Concepts and Instruments For A Sustainable Construction Sector
Concepts and Instruments For A Sustainable Construction Sector
Holger Wallbaum, Senior Consultant, Wuppertal Institute, and Director for Research, Triple Innova, Luisenstrasse 102, 42103 Wuppertal, Germany
([email protected])
Claudia Buerkin, consultant, Hebelstrasse 35, 77960 Seelbach, Germany ([email protected])
mental impact of materials in the construction
Summary industry is the “ecological rucksack”, which
This article presents an overview of methods used by the Wuppertal Institute to determine sus-
tainability targets in the construction sector and to develop pathways for achieving targeted
describes the total quantity of material that must
improvements. Resource productivity is considered over a building’s entire life cycle (MIPS). be extracted to obtain a unit of pure (and thus
The COMPASS concept integrates environmental, economic and social aspects for single com- usable) material. For example, for iron ore extrac-
panies or industrial sectors in order to make progress towards greater sustainability. Profiting tion the ecological rucksack can be expressed as a
from each of these approaches, and based on various types of research, recommendations are ratio of 14:1 – that is, 14 metric tonnes of waste in
derived for companies and policy makers. Multi-stakeholder processes can be used to promote the form of tailings or mine waste are created in
overall sustainable development in the construction sector, and eventually to integrate con- the production of one metric tonne of iron. In the
cepts related specifically to the micro and meso levels. case of rarer materials such as gold and platinum,
the ratio can range up to 350,000:1.
Résumé With their knowledge of these impacts and the
L’article examine les méthodes employées par le Wuppertal Institute pour fixer des objectifs de extent of material consumption in today’s soci-
durabilité dans le secteur du bâtiment et élaborer les filières qui permettront les améliorations eties, senior governmental, non-governmental,
recherchées. La productivité des ressources est étudiée sur la totalité du cycle de vie du bâti- industry and academic leaders argue the follow-
ment. Le concept de COMPASS intègre les aspects environnementaux, économiques et sociaux
pour des entreprises isolées ou des secteurs industriels entiers, afin de progresser vers une plus
ing: to redirect our course towards that of a sus-
grande durabilité. Tirant parti de chacune de ces approches et des divers travaux de recherche tainable economy, each country’s total resource
engagés, des recommandations sont formulées à l’intention des entreprises et des décideurs. productivity should be increased by a factor of 2;
Des processus associant de nombreux acteurs peuvent être mis en place pour promouvoir le and in industrialized countries it should be
développement durable dans l’ensemble du secteur du bâtiment, voire pour intégrer des con- increased by a factor of 4 within the next decade
cepts spécifiques aux niveaux microsectoriels et mésosectoriels. and by a factor of 10 overall within one genera-
tion. To achieve these increases, every actor with-
Resumen in the economy must optimize resource use from
El artículo presenta una visión general de los métodos del Instituto Wuppertal para definir obje- the national (macro) level, through the sectoral
tivos sostenibles en el sector de la construcción y para desarrollar procedimientos que permi- and regional (meso) levels and on down to the sin-
tirán lograr las mejoras deseadas. Se estudia la productividad de recursos durante todo el ciclo gle firm and household level (micro) levels.
de vida de un edificio (MIPS). El concepto COMPASS integra aspectos medioambientales, Different tools have been developed to measure
económicos y sociales para compañías individuales o sectores industriales con miras a pro-
resource productivity and the potential for improve-
gresar hacia una mayor sostenibilidad. Aprovechando cada uno de estos enfoques y basándose
en varios tipos de investigación, se preparan recomendaciones para las compañías y los encar- ment. These tools can be applied to the construc-
gados de elaborar las políticas. Procesos que cuentan con la participación de múltiples partes tion sector. A sustainable construction sector also
interesadas pueden ser utilizados para promover el desarrollo sostenible en general en el sec- has to consider other dimensions (e.g. economic
tor de la construcción y, con el tiempo, integrar conceptos relacionados específicamente con and social considerations) in order to take the holis-
niveles medianos y pequeños. tic approach needed to build a sustainable future.
“ecological rucksacks” – that is, the total achieved. Further dematerialization can be
Figure 1
mass of material flows activated by an item Material input per capita for different types of
achieved through technological progress.
of consumption in the course of its life needs in western Germany, 1990 Summarizing the potential for improving
cycle (www.wupperinst. org).2 MIPS is the environmental sustainability of build-
computed in material input per total unit 16 ings, Stefan Bringezu suggests what he
of services delivered by the product over its calls the “Golden Rules of Eco-Design”:4
entire useful life span Resource extraction, non-saleable production 14 1. Potential impacts on the environment
manufacturing, transport, packaging, soil excavation should be considered on a life cycle-wide
operation, reuse, recycling and remanufac- erosion basis.
(balance of expended and saved material flows), Figure 2 involved in the COMPASS assessment. The prod-
which will reach a scale of around 68 million met- The MIPS formula ucts in question were detached houses of varied
ric tonnes per year by 2020. design, appealing mostly to the same type of
This investment plan, which is now activated
by a governmental support programme (www.
MIPS == MI
MIPS MI prospective buyers. The resulting indicators con-
sidered by the company are:
kfw.de) among other measures, will entail higher SS ◆ resource consumption (production and use);
state revenues from national insurance and from ◆ energy consumption;
direct and indirect taxes. At the same time, expen- ◆ reduction of costs;
diture for social benefits will decrease because of Figure 3 ◆ effects on man;
an improvement in the labour market situation. Resource intensity of the new ◆ effects on the ecosystem;
Comparing the potential of existing and new Flintenbreite Housing Estate ◆ acceptance by tenants;
buildings, we can conclude that on the German in Lübeck, Germany ◆ profitability.
and similar European markets the (energy relat- Renovation 53% All indicators will be applied to the service unit
ed) renovation of existing buildings offers a far “living space and year”. Only the “acceptance”
more promising contribution to sustainable con- indicator will be assessed per tenant or buyer ques-
struction than construction of new ones. Further- tioned. Taking the “resource productivity” indi-
more, economic and social benefits as well as land cator as an example, the structure and procedure
savings should lead us to direct our efforts towards are briefly explained. The “system-wide resource
the modernization of existing buildings. It goes consumption” indicator can be subdivided into
without saying that where new construction is part indicators (Figure 4). The subdivision into
necessary, the utmost resource productivity and part and sub-indicators, for example, depends on
eco-efficiency must be targeted. production processes and responsibilities within
Windows
Construction Use phase
(heating, gas) 1% companies.
(shell without
COMPASS: the path to sustainability windows) 3% An assessment scale (performance comparison)
for companies and sectors 37% Electrotechnics
6%
for all indicators was determined, ranging from 1
It is important for companies and sectors to know (very good) to 6 (unsatisfactory). Grade 4 (satis-
Source: Holger Wallbaum, Denk- und Kommunikationsansätze zur
what kind of targets and actions will lead them Bewertung des nachhaltigen Bauens und Wohnens. factory) corresponds to the state of the art. With
towards sustainability. Resource productivity is Dissertation, Fachbereich Architektur, University of Hannover, the help of “traffic lights” – grades 5 and 6 (red),
2002. (Also see www.flintenbreite.de.)
only one important path; in the broader context grades 2, 3 and 4 (amber) and grade 1 (green) –
of sustainable development there are also numer- the management decisions or measures intro-
ous other economic targets (e.g. high profits, high duced can be observed, discussed and evaluated
competitiveness, low rate of investment pay- decisions. It includes a methodological frame- with respect to their effects at all indicator levels.
back), environmental targets (e.g. low toxicity, work, instruments and measures to put the nor- The grades will then be equally weighted from the
high biodiversity, low erosion) and social targets mative concept of sustainable development into bottom up and identified as the arithmetical mean
(e.g. employee satisfaction over low unemploy- practice. Step by step, it helps the user understand of the overall grade of the indicator at the next
ment rate, overall stability in society) that have to what sustainable development means for an enter- higher level. The grading system can, of course,
be addressed. prise or a sector – from a life-cycle perspective of a be freely chosen and can be shown in the stan-
COMPASS (Companies’ and Sectors’ Path to product or service – and shows the extent to which dards of other countries.
Sustainability)5 is a tool developed to provide a development in the direction of a sustainable To compare the houses of the company men-
decision makers in a company or a sector with suf- economy has already been achieved. tioned above, results were clearly presented on the
ficient information for integrated analysis and In cooperation with a company in the housing topmost indicator level as in Figure 5. In the so-
industry, the sustainability of its product range called “Sustainable Development Radar” (COM-
(four residential houses) was investigated. Eco- PASSradar) the economic, environmental and
nomic and environmental issues were the main social efforts of entrepreneurial development are
The “Cement and
focus.6 However, it was important to record accep- portrayed. The axes show the selected indicators
Sustainability” initiative tance by tenants or buyers of the houses being whereby the determined grades describe the dis-
It is widely recognized that to achieve sus- offered. Product specific indicators apart from tance to the defined target (grade 1) and the state
tainable development, it is essential for dif- MIPS were determined in dialogues with people of the art (grade 4).
ferent actors to work together. The federation
of the German Cement Industry (Bun- Table 1
desverband der Deutschen Zementindustrie, Eco-efficiency strategies in the construction sector
BDZ) and the industrial union for the build- Level of product components Level of product structure
ing and construction industry (IG BAU) Selection of materials with little environmental impact, e.g. Optimization of product techniques, e.g.
have concluded a sectoral agreement to facil- • environmentally compatible materials • alternative product processes
itate joint consideration of economic, eco- (small ecological rucksack, no substances toxic to • more efficient energy use
humans or the environment) • less product waste
logical and social challenges throughout the • renewable materials (if sustainably produced)
whole life cycle of cement products. Based on • materials with low energy content
stakeholder dialogue and practical projects, • recycled materials
• recyclable materials
this initiative tackles the issues of biodiversi-
Reduction of material inputs, e.g. Optimization of distribution systems, e.g.
ty, protection of resources, sustainable trans- • reduction of product weight • less, environmentally compatible and reusable packages
port and logistics, as well as workers’ • reduction of product volume • use of more energy efficient transport systems
qualifications. The stakes in the cement • choice of more energy efficient logistics
industry are particularly high due to large Reduction of environmental impacts during use phase, e.g.
• more efficient energy use
capital investments and long amortization • energy from environmentally compatible sources
periods in an increasingly globalized market. Shifting from product-oriented to service-oriented approaches
• mobility management, e.g. car sharing, removal services, caretaker services
Notes 3. Ritthoff, M., H. Rohn and C. Liedtke (2002) 6. At first, social criteria were deliberately kept in
1. Adriaanse, A. et al. (1997) Resource Flows: The MIPS berechnen: Ressourcenproduktivität von Pro- the background, mainly because at this point the
Material Basis of Industrial Economies. World dukten und Dienstleistungen. Wuppertal Spezial 27 discussion of social indicators on both the nation-
Resource Institute Washington, D.C. (downloadable at www.wupperinst. org). English al and international level has not yet reached a level
2. Schmidt-Bleek. F. (1993) Wieviel Umwelt translation will soon be available. equal to that of the development of environmental
braucht der Mensch? MIPS – Das Mass für oekolo- 4. Bringezu, S. (2001) Construction ecology and and economic indicators.
gisches Wirtschaften, Birkhaeuser (English transla- metabolism: re-materialization and de-materializa- 7. Buerkin, C. (2003) Multi-Stakeholder-Prozesse
tion: The Fossil Makers – Factor 10 and More). tion. In: Construction Ecology and Metabolism: als Chance für nachhaltiges Wirtschaften: eine kri-
Birkhäuser Verlag, Berlin, Basel and Boston. Also Nature as the Basis for the Built Environment, C. tische Betrachtung am Beispiel des Bausektors. The-
see F. Schmidt-Bleek (1995) Increasing resource Kibert, J. Sendzimir, G. Guy (eds.), Spon, London. sis, University of Passau/Wuppertal Institute.
productivity on the way to sustainability, Industry 5. Kuhndt, M. and C. Liedtke (1999) COMPASS
and Environment, Vol. 18, No. 4, pp. 8-12. – Die Methodik. Wuppertal Institute. ◆
Suzy Edwards, Principal Consultant, Centre for Sustainable Construction, BRE, Garston, Herts WD25 9XX, UK ([email protected])
Philip Bennett, Secretary General, Council of European Producers of Materials for Construction, Gulledelle 98 Box 7, 1200 Brussels, Belgium ([email protected])
onstruction materials and products are
Summary
Life-cycle concepts, in the context of the building and construction sector, are particularly suit-
ed to analysis of building products. Such products play an essential role in increasing the ener-
gy efficiency of buildings and contributing to economic prosperity. It has been estimated that
C essential to life as we know it – with respect
to both buildings and infrastructure.
Humans spend around 80% of their time (on
the construction sector is responsible for up to half of material resources taken from nature average) in some type of building or on roads.
and of total waste generation. To manage and minimize the impacts of construction prod- Construction products play a major role in
ucts, the impacts have to be measured using a life-cycle approach. This article reviews life- improving the energy efficiency of buildings and
cycle concepts and considers recent developments. Materials and sustainable construction, contributing to economic prosperity.
environmental product declarations, embodied energy and differences encountered in the On the other hand, construction products also
assessment of construction products in the North and South are among the topics addressed. have a considerable impact on the environment.
According to one source, the construction sector is
Résumé responsible for 50% of the material resources taken
Dans le contexte du bâtiment, les concepts fondés sur le cycle de vie se prêtent particulière- from nature and 50% of total waste generated.1
ment bien à l’analyse des produits de construction, lesquels jouent un rôle essentiel dans
l’amélioration de l’efficacité énergétique des bâtiments et la prospérité économique. On estime
The impact of construction products relative to
que le secteur du bâtiment est responsable de près de la moitié des ressources naturelles con- the overall lifetime impact of a building is cur-
sommées et du volume total de déchets produits. Pour gérer et limiter le plus possible les rently 10-20%. For infrastructure this value is sig-
impacts des produits de construction, il faut pouvoir les mesurer selon une méthode fondée sur nificantly higher, greater than 80% in some cases.
le cycle de vie. L’article fait le point sur les concepts liés au cycle de vie et sur les tendances As buildings become more energy efficient, the
récentes dans ce domaine. Matériaux et techniques de construction durables, déclarations de impact of construction products will make up an
produits respectueux de l’environnement, contenu énergétique et différences entre le Nord et increasingly significant proportion. This has
le Sud dans la façon d’évaluer les produits de construction figurent parmi les sujets abordés. already been seen in recent entrants for the Green
Building Challenge, where construction products
Resumen contributed up to 50% of the impacts of some of
Los conceptos de ciclo de vida, en el contexto del sector de la construcción y edificios, resultan the buildings (www.buildingsgroup.nrcan.gc.ca/
particularmente apropiados para los productos de construcción. Estos productos desempeñan projects/gbc_e.html).
un papel capital para el aumento de la eficiencia energética de los edificios y el desarrollo de la
prosperidad económica. Según estimados, el sector de la construcción utiliza la mitad de los
recursos materiales provenientes de la naturaleza y es responsable de la mitad de todos los Different contexts for considering
desechos generados. Para poder administrar y minimizar el impacto de los productos de con- construction products: North and South
strucción, es necesario medir dicho impacto utilizando criterios de ciclo de vida. Los autores When considering differences related to con-
examinan conceptos de ciclo de vida y analizan la evolución reciente. Algunos de los temas struction products in the North and South, it is
tratados son: materiales y construcción sostenible, declaraciones de productos ambientales, important to make a distinction between “global”
energía incorporada y diferencias en la evaluación de productos de construcción en el Norte y and “local” construction. At the most simplistic
el Sur. level, this can be considered as a split between city-
based commercial buildings and dwellings, and
rural dwellings and public buildings. The distinc-
tion can also be applied to products required to
UNEP Industry and Environment April – September 2003 ◆ 57