Impact of Celebrity Endorsements and Brand Mascots On Consumer Buying Behavior
Impact of Celebrity Endorsements and Brand Mascots On Consumer Buying Behavior
ABSTRACT. Celebrity and brand mascot endorsements are very popular and often-used techniques
by marketers. Marketers believe that celebrity and brand mascot endorsements provide a higher
degree of appeal, attention, and customer recall ability compared with when this technique is not
used. Marketers also claim that a celebrity affects the credibility of claims about a product and
increases the memorabilia factor of the message, which may provide a positive effect that could be
generalized to the brand. Primarily this essay has been designed such that it examines various
parameters related to advertisements containing celebrity and brand mascot endorsements. Data were
been collected from 150 respondents through questionnaire and subjected to t test, χ 2 test, and
difference of means test to enforce the hypotheses that celebrity endorsements have impacts on
customers’ perceptions and their purchase intentions. The findings of this study provide insights for
marketing and brand managers to design and market their campaigns effectively.
Garima Malik is an assistant professor associated with Amity Business School, Noida, India. Abhinav
Guptha is an assistant manager-branding at National Payments Corporation in Mumbai, India.
Address correspondence to Dr. Garima Malik, c/o Prince Malik, No. 25, Sector 16-A, Noida, Uttar-
Pradesh, India 201301. Email: [email protected]
128
Garima Malik and Abhinav 12
Guptha
with a large customer base. In short, celebrity TABLE 1. Valuable Factors That Influence
en- dorsements are more typical for nationally Purchasing Decisions
mar-
keted products than they are for local or niche
market products and are more typical for prod- N Mean SD
ucts such as running shoes, soft drinks, and other
products for which the price–cost margins are Price of the product 150 2.38 1.028
Celebrity endorsement 150 3.04 1.029
large. Quality of product 150 1.83 1.085
There is a tremendous impact of celebrity tele- Value for money 150 2.29 1.102
vision endorsements among Indian consumers;
there is a large fan following in India, and
celebrities act as role models for a majority
of Indians (Balakrishnan & Kumar, 2011). In- estimated that one quarter of all advertisements
creasingly, companies prefer to use celebrities use a celebrity spokesperson to endorse a
from different fields in India such as cricket product or brand (Shimp, 1997) to the extent
players, Bollywood celebrities, and other sports that it is a global phenomenon today. This
personalities to endorse their brands. Many indicates the validity of this strategy as a
com- panies brand mascots to endorse their means of persuasive communication.
products, and this strategy is very popular for Celebrities are often employed by advertisers
fast-moving consumer goods. Marketers spend to lend their personality to a product or brand
an enormous amount of money on celebrity (Kaikati, 1987). They have been found to
endorsement con- tracts based on the belief that produce more positive responses toward
celebrities are effective spokespersons for their advertising and greater purchase intentions
products or brands (Katayal, 2007). Television than a noncelebrity endorser (Atkin & Block,
has widely penetrated the minds of people from 1983; Petty & Cacioppo, 1983). Furthermore,
diver- gent socioeconomic classes. In India, McCracken found that celebrity endorsers
celebrity power can rightly be assessed by their represent an effective way of transferring
successful endorsements; film stars and cricket meaning to brands. From a theoretical
players have been successful not only in perspective, celebrities are effective endorsers
gathering huge public attention but also in because of their symbolic apparition reference
increasing com- panies’ sales volumes. For group associations (Assael, 1984; Solomon &
example, Cadbury and Nestle´ used Amitabh Assael, 1987). Advertisers use celebrities
Bachchan to promote their brand when it went because they heighten the appeal of
through a bad phase in India. Soon, the advertisements. They are believed to enhance
endorsement restored peo- ple’s love for the audience attentiveness; make the advertisement
brand and hence this phe- nomenon increased memorable, credible, and desirable; and add
Cadbury’s and Nestle´’s sales (Joshi & glamour to the product (Spielman, 1981).
Ahluwalia, 2008; Matrade, 2005). Aamir Khan Kaikati (1987) enumerates five advantages
is used by Coca-Cola to com- municate to and of employing celebrities to endorse products:
influence semiurban and ru- ral consumers to drawing attention, crisis management, brand
purchase the brand “Chota Coke.” This repositioning, global marketing, and boosting
celebrity endorsement has also been quite sales.
effective in influencing consumers’ buy- ing
decision. Similarly, various endorsements by
TABLE 2. Friedman Test
Shah Rukh Khan, Sachin Tendulkar, and others
have been found to be successful in af- fecting
consumers’ buying decisions (Joshi &
Ahluwalia).
Celebrity endorsement advertising has been
recognized as a “ubiquitous feature of modern
day marketing” (McCracken, 1989). It has
been
Parameters Mean rank
advertising,” which refers to inadequate with three tarnished celebrities: Mike Tyson,
content masked by the use of a celebrity. There Madonna, and Michael Jackson) suggest that
is also the fear of brand–celebrity disconnect, celebrity endorsers may at times become lia-
which points out that if the celebrity represents bilities to the brands they endorse. Observa-
values that conflict with the brand values, the tion reveals an increase in the use of animated
advertising would create conflict in the minds characters as product endorsers. It was deter-
of the target audience. Agarwal et al. (2005) mined that 28% of animated advertisements
defined brand attitude as consumers’ general con- tained cartoon-character celebrities such
evaluative judg- ment of a brand based on as Bugs Bunny and Mickey Mouse as these
brand beliefs. Such beliefs concern product- characters are generally immune to negative
related attributes, like practical and publicity.
experimental benefits. A success- ful endorser
is able to enhance intentions and preferences
toward brands directly or indirectly. Surana
(2008) revealed that some properties, such as
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
likability, expertise, trustworthiness, and
similarity, cause a celebrity endorser to become
a source of persuasive information, and this • To study the degree to which con-
sumers’ purchasing decision is influ-
cre- ates a sense of certainty. enced by celebrity endorsements and
Shimp (1998) examines the impact that brand mascots.
nega- tive information about a celebrity might
have on consumer evaluations of endorsed
brands. Prac- titioners hope their target
audience’s positive feelings toward a chosen TABLE 4. Attributes of Celebrity
celebrity will transfer to the endorsed brand or
will otherwise enhance the brand’s standing.
What happens if either during or after an ad-
vertising campaign negative information about
the celebrity becomes public? Widely
publicized incidents (e.g., Pepsi Cola’s series
of debacles
N Mean SD SEM
Unstandardized
Model coefficients Standardized coefficients t Sig.
Factors That Most Persuade You to considered genuine because of their winning
Purchase Personal and Food personalities. There are other famous person-
Products alities like television stars or famous writers or
singers who also sometimes influence people’s
Respondents were asked to rank the factors
purchasing intent. Politicians possess a negligi-
according to their importance when purchasing
ble share.
the various categories of products.
Table 3 clearly shows the factors that were
ranked on the basis of mean, from which we Attributes of Celebrity That Influence
can clearly ascertain that celebrity has a major Purchase Intention Toward a
role to play in persuading people to purchase Celebrity-endorsed Brand
personal care items. Followed by celebrity, it is
For further analysis, the respondents were
the cost factor that most influences purchase
asked to give their responses on the at-
decision. Brand name is rated as the third most
important factor, followed by quality.
For food products, the factors were ranked,
TABLE 9. Believes Celebrity Endorsements
from which we can clearly ascertain that
celebrity has a major role to play in persuad-
N Mean SD SEM
ing people to purchase food products. Followed
by celebrity, it is the attractive packaging that
most influences purchase decision. Cost is Easily influenced by a 150 2.69 0.970 0.079
rated as the third most important factor, celebrity endorser
followed by quality. when you purchase
a celebrity-
endorsed brand
Ever considered 150 2.67 1.240 0.101
Type of Celebrity Endorsement purchasing a new
That Most Persuades You product just
because of the
A question was asked about the type of presence of a
celebrity you liked.
celebrity the respondents would like to see Believe products 150 2.84 0.984 0.080
most to endorse the product. specifically
Figure 1 shows that more than half of re- advertised by the
spondents said that film stars are most persua- celebrities are of
good quality.
sive of all the types of celebrities. Around 24% Believe the celebrities 150 2.25 1.029 .084
believe that sportspersons are most persuasive; also use those
this is perhaps because sportspersons, products which they
especially cricket players, are personalities that themselves
endorse.
people tend to look up to and, hence, their
opinions are
TABLE 10. The t Test
Test value = 4
95% CI of the difference
Easily influenced
endorser when by
youa purchase
celebrity a −16.578 149 .000 −1.313 −1.47 −1.16
celebrity-endorsed brand
newconsidered
Ever product just because of
purchasing a −13.107 149 .000 −1.327 −1.53 −1.13
tributes related to celebrities, like the attrac- level of less than 5%, implying that both are
tiveness of a celebrity, the trustworthiness of significant. “Attractiveness of celebrity” is just
a celebrity, and the expertise of a celebrity above 5%, thereby implying that it is not that
(Table 4). insignificant. The results are insignificant for
Difference of means (DOM) was imple- DOM for purchase intention. The F statistic also
mented to observe significant differences be- confirms this insignificance because all
tween the means of the variables. The results observed F values are less than the critical F
in Table 5 for “Trustworthiness of celebrity” value of 2.76. H0 (Null Hyphothesis):
and “Expertise of celebrity” show a Attractiveness of celebrity, trustworthiness of
significance celebrity, expertise
FIGURE 2. How Often Do Brand Mascots Influence You? (color figure available online).
TABLE 11. Attributes in Brand Mascots That TABLE 13. The χ2 Test
Influence Purchase Decisions
χ2 0.107a
df 1
Parameters N Mean SD
Asymp. sig...................................................................744
Friendliness 150 2.55 1.235
Uniqueness 150 2.45 1.108
Humor 150 2.39 1.128
Emotional touch 150 3.01 1.144
Trustworthy 150 2.61 1.335
ing the t test to responses to four statements.
Loyalty 150 2.48 1.294 It was found that the significance value for
Attractiveness 150 2.73 1.262 all is .000, which is less than .05 and, hence,
the null hypothesis is rejected and H1 is ac-
cepted (i.e., Celebrity endorsers has a signif-
icant impact on the consumers’ mind and al-
of celebrity do not highly intend customer to ways received special attention from them)
purchase advertised products. (Table 10).
Tables 6, 7, and 8 show the results of regres- It was ascertained that 69% of respondents
sion testing, where the values to be considered say they are only sometimes influenced by
are R2 values, referring to the fitness of model brand mascots, around 25% said that they are
and the explanatory power of the model. The never influenced, and the remaining 6% said
model has 34% explanatory power of the de- that they are always influenced by brand
pendent variable. Because the significance mascots (Figure 2).
value is .000, which is less than .5, the null
hypoth- esis, H0, is rejected and the alternative
hypoth- esis, H1, is accepted. The Important Attributes of Brand Mascots
attractiveness of the celebrity, the Respondents were asked whether they are
trustworthiness of the celebrity, and the in- fluenced by the brand mascots, and their
expertise of celebrity endorser have signifi- re- sponses were “always,” “sometimes,” or
cant impacts on consumers’ buying decisions. “never.” From Table 11, we can deduce that it
is the emotional touch feature of brand
Believes Celebrity Endorsement mascots that is the most important influence
on a person’s purchase decision.
Respondents were asked to rank the state- Attractiveness, trustworthy, friendliness, and
ments according to their perceptions of what uniqueness are other features
they think about the advertisment and products that influence purchase decisions.
that are endorsed by the celebrities (Table 9).
Celebrity Versus Brand Mascot
H0: Respondents do not pay special
attention to advertisements and products In this question, respondents were asked to
that are en- dorsed by celebrities. compare the celebrity and brand mascot and
asked to give a response regarding their pref-
Responses were collected for four erence.
statements through the use of Likert-type
scales, apply- H0: Celebrity endorsers are not more influen-
tial than brand mascots.
TABLE 12. Celebrity Versus Brand Mascot
On the basis of χ 2 test, because the sig-
Observed N Expected N Residual
nificance value is .744, which is greater than
Celebrity 73 75.0 −2.0 .05, the null hypothesis is accepted. Celebrity
Brand mascot 77 75.0 2.0
Total 150
endorsers are not more influential than brand
mascots.
FIGURE 3. Descriptive Statistics on Brand Mascot (color figure available online).
Various brand mascots influenced the pur- Coco Monkey and Kraft’s Tiger stand in the
chasing decision of cutomers: Respondents aver- age position, which basically indicates
were asked to rate brand mascots according to that these mascots have low recall value.
their influential power (Tables 12 and 13). Regarding the television channel that most
Figure 3 clearly shows that Amul’s polka- in- fluences purchase intentions, respondents
dotted girl, 7 Up’s Fido Dido, Parle Agro’s were asked to give their responses concerning
Hippo, and Pillsbury’s Doughboy have had a broad- cast medium. According to the survey,
high level of influence on people’s purchasing televi- sion is the most influential medium,
decisions.This indicates that these four mascots followed by newspaper, Internet, magazines,
most certainly have high recall value. Kellogg’s and social network (Figure 4).
2) Which of the following factors most persuades you to purchase personal care items? please rank 1 to 4, with 1
being the highest and 4 being the lowest rank)
Brand Q
name
Celebrity Q
Quality Q
Cost Q
3) Which of the following factors most persuades you to purchase food products? (please rank 1 to 4, with 1 being
the highest and 4 being the lowest rank)
Celebrity Q
Attractive package Q
Quality Q
Brand name Q
Attractiveness of
the celebrity
Trustworthiness
of the celebrity
Expertise of the
celebrity
Please answer the following questions (please check)
Strongly
Strongly
disagree Disagree Average Agree
agree
14) What is the most persuasive feature in brand mascots that make you purchase products? (please rank 1 to 5,
with 1 being the highest and 5 being the lowest rank)
Feature 1 2 3 4 5
Friendliness
Uniqueness
Humor
Emotional touch
Loyalty
Trustworthy
Attractiveness
15) Of the two, what influences your purchase decision more? (please check)
Fido Dido–7 Up
Doughboy – Pillsbury
Personal Details
Name: Q
Gender: Male Q Female Q
Age:
20–25 Q
26–30 Q
31–35 Q
36–40 Q
Copyright of Journal of Global Marketing is the property of Taylor & Francis Ltd and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.