Chapter 16 - Elemental Paving
Chapter 16 - Elemental Paving
Index
16.1 Introduction
Page 1 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Plates
16.1 Sett paving construction, Barnsley, UK, circa 1900
16.2 Sealing sett paving construction, Barnsley circa 1900
16.3 Interlock allows pavers to retain integrity
16.4 Example of surface deformation in block paving
16.5 Creep in pavers under traffic due to incorrect bonding
16.6 Pushing of pavers due to sand bed being too thick
16.7 Example of heavy duty pavers – Dallas Fort Worth USA
16.8 Use of spreader plate under jack to prevent local overload and
depression of surface
16.9 Heavy duty pavement in port container yard
16.10 Natural stone setts laid on stabilised granular bedding, Blackpool
16.11 Natural sawn stone laid on concrete bed, Leeds
Figures
16.1 Introduction
16.2 Typical heavy Sett construction circa 1900
16.3 Concrete block paving joint mechanics
16.4 Inadequate sand interlock
16.5 Adequate sand interlock
16.6 No rotational interlock
Tables
16.1 Typical values of layer stiffness derived by FWD testing
16.2 Factors affecting performance of trafficked block paving
16.3 Bedding sand categories
16.4 Bedding sand parameters
16.5 Bedding and Jointing sand grading
16.6 Failures in concrete block paving – some causal factors
Page 2 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
This chapter is intended to cover the diverse range of elemental paving, where an
element is defined as a single item of construction fabric, used in conjunction with
others to form the surface course of a pavement. Elements can be made from a broad
range of materials the main ones being
Natural Stone
Concrete
Brick
In the Victorian era almost, without exception, constructed walking surfaces consisted
of riven stone slabs in a range of sizes and thickness. There is currently an increasing
amount of sawn imported natural stone, typically 125 - 150 mm in thickness and width
and in random lengths laid with a grouted joint being used in pedestrian areas. In
Europe and many Mediterranean countries natural stone sets are used in a range of
pavements – both pedestrian and vehicular but generally with granular joints to
preserve flexibility and minimise relaying costs.
Page 3 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Concrete paving is available in a considerable range of shapes, sizes and colours but
those used in highway and port/industrial pavements tend to be 200mm x 100mm in a
range of thickness from 50mm for domestic use to 100mm heavy duty pavements. In
some countries the use of irregular shapes is common, but less so in the UK. Concrete
block paving is used extensively in central shared surface area.
The recent move towards SUDS (sustainable urban drainage systems) exclusively uses
concrete block paving. Concrete blocks can have either a square or chamfered edge
and can be a made in a broad range of surface textures and exposed aggregate
finishes. In Germany, where block-makers tend to be smaller and more local; many
towns have their own special exposed aggregate mix.
Brick paving is similarly available in a range of colours but tend to have a regular
200mm x 100mm plan size x 50 or 65mm in thickness. Edges can be square or
chamfered.
In urban areas in the UK, especially where heavy loads were generated from adjacent
industry and especially from ports the use of stone sett paving became normal. Setts
had two major advantages, firstly, they were resistant to the imposed stresses from
the iron tyres of carts, and secondly, they provided some grip for the feet of the horses
pulling the carts, which were the principal means of transporting goods at the time.
In some areas local hard stone was used where it was available and these tended to
be rectangular sections 6 x 10 inches deep (150mm x 250mm) in plan and typically 8
inches (200mm) deep, with the larger dimension laid across the road. In many port
areas the use of smaller granite setts 150mm or 200mm cube was the norm. These
setts having usually arrived as ballast in returning trading ships.
Experience indicates there are two different constructions found with setts, which it is
convenient to refer to as normal and heavy. In the latter case a concrete supporting
layer will be found under the setts. The typical cross section of heavy construction is
shown in the diagram below and it should be noted that the sett was not laid directly
onto the concrete, rather onto a 12 - 20mm thick bed of tarred chippings. When laid
the sett construction is sealed with hot poured tar for the top half of the sett. This
ensures a degree of flexibility and a very high resistance to moisture penetration, the
later being important in the days of horse drawn traffic.
Clinker ashes can be found in the lowest layer; these being the product of coal-fired
boilers and furnaces. From about 1850 onwards most industrial processes needed
steam driven motive power requiring coal-powered boilers and furnaces.
Consequently furnace clinker ashes were in ready supply and in many cases could be
obtained at no cost, as the factory owners were very happy to have somebody take
them away. For this reason many highway constructions between 1800 and 1920
contained ashes. In some cases they were stabilised by the use of about 5% of
cement, which in the Manchester area was found to be especially suitable in
reinstatements (utility cuts), because they ensured no settlement and were not too
hard to excavate.
Page 4 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Setts are still widely used in Scandinavia, Germany and most Mediterranean Countries,
although it is normal for the top half of the sett to be filled with 3-6mm nominal size
crushed granite. Filling with a granular material has the great advantage that relaying
is a straightforward affair, with very limited materials cost.
The two following pictures, which are used, with permission from "The Tasker Trust"
show the installation of tram tracks and associated sett paving in Barnsley circa 1900.
It can be seen that the setts are bedded in a granular material and are laid to a
camber between the rails. An indication of the size of the setts can be seen by
comparison with the man looking directly into the camera.
The dress code of the day being that the labourers wore flat caps and the foreman a
bowler hat. On larger jobs it would not have been usual to find a more senior person
denoted by wearing a top hat.
In the second photograph the foreman can be seen using a "beetle", which is a heavy
wooden tamping tool used for settling the sett into the granular bed prior to the filling
of the joints with liquid tar which was heated on site in the boiler which can be seen in
the right of the picture. In the situation seen here the tram lines clearly act as a
robust edge restraint.
Page 5 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Plate 16.2 - Sealing sett paved construction, Barnsley, UK, circa 1900
Page 6 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Wood
Rubber
Concrete
Brick
The first two were used in the early 1800's, particularly near hospitals where the noise
of the horses feet on the natural stone Setts was found to be intrusive. In both cases
the use of a concrete bed was normal and the Setts were held in place by a bitumastic
grout. Whilst both surfaces were found to be quiet, in the days of horse drawn
transport they resulted in smelly, in-sanitary conditions and were only used for a short
period. The author has encountered timber blocks in central urban road constructions,
which had provided a robust formation to support a later asphalt layer, which has
lasted for many years. These blocks were found to be set in pitch.
In the latter two cases the size of the elements is the same and generally construction
is the same, being either rigid or flexible. The pavers are laid on a 30mm sand bed,
supported on either by a flexible or cement bound base. If a robust pavement is
required the latter is to be preferred.
As with all other pavements the contribution to overall failure by the construction
process exceeds that of the design process. This is especially true of all forms of
Elemental Paving, where the expertise of the genuine artisan generally exceeds that of
the designer.
One of the problems with elemental paving is that it is very difficult to demonstrate
stability and bearing capacity by analytical calculation. Nevertheless much worldwide
experience supports the contention that if properly constructed by skilled artisans it
provides a long lasting surface course to a robust pavement.
Lilly (1991) suggests that failure is not easy to define, as requirements demanded by
one profession may not be the priority of another profession. For example, an
Architect may concentrate his attentions on the visual impact of the pavement. If this
is not achieved the pavement will, in his estimation, have failed before it has been in
service. Highway Engineers, are concerned about the longevity of a road, adequacy of
riding quality and skid resistance. Maintenance Engineers, who are responsible for the
day-to-day function of an area, may consider the pavement a failure if extensive
maintenance is required. Dowson (2001)
The performance of block paving relies on interlock being achieved between the
individual units. The concept of interlock relies on the transfer of load across the joint
between adjacent elements. This is achieved by mobilising shear transfer in the joint
sand as shown in the following diagram.
Page 7 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
The blocks are laid on the bedding sand. Unless the area is very large this is usually
done by hand and it is important that no work should take place from the bedding
sand, rather working out from the blocks already laid.
The blocks are then settled into the bedding sand by means of a vibrating plate or
wheeled roller. Jointing sand is brushed over the area and further passes of the
vibrating plate cause the sand to enter into the vertical joints between adjacent blocks.
In the UK it is normal for this jointing sand to be a fine grained dried sand to ensure
penetration and filling of the full depth of the joint.
In continental Europe, however, the same sand which is used for the bedding is also
employed in the joint and after the second pass of the vibrating plate passing traffic,
either vehicular or pedestrians are left to finish the process. As may be imagined this
leaves a very difficult surface, especially for pedestrians until the surplus sand is
removed.
The climatic and environmental factors begin to affect the pavement immediately. The
daytime and night-time temperatures vary and rainfall modifies the moisture content of
the sand in the joints and in the blocks themselves. Passing traffic changes the
Page 8 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
quantity and density of sand in the joints either by wheel action or by the effects of
wind generated by the moving vehicle. Any sand thus removed from the joints adds to
the detritus lying on the surface of the pavement. This detritus comprises particles of
rubber, dust, organic matter and so forth. In time the detritus settles into the joints
between the blocks and forms an upper plug over the jointing sand. Because of the
complex nature of the detritus the plug formed helps to seal the joint thereby
improving their waterproofing characteristics.
In time a firm bond develops between the blocks and the jointing sand. The blocks
themselves settle a little further into the bedding sand, which is also affected by its
environment and absorbs moisture, if present. The combined effect of all this is to
compact the bedding sand and the jointing material to a somewhat higher density than
that achieved immediately after construction. In this way the bonding of block,
bedding sand and jointing sand is improved. This is the condition of the block
pavement after the initial settling-in period.
From the earliest use of pavers, it was observed that interlock between rigid
components with a flexible joint formed a stable flexible surface with inherent strength.
The jointing material effectively prevents any block from moving horizontally, vertically,
or rotating and consequently causing the concrete pavers to act in unison.
Knapton (1976) defined interlock as the ability of one block to transfer the load to its
neighbours without deformation or loss of integrity and identified horizontal, vertical
and rotational interlock as follows.
Page 9 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
The following figures have been adapted from Dowson (2001) in an attempt to clarify
the mechanics of failure if interlock does not develop.
Plate 16.3 - Interlock effect allows pavers to retain their integrity even when the
underlying support is removed. Dowson (2001)
For both rigid concrete and asphalt pavements it is commonly required that the
surface deflections be strictly limited to values, which are usually less than
0.5mm. This is to avoid load-associated cracking of the pavement surface.
Page 10 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Figure 16.4 - Inadequate sand interlock, individual unit settles relative to adjacent
Page 11 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Tests have shown that the efficiency of the block layer in distributing stress depends
on the method of construction. In particular, it has been found that, by rolling a block
pavement during construction using a pneumatic tyred roller, the stiffness of the block
surface can be greatly increased. Indeed, following rolling, the stresses measured
immediately below the blocks may be as little as 25% of the surface (contact) stresses.
Further evidence of the relative importance of the various pavement layers has been
provided by studies of deflection profiles in block pavements. For example, the rate at
which deflection diminishes with depth depends on the type of base material used. In
this respect cement-bound materials are generally found to be associated with smaller
deflections than bitumen-stabilised bases.
The fact that the block surface is a structural layer has been confirmed by FWD
studies, these studies have established that the pavers may be characterised in terms
of equivalent elastic moduli which are often higher than those measured in asphalt
pavements. Typical values are given in the following table:
Page 12 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
All sand used for bedding paving should be naturally occurring silica sand and current
guidance is based on a classification of the site related to useage as follows:
Sand Categories
Category Application
1 Pavements subject to severe channelised traffic
Industrial pavements
Bus stations
Loading bays
2 Adopted highways
Petrol station forecourts
Pedestrianisation projects with regular heavy traffic
Car parks with occasional heavy vehicles
Aircraft pavements
3 Pedestrianisation projects with occasional heavy traffic
Car parks with no heavy vehicles
Private driveways
Public areas with pedestrian traffic only
Footpaths likely to be overridden by vehicular traffic
4 Footpaths not likely to be overridden by vehicular traffic
Private areas with pedestrian traffic only
The grading for bedding and jointing sand is set out below:
Page 13 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Page 14 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
The majority of structural failure manifests itself in the surface layer as depressions as
illustrated in the following photograph, causes of failure of the surface can be
categorised into inadequate design, sand degradation or construction methods.
As with other pavement constructions, failures can be categorised into four distinct
types:
Design
Construction
Materials
Maintenance
The following table sets out some of the principal reasons for the degradation / failure
of concrete block paving.
This rationale may also be applied to burnt clay pavers if laid on a sand bed.
Page 15 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Some causal factors for failure of concrete block paving are set out below
Design
Inadequate evaluation of formation bearing capacity
Inadequate falls to facilitate drainage resulting in ponding
Inadequate edge restraint
Inadequate detailing of surface course bonding leading to creep under
vehicle braking loading
Inadequate detailing of joints in base leading to loss of fines in sand bed
resulting in localised settlement
Incorrect detailing of vertical alignment causing impact by vehicles,
especially buses in pedestrianised area
Construction
Sand bed too thick leading to uneven settlement
Sand bed too thin leading to fracture of blocks
Irregular joint thickness to achieve straight lines in laid blocks
Incorrect bonding of elements; if trafficked must be herringbone and
not stretcher bond
Use of unskilled labour
Incorrect cutting adjacent to edge restraints
Incorrect cutting around access chambers
Variable open texture of formation allows migration of bedding course
sand fines leading to local settlement
Incorrect setting out of location of edge restrains requiring small cuts
Irregular formation especially on reconstruction or overlay
Not keeping sanding of joints up to laying
Edge restrain not sufficiently robust or inadequately anchored
Joint thickness inadequate leading to spalling of elements
Materials
Incorrect bedding sand specification for usage
Degradation of bedding sand leading to evacuation of fines and
subsequent settlement due to loss of support – equivalent of mud
pumping from formation of flexible construction
Faulty manufacture of pavers, mix constituents or curing
Maintenance
Progressive removal of joint sand by suction sweepers
Lateral movement of blocks due to inadequate support to sides of utility
or other excavation
Surface degradation due to abrasion
Local overload due to transient point loads
Table 16.6 - Failures in concrete block paving some causal factors (Dowson 2001)
Page 16 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Plate 16.5 - Creep in pavers under traffic due to incorrect bonding (Dowson 2001)
Plate 16.6 - Pushing of pavers due to sand bed being too thick (Dowson 2001)
Page 17 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Plate 16.7 - Example of heavy duty pavers – Dallas Fort Worth USA (Dowson 2001)
Plate 16.8 - Use of spreader plate under jack to prevent local overload and
depression in surface (Dowson 2001)
Page 18 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Plate 16.9 - Heavy duty pavement in port container yard (Dowson 2001)
If, a cement bound base (CBM) has been specified this will inevitably suffer from
shrinkage cracking cracks due to thermal movement. In these circumstances,
especially with a heavy duty pavement, there is a high probability that fines from the
sand laying course will migrate into the base leading to local surface depressions. This
was particularly the case in one of the early airfield applications at Dallas Forth Worth,
where after a short time local transverse depressions were noted in the surface. On
investigation migration of fines into the underlying CBM was found. Soule (1995)
Consequently, if a CBM is used there is merit in considering the use of geotextile layer
to prevent this migration of fines into the supporting layer
If inadequate lateral restraint is provided the blocks will "float" horizontally resulting in
no rotational interlock with a serious loss of stability, which will destabilise the
construction. Assuming lateral restraint to be adequate, deformation failure must be
due to vertical movement caused by loss of support.
Page 19 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
Plate 16.10 - Natural stone setts laid on stabilised granular bedding, Blackpool
Page 20 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
DWFS (1996) Concrete Block Paving for Airfield, Defence Works Functional
Standard – Specification 035, Defence Estate organisation
(Works), Ministry of Defence, London, HMSO, 1996)
KNAPTON (1976) Knapton, J., - The Design of Concrete Block Road, Cement and
Concrete Association, Technical Report 42.515, Cement and
Concrete Association, Slough, UK, 1976.
LILLEY (1986) Lilley, A.A., A.J.Dowson, - Laying course sands for Concrete
Block Paving, Proceedings 3rd International Conference on Block
Paving, pgs 457-462, Rome, Italy, 1986.
Page 21 of 22
Deterioration and Maintenance of Pavements Elemental Paving
BSS : 7533 British Standards Institution, London, UK. Various parts as follows:
Part 2 (2001) Guide for the structural design of lightly trafficked pavements
constructed of clay pavers or precast concrete paving blocks.
Part 3 (2005) Code of practice for laying precast concrete paving blocks and
clay pavers for flexible pavements.
Part 6 (1999) Code of practice for laying natural stone, precast concrete and
clay kerb units.
Part 9 (2010) Code of practice for the construction of rigid pavements in clay
pavers.
Page 22 of 22