern and
commitment to
correct the
wrong, could
there be
national amity?
22
The habit of neglect
and its history
23
religion or ethnic group, should not
be imposed upon the persons
belonging to another religion or
another ethnic group.
24
∗ Tamil Language should be the language
medium for Government Tamil schools.
[ 2(1) ]
∗ The examinations for selecting Tamil
persons to Government service should
be conducted in Tamil Language. [ 2 (2) ]
25
With the adoption of Sinhala Language as
official language in 1956 and the non
implementation of the Tamil Language
Usage Act in 1958, Tamil government officers
were directed to acquire Sinhala proficiency
within a stipulated time period (3 years). If
such proficiency is not acquired, salary
increments were stopped. A government
officer, Mr. Kodeswaran filed a case in the
District Court of Colombo challenging that
punishment meted out for not obtaining the
Sinhala proficiency is inconsistent with the
Constitution of the country. Mr.
Kodeswaran won the case. The government
Mr. made an appeal to Court of Appeal against
Kodeswaran this judgment which dismissed the ruling of
won the case
the District Court. Mr. Kodeswaran, then
he field against
the provision
appealed to the Privy Council in Britain,
that Tamil where it was ruled that section 29(2) of the
public servants Constitution has been violated. The
should obtain judgment was received only in 1970. Instead
Sinhala of granting the language rights of the Tamil
language
government officers, the government
proficiency
within 3 years.
committed a historical error. The thinking
26
was that if we are to be rid of British
bondages, we should be rid of the Privy
Council too. Giving way to the surging
nationalistic feelings, Lanka (Ceylon) became In 1972, when
Sri Lanka
a Republic. What is the historical error that
became a
was committed in this process ? Republic, the
* 1972 – Buddhism was declared as the State verdict that
was given
Religion by the 6th Constitution.
favoring
* 1972 – Sinhala Language which was Kodeswaran
declared as the Official Language by Act No: was subdued
and a historical
33 of 1956 was redeclared and adopted as
error was also
the Official language by the 7th Constitution. committed.
Sinhala
Both the above Constitutions are strictly
language which
against section 29(2) of the former was stated as
Constitution. the official
language by an
Accordingly will it not hurt the feelings of
Act was
those who follow another religion and use included in to
another language ? There were two Acts the
pertaining to Tamil Language provisions Constitution
adopted in 1966. Along with the 1972 legally.
Constitution, the practice of those Acts was Buddhism
became the
abandoned. When Acts pertaining to
State religion.
27
Languages turned in to misdeeds, the
struggle for Language became an armed
struggle. One of the solutions offered was
the acceptance of the Tamil Language as an
official Language in 1987.
Still the act of ‘not doing’ continued further.
In 1991 Official Language Commission was
appointed as one of the solutions. Later this
Commission was brought under the
Ministry of Constitutional Affairs and
National Integration. At present it is assigned
to the Ministry of National Languages and
Social Integration which has a different set
of nomenclature and subjects and a new
Language mode of operation.
struggle
transformed in The report of the Official Languages
to an armed Commission issued in June, 2005 provides
struggle. As a strong evidence to say that there was
consequence, discrimination against Tamil Language
Tamil Language through administrative and executive
was also actions as mentioned in the Soulbury
declared as an
Commission Report, and that such
official
language in discrimination continued up to 2005. It is
1987. as follows.
28
“ those Divisional Secretary Divisions which
are directed to function in both Sinhala and
Tamil languages, have so far failed to offer
satisfactory services to people who use
Tamil Language.” (page 05)
29
Hence the injustices caused by the
Administration and the Executive cannot be
remedied by laws alone. It has to be done
with our conscience and through our actions.
If we love all the mankind, the language that
understands that love does not have figures,
sounds or words. If the language is to be
considered a tool to suppress, discriminate
The injustice and suspect others, we are simply inviting
caused by
Administration
the people and humanity to engage in
and Executive conflicts and calamities. Time is now long
cannot be lapsed to change this behaviour.
changed by
laws alone. We
need a
procedural
arrangement to
change our
mode of
thinking. This is
delegated to
the “Ministry of
National
Languages and
Social
Integration”
30
PART II
Discrimination as reported
by the Soulbury Report
31
“ If there is any discrimination against a
minority population, it happens through
administrative actions: it is because that
such actions cannot be easily
comprehended or revealed.”
Non
implementation
of laws
which was a
condition
that
prevailed
before 100
years, still
prevails, at
present.
32
Kandyan Convention
1815 (2nd March)
33
Among a host of other issues, the above
conditions were put in to practice. It is
certain that common people were happy to
accept these conditions. They were relieved
that they are now free from painful corporal
punishments, fines etc.
34
hands of the King and the aristocrats which
made people to enjoy the British rule.
35
Fundamental Rights
36
higher degree than usual. It means
that justice is not meted out in an
equal manner. A person has to get
subjected to that discrimination. It
should be done either by a
government institution or an officer.
37
Official Languages
Constitution 18
38
Language. (Link language) to be
used)
39
(II) Any person can receive education
through the medium of language of his
choice. (Constitution 21) ( But this rule
does not apply to a school which uses
another language for purpose of
education. eg. International schools )
40
East, Sinhala Language is the administrative
language in the rest of the Island.
41
(Nuwara Eliya) - Ambagamuwa,
Hanguranketha, Kothmale, Nuwara Eliya,
Walapane
(Puttalam) - Kalpitiya,Mundel,Puttalam,
Wanathawilluwa
( Galle ) - Galle Kadawathsathara
With all such declarations, discrimination
against language still continues. The reasons
are the absence of necessary facilities and
the attitudes of the officers concerned.
But, according to the law regarding the
administrative language, people have the
right –
(I) To communicate by letters written
either in Tamil language or English
language,
42
document has been signed by that
person. [Constitution 22 (2) a– d]
[Constitution 22 (3)]
43
Constitution 22 (5) –
Constitution 23
44
However, all the orders, publications,
regulations, interim constitutions,
directives, notices and announcements and
the gazettes which are issued under a certain
written law, should be published in both the
official languages, Sinhala and Tamil along
with an English translation [23 (2)]
Written law,
Notices and
the Gazette
should be
published in all
the three
languages.
45
Language of the Judiciary
46
But the lawyer who initiates the judicial
proceedings could present the case in either
Sinhala or Tamil language. [24 (2)]. However
the use of such practice is very rare. Such
practice receives a poor response in the
judicial environment.
All the
proceeding of
the Court of
Appeal and the
Supreme Court
are still
conducted in
English
language.
47
Implementation of the
Official Language Policy
48
whilst an Additional Head or the Deputy
shall be in charge of implementation.
49
7. In the case of Urban Councils and
Divisional Councils, the Secretary to the
council holds the responsibility whilst
the Administrative Officers shall
implement the policy.
50
(d) That steps have been taken to eliminate
any obstructions for implementation of
the plans;
51
(c) That there is a definite procedure for
the implementation, monitoring and
evaluation of the Official Language
Policy.
The relevant
information
should be
submitted to
the Ministry, to
the
Commissioner
and to the
Chairman of
the Official
Language
Commission.
52
A few Circulars issued for
purpose of implementation
of Official Language Policy
53
∗ That letters written in Tamil Language
do not get the replies in the same
language, and there are complaints in
this regard.
∗ That action should be taken as
follows ;
I Replies to letters written in
Sinhala, Tamil or English should
receive the replies in the same
language.
II If the officers concerned does not
have the required knowledge in
that language, a translation should
be sent.
II General instructions like Circulars
should be issued in all three
Still there are
languages.
complaints to If action has not been taken while
say that letters all the necessary facilities are
sent in Tamil
available, there should be a
language are
punishment. The government shall
not replied in
the same be responsible if the facilities are
language. not available.
54
Public Administration
Circular No: 7 / 2007 / 1
This has drawn attention to the Circular No:
07 /2007 dated 2007.05.28 issued
previously.
55
Hence it became a condition to be fulfilled
on entry to public service.
Other Circulars
56
The Cabinet of Ministers has taken a decision
in this regard on 2008.04.09 Accordingly,
introducing theme of government projects
should be done in Sinhala Tamil and English
for which assistance could be sought from
Official Languages Department.
There is a
cabinet
decision to say
that
introductory
passages of all
government
projects should
be in all three
languages.
57
The Ministry for
implementing
the Language Policy
58
∗ Relevant factors for preparation of
National Language Policies and its
operation.
59
∗ To introduce modern technology for
training in languages.
∗ To arrange examinations and
relevant certificates.
2. Official Languages Commission
The This was established by the Act 1991 /
Department 18. the objective of the Commission is
and the to inquire and monitor whether action
Commission is being taken in conformity to the
are vested with
provisions of chapter VÉ of the
the
responsibility Constitution.
to impart The functions of the Commission are :
training for ∗ To take the responsibility of
achieving
implementing the official languages
proficiency in
as a Fundamental Right.
all three
languages, and ∗ Evaluation, encouragement of the
to ensure that official languages and to accept the
official status, equality, and the right to
language practice them.
policy is
implemented Shall continue to maintain
considering it statusquo.
as a ∗ To inquire in to the complaints
Fundamental made by citizens by the Commission
Right. itself and to remedy the situation.
60
3. National Languages Education and
Training Institute (Agalawatte)
Objectives
61
∗ To conduct special training courses for
languages, translators and short hand
typists.
∗ To make recommendations to the
authority regarding the advancement of
languages.
∗ To engage in research activities
regarding Sinhala, Tamil, English and
foreign languages.
The Inquiring in to complaints by the
Commission Commission
can inquire in
to the A complaint could be made against a
complaints government institution for making a fault
made against in respect of the status or practice of a
any action
language by some act or by neglect :
taken by a
government That is ,
institution in
respect of a (a) There is no acceptance or has not
language or for accepted the entitled status of a
not taking certain official language: or
action or
neglecting a
language
issue.
62
(b) Action is not being taken in accordance
with the Constitutions 20 -24 of the
Constitution : or
(c) Action is not being taken in accordance
with an order, regulation, conclusion,
administrative decision made according
to provisions of an Act : or
(d) Action is not being taken according to
objectives stated in chapter ÉV of the
Constitution ;
In such instances the Commission has to Complaints
make inquiries. could be made
to the
(2) Complaints can be dismissed on Commission on
justifiable grounds. The reason for dismissal the grounds
has to be conveyed to the complainant. that action is
Within 14 days – not taken
accordingly to
∗ A person or a group of persons who an Act or for
were affected by doing or not doing not abiding by
a certain act can make a complaint. the objectives
spelt out in
∗ If so requested, the inquiry could chapter ÉV of
proceed in a confidential manner. the
Constitution.
63
Powers of the Commission ( Section 21 of
the Act )
64
23 (1) After investigating –
65
(4) Whatever the reasons could be, the
final report has to be submitted within
120 days of making the complaint
along with a copy to the complainant.
Judicial Remedies
66
After the lapse of 120 days or within 30 days
of receiving the verdict, the complainant can
file a Fundamental Rights case before the
Supreme Court. Such a case has to be filed
by the complainant.
67
Filing a case before
the Magistrates Courts
Section 29 (1) –
68
6.5 - Concession by the Human Rights
Commission (1996 /21 )
69
6.4 Concessions that could be granted by
the Ombudsman
70
Human Rights Declaration
and Language
All are equal before the law. All are The Human
entitled to equal protection of the law. Right which
spells that “All
All are entitled to equal protection
are equal
against any discrimination in violation before the law”
of this Declaration and against any should be the
basis of all the
incitement to such discrimination.
laws in the
country. It is
an injustice to
cause
discrimination
due to the use
of a language.
71
International Covenant on Civil and Political
Rights (1996)
Article 2
72
(b) To obtain the services of a translator
when the languages used in Courts is
not understood by him.
Article 26
73
right to express and follow their religion, the
right to use their language should not be
denied or rejected. Sri Lanka is bound by the
Convention to protect these rights.
Article 1
74
Article 2
According to
the Declaration
on the Rights
of the
Minorities
(1992),
necessary
laws should be
enacted to
secure the
Right to the
use of their
language.
(Articles 1
and 2)
75
76
Language and Humanity S.G. Punchihewa