11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

State Exams CGPSC UKPSC HCS MPSC JPSC Other Exams Mock

Home > Other State Exams > Article

Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with

that of Other Countries
92 upvotes 7 comments Updated : Dec 9, 2019, 18:00

By : Hemant Kumar

 A constitution is a set of rules and fundamental principles according to which a country

should be governed. It is a document that contains detail description of power distribution,
citizen rights and duties of various organization of the government i.e. legislature, executive
and judiciary.

Constitution of India:  At a glance:

Indian constitution is one of the unique constitutions with its content and spirit. The
constitution of India was framed by constituent assembly under the scheme formulated by
cabinet Mission plan in 1946 under the president of constituent assembly Dr Rajendra
Prasad and chairman of the drafting committee Dr B.R. Ambedkar.  The constitution was
adopted on November 26, 1949.

The constitution of India is the lengthiest of all written constitution of the world. Although
borrowed from almost every constitution of the world, the framers tried to borrow the best
features of each of the existing constitution and modi ed that according to the conditions
and needs of the country. Some of the important features of the Indian constitution include
sources from the Government of India Act 1935. Presently, it consists of a Preamble, about
465 articles and 12 schedules.

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 1/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

The constitution of India describes India as a ‘Union of state’ and an independent Socialist
Secular Democratic Republic with a parliamentary form of government.

Some of the salient features of the Constitution of India:

Lengthiest Written Constitution-   Due to geographical and historical factors, a single

constitution for both the centre and the state and imaginative ambition of the
nationalist leaders.
Blend of Rigidity and Flexibility-  Article 368 provides for two types of amendments,
one with the special majority of the parliament and other special majorities of the
Parliament and with the rati cation by half of the total states.
The federal system with unitary bias-  Indian Constitution contains all the usual
features of the federation such as two governments, division of powers,  bicameralism
etc. while unitary features like single citizenship, single constitution, emergency
provision etc.
Parliamentary Form of Government -  The parliamentary system is based on the
principle of cooperation and coordination between legislative and executive organs.
President is the nominal executive and the prime minister is the real executive. It is also
known as ‘Westminster’ model of government
The sovereignty of Parliament-  The doctrine of the sovereignty of parliament is
associated with the British parliament with one difference where the British state has
hereditary head called monarchy whereas in case of India has an elected head.
Fundamental Rights – The fundamental Rights are meant for promoting the idea of
political democracy and operate as limitations on the tyranny of the executive and
arbitrary laws of the legislature.
Citizenship- The Indian Constitution is although federal but it provides for only single
citizenship.

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 2/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

As most of the features of the constitution of India borrowed from several countries. Here
are some of the comparisons of the constitution with other countries:

1. Witten Constitution- A written constitution is a formal legal document de ning the

nature of the constitution, the rules that govern the political system, governments and the
rights of the citizen in a codi ed manner. A written constitution is an absolute must for the
rule of law.

India- lengthiest Written constitution

British- most important feature of the British constitution is its unwritten character
because it is based on conventions, common law, statutes, charters and political
traditions which have not been laid down in any document.
USA- American constitution is the shortest and the rst written constitution. The US
constitution came through a convention in 1787.
France- French constitution is the only Democratic constitution based on the principle
of supremacy of Executive. Due to political instability, France has changed its
constitution very often, presently the constitution of the 5th republic provides a strong
president with a xed term of 5 years.

2. Flexible or Rigid- A exible constitution can be changed by simple majority or ordinary

law while a rigid constitution is one which can be altered by a special procedure of
amendment.

India-The Indian constitution is more exible than rigid as some provision of the
constitution can be amended by a simple majority of parliament but due to regional
parties, it is becoming dif cult to amend the constitution as some of the amendment
requires the consent of the half states.
British- The British constitution is the most exible constitution as it can be passed,
amended and repealed by a simple majority of the parliament. There is no distinction
between ordinary law and constitutional law. Due to its exibility, it provided for the
continuation of constitutional monarchy and virtue of adjustability and adaptability
with the growing needs of the time.
USA- American constitution is the most rigid constitution of the world which can be
amended by congress by a special procedure.
France- French constitution can be changed by a rigid procedure requiring a resolution
to get passed by 60% majority in both the Houses of Parliament. However, the
President has one special power to refer the amendment to people by referendum.
Germany- German constitution is a rigid constitution. Germany has two houses one is
Bundestag which is a lower house while the other one is Bundesrat which is the upper
house. Basic law can be amended by an absolute two-thirds majority of Bundestag
along with a simple two-third majority of Bundesrat.

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 3/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

Japan- It has a rigid constitution. The two houses of Parliament are called Diet. Any
amendment to the constitution initiated by diet passed by the special majority then
submitted to the people for rati cation at a special referendum.

3. Unitary or Federal: A unitary form of government is governed as a single constitutional

unit, with one constitutionally created legislature while a federal form of government which
function between a central government and constituent political units like states or
provinces.

India- The Indian constitution is federal in character with unitary bias.

British- The British constitution has a unitary character. The British parliament is a
sovereign body vested with all the powers of the government.
USA- American constitution is truly a federal. It provides for complete independence
between centre and state. Every state has its own constitution, governor, elected
legislature and supreme court.
France- France has a unitary feature.
Germany- Germany is a federation and the residuary powers in Germany lie with the
states.

4. Type of Government (Parliamentary or Presidential): In a parliamentary form of

government executives are responsible and accountable to the legislature whereas in the
presidential form of executive and legislature are entirely independent and executives are
not responsible to the law-making members.

India- Indian constitution provides for a parliamentary form of government both at the
centre and the state. Some of the principles of parliamentary form are nominal and real
executive, majority party rule, collective responsibility, double membership as ministers
are executive as well as legislature.
British- One of the major similarity between the British Constitution and the Indian
constitution is both have a parliamentary form of government. British constitution
provides de jure head in the form king who is sovereign but deprived of all his powers
and the real functionaries are ministers who belong to the majority party in the
parliament.
USA- America has a presidential form of government in which the president is directly
elected by people. President is not accountable to the House of Congress and head of
the state as well as the government.
France- France has some features of the parliamentary system and others of
Presidential type and therefore it is called a semi-Presidential type of government.
French President is directly elected by the people for the for a seven-year term and
there are nominated council of ministers headed by the prime minister.
Japan – Japan has a parliamentary form of government with some features of the
British form of parliament like Japan has also a constitutional monarchy.

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 4/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

5. The sovereignty of Parliament: The term Sovereignty means Supreme Power. Parliament
sovereignty means parliament has the supreme authority over all other government
institution including judiciary and executive. Parliament is not bound by the written laws of
the constitution. Some democracies have absolute sovereignty while some democracies
have checks and balances through judicial supremacy.

India- India parliament is not a sovereign body like the British Parliament. Any laws
made by the parliament can be presented to the supreme court for the judicial review
as the supreme court is the custodian of the constitution
Some of the other countries that have similar features of Judicial Review of the
parliamentary law are USA and Japan.
British- One of the most important features of the British constitution is the
sovereignty of the British parliament. The British parliament is the only legislative body
with unrestricted power of legislation. It can amend, make or repeal any law without
any question of the validity of the law.
France- French Constitution has a sovereign parliament with limited powers. The
legislature is clearly subordinate to the executive. Article37 of the French constitution
put a limitation on the legislative power of the parliament.

6. President-

India- The President of India is the head of the Indian state. He is the nominal head of
the government while the real power is vested with the Prime Minister of India with
the aid and advice of the council of Ministers. Although all the executive actions of the
government are formally taken in the name of the President.
The USA- The President of the USA holds the real executive power. He is the head of
state as well as head of the government. He is also the commander in chief of the
United States Armed forces. President of USA holds of ce for a term of 4 years and
can be re-elected twice.
France- The French President is the most powerful within the French system as well as
amongst all other executives across world democracies. France has PM as well as
President but he is assistant to the President unlike that in India and Britain. The
President is elected for a xed term of currently 5 years.
Germany- Germany has a parliamentary form of government and called as ‘
Chancellor’s Democracy’. Chancellor is the PM. President is the constitutional head of
the government.

7.Citizenship-

India- The constitution f India provides for single citizenship for all over the country
despite being a federal country.
British- British citizenship is liberal in the sense that in order to get British nationality
one doesn’t need to renounce his/her citizenship of that country.

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 5/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

The USA- The American constitution provides for Dual Citizenship. One for the whole
USA and one for the state one belongs to but USA law doesn’t mention dual
nationality or require a person to choose one citizenship or another.
France and Germany have dual citizenship.

8. Due Process of Law or Procedure established by law:

Due process of law is the legal necessity that the state must follow the principles of fairness,
fundamental rights, liberty etc during legal requirement as these rights are owed to the
person. The legality of law cannot be questioned on the ground that the law is unreasonable
as this law follows the principle of natural justice. Example – American constitution provides
for Due process of law

The procedure established by law – This law clearly states that the law is valid only if the
legislature has followed the correct procedure and contrary to principles of justice and
equity. Article 21 states that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except
according to the procedure established by law.

9. Fundamental Rights, Fundamental Duties and Directive Principle:

Fundamental Rights- Fundamental Rights are meant for promoting the idea of political
democracy It is meant for establishing a government of laws.

India- Fundamental Rights are enshrined in Part III of the constitution from Article 12
to 35. Fundamental Rights are borrowed from the American Bill of Rights. The
Fundamental Rights guaranteed by the constitution are Right to equality, Right to
freedom, Right against exploitation, Right to freedom of Religion, Cultural and
educational rights and Right to constitutional remedies.
USA- Fundamental Rights in the USA are absolute not like India where the reasonable
restriction is present.
Japan have also Fundamental Rights but no such rights are mentioned in Britain
constitution.

Fundamental Duties-  Fundamental Duties and rights of the citizen are inseparable and
correlative. The citizen must have some moral and civic duties toward their country.

Originally the Indian constitution does not contain Fundamental Duties. It has been
borrowed from USSR and no major country has Fundamental Duties.

Directive Principle- The constitution of India contains the directive principle borrowed from
the Irish Constitution. The Directive principles constitute a very comprehensive economic,
social and political programme for a modern democratic state.  Although directive principles
are not enforceable in nature the state should keep in mind while formulating policies and
enacting laws.

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 6/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

Conclusion:

Recently the Indian Constitution completed 70 years of adoption. For newly independent
nation making of the constitution and entering into force was a challenge for the framers of
the constitution.  Several Political scientists had criticized the newly adopted constitution
that this will not be able to run the diversity of the nation and soon will collapse. But the
working of the constitution has stood the test of time and made India one of the successful
and largest democracy of the world.

More from Us:

िन य Jharkhand PCS Prelims: A 50-Day Course

ल MPPSC 2020: A 45-Day Course to Clear GS Paper

Are you preparing for State PCS exam,

Get Unlimited Access to ALL Mock Tests with Green Card Here

Check other links also:

Previous Year Solved Papers

Monthly Current Affairs

UPSC Study Material

Gist of Yojana

Daily Practice Quizzes, Attempt Here

92 upvotes 7 comments

Tags : Other State Exams General

Dec 9 Other State Exams

Posted by:

Hemant Kumar

Member since Nov 2019

4 Doubts Answered & 0 Best Answers

0 Thanks Recieved
https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 7/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

83 Questions Answered Correctly

FOLLOW

UPVOTE COMMENT SHARE

Related Posts

Modern Indian Architecture

Dec 8 | 109 upvotes

NRC In Assam And Its Possibility In India

Dec 10 | 73 upvotes

Minimum Support Price (MSPs)

Dec 7 | 114 upvotes

Comments WRITE A COMMENT

Vaibhav Mishra Dec 9

Please share with pdf

7 UPVOTE 0 REPLY

Barath De Firranze Dec 9

Directive principles are *not enforceable*

1 UPVOTE 0 REPLY

roshni gupta Dec 9

Please provide in Hindi also

2 UPVOTE 1 REPLY

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 8/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams
Deepti Jain Dec 9
Kashmir alag Kyu dikhaya gaya h...it's unfair
1 UPVOTE 1 REPLY

Deepti Jain Dec 9

Please map change kariye

0 UPVOTE 0 REPLY

Rajani Kumari Baodya Dec 11

Sir plss hindi me bhi....

0 UPVOTE 0 REPLY

Rajani Kumari Baodya Feb 7

Thnk u sir😊
OUR APPS
0 UPVOTE IMPORTANT EXAMS 0 REPLY

Gradeup: The Exam Preparation App CGPSC

Write a comment
NCERT Solutions UKPSC

Goprep Haryana PCS

MPSC

JPSC

PPSC

OPSC

TEST SERIES ONLINE COURSE

WBPSC Test Series JPSC Online Coaching

JPSC Test Series PPSC Online Coaching

MPSC Test Series MPSC Online Coaching

PPSC Test Series UPPSC RO ARO Online Coaching

CGPSC Test Series UPPSC BEO Online Coaching

OPCS Test Series MPPSC Online Coaching

Haryana PCS Test Series WBPSC Online Coaching

WBPSC Online Coaching

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 9/10
11/23/2020 Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of Other Countries : Other State Exams

GradeStack Learning Pvt. Ltd.

Windsor IT Park, Tower - A, 2nd Floor,
Sector 125, Noida,
Uttar Pradesh 201303
[email protected]

About Us Authors Contact Us FAQs Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Sitemap Careers

gradeup © 2020

https://gradeup.co/comparison-of-the-indian-constitutional-with-others-i 10/10