Advanced Structural Audit Scheme - Case Study On Bishop's House Building, Palai
Advanced Structural Audit Scheme - Case Study On Bishop's House Building, Palai
Abstract Structural Audit is a technical survey of an Establishing the role of NDT Tests in Structural
engineering structure to assess its health. Evaluation Audit
of current vague practices of Structural Audit paved Organize the repair and retrofitting methods to suit
way to understand the drawbacks of those processes the new Audit Scheme
and modify the same for methodical implementation of Develop a standard operating procedure
Structural Audit. This research aims at understanding Aids Forensic Structural Engineering Process
the drawbacks if any in the current procedure, recast Structural Audit of Bishop’s House building, Palai
the structural auditing process and propose some Suggestions to make Structural Audit compulsory
improvement measures to the governing body. This for buildings that exceed 30 years
paper also deals with the repair rehabilitation
measures that are to be enacted after the Audit and III. LITERATURE REVIEW
prepare an advanced operating procedure for A.B. Mahadik and M.H. Jaiswal in 2014, shared
Structural Audits. awareness amongst the civil engineers, residents and
owners of building towards the health examination of
Keywords — Structural Audit, Non-Destructive Test, existing concrete buildings called as Structural Audit.
Repair, Rehabilitation. The need of structural audit, for maintenance and
repairs of existing structures whose life has exceeded
I. INTRODUCTION the age of 30 years to avoid any mishaps and save
Recent years witnessed the boom of construction valuable human life.
sector in Kerala. In cities like Mumbai and Delhi B.H Chafekar et al. in 2014 studied about frame
urbanization has started very long before, such that which is the heart of building, different techniques
now the buildings are aged. Thus there are many used to assess of frames of old structure. Visual
structures that have reduced strength in due course of inspection, non-destructive test are used to access
time. It may endanger the life of people who are living frame of structure. Now a days in different locations
inside those buildings. In such a case appropriate in India building collapse occurs.
actions should be proposed and implemented to Bhavar Dadasaheb O. et al. in 2013 analysed that
improve the performance of structures and restore the many parts of the country have suffered earthquake in
desired function of these buildings. There came up the last three decades. In costal part of South India faced
importance to perform structural audit of existing Tsunami. In first three earthquakes it was found that
buildings and to put forward maintenance/ repair work many of damaged structures were built in non-
timely which will lead to prolonged life of the engineered masonry techniques. Thus it is always
building and safety of the occupant. Structural Audit useful to investigate the behaviour of masonry
of a building is the preliminary technical survey [3] to buildings after an earthquake, so as to identify any
assess its general health as a civil engineering inadequacies in earthquake resistant design.
structure. With the study of current process of Giacinto porco et al. in 2014 studied about the
Structural Audit there is a need to find the lacks of the mitigation of seismic vulnerability related to both
current processes and advancing the process for cultural and historical buildings as a very important
efficient implementation of Structural Audit on issue especially when considering monumental
present day structures. heritages located on seismic areas, since it allows
defining the seismic risk of selected structures. Within
II. SCOPE AND OBJECTIVES such a framework, Non Destructive Testing (NDT)
Structural Audit is an overall health and techniques and proximal remotely sensed tools played
performance check-up of a building like a doctor a key role for providing the damage detection and the
examines a patient. The current research aims at conservation status evaluation of heritages, especially
establishing an advanced Audit scheme [2] for the in response to seismic hazards.
new generation structures. The engineering structures K.R.Sonawane and Dr.A.W.Dhawale in 2015
are getting complex day by day. Thus the old vague studied that the life cycle of building can be broadly
Audit practises are to be altered. Objectives of the divide into four phases i.e. architectural planning,
research are as follows: structural design, construction, maintenance. In most
of the building utmost care is taken in first three cases
but maintenance is forgotten. Ignorance to applied at each of the junctions before initiating
maintenance causes several structural distresses in testing.
building over period of time. Most of the building 5) The probes are connected to the display unit via
constructed in last 23 to 30 years is in severe structural cables of suitable lengths and calibrated onsite using
distress and needs to repair, hence these building the calibration rod supplied along with the device.
needs periodical survey from structural point of view 6) Once calibration is done the probes are faced on
to assess the structural health. either side of the marked locations; ensuring that the
probes are geometrically opposite to each other.
IV. METHODOLOGY 7) The readings are taken and noted into the field data
sheet.
A. General
8) The equation for calculating pulse velocity is:
The Technical Audit is a solely technical Pulse Velocity V= L/T, where
achievement where technically sound personal/ V is the pulse velocity in concrete in
Experienced Civil Engineer, conduct the audit with a km/second.
few handheld equipment. L is the path length measured between the
B. Architectural and Structural Plans probes in millimetres.
T is the time taken by the pulse to travel from
It is crucial that we must have Architectural and one probe to another in µS.
Structural plans of the buildings. These drawings will V. TABLE 1
help in the identification of the location of the
Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity vs. Concrete Quality
different tests done, and it helps in the future
Ultrasonic Pulse Concrete
references also. S.No.
Velocity Quality
C. Visual Inspection of the Building 1 Above 4.5 Excellent
All foundations settle to some extent as the earth 2 3.5- 4.5 Good
materials around and beneath them adjust to loads of
the building. Slight tapping with hammer can reveal 3 3.0 – 3.5 Medium
deterioration in concrete. Freezing and thawing cycles 4 Below 3.0 Doubtful
can be very detrimental to concrete over time.
Corrosion [5] of the reinforcing steel in concrete can 2) Core Test: In most structural investigations [4] or
be a major structural issue. Under normal conditions, diagnoses extraction of core samples is unavoidable
the pH level of concrete is high (above 12.5). The high and often essential. Cores are usually extracted by
pH of concrete allows an inactive layer of ferric oxide drilling using a diamond tipped core cutter cooled
to form around the reinforcement, preventing rust [1]. with water. Broken samples, for example, due to
Dampness can damage much more than a buildings popping, spalling and delamination, are also
appearance. It may lead to the deterioration of plaster commonly retrieved for further analysis as these
and masonry, promote timber decay and create samples may provide additional evidence as to the
unhealthy conditions for occupants. cause of distress. The selection of the locations for
extraction of core samples is made after non-
D. Non-Destructive Testing destructive testing which can give guidance on the
1) Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity Test: In UPV test [6] the most suitable sampling areas.
quality of concrete is assessed based on the pulse 3) Rebound Hammer Test: The test is performed to
generated by the electro- acoustical transducers which estimate the in situ strength of concrete based on the
are placed on the concrete surface. The pulse correlation established between in-situ strength [9] at
encounters multiple reflections at the boundaries of the particular location & rebound numbers. The
the various material phases and reaches the receiving plaster is removed at test locations. The compressive
transducer. The underlying principle of assessing the strength of concrete against each rebound number is
quality of concrete is that comparatively higher obtained from graph prepared on correlation
velocities are obtained when the quality of concrete in established between rebound numbers at core test
terms of density, homogeneity and uniformity is good. locations & equivalent cube strength values.
In case of poorer quality lower velocities are obtained. 4) Half Cell Potentiometer Test: The method of half-
1) The members to be tested are identified and the cell potential [8] measurements normally involves
dimensions are measured for member size and path measuring the potential of an embedded reinforcing
length. bar relative to a reference half-cell placed on the
2) Grid points are marked at 300 x 300mm sizes as per concrete surface. The half-cell is usually a
the provisions of IS: 13311 (Part – 1) 1992. copper/copper sulphate or silver/silver chloride cell
3) The junctions of the grids are cleared of all surface but other combinations are used. The concrete
undulations or deformations by using carborundum functions as an electrolyte and the risk of corrosion of
stone, grinder or any other suitable methods. the reinforcement in the immediate region of the test
4) Suitable acoustic couplants like petroleum jelly, location may be related empirically to the measured
grease, liquid soap or kaolin glycerol paste shall be potential difference.
5) Cover Meter Scanning: Cover meter [7] test is VI. STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE-CASE
carried out on RC Columns, beams and slabs in order STUDY
to assess the thickness of cover concrete provided for Structural Audit of a building is the preliminary
embedded peripheral rebars. technical survey to assess its general health as a civil
6) Abrasion Resistance Test: The surface of concrete engineering structure. As the construction sector
cubes is subjected to impingement of an abrasive [10] advanced there is no validity for the old vague audit
charge. As a result, abrasion of the concrete surface of practices. Thus an Advanced Audit of the structure
the cubes occurs and resulting loss in mass of the would be of help.
cubes is taken as the abrasion loss of concrete. This
loss of mass of the specimen gives us a clear idea of A. Objectives and Scope
the abrasion occurred on the concrete specimen and Smooth and Systematic conduct of Technical Audit.
this can be directly related to the concrete abrasion Forensic Structural Engineering.
resistance. Increase the life of structure and sustain unwanted
7) Windsor Probe Test: The Windsor probe, like the disturbances.
rebound hammer, is a hardness tester, and its Decide remedial measures to any type of structural
inventors’ claim that the penetration of the probe defects.
reflects the precise compressive strength in a localized
area is not strictly true. However, the probe B. Description of the Building
penetration does relate to some property of the The Bishop’s House is situated at the heart of Pala
concrete below the surface, and, within limits, it has town on coordinates 9°42'30.0"N 76°40'30.5"E. The
been possible to develop empirical correlations foundation stone of the Bishop House Building was
between strength properties and the penetration of the laid on 4th January 1958 under the guidance of H.E.
probe. Rt. Rev. Dr. Sebastian Vayalil. The planning and
8) Permeability Test: Permeability of concrete is designing of the building was given to a Bangalore
important when dealing with durability of concrete based Engineering cum Architectural Firm. The total
particularly in concrete used for water retaining number of floors is two. The structure is constructed
structures or watertight sub-structures. Permeability partially as load bearing and partially framed. The
tests measure the ease with which liquids, ions and building has been in use since the beginning of the
gases can penetrate into the concrete. diocese and has undergone very minor changes. The
9) Radar Test: Ground penetrating radar (GPR) is a structure is in a well maintained condition. The
non-destructive technique with a wide range of building is situated on the banks of Menachil River.
potential applications in the testing of concrete. It is
gaining acceptance as a useful and rapid technique for C. Tasks and Responsibilities
non-destructive detection of delaminations and the
types of defects, which can occur in bare or overlaid VII. TABLE 2
reinforced concrete decks. Tasks and Responsibilities
10) Acoustic Emission: Acoustic emissions are micro Task Authorized Responsible
seismic activities originating from within the test Formalities for CONSULATN
ENGINEER
specimen when subjected to an external load. Acoustic performing NDT T
emissions are caused by local disturbances such as Built drawings DRAFTSM ENGINEER
Visual Inspection AN CONSULTAN
micro cracking, dislocation movement, intergranular ENGINEER
friction, etc. An acoustic signal travels to a number of of Structure T
Conducting Tests ENGINEER CONSULTAN
piezoelectric transducers, which convert the acoustic T
signals (mechanical waveforms) to electric signals. Developing Audit CONSULTAN
ENGINEER
Report T
11) Chemical Test: The samples of deteriorated
concrete particles are to be tested for pH, Chloride D. Procedure
content, Sulphate content, Depth of carbonation etc.
1) Obtaining/ Preparing Built drawings: The
E. Repair and Retrofitting building drawings were not available and the built
drawings were prepared as per the measurements from
Based on the audit findings and recommendations
the site. Each story of the building was of 1001 square
different measures of repairs and strengthening are
meters. The drawings were prepared in AutoCAD
carried out. Excluding technical considerations, the
ultimate choice of method of repair and strengthening 2010.
of a concrete structure may also be influenced by 2) Visual Inspection of the Structure: The structure
factors like overall quality of repairs and the size of was checked for any settlements in foundation, visual
individual repairs, access for repair, relative cost, ease cracks in slabs, columns and beams, concrete
of application, available labour skills and equipment disintegration, exposed reinforcements, Leakages
and client requirements including future maintenance from other floors, Status of lift and lift machine room
and economic considerations. etc. The plinth level of the building is inspected
keenly since the area is prone to flood. But as per the
authorities no flood has affected the building in its
[13] Saleem Akthar et al., “Review of Non-Destructive testing [14] Shah I.H, “Structural audit of existing buildings”, I.H Shah and
methods for condition monitoring of concrete structures”, Journal Associates, June 2011
of Construction Engineering, Vol 2013, March 2013 [15] Sharma.S, “Scheme of certification of design”, Institution of
Structural Engineers, May 2013