Loss Prevention: Industry Specific Q&A
Loss Prevention: Industry Specific Q&A
Loss Prevention is not all about floor walking—most Loss Prevention departments
are much more than that and are depended upon for education, guidance, investi-
gations, interviews, helping to reduce shrinkage, always with integrity and trust.
Related terms:
Chlorine cylinders
Loss prevention engineers and safety professionals have repeated stories in
Louisiana about the misapplication of steam on one-ton chlorine cylinders. Two
similar stories were discussed at inter-plant loss prevention meetings a couple of
decades ago. Naturally, the details are now a little vague but the stories were from
companies located over 100 miles apart in two separate petrochemical sections of
the state.
Process engineers who have requirements for low flow rates of chlorine can purchase
chlorine in 150 pound and one-ton cylinders. These containers are very robust and
industries have safely used them for decades. The one-ton cylinders are 2½ ft. (0.75
m) in diameter and just under 7 ft. (2.1 m) long with extended cylinder walls to
protect the valves. Chlorine ton-cylinders are hydro-tested at 500 psig (3450 kPa
gauge).
Chlorine can be provided from the ton cylinders as a liquid or a gas. The discharge
rate depends on the pressure within the cylinder and this is a function of the
ambient temperature. In order to withdraw gas, you must vaporize liquid chlorine.
Withdrawal tends to reduce the temperature and hence the vapor pressure and the
surrounding air must supply sufficient heat to boost the vapor pressure. Typical
maximum discharge rate for a one-ton chlorine cylinder in a 70°F environment is
about 15 lb/h.
When chlorine gas is withdrawn from a chlorine cylinder at a rapid rate, the cylinder
will cool down. Some companies that need to boost the gaseous chlorine flow rate
have placed warm water spray or utility water on the cylinder to add a well-controlled
heat input on cool days. However, some individuals were reported to have become
more creative and blew live steam via a hose to even further increase the rate of
vaporization. That would seem like a good idea – unless you took the time to read
the precautions.
Each chlorine ton cylinder has three fusible plugs on each end of the tank to protect
it from overtemperature. These plugs are designed to melt between 158°F and 165°F
(70–74°C). They are designed to protect the tank from overpressure if the cylinder
is accidentally exposed to fire or other sources of excessive heat. In fact, if you
accidentally heat steel containing chlorine to over 483°F (250°C), a steel-in-chlorine
fire can be ignited.
Stories from plant safety professionals indicate that live steam was exhausted on the
cylinders to make a crude vaporizer to increase chlorine flow. The frightful result
was more chlorine, but it was to the atmosphere, not to the process. There were no
reports of injuries when these memorable stories were told.
Keywords
external loss prevention, forced entry, smash and grab attacks, surreptitious entry,
aura of security, redundant security, layered security, environmental security design,
“Broken Windows” theory, sustainability, green security, perimeter, clear zones,
natural barriers, structural barriers, human barriers, animal barrier, energy barri-
ers,passive vehicle barriers, active vehicle barriers, common wall, land use controls,
target-rich environment, keep out zones, stand-off distance, blast and antiramming
walls, fiber optics, bypass, spoofing, point protection, spot or object protection, area
protection, perimeter protection, local alarm, central station, remote programming,
lumens, illuminance, foot-candle (FC), lux, color rendition, traffic calming strategies,
stationary post, foot or vehicle patrols, contraband
When a person or business takes out an insurance policy to cover valuables, the
insurance agent may not require proof that the valuables exist. However, when a
claim is filed, the insurer becomes very interested in not only evidence to prove that
the valuables were stolen (e.g., police report), but also evidence that the valuables in
fact existed. Without proof, indemnification may become difficult. To avoid this
problem, several steps are useful. First, the insured should prepare an inventory of
all valuables. Accounting records and receipts are good sources for the inventory list.
The list should include the item name, serial number, date it was purchased, price,
and a receipt. Photographs and video of valuables are also useful. Copies should be
located in two separate safe places.
Bonding Claims
Numerous insurance companies have found the fidelity bond business to be gen-
erally unprofitable. To compound the situation, businesspeople have attempted to
used fidelity bond claims to cover losses from mysterious disappearance and general
inventory shortages, rather than for their intended purpose—coverage for internal
theft. For these reasons, when a claim takes place, the insurer and insured have a
tendency to enter negotiations as adversaries. The strength of the loss prevention
practitioner's case will definitely affect the settlement. Care must be exercised
throughout the interaction with the insurer so as not to in any way invalidate the
contract. Furthermore, the burden of proof for losses rests entirely on the insured.
Before 1970, the insurer investigated applicants and notified the insured of any
criminal history of the applicant that would bar coverage. Because of economy
measures and the difficulty of checking into a person's background, many insurers
have made a shift to the insured for verifying the applicant's past. Bonds stipulate
that past dishonesty by the employee justifies an exclusion from bonding from the
day the information is discovered; if a loss occurs and the insurer can prove that this
information was known to the insured company but not reported to the insurer, the
bond is likely to be invalid.
In reference to the burden of proof, the loss prevention practitioner should have
considerable expertise when dealing with the insurer on behalf of his or her employ-
er. Confusion often arises from the “exclusionary clause” of the fidelity bond policy.
This clause essentially states that the bond does not cover losses that are dependent
on proof from inventory records or a profit and loss computation. Prior to 1970,
these records were not even allowed to establish the extent of losses even though
employees had confessed. However, in the early 1970s, courts began to be more
flexible in limiting the exclusionary clause and thus allowing inventory records and
associated computations to establish the amount of loss when independent proof
also was introduced to establish that there was loss due to employee theft.
What do you think are the most difficult challenges of a risk manager's job?
Security and loss prevention practitioners face enormous challenges. Dealing with
crimes, accidents, and natural disasters requires sound planning and action and
the ability to adapt to a changing environment. Critical thinking offers an avenue
for practitioners to enhance positive results in their work. The techniques of critical
thinking are also helpful to students in any discipline to improve their thinking. We
all think, but when we apply critical thinking, we produce a clearer, more accurate
picture of our world.
Keywords
critical thinking, security, loss prevention, Chief Security Officer (CSO), layered
security, redundant security, circumvent, Great Wall of China, Hammurabi, King
of Babylon, polis, Praetorian Guard, vigiles, feudalism, comitatus, posse comitatus,
Posse Comitatus Act, frankpledge system, tithing, Magna Carta, Statute of West-
minster, watch and ward, Henry Fielding, Bow Street Runners, Sir Robert Peel,
Metropolitan Police Act, Allan Pinkerton, Henry Wells, William Fargo, William Burns,
Washington Perry Brink, George Wackenhut, Edwin Holmes, first wave societies,
second wave societies, third wave societies, convergence of enterprise security
Remedies for the above challenges include cost-effective screening, adequate social-
ization, auditing, and investigations. Another possible measure would be to assign
part-time and temporary employees to be supervised by and work with permanent,
experienced employees. Additionally, inexperienced employees could be barred from
performing certain tasks and entering specific areas. Besides potential losses from
part-time and temporary employees, loss prevention planning must also consider
full-time regular employees.
Screening
The quality of job applicant screening is dependent on numerous factors. In a small
store, the owner may interview the applicant; record pertinent information, such as
address, telephone number, and social security number; and ask for a few references.
In large multistore organizations, however, employment procedures are commonly
more structured and controlled. Cambern (2010: 71) writes of vulnerabilities from
retail employees obtained from staffing agencies. She writes that adverse results
(e.g., criminal convictions) from background checks are higher for contract workers
that for other employees. In addition, she notes that the most common alert is
a bogus social security number, which signals false identity. Hollinger (2011: 26)
reports that the “hottest” screening methods are criminal history checks, followed
by honesty testing and computer-assisted interviews.
Socialization
Various training programs are applicable to adequately socialize an employee toward
business objectives. Training can reduce employee mistakes and losses, raise pro-
ductivity, create customer satisfaction, and reduce turnover.
Some retail businesses require employees to sign a statement that they understand
the loss prevention program. This procedure reinforces loss prevention program-
ming. Furthermore, as models of appropriate work attitudes and behavior, execu-
tives should set a good example and practice what is preached.
Numerous loss prevention awareness programs are applied by retailers. These in-
clude anonymous telephone hot lines, online reporting, discussions about shrink-
age, bulletin board notices and posters, employee code of conduct, honesty incen-
tives, and a variety of online and video training programs.