Chapter 1 (Intro)
Chapter 1 (Intro)
Precision: Is a measure of
how closely clustered a
group of measurements of
the same
- reproducibility.
- high precision means a
number of readings or trials
result in values close to the
same number.
Precise but not accurate
10
Accuracy: Refers to how
close a measurement is
to the true or accepted
value.
Relatively low
determinate error.
Close to a ‘true’ value.
Accurate and precise
11
Fundamental Methods of Measurements
There are two basic methods of measurement:
Direct comparison: with a primary or secondary
standard
Indirect comparison: conversion of measurand
input into an analogous form which can be
processed and presented as known function of
input
- A transducer is required to convert the
measurand into another form
12
ERROR DEFINITIONS
Error – The deviation of a measured result from the
correct or accepted value of the quantity being
measured.
15
Errors in measurements are due to:
1) Systematic Errors:
Procedural errors made by the experimenter. They cause
the measured value to deviate from the "accepted" value
in the same direction i.e. always higher or always lower.
Examples of causes include miscalibration of instruments
and parallax errors. These errors can be detected and
corrected. Systematic errors are calculated as Percent
Error. AKA the accuracy of the work
16
Systematic Errors – cause the measured result to
deviate by a fixed amount in one direction from the
correct value. The distribution of multiple
measurements with systematic error contributions will
be centered some fixed value away from the correct
value.
Some Examples:
Mis-calibrated instrument
Unaccounted cable loss
17
2) Random Errors
These errors arise due to uncertainties in the measuring
instruments. They result in measured values that are
either too high or too low. They are found commonly in
mass, volume and temperature readings. These errors
cannot be determined and
eliminated, however, they can be treated with statistics.
The effect of these errors can be minimized by taking
multiple measurements of the same thing so that the
random errors cancel out. They are always written +/-.
Random errors are calculated as Uncertainty.
18
Random Errors – cause the measured result to deviate
randomly from the correct value. The distribution of
multiple measurements with only random error
contributions will be centered around the correct
value.
Some Examples
Noise (random noise)
Careless measurements
Low resolution instruments
Dropped digits
19
Measurements typically contain some combination of
random and systematic errors.
Precision is an indication of the level of random error.
Accuracy is an indication of the level of systematic
error.
Accuracy and precision are typically qualitative terms.
20
Generalized Measurement System
Sensor or transducer stage to detect
measurand and Convert input to a form
suitable for processing e.g. :
- Temp. to voltage - Force to distance
Signal conditioning stage to modify the
transduced signal e.g. :
Amplification, Attenuation, Filtering,
Encoding
Terminating readout stage to present desired
output (Analog or Digital form)
22
MEASUREMENT STAGES
Variable manipulation
Performs mathematical operation on data
Amplifier, filter
26
MEASUREMENT STAGES
Data transmission
Gets data between measurement elements
Wire, speedometer cable, satellite downlink system
Data storage/playback
Stores data for later retrieval
Hard drive, RAM
Data presentation
Indicators, alarms, analog recording, digital recording
27
Calibration
Calibration involves the determination of the
relationship between the input and output of
a measurement system
Eliminate Bias error
The proving of a measurement system’s
capability to quantify the input accurately
Calibration is accomplished by applying
known magnitudes of the input and observing
the measurement system output
The indirect measuring system must be
calibrated.
31
CALIBRATION
Once a measurement device is selected, it must be
calibrated
Calibration –Comparison of instrument’s reading to a
calibration standard
Calibration standard created from a measurement
Inherent error
Basic issue is how do we know that what we record
has any relation to what we wish to measure?
32
What is Uncertainty?
Uncertainty is essentially lack of information to
formulate a decision.
Uncertainty may result in making poor or bad
decisions.
As living creatures, we are accustomed to dealing
with uncertainty – that’s how we survive.
Dealing with uncertainty requires reasoning under
uncertainty along with possessing a lot of common
sense.
35
Dealing with Uncertainty
Deductive reasoning – deals with exact facts and exact
conclusions
Inductive reasoning – not as strong as deductive –
premises support the conclusion but do not guarantee it.
There are a number of methods to pick the best solution
in light of uncertainty.
When dealing with uncertainty, we may have to settle
for just a good solution.
36
Uncertainty of Measurements
Measurement error = Measured result - True value
The true value of a measurand is Unknown ( Error
is unknown )
The potential value of error can be estimated
(uncertainty)
Two types of error:
a) Systematic errors (bias) e.g. Failure to calibrate or
check zero of instrument, Instrument drift, Lag time
and hysteresis
b) Random errors ( Statistics to estimate random
errors) e.g. Instrument resolution, Physical variations
37
UNCERTAINTY IN PLANING
During the design of the experiment
Identify all possible sources of error:
Experiment set up: facility effects, environmental effects, human , …..
Measurement system: velocity, temperature,...
Estimate possible severity of each source
Discuss with advisor.
For those that are considered “important”, identify strategies.
Experimental design and/or test protocols (e.g. repeat tests)
Plan for quantitative analysis of reduced data
Quantitative analysis relies on math model of the system
Often good for measurement systems: pitot probe, strain gauge,...
38
UNCERTAINTY STAGES
During the experiment
Execute experiment with replications
Record notes in lab notebook
Check for mistakes and Bias errors
During data reduction
Calculate error bars for measurements
Check for outlier points
During data interpretation/reporting
Consider errors when interpreting data 1st order &Nth order
Assure findings are beyond uncertainty of experiment
Display error bars in way that aids in understanding findings
39
Propagation of Uncertainty
When a measurement model is used to
estimate the value of the measurand, the
uncertainty of the output estimate is usually
obtained by mathematically combining the
uncertainties of the input estimates
The mathematical operation of combining
the uncertainties is called propagation of
uncertainty
40
Standard Uncertainty
41
Combined Standard Uncertainty
The standard uncertainty of an output estimate
obtained by uncertainty propagation is called the
combined standard uncertainty
42
m = 75 ± 5 g
What is the meaning of ± 5 ?
Best guess by experimenter
Half the smallest division of measurement
Standard deviation: σ
Standard error: σm = σ/√n
Expanded uncertainty of ± 2σ or ± 3σ (95% or 99%
confidence interval)
Standard uncertainty: u
Combined standard uncertainty: uc
43
Experimental Data and Measures of
Uncertainty
44
Average deviation
45
Sample standard deviation
46
Standard error
47
Errors Related to Measurement
Errors of precision – how well the truth is known
48
Types of Errors
49
SOURCE OF ERRORS
50
BIAS AND RANDOM ERRORS
51
Bias (systematic) and
Random (precise) Errors
52
Bias and Random Errors
54
Errors in Measuring a Variable
55
Types of Input Signals
Static
Dynamic ( Time dependence )
- Steady periodic, complex periodic
- Nonperiodic: nearly periodic or transient
- Single pulse.
- Random
Analog or digital:
- Analog; continuous signal,
- Digital; distinct values, step changes.
58
Dimensional Analysis
Data presented in dimensionless form.
Reducing No of experimental variables.
No of variables - No of dims.= No of π groups
Use pi method or by inspection
Basic dimensions: M L T θ (kg, m, sec, K )
Saving (time & $) (10 tests – vs - 104 tests for F= fn (L,V,ρ, μ ))
Force coef. F/ρV2L2 = fn (Reynolds number ρVL/μ)
Helping in exp. Planning, insight, and similitude.
65
Sensors
A sensor is a converter that measures a physical
quantity and converts it into a signal which can be read
by an observer or by an (today mostlyelectronic)
instrument. For example, a mercury-in-glass
thermometer converts the measured temperature into
expansion and contraction of a liquid which can be read
on a calibrated glass tube. A thermocouple converts
temperature to an output voltage which can be read by
a voltmeter. For accuracy, most sensors
are calibrated against known standards.
75
List of sensors
1 Acoustic, sound, vibration
2 Automotive, transportation
3 Chemical
4 Electric current, electric potential, magnetic, radio
5 Environment, weather, moisture, humidity
6 Flow, fluid velocity
7 Ionizing radiation, subatomic particles
8 Navigation instruments
9 Position, angle, displacement, distance, speed, acceleration
10 Optical, light, imaging, photon
11 Pressure
12 Force, density, level
13 Thermal, heat, temperature
14 Proximity, presence
15 Sensor technology
16 Other sensors and sensor related properties and concepts
76
Examples: Acoustic, sound, vibration
Geophone
Hydrophone
Lace Sensor a guitar
pickup
Microphone
Seismometer
77
Automotive, transportation
Air–fuel ratio meter
Blind spot monitor
Crankshaft position sensor
Curb feeler, used to warn driver of curbs
Defect detector, used on railroads to detect axle and signal
problems in passing trains
Engine coolant temperature sensor, or ECT sensor, used to
measure the engine temperature
Hall effect sensor, used to time the speed of wheels and shafts
MAP sensor, Manifold Absolute Pressure, used in regulating fuel
metering.
Mass flow sensor, or mass airflow (MAF) sensor, used to tell
the ECU the mass of air entering the engine
78
Flow, fluid velocity
Air flow meter
Anemometer
Flow sensor
Gas meter
Mass flow sensor
Water meter
79
Pressure
Barometer
Boost gauge
Bourdon gauge
Permanent Downhole Gauge
Piezometer
Pirani gauge
Pressure sensor
Pressure gauge
80
Force, density, level
Hydrometer
Force gauge
Level sensor
Load cell
Magnetic level gauge
Strain gauge
Torque sensor
Viscometer
81
Resistive Displacement Sensor
82
Capacitive Displacement Sensor
C= Capacitance, εo &εr =Permittivity of air and Dielectric
83
Strain Gage
[Gage Factor = (∆R/R)/(∆L/L) & Young’s Modulus = (P/A) / (∆L/L) ]
87
Laser Doppler Anemometer
106
Periodic Wave and its Spectrum
107
Time Domain & Freq. Domain
108
frequency spectrum examples
109