Research Article Review On Electric Vehicle, Battery Charger, Charging Station and Standards
Research Article Review On Electric Vehicle, Battery Charger, Charging Station and Standards
DOI:10.19026/rjaset.7.263
ISSN: 2040-7459; e-ISSN: 2040-7467
© 2014 Maxwell Scientific Publication Corp.
Submitted: April 19, 2013 Accepted: May 31, 2013 Published: January 10, 2014
Research Article
Review on Electric Vehicle, Battery Charger, Charging Station and Standards
1
Afida Ayob, 1Wan Mohd Faizal Wan Mahmood, 1Azah Mohamed 2Mohd Zamri Che Wanik,
2
MohdFadzil Mohd Siam, 3Saharuddin Sulaiman, 3Abu Hanifah Azit and 4Mohamed Azrin Mohamed Ali
1
Department of Electrical, Electronic and Systems Engineering, Universiti Kebangsaan, Malaysia
2
TNB Research Malaysia
3
TNB Distribution Malaysia
4
Malaysian Green Technology Corporation, Malaysia
Abstract: Electric vehicles are a new and upcoming technology in the transportation and power sector that have
many benefits in terms of economic and environmental. This study presents a comprehensive review and evaluation
of various types of electric vehicles and its associated equipment in particular battery charger and charging station.
A comparison is made on the commercial and prototype electric vehicles in terms of electric range, battery size,
charger power and charging time. The various types of charging stations and standards used for charging electric
vehicles have been outlined and the impact of electric vehicle charging on utility distribution system is also
discussed.
Corresponding Author: Azah Mohamed, Department of Electrical, Electronic and Systems Engineering, Universiti
Kebangsaan, Malaysia
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (URL: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
364
Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7(2): 364-373, 2014
Fig.1: The paradigm shift in transportation from ICE vehicles to advanced electric-drive vehicles
Fig. 5: A plug-in hybrid electric vehicle with a series hybrid power train
Fig.6: A plug-in hybrid electric vehicle with a series-parallel hybrid power train
366
Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7(2): 364-373, 2014
Fig.7: An all-electric
electric power train with adaptive control unit
storage system larger than power hybrid. Among the not have an ICE to supply pply the additional power. A
hybrid car models are such as the Toyota Prius, Honda typical EV architecture is shown in Fig. 7. These EVs
Insight, Honda Jazz and Honda CR--Z. Toyota Prius rely mainly on external charge from the utility power
uses a series-parallel
parallel configuration while the Honda grid and these types of advanced electric-drive
electric vehicles
family is more close to parallel configuration bu but are expected to affect the electricity distribution
allowing battery charging through motor regenerative network.
braking. Power demand of EV is a function of voltage and
Plug-in
in Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEVs) is current and its energy requirement depends on the
essentially an HEV with the option to recharge its battery size. The technical information on commercial
energy storage system with electricity from the grid and prototype EV sin terms of electric range, battery
(Markel and Simpson, 2006). PHEVs have a high high- size, charger power and charging time is tabulated
tabul and
energy-density
density energy storage system that can be summarized in Table 1. Such information is useful for
externally charged and they can run solely on electric determining the power demand required by EV. It is
power longer than regular hybrids, resulting in better estimated that a single EC can increase electricity
fuel economy. Just like HEVs, PHEVs can have series, consumption of a household by 50% (WDI, 2008).
parallel and series-parallel
parallel configurations. Figure 5 and Some EVs consumed more than 5 kW powers which whi is
6 show a PHEV with series and series series-parallel greater than the consumption of a typical residential
configuration, respectively. PHEVs make use of utility house and this consumption is continuous up 10 h
power as the batteries are usually charged overnight. subject to the state of charge of the EV’s battery. This
The battery can also be charged onboard to increase the power consumption is required for EV which is charged
vehicle range. All electric vehicles have all all-electric using the slow type on board charger.
charger If EV is charged
propulsion system. Unlike HEVs and PHEVs, EVs do using rapid/fast charger, the power consumption can go
367
Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7(2): 364-373, 2014
Types of charging stations: EV charging stations From Table 2, essentially ‘Level 3’ does not exist
when categorised in terms of voltage rating, power yet and the charging standard everybody has been
rating and place of application, can be classified into thinking of as ‘Level 3’ is really either ‘DC Level 1’ or
three different types of charging stations, namely, ‘DC Level 2’.
domestic charger at residential area, off-street and
robust charger at commercial and office area and rapid Standards for EV charging stations: Different type of
charger at strategic location. Example pictures of these
standard is being used in different region of the globe
three chargers are depicted in Fig. 11 to 13.
In this document, the charging stations discussed for charging of EV. This section is comparing different
will be focusing on conductive chargers due to the fact standard that are being used in USA, Europe and Japan.
that the inductive charging method is still under Standards that have been published are described as
development. According to Daimler’s Head of Future follows:
Mobility, inductive chargers are at least 15 years away
and the safety aspects of inductive charging for EVs • IEC 61851(IEC, 2010): The IEC 61851 standard
have yet to be looked into in greater detail. Most covers the overall EV conductive charging
rechargeable EVs and equipment can be charged from a systems. In this standard, the IEC defines the four
domestic wall socket. However, a charging station may modes of EV charging that has been described
be required due to the following reasons:
above. This standard became the basis for IEC
62196. A few important sections in IEC 61851 are:
• Charging can be provided for multiple EV owners
at one time,
• The facility may have additional current or IEC 61851-1: This standard defines three cables and
connection sensing mechanisms to disconnect plug setups which can be used to charge EVs:
power when the EV is not actually charging,
• Readily provide option for suppliers to monitor or Case A: Where the cable is permanently attached to
charge for the electricity actually consumed. the EV
Case B: Where the cable is not permanently attached
Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) and to anything
International Electro technical Commission (IEC) both Case C: Where the cable is permanently attached to
have come up with standards which define EV the charging station.
charging. The term ‘level’ used by SAE and ‘mode’
used by IEC essentially means the same thing.
According to IEC 61851-1, there are 4 modes for IEC 61851-23: This standard defines the
charging EVs as described in Table 2. However, SAE requirements for DC fast charging stations in terms of
defines 6 levels of EV charging as shown in Table 3. electrical safety, harmonics, grid connections and
Some information in the table is still to be defined communication architecture. The standard is expected
(TBD) by the standard. to be published in November 2012.
369
Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7(2): 364-373, 2014
• IEC 60309-Plugs, socket-outlets and couplers • SAE J1772: This SAE Recommended Practice
for industrial purposes (IEC, 2012): IEC 60309, covers the general physical, electrical, functional
formerly known as IEC 309 is an international and performance requirements to facilitate
standard from the IEC for ‘plugs, socket-outlets conductive charging of EV/PHEV vehicles in
and couplers for industrial purposes’. The North America (SAE International, 2013). This
maximum limits under this standard include; document defines a common EV/PHEV and supply
voltage 690V AC or DC, current 125A, frequency equipment vehicle conductive charging method
500 Hz and temperature range -25 to 40oC. The including operational requirements and the
two parts of IEC 60309 are: functional and dimensional requirements for the
o IEC 60309-1: General requirements and vehicle inlet and mating connector.SAE J1772-
o IEC 60309-2: Dimensional requirements. A few 2009 is the most recent standard in use and
details outlined under this standard include i) a maintained by the SAE. The previous standard,
range of plugs and sockets of different sizes with SAE J772-2001 was manufactured by Avcon but is
differing numbers of pins, depending on the current being phased out.
supplied and the number of phases accommodated,
ii) limited weather proofing and iii) color coded Details on SAE J1772-2009 are described as follows:
370
Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7(2): 364-373, 2014
happen because of many factors. One of the factors is distribution of these EV will depend on promotional
that the number of charging station is limited. As for policies, incentives and the deployment of charging
the impact of EV battery chargers on the power supply infrastructures.
system, it depends on the technology of the chargers.
Older version of chargers is based on full-wave CONCLUSION
rectification using diodes and progressively, thyristors
are used. Later designs use microprocessor-controlled Electric vehicles are expected to enter the world
charging technologies with several algorithms being market such that by 2030, 10% of the vehicles will be
implemented for parameter monitoring and control. of EV type. To have a better understanding on EV
Today, smart battery chargers are available which can technology, this study outlines the various types of EV,
interactively communicate with the utility system in battery chargers and charging stations. A
order to receive and send information about the state of comprehensive review has also been made on the
charge, energy availability, tariffs and management data standards currently adopted for charging EV
in general. Such designs have resulted in reduction of worldwide. For better understanding on the state of the
harmonic distortion and power factor improvement. A art EV technology, a comparison is made on the
survey of battery charger manufacturers from 1993 to commercial and prototype electric vehicles in terms of
1995 shows that the average total harmonic distortion electric range, battery size, charger power and charging
decreases from 50.1 to 6.12% (Gomez and Morcos, time.
2003).
The general effect of home battery chargers on REFERENCES
distribution systems will be load increase and large
increment of system voltage distortion. Another issue Autocar, 2012. The New i3. Retreived form: http://
that should be considered is the coincidence between www. autocar. co. uk/car-news/frankfurt motor-
the charging start time and the eventual evening load show-2011/frankfurt-show-new-bmw-i3.
peak period, which varies with customer and country Berdichevsky, A., M. Viswanathan, H.R. Horvitz and
(Autocar, 2012). However, the net effect of a L. Guarente, 2006. C. elegans SIR-2.1 interacts
population of EV chargers is not merely the numerical with 14-3-3 proteins to activate DAF-16 and
sum of the THDs, which involves both the magnitude extend life span. Cell, 125: 1165-1177.
and phase angles of individual harmonic components CHAdeMO, 2012. CHAdeMO Standard. Retreived
(Lambert, 2000). For higher harmonic orders, harmonic form: Online: www. CHAde MO .com.
cancellation effect can take place. Chan, C.C. and K.T. Chau, 2001. Modern Electric
Another issue of EV charging that has been Vehicle Technology. Oxford University Press on
investigated is on the lifetime of transformers. For Demand, Vol. 47, ISBN: 019-850416-0.
calculation of transformer life reduction or the derating Che Din Z., 2011. PROTON vehicle electrification
factor, parameters that are required are the winding development. Proceeding of 1st Sustainable
eddy-current loss, harmonic current magnitudes and Automotive Mobility Conference. Malaysia.
Chevrolet, 2012. Chevrolet Volt Specifications. Online:
harmonic order values (IEEE, 1998). However, THD
http://gm-volt.com/full-specifications/.
values do not give enough information for transformer
Emadi, A., 2011. Transportation 2.0. IEEE Power
temperature and life span calculations, as the harmonic
Energy M., 9(4): 18-29.
order is very important for thermal effect evaluation.
Gomez, J.C. and M.M. Morcos, 2003. Impact of EV
Two harmonics of the same magnitude, but having
battery chargers on the power quality of
different order, can have dissimilar thermal effects. distribution systems. IEEE T. Power Deliver.,
Therefore, as a conclusion, EV charging should be 18(3): 975-981.
looked at not only in harmonics and voltage overload Honda, 2012. Honda Jazz EV Review. Retrieved from:
issues, but also its effects on distribution equipments http://hondaaction.com/honda-jazz-ev-review/.
such as transformers, cables, circuit breakers and fuses. IEC, 2005. Low-voltage Electrical Installations-part 1:
The degree of impact on power system depends on Fundamental Principles, Assessment of General
how much the EV penetrates the market. This Characteristics, Definitions. 5.0 Edn., IEC
penetration will depends on the battery cost, gasoline 60364-1.
prices, charging infrastructure, competition from other IEC, 2010. Electric Vehicle Conductive Charging
vehicles and government policy. When referring to System-part 1: General Requirements. 2.0 Edn.,
impact of EV to power grid, the regional or local IEC 61851-1.
penetration is of importance to utilities. Some parts of IEC, 2011. Plugs, socket-outlets, vehicle connectors
the region will be more severely impacted by the and vehicle inlets-Conductive charging of electric
presence of EVs than others. Even within the same vehicles-Part 1: General requirements. 2.0 Edn.,
region, only certain part will need significant focus. The IEC 62196.
372
Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7(2): 364-373, 2014
IEC, 2012. Plugs, Socket-outlets and Couplers for Mercedes, 2012. Mercedes Media Newsroom.
Industrial Purposes-part 1: General Requirements. Retrieved from: http://media.daimler.com/dcmedia.
4.2 Edn., IEC 60309-1. Mitsubishi, 2012. Charging and Battery. Retrieved
IEEE, 1998. Recommended Practice for Establishing from: http://i.mitsubishicars.com/miev/charging.
Transformer Capability When Supplying Nissan, 2012. Nissan News Releases. Retreived form:
Nonsinusoidal Load Currents. ANSI/IEEE Std. http:// www. Nissan -global. com/ EN/ NEWS/
C57.110. 2012/_STORY /120530-01 -e.html.
Lambert, F., 2000. Secondary Distribution Impacts of Prius, 2012. Prius Plug-in Hybrid. Retrieved from:
Residential Electric Vehicle Charging. California http://electricvehicle.ieee.org/vehicles/prius-plug-
Energy Commission, Public Interest Energy in-hybrid/.
Research Program, Sacramento, Calif. SAE International, 2013. J1772: SAE Electric Vehicle
Maggetto, G. and J. Van Mierlo, 2000. Electric and and Plug in Hybrid Electric Vehicle Conductive
electric hybrid vehicle technology: A survey. Charge Coupler.
Proceeding of IEE Seminar Electric, Hybrid and WDI, 2008. Plan Decentralized Infrastructure.
Fuel Cell Vehicles (Ref. No. 2000/050). Durham, Decentralized Infrastructure Working Group,
pp: 1/1-111. SenterNovem: Utrecht, pp: 16 (Dutch).
Markel, T. and A. Simpson, 2006. Plug-in Hybrid Zeraoulia, M., M.E.H. Benbouzid and D. Diallo, 2006.
Electric Vehicle Energy Storage System Design. Electric motor drive selection issues for HEV
National Renewable Energy Laboratory, propulsion systems: A comparative study. IEEE T.
Conference Paper, NREL/CP -540-39614, Veh. Technol., 55(6): 1756-1764.
Maryland.
Mazda, 2012. News from Mazda: Mazda to Lease
'Demio EV' Electric Vehicle in Japan. Retrieved
from:http://www.mazda.com/publicity/release/201
2/201207/120706a.html.
373