Distillery Safety Audit Report (Is 14489)
Distillery Safety Audit Report (Is 14489)
The audit team of M/s ABC Engineers (P) Ltd., Meerut visited the 160 KLPD distillery of
Amba Sugar Limited, Mawana, Dist. Meerut on 28.12.2017 for carrying out the
Occupational Safety & Health Audit as per IS:14489. The general comments and
recommendations are given below:
5. It was observed that though the security staff was found alert on duty but the
physical frisking is not 100%. There is scope for improvement and it should be
ensured to record and physically check every person entering the premises.
6. Loose cables were observed at the MCC as shown and there is need to review
same at all electric control rooms and corrective action may be taken.
7. Auditors were informed about the many recent improvements in fire fighting
arrangements at the factory. It is further recommended to upgrade these
arrangements as per the item “Part B- General Recommendations“ mentioned at
page 3 of HAZOP study of the plant already conducted.
Date: 15.1.2018
(Er.SK GUPTA)
---------------------------------------------------------
INRODUCTION
1.1 PREAMBLE
Amba SugarSugar Limited (BHSL) was incorporated on 23rd November, 1931 under
the name - The Hindusthan Sugar Mills Limited – on the initiative of Jamnalal Bajaj - a
businessman, confidante, disciple and adopted son of Mahatma Gandhi. He sought
Gandhiji's blessings in this new venture, which, apart from being a sound commercial
proposition would also meet a national need. Till then, there were barely thirty sugar
factories in the country.
In the year 1988, The Hindusthan Sugar Mills Limited was renamed as Amba
SugarSugar Limited and shortly thereafter in 1990, Sharda Sugar & Industries Limited
was amalgamated with Amba SugarSugar Limited.
Amba Sugar Limited (Distillery Unit), Mawana, Meerut was established in 2006 and
commenced production in the same year itself..
Amba Sugar Limited, Distillery Unit, Mawana, Dist. Meerut being a prestigious unit of
Amba Sugargroup, needs a well planned strategy for the smooth functioning of the
plant. For the successful Implementation of any plan related to the safety of the plant it
is essential that the various departments and every component of the total system
should be examined critically , this systematic critical examination with the aim of
minimizing loss to organization is termed as “ SAFETY AUDIT ‘’. In safety audit every
component is included e.g. Management policy, attitude to training, features of the
process and of design, emergency plans, personal protection, accident records, medical
& first aid facilities etc. An Audit (as in the field of accountancy) subjects to discuss the
strength and weakness and vulnerability of risk.
The Safety Audit for M/s Amba Sugar Limited, Distillery Unit, Mawana, Dist. Meerut has
been carried out as per the guide notes given in the “Indian Standard code of practice
on Occupational Safety & Health Audit (IS -14489, 1998)’’. The audit research and
recommendations are based on the process data, background information and
discussion held with plant personnel during audit activities. Besides, the auditors have
exercised all reasonable skills and care in carrying out the study.
“ABC ENGINEERS (P) LTD.’’ conducted a safety audit of M/s Amba Sugar Limited,
Distillery Unit, Mawana, Dist. Meerut. The study was conducted as per guidelines
formulated in IS 14489-1998.
1.2 Location:
The plant site is situated at Mawana, Dist Meerut. The site is fairly flat. The site is more
than 550 m away from the railway line and still further from highway and hence meets
the requirements of Department of Environment with respect to its distance from railway
line and highway. There are no archeological monuments, reserved forests, or
sanctuaries in study area. Mawana is about 33 Km from Meerut. Plant is easily
accessible by road.
The Plant is manned on continuous basis the Plant operates in four shifts namely A, B,
C and G Shift. Plant has an approximate strength of 118 employees including 30
contract workers. The shift timings are as under:
The Amba Sugar Limited, Distillery Unit, Mawana, Dist. Meerut is engaged in
manufacturing and storage of chemicals having inflammable characteristics in
appreciable quantities as per the criterion mentioned above. The plant therefore
qualifies for current study under above mentioned rule. While conducting the Safety
Audit, the norms and procedures mentioned in IS – 14489- 1998 were given due
consideration. The scope of study is as under.
1.5 Methodology: The activities carried out in conducting the Safety Audit and
implementing the audit recommendations are given below:
Pre- audit session includes gathering all background information and process data
on Pre – designed questionnaire.
This includes the inspection of areas and activities being carried out in the plant;
discussions with the plant engineers and workmen and checking all the necessary
records with the object of identifying status and effectiveness of the safety systems,
procedures and emergency preparedness at the plant.
The post audit session includes the evaluation of the audit research and observation
and evidences gathered. Findings are discussed with plant management and then
summarized in the form of Audit Report is submitted to Chief Executive of the unit.
Mawana distillery capacity is 160 KLPD. The plant is divided into various blocks with
adequate separation distances. The office block is a building of class “A” construction
with RCC columns 4 slabs and brick masonry walls. The plant has following sections
viz.
Fermentation section
Distillation section
Receiver and bulk storage section
Cooling Tower and water treatment plant
Raw Molasses tank
Molasses unloading pit
Biogas plant
Boiler House
D.M. Plant/ Mechanical workshop
Power House
Bagasse yard
Lagoon for spent wash
Bulk and storage tank
PCC Room
CO2 Recovery Plant
ETP
Etc.
These sections have RCC structure and/or MS columns and ACC sheet roofing. All the
manufacturing sections are of non-combustible construction and fire accident in one of
the manufacturing blocks is not likely to have any impact on the other block.
M/S Amba Sugar Limited, Distillery Unit, Mawana, Dist. Meerut have the approved
building plan from the Directorate of Factories, U.P. and Certificate of Stability of the
entire building from the competent person approved by Directorate of Factories U.P.
Product carrying equipment, pipe-work and valves of the plant are made of standard
materials.
Molasses tank
Fermenter
Analyzer
Pre rectifier
Rectifier
Purifier
Simmering
Condenser
Alcohol storage tank
Boiler
Turbine
Power house
DM RO Bio-digester
ETP (RO)
All the manufacturing sections are located with adequate separation distances to ensure
that a fire in one section does not affect the neighboring section.
The manufacturing/storage areas identified as flame proof zones are provided flame
proof type electric fittings to ensure absence of a source of ignition in the plant.
In Distillery, molasses is used as a raw material, which is the by- product of sugar mills
obtained by final extraction of sugar.
FERMENTATION
In Anaerobic stage the conversion of sugar in to ethyl alcohol and carbon dioxide takes
place. -
INVERTASE
ZYMASE
DISTILLATION
DISTILLATIONSECTION
Y E A S T V E S S E L
TESTTUBE 3 0 0 L I T
WASH
ANALYSER COLUM FOCCOLUMN ATM RECEIVER IMPURE
CONICAL VACUME SPIRIT
C V - 2 Y E A S T W A S H C L E A R T A N K
RS ENA SDS
1LIT. V E S S E L 8 0 0 L I T 1 0 . 0 L A C
SPENTWASH
L I T
C V - 3 Y E A S T F E R M E N T O R RUM
V E S S E L 8 0 0 0 1 0 . 0 L A C L I T
L I T
MOLASSES V E S S E L 3 2 0 0 0 1 . 6 0 L A C L I T
L I T
P U R I F I E R C O L U M N RECEIVER RS
F O R E N A A T M
WATER
SALE
STORAGEVATS RS
CHAPTER -3
The Safety Audit was conducted as per standards and procedures as well as area of
concern laid down in the IS – 14489-98 “CODE OF PRACTIE ON OCCUPTATIONAL
SAFETY AND HEALTH’’. The areas of occupational safety and health system covered
in audit are as follows:
M/s Amba Sugar Limited, Distillery Unit, Mawana have enunciated an integrated
Environmental, Occupational Health & Safety Policy which indicates company’s total
commitment towards preservation of environment and ensuring occupational health and
safety of company’s employees, plant and who so ever visits the plant.
The policy has been prepared as per guidelines of the statutory requirement.
Plant has a Safety Officer. The details of the Safety Officer are as follows:
Plant has a Fire Safety department. Mr. Beer Singh Choudhary is the Head of the
department and the total strength is 5.
- The safety committee meets as often as necessary but at least once in six
months.
- Safety committee has the right to be adequately and suitable informed of:
(a) Potential safety and health hazards to which the workers may be exposed at
work place.
(b) Data on accident as well as data resulting from surveillance of the working
environment and of the health of the workers exposed to hazardous substances so
far as the factory is concerned.
(c) All the accidents occurred in previous 15 days and analyzed suggested remedial
measures are implemented or not.
(f) Safety points pertaining to individual areas are discussed and plan of action is
framed or not
- Dealing with all matters concerning health, safety and environment and to arrive
at practicable solution to problems encountered.
- Carrying out health and safety survey and identifying causes of accidents.
- Looking into any complaint made on the likelihood of an imminent danger to the
safety and health of the workers and suggesting corrective measures; and
There is no separate Safety budget. Suitable expenditures under this head is made at
the unit level as per the need. Any major expenditure on this account is made as per the
recommendations made by the Safety Officer and other officers of the unit and/or
review/decision taken by Unit Head and at regional/ head office level.
The medical attendants are available round the clock in the center. One
ambulance is available round the clock.
Distillery has the occupational safety and health center that conforms to the provision of
Factories Act, 1948. The medical attendant is available round the clock in the OHC.
One ambulance is available round the clock in the plant.
The factory has made the provision for the personnel protective equipment within the
plant, which are regularly used by the workers and these can be useful in case of
emergency are as under:
Safety Helmets,
Rubber gloves,
Asbestos gloves,
canvas gloves,
Safety Belts,
Ear plugs,
Dust masks,
Safety goggles,
Gum boots,
Ear mufs,
Face Sheilds,
PVC Suit,
PVC Apron
Etc.
In the process plant all processes are closed type so there is no chance of
fumes/gases present within the plant during normal plant operation but the fumes
may be generated in the plant due to leakage in vessels/pipelines and during the
collection of samples.
No dusty process is carried out in the process plant. However bagasse is used
in boilers as fuel and bagasse dust is observed at bagasse storage. Bagasse
dust is controlled by sprinkling water using water monitors. Workers also use
appropriate PPEs in this area.
All the moving machines and storage areas of hazardous chemicals are well guarded/
fenced in the plant. Plant is also guarded round the clock by the security staff.
The process and equipments capable of generating and accumulating static charge
have been identified. All such equipments are properly bonded and earthed. Electrical
earth resistance measurement and continuity tests are carried out periodically and test
record is maintained in plant- Annexure 10.
A. Lifting machines
All the examination and test document of the lifting machine, ropes and lifting
tackles are maintained in the Register as per ‘The U.P. factories Rule, 1950’.
Adequate lifting tackles are provided at all places where it is required and are
maintained in good conditions.
Plant has hand trolleys; tractor trolleys as well as fork lift for transportation of
materials. All the mobile equipment is in good condition & installed with muffler .
Ventilation:
Effective ventilation system is provided in the working area. Almost in all working areas,
natural ventilation system is provided.
Illuminations:
Effective illumination system (natural and electric lighting) system is provided in working
areas, the employees do not feel any discomfort conditions of darkness.
Noise:
The management has a system to conduct work place monitoring in plant area to
assess contents of chemical escaping into atmosphere.
Every employee so declared medically fit would conform to the medical fitness norms in
accordance with the rules standards prescribed by the company.
All employees are also medically examined every 6 months by the Factory Medical
Officer.
Technical aspects:
The written safe procedures of various equipments installed in plant are available at
plant. The safety procedures for plant operation and maintenance highlights need of
work permit requirement, training in use of personal, protective equipment, preparation
for maintenance work, release of plant and equipment, preparation for maintenance
work, release of plant and equipment pressure, opening of malfunctioning equipment,
entry into equipment. No contractor workers are deployed on any main stream process/
operation.
Access:
All accesses are maintained in sound condition. Oiling and greasing points are located
at safe places not liable to drip into walk ways.
3.26 Work permit system: A written permit to work system for hot work, working at
height, Rigging, vessel/tank entry, digging/excavation and cold work exists in the plant
The Safety and fire fighting arrangement available within the plant is as under:
7 Portable fire extinguishers The plant has provided total 72 nos. of portable
fire extinguishers all around the plant to cover
entire plant area.
Fire extinguishers/ hydrants/ water monitors/hose boxes/ nozzles etc are regularly
checked/ tested. The plant has full-fledged trained fire fighting staff under direct control
of Safety officer. These employees are selected from various departments ensuring that
these are uniformly distributed in all shifts. Apart from them, all the security guards are
also trained in fire fighting.
Plant has a detailed On Site Emergency Plan, and mock drill is conducted once
in three month as per On Site Emergency Plan.
The office of the Unit Head in the distillery is the emergency control center and
plant has two numbers of assembly points, these are located at the distillery
administrative building and near distillery main gate.
The emergency team and key personnel have been identified in the On Site
Emergency Plan.
The fixed line telephone and mobile phone is the primary mode of
communication service at the distillery. Electric siren is available for sounding
emergency. Email and fax is available.
Distillery has mutual aid available through the Amba Sugar group Sugar Plant.
Mawana distillery has installed a well maintained ETP Plant. The total effluent is being
treated by bio-gas plant and concentrated through RO Plant. After that concentrated
effluent is being gainfully utilized in Bio- composting. Distillery has also upgraded
treatment system by installing a new 6 stage multi Effect Evaporator System.
The management has adequate facilities for storing of raw materials as well as of
final product.
All the tanks are clearly marked by name of the content inside the tank. The
storage areas are clearly/ marked / defined.
In stores all the racks and steel cages are kept in good condition.
As informed the workers, handling the material, are acquainted with the hazards
associated with the material. Also, they are trained in safe procedure of handling
the material.
All the electrical installation in the tanks, process section where flammable
materials handled or stored are flames proof and which can generate static
charge are earthed and bonded.
The fire extinguishers and/ or water monitors are provided in these areas.
No Contract workers are involved in plant operations. The contractor workers are
hired for other variety of jobs.
- All contractors/ sub contractors labours and transporters engaged in all kinds of
jobs are directed to follow safe and healthy work practices as described by the
company from time to time.
The material data sheets of all the hazardous materials are available at the plant,