Improving Reading Comprehension by Using Short Story To The Tenth Grade of Sma Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research at The First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
Improving Reading Comprehension by Using Short Story To The Tenth Grade of Sma Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research at The First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
http://iraj.in
IMPROVING READING COMPREHENSION BY USING SHORT
STORY TO THE TENTH GRADE OF SMA NEGERI 1 BULUKUMBA
( A CLASSROOM ACTION RESEARCH AT THE FIRST YEAR OF
SMAN 1 BULUKUMBA )
MUTAKHIRANI MUSTAFA
Abstract – The research aimed at finding out the improvement of students’ reading comprehension by using short story at
class XMIA3 of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba Kab. Bulukumba.This research used short story technique to applied in the class
when the researcher taught the students of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba. This research was classroom action research that
consisted of two cycles. One cycle consisted of three meetings. It means that there were six meetings in two cycles. This
classroom action research was done at SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba for English subject. As subject in this research was class
XMIA3 senior high school in 2014-2015 academic years with student’s number as about 32 students. Those consist of 22
female and 10 male. Instruments are essay test and observation sheet. The findings of this research were the improvement of
the students’ reading comprehension in terms of try to find main idea and supporting idea in which the mean score of cycle I
was 73,25 and the mean score of cycle II was 88,06. The result above indicated that there was significant improvement of the
students’ reading comprehension by using short story at class XMIA3 of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba Kab. Bulukumba.
Conclusion based on the analysis result of the research, it can be concluded that the use of short story can improve reading
comprehension ability of the tenth grade students of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba. The students’ mean score for cycle I is
73,25 and it is improved in cycle II with the means score is 87.
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
57
International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-4, Issue-5, May-2018
http://iraj.in
short story can offer learners adequate linguistic, meaning of materials whether printed or written and
intellectual, and emotional involvement and enrich verbal symbol. Reading skills is the ability of process
their learning experience in Teaching L2 Reading the written or printed material from what was been
Comprehension through Short Story. And then other read and improve a construct of ideas depend on the
research by Nina Haslinda (2004: 39) concluded that experience or prior knowledge of the reader.
there was a significance difference between the b. Concept of Reading Comprehension
student’s achievement in reading comprehension Reading comprehension is a dialogue author and
before and after using question and answer technique reader. The activity needs ability to communicate
can improve the students reading comprehension of with an author. While reading silently rather than
the first years students of SMAnegeri 1Bulukumba, orally (Smith and Jhonsonin Hendra 2009: 16) it is a
and it is proved by their achievement in the pre-test complex process in which the readers use his mental
and posttest. Addition related research by Naeemeh content to obtain from written material. Teaching
Kharaghani (2013) The results were analyzed using reading comprehension use short story can help the
T-tests. It was found that the group which received students improve their reading comprehension when
short stories as their reading text outperformed the the teacher teach short story. .
other group in the effect of short stories on reading
comprehension ability of iranian efl learners. Other 2. The Concept of Short Story
supporting research by Hendra (2009: 30) concluded a. Definition of short story
that by comprehending short story can improve According Irvan Al Radjab (2007: 98), short story is
students reading skill of the second years students of (1) a short piece of prose fiction organized into a plot
SMANegeri 2 Malusetasi. From some findings of the and with a kind of dénouement at the end.(2) A short
research above the researcher concluded that in fictional narrative.Grellet (1986) says that there two
teaching and learning process, the teachers are reasons for reading. They are: reading for pleasure
supposed to make the students more interested in and reading for information. Both pleasure and
material and involve them in learning process by information depend on the reader. Reading for
creating a good atmosphere in teaching English pleasure is done without other people’s order, while
reading comprehension. Therefore, the researcher reading for information, in many cases relevant to
believes that the use of short story will be effective to current study of the readers. People read to find out
improving the reading comprehension of the students, things, as a natural phenomenon of innate
So the both of previous finding will be reference to characteristics of the human doing to be curious about
support this research. world around him, he needs information to reduce
uncertainties.
B. Some Pertinent Ideas b. Teaching reading comprehension by using short
story
1. The Concept of Reading According to Erkaya (2005) short stories motivate
a. Definition of Reading students to continue reading so that they can solve the
There are some definitions of reading given by problem. And since it is interesting for students they
some author as follows: would not easily get frustrated.
1) Haris and Sipay (1980) explains that reading is
the meaningful interpretation of written verbal III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
symbol. Reading is a result of interaction
between the perception of graphic symbol that A. Research Design
represent language and reader’s language skill’s This research is classroom action research. This
language and knowledge of the world. research has characteristics to solve the problem
2) Kustaryo (1988: 273) says that, reading is a which occur in the class so that it aims to increase the
complex process in which recognition and motivation, maximize the result of study or to know
compression of written symbol are influenced by the effective of studying or lesson plan. This research,
reader’s language background, mind sets, and the teacher purposed two cycles consist of four steps.
reasoning abilities, and they anticipate meaning They were planning, action, monitoring, and
on the basic of what has been read. reflection
3) Richards (2002: 273) says that reading is a skill
that is highly valued by students and teachers B. Setting of The Research
alike. Reading comprehension is a complex 1. Location of Research
process in which the reader used his mental This classroom action research performed in
ability to obtain the information. It means that SMAN 1 Bulukumba, in the tenth grade. This
the reader must be able to recognize the meaning research was applied in one month.
of printed words. 2. Time of the Research
This research was applied in one month. It
Based on the definition of reading above, it will be started on January, 25th 2015 until on February,
concluded that reading is a process or activity to get 27th 2015.
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
58
International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-4, Issue-5, May-2018
http://iraj.in
3. Cycle of Research ∑X = Total Score
The teacher purposed two cycles consist of four N = The number of students
steps. They were planning, action, monitoring, (Gay in hasriati, 2004 ∶ 28)
and reflection. 2. To classify the students’ score, there were seven
classifications which were used as follows:
C. Research of the Instrument
There are two instrument of the research that will be Table. I The score qualification
used, they are: No. Qualification Score
1. Observation 1. Excellent 86 – 100
Using sheet of observation is to get information about
the using in teaching reading comprehension. 2. Good 71 – 85
2. Test 3. Fair 56 – 70
Test will be used for measuring the result of student’s 4. Poor 41 – 55
achievement. So, the researcher can identify whether 5 Very poor < 40
the students make progress in reading comprehension (Dirjen Pendidikan Dasar dan Menengah, 2005:2)
or not.
3. To Calculate the percentage of the students’ score,
D. Subject of the Research the formula which was used as follows:
The subject of this research was the tenth grade F
students of SMAN 1 Bulukumba, second semester of P = X 100
N
academic year 2014/2015. The researcher chose class
X MIA3 which consists of 32 students. Notation:
P : Rate Percentage
E. Source of Data and Technique of collecting F : Frequency of the correct answer
Data N : The total number of students
1. Source of Data
Source of data from this classroom action research (Sudjana in hasriati, 2004: 28)
were students, the teacher and the school.
2. Technique of Collecting Data G. Procedure of The Research
a) The data about the students participation would This Classroom Action Research applied into two
be collected from the observation sheet. cycles; every cycle presented into third meetings. The
b) Data about the students achievement would be second cycle based on the first cycle. It means that
collected from test. the activity of the second cycle was continued and
repaired based on the reflection the first cycle. In
F. Technique of Data Analysis every cycle was divided into four steps. There were
The data analysis that would be used were planning, action, monitoring/observation, and
Quantitative Data and Qualitative Descriptive reflection.
Analysis. To analyze the data collected through
analysis quantitative data and qualitative data. These
quantitative data and qualitative data can be analyzed
in descriptive statistic, such as the indicator of
achievement and the data such as information which
give the description of the students’ comprehension
in one subject, behavior or the student. The activity of
the students in learning process was attention,
enthusiasm in learning process, and motivation. There
are steps that would be applied in analyzing the data:
observation and discussion between the teacher and
collaborator from reflecting the result cycle of the
classroom action research.
The data on the students’ reading comprehension by Figure 1: Action Research Cycle
using short story was analyzed in the following (source McTaggart et al., 1982)
procedures:
1. To find out the mean score of the students’ test, Activity of the first cycle
the researcher used the formula : The first cycle was continued for four meetings. It
∑X was divided into four steps as follows:
X= 1. Planning
N This step gave with the following procedure:
Where :
X = Mean Score
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
59
International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-4, Issue-5, May-2018
http://iraj.in
a. Made a learn plan that would be implemented a. The activity of situation in learning process. In
during learning and teaching process, namely learning process, the researcher would observe as
syllabus and lesson plan. follows:
b. Determining the material. In this research, the 1) Checking attendance
material would be taken is short story, the story 2) The student’s activities
is narrative text form. 3) The ability of the teacher and the students.
c. Glancing at all key words, bolded text, questions a. Collecting data of the task
for consideration, problem sets.
d. Made worksheet. 4. Reflecting
e. Preparing the criteria and preparing research On the last cycle the researcher reflected of the result
instrument. observation. The next researcher reflected toward
f. Arrangingfor learning evaluation. disadvantage.
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
60
International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-4, Issue-5, May-2018
http://iraj.in
researcher asked the students to read the short story In the first meeting there are 25 students, the
and they understand it. second meeting there are 24 students and the
third meeting there are 25 students paying
B. The Implementation Result of Cycle I attention when the researcher is explaining the
During the implementation of cycle I, the researcher material. It means that some students do not pay
used two techniques of collecting data. The first data attention to researcher’s explanation in class
of learning result and the second is learning situation and they do other activities while researcher
data. It means the researcher gets two kinds data are gives explanation.
quantitative and qualitative data. c. Number students giving question to the
researcher
1. The Quantitative Data There are 4 students in the first meeting give
Reading comprehension by using short story shows question to the researcher when they are taught
that the students’ reading comprehension ability is writing through paraphrasing technique, in the
improved, but there are some students have not second meeting there are 6 students and in the
achieved the criteria of success. The minimal third meeting there are 10 students give
standard criteria are mean score of the students’ question to the researcher. It means that amount
reading comprehension is 75. The students’ score students giving question to the researcher is
after implementation of cycle I . more than previous meeting.
2. The Qualitative Data d. Number students doing assignment
Beside data of learning result, to improve the In the first meeting, there are 32 students doing
students’ reading comprehension the researcher also assignment from the researcher. In the second
takes data of learning situation for three times meeting there are 31 students doing assignment
meeting. Improvement of students’ learning result because one student is not present. And the third
cannot be separated by students’ activities in class meeting amount students doing assignment are
during learning process, so that observer made a note 32 same with the first meeting. It means that
about all students’ activities during learning process. willing of the students to do assignment from
Observer used observation sheet to observe six the teacher is very good.
activities of the students. The activities as follow: e. Number students doing other activities beside
No. 1: students presenting in class the learn in class
No. 2: students paying attention to researcher’s Some of the students doing other activities
explanation beside the learn such as make a noisy, fancying,
No. 3: students giving question to the researcher disturb at each other, etc. in the first meeting,
No. 4: students doing assignment second meeting and third meeting there are 7
No. 5: students doing other activities beside the students of 32 students doing activities beside
learn in class the learn. It means that their interest in writing
No. 6: students out from class without researcher’s is still low.
permission f. Number students out from class without
The result of observing will be presented as follow: researcher’s permission
During three times meeting of cycle I there is no
Table 4.3 Result of Observing Students’ Activities student out from class without researcher’s
Students’ Activities/ Total number permission. It means that students’ awareness to
of the Students present in class is very good.
Cy Mee
cle ting 1 2 3 4 5 6
C. Reflection for Cycle I
32 32 32 32 32 32 One of the criteria of success is the students’ mean
score is 64 or more. Based on the data of students’
I 32 25 4 32 7 0 score presented on the table 4.1 above, it can be
I II 31 24 6 31 7 0 concluded that the implementation of short story in
teaching to improve reading comprehension of the
III 32 25 10 32 7 0 tenth grade students of SMA Negeri1 Bulukumba in
reading short story is not successful yet because mean
a. Number students presenting in class score of the students is below the criterion of success.
In the first meeting all students (32 students) Other criterion of success is if the students’
present in class, in the second meeting there are participation, interest, and motivation are more
31 students present and one student is sick. In increased. Based on the qualitative data gotten from
the third meeting same with the first meeting, observation sheet, the students’ participation,
all students present in class. It means that motivation, and interest in teaching writing is need to
presence of the students is very good. be improved. It caused by there are still some
b. Number students paying attention to students are not active in class.
researcher’s explanation
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
61
International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-4, Issue-5, May-2018
http://iraj.in
Although some students show their improvement in Table 4.6 Result of Observing Students’ Activities
reading comprehension and their score, the cycle 2 Students’ Activities/ Total number
needs to be conducted. It is done because some C of the Students
Meet
students get score under the standard criteria of yc
ing 1 2 3 4 5 6
success is determined. There are 14 students get score le
below 64. The cycle 2 is done to find appropriate 32 32 32 32 32 32
strategy in improving reading comprehension of the
students by using short story. I 32 26 9 32 6 0
I II 32 27 11 32 5 0
D. The Implementation of CycleII
In the cycle I, the researcher just gave the students III 32 29 13 32 3 0
short story and explained steps to read and find the
main idea. After that, the researcher asked the a. Number students presenting every meeting
students to read short story and they understand of the In the fifth, sixth, and seventh meeting all
content of the short story. The result of testing in students present in class. It means that present of
cycle I show that there are some students get score the students every meeting is very good. It gives
below the criteria of success and not active in reading good effect for their improvement because if
comprehension activity but some others shows their students’ willing to learn is improved, so their
improvement and activeness in reading interest and motivation will improve their
comprehension. In the cycle II, the researcher gave improvement.
some sequence questions to help the students to find b. Number students paying attention to
the main idea of the short story. The researcher asked researcher’s explanation
the students to answer the sequences question based In the fifth meeting there are 26 students, the
on the short story given. The students read answer of second meeting there are 27 students and the
the short story according to order of the question into third meeting there are 29 students paying
paragraph. These sequence questions made the attention when the researcher is explaining the
students easier to express their idea and could more material. It means that most students pay
understand the short story so they are more active attention to researcher’s explanation in class and
reading comprehension. their interest in teaching writing is more
improved.
E. The Implementation Result of Cycle II c. Number students giving question to the
In the second cycle, the researcher also gets two kinds researcher
data during implementation are quantitative and There are 9 students in the first meeting give
qualitative data. question to the researcher when they are taught
1. The Quantitative Data reading comprehension by using short story, in
In the cycle II, teaching short story shows that the second meeting there are 11 students and in
reading comprehension of the students is more the third meeting there are 13 students give
improved than cycle I. All students have achieved the question to the researcher. It means that amount
criteria of success. The minimal standard criterion is students giving question to the researcher is more
the mean score of the students’ reading than previous meeting.
comprehension is 64. d. Number students doing assignment
2. The Qualitative Data In the every meeting in cycle I, there are 32
Same with technique of collecting data in the cycle I, students doing assignment from the researcher. It
beside data of learning result to improve the students’ means that willing of the students to do
reading comprehension the researcher also takes data assignment from the teacher and their motivation
of learning situation for three times meeting. to learn is very good.
Observer used also observation sheet to observe six e. Number students doing other activities beside
activities of the students in this cycle. The activities the learn in class
as follow: Some of the students doing other activities beside
No. 1: students presenting in class the learn such as make a noisy, fancying, disturb
No. 2: students paying attention to researcher’s at each other, etc. in the first meeting there 6
explanation students doing other activity, second meeting 5
No. 3: students giving question to the researcher and third meeting there are 3 students of 32
No. 4: students doing assignment students doing activities beside the learn. It
No. 5: students doing other activities beside the means that more students are active.
learn in class f. Number students out from class without
No. 6: students out from class without researcher’s researcher’s permission
permission Same with cycle I, during three times meeting of
The result of observing in the cycle II will be cycle II there is no student out from class without
presented as follow:
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
62
International Journal of Management and Applied Science, ISSN: 2394-7926 Volume-4, Issue-5, May-2018
http://iraj.in
researcher’s permission. It means that students’ [4] Donnelly, Mona. 1979. Teaching Reading. Boston Toronto:
Little , Brown and Company.
awareness to present in class is very good. [5] Erkaya, O. R. (2005). Benefits of using short stories in the
EFL context. Asian EFL Journal, 8, 38-49.
F. Reflection for Cycle II [6] Greenwood, Jhon. 1981. Teaching of English as
Based on the data result of the reading AnIinternational Language. Collin.
comprehension on the table above, it can be [7] Grellet, Francoise. 1986. Developing Reading Skill. London:
Cambridge
concluded that ability of the students in reading [8] Haris, Albert, and Sipay, Edward,R. 1980. How to Increase
comprehension by using short story is very improved. Reading Ability.A Guide to Development and Remedial
The data shown that the students’ mean score was 87 Methods. New York. Longman inc.
[9] Hendra. 2009. Improving The Reading Skill Through
and it means that their learning achievement is
Comprehending Short Story To The Second Years Students
improved. If in terms of the students’ participation, of SLTP Negeri 2 Mallusetasi. Unpublished Thesis.Parepare:
interest, and motivation in reading comprehensionn, it FKIP UMPAR>
was also improved. It means that teaching short story [10] Hismanoglu, M. (2005). Teaching English through literature.
Journal of Language and Linguistic Studies, 1(1), 53-66.
can improve reading comprehension ability of the [11] Hornby, AS. 1987. Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary of
tenth grade students of SMA Negeri1Bulukumba in Current English. London: Oxford University Press.
reading comprehension of short story [12] Horowitz, Sheldon H. Reading Comprehension-Reading for
Meaning (Online),
http://www.education.com/reference/article/reading-
CONCLUSION comprehension for-meaning/). Accessed. On 2nd April
2010.
Based on the analysis result of the research, it can be [13] Irwan. 2008. Teaching Reading Comprehension To The Eight
concluded that the use of short story can improve Grade Students of SMP Negeri 8 Parepare by Using English
Comic book. Unpublished Thesis.Parepare: STKIP
reading comprehension ability of the tenth grade
Muhammadiyah Bulukumba.
students of SMA Negeri1Bulukumba. The students’ [14] Kharaghani Naeemeh . 2013.The effect of short stories on
mean score for cycle I is 73,25 and it is improved in reading comprehension ability of iranian efl
cycle II with the means score is 87. It means that the learners.Department of English, Quchan Branch, Islamic
mean score of the students fulfills target determined. Azad University, Quchan, Iran.Proceeding of the Global
Summit on Education (GSE2013).
In addition if in terms of students’ participation, [15] Kustaryo, Suhera. 1988. Reading Technique for Collega
interest, and motivation during teaching and learning Students. DepertementPendidikandanKebudayaan.
process after applying short story technique in [16] McTaggart, R. et al. 1982. The action research planner (rev.
reading comprehension are also improved, they are ed.). Geelong: Deakin University Press.
[17] Nasir, Rajad T. 1984. Teaching and Learning English
more motivated to read and involved actively. Selected and Simplyfied Reading. London: Logman
[18] Ghasemi Parvin et all . 2011. Teaching L2 Reading
REFERENCES Comprehension through Short Story. International
Conference on Languages, iterature and Linguistics IPEDR
[1] Al Rajab, Irvan. 2007. Intruduction to Literature. Fakultas vol.26 (2011) © (2011) IACSIT Press, Singapore.
Keguruan dan Ilmu Pendidikan Universitas Muhammadiayah [19] Richards, Jack. C. 2002. Methodology in Language Teaching.
Parepare. Cambridge: University Press.
[2] Badolo, Mas’ud, 2008. [20] Richards, J.C. &Renandy, W.A. (2002).Methodology in
PedomandanTeknikPenulisanSkripsi.Parepare: Universitas language teaching: An anthology of current practice
Muhammadiyah Parepare. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[3] Brown, Douglaes, H. 2001. Teaching by Principle and
Interactive Approach to Language Pedagogy Second Edition.
San Fransisco: Logman.
Improving Reading Comprehension by using Short Story to the Tenth Grade of SMA Negeri 1 Bulukumba (A Classroom Action Research
at the First Year of Sman 1 Bulukumba)
63