Modinomics: Put To The Test
Modinomics: Put To The Test
12 PAGES
BAZAAR MAGAZINE - VOLUME 0220-1
MODINOMICS
IN THIS EDITION OF
BAZAA₹ MAGAZINE
Bazaar Brief : SENSEX,
NIFTY nosedive P5
SMEs need more than a
stimulus package P6 PUT TO THE TEST
P7
Adapting to a work from COVID-19: Battling the Will the 1.73 lakh crore
home lifestyle P11 biggest threat to India Inc fiscal stimulus be enough?
BAZAA₹
A Wealth Group
Publication
India Edition
April 2020
M AG A Z I N E 12 pages
Price ₹ 150
S AM I T S H AR MA
4 BAZAA₹ M AG A Z I N E
Index
MARKETS
APRIL 2020 5
MARKETS
Bazaar Brief
Coronavirus Mayhem
on Dalal Street
SAMIT SHARMA
India’s equity markets are facing anoth- anticipating a further crash, some may
er meltdown, more than a decade after be thinking about not putting more
the 2008 financial crisis roiled global money in equities and preferring to wait
markets. Such steep falls – close to 30 and watch, while others may be willing
per cent plus in the last couple of to continue their investments but with a
months can make even seasoned lot of anxiety. A courageous few inves-
investors impatient. It is normal for the tors may be willing to pull a big short,
investors to get jittery about their future be adventurous and put more money in
course of action at this stage. Some markets to buy at what many people
investors may be thinking about exiting, are saying are low prices.
6 BAZAA₹ M AG A Z I N E
FISCAL POLICY
<<< A local
market in Old
Delhi is deserted
during the 21 day
lockdown
imposed by the
Indian govern-
ment. The
lockdown which
began on March
25th, has been
extended, in a
further blow for
already reeling
MSMEs
SAMIT SHARMA
APRIL 2020 7
ECONOMY
Saving India Inc.
from the pandemic
COVID-19 might be a bigger threat to
livelihoods than to lives. Is the Indian
government doing enough to bolster the
economy? Will Modinomics save the
Indian economy from catching the flu?
SAMIT SHARMA
W hen Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced There are several indications that except in COVID-19
a total lockdown of the country to fight COVID-19, he did hotspots identified by state governments, he does not
it perhaps with one idea in his mind. The spread of the intend to extend it further. On April 15, the home minis-
virus had to be stopped first, no matter what it cost the try sent a circular to the state governments strongly
economy. A trade-off between saving lives and saving recommending the restarting of certain economic
incomes was unavoidable and lives had to come first. activities in a phased manner outside identified
COVID-19 hotspots from April 20.
What he, therefore, imposed on India was, according to
an Oxford study of 73 countries, one of the most strin- Several state governments, including Delhi, have
gent lockdowns in the world. preferred to wait till May 3, but those that have not are
starting to get their first taste of the unprecedented
Was Modi wrong in doing so? A month into the lock-
crash in demand that the lockdown has brought about.
down, that trade-off has not yielded the quick results
The first to feel it have been the farmers. The vegeta-
that he may have hoped for. There can be no doubt that
bles they are bringing to the market are
it has slowed down the spread of the virus. But it has
rotting for want of buyers.
not stopped it. The number of new cases registered
every day is still rising, and a turndown is not i n sight. At the opposite end of the scale, automo-
bile plants, like the Maruti plant at
On the other hand, the lockdown has virtually disman- Manesar in Haryana, are reluctant to
tled the economy. With shops and markets closed and restart produc-
transport, except for essentials, forbidden, demand and tion because
production have both crashed. Unemployment, which their yards are
in India really means the absence of even casual work, still full of the
has soared to 23.4% according to estimates put out by unsold cars
the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) left there by
the 30% to
40% fall in
The lockdown has virtually dismantled sales over
the economy. With shops and markets the last
year. In
closed and transport, except for essen- between
tials, forbidden, demand and produc- t h e s e
e x -
tion have both crashed. tremes
8 BAZAA₹ M AG A Z I N E
fall the 2,71,000 working factories and 71 million
trading and other non-agricultural enterprises that “The magnitude of the crisis becomes
provide components, sub-assemblies, and materials
and transport to the large enterprises at the apex of
clearer when we consider that almost a
production chain, and final goods to the public. The quarter of the country’s workforce –
lockdown has disrupted not only these supply chains about 111 million out of 461 million – is
but, by virtually forcing the employers to throw tens engaged in elementary occupations.
of millions out of work, it has also destroyed a large These include labourers, agriculture
part of the demand for their products.
and domestic workers. They are mostly
The lesson the government should have learnt is
therefore obvious: A market economy is not an auto-
daily wagers with little to no savings.”
mobile that can stop and restart at the touch of a
button. The more severe the lockdown, and the
longer it lasts, the more complete is the disruption of 3,37,000 crore into the economy. It sounds like a great
the economy and the slower the recovery will be. By deal of money, but is only 1.8% of the GDP – half of
the same token, the more the economy is protected, what Bangladesh is putting into its economy as inter-
the sooner it will bounce back when the lockdown est-free and very low-interest loans. But much of even
ends. this small sum is not likely to find its way to the
construction sector and other small and medium enter-
GLOBAL REACTIONS
prises that will need it the most.
The industrialised market economies understand this.
This is because the relief is being offered in the form of
That is why, despite facing a pandemic fifty times as
loans, not grants. Even at the best of times, taking a loan
severe as what India is facing, they have thrown their
involves taking a risk. And these are not the best of
balance sheets out of the window and are commit-
times for industry and trade.
ting sums not dreamed of even
during the Great
Modi and his advisors need to admit, therefore, they
Depression of the
need a completely different philosophy, and a radically
1930s, to keep
different approach to the economy while fighting
both demand
COVID-19. This requires giving grants not loans, creating
and production
entitlements not additional millstones for those who
capability alive
have been harmed by the lockdown.
while they fight
the virus. Preparedness in terms of policy responses is impera-
Taken togeth- tive to contain both the spread of the virus and
er, the Modi economic slowdown. An expansionary fiscal policy – a
g ove r n m e n t big push for a big problem – is a must to save lives and
intends to livelihoods. Hence, to give a ‘big push’ to the economic
infuse Rs engine, the government should aim at a fiscal stimulus
of at least 5-6% of GDP.
APRIL 2020 9
AVIATION
How COVID-19 sent
Indian airlines crashing
It will forever change airlines and the way we fly
SAMIT SHARMA
The immediate relief to the Indian sector could In a matter of months, the coronavirus reset the
surely come in the form of resumption of clock on a decades-long aviation boom that’s been
domestic flights if and when it happens . one of the great cultural and economic phenomena
of the postwar world. The explosion in air travel
The international sector will still be a month or shrunk the planet, created jobs and hundreds of
two away from resumption and normalisation millions of first-time fliers, and dispersed families
as much of Europe and the United States are still rich and poor over continents. Now it’s all on hold,
reeling under the COVID-19 outbreak. with airlines slashing seat capacity by more than
It is ironic that the COVID-19 pandemic first 70% since January, according to Cirium.
resulted in a steep reduction of oil prices, which
should have spurred growth of the aviation
industry, and then crippled the sector, owing
lack of demand worldwide.
10 BAZAA₹ M AG A Z I N E
PRODUCTIVITY
How to
succeed at
working
from home
Millions of people are now
working from home due to the
coronavirus pandemic. For
some, that may wind up
being a permanent change
SAMIT SHARMA
W e’re currently in the midst of the greatest Establish a routine — Perhaps the biggest challenge
remote work experiment in history. The COVID-19 to adapting to a new work arrangement is finding your
pandemic is forcing businesses to quickly adapt to routine. Humans find comfort in the familiar, so until
new work setups that allow for greater social distanc- you become used to working from home you’ll likely
ing. While it is not a big adjustment for remote work feel out of place.
veterans, it can be somewhat challenging for those Morning exercise—It’s important to take into account
trying this arrangement for the first time. the reduction in your own mobility while working from
Even before the current situation around COVID-19, home. Previously you may have walked to work,
remote work has been on the rise. A recent study climbed some stairs, left the office to get lunch, etc.
released prior to the coronavirus pandemic found that Compensating for this is important for your physical
and mental health.
50% of employees globally worked remotely for at
least half of the week. This has been matched by a Get dressed for work—There’s a general principle that
similarly positive trend in employee preference when just because you can do something doesn’t mean you
it comes to remote work. The same study found that should. In the context of working from home, just
when faced with similar job offers, 80% of employees because you can spend all day in your pajamas
doesn’t mean you should. In order to set the right tone
would refuse the offer that didn’t offer a flexible work
for yourself, take the time to prepare yourself for the
option.
day just as you would if you were going to the office.
All of this means that whether you’re ready or not, Breakfast and personal time—Maintaining healthy
remote work is here to stay. The logical question now eating habits is always important, but never more so
becomes how can you not only survive in this new than when working from home and practicing social
reality, but thrive. Luckily, there’s an abundance of distancing. Breakfast is also the perfect opportunity to
collective knowledge on remote work gained by early do something for yourself: catch up on the news, read
adopters. Read on to find some practical tips and tools a book, just look out the window, or anything else that
that will help you make the most of this situation. brings you joy.
APRIL 2020 11