Modelling of DG Sets
Modelling of DG Sets
In this paper, we are studying an innovative solution to Université du Québec à Rimouski, 300 allée des
reduce fuel consumption and production cost for electricity ursulines, Rimouski, Québec G5L 3A1, Canada
b Entreprise EO-SYNCHRO, Département De la
production by diesel generators. The solution is particularly
suitable for remote areas where the cost of energy is very Recherche et Du Développement, 201 Rue
high not only of inherent cost of technology but also due to Monseigneur Bourget, Lévis, Québec, G6V 6Z9,
Canada
transportation cost. After a brief description of power
generation based on a conventional synchronous alternator, 1 [email protected] 2 [email protected]
3 [email protected]
the attention is focused on the Eo-Synchro concept. Then 4 [email protected] 5 [email protected]
an innovative approach for optimizing the energy is
proposed; it is based from the fact that the structure that
contains the stator windings of the alternator is mounted on
roller bearings which allows its free rotation around the axis peaking at 147$CAD/barrel in July 2008, averaging over
of the rotor, consequently stopping the rotor structure from 100$/barrel during 2011, averaging over 110$/barrel until
being static and aims to minimize the unit cost of electricity. October 2014, and then it fell to 80$/barrel. Recently, the
Our model yields improved performance on fuel saving at oil price is around 45$/barrel. Despite this considerable
all generator load stages compared to the conventional drop, the diesel fuel prices are losing only a few cents in
model. Experimental results on a 75kW Diesel Generator some provinces in Canada. According to Statistic Canada, in
(DG) validate the performance of the proposed model. St. John’s Newfoundland, the diesel fuel lost only 5.7¢/L,
and in Whitehorse in Yukon increased by 3.5¢/L and in
Keywords Yellowknife in Northwest Territories was set to rise up to
9.3¢/L in October 2014 compared to 2013. According to
Diesel generator, power generation system, electrical Statistics Canada (http://www5.statcan.gc.ca), the decline in
machines, control of rotor speed, control of stator speed, crude oil prices is not felt at the pump in this region.
Eo-Synchro concept, fuel saving. However, the pump price gasoline only decreased by
11.8¢/L from a high of $112 per barrel to a low of $35 per
barrel in December 2015. Therefore, the decrease in oil
1. Introduction prices has not greatly affected the price of diesel fuel,
Most of the remote and isolated communities or technical which implies that the electrical energy produced using only
installations (communication relays, meteorological systems, oil and energy source will always remain expensive, at any
tourist facilities, farms, etc) that are not connected to cost per barrel [6]. According to Hydro Quebec, extending
national electric distribution grids rely on diesel engines to the main grid to these isolated areas will cost around
generate electricity [1]. In Canada, approximately 200,000 (1M $/km), which is impossible to do with the actual
people live in more than 300 remote communities (Yukon, economic crisis.
Northwest Territories, Nunavut, etc) that use diesel
generated electricity, which is responsible for the emission There are two types of DGs. The first type consists of a
of 1.2 million tons of greenhouse gases annually [2]. In Diesel Engine (DE) running at a fixed speed coupled with a
Quebec alone, there are over 14,000 subscribers scattered in Synchronous Generator (SG); this solution has the
about forty communities that are not connected to the main advantage of simplicity. However, there are some
electrical grid. Each community constitutes an autonomous drawbacks, including high level of noise regardless of the
network that uses diesel generators for electricity power level required by the load, high level of greenhouse
production [3]. The diesel power generating units, while gases emission (GHG) even when load power demand is
requiring relatively little investment, are generally expensive low and over dimensioning in case of non-linear or
to exploit and maintain, particularly when they are unbalanced loads. The second type of DG operates with a
functioning regularly at partial load [4]. The use of diesel variable speed. In this option the DE is coupled with an
power generators under weak operating factors accelerates electrical generator operating at variable speed. This
wear and increases fuel consumption [5]. During the past concept is able to reduce fuel consumption and reduce the
several years, the oil prices have achieved historic highs, cost of DG power generation [7]. Currently, most existing
DGs in remote areas operate at a constant rotational speed variable speeds in direct relation to the electrical load demand
due to the restriction of the constant frequency required at [12]. In a previous work [13], Peter Dengler and Marcus
the terminals of the generator. This operating mode causes Geimer from Karlsruhe Institute of Technology demonstrated
high fuel consumption, as well as increases the maintenance that using an electronic converter is an easier way to provide a
costs [6]. To overcome these drawbacks, variable speed system at variable engine speed but at constant electric
DGs are being proposed as an alternate configuration frequency (VSCF). These devices are already available on the
(Pena et al, 2008). Compared to the fixed speed DGs, market for other purposes, but a system with a generator in
variable speed DGs, are more efficient but costly, due to the VSCF technology is still not established in the market as their
use of power converters or mechanical transmissions. higher investment costs are not yet proved to be economically
justified by lower fuel consumption [13]. The objective of this
In our project, we investigate another possibility that, when study is to demonstrate that the Eo-Synchro application is
coupled to a DG operating in a power unit (Figure 1), the able to reduce the fuel consumption and to reduce the cost of
alternator with the Eo-Synchro application features can DG power generation. The structure of the present article is
operate at variable speeds without the need for costly power as follows. Section 3. presents the design approach of the
electronics components to generate a constant frequency at active power generation by a synchronous alternator in
the generator terminals. Per its configuration, the system can general followed by the mechanical concept of Eo-Synchro
compensate for a lower or higher heat motor speed with no and its principle control. In Section 4. we present the bench
perturbation on the wave quality of the electricity being test and discuss the results obtained in order to demonstrate
generated. It can operate in instant and/or prolonged mode, the efficiency of Eo-Synchro technology for generator
depending on the desired application. The system can applications. In Section 5. we provide a preliminary
therefore be used to compensate brief speed fluctuations or conclusion of our study and a perspective for future work.
extended under-speed use while still compensating for
intermittent and brief speed fluctuations [7, 8].
3. The design approach
3.1 Three phase synchronous alternator
The active power which is supplied by a three-phase
synchronous generator is given by:
MECHANICAL
COUPLING E0 Eb
P = sinδ(1)
Xs
EO- where:
HEAT SYNCHRO
ALTERNATOR WITH
MOTOR MOBILE STATOR P = active power provided per phase (W);
E0 = induced voltage per phase (V);
Eb = voltage across terminal per phase (V);
Xs = synchronous resistance per phase (Ω);
δ = internal phase difference angle between E0 and Eb, in electrical
degree.
When the motor develops a torque, the poles of the rotor synchronous speed) is 1,800rpm. In a synchronous alternator,
move backward of the poles of the stator. the rotating speed of the stator field must be identical to the
rotating speed of the rotor field. The two fields are therefore
In a standard synchronous alternator, the stator is stationary. stationary with respect to one another and rotate at a constant
If a torque is applied to the rotor, its axis has a tendency to speed. From a mechanical point of view, if free rotation of
deviate from the central axis of the stator. Figure 2 confirms the stator is possible, the equation which describes the
this principle for a synchronous motor however, it is applied synchronous speed n in rpm is the following:
as well to a synchronous alternator.
nsync = nrotor – nstator (4)
and by transmutation,
Standard Rotor
Stator on Bearings
Electric machine
Synchronous
alternator Casing of Compensating
motor
controlling unit can be provided as a programmable logic PF and the total harmonic distortion (TDH) of the current
controller, a computer or any other processing unit for and voltage.
example. The variable speed drive is typically powered using
the electric current produced by the alternator and the Y1: CURRENT Y2: CURRENT
VOLTAGE VOLTAGE
frequency regulation consequently consumes part of the
POWER POWER
produced power, but the total balance of produced electric PF PF
power remains positive. By controlling the rotation of the THD THD
stator about the rotor, the relative speed, and thereby the
frequency of the generated electric current, can be regulated
[18]. For example, in a typical wind turbine generator
(Figure 7), a 60Hz alternating current is generated in a 4-pole-
3-phase alternator that rotates at 1,800rpm [19].
DE SA
COUPLE
SPEED
MECHANICAL DRV
POWER
Compensating
Motor
Figure 8 Schematic of the bench test
Three phase
alternator Figure 9 shows the main components of the bench test and
their technical characteristics. All tests were performed with a
mechanical power between 20kW and 60kW at 600V and a
speed ranging from 1,400rpm to 1,800rpm.
Figure 7 The Eo-Synchro applied in a wind turbine
Table 1 Evaluation of fuel consumption with a blocked stator with a blocked stator. However, when the load is increased to
80%, we achieved a significant gain of 7% on fuel
Blocked Stator Without Eo-Synchro Intervention consumption followed by 8% for a load of 90%.
Load Load Consumption Engine speed Unfortunately, the test was suspended at 100% when the load
(%) (kW) g/kWh (rpm) was increased to 100% because the spyder had broken.
5. Conclusion
This article presented the innovative features of the
Eo-Synchro technology which originate from a rotational
non-fixed stator design and a fuel savings evaluation for a
DE generator application that can be achieved by
controlling the rotation of the stator. A decrease of the
heat losses to the DE exhaust is facilitated by allowing for
lower engine operating speed at low power load with the
Figure 10 Example of a typical electrical daily load Eo-Synchro technology. For this reason significant fuel
profile in a remote area. The peak load for any savings of up to 12% can be obtained at low DE
community occurs during the daytime hours when generator power loads (40%). The maximum gas pressure
residents, businesses and manufacturers consume in the combustion chamber has to stay below a certain
electricity at their peak demand. threshold and limits the intake pressure and therefore the
fuel savings can be realized. This is why the fuel economy
is higher for lower loads. Based on our results, for a 1MW
Table 3 shows the fuel consumption difference between the DE generator unit, the fuel saving are projected to be 23g
conventional generator model (stator is fixed) and when per kWh at 90% load. For an 1MW unit producing
Eo-Synchro technology is applied. As we can see, results 1,000kWh, fuel savings would be 23kg/h. For equivalent
obtained at 60% and 70% of applied loads are highlighted in purposes, as 1 liter of fuel weighs approximately 0.85kg,
red because they are very close to a conventional generator we can assume fuel saving of 27 liters/h, which represents
While the present paper presents the original aspect of [7] Fiset Jean, Canadian Intellectual Property Office
Eo-Synchro technology and theoretical results that are valid -Patent no.2580360: Energy Transfer Apparatus
for a small DE, some preliminary experimental results [8] Fiset Jean, Canadian Intellectual Property Office
under a 500kW DE were conducted under a new test bench -Patent no.2697420 :Mechanical Regulation Of
by PhD researchers at University of Quebec in Rimouski Electrical Frequency In An Electrical
and will be published shortly. The published experimental Generation System
results cover a mathematical model to characterize the [9] Jean Fiset, Tony Durand, United States Patent &
generated power model and the results of fuel economy Trademark Office - Patent no.
savings obtained. n US8258641B2:Mechanical Regulation Of
Electrical Frequency In An Electrical
Generation System
Nomenclature
[10] Jean Fiset, Tony Durand, Australian Patent -
DE Diesel Engine Patent no. 2008291635:Mechanical Regulation
DG Diesel Generator Of Electrical Frequency In An Electrical
VSCF Variable Speed @ Constant Frequency Generation System
SA Synchronous Alternator [11] TiberiuTudorache, and Cristian Roman: The
Numerical Modeling of Transient Regimes of
DRV Drive
Diesel Generator Sets.
SG Synchronous Generator ActaPolytechnicaHungarica, vol. 7(2), 2010.
GHG Green House Gases emission
[12] ChemNayar : Innovative Remote Micro-Grid
PF Power Factor Systems. International Journal of Environment
TDH Total Distortion Harmonic and SustainabilityISSN 1927‐9566 | Vol. 1 No.
3, pp. 53‐65 (2012), Regen Group Pty Ltd,
Curtin University of Technology, Western
Australia, Australia
[13] Peter Dengler and Marcus Geimer : Potential of
Reduced Fuel Consumption of Diesel Electric
References
APUs at Variable Speed in Mobile Applications
[1] Ibrahim H, Younes R, Basbous T, Ilinca A, - Peter Dengler and Marcus Geimer Karlsruhe
Dimitrova M. Optimization of diesel engine Institute of Technology
performances for a hybrid wind-diesel system
[14] WILDI, T. SYBILLE, G., Électrotechnique, 4e
with compressed air energy storage. Energy
édition, PUL 2005.
2011;36:3079—91.
[15] Geoff Klempner and IsidorKerszenbaum,
[2] Liu W, Gu S, Qiu D. Techno-economic
Handbook of Large Turbo-Generator
assessment for off-grid hybrid generation
Operation & Maintenance. Chapter One:
systems and the application prospects in China,
Principles of operation of synchronous
http://www.
machine.
worldenergy.org/wecgeis/publications.
[16] Marian Kazmierkowski, The Electric
[3] Ibrahim H, Ilinca A. Younes R, Basbous T.
Generators Handbook : Synchronous
Study of a hybrid wind-diesel system with
Generators, Ion Boldea 2006
compressed air energy storage, electrical power
conference 2007, "Renewable and alternative [17] L.L.J. Mahon, Diesel Generator Handbook 1992
energy resources", EPC2007. Montreal, Canada: [18] HAU, E., Wind Turbines, 2nd edition, Springer
IEEE Canada; 2007. October 25-25, 2007 2006
[4] Hunter R, Elliot G. Wind-diesel systems-a guide [19] NREL, Advanced Control Design and Field
to the technology and its implementation. Testing for Wind Turbines at the National
Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press; Renewable Energy Laboratory, NREL/CP-500-
1994. 36118, 2004
[5] Forcione A. Système jumelé éolien-Diesel aux [20] MIA M. DEVINE, Analysis Of Electric Loads
îles-de-la-Madeleine (Cap-auxMeules)- And Wind-Diesel Energy Options For Remote
Établissement de la VAN optimale. Institut de Power Stations in Alaska, M.S., University Of
Recherche, HydroQuébec, Février; 2004. Massachusetts, February 2005.