Global Research: Equity
Global Research: Equity
Saudi Arabia
Mihir J. Marfatia
Financial Analyst
[email protected]
Phone No:(965) 2400551 Ext.421
Abeer Gouda
Financial Analyst
[email protected]
Phone No:(965) 2400551 Ext.501
Global Research - Saudi Arabia Global Investment House
Listing: BUY
Saudi Stock Exchange
Current Price
SR65.5 (Oct 09, 2007)
Investment Summary
• The company went public in 2004 following an IPO on the Saudi Stock Exchange in
October 2004, which raised US$267mn for 20% of its shares. The remaining shares
are held by Etisalat which owns 35% of Mobily, while 45% of the shares are held
by 6 local entities including a 15% stake held by the government of Saudi Arabia
through the General Organization for Social Insurance.
• Mobily launched its services in May 2005, and ended the year with 2.3mn subscribers,
capturing a market share of 16%. By the end of 2006, the company’s subscriber’s base
rose to 6mn subscribers, thus increasing its market share to 31%. Mobily managed
to break-even in 2006 with an EBITDA of SR2bn and net income of SR700.36mn.
The company’s strong performance has been supported by Saudi’s relatively lower
mobile penetration rates, and supportive regulatory environment.
• The company has been capitalizing on KSA’s low broadband and data penetration
rates which stood at 1% in 2006. In June 2006, Mobily launched its 3.5G services
covering 19 cities in the Kingdom, and ended the year with 500,000 users of 3G, and
3.5G, representing a market share of 58% of 3G users in 2006. In 2007, the company
doubled the broadband mobile Internet speed and introduced a 7.2 Mbps modems
and data service SIM cards based on HSDPA (high-speed downlink packet access).
• The company agreed with Bayanat Al-Oula and Integrated Telecom Company to
build, deploy and operate the Kingdom’s largest fiber optic network with a total value
of SR1bn that will cover 12,000 km of highways as well as cities Kingdom-wide.
The new network, which is scheduled for completion in 2008, will likely reduce
operational costs as the company develops its own international gateway, which will
lead to the decline in international gateway costs as well as the reduction in national
and international roaming costs as the company increases its own network coverage.
Accordingly, we expect an improvement in EBITDA margins going forward.
• In March 2007, MTC of Kuwait (Zain) won the bid for Saudi Arabia’s third mobile
license which included 2G, 3G and international licenses for a price of US$6.1bn
(SR22.9bn). We expect the entrance of a third operator to have a greater effect on
the operator with the largest market share, STC, than on Mobily. Though, we expect
further reduction in mobile tariffs with increased competition, we believe that the
focus on high quality services based on the latest technologies will be the main
differentiator between the competitors.
Investment Indicators
Price as on Shares in issue Market Cap 52-week price
October 9, 2007 (SR) (mn) (SRbn) range (SR)
65.5 500 32.75 38 - 73
Year EBITDA Net Profit EPS BVPS ROE P/E P/BV
(SR 000) (SR 000) (SR) (SR) (%) (x) (x)
2008 E 3,553,321 1,945,762 3.89 15.58 24.86 16.83 4.20
2007 E 2,786,234 1,310,797 2.62 11.69 22.43 24.98 5.60
2006 2,000,504 700,358 1.40 9.07 15.45 37.12 5.74
2005* (112,767) (1,167,379) - 7.67 - - -
Source: Annual Reports and Global Research estimates *From 14/12/2004 to 31/12/2005
* Historical P/E & P/BV multiples pertain to respective year-end prices, while those for future years are based on
market price in the Saudi Stock Exchange as on October 9, 2007.
15,000
100
10,000
5,000 50
0 0
01.01.06
03.04.06
26.06.06
18.09.06
19.12.06
20.03.07
12.06.07
04.09.07
Abundant liquidity…
The Saudi economy has enjoyed a strong liquidity position as can be seen in the 20% y-
o-y increase in Money supply (M2) in 2006. This was mainly on the back of the 37% in
Time and Savings Deposits. The increase in interest rates combined with the correction
in stock markets encouraged investors to move their investment in safer time deposits
in banks which led to strong rise in the time and saving deposits. But inflation has not
been a concern for the Saudi economy as according to Ministry of Finance, inflation, as
measured by the Consumer Price Index is estimated to have increased only by 1.8% in
2006.
Company (WEC) was established by the Supreme Economic Council to promote private
investments in the IWPPs. Marafiq is also planning an IWPP in the industrial city of
Jubail with an estimated cost of SR9.4bn (US$2.5bn). As per SAGIA, overall power
capacity in Saudi Arabia is forecasted to grow to 59,000 MW by the year 2024 requiring
an estimated investment of SR430bn (US$115bn). To achieve this target the ministry
will have to present several joint projects to the private sector, local and foreign, in order
to increase power generation capacity. Saudi Arabia’s Communications and Information
Technology Commission (CITC) has also liberalized the telecom sector through the
offering of the Kingdom’s second fixed-line phone license and third mobile phone
license to foreign investors.
(For a detailed analysis of the Saudi economy please refer to our Saudi Economic and
Strategic Outlook)
Company Overview
Background
Expanding strongly…
Mobily launched its services in May 2005, and ended the year with 2.3mn subscribers,
capturing a market share of 16%. By the end of 2006, the company’s subscriber’s base
rose to 6mn subscribers, thus increasing its market share to 31%. Mobily managed to
break-even in 2006 with an EBITDA of SR2bn and net income of SR700.36mn.
Huawei. In May 2007, the company announced a plan to award a SR1bn (US$266.7mn)
contract to expand its 3G network to cover more Saudi cities. In June 2007, the company
doubled the broadband mobile Internet speed on its network, with an HSDPA (high-
speed downlink packet access) speed of 3.6 Mbps. Later in September 2007, the company
introduced a 7.2 Mbps modems and data service SIM cards also based on HSDPA.
Management
The company’s management is led by Mr. Khaled Al Kaf, who is the chief executive
officer and managing director of the company. Since inception, Mobily’s management
has applied the right strategies in capitalizing on the Saudi mobile market growth
potential. The company has managed to grab a market share of 16% in the first year
of operation and 31% in the second through the launch of innovative and new services
in the market. Though the company has been offering services at lower costs than the
incumbent operator, management has focused on the differentiation strategy in building
its customers base. As such, the company has attracted customers through the introduction
of new services into the market. Mobily also catered to the needs of corporate customers
through the introduction of Blackberry services in the Kingdom. Management has been
also focusing on the 3G and broadband services which cater to the young segment of the
Saudi population of which 32% are in the age of 10 to 24. At the end of 2006, Mobily
had a 58% market share of 3G users in the kingdom, higher than the incumbent’s market
share. Management’s latest decision to acquire the local service provider, Bayanat Al
Oula Company is also expected to reinforce Mobily’s market position in the 3G and data
segment.
The company underwent an IPO on the Saudi Stock Exchange in October 2004, which
raised US$267mn for 20% of its shares. The remaining shares are held by Etisalat which
owns 35% of Mobily, while 45% of the shares are held by 6 local entities including a
15% stake held by the government of Saudi Arabia through the General Organization
for Social Insurance.
Mobily’s started with a paid-up capital of SR5bn with a par value of SR50 per share. In
April 2006, the company effected a 1:5 stock split increasing the number of outstanding
shares to 500mn shares with a par value of SR10 per share. Mobily’s shares started
trading on the Saudi Stock Exchange (Tadawul) on December 19th 2004. The stock
ended the year 2005 with turnover ratio of 156%. During 2006, trading on the stock was
affected by the wave of stock market corrections in the region with a total volume traded
of 471.1mn shares, a 39% drop from 2005. Turnover dropped to 94% in 2006.
During 2007, the total volume of shares traded YTD was 124.3mn shares. The stock
closed at SR65.5 at the end of trading on October 9, 2007 with a market cap of SR32.75bn,
forming 2.5% of the total market cap of Tadawul as on October 9, 2007. During the past
52 weeks, the stock traded within a band of SR73-38 per share.
Regulatory Environment
CITC, the regulator
The Communication and Information Technology Commission (CITC) was established
in 2001 as a stand-alone legal entity with financial and administrative independence. Its
mandate includes regulating the Information Communication Technology (ICT) sector
in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and promoting information technology (IT) adoption
in the country. The Ministry of Communications and Information Technology (MCIT)
is mainly concerned with supervising activities of the Communications and Information
Technology (IT) sector in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. CITC reports to MCIT, and is
responsible for licensing, numbering, setting interconnection guidelines, price regulation,
equipment approval, spectrum management , and overseeing the quality of service. CITC
is also responsible for the liberalization and the opening up of the data, mobile, and fixed
markets.
In February 2007, the Saudi government introduced a new legislation designed to boost
investment in the telecom sector. The decision entails that any company licensed to
provide mobile phone services has to float at least 40% of its capital for public subscription
while any new fixed services provider must float at least 25% of its capital. In addition, it
decided to reduce the fees levied by the government on fixed services from 15% to 10%.
Telecom Act
2001
CITC formed
Telecom Bylaw
2002
IPO of STC
3G services launched
2006
MNP launched
10
8
US$ bn
6
6.7 8.1
4.7 5.6
4 2.1 2.8
Source: CITC
Saudi Arabia is one of biggest economies, and highly populated countries in the region,
a favorable environment for telecom operators. Saudi Population has been growing at a
CAGR of 2.7% from 2001-2006. During 2006, KSA population grew by 3.8% to reach a
total population of 24mn. Expatriate population form around 30% of the total population
of Saudi Arabia. The increasing young population has been one of the underlying factors
of the increasing mobile phone usage in Saudi Arabia, with around 32% of the population
in the age of 10 to 24.
10.0 15.0%
10.0%
5.0
5.0%
0.0 0.0%
KSA UAE Kuwait Oman Qatar Bahrain
Fixed Market
No Longer a Monopoly…
Fixed line subscribers approached 4mn subscribers at the end of 2006, translating into
a penetration rate of 16.5% and a household teledensity of around 70% (70 residential
phones for every 100 households). Residential lines formed around 75% of the fixed
lines in Saudi. The country’s fixed market was controlled by the incumbent operator,
STC, until April 2007, when CITC liberated the market and issued three licenses to
the three consortia led by Batleco, Hong Kong’s PCCW, and US-based Verizon
Communications.
4
1
0.8 0.9 0.9
3 0.7 0.7
2
mn
1
2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 3
0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Source: CITC
Getting Bigger….
As per the government’s new regulation, the three groups must float 25% of their shares
to the public and 10% to the General Organization for Social Insurance (GOSI) and the
Pension Fund before the start of operations, expected in 2008. Their fixed line coverage
should reach at least three regions in three years and the whole country in seven years.
Each operator should cover at least 3% of the country by fiber optics network or 15% by
wireless network within seven years of operation.
The PCCW and Batelco consortia are planning to use wireless broadband technology,
WiMax, to offer landline services. They made 52 separate bids each for spectrums in 13
regions. Verizon didn’t go through the bid phase because it didn’t apply for a spectrum,
and will operate an optical wire fixed line service.
Internet users in Saudi Arabia grew at a CAGR of 36% from 2001 to 2006 to reach 4.7mn
users in 2006. The year 2006 however witnessed the highest y-o-y growth rate, growing
by 57% from 3mn users in 2005. Penetration rate stood at 19.6% in 2006 compared to
13% in 2005. KSA internet penetration rate is the fourth in the GCC region after UAE,
Kuwait, and Bahrain, however lower than an average of around 22% for the region.
10 % 25
%
2 10 17
8
6
1 5 5 12
8
0 0 0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 UAE Kuwait Bahrain KSA Qatar Oman
Internet Users Penetration Rates Penetration Rates
Source: CITC
Broadband subscribers grew from 14 thousand subscribers in 2001 to around 220 thousand
in 2006, with a whopping y-o-y increase of 240% in 2006. DSL subscribers which stood
at 194 thousand subscribers in 2006 formed 89% of total broadband subscribers and
grew by a remarkable 273% over the number of DSL subscribers in 2005. Despite the
remarkable growth, still KSA broadband penetration rate, which stood at 1% in 2006,
is considered a very low rate when compared to both the world average of 5% and the
developed countries average of around 20%.
240 0.91 1
210
0.8
180
150 0.6
120
‘000
90 0.27 0.4
60 0.11 0.15 0.2
0.06 0.08
30
0 0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Source: CITC
Mobile Market
Monopoly, Duopoly, Triopoly…
The Saudi mobile market has been a monopoly since STC was established in 1998,
however after Mobily won the second license and launched its operation in 2005, STC
has been losing market share to Mobily which managed to grab a market share of 16% in
the first year of operations and increased it to 31% in 2006. In March 2007, the duopoly
was broken when a consortium led by MTC of Kuwait (Zain) won the third license.
Growing Market…
KSA mobile subscribers grew at a CAGR of 51% during the period from 2001 to 2006
with penetration rates jumping from 12% in 2001 to 82% in 2006. During 2005, when
Mobily launched its operations, subscribers grew by 54% from 9.2mn subscribers in
2004 to 14.2 subscribers in 2005 compared to a y-o-y growth rate of 27% in 2004. During
2006, mobile subscribers grew by 38% on an annual basis to reach 19.6mn subscribers
of which 870,000 were 3G customers.
82
20 100
61 80
15
40 60
10
%
mn
32
23 40
5 12
20
0 0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
40,000 33,122
30,160 80%
30,000 20,533 60%
20,000 14,528 13,696 40%
10,000 20%
- 0%
Qatar Kuwait UAE Bahrain KSA Oman
Expected to increase…
We believe that mobile penetration in Saudi Arabia will cross the 100% mark in the next
few years to reach 130% in 2010.The key drivers for the growth in penetration rates will
be increasing demand for mobiles among younger generation, increasing competition
in the local market driving down the usage cost, increasing economic activities in the
country requiring telecom infrastructure support, and the government’s intention to
liberalize various sectors as part of joining WTO.
60
Halalah/min
40
20
0
KSA Bahrain Qatar Oman UAE Kuwait GCC
Average
Prepaid Postpaid
Chart 11: ARPUs and EBITDA margins for selected operators in GCC
80.0 60
50.3 50.1 51.3
47.3 47.1 50
60.0
40
35.5
%
US$
30.1
40.0 32.4 30
20
20.0
10
0.0 0
ily
l
C
o
a
t
TC
el
te
la
iy
lc
ST
-T
an
ob
isa
te
an
M
Q
m
Ba
M
Et
at
O
W
STC ranked the first among its regional peers in terms of market cap., revenues and
profit. The company’s market cap. stood at US$34.2bn on October 9, 2007. The company
recorded revenues of US$9bn for 2006, with net profit of US$3.4bn. Mobily ended its
second year of operations with revenues of US$1.6bn and a net profit of US$187mn.
Mobily’s market cap stood at US$8.8bn on October 9, 2007. During the first half of
2007, Mobily’s revenues stood at US$1bn, while net profit stood at US$148mn during
the same period.
Competitors’ Profile
Saudi Telecom Company (STC)
The company reported revenues of SR33.7bn for 2006 increasing by 3.8% on a year
on year basis, while net income increased by 2.8% over the year 2005. STC’s mobile
subscribers’ base is estimated to have increased by 19% to reach 13.8mn at the end of
2006, capturing around 70% market share, while fixed line subscribers approached 4mn
subscribers by the end of 2006.
STC was awarded a 3G license in July 2005 for SR753.7mn, and launched its 3G
network in June 2006. The company selected Huawei Technologies Company, a leading
provider of next generation telecommunications network solutions to deploy the first
WiMAX 802.16e-based network in the Middle East, covering major cities including
Riyadh, Jeddah and Dammam. Under the agreement, Huawei will design and deploy an
end-to-end WiMAX 802.16e network including Base Station, Access Service Network
Gateway, Network Management System, as well as an Authorization, Authentication
and Accounting system.
STC is still playing a leading role in the internet and data markets. However, the company
operates in a very competitive environment that includes more than 50 ISP providers,
8 VSAT operators, and another 2 data service providers namely Integrated Telecom
company (ITC), and Bayanat Al Oula Co.
Following the break-up of STC’s monopoly , and increasing competition in the Saudi
telecom market, the company started considering inorganic growth opportunities. In
June 2007, STC entered into a deal to form a strategic partnership with Binariang GSM
(Binariang), the principal shareholder of Maxis Communications (Maxis), the Malaysian-
based integrated telecommunications operator, and its subsidiary PT Natrindo Telepon
Seluler (NTS). The deal is worth SR11.4bn (US$3.05bn), including a SR3.4bn credit
facility to be provided equally by the partners to finance the Indian expansion of Maxis
Indian unit, Aircel.
The Maxis Group has operations in Malaysia, Indonesia and India. STC will participate
in the recapitalization and restructuring of Binariang which, under the terms of the
current take-private offer, will hold 100% of Maxis, and will invest together with the
other shareholders of Binariang to fund the international operations of Maxis in India
and Indonesia. Upon conclusion of the deal, STC will have a 25% effective interest in
Maxis and a 51% direct stake in NTS, Maxis’ subsidiary in Indonesia.
Maxis had 8.5mn subscribers in Malaysia at end of March 2007, a market share of 41.5%.
NTS has a license to build and operate 2G and 3G networks in Indonesia, which it plans
to launch by the end of 2007. Aircel, Maxis’ Indian subsidiary, has operations in nine
of India’s 23 telecoms regions and has obtained licenses for the rest. Aircel had 5.5mn
subscribers at end of March 2007.
(For more information please refer to our latest research update on the company)
MTC , now re-branded to Zain, won the bid for Saudi Arabia’s third mobile license in
March 2007, which included 2G, 3G and international licenses. MTC (Zain) and its
consortium partners won the bid for a price of US$6.1bn (SR22.9bn). The company is
expected to launch its operations in Saudi by 1Q-2008 under the brand name Zain.
Listed on the Kuwait Stock Exchange, MTC (Zain) market capitalization stood at
US$28.8bn as at October 9, 2007. There are no restrictions on MTC (Zain) shares as the
company’s capital is 100% free float and publicly traded. The largest shareholder is the
Kuwait Investment Authority (24.6%).
MTC (Zain) has had a partner network agreement with Vodafone in 2001 in Kuwait and
Bahrain by which management and operational know-how is shared between the two
companies.
The company moved into Lebanon in 2002 when it was awarded a five year contract by
the Lebanese government to manage and develop Mobile Interim Company (MIC2), one
of two government owned mobile telephone companies.
MTC (Zain) launched in 2003, through MTC Vodafone Bahrain, the first 3G/EDGE
nationwide network in the world. It also launched in December 2005 the first video calls
in the region between Kuwait and Bahrain.
MTC (Zain) moved into Iraq when it acquired 30% of Atheer Telecommunications in
2003. It also expanded into Jordan by acquiring Orascom’s shares in Jordan Mobile
Telephone Services (Fastlink) for US$423.9mn. Later, MTC acquired 100% of the
African operator Celtel in April 2005 for US$3.1bn. Celtel operated in 14 Sub-Saharan
countries with 8.5mn subscribers, which made up 65% of MTC total subscriber base
when it was acquired.
(For more information please refer to our latest research update on the company)
Activation Fees
Rental Fees
Usage
SR 6.2bn
Interconnect Revenues
Visitor Roaming
Others
8,000,000 85
83 85 85
SR
6,000,000
4,000,000 81 80
2,000,000
- 75
2006 2007E 2008E 2009E 20109E
Revenues ARPU
Consumption of Inventories
Interconnection Expenses
National & International Roaming Costs
License Fees
SR 2.7bn Government Revenue Share
Frequency Charge & Rental
Transmission & International Gateway Cost
Technical Repair & Maintenance Cost
Sites Rental
Others
Costs to decline with the completion of Mobily’s own network and increase in
coverage….
Costs to revenues ratio stood at 43% in 2006, down from 58% in the previous period.
Accordingly, Gross margin improved from 42% to 57% in 2006. Going forward, we
expect the ratio to come down after the company develops its own international gateway,
expected in 2008 which will lead to the decline in international gateway costs. In addition,
national and international roaming costs are also expected to decline in tandem with the
increase in Mobily’s network coverage. On another hand, interconnection expenses, the
major component of total costs is likely to come down with the increase in Mobily’s
market share. We expect costs to revenues ratio of 47% in 2007, then gradually declining
starting from 2008.
25%
3,000,000
20%
2,000,000 15%
10%
1,000,000
5%
- 0%
2006 2007E 2008E 2009E 2010E
Improving Profitability…
The company reported net income of SR700.4mn in 2006 compared to a loss of SR1.2bn
in the previous period, with a net profit margin of 11.3%. Return on Equity stood at
15.5% in 2006, while Return on Assets stood at 4%. We expect Net profit to grow at
CAGR of 47% during the period (2006-2010E).
0E
9E
9E
E
E
7E
7E
06
06
08
08
20
20
1
1
0
0
0
0
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20.0
4.3 5.6 7.2
2.0 2.9
15.0
3.8 4.9 5.7 6.2 6.5
SR bn
10.0
5.0
11.8 11.3 10.8 10.3 9.7
-
2006 2007E 2008E 2009E 2010E
During 2006, capex stood at SR1.5bn, declining by 48% from SR2.8bn in 2005. Capex
to sales ratio stood at 24% in 2006. We expect a gradual decline in capex to sales ratio
to reach 8% by 2010.
17% 20%
1,500,000 14%
10%
SR’000
8% 15%
1,000,000
10%
500,000
5%
- 0%
2006 2007E 2008E 2009E 2010E
Capex Capex to Sales
5.8 6.6
6.0
4.5
4.0
2.0
-
2006 2007E 2008E 2009E 2010E
Debt Equity
1H 2007 Results
Cost to revenues ratio increased from 45.4% in 1H 2006 to 46.3% in 1H 2007. Gross
margin increased by 49% to reach SR2bn. EBITDA increased by 64% to reach SR1.3bn
in 1H 2007 compared to SR782mn in 1H 2006, with an EBITDA margin of 33%
compared to 30% in 1H 2006. Net profit margin for the period stood at 14.2% compared
to 6% in 1H 2006.
Total assets stood at SR17.72bn, increasing marginally by 0.2% from SR17.68bn reported
at the end of 2006. Property and Equipment increased by 8.9% from SR3.8bn at the end
of 2006 to SR4bn in 1H 2007. During 2007, Mobily signed long term Islamic financing
agreements with a group of local, regional and international banks for US$2.875bn
(SR10.78bn). The new funds were used to repay the company’s short term debt.
Around 20 million people now own mobile phones in Saudi representing 82% of the
population. With most of the penetration rates in GCC countries surpassing the 100%
mark, we believe that there is a potential for more in Saudi. As such, mobile penetration
rates in Saudi Arabia are expected to increase going forward on the back of increasing
demand for mobiles among younger generation, increasing economic activities in the
country requiring telecom infrastructure support, and the government’s intention to
liberalize various sectors as part of joining WTO. In addition, a third mobile operator,
MTC (Zain) will join the market in 2008 which will force market players to strive to
offer new and innovative services at the best prices, thus attracting more demand.
Since inception, Mobily has relied on innovative services and latest technologies to attract
customers. The company was the first mobile operator in Saudi to offer services such as
Blackberry MMS, locations based service (LBS), international roaming for prepaid SIM
cards in addition to GPRS and GPRS EDGE roaming. Mobily has also made tremendous
strides in expanding broadband services. In May 2007, Mobily shifted the data service
consumption conversation from kilobytes to gigabytes when it launched the region’s
first unlimited broadband mobile internet package in the region, along with the two high-
value 5 and 1 gigabyte bundles. The company had the highest market share of 3G users
in 2006, with a market share of 58%, and is currently investing SR1bn to expand its 3G
network to cover more Saudi cities. In 2007, the company doubled the broadband mobile
Internet speed and introduced a 7.2 Mbps modems and data service SIM cards based on
HSDPA (high-speed downlink packet access).
The company’s latest acquisition of the local data provider Bayanat Al-Oula will further
enhance the company’s position in the wireless broadband internet segment, with the
WiMAX technology along with Mobily’s current HSDPA technology. Mobily had earlier
joined forces with Bayanat Al-Oula and Integrated Telecom Company to build, deploy
and operate the Kingdom’s largest fiber optic network with a total value of SR1bn that
will cover 12,000 km of highways as well as cities Kingdom-wide. The new network
will enable Mobily to provide other services with highly sophisticated technologies.
Going forward, we believe that key growth areas for the company would be broadband
and 3.5G services, especially with a penetration of only 1% in Saudi Arabia which is
lagging behind many countries. Lower mobile penetration rates compared to regional
peers offers another potential for the company. We expect the entrance of a third operator
to have a greater effect on the operator with the largest market share, STC, than on Mobily.
Though, we expect further reduction in mobile tariffs with increased competition, we
believe that the focus on high quality services based on the latest technologies will be the
main differentiator between the competitors.
With competition intensifying, we believe there would be pressure on ARPUs for Mobily
particularly since most of the company’s customers’ base (93%) is prepaid subscribers.
However, we expect the pressure to be eased in the medium term through the expected
increase in the company’s postpaid subscribers, coupled with Mobily’s increased focus
on broadband and 3.5G services.
Two valuation methods have been used to arrive at the fair value of Mobily, the Discounted
Cash Flow (DCF) – discounting the company Free Cash Flow to Firm (FCFF)- along
with the Price to Earnings (P/E) relative valuation method. We have assigned an 80%
weight to the DCF valuation and 20% to the P/BV valuation.
1. Risk Free Rate (RFR) of 5.8% as per yield on the 10-year bond.
2. Equity risk premium of 5.5%.
3. Beta of 1.
4. A terminal growth rate of 4%.
5. A target cost of debt of 7%.
Using the above assumptions, we have derived a cost of equity for the company under
the Capital Assets Pricing Model of 11.3%, and a WACC of 10.0%, resulting in fair
value of SR86.8 per share.
Sensitivity Analysis
We provide below a sensitivity analysis table, which shows the probable value given
different growth rate assumption and WACC. The shaded area represents the most
probable outcomes.
b) Valuations based on multiples – For relative valuation, we have used the valuation
of selected telecom operators in the GCC region. We believe that the comparative
valuation would be appropriately reflected through the earnings multiple i.e. P/E.
The price-earnings multiple of a stock is a reflection of various factors, such as the
expected profitability of the company, its growth potential as perceived by the market,
predictability and sustainability of its revenues, the quality of its earnings and the quality
of its management, among others. Based on a weighted average P/E of 14x, Mobily’s
stock valuation comes to SR36.8 based on its forecasted earning for FY 2007.
As the earnings multiples vary with time and are dependent on several factors such as
market sentiment and other qualitative factors, we have provided 20% weight to the P/E
multiple and 80% to the DCF value calculation.
The combination of both the methods suggests a fair value of around SR76.8 per share.
The stock currently trades at around SR65.5, which implies that the value arrived by
using above methods is 17.3% higher than the current market price. Therefore, we
initiate our coverage on Mobilly with a “BUY” recommendation.
October 2007
Inventories 32,075 38,048 55,113 153,787 203,809 247,434
Other Current Assets 782,765 716,688 1,039,198 1,298,997 1,623,746 2,029,683
Total Current Assets 1,166,834 2,041,487 2,873,178 4,335,152 5,560,582 7,205,201
Property & Equipment (Net) 2,723,840 3,847,532 4,855,147 5,668,797 6,181,665 6,455,027
License Acquisition Fees (Net) 12,313,626 11,800,160 11,286,694 10,773,228 10,259,762 9,746,296
Total Non Current Assets 15,037,466 15,647,692 16,141,841 16,442,025 16,441,427 16,201,323
Global Research - Saudi Arabia
33
Total Shareholders’ Equity 3,832,621 4,532,979 5,843,776 7,789,538 9,934,099 12,112,515
Total Liabilities and Shareholders’ Equity 16,204,300 17,689,179 19,015,020 20,777,178 22,002,009 23,406,525
34
INCOME STATEMENT
Etihad Etisalat Company “Mobily”
SR’000 2005* 2006 2007 (E) 2008 (E) 2009 (E) 2010 (E)
Service Revenue 1,661,737 6,183,236 8,381,029 10,007,922 11,127,982 12,371,698
Cost of Services (967,240) (2,661,184) (3,936,635) (4,393,924) (4,529,089) (4,948,679)
Gross Margin 694,497 3,522,052 4,444,394 5,613,998 6,598,893 7,423,019
Selling & Marketing Expenses (274,298) (702,670) (544,767) (700,555) (778,959) (866,019)
General & Administrative Expenses (480,316) (694,704) (955,223) (1,133,367) (1,272,706) (1,361,272)
Global Research - Saudi Arabia
October 2007
CASH FLOW STATEMENT
Etihad Etisalat Company “Mobily”
SR’000 2005* 2006 2007 (E) 2008 (E) 2009 (E) 2010 (E)
Net Income / Loss (1,167,379) 700,358 1,310,797 1,945,762 2,631,002 3,230,817
Amortization of License Acquisition Fee 665,613 513,466 513,466 513,466 513,466 513,466
Depreciation 73,528 331,513 445,005 551,486 641,529 718,927
October 2007
Provision For Employees’ End Of Service Benefits 2,650 10,698 7,312 6,581 5,923 5,331
Provision For Doubtful Accounts 50,000 113,476 150,859 220,174 267,072 296,921
Changes in Working Capital 2,389,238 (343,769) (29,579) (694,739) (571,842) (429,174)
Accounts Receivable (216,822) (685,882) (31,733) (452,263) (352,853) (281,817)
Inventories (32,075) (5,973) (17,065) (98,674) (50,022) (43,625)
Other Current Assets (782,765) 66,077 (322,510) (259,799) (324,749) (405,937)
Global Research - Saudi Arabia
Purchase of Property and Equipment (2,797,368) (1,455,205) (1,452,620) (1,365,136) (1,154,396) (992,290)
Payment for license Fees (12,979,239) - - - - -
35
Cash & Cash equivalents at the end of the year 185,172 547,523 1,158,765 2,030,176 2,795,053 4,005,215a
Global Research - Saudi Arabia Global Investment House
FACT SHEET
Etihad Etisalat Company “Mobily”
2005 2006 2007 (E) 2008 (E) 2009 (E) 2010 (E)
Liquidity Ratios
Current ratio (times) 0.11 0.18 0.61 0.83 1.03 1.26
Quick ratio (times) 0.11 0.17 0.59 0.80 0.99 1.22
Cash ratio (times) 0.02 0.05 0.24 0.39 0.52 0.70
Profitability Ratios
Gross Margin % 41.8% 57.0% 53.0% 56.1% 59.3% 60.0%
EBITDA Margin % -6.8% 32.4% 33.2% 35.5% 38.4% 39.6%
EBIT Margin % -51.3% 18.7% 21.8% 24.9% 28.0% 29.6%
Net Profit Margin -70.3% 11.3% 15.6% 19.4% 23.6% 26.1%
ROE % -30.5% 15.5% 22.4% 26.6% 29.6% 30.8%
ROA % -7.2% 4.0% 6.9% 9.4% 12.0% 13.8%
ROS % -70.3% 11.3% 15.6% 19.4% 23.6% 26.1%
Efficiency Ratios
A/R Turnover (times) NA 13.65 12.33 13.60 12.43 13.30
Inventory Turnover (times) NA 75.90 84.51 42.07 25.33 21.93
A/P Turnover (times) NA 2.22 2.73 3.14 3.08 3.21
COGS/Sales 58.2% 43.0% 47.0% 43.9% 40.7% 40.0%
S,G&A /Sales 45.4% 22.6% 17.9% 18.3% 18.4% 18.0%
Financing Ratios
Debt to equity (times) 2.33 2.08 1.56 1.13 0.78 0.55
Debt to total assets % 55.2% 53.4% 47.9% 42.4% 35.1% 28.4%
Dividends payout ratio % - - - 25% 40% 50%
Growth Rates
Revenue growth rate NA 272% 36% 19% 11% 11%
Net income growth rate NA -160% 87% 48% 35% 23%
Equity growth rate NA 18% 29% 33% 28% 22%
Total assets growth rate NA 9% 7% 9% 6% 6%
Sustainable growth rate NA 15.5% 22.4% 20.0% 17.8% 15.4%
1. Global Investment House did not receive and will not receive any compensation from the company
or anyone else for the preparation of this report.
2. The company being researched holds more than 5% stake in Global Investment House.
3. Global Investment House makes a market in securities issued by this company.
4. Global Investment House acts as a corporate broker or sponsor to this company.
5. The author of or an individual who assisted in the preparation of this report (or a member of his/her
household) has a direct ownership position in securities issued by this company.
6. An employee of Global Investment House serves on the board of directors of this company.
7. Within the past year , Global Investment House has managed or co-managed a public offering for
this company, for which it received fees.
8. Global Investment House has received compensation from this company for the provision of
investment banking or financial advisory services within the past year.
9. Global Investment House expects to receive or intends to seek compensation for investment banking
services from this company in the next three months.
10. Please see special footnote below for other relevant disclosures.
This material was produced by Global Investment House KSCC (‘Global’),a firm regulated by the Central Bank of
Kuwait. This document is not to be used or considered as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any
securities. Global may, from time to time,to the extent permitted by law, participate or invest in other financing
transactions with the issuers of the securities (‘securities’), perform services for or solicit business from such issuer,
and/or have a position or effect transactions in the securities or options thereof. Global may, to the extent permitted
by applicable Kuwaiti law or other applicable laws or regulations, effect transactions in the securities before this
material is published to recipients.
Information and opinions contained herein have been compiled or arrived by Global from sources believed to
be reliable, but Global has not independently verified the contents of this document. Accordingly, no representation
or warranty, express or implied, is made as to and no reliance should be placed on the fairness, accuracy,
completeness or correctness of the information and opinions contained in this document. Global accepts no liability
for any loss arising from the use of this document or its contents or otherwise arising in connection therewith.
This document is not to be relied upon or used in substitution for the exercise of independent judgement. Global
shall have no responsibility or liability whatsoever in respect of any inac curacy in or ommission from this or
any other document prepared by Global for, or sent by Global to any person and any such person shall be
responsible for conducting his own investigation and analysis of the information contained or referred to in this
document and of evaluating the merits and risks involved in the securities forming the subject matter of this or
other such document.
Opinions and estimates constitute our judgment and are subject to change without prior notice.Past performance
is not indicative of future results. This document does not constitute an offer or invitation to subscribe for or
purchase any securities, and neither this document nor anything contained herein shall form the basis of any
contract or commitment what so ever. It is being furnished to you solely for your information and may not be
reproduced or redistributed to any other person.
Neither this report nor any copy hereof may be distributed in any jurisdiction outside Kuwait where its distribution
may be restricted by law. Persons who receive this report should make themselves aware of and adhere to any
such restrictions. By accepting this report you agree to be bound by the foregoing limitations.