Cutler Bode PDF
Cutler Bode PDF
analysis
with illustrative
problems
Phillip Cutler
Education Research Associates
and
Orange Coast
College
Costa Mesa
California
j
E! 1
c?
'•"'-'i
i E2 , 1
•" ~ RC
&
Low-pass filter
FIGURE 11-1
FIGURE 11-3
to as the comer frequency,-and n is an integral exponent These values are plotted for the n = 1 curve in Fig.
1, 2, 3, 4 , . . . , n.3 To Bode plot this function, let us first 11-4, with the dashed line for the phase and solid line
consider n = 1. In this case the function is simply for the amplitude.
Note and memorize the following, as evidenced in
. . co
2) A =]— Fig. 11-4. For a transfer function of the form in Eq. (1)
CO,
with n = 1, the slope of the Bode plot is positive and a
Clearly the j indicates a constant phase shift of 90° constant equal to 20 dB/decade s 6 dB/octave where a
irrespective of the ratio CO/CD,;. Hence the phase response decade is a frequency ratio of 10, and an octave is a
plots as a straight line (dashed) at 90 ° as shown in Fig. frequency span of 2. The plot crosses 0 dB at co = co,..
11-4 for n = 1. The phase angle associated with this slope is 90°.
The only way we can plot the magnitude (in dB) of Now let n == 2 in Eq. (1) so that the specific function we
A is to assume various values of CD relative to our arbi- are dealing with is
trary co... Constructing a table of values we have
/ co' I CO ' CO I CO 1
db
\\ \ \'.
4+4—<
, "H
T^
•i i i 1 +-
•p '^ "ft "ri ^ -::-^....ll^ii 1 ; [ ! !;]| i ' 1,1 ,^! 1
-^-- .-..^. • -phase4*^^-"^ 315°
4^-L-t
-^ ^1' 4t*l -i-u **T' "tT"''^;'"'——•'"T"-'
M >w* •M> •jt" -1. «•-LM-^——.««^. ^ " - 3 ^ S27no
60 ^ ,. i • i . l
, ,
,,
\: ' i '
1 1 1 1
•-"H
;i
^-^
ff
BUdH/aec i ' , ; l ^ ; j :i rTT"^'
•' ' t ' •y =
18dR/oct^———-r-
;
' 1
]
>-. ^. ^ 2^5,
^^
1
50 ^~. >
!•'' • i 1! i "^ n.iiii,;iii...>,
:
^ T-' y
."» 4 ——— 77 - 2^::
40
i ;
-»<
—7 .,^"-2-^
•*UUO/UBt' ,: : ' 1 ; • ^-•''31''"'': 180°
^'"^ S
—
' \. ' • i '
1 1 ' '-y-
4
^
lope ,2^/^:S;a:S::
i
! ' i \\ . ^ , \ , , ,.,,v.,i ,1
30 ', i i
i
.
'^ -^
4t ———1——————t————^ q,
^ i—3- Pe - ,i
-,—j-y "~r^ ^ 1
W 6dB/oct ——
10 —^ ^ M— fff r w* -j- [ | ; i ; +T- l l ? ' " ! 1 -t-^i- ^^^E^s-
i .^ ' ^' •; ^— Vs.'- "ss
ff* 1
i'' . li 1 ; 1 1 1 . . ,
1 i• .[
^r-^rT
! 1
, i
l i . 1
; j 1 ! ! ; ,
j j ' 1
^^-—— ' l''
0
. 1' ^ff:*41"""^
1
0
' l i t
, , ; jff
•^^ • •
i ! :i , i '
i i ; .. .. ... i i • i 1 j i '. 11 . —--
^ u 450
-10 1—~~ • ' ' • t ••'•ta ^ T»»
ff1-
'* T*' l 4
' j ' ! 1 ' " l ^ " i ! l t !! ; 4** - SlEi::^^^"
' iiii' i ^ ; '' ' 'i' ^\
..^yy
-^*< -y ~3^
^-
i ' ' 1
i
,
i '
i, i
. ;
! •
; i | ' • i ii
' 1 ; i1
-30
—'~ i^
)*"-;— ^
—4"»c
i^I;:
-^
yr~
^
. i,
i •
^a
S:
3-
f
\
"\ »t--*T^^~ ^Hi
"<• 1 " I lIi It ' ^TTT
. 1 • •^ ttt
n<20dB/dec)+.. -4w-|—
~: t+ 4 t r
; 1 "^ ' T7 tt " ^" 't
4 +J
350
setea:®!"'
1' , J1
—,^T'''' 2 •
.z - .,, i''
^- slope n(6d8/oct) SSffla-
i i i 11 'i' 1 iii * T 'i
-40 ea^-
^h: ill |il| ^ [•-0-n90°-- i l l lU 1 i ll ' | Ii t*" •
i .
^4 i, ' ttn^
i '• i -'-t——
j
"i~H'
i ^ r rf+tr
i i 1[ 3""
'^ ' '
-+
'tti t[
T^ " ^ 11 i ' i i
' -:i::::.:::::: :!::
.' 1
-50 -,—-y 'f— 11 • * ' 11,'" ' ' 11 ' ' i •.' ' t ± '
—yf- 1 ' ! ! I'
i
,. !
'! , T '
^ -1 —-.-
^ • 1
t l l
-60 r^,——t "Ttt -l- -+i-^t••••H••• •• "r- :StsaS
0.1 10 100
ai/<*'c
FIGURE 11-4
ilB = 40 log (fj o^.) -40 -12.04 0 12.04 27.96 40 <A = n90° (ll-6c)
0 t ono
Another commonly encountered form of transfer
function term is4
Note that because this time the transfer function is
the square of the previous case (n = 1), the slope is 1) A = (ll-7a)
exactly twice as much and the phase angle is doubled. / u)}
Therefore for n = 2 and a transfer function of the form [j^
given in Eq. (1), you should think in terms of a positive
Inspection of(l) reveals that an increase ofco causes the
slope of 40 dB/dec or about 12 dB/oct and associate a
denominator to increase, since u>c is some fixed value,
180° phase shift with this slope. These results are also
and hence it causes A to decrease. Therefore, the ampli-
shown in Fig. 11-4.
tude response should have a negative slope. We also see
A Bode plot for n = 3 is also shown in Fig. 11-4. As
that for any value of n, the amplitude must be 0 dB at
might be expected, this curve also goes through 0 dB
cu = co,.. Since the j represents 90° of phase in the
at o> = (»c with a positive slope equal to 60 dB/dec or
denominator of A, the net phase angle in the denominator
approximately 18 dB/oct and the associated phase
must be n 90°. Consequently, the net phase of A must
angle is 270°. be -n 90°.
As you can see from Fig. 11-4, the slope in general is Although we will not take the time to derive the data
given by
slope = n (20 dB/dec) S n (6 dB/OCt) (ll-6fc) •'This transfer function is sometimes referred to as the integral function.
..11;: , M , | . . >
———-——•—wW-t Amplitude^ m ft
i ^
—i——
^" . ..i i . i , , : , :;^;;' : Hi ! ; , ;'
1 i——-*. n , i -»^.,^.^ Pha?- ill,,i,l',,,l,l',ll,."
1 1
S^lnrl^ai I I !'! '
1
' i 111 ^!
I n, !! , . i , i.
60 • • 1
^——
^—— 1 ; 1 ——^~t4^+^4
^•fi \-
-s;,— i
/' "" ^:ts:"^:n-:m i n" 1 1 1
"c ^titltttttti^
^^
S ' i ^ !i i
-^>—
^. .... , 1
^
'i.
f-n(20dB/dec)1 T:- ^ 1 4
't^ <t'°
I \
c:— — 1 i——- •^ • slope- \-n{ 6dB/oct) J^.I.^T—^—|M|,,||,,|
\\\ 1 , , M ,'
40
s^—. ^c"'—
-'s^.' — ...^... f~Sit— 1 1
^ , >-.^ . . . :
*s ( = —n qn°' "i i !" | j
\
! ' ' :
'[
-
' • 1
, .
-^- «^ -s
20 t -^trr-r 90
- -^— SIT-*
v
' T
.
; , ' i. i ' i ill Ai^
1
-S k—m^Uu
— " "• ' •^
^is- '^FSffi? ^-^——^^^•l+^^^^rrt^s0
ttt
ss •"'s! iri— : ^—
' 1
^:-!-.
^
i i ! 1 ! \ 1 ] [ t '
it-'^S P
•i j ' 'E'^ tii'S ^
• i>
1 , 1 1 1 1 ' 1 1
"x'tn °
, 1, t-*.i
''
, If , ' . , , , 1 , ',., , i
-14-
-*-.4+
tT
^
"4 ill
-t+'T^-"
"^i^ ^^ Sd-
sf^
^^^i-LU
»^. . 1
^.1
•«c +u*
7"!
?1
1 ' """^t*tf "w'
--i-f-^-j----^'^^ ••4"' •4'!
• • +""""
; -45°
•^-satttr;
.i<tf^
T
F ---^
^
t T*
. '' ^ •^ +..-S
\\ TT" +^S ^-
m
i ^^4 » * « i ! • • "4 :5:: t2
1 1 •
n-i +H*
'TT •»*•
^tH
**f*t-
t^^- B
l-^--^.4^•-L4t•,,f4ti••u+*t+rtt^= if -90"
|.|! 1 ; . 1 1
1 i . ,^».,. ,'
< (
"It-
" - 1' ! i i il 1 i
M1
ll -*w- 1
-^-— -n-r-t ^a "^
>+». 4 -4
-135
lE v °
"y- &"^ ; 3S^ !" {d: -20dB/dec - - - - -
+t+J• )4->4.t^U „'t ^ ! ' ' ' '^'e1""' Sl'
^
P?
^-i- Slopes ... •-•4
S
^^
^ •-**-*
\ ; ii . '
'
-60
' 1 1 L—Lj-
-11,—...,,:
•I-** ii^ t+tf ^s ^
^^-^--s- ope=
-18dB/oct
-•-yi
^S n= 3 :::i±ttiiiiiiffl : ±::::-:::t
.^. , t e . . ^ . . — . . ' — ^ . w ^ u . - ^ ^ . — . — - . . - .^-^—•k.-J.u - .^10 •
3
270°
.1 1 10
tJ/(^C
FIGURE 11-5
^^
I •
75
6° ^
J?
,- 60
.r-^
Phase
lead ^
——f K
^
J
30 7<i ^
'> ^f
.
^
^,
^6 - ^
15
•*
^
0 i
"c ^[f CJc 2 LJC 1 0^
10
FIGURE 11-6
call u)c the break, corner, or cutoff frequency because of For (D ~s> u>c the straight-line approximation and actual
the abrupt change of slope exhibited by these lines at amplitude curve merge for all practical purposes and
We- For u) < cue the approximated magnitude response the phase error is again about 6°. As you can see, the
of this transfer function is flat. At a decade below co,. or amplitude and—to a somewhat lesser extent—the phase
u> = 0.1 <y<- the error in this approximation is negligible response can be readily approximated by merely draw-
since the above table of values indicates an actual value ing straight lines with well-defined slopes. If greater
of only 0.043 dB. In the lower figure the dashed-line accuracy is desired, we can use the easily remembered
approximation to the phase curve is only about 6° below amplitude correction factors of the following table:
the true value.
At an octave below &>,., or u> = 0.5 u>^ the error (U/CU, 0.1 0.5 1 2 10
between the actual and approximate amplitude curves dB 0 1 3 1 0
is only about 1 dB and the phase error is only about 6°, 6 6
<f>° 0 6 6
which is essentially the largest phase error at any point.
At o»c we have the largest amplitude error, which is
only 3 dB, and the phase error is zero since we draw the The above correction factors and the general shape of
phase approximation curve (dashed line) so that it the phase and amplitude curves should be committed
intersects 0° at (Uc/10 and 90° at 10 a»c. A straight line to memory.
connecting these two points will intersect the point Now let us consider other values of n in the function
((o/a>, = 1, <f> = 45°).
At 0)^ the approximation to the amplitude response A- (ll-8fl)
changes slope abruptly from 0° dB/dec to 20 dB/dec or
1)
v 1 + 7wj
"
6 dB/oct. At an octave above a>c, or 2 cu,., the amplitude which has an amplitude given by
error is such that the true response is only about 1 dB
high and the phase error is about 6° low. 2) A^ = n 20 log ,/! + (ftJ/Mc)2 (ll-W
d8
Annplitude in - 3
60 Ph ase f
. CJ
55 A d +
^ /
e n t an -' "-y.
|
\
"c 1
45
40
/
/
r
i
0" )
(lead)
f
315 r 35 ^
/ ^ f r7 =
270 30
i <-. y
225
180
25
20 /
,--// 'f
t /•
:'
»
4
•>
'
^
t
7 n= 1
./// //
135 15 ^ y-
- »•
,' ' /
^A
90 10 ^ n=1
^ ." . <• -
45
0
5
0 —————————————————
0.1
^ f
--
0.5 1 2 10
tJ/OJc
FIGURE 11-7
0
/
N /
^
^ >.
/ ^
s\
- -5 —^
00
3 1 dE
OJ
3 B\?
"§ -10
C
A =
1
1d1
s\
1 -15 1 +/
^C
^q ^—
-20 s
0
\^
-15
^1
0
6
^S > s
1'
2 -45
-30
6
^
-S
S
^ ^
S'
£
-75
ks- ^ \
6°
^ •k,
i ^
6
"
0.1 0.5 1 2 10
fc>/CJc
FIGURE 11-8
7 {We. ^"c.
^ CO.
Thus the phase angle approaches 180° and the amplitude
approaches zero. In general, for co > co,;, the amplitude is
' CO
1 - +j28to- (11-lOfc) given by
I.C"r. co,
CO
These forms are called quadratic factors and they 4) A.IB == 20 log • 40 log —
generally arise due to interaction between two energy W CO,
ac circuit analysis
Frequency, radians per sec Frequency, radians per sec
FIGURE 1 1-9
as co increases, whereas in (2) the amplitude decreases sketching denominator quadratic factors, we have Fig.
and the phase lags. In both cases the phase asymptotically 11-9. Note that as 6 (sometimes called damping factor)
approaches 180°, though from different directions. increases, the peak or resonant point shifts below a);,.
Now what happens at CD = o><. in (2)? Clearly the func- The same curves may be used for numerator quad-
tion reduces to ratic factors if you remember that for o» > o»c the
amplitude curve slopes upwards at 40 dB/dec; and at
5) A = -1- = ^-/-90°
i
o»c, instead of a resonant rise, we may see a resonant dip
j20 20 ——— as shown in Fig. 11-lOa. The phase response is also
similar except that it approaches 180° of phase lead for
Thus the phase at w = co, is -90° in (2) or +90° in (I). u> > coc. Fig. 11-lOfc illustrates the phase response in
The corresponding amplitude in (2) is this case.
6) A^ = -20 log 26 (11-lOc) Now work through problem PS 11-14.
Inspection of (6) indicates that i f < $ = ^ , log 25 = log 1 =
0, so that A^ =0. If S < ^, say 6 = j for example, 180°
log 26 will be the log of a number less than 1 which is a
negative quantity, and in this case
Slope
Ads = -201og2(^) = -20(- 0.3979) s +7.96dB 40dB/dec 90°
ratios) whose reciprocals denote corner frequencies. If Equation (1) may be resolved into two factors
several time constants arise in the analysis, we can
correspondingly expect to have several corner fre- -E" 1 +7
U)
quencies to consider. E.
Starting with the voltage divider relationship, we may 1 +7 QJ,
derive
The first factor was studied in conjunction with Eq.
(11-8) and the second with Eq. (11-9). A Bode plot of the
R. J^c, R^ + l / j c o C i amplitude response of the first factor (numerator) is
/?! 4- Ri - ] X c , PI + P2 + I/.AOC;, shown as curve .V in Fig. l l - l l f r . The amplitude response
1 fi
= 0.707/-45° 4) A,. =
3) A,. =
•+!
which is precisely what we showed in the previous
Setting/,7, equal to 0.1. 0.5, 1, 2, and 10 yields the
problem when we set/=yi,.
following values
PS 11-3 What would be the corner frequency of the
circuit in Fig. PS ll-3 9 / /, 0.1 0.5 1 2 10
. ,, = -7.9588 dB
This is exactly the same result that would be obt ained by
setting/=/, in (5) of the previous probi em. Th us when PS 11-9 The voltage gain in c1B o f t h e four-ter minal
/ = / , . X c = ^ + RZ. network in Fig PS 11 -9 is A, = -5.67 cIB. What is the
voltage gain rat io E-i/lr-i ••)•
PS 11-7 Express the voltage gain o the circuit in
r"
Fig. PS 11-7 in dB a t / = / , , the resona nt freq uency.
?
270 n 39 mH
'
E i dBA, =
-5.67
?
E2
1t j
E,n(^\J 40pF^.S; E0
dSA, = -5.6 7
FieSURE PS 1 1-9
» SOLUTION
FIGURE PS 11-7
1) /4, = 20 lo
^ t
• -'l
iE i
SOLUTION
2) -5.67d B = 20 lo
^
'-'i
iE }
FIGURE PS 11-10
...— ——
40
,
—— —[
"t ^~ ---- ®
cV-^ ———\
[
——-^————
Mf-— -/
JT f - ^==
————^,——
in. ,.(
20 -^ . , .. \
.... - - \-/-
<^
——————\t
: ; : ; ::"'L,—
^ -^r — i '
V
—\
-——- I--..;^ ^
d8 0 ^ ^T* r^
———Tf
^-^
^ ^-^
h
,<*"•.»•'•' ——.yc— Sr
——
©
^"-4
^- *-\ ' ' !
• i
—j^"'
i—^— \.- •::
^r—— -\-
-20
^r — — ^ —-^-
^ -T-.\
^
i
t-j ) : ' ! ';
T-'""
1 ..
i '• 1 '•' 1 1
j • : 1i
i ;
• 'i^
'. : 1
i
;
! ;w
-40 —h- i] 1 1 •!
—————(^ : i ; ! * ;!'
, - • ,i
' '—/
i . . ; , .1 , „
. i ' '
L>•'; i11 1n
•
,•
'
i i
1 '
!
• 1 . !
l' i
i L1': i
; ,•
i' ^ , * ;
| ; 1 '
[
• ! ! ' 'i ' 1 ! '' "!
1 i ;
I
'' | • i , . i 1 1. i' 1 '] ^ j
-60
0.01 0.1 1.0 10
^(kHz)
FIGURE PS 11-11
Since the 6 dB/oct slope implies 90° of phase shift, PS 11-12 Construct a Bode plot for the function
2
^•io ^O^'^) -
First show the straight-line approximations for the
Curve b is constant at —43 dB. Therefore amplitude and phase response and then insert the correc-
-43dB = 201ogAb tion factors so that a smooth curve may be constructed.
SOLUTION The amplitude response will be flat from
43 dB' / = 0 Hz until/ = /, = 500 Hz, For/ > f c , the slope rises
A,, = log == 0.00708
20 at 40 dB/dec or 12 dB/oct. Since n = 2, the amplitude
correction factors are 2, 6, and 2 dB at 0.5/,/, and 2 f c
Curve c has fc = 200 Hz and a positive slope of 18 respectively. The phase corrections are approximately
dB/oct. Hence the phase shift is 3(90°) as n = 3. Therefore + 12° and - 12° at O.I/ and 10/ respectively and -12°
and 4-12° at 0.5 / and 2/ respectively. The phase curve
. /V
Ac = [ j will go through 90° at / and approach 0° and 180°
200.
asymptotically for / <S / and / S> / respectively. The
Curve d has f , = 3000 Hz and a negative slope of 24 resultant plot is shown in Fig. PS 11-12.
dB/oct. Therefore PS 11-13 Construct a Bode plot of the transfer
_1____
A,= function A =
/ ^3•
3000/
1 + 7 500 Hzy
FIGURE PS 11-12
R L
470 n 0.6 H
C
E,n
0.02 M?
FIGURE PS 11-14
CD = 100, at which it breaks down again at —20 dB/dec SOLUTION The above transfer function may be re-
and remains so. If correction factors are inserted or written as
Ada is actually computed, the smoothed amplitude CO
response curve results.
COi
The phase response is approximated by lines sloping 2) A =
plus or minus 45°/dec, depending upon whether or not . d} . W
1 +J— 1 + ; —
the term is in the numerator or denominator. The phase (Ui COi
approximations start at 0° at 0.1 a>c, go through 45° Inspection of (2) indicates that the first factor is that of a
at a>,, and terminate at + 90° at 10 u>c. The resultant phase high-pass RC type filter and the second factor is that of a
approximation is illustrated by the stepped phase curve. low-pass filter with identical comer frequencies. There-
For more accuracy, the various correction factors can be fore, in the frequency range co < <Ui, we have the low-
inserted or the actual phase angle of A may be computed pass response climbing at 20 dB/dec while the high-pass
to yield the smoothed phase curve of Fig. PS 11-16. response is flat at 0 dB. At <u = coi, the high-pass re-
PS 11-17 Bode plot the transfer function sponse breaks to zero slope while the low-pass response
breaks downward at —20 dB/dec. This yields the ap-
(U
proximated amplitude response of Fig. PS 11-17.
CD, The approximate phase response may be sketched by
1) A =
0) first drawing the high-pass filter phase response as a line
1 +J
0», starting at co/coi = 0.1, sloping down 45°/dec from +90°
PA 11-1 Deve lop the transfer f unction and Bode plot P»A 11-4 Develop the transfer fu notion and Bode plot
the amplitude re sponse of the cir cuit in Fig. PA I I - l a . t ie amplitude response of the circ uit in Fig. PA ll-4a.
r
L , I/ -
"c 2cji;
1 . T ^
".
Y .[
c
• t 0
1
(a)
0
-dB -20dB\.
dec
16)
'
<0——————
(a>
+• • -6
-dB
(6)
PA 11-2 Deve lopth e transfer function and Bode plot F»A 11-5 Develop the transfer fu notion and Bode plot
the amplitude re sponse of the circuit in Fig. PA 1 l-2a. the ampli tude respomse of the circ uit in Fig. PA ll-5a.
60 kn
o—WSr-t———' i——c ft /? (^ c- RC
50 i
]t °- - I -9.54
x
?s
| ^30 kn ^. -40dB
-9.54 c? ^ c? ^ E0
>>.dec
1 nF ? -dB
^ -dB
0——————•—————« 0
(a) W
(a) w
•
PA 11-3 Deve op th e transfer function and Bode plot P*A 11-6 Develop the transfer fu notion and Bode plot
the amplitude re sponse of the circuit in Fig. PA 11-3a. t he amplitude respo)nse of the circ uit in Fig. PA ll-6a.
' T E -20d^<!
-6.02 - dec ^————— I
c E-0
-'-~-20dB--^
r
(a)
-dB
?1 (a)
C?
0
-dB
dec
tol
-20
ANSWER
0} cy
j 0.01 1 +J 100
A = 10
1 +3
0.01
(0
f[ ll ++j /I ^(- ^
l(V
. / . • a) V, . &)
' ^T ^oT
A =
/ . *" \ / < • (y
^^- ^ 100;
-90
P 11-1 Bode plot the transfer function A = 28,000. P 11-8 Develop the transfer function and construct
the Bode plot for the circuit of Fig. P 11-8.
93 kn
o—VA-
7kn<
CO
P 11 -3 Bode plot the transfer function A = j I^F'
CL>,
/ /-v 1fF
P 11 -4 Bode plot the transfer function A = [ j — I .
\ Jc / -ie
100 kn'
1 kn<
A* _
= .1, +. j. / P 11-12 Develop the transfer function and construct a
5kHz Bode plot for the circuit of Fig. P 11-12.
3n
M
*=0.5;L ^
A =
1 •I I ]
\2 • 1 H-
f
1 +J 80kHz;
-20