Technical Application Papers No.

6
Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and
controlgear assemblies
 Technical Application Papers

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and

controlgear assemblies
Index
1 Generalities about LV 2 The electric arc
switchgear and controlgear
2.1 Electrical arc phenomenon ................... 13
assemblies
2.2 Effects of the electric arc inside switchgear
1.1 Introduction. ............................................ 2 and controlgear assemblies .................. 13

1.2 Standards concerning switchboards and 2.3 Effects of the electric arc on human
relevant applicability ............................... 3 beings ................................................... 14

1.3 Electrical characteristics of assemblies .. 4

3 Internal arc-proof switchgear
1.4 Classification of assemblies ................... 4
1.4.1 Constructional types .............................................. 4
and controlgear assemblies
1.4.2 Primary distribution switchgear
(Power Center) ....................................................... 4
3.1 Generalities ........................................... 15

1.4.3 Secondary distribution switchgear......................... 5 3.2 Characteristics of internal arc-proof

1.4.4 Motor Control Center (MCC) .................................. 5
switchgear and controlgear
assemblies ............................................ 16
1.4.5 Control, measurements and protection boards ..... 6
3.2.1 Assemblies mechanically capable of withstanding
1.4.6 Assemblies for construction sites (ACS) ................ 6 the electric arc (passive protection) ..................... 16

3.2.2 Assemblies equipped with devices limiting internal

1.5 Degree of protection IP ........................... 7 arc effects (active protection) ............................... 16

1.5.1 Degrees of protection provided by switchgear 3.2.3 Switchgear and controlgear assemblies with
and controlgear assemblies ................................... 8 current limiting circuit-breakers............................ 18

1.6 Degree of protection IK ........................... 9

1.7 Forms of separation .............................. 10

4 ABB SACE arc-proof
switchgear
1.8 Temperature-rise inside assemblies ..... 11
4.1 Constructional and functional
1.9 Switchgear and controlgear characteristics of the switchgear
assemblies - special executions .......... 12 PC3.0/MNS R ....................................... 19

1.9.1 Testing under conditions of arcing due

to internal fault ..................................................... 12 4.2 Versions of the switchgear type
PC3.0/MNS R ....................................... 25
1.9.2 Seismic qualification testing ................................ 12

1.9.3 Testing for shock-proof execution ....................... 12

Annex A:
Test on an arc-proof switchboard ......................... 28

1
 Technical Application Papers

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear

assemblies
1.1 Introduction Besides, the involved materials can generate hot decom-
position products, gases or fumes, which, due to the
1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

In the last years safety in LV electrical installations has overpressure, are almost always ejected to the outside
taken an increasingly dominant role. of the enclosure thus jeopardizing the operator safety.
Also from a normative point of view, the panorama has The European Directive 2006/95/EC states the funda-
become more complete and a large number of users mental safety requirements for low voltage electric ma-
consider safety in the first place among the necessary terials (from 50 V to 1000 V in alternating current, from 75
requirements for their own plant. V to 1500 V in continuos current) to be put on the market
LV switchgear assemblies are undoubtedly the compo- within the European Community.
nents of the electric installation more subject to the direct Among the essential safety requirements defined by this
intervention of personnel (operations, maintenance, etc.) Directive particular importance is given to the need of
and for this reason users demand from them higher and taking technical measures to prevent “temperature rises,
higher safety requirements. electric arcs or radiations which may result in hazards”
In the last years a lot of users have underlined the ques- from occurring.
tion of safety in electrical assemblies with reference to This aspect has always been highly considered for ap-
one of the most severe and destructive electrophysical paratus, but it has been wrongly neglected for electrical
phenomenon: the electric arc. switchgear and only in the last 10-15 years it has been
Unlike tripping devices, for which arc phenomena rep- catching on both at Italian as well as at international
resents one of the standard operating conditions, in LV level.
switchgear the electrical arc is an absolutely anomalous
and rare event.
But, if the electric arc occurs inside LV switchgear it
generates internal overpressures and results in local
overheatings which may cause high mechanical and
thermal stresses in the equipment.

2 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

1.2 Standards concerning switchboards TYPE-TESTED AND PARTIALLY TYPE-TESTED

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

and relevant applicability ASSEMBLIES
The Standard IEC 60439-1 differentiates between two
Low voltage switchboards are defined by the Standard categories of assemblies:
IEC 60439-1 “switchgear and controlgear assemblies”, • TTA (Type-Tested Assembly)
in short: assemblies. • PTTA (Partially Type-Tested Assembly)
The Standard gives the following definition: “combina- The term Type-Tested Assembly (TTA) is used to mean an
tion of one or more switching devices together with assembly “conforming to an established type or system
associated control, measuring, signalling, protective, without deviations likely to significantly influence the
regulating equipment etc., completely assembled under performance from the typical assembly verified to be in
the responsibility of the manufacturer with all the internal accordance with this standard”.
electrical and mechanical interconnections, including To be declared TTA an assembly shall meet at least one
structural parts”. of the following conditions:
The compliance of an assembly with the state of the art 1. it is manufactured in a single example and subject to
and therefore, presumptively, with the relevant techni- all the type tests required by the Standard;
cal Standard, cannot be based only on the fact that the 2. it is similar to another assembly which has been sub-
components which constitute it comply with the state jected to all the type tests, that is it differs from the
of the art and therefore, at least presumptively, with the tested one only for details considered irrelevant for
relevant technical standards: this is necessary but not the results of the same tests and, consequently, for its
sufficient. performances, that is for its nominal characteristics;
The components shall be assembled according to deter- 3. it is part of a pre-established structural system sub-
mined rules which can guarantee short-circuit withstand jected to type tests in some of the many possible
strength, compliance with the temperature-rise limits, arrangements chosen among the most significative
insulation, etc. ones which can be obtained by combining the system
In other words, the whole assembly must be designed, elements. It is the typical case of assemblies sold as
built and tested in compliance with the state loose components.
of the art. The term Partially Type-Tested Assembly (PTTA) is used
Since the assemblies under considera- to mean an assembly “containing both type-tested and
tion are low voltage equipment, their non-type-tested arrangements, provided that the latter
rated voltage shall not exceed 1000 are derived (e.g. by calculation) from type-tested arrange-
Va.c. or 1500 Vd.c. As regards ments which have complied with the relevant tests”.
currents, neither upper nor lower
limits are provided in the appli- A PTTA is an assembly which has been subjected to one
cation field of this Standard. part of the type tests, whereas the other ones have been
The Standard IEC 60439-1 states the replaced by some extrapolations (calculations) based on
construction, safety and maintenance the experimental results obtained on assemblies which
requirements for low voltage have already passed the type tests.
switchgear and controlgear The distinction between TTA and PTTA is of no weight
assemblies, without with respect to the declaration of conformity with the
dealing with the func- Standard IEC 60439-1, since the assembly must simply
tional aspects which comply with it apart from its having been subject - totally
remain a competence of (TTA) or partially (PTTA) - to type tests.
the designer of the plant for which
the assembly is intended.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 3

 Technical Application Papers

1.3 Electrical characteristics of assemblies 1.4 Classification of assemblies

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

The Standard IEC 60439-1 identifies the nominal char-

acteristics to be assigned to each assembly, defines the 1.4.1 Constructional types
environmental service conditions, establishes the me- Switchgear and controlgear assemblies often have a cu-
chanical requirements and gives prescriptions about: bicle-type structure which generally stands on floor and
• insulation which can be divided into sections and compartments.
• thermal behaviour The section is a constructional unit limited between two
• short-circuit withstand strength adjacent vertical planes, whereas the term compartment
• protection against electrical shock is used to define a completely enclosed part of a section
• degree of protection of the enclosure (sub-section), excepted for the openings necessary for
• installed components, internal separation and con- interconnection, control and ventilation (Figure 1).
nections inside the assembly
• electronic equipment supply circuits.
Information specified under items a) and b) shall be given Figure 1 – Enclosed assembly, built by three sections; each section is in its
turn subdivided into more compartments
on the nameplate according to the Standard.
Information from items c) to t), where applicable, shall
be given either on the nameplates or in the technical
documentation of the manufacturer:
a) manufacturer ’s name or trade mark;
b) type designation or identification number, or any other
means of identification making it possible to obtain
relevant information from the manufacturer;
c) IEC 60439-1;
d) type of current (and frequency, in the case of a.c.);
e) rated operational voltages;
f) rated insulation voltages (rated impulse withstand volt-
age, when declared by the manufacturer);
g) rated voltages of auxiliary circuits, if applicable;
h) limits of operation;
j) rated current of each circuit, if applicable;
k) short-circuit withstand strength;
l) degree of protection;
m) measures for protection of persons;
n) service conditions for indoor use, outdoor use or spe-
cial use, if different from the usual service conditions.
Pollution degree when declared by the manufacturer;
o) types of system earthing (neutral conductor) for which
the ASSEMBLY is designed;
p) dimensions given preferably in the order of height,
width (or length), depth;
q) weight;
r) form of internal separation;
s) types of electrical connections of functional units;
t) environment 1 or 2. 1.4.2 Primary distribution switchgear
(Power Centers)
They are usually installed on the load side of MV/LV trans-
formers or generators. These assemblies include one or
more incoming units, bus ties and a relatively reduced
number of outgoing units.

1
The manufacturer is deemed to be the organization taking the responsibility for the
complete ASSEMBLY.

4 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

There are also present measuring instruments and other The constructional models provide for the use of metal or
switching and control equipment (Figure 2). insulating material enclosures and can be both floor- or

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

wall-mounted, according to dimensions and weight.
Figure 2 – View of a primary distribution switchgear
In case the assemblies are used by unskilled persons,
the Standard IEC 60439-3 is to be applied.
The distribution boards (ASD) are subject to the additional
prescriptions of the Standard IEC 60439-3.
They are intended to be installed in places where un-
skilled persons have acces for their use, otherwise the
general rules of the Standard IEC 60439-1 are applied.
The Standard IEC 60439-3 takes into consideration only
Type-Tested Assemblies (TTA).
This means that each manufactured product shall comply
with a prototype or with a pre-established constructional
system, that is, it shall not present deviations which can
remarkably modify its performances with respect to the
type-tested assembly.

1.4.4 Motor Control Centers (MCC)

Motor Control Centers are intended for the control and
centralized protection of motors: they include the rel-
These assemblies have a sturdy structure to withstand evant switching and protection equipment (independent
the electrodynamic stresses and the weight of big sized functional units) and the control and signalling auxiliary
apparatus. As a matter of fact peculiar characteristics equipment.
of the power center are high rated currents and short- They are characterized by drawer-units (outgoing units),
circuit currents. each of them connected to one motor so that it may be
The constructional type is a cubicle structure, with metal possible to operate in total safety on each single outgoing
enclosure and sections divided into compartments with unit without disconnecting the loads (Figure 4).
selective access.

1.4.3 Secondary distribution switchgear

Figure 4 – View of a Motor Control Center (MCC)
These assemblies are usually provided with one incoming
unit and many outgoing units (Figure 3).
The apparatus housed inside the assembly are mainly
molded-case circuit-breakers and/or miniature circuit-
breakers.
Figure 3 – Secondary distribution switchgear

The rated currents and the short-circuit currents of sec-

ondary distribution switchgear are lower than those of
primary distribution switchgear.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 5

 Technical Application Papers

1.4.5 Control, measurement and protection 1.4.6 Assemblies for construction sites (ACS)
boards
1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

Assemblies for construction sites have different dimen-

They are usually constituted by banks containing above sions, ranging from the simple socket-outlet units to proper
all apparatus intended for the control, switching and distribution boards in metal enclosure or insulating mate-
measurement of industrial installations and processes. rial. These assemblies are usually mobile (Figure 6).
Usually supported by a metal frame, they have a “desk The Standard IEC 60439-4 establishes the particular require-
form” and allow quick access to the commands and easy ments for this type of assemblies, making specific reference
readability of the instruments (Figure 5). to mechanical strength and resistance to corrosion.
This Standard states that the ACS shall comply with the
Figure 5 – Control boards
a) Desk-type
requirements of the Standard IEC 60439-1 and that the
b) Console-type. clauses of the Standard IEC 60439-4 either complete,
a) modify or replace the relevant clauses of the general
reference Standard.
ACS must be exclusively type-tested low-voltage switch-
gear and controlgear assemblies (TTA) and consequently
each manufactured assembly shall comply with a proto-
type which has been already subject to all the type tests
prescribed by the Standard IEC 60439-4.
Figure 6 – Assemblies for contruction sites (ACS)
a) ACS supported by feet or legs
b) ACS to be mounted on a vertical surface
b) c) ACS - mobile socket-outlet unit

a)

b)

c)

6 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

1.5 Degree of protection IP If the indications refer exclusively to the safety of persons
against direct contact, both characteristic numerals are

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

The code IP indicates the degrees of protection provided omitted and replaced by “XX”; in this case the degree of
by an enclosure against access to hazardous parts, in- protection is indicated by the additional letter.
gress of solid foreign objects and ingress of water. Obviously, also the additional letter is not independent
The degree of protection of an enclosure is identified, in of the two numerals by which it may be preceded, but
compliance with the specifications of the Standard IEC it is closely connected to them; that is the reason why
60529, by the code letters IP (International Protection) the additional letter shall be used only if guaranteeing a
followed by two numerals and two additional letters. degree of protection against direct contact higher than
The first characteristic numeral indicates the degree of that guaranteed by the first characteristic numeral.
protection against ingress of solid foreign objects and The supplementary letter gives supplementary informa-
against contact of persons with hazardous live parts tion.
inside the enclosure. The table below sums up the meaning of the various ele-
The second characteristic numeral indicates the degree ments which form the code. For further details reference
of protection against ingress of water with harmful ef- should be made to the Standard IEC 60529.
fects.
It is easy to understand that the two characteristic numer-
als influence each other. IP 2 3 C H
The additional letter indicates the degree of protection of
persons against access to hazardous parts. Code letters
International
protection
The additional letter is used only if the actual protection
against access to hazardous parts is higher than that First characteristic numerals 0 to 6, or
numeral letter X
indicated by the first characteristic numeral; if only the
Second characteristic numerals 0 to 8, or
protection against access to hazardous parts is indicated, numeral letter x
then the first characteristic numeral shall be replaced Additional letter
letters A, B, C, D
by the letter X. For example this higher protection could (optional)

be provided by barriers, openings of suitable shape or Supplementary letter

letters H, M, S, W
distances inside the enclosure. (optional)

Protection of equipment Against access to hazardous part with:

First characteristic numeral 0 non-protected non-protected
(access of solid foreign objects) 1 ≥ 50 mm diameter back of hand
2 ≥ 12.5 mm diameter finger
3 ≥ 2.5 mm diameter tool
4 ≥ 1.0 mm diameter wire
5 dust-protected wire
6 dust-tight wire
Second characteristic numeral 0 non-protected
(ingress of water) 1 vertically dripping
2 dripping (15° tilted)
3 spraying
4 splashing
5 jetting
6 powerful jetting
7 temporary immersion
8 continuous immersion
Additional letter A back of hand
(optional) B finger
C tool
D wire
Supplementary letter H High-voltage apparatus
(optional) M Motion during water test
S Stationary during water test
W Weather conditions

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 7

 Technical Application Papers

1.5.1 Degrees of protection provided by As regards enclosed switchboards, the Standard requires
switchgear and controlgear assemblies
1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

the minimum degree of protection IP 2X or IPXXB for live

As regards assemblies, if not otherwise specified by the parts which are not to be touched intentionally and IP4X
manufacturer, the degree of protection is applicable to or IPXXD for readily accessible horizontal surfaces.
the whole assembly, mounted and installed as in the or- As an example the following table shows the minimum
dinary use (closed door). Besides, the manufacturer may degrees of protection required for an assembly to be
indicate the degrees of protection relevant to particular installed in the listed environments, in compliance with
arrangements which may occur during operation, such the mentioned Standards.
as the degree of protection with open doors and that one
with removed or withdrawn apparatus.

Type of assemblies/Type of environments Standards and sub-clause Minimum degree of protection

Switchgear and controlgear assemblies: enclosed switchboards IEC 60439-1 sub-clause 2.3.3 Not defined
Assemblies for outdoor installation IEC 60439-1sub-clause 7.2.1.3 IPX3
Assemblies with protection by total insulation IEC 60439-1 sub-clause 7.4.3.2.2 IP2XC
Installations in normal environments
Live parts which are not to be touched intentionally IEC60364-4 sub-clause 412.2.1 IPXXB (IP2X)
Live parts which are readily accessible (horizontal top) IEC60364-4 sub-clause 412.2.2 IPXXD (IP4X)
Installations in locations containing a bath tube or shower basin
Zone 1 and 2 IEC60364-7 sub-clause 701.512.2 IPX4
Zone 3 IEC60364-7 sub-clause 701.512.2 IPX1
Zone 1-2-3 public baths where water jets are used for cleaning purposes IEC60364-7 sub-clause 701.512.2 IPX5
Installations for swimming-pools
Zone 0 IEC60364-7 sub-clause 702.512.2 IPX8
Zone 1 IEC60364-7 sub-clause 702.512.2 IPX5
Zone 2 for indoor locations IEC60364-7 sub-clause 702.512.2 IPX2
Zone 2 for outoor locations IEC60364-7 sub-clause 702.512.2 IPX4
Zone 2 where water jets are used for cleaning purposes IEC60364-7 sub-clause 702.512.2 IPX5
Installations for rooms and cabins containing sauna heaters IEC60364-7 sub-clause 703.512.2 IP24
Assemblies for construction sites (ACS) IEC60439-4 sub-clause 7.2.1.1 IP44

The figure below shows the degrees of protection which can be obtained with ABB SACE ArTu series switchgear

ArTu L ArTu M - K
IP31 IP43 IP31 IP41 Without door IP41With door IP65
Without door With door Without door with IP41 kit and and ventilated With door and
ventilated panels panels (ArTu K blind panels
(ArTu K only) only)

8 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

The figure below shows an application of ABB switchgear Each characteristic group numeral represents a value of
series MNS designed for the degree of protection IP41. impact energy as the following table shows:

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

MNS switchgear series is designed to fulfil the require-
Code IK Impact energy (Joule)
ments for degrees of protection up to IP54.
IK 00 (*)
IK 01 0.14
IK 02 0.2
Figure 7 - MNS R switchgear with degree of protection IP41 IK 03 0.35
IK 04 0.5
IK 05 0.7
IK 06 1
IK 07 2
IK 08 5
IK 09 10
IK 10 20

(*) Not-protected according to this Standard.

In general, the degree of protection applies to the com-

plete enclosure. If parts of the enclosure have differ-
ing degrees of protection, the latter shall be indicated
separately.

Here are the degrees of protection against external me-

chanical impact (code IK) of ArTu series

ArTu L
1,7 kg
IK 08 Impact energy
300mm

Joule 5.00

1.6 Degree of protection IK

The code IK indicates the degrees of protection provided 5 kg ArTu M-K
200mm

by an enclosure to the housed equipment against harmful IK 09 Impact energy

effects of mechanical impacts verified by standardized Joule 10.00
test methods complying with the requirements of the With glass
Standard IEC 62262. door
The degree of protection provided by enclosures against
external mechanical impacts is indicated by the code IK
as follows:
IK 05
5 kg ArTu M-K
IK 10
400mm

Impact energy
Joule 20.00
Characteristic letters International mechanical protection With blind
door
Characteristic group numeral from
00 to 10

(*) Not-protected according to this Standard.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 9

 Technical Application Papers

1.7 Forms of separation Figure 8 - Structural frame form 4b - view with rear doors open. The
metallic separations mounted on the main busbars and on the distribution
1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

busbars can be noted, as well as the insulating covers which complete the
The designation form of separation indicates the type of compartments for cable connection
subdivision provided inside the enclosure. Separations
by means of barriers or partitions (metallic or non metallic
materials) are aimed at:
• guaranteeing protection against direct contact
(minimum degree of protection IPXXB), in case of
access to an insulated part of the assembly when
voltage is still applied to the rest of the assembly;
• reducing the likelihood of ignition and propagation
of an internal arc;
• impeding the passage of solid foreign bodies from
one unit of the assembly to an adjacent one (mini-
mum degree of protection IP2X).
A partition is an element of separation between two cu-
bicles, whereas a barrier protects the operator against
direct contact and against the effects of circuit-breaker
arcs propagating in the direction of usual access.
The table below, taken from the Standard IEC 60439-1,
points out the typical forms of internal separation which
can be obtained by using barriers or partitions:
Symbols
d
Caption Representation of the structural frames in form 3a, 3b and 4b for switch-
a Enclosure gear type PC3.0/MNS R
b Internal separation
c Functional units including terminals Form 3a
for associated external conductors
d Busbars, including distribution
busbars
c
a b

Form 1
(no internal separation)

Structural frame of a compartment Top view of a column with

with moulded-case circuit-breaker moulded-case circuit-breaker
in form 3a separated in form 3a
Form 3b

Form 2 Form 3 Form 4

Separation of busbars from Separation of busbars from Separation of busbars from the
the functional units the functional units functional units – separation of all
– separation of all functional functional units from one another
units from one another – separation of terminals from
those of any other functional unit
Form 2a Form 3a Form 4a
Terminals not separated from Terminals not separated Terminals in the same
busbars from busbars compartment as the associated
functional unit Structural frame of a compartment Top view of a column with
with moulded-case circuit-breaker moulded-case circuit-breaker
in form 3b separated in form 3b
Form 4b

Form 4b
Form 2b Form 3b Terminals not in the same
Terminals separated from Terminals separated from compartment as the
busbars busbars associated functional unit

Structural frame of a compartment Top view of a column with

with moulded-case circuit-breaker moulded-case circuit-breaker
in form 3b separated in form 4b

10 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

1.8 Temperature-rise inside assemblies Table 1: Temperature-rise limits for LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

Parts of assemblies Temperature rise (K)
An excessive temperature-rise inside assemblies repre- Built in components(1) (6) In accordance with the relevant requirements for the
individual components, or in accordance with the
sents one of the main problems which are often subject manufacturer’s(6) instructions, taking into consideration
for discussion and to which users pay the most atten- the temperature inside the ASSEMBLY
Terminals for external insulated conductors 70(2)
tion. Busbars and conductors (7), plug-in Limited by:
It is evident that an anomalous heating inside switchgear contacts of remowable or withdrawawble • mechanical strength of conducting material (7)
parts which connect to busbars
can jeopardize the safety of people (possible fires) and • possible effects on adjacent equipment
• permissible temperature limit of the insulating
plants (malfunctioning of the apparatus). materials in contact with the conductor
For this reason, the Standard IEC 60439-1 gives a lot • the effect of the temperature of the conductor
on the apparatus connected to it
of space to the permissible temperature-rise limits in an • for plug-in contacts, nature and surface treat-
assembly and to the methods to determine such limits ment of the contact material
Manual operating means:
either directly as type test or by analytic extrapolation.
• of metal 15(3)
The term type test defines the tests indended to as- • of insulating material 25(3)
sess the validity of a project according to the expected Accessible external enclosures and covers:

performances. • metal surfaces 30(4)

• insulating surfaces 40(4)
Such tests are usually carried out on one or more proto- Discrete arrangements of plug and socket Determined by the limits of those components of the
types and the results of these type tests are assumed to type connection equipment of which they form part (5)
(1) The term “built-in components” means:
obey to deterministic laws. Therefore these results can be
- conventional switchgear and controlgear;
extended to all the production, provided that it complies - electronic sub-assemblies (e.g. rectifier bridge, printed circuit)
with the design of the tested samples. - parts of the equipment (e.g. regulator, stabilized power supply unit, operational amplifier).

(2) The temperature-rise limit of 70 K is a value based on the conventional type test.
The type tests prescribed by the Standard IEC 60439-1 An ASSEMBLY used or tested under installation conditions may have connections, the type,
nature and disposition of which will not be the same as those adopted for the test, and a different
include: temperature rise of terminals may result and may be required or accepted. When the terminals
• verification of temperature-rise limits of the built-in compenents are also the terminals for external insulated conductors, the lower of
the corresponding temperature-rise limits shall be applied.
• verification of the dielectric properties (3) Manual operating means within ASSEMBLIES, which are only accessibile after the ASSEMBLY
has been opened, for example draw-out handles, which are operated infrequently, are allowed
• verification of the short-circuit withstand strength of to assume higher temperature rises.
the main circuits (4) Unless otherwise specified, in the case of covers and enclosures which are accessible but need
not to be touched during normal operation, an increase in the temperature-rise limits by 10 K
• verification of the short-circuit withstand strength of is permissible.
the protective circuit (5) This allows a degree of flexibility in respect of equipment (e.g. electornic devices) which is
subject to temperature-rise limits different from those normally associated with switchgear
• verification of the effective connection between and controlgear.
the exposed conductive parts and the protective (6) For the temperature-rise tests in accordance with 8.2.1, the temperature-rise limits shall be
specified by the manufacturer of the ASSEMBLY.
circuit As regards circuit-breakers, the temperature-rise limits are the following:
• verification of clearances and creepage distances - 70 K if an insulated conductor is connected to the terminal.
- 85 K for the terminals of ABB cirucit-breakers if insulated conductors are not directly con-
• verification of mechanical operation nected to them (the temperature-rise of 85 K is always referred to the ambient air temperature
• verification of the degree of protection of 35°C outside the assembly).
(7) Assuming that all the other listed criteria are met, a temperature-rise of 105 K for busbars and
bare copper conductors shall not be exceeded. 105 K refers to the temperature over which
copper annealing may occur.

As said above the verification of temperature-rise limits

is one of the most critical aspect for an assembly; the In addition to type tests the Standard requires also some
Standard states the temperature-rise limits referred to routine tests.
an average ambient air temperature of ≤ 35°C which These tests are carried out on each manufactured item
the switchgear complying with the Standard must not to ascertain the lack of rough defects due to materials or
exceed (Table 1). assembling. These are non destructive tests and can be
In TTA the verification of the temperature-rise limits shall carried out in the manufacturer’s factory for switchgear
be carried out through type tests. and controlgear supplied already wired or at the instal-
In PTTA an extrapolation, for example complying with IEC lation site after assembling.
60890, can be made in alternative to type tests. The routine tests prescribed by the Standard IEC 60439-13 are:
• visual inspection of the assembly, including inspec-
tion of wiring
2
IEC 60439-3, specifically intended for distribution boards (ASD), requires, in addition to • electrical operation test
the type tests established by IEC 60439-1, the following additional verifications: • verification of insulation resistance
• verification of contruction and marking
• verification of impact strength • checking of the protective measures and of the
• verification of resistance to rusting and to humidity
• verification of resistance of insulating materials to heat
electrical continuity of the protective circuits.
• verification of resistance of insulating materials to abnormal heat and fire due to internal
electrical effects
• verification of mechanical strength of fastening means of enclosures. 3
Analogous tests are prescribed by IEC 60439-3 for distribution boards (ASD).

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 11

 Technical Application Papers

1.9 Switchgear and controlgear assemblies • Uniform Building Code 1997

• Italian Government Decree PCM No. 3274,
1 Generalities about LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies

– special executions 20/03/2003 “Primi elementi in materia di criteri

The term “special execution” is used to define switch- generali per la classificazione sismica del territorio
boards having characteristics not considered in the nazionale e di normative tecniche per le costruzioni
Standard 439-1, but often required by users according in zona sismica” (“First elements regarding general
to the characteristics of the plant. criteria for the seismic classification of the national
territory and technical guidelines for building in
Among the most common available special executions seismic areas”)
there are: • IEEE 693-1997 “Recommended Practices for Seis-
• arc-proof switchboars mic Design of Substations”
• anti-seismic switchboards • IEEE 344-1987 “Recommended Practice for Seismic
• shock-proof switchboards4 Qualification of Class 1E Equipment for Nuclear
Power Generating Stations”
The compliance of such switchgear and controlgear as- • IEC 60980 “Recommended practices for seismic
semblies with these requirements is guaranteed by tests qualification of electrical equipment of the safety
specified by international and/or national Standards and system for nuclear generating stations”
not included in the Standard 439-1. • IEC 60068-3-3 “Guidance Seismic test methods for
equipments”
4
Obtained through a suitable choice of frames and equipment.
• IEC 60068-2-6 “Tests- Test Fc: Vibration (sinusoidal)”
• IEC 60068-2-57 “Tests- Test Ff: Vibration – Time
history method”
1.9.1 Testing under conditions of arcing due to
internal fault
The most widespread international Standard is the Tech-
nical Report IEC 61641 (see Annex A).
This test verifies the capability of the switchboards to 1.9.3 Testing for shock-proof execution
meet some requirements typically linked to the operator
In particular applications, such as for example military
safety under conditions of arcing due to internal fault.
ships, LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies are re-
It is a special test which is subject to an agreeement
quested to withstand specified vibrations and shocks.
between manufacturer and user.
The reference Standards for this type of version are:
The results of such test are presented in the form of a
test report and are not object of a test certificate. The
• IEC 60068-2-6 / EN 60068-2-6 (vibration)
interpretation of the results is subject to an agreeement
• IEC 60068-2-27 / EN 60068-2-27 (shock))
between manufacturer and user.
In this case too, since the overview of rules and standards
is very varied (to remain in the naval field, the shipping
1.9.2 Seismic qualification testing
registers are numerous and have different specifications)
Seismic qualification testing is intended to demonstrate the test shall be carried out by pre-defining the testing
the capability of an assembly and of the relevant housed modalities and the performances to be guaranteed by
equipment to withstand the stresses resulting from an the equipment.
earthquake keeping the functions required.
The overview of the standards and rules regarding
seismic qualification is wide and varied; therefore, it is
fundamental to define in advance the performances that
the testing object must guarantee.
Among the applicable Standards (different depending
on States, environments and functions for which the
equipment is intended) the following ones are to be
mentioned:

12 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

2 The electric arc
2.1 Electric arc phenomenon The flow of the high fault current causes the overheating
of the cables or of the circuit busbars, up to the melting of

2 The electric arc

The electric arc is a phenomenon which takes place as a the conductors of lower section; as soon as the conduc-
consequence of a discharge which occurs when the volt- tor melts, analogous conditions to those present during
age between two points exceeds the insulating strength the circuit opening arise. At that point an arc starts which
limit of the interposed gas; then, in the presence of suit- lasts either till the protective devices intervene or till the
able conditions, a plasma is generated which carries the conditions necessary for its stability subsist.
electric current till the opening of the protective device
on the supply side. The electric arc is characterized by an intense ionization
of the gaseous means, by reduced drops of the anodic
Gases, which are good insulating means under normal and cathodic voltage (10 V and 40 V respectively), by high
conditions, may become current conductors in conse- or very high current density in the middle of the column
quence of a change in their chemical-physical properties (of the order of 102-103 up to 107 A/cm2), by very high
due to a temperature rise or to other external factors. temperatures (thousands of °C) always in the middle of
To understand how an electrical arc originates, reference the current column and – in low voltage - by a distance
can be made to what happens when a circuit opens or between the ends variable from some microns to some
closes. During the opening phase of an electric circuit centimeters.
the contacts of the protective device start to separate
thus offering to the current a gradually decresasing
section; therefore the current meets growing resistance
with a consequent rise in the temperature. As soon as
the contacts start to separate, the voltage applied to the
circuit exceeds the dielectric strength of the air, caus-
ing its perforation through a discharge. The high
temperature causes the ionization of
the surrounding air which keeps
the current circulating in the form
of electrical arc. Besides thermal ionization,
there is also an electron emission from the cathode due
to the thermionic effect; the ions formed in the gas due
to the very high temperature are accelerated by the
electric field, strike the cathode, release energy in the
collision thus causing a localized heating which gener- 2.2 Effects of the electric arc inside
ates electron emission. switchgear and controlgear assemblies
The electrical arc lasts till the voltage at its ends supplies In the proximity of the main boards, i.e. in the proximity
the energy sufficient to compensate for the quantity of of big electrical machines, such as transformers or gen-
heat dissipated and to maintain the suitable conditions erators, the short-circuit power is high and consequently
of temperature. If the arc is elongated and cooled, the also the energy associated with the electrical arc due to
conditions necessary for its maintenance lack and it a fault is high.
extinguishes.
Without going into complex mathematical descriptions
Analogously, an arc can originate also as a consequence of this phenomenon, the first instants of arc formation
of a short-circuit between phases. A short-circuit is a low inside a cubicle can be schematized in 4 phases:
impedance connection between two conductors at differ-
ent voltages. The conducting element which constitutes 1. compression phase: in this phase the volume of the
the low impedance connection (e.g. a metallic tool forgot- air where the arc develops is overheated owing to the
ten on the busbars inside the enclosure, a wrong wiring continuous release of energy; due to convection and
or a body of an animal enetered inside the enclosure), radiation the remaining volume of air inside the cubicle
subject to the difference of potential is passed through warms up; initially there are temperature and pressure
by a current of generally high value, depending on the values different from one zone to another;
characteristics of the circuit.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 13

 Technical Application Papers

2. expansion phase: from the first instants of internal

pressure increase a hole is formed through which the
2.3 Effects of the electrical arc on human
2 The electric arc

overheated air begins to go out. In this phase the pres- beings

sure reaches its maximum value and starts to decrease From the above, it is evident that the electrical arc
owing to the release of hot air; represents a hazard source for people and goods.
The hazards to which a person is exposed due to the
3. emission phase: in this phase, due to the continuous release of energy generated by an arc event are:
contribution of energy by the arc, nearly all the air is • burns;
forced out under a soft and almost constant overpres- • injuries due to ejection of materials;
sure; • damages to hearing;
• inhalation of toxic gases.
4. thermal phase: after the expulsion of the air, the tem-
perature inside the switchgear reaches almost
that of the electrical arc, thus beginning this Burns
final phase which lasts till the arc is quenched, The high temperature levels of the gases pro-
when all the metals and the insulating materi- duced by the electrical arc and the expulsion of
als coming into contact undergo erosion with incandescent metal particles may cause more or less
production of gases, fumes and molten material severe burns to people.
particles. Flames can cause all degrees of burn up to carboniza-
tion: the red-hot solid bodies, such as the metal frag-
Should the electrical arc occur in open configurations, ments of the assembly involved, cause third degree
some of the described phases could not be present or burns, superheated steam causes burns analogous
could have less effect; however, there shall be a pres- to those by hot liquids whereas radiant heat generally
sure wave and a rise in the temperature of the zones causes less severe burns.
surrounding the arc.
Injuries due to ejection of materials
Being in the proximity of an electrical arc is quite The ejection of metal particles or other loose
dangerous; here are some data to understand how items caused by the electrical arc can result in
dangerous it is: severe injuries to the weakest parts of the hu-
• pressure: at a distance of 60 cm from an man body as, for example, the eyes. The materials
electrical arc associated with a 20 kA arcing expelled owing to the explosion produced by the arc
fault a person can be subject to a force of 225 kg; may penetrate the cornea and hurt it. The extent of
moreover, the sudden pressure wave may cause the lesions depends on the characteristics and on the
permanent injuries to the eardrum; kinetic energy of these objects.
• arc temperatures: about 7000-8000 °C; Moreover, the ocular region can sustain injuries to the
• sound: electrical arc sound levels can reach 160 db, mucosa because of the gases released by the arc and
a shotgun blast only 130 db. the emission of ultraviolet and infrared rays can injure
the cornea and the retina depending on the radiation
wavelengths.

Hearing
As already mentioned, the electrical arc is a real
explosion, whose sound may cause permanent
injuries to hearing.

Inhalation of toxic gases

The fumes produced by burnt insulating materials
and by molten or vaporized metals can be toxic.
The fumes are caused by incomplete burning
and are formed by carbon particles and by other solid
substances suspended in the air.

14 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

3 Internal arc-proof switchgear and controlgear
assemblies
3.1 Generalities The causes of an arc fault can be both technical as well
as non technical; among the latter the most frequent are

3 Internal arc-proof switchgear and controlgear assemblies

In LV switchgear there are two types of fault to which the following:
the development of currents of remakable intensity is • personnel errors, above all during maintenance
associated: operations;
• bolted fault • installation operations not sufficiently accurate;
• arc fault. • inadequate maintenance, above all in the case of
With the term “bolted” reference is made to a fault in severe environmental conditions.
which two or more live parts at different potential get Among the technical causes of an arc fault in a LV as-
in touch; this is the case of phase-to-phase or phase- sembly the following ones are to be remembered:
to-earth short-circuits to which the circulation of an • breakdown of the insulation essentially in the
anomalous current within the ring developed at the fault proximity of the supports of the busbars and of the
moment is associated. plug-in contacts of the withdrawable units (75% of
cases);
On the contrary, an arc fault occurs when there is a re- • overvoltages generating disruptive discharges
duction in the dielectric strength of the insulating means between the points at minimum clearances (15%
(air, in LV switchboards) interposed between two or more of cases);
conducting elements at different potential. • constructional defects of the apparatus (10% of
cases).
The arc is generated at the moment when, due to the It is known that the low voltage Standard (IEC 60439-1)
high ionization of the air, there is a breakdown of the requires as type test the verification of the short-circuit
dielectric of the medium and the consequent flow of the withstand strength for the bolted fault, whereas it does
current through it. not give any precise indication as regards arc faults.

In a bolted fault the most harmful effects are prevalently The only indication as regards this matter given by the
of electrodynamic type, proportional to I2, due to the high Standard 439-1 is addressed to the manufacturer who
intensity of the current and to the low fault resistance is obliged to provide all the possible precautions aimed
involved (the medium in which the fault current flows is at reducing the possibility of arcing inside an assembly.
a conducting material). However, there is a guideline document for the verifica-
tion of the internal arc withstand of LV assemblies very
On the contrary, in an arc fault the highest stresses are diffused both at Italian as well as at international level.
of thermal type and proportional to RaI2 owing to the high It is the document IEC 61641 ”Enclosed low-voltage
value taken by the arc resistance Ra; this because the switchgear and controlgear assemblies - Guide for test-
fault current flows in a medium which is always insulating, ing under conditions of arcing due to internal fault” (see
even if extremely ionized. Annex A).

Such stresses manifest themselves essentially in the Since it is a Technical Report type 3, this document
form of: has not the validity of a Standard and consequently the
• high thermal gradients caused by the quick and relevant tests do not represent a mandatory type test to
intense rise in the air temperature; the purpose of obtaining the state of TTA.
• high pressure gradients in the form of pressure
wave; Nevertheless, this document represents a solid technical
• high ionization of the air with consequent reduction reference as regards the testing modalities, defining the
of its insulating strength. main characteristics of an arc-proof assembly and the
requirements it must meet.
Generally speaking, in a LV assembly designed and According to the document IEC 616411 a LV switchgear
tested according to the Standard IEC 60439-1 an arc and controlgear assembly shall:
fault is not very likely to occur; however, should it occur, • limit the risk of injuries/accidents for the personnel
the consequences would be extremely harmful to both in case of internal arc
the equipment as well as the personnel (see Chapters • limit the damage of the switchboard to the section
2.2 and 2.3). affected by the fault, thus allowing the not-affected
part to be put into safety (emergency operations).

1
New edition to be published.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 15

 Technical Application Papers

3.2 Characteristics of internal arc-proof The thermal consequences of arcing (exhausted gases at
high temperature) are then limited by designing the inside
3 Internal arc-proof switchgear and controlgear assemblies

switchgear and controlgear assemblies

of the switchgear so that the outlet of gases takes place
Safety for the operator and for the installation in case in the top part (over 2 m) and not at lower heights which
of arcing inside LV switchgear can be obtained through might be potentially dangerous for the operator.
three different design philosophies:
It is evident that each opening of significant dimensions
1. assemblies mechanically capable of withstanding on the doors might constitute a vent for the gases and
the electric arc (passive protection) result dangerous for the operator; therefore such open-
2. assemblies equipped with devices limiting the ef- ings are usually avoided in this type of switchgear.
fects of internal arcing (active protection) As already said, in addition to the operator safety, the
3. assemblies equipped with current limiting circuit- Document IEC 61641 prescribes that the switchgear
breakers. shall guarantee also safety for the plant in case of an arc
event (see Annex A).
These three solutions (also combined together) have As a consequence, the manufacturer shall adopt ad-
found a remakable development in the industrial field and ditional design measures.
have been successfully applied by the main manufactur-
ers of LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies. Fundamentally, the switchboard shall be manufactured
As it can be seen hereafter by examining the first two so as to safeguard its functional part in case of arcing
solutions, an “active” protection against arc faults is and then to allow putting into safety of the plant once
intrinsecally more complex than a “passive” one. the fault has been eliminated.
This because of the presence of additional electrome- A switchboard of this type shall have mainly two design
chanical/electronic devices5 which limit the arcing effects characteristics:
and which, by their nature, may be subject to faults or • non-propagation of the arc between two adjacent
not-tripping. columns;
• non-propagation of the arc between the compart-
3.2.1 Assemblies mechanically capable of ment housing the bars and that where the apparatus
withstanding the electric arc (passive are installed.
protection) The fulfilment of these requirements is the result of the
internal division into compartments of the switchboard.
The switchboards which take constructional precau-
As a matter of fact this allows obtaining internal “arc-
tions suitable to the containment of the arc and to the
proof” subdivisions, that is cubicles or compartments
successive outlet of the exhausted gases belong to this
where the arc is confined in its place of occurrence, thus
type of assemblies.
avoiding damages to adjacent areas.
Two are the peculiar characteristics of these types of
switchgear:
• reinforced mechanical frame able to withstand the
3.2.2 Assemblies equipped with devices limiting
stresses (overpressures) caused by internal arcing;
• creation inside the assembly of a preferential path for internal arc effects (active protection)
the discharge of the hot gases generated by arcing. A design philosophy which is completely different from
that just considered consists in guaranteeing the resist-
Both characteristics are indispensable to satisfy the ance to internal arcing by installing devices limiting the
safety requirements for the operator and the installation arc.
established by the Document IEC 61641. The approaches in that direction can be of two different
As a consequence, the manufacturers take design meas- types:
ures to prevent the accidental opening of the doors (or • limiting the destructive effects of the arc, once it has
their perforation) due to the pressure wave generated occured, by means of arc detectors
by the arc. • limiting the destructive effects of the arc, once it has
Besides, also the instruments which can be positioned occured, by means of overpressure detectors.
on the doors must be able to withstand an overpressure The first possibility consists in installing in the assembly
of about 1bar (=1kg/cm2) without being ejected and arc detectors which sense the light flux associated with
projected outside the switchboard. the electric arc phenomenon.
Once the arc has been detected, these devices send an
5
Arc and/or overpressure detectors opening signal to the incoming circuit-breaker, thus guar-

16 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

anteeing tripping times of the order of 1-2 ms, therefore sociated with the arc enable the system to intervene and

3 Internal arc-proof switchgear and controlgear assemblies

shorter than those proper of the circuit-breaker. allow the consequent opening of the circuit-breaker.
The operating logic of an arc detector is the following: the
occurrence of an arc inside the switchboard is detected The second possibility consists in installing overpressure
by the arc detector because an intense light radiation sensors inside the switchboard.
is associated with this phenomenon. The arcing control As previously described, the overpressure wave is one
system detects the event and sends a tripping signal to of the other effects occurring inside an assembly in case
the circuit-breaker. of arcing.

All the above with trip times of a few milliseconds and As a consequence it is possible to install some pressure
supplanting the tripping of the CB overcurrent relay sensors which are able to signal the pressure peak as-
which, for example, could be delayed due to current sociated with the arc ignition with a delay of about 10-15
selectivity questions. ms. The signal operates on the supply circuit-breaker
without waiting for the trip times of the selectivity protec-
Figure 1 shows the possible positions where this device tions to elapse, which are necessarily longer.
can be installed inside a switchboard.
The ideal solution is that which provides the installa- Such a system does not need any electronic processing
tion of at least one detector for each column, with the device, since it acts directly on the tripping coil of the
consequent reduction to a minimum of the length of the supply circuit-breaker.
optical fibers carrying the signal.
Obviously it is essential that the device is set at fixed trip
In order to prevent from an unwanted tripping caused by thresholds. When an established internal overpressure
light sources indepent of the arc (lamps, solar radiation is reached, the arc detector intervenes.
etc.), an additional current sensor is often positioned at However, it is not easy to define in advance the value of
the incoming of the main circuit-breaker. overpressure generated by an arc fault inside a switch-
Only in the event of an arc, both the incoming sensor - board.
which detects an “anomalous” current due to the arc fault
- as well as the sensor detecting the light radiation as-

Figure 1 - Possible positions of arc detectors

1.

2. Current Sensing Unit

Example showing the position of detectors in:

1. Horizontal and vertical busbar system
2. Circuit-breaker cubicle
Arc monitor

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 17

 Technical Application Papers

3.2.3 Switchgear and controlgear assemblies than 65kA, the solutions of type a) or b) shall be with no
doubt fit for guaranteeing safety in case of an internal
with current limiting circuit-breakers
3 Internal arc-proof switchgear and controlgear assemblies

arc fault.
A last possibility to limit the effects of an internal arc fore-
sees the installation of current limiting circuit-breakers.
In this case two are the possible solutions:
• separating the parts of the installation at high short- Fig. a
circuit current (Figure a);
• limiting - at each incoming section - the short-circuit
current and consequently the intensity of a possible
arc (Figure b).
In the case a), the current limiting circuit-breaker sepa-
rates the right and the left part of the plant thus limiting
the contribution to the fault (in our case the arc fault) given
by the sound part of the plant to the affected one.

Should this be insufficient, the most extreme solution is

Is
the b) where each incoming feeder from the transformer
has a current limiting circuit-breaker which reduces the
Fig. b
energy supplied by each bus riser in the event of an arc
fault.

Both these solutions are frequently used in assemblies

which are arc-proof from a mechanical point of view (pas-
sive protection), when the arc resistance performances
of the switchboard (or of part of it) are insufficient for the Is Is Is
installation requirements.

For example, if the switchboard under consideration

has a mechanical resistance of 65kA to an internal arc
and the short-circuit current of the plant is much higher

18 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear
ABB SACE6 low voltage switchboards of MNS series are 4.1 Constructional and functional character-
designed and certified to guarantee a passive-type pro- istics of the switchgear PC3.0/MNS R

4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

tection against internal arcing by reaching arc withstand
values up to 100kA for 0.3s. Switchgear frame
MNS switchboards are tested and certified in compli- The PC3.0/MNS R frame is based on modular 2 mm thick
ance with the Standard IEC 61641-2007 fulfilling all the steel C sections, pre-drilled at a pitch of 25 mm DIN. Each
seven criteria of the internal arc-proof verification test unit is based on modular elements and consists of:
(see Annex A). • circuit-breaker compartments;
• instrument compartments;
Thanks to careful design choices, in MNS switchgear • busbar compartment;
the arc is confined in the compartment where it ignites, • cable compartment.
thus guaranteeing not only safety for the operator, but All compartments are mechanically segregated from the
also safeguarding the switchboard by permitting the put others. The switchgear is pre-set for easy extensions on
into safety of the installation and the quick removal of the both sides.
compartment where the arc event has occurred.

6
Versions MNS3.0, MNS R, MNS iS

Figure 1 Arc-proof switchgear of MNS series

Earthing
The switchgear is provided with a continuous electrolytic
copper earthing busbar, with a cross-section suitable for
the switchgear short-circuit rating and pre-set on both
The switchboards of MNS series are available in the fol-
sides for the connection to the earthing network. The fol-
lowing versions, all arc-proof:
lowing elements are connected to the earthing busbar:
• PC3.0/MNS R, main distribution switchboard (Power
• the metallic frame structures of the separate compartments;
Center)
• the not-live metallic parts of the circuit-breakers;
• MNS3.0, Motor Control Center
• the CTs and VTs earthing secondary windings.
• MN iS “intelligent”, Motor Control Center
The other not-live metallic parts of the apparatus are con-
nected to the earthing busbar by means of the metallic
The main characteristics of the primary distribution
frame of the compartment.
switchboard type PC3.0/MNS R are illustrated below.
The doors with installed apparatus are connected to
the structure by means of flexible copper braids. All
the ground connections are made with screws or bolts
provided with gripping washers.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 19

 Technical Application Papers

Circuit-breaker compartment Instrument compartment

The compartment, in the front part of the switchgear, The instrument compartment as well is positioned in the
4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

is suitable to house both air as well as moulded-case front part of the switchgear and it can be dedicated to
circuit-breakers. It is accessible through a locked hinged each functional unit or be common to more functional
door. The circuit-breakers can be installed in all the avail- units. It is accessible through a locked hinged door.
able versions, fixed, plug-in and withdrawable, in single The measuring instruments, the protection relays and
or multiple compartments. In order to guarantee the the control and signalling devices are usually mounted
maximum safety level for the operator, the disconnection on the compartment door, whereas any other auxiliary
of air and moulded-case circuit-breakers in withdrawable apparatus, such as circuit-breakers, protection fuses of
version can be carried out also with closed door. command circuits and auxiliary relays are placed inside
the compartment.
Equipment wiring is made of flexible copper cables and
arranged in dedicated wiring channels.
The terminal blocks of each circuit-breaker are separated
and properly identified.

20 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

Busbar compartment Main busbars
The busbar compartment is located in the middle sec- PC3.0/MNS R main busbars are available for currents up

4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

tion of the switchgear. The main busbars can be located to 6300 A. Main busbars, as well as distribution busbars,
at the top, in the centre or at the bottom of the panel can be completely segregated (according to the required
depending on the selected design and they distribute form of separation).
power to the various switchgear units; in some of the Each PC3.0/MNS R panel can be fitted with three busbar
existing configurations the main busbars can be directly systems simultaneously (top-centre-bottom) each one
connected to and supply the circuit-breakers. The distri- segregated from the others.
bution busbars are positioned vertically in the column and
feed the panel circuit-breakers. The busbar system can
be composed by 1, 2 or 3 busbars per phase, according
to the requested rated current, short-circuit withstand
and environmental conditions in terms of temperature,
altitude and humidity.
Busbars are normally bare copper made, but upon re-
quest they can be suitably treated: tinned, silver-plated
and/or sheathed.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 21

 Technical Application Papers

Distribution busbars Cable compartment

PC3.0/MNS R distribution busbars are available for The cable compartment is located at the rear side of
4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

currents up to 4000 A. Distribution busbars, branched the panel.

directly from the main busbar system, are vertically in-
stalled either on the right or on the left in the column. They It is accessible through locked hinged doors or removable
feed the outgoing circuit-breakers and are connected bolted doors. Its purpose is containing:
to them by means of rigid or flexible copper busbars, • power terminals;
or cables. In any case, all the connections are suitably • outgoing cables;
sized to withstand the thermodynamic stresses of the • current reducers;
fault currents. • auxiliary terminal boxes (if any).

Distribution busbars

Connection terminals

Cable connections

Copper busbar
connections

Removable sheets for

cable entry

22 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

Forms of internal separation
PC3.0/MNS R switchgear allows to achieve forms of

4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

internal separation in compliance with the reference
Standard IEC 60439-1, Annex D.

The use of these separation forms provides safe access

to the internal parts of the switchgear for the operators
and prevents as well any possible fault from propagating
through the circuits and through the adjacent compart-
ments, to the advantage of service continuity for the
installation.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 23

 Technical Application Papers

Typical compartments and cross-sections Ventilation

ABB SACE PC3.0/MNS R switchboards have been To guarantee an effective natural ventilation of the in-
4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

designed and built for the installation of both ABB air stalled components, PC3.0/MNS R switchgears have
circuit-breakers type Emax as well as moulded-case been designed so as to create separate air flows in all
circuit-breakers type Isomax and Tmax, in fixed, plug-in their internal areas.
and withdrawable versions. They allow the installation
of the main ABB apparatus and of the measuring and Gratings for natural air circulation are placed on the
protection instruments available on the market, according front and rear closing panels in the bottom part of the
to the different design requirements. compartment with air outlet through the gratings on the
roof and on the rear closing panel in the top part of the
compartment.

A = Apparatus area
B = Busbar area
C = Cable area

B
A

Diagram of natural ventilation of the unit

24 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

4.2 Versions of the switchgear type Arc-proof version
Upon request, in order to achieve the maximum safety

4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

PC3.0/MNS R
levels, a version tested in compliance with the Techni-
Available versions cal Report IEC 61641 is available. It can withstand the
ABB PC3.0/MNS R switchgears are available, accord- stresses caused by any possible internal arc for short-
ing the customers’ requirements, in the following ver- circuit currents up to 75 kA for 500 ms at 726 V, corre-
sions/types: sponding to 100 kA for 300 ms, still keeping unchanged
• for indoor installations; the voltage value of 726 V.
• top and bottom entry for power cables;
• top and bottom entry for bus ducts;
• top and bottom entry for auxiliary cables;
• standard painting;
Version complying with UL
• special painting cycle for aggressive environments;
Standards
• bare busbars;
There is a solution available in
• sheathed busbars;
compliance with the Standard UL
• busbars with protective electrolytic treatment;
1558 and intended for the North
• flame-proof cables and wiring;
American market.
• flame-proof and alogen free cables and wiring;
• arc-proof;
• degree of protection IP30...54;
• forms of separation 3a, 3b and 4b.

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 25

 Technical Application Papers

Power Motor Control Center integrated solutions

By means of a busbar transition panel it is possible to
4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

build Power Motor Control Centers to supply withdraw-

able motor control feeder units.

Besides, without transition panels, it is possible to obtain

Power Motor Control Centers with withdrawable drawers
by using MCC columns with rear access.
In this solution, the auxiliary connections are always ac-
cessed from the front, whereas the power connections
are available at the back.

Front view Lateral section INTERNAL DIVISIONS

Drawers/apparatus area
Auxiliary cable area
Power cable connection area (form 4b)
Power cable entry/exit
Vertical busbar area

Main busbar
compartment

Front
2200

2200

1025/1200/1400/1600

600 200/300 600 200/300

800/900 Earthing busbar 1025/1200/1400/1600 800/900

Power cable entry

Front

26 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

“Intelligent” switchgear lation management, ABB SACE supplies SD-View 2000,
Thanks to the use of electronic releases with dialogue a “ready to use” system consisting of a software which,

4 ABB SACE arc-proof switchgear

function, the air and moulded-case circuit-breakers when installed in a personal computer with standard
installed inside the switchgear can be controlled and configuration, allows the full control on the low voltage
managed by a supervision system. electrical installation. Modbus® RTU, the recognised
standard in the electrical distribution sector, is supplied
To integrate the moulded-case and air circuit-breakers as communication protocol.
equipped with electronic releases into a correct instal-

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 27

 Technical Application Papers

Annex A: Test on an arc-proof switchboard

This Annex describes a test carried out on an arc-proof facing all the points where gases are likely to be emitted
switchboard. (joints, inspection windows, doors etc.).
Annex A: Test on an arc-proof switchboard

The purpose of this test is verifying that no solid parts fly The arc has been initiated between the phases by means
off in the area adjacent to the assembly due to internal of a bare copper ignition wire connecting the adjacent
arcing; the arc is caused by a current with a prospective conductors across the shortest distance. The arc shall be
short-circuit value specified by the manufacturer. More initiated on three phases so that it can turn into a three-
precisely, compliance with the following seven criteria phase fault and the point of initiation shall be chosen so
must be assessed: that the effects of the resultant arc produce the highest
1. correctly secured doors, covers , etc., do not open; stresses in the assembly. The wire size depends on the
2. parts which may cause a hazard, do not fly off (this test current.
includes both large parts as well as parts with sharp
edges); The initiation points of the arc shall be chosen where, ac-
3. arcing does not cause holes in the freely accessible cording to experience, an internal arc can form, that is:
external parts of the enclosure as a result of burning • at the connection points of the main busbar sys-
or other effects; tems;
4. the indicators arranged vertically do not ignite; • in the live not insulated parts on the supply side of
5. the equipotential bonding arrangement for the acces- the switching and protective devices;
sible parts of the enclosure is still effective; • in the areas of cable terminals.
6. the arc is limited to a defined area without re-ignition
in adjacent areas; Besides, the ignition wire shall be connected only to ac-
7. after the fault extinction, the isolation or the removal of cessible bare conductors.
the functional unit affected by the fault, it is possible
to put into safety the sound part of the switchboard The applied voltage of the test circuit shall be equal to the
(emergency operations). This shall be verified by a highest rated voltage of the assembly, with a tolerance of
dielectric test to be performed at a value which is 1.5 +5% and the prospective short-circuit current, specified
times the rated voltage for the duration of 1 minute. by the manufacturer, shall be verified by a calibration
The test shall be carried out on a test specimen not oscillogram. The peak value of the current is obtained by
previously subjected to an arcing test and the mounting multiplying the short-time withstand current by a factor
conditions shall be as close as possible to those of nor- n. The standardized values of factor n and the relevant
mal service. The test specimen shall be fully equipped power factor values are shown in the following table.
with its internal components and the assigned measure
for the protection of person shall be effective.
To verify that gases or ejected solid parts do not cause
unwanted effects, indicators constituted by pieces of
cotton cloth fitted in mounting frames are used. These
indicators shall be placed up to a maximum height of
2m and at a distance of 30cm ± 5% from the assembly,

RMS value of
short-circuit current
kA cosϕ n
I≤ 5 0.7 1.5
5 < I ≤ 10 0.5 1.7
10 < I ≤ 20 0.3 2
20 < I ≤ 50 0.25 2.1
50 < I 0.2 2.2
Note Values of this table represent the majority of applications. In special locations, for example in the vicinity of transformer or generators, lower values
of power factor may be found, whereby the maximum prospective peak current may become the limiting value instead of the r.m.s.value of the
short-circuit current.

28 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

 The impedance used to verify the test current shall be A. calibration test
the same used during the test. The current carrying capacity of the circuit is verified with

Annex A: Test on an arc-proof switchboard

The test duration is given by the manufacturer. It is 65 kA test current at 462 V (440 V+5%) rated voltage.
chosen according to the time response of the electrical The table below shows the values measured during the
protection devices. If details regarding these devices are test.
not known, a power supply duration of at least 0.1s is
applied. Normally this duration should not exceed 0.5s. 1_I1 2_I2 3_I3
Average
values
Symmetrical current [kA] 65.9 65.0 65.7 65.5
A positive test result is obtained when the above men-
Peak current [kA] -129 144 -106
tioned criteria are fulfilled. Start [ms] 75.8 76.5 75.9
Three tests have been carried out: End [ms] 409.4 408.5 409.4
A. calibration test; Cosϕ 0.16
B. test with arc ignition at the terminals of an outgoing unit;
Legend:
C. test with arc ignition between the main busbars. • 1_I1, 2_I2, 3_I3: currents in the three phases
• Cosϕ: power factor

The figure below reports the oscillogram showing the

line-to-line voltages (7_Ur1, 8_Ur2, 9_Ur3) and the cur-
rents (1_I1, 2_I2, 3_I3) in the three phases.

1
4_Ur4 kV
1 k/div
-1
250
kA
1_I1
250 k/div
-250
1
kV
7_Ur1
1 k/div
-1
1
5_Ur5 kV
1 k/div
-1
250
2_I2 kA
250 k/div
-250
1
kV
8_Ur2
1 k/div
-1
1
kV
6_Ur6
1 k/div
-1
250
kA
3_I3
250 k/div
-250
1
kV
9_Ur3
1 k/div
-1
10
V
10_Cam
10/div
-10
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420
20 ms/div ms

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 29

 Technical Application Papers

B. test with arc ignition at the terminals of an outgoing unit The table below shows the values measured during the
After the circuit calibration an arc-proof test shall be test.
Annex A: Test on an arc-proof switchboard

carried out applying for 0.3 s a test current of 65 kA at a

voltage of 462 V (440 V+5%). 1_I1/4_Ur4 2_I2/5_Ur5 3_I3/6_Ur6
The arc has been initiated between the upper terminals Maximum current [kA] 10.3 19.8 -19.8
of a circuit-breaker of one of the outgoing units: the du- Maximum voltage [V] 786 349 -746
ration of the current has resulted to be only 7.7 ms due Arcing energy [kJ] 1.28 22.7 22.3

to self-extinction of the arc. As a consequence also the Total specific energy [A2s] 4.38E+04 1.43E+06 1.52E+06
Arcing power [W] 6.98E+06 5.52E+06 7.55E+06
current value results to be reduced.
Arc duration [ms] 1.1 7.7 7.6
The arc has extinguished within the first half of the full
intended test duration without being ignited again and Legend:
• 1_I1, 2_I2, 3_I3: currents in the three phases
therefore, in compliance with the Technical Report IEC • 4_Ur4, 5_Ur5, 6_Ur6: arcing voltages
61641, such test shall be repeated using the same point • Cosϕ: power factor
of initiation as for the first test.
Since the arc has extinguished within the first half of the The figure below reports the oscillogram showing the
full intended duration also during this repetition, a further arcing voltages (4_Ur4, 5_Ur5, 6_Ur6), the line-to-line
test is not required. voltages (7_Ur1, 8_Ur2, 9_Ur3) and the currents (1_I1,
2_I2, 3_I3) in the three phases. In the oscillogram the
short duration of the currents due to the fast arc extinc-
tion can be noticed.

1
4_Ur4 kV
1 k/div
-1
50
kA
1_I1
50 k/div
-50
1
kV
7_Ur1
1 k/div
-1
1
5_Ur5 kV
1 k/div
-1
50
2_I2 kA
50 k/div
-50
1
kV
8_Ur2
1 k/div
-1
1
kV
6_Ur6
1 k/div
-1
50
kA
3_I3
50 k/div
-50
1
kV
9_Ur3
1 k/div
-1
2
V
10_Cam
2/div
-2
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420
20 ms/div ms

30 Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

 C. test with arc ignition between the main busbars The table below shows the values measured in the test.
A further test, always 65 kA at 462 V, is carried out with arc

Annex A: Test on an arc-proof switchboard

initiation between the main busbars; the actual duration 1_I1 2_I2 3_I3
of the current has resulted to be 0.3 s, with temporary Peak current [kA] 55.7 -62.3 46.6
self-extinctions of the arc on the phases L1 and L3 and Duration [ms] 301.37 301.37 216.76
subsequent re-ignition. Specific energy [A2s] 2.53E+08 2.97E+08 1.12E+08

The figure below reports the oscillogram showing the

arcing voltages (4_Ur4, 5_Ur5, 6_Ur6), the line-to-line
voltages (7_Ur1, 8_Ur2, 9_Ur3) and the currents (1_I1,
2_I2, 3_I3) in the three phases.

1
4_Ur4 kV
1 k/div
-1
100
kA
1_I1
50 k/div
-100
1
kV
7_Ur1
1 k/div
-1
1
5_Ur5 kV
1 k/div
-1
100
2_I2 kA
50 k/div
-100
1
kV
8_Ur2
1 k/div
-1
1
kV
6_Ur6
1 k/div
-1
100
kA
3_I3
50 k/div
-100
1
kV
9_Ur3
1 k/div
-1
2
V
10_Cam
2/div
-2
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420
20 ms/div ms

Arc-proof low voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies 31

 1SDC007105G0201 February ’08
Printed in Italy
0.000 - CAL

Due to possible developments of standards as well as of

materials, the characteristics and dimensions specified in this
document may only be considered binding after confirmation
by ABB SACE.

ABB SACE
A division of ABB S.p.A.

L.V. Breakers
Via Baioni, 35
24123 Bergamo - Italy
Tel.: +39 035.395.111 - Telefax: +39 035.395.306-433

http://www.abb.com