Arc Flash Exercise 4

Setup
Load the project file named “ArcFlashExample4”. The solution to this example is located in a directory
called “Solution4”. Open the solution project only to compare against your exercise once completed.

Purpose & Description

The purpose of this exercise is to get you familiarized with the required input data to perform an arc flash
study. The type of data required is for Short-circuit, Arc Flash and Protective Device settings. This
exercise also illustrates important concepts like NFPA 70E incident energy limits and the effect of
automatic calculation of the arcing current variation per IEEE 1584 guidelines.

Procedure

Step1
Enter all the Arc-Flash required information for the system in arc flash exercise 4. The system is shown
below. Please refer to table1 for the required information.

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 1 of 7

 Arc Flash Exercise 4

Table1: Power Grid Parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required
Rated kV 13.8 kV Yes
3-Phase MVAsc 190 MVA Yes
1-Phase MVAsc 190 MVA No
Utility X/R 3-phase 20 Yes
X/R 1-phase 20 No
Design % Volt 100% Yes
Grounding Solid Ground Yes

Table2: Network Parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required
Nominal kV 13.8 kV Yes
Equipment Type Open Air Yes
Gap between Conductors 153 mm Yes
Limited Approach Exp. Mov. Cond 11 ft. Yes
Bus 9 Limited Approach FCP 6 ft. Yes
Restricted Approach Boundary 2.16 ft. Yes
Prohibited Approach Boundary 0.6 ft. Yes
Distance X factor 2.00 Yes
Working Distance 36 in. Yes
Nominal kV 0.480 kV Yes
Equipment Type Switchgear Yes
Gap between Conductors 32 mm Yes
Limited Approach Exp. Mov. Cond 10 ft. Yes
Switchgear A Limited Approach FCP 3.5 ft. Yes
Restricted Approach Boundary 1 ft. Yes
Prohibited Approach Boundary 0.1 ft. Yes
Distance X factor 1.473 Yes
Working Distance 24 in. Yes
Nominal kV 0.480 kV Yes
Equipment Type MCC Yes
Gap between Conductors 25 mm Yes
Limited Approach Exp. Mov. Cond 10 ft. Yes
Bus1 Limited Approach FCP 3.5 ft. Yes
Restricted Approach Boundary 1 ft. Yes
Prohibited Approach Boundary 0.1 ft. Yes
Distance X factor 1.641 Yes
Working Distance 18 in. Yes
Nominal kV 0.208 kV Yes
Equipment Type Panelboard Yes
Gap between Conductors 30 mm Yes
Limited Approach Exp. Mov. Cond 10 ft. Yes
Bus2 Limited Approach FCP 3.5 ft. Yes
Restricted Approach Boundary 1 ft. Yes
Prohibited Approach Boundary 0.1 ft. Yes
Distance X factor 1.641 Yes
Working Distance 24 in. Yes

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 2 of 7

 Arc Flash Exercise 4

Device ID Field Description Value Required

Rated Prim kV 13.8 kV Yes
Rated Sec. kV 0.480 kV Yes
MVA 3 MVA Yes
Max MVA 3 MVA Yes
T8
Pos Sequence Z % 5.75% Yes
X/R Pos Sequence 10.67 Yes
X/R Zero Sequence 10.67 Yes
Grounding Delta – Y solid Yes
Rated Prim kV 0.480 kV Yes
Rated Sec. kV 0.208 kV Yes
MVA 0.750 MVA Yes
Max MVA 0.750 MVA Yes
T1
Pos Sequence Z % 5.75% Yes
X/R Pos Sequence 3.96 Yes
X/R Zero Sequence 3.96 Yes
Grounding Delta – Y solid Yes

Table3: Motor parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required
HP 100 Yes
Rated kV 0.460 kV Yes
Select Manufacturer PF% = 92.04 Eff% Yes
Mtr1
Typical Nameplate = 93.52
Data 4 poles
Quantity 2 Yes
HP 100 Yes
Rated kV 0.460 kV Yes
Select Manufacturer PF% = 92.04 Eff% Yes
Mtr2
Typical Nameplate = 93.52
Data 4 poles
Quantity 2 Yes

Table4: Static Load parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required
Rated MVA 0.5 MVA Yes
Load1 Rated kV 0.208 kV Yes
%PF 95 % Yes

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 3 of 7

 Arc Flash Exercise 4

Table5: High Voltage Circuit Breaker Parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required
Rated Max kV 15 No
Manufacturer Cutler-Hammer No
Model 150VCP-W1000 No
HVBC1 Cycle 5 Yes*
CPT 3 Yes*
Continuous Amps 1200 Amps No

*Required if ETAP is to automatically determine the fault clearing time for this HVCB

Table6: Fuse Parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required
Rated Max kV 15.5 kV Yes*
Manufacturer Cutler-Hammer
Model BA-200 (Condenser) Yes*
Fuse3 Size 200 E Yes*
Continuous Amps 200 Yes*
Interrupting 12 Yes* Not in lib
Test PF 3.95 Yes*
*Required if ETAP is to automatically determine the fault clearing time for this fuse.

Table7: Current Transformer Parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required?
Primary Turns 150 Yes*
CT9
Secondary Turns 5 Yes*

*Required if ETAP is to automatically determine the fault clearing time for a device connected to this
Current Transformer.

Table8: Overcurrent Relay Parameters

Device ID Field Description Value Required?
Input CT CT9 (Phase) Yes*
Output PD HVCB1 Yes*
Relay Element Any Yes*
Level/Zone Any Yes*
Action Open Yes*
OCR Manufacturer GE Multilin Yes*
Relay1 Model IFC Yes*
Curve Type Inverse (51) Yes*
Pickup Range 1-12 sec – 5A Yes*
Pickup 12 Yes*
Time Dial 2.3 Yes*
Inst Pickup Range 30-150 Sec – 5A Yes*
Pickup 100 Yes*
*Required if ETAP is to automatically determine the fault clearing time for this Relay.

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 4 of 7

 Arc Flash Exercise 4

Low Voltage Circuit Breaker Data

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 5 of 7

 Arc Flash Exercise 4

Step2
Setup the following study case settings. Enter the data into Study case “SC”
Device ID Field Description Parameter
Use Nominal Tap Apply
Include MV Mtr Equip. Cable & OLH Apply
Include LV Mtr Equip. Cable & OLH Apply
Fault All Buses Apply
Standard ANSI Apply
Prefault Voltage 100%
Arc-Flash Method IEEE 1584
SC Arcing Current Variation 15%
Total Bus Fault current Apply
Auto Select Source PD –FCT from TCC Apply
System Grounding OLD connection
Update Bus Fault Currents Apply
Update Bus Fault Clearing Time Apply
Update Bus Grounding Apply
PPE Hazard/Risk Categories NFPA 70E 2004

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 6 of 7

 Arc Flash Exercise 4

Step3
Run the arc flash calculation using study case “SC”. Name the output report AF1.

Observe the arc flash analysis results for the low voltage panelboard named “Bus2”. You will notice that
there are two warning messages displayed on the one-line diagram results. The first message shows a
percent arcing current variation of 85%. The second indicates that the incident energy value has exceeded
the NFPA 70E hazard category 4 limits.

3.1 How long does it take LVBC3 to trip in the event of an arc fault at “Bus2”? ________Sec.

3.2 Switch from short-circuit mode to “Protective-device coordination” mode. Run a sequence of events
study on “Bus2”. How long does it take LVCB3 to operate? _________Sec.

3.3 Switch back to SC mode and change the arcing current variation in the SC study case to 0%. Re-run
the calculation. What hazard category does the program calculate now?

___________________________________________________________________________

Observe the results for a fault at bus “Switchgear A”. The warning message indicates that the calculated
incident energy is too high (similar to Bus2).

3.4 If you open the Arc Flash page of Bus “Switchgear A”, which device does the program select as the
source protective device?

____________________________________________________________________________

3.5 If you place a bolted short-circuit fault on Switchgear A, which device operates first?

____________________________________________________________________________

Step4
Try to change the current protective device settings or add protective devices as needed in order to reduce
the incident energy to a category 2 or 3.

ETAP Workshop Notes ©1996-2009 Operation Technology, Inc. Page 7 of 7