Program Development
Program Development
SIGNIFICANCE
Nationally, 1 in 5 children in the United States experiences mental illness each year,
affecting all ethnic, racial, and socioeconomic groups (Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, 2020). The most common mental disorders in children are anxiety disorders,
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, disruptive behavior, and mood disorders (Child Mind
Institute, 2015).
Poor emotional regulation is common across psychiatric diagnoses in children (Masi et
al., 2015; Wyman et al., 2010). According to Sheftall et al. (2016), impulsivity is of particular
concern due to its potential role in suicide for this age group. Suicide is the 10th leading cause of
death in children ages 5 - 11, with rates of 0.17 per 100,000 (Sheftall et al., 2016). Other public
health concerns linked to deficits in emotional regulation include depression, addiction,
antisocial behavior, and school absences, suspensions, and expulsions (Stagman & Cooper,
2010; Wyman et al., 2010). Furthermore, poor self-control in childhood is predictive of higher
crime rates as adults (Moffitt et al., 2011). This clearly shows that emotional regulation is a
public health issue that needs to be addressed.
Program Overview
We developed a program that aims to improve emotional regulation skills and
enable healthy participation in childhood roles and occupations. It will take place at a
children’s mental health partial hospitalization program in Salt Lake City, Utah, called Kidstar.
This treatment program serves children ages 5 - 12 and they typically attend Kidstar for 6
weeks. Up to 14 children are enrolled in the program at any given time, and they are divided into
two separate classrooms. The children have severe mental illness and exhibit externalizing
behaviors (i.e., aggression, antisocial behavior). These behaviors are associated with poor
emotional regulation (Dvir et al., 2015; Eisenberg, Valiente, & Eggum, 2010). A survey of
Kidstar staff and parents also identified emotional regulation as a particular need for their
population. Children in the Kidstar program are currently unable to attend their typical school
due to emotional and behavioral challenges, which greatly impact their school and homework
performance. Furthermore, the children’s poor emotional regulation skills limit their participation
in all areas of occupation. The current programming at Kidstar does not include a curriculum
that targets emotional regulation skills, particularly as it relates to childhood occupations.
Therefore, we developed a program to address this need.
We used a modified version of the Zones of Regulation curriculum (Kupyers, 2011) as
the foundation of our program due to its use of both sensory and cognitive strategies to improve
emotional regulation. Zones of Regulation categorizes emotions into four different “zones” and
teaches children to recognize when they have entered each zone by referring to their level of
alertness and mood. It teaches strategies (i.e., sensory tools, cognitive approaches) to help
them regulate in their current zone or move to a more appropriate zone for the situation.
Although limited, there is evidence of the effectiveness of Zones of Regulation. Suarez et al.
(2019) used Zones of Regulation to guide individual treatment with four children in an outpatient
clinic who had poor behavior or emotional regulation. The authors identified an increase in self-
regulation from baseline. Additionally, Zones of Regulation may lead to increased independence
in activities of daily living (ADLs) (Suarez et al., 2019). Other studies have found the Zones of
Regulation curriculum is effective in classroom settings (McQuade, 2017) and in a small group-
based intervention for children with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (Anderson et al., 2017).
Although these studies settings were different from Kidstar, the curriculum increased self-
regulation in children with similar challenges to the children attending Kidstar. The potential of
Zones of Regulation to increase independence in ADLs impacted by poor emotional regulation
indicates that this curriculum, modified for this setting, is a viable option to meet the needs of the
Kidstar population.
INNOVATION
Although Kidstar teaches some emotional regulation skills through their current social
skills training curriculum, the children have a limited understanding of emotions, often using
basic vocabulary such as “happy” or “sad” to describe their emotions. The children do not have
a reliable way of categorizing their emotions to help them identify appropriate times to display
and act on those emotions. Our program offers a novel approach to emotional regulation
that is adapted for the specific needs of an intensive mental health treatment program.
Specifically, the children in Kidstar are admitted and discharged on individual schedules, which
is a common feature of treatment programs. To accommodate this, we structured the delivery of
our program so it applies to newly admitted children who are attending their first session and to
children who have been participating in the program for several weeks. A second innovative
feature of our program in this setting is teaching sensory processing skills. We will do this
by completing a sensory evaluation, training children, and educating parents and staff on the
best use of sensory tools. Our program will ensure effective use of sensory tools that can be
generalized across settings to improve the children’s functioning at home, school, and in the
community.
In each session of our program, the children will participate in activities of interest, which
provides opportunities for them to apply the emotional regulation skills being taught. The current
Kidstar curriculum does not address the occupational needs of the child as they relate to
emotional regulation. This is not uncommon in traditional mental health treatment facilities. In
fact, many interventions that currently exist to address emotional regulation have not indicated
long-term effects; therefore, there is a need for children to generalize and adapt these skills
across occupations and environments to increase the program’s effectiveness (Wyman et al.,
2010). Our program addresses this issue by applying the concepts to daily occupations. It will
incorporate activities that the children are interested in to make the curriculum engaging. Role-
playing activities will target how to apply their emotional regulation skills to challenging
occupations. Moreover, involving the family in the program will assist the children in generalizing
their skills beyond treatment.
The creation of an occupational therapy program that meets the needs of children in
intensive mental health treatment will support the value of occupational therapy in this setting.
This can be used to meet the demand for additional providers in this underserved field.
APPROACH
Needs Assessment Demonstrates Emotional Regulation Concerns
We conducted data collection through an interview with the Kidstar director and surveys
from Kidstar staff and parents. Both the director interview and staff surveys indicated that
children have the most difficulty regulating their emotions during school, free-time, and in the
afternoon. In the parent survey, all parents reported that their child has difficulty controlling
emotions, and 75% reported that their child has difficulty expressing emotions. Parents
identified emotional regulation as leading to the most difficulties in occupations in the following
order: school and homework, household chores, sleep and nighttime routine, community
activities, social participation and play, and self-care. We also explored sensory tools and
knowledge of their use in our needs assessment. Results from the staff survey indicate a lack of
in-depth understanding of sensory processing. Kidstar has demonstrated a willingness to invest
in sensory supplies, but an occupational therapist is needed to train staff on how to make use of
sensory tools throughout the programming day. We designed a program with an emphasis on
emotional regulation to address these needs and improve participation in occupations.
Program Sustainability
The program requires adding one staff member (OTR) for 10 hours per week. We are
seeking grant funding to establish and run the program for the first 12 months. After that time,
direct services provided by the OTR would be billed to private insurance, which is the current
funding source of Kidstar. Alternatively, additional grant funding could be sought to provide
continued funding for the program. This program requires very few resources to implement. The
supplies and resources needed are low cost and can be used long-term.
References and Literature Cited
Personnel ($18,200)
The OTR will prepare and run two 1-hour sessions each week (3 hours/week), conduct sensory
evaluations on each child in the program and create individualized sensory recommendations
(3.5 hours/week), source appropriate sensory tools and equipment (0.5 hours/week), and
provide parent education during family treatment sessions (3 hours/week).
Consultants ($0)
N/A
Equipment ($650)
$650 is budgeted to purchase a Chromebook for OTR use in documentation and session
preparation.
Travel ($0)
IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS
Kidstar will provide space for treatment sessions and OTR/L administrative and evaluation
needs. Kidstar will supply use of a printer for handouts and worksheets (8 pages per child at
$0.15/page: 8x$0.15x140 = $168 value) and support staff for treatment sessions (4 hours per
week at $12/hour: 4x$12x52 = $2,496 value).
Triggers for child becoming • Conflict with others (perceiving something as unfair,
out-of-control (open-ended being told no, turn-taking, an expectation not met, not
responses) getting attention)
• Lack of autonomy (feeling forced or controlled, asked to
do chores, asked to stop an activity, perceiving things as
being unfair)
• Environment (loud noise, large groups)
• School (refusal to do homework, classwork, follow set
school schedule)
• Feeling anxious or overwhelmed (being asked too many
things)
• Diet (eating high sugar foods)
• Nighttime routine
• Difficulty falling asleep and staying asleep through the
night
• Staying on task during household chores
• Seeking attention from others
• Wanting everything while shopping at a store
Self-Care 2.44
The following scale was used to measure difficulty in occupations: 1 - never difficult; 2 -
sometimes difficult; 3 - frequently difficult; 4 - always difficult.
*Only 8 of 9 parents responded to this question.
All parent surveys were collected on June 12, 2020; completed by 9 parents.
Appendix B: Needs Assessment - Kidstar Staff Survey Results
Times of day when children are most ● Last groups of the day
dysregulated (open-ended responses)
● Unstructured/free time
The following scale was used to measure understanding of sensory processing: 1 - none; 2 -
some; 3 - good; 4 - in-depth.
All staff surveys were collected on June 12, 2020; completed by 2 staff members.
Appendix C: Social Emotional Evaluation (example question)
Appendix D: Sensory Profile 2 (example page)
Appendix E: Parent Outcome Survey (example questions)
Please rate how satisfied you were with the program in improving your child’s emotion
regulation.
1 - not satisfied 2 - somewhat satisfied 3 - very satisfied
Please rate how capable you feel in helping your child use emotional regulation skills.
1 - not capable 2 - somewhat capable 3 - very capable
What tools are working for your child when they need to change their zone?