Technical and Financial File Uga160331t
Technical and Financial File Uga160331t
TO SKILLING UGANDA
INTERVENTION (SSU):
INTEGRATION OF THE
KARAMOJA REGION
UGANDA
BUDGET: 6,000,000€
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABBREVIATIONS ................................................................................................... 4
2 STRATEGIC ORIENTATIONS.............................................................................. 27
2.1 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 1: ACT ON THE INSTITUTIONAL LEVEL, DEVELOPMENT OF SKILLS FINANCING
INSTRUMENTS AND ON TRAINING DELIVERY OF THE BTVET-SYSTEM ............................................. 28
2.2 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 2: DIRECT COMPREHENSIVE SUPPORT TO 2 TRAINING PROVIDERS, WITH SOFT
SUPPORT TO SKILLS DEVELOPMENT PROVIDERS IN THE OTHER 5 DISTRICTS .................................. 29
2.4 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 4: MAINSTREAMING OF THE SKILLING UGANDA REFORM PROCESSES FOR
KARAMOJA................................................................................................................................. 31
2.5 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 5: SOCIAL TARGETING .......................................................................... 33
2.6 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 6: FOCUS ON INNOVATION, GREEN SKILLS AND EMPLOYMENT NICHES ...... 34
2.7 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 7: OPERATE THE SKILLS DEVELOPMENT FUND IN KARAMOJA ................ 35
2.8 GUIDING PRINCIPLE 8: RENDERING THE ACTION SUSTAINABLE .............................................. 39
4 RESOURCES ................................................................................................. 75
4.1 FINANCIAL RESOURCES ..................................................................................................... 75
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
4.2 HUMAN RESOURCES .......................................................................................................... 75
6 ANNEXES ...................................................................................................... 88
6.1 CROSS CUTTING THEMES ................................................................................................... 88
6.2 CHRONOGRAM .................................................................................................................. 93
6.3 DETAILED BUDGET FOR THE TWO VTI’S............................................................................... 94
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
ABBREVIATIONS
ADP Aridland Development Programme
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
(p)SDF (Pilot) Skills Development Fund
RSC Regional Support Centers
RTF Reform task Force
SD Skills Development
SDA Skills Development Authority
SSU Support to Skilling Uganda
SU Skilling Uganda
SWAP Sector Wide Approach
TFF Technical and Financial File
ToT Training of Trainers
TVET Technical and Vocational Education & Training
UBOS Ugandan Bureau of Statistics
UBTEB Uganda Business and Technical examination Board
FUE Federation of Ugandan Employers
UGAPRIVI Uganda Private Vocational Institutes Association
UMA Ugandan Manufacturers Association
USSIA Ugandan Small Scale Industries Association
UV(Q)F Ugandan (Vocational) Qualification Framework
VTI Vocational training Institute
WB World Bank
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The “Support to Skilling Uganda – Karamoja region” can be considered as a geographical extension of
the Belgian funded Support to Skilling Uganda intervention, and will be implemented as such by BTC.
It follows the same strategic approach, and is contributing to the same objectives as the SSU-
intervention, while targeting a new geographical area, being Karamoja. The intervention it is focusing on
supporting the BTVET reform agenda, strengthening the national, regional and /local Skills Development
stakeholders, and piloting new competitive and demand driven Skills Development funding
mechanisms. Finally, for the Karamoja region, the project will support (a) two formal training providers
(VTI) in Moroto and Nakapiripirit in raising the quality and quantity of their skills provision and (b)
ensuring that more Karamojong can attend skills training relevant for the local labour market and
economy. In total, nearly 75% of the total available budget (+4,000,000€) is earmarked for activities and
results in Karamoja.
Based on realistic projections, the intervention will provide skills for over 2000 youth in the targeted
area1:
- approximately 1000 students in the formal (2 years courses) and non-formal (3 to 6 month
courses) BTVET-provision system, attending training either in the two supported VTI (approx. 2
batches of 250 students over 4 years), either in accredited training providers for non-formal
courses in the region stimulated through the SDF.
- approximately 1000 youth that will receive short courses (max 10 to 100 hours), either in a
BTVET-institution, either in a vocational training centre of a NGO or by a private provider.
Out of these direct beneficiaries, an indicative target of 70% Karamojong and 30% girls is adhered to.
The two targeted VTI (Nakapiripirit VTI and Saint Daniel Comboni in Moroto were selected on objective
data, and will receive a comprehensive support package, including infrastructure, equipment and soft
supportsuch as management support, training of trainers and pedagogical support.
As the Karamoja region has specific features (high poverty, low economic development, few training
providers and low quality training), the approach for the field component as reflected in the 4 th result, is
somehow different from the approach developed in the 4 districts in the West of Uganda. To ensure
relevance to the Karamoja context, this component will be focusing more on complementarity of skills
development with livelihood activities, more focus on short term vocational trainings and on emerging
markets and on possible future economic developments. This adapted, complementary approach is also
reflected in the three windows for Karamoja Basket of the Skills Development Fund.
As this intervention is conceived as an additional component to the support to Skilling Uganda
programme, it is modestly adding support to already ongoing activities and actions to strengthen the
Ugandan stakeholders from Government, Employers, Trade Unions and Civil Society, in implementing
the strategic lines and proposals made in the Skilling Uganda strategy, both on a national scale and in
a specific part of the country, being Karamoja.
A specific feature of the framework conditions for the project is, that it will “meet” several other
interventions, given the interest of the Government and international donors in the region. As there will
1
Depending on the length of the non-formal training courses (see chapter 2 and 3), these numbers can vary. Enrolment in the
two targeted VTI is mainly depending of a national dispatching system, and cannot be influenced by the intervention.
6
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
be many actors with different and sometimes diverging agendas on the ground, the project management
has to be quite flexible and cooperative. Overlaps can be avoided or turned into additional forces, if the
project management ensures complementarity and, in specific cases, opts for co-financing specific
activities.
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
ANALYTICAL RECORD OF THE INTERVENTION
Intervention number NN
Sector (DAC code) 11330 Technical and Vocational Education and Training
Brief description of the The project will complement the ongoing Belgian funded intervention
intervention to support the implementation of some of the key-reforms of the
national BTVET strategy, both on a national/central level, and add on
a new regional focus in Karamoja. It will support and strengthen
policy formulation and implementation, it will assist in developing
financing instruments and new modalities for training delivery, and it
will support 2training providers in Karamoja
Results Result 1:
The BTVET and employment (sub)sector have a coordinated and
formally agreed governance structure, vision and medium-term
strategy
Result 2:
The Skills Development Fund is established and operates in
Karamoja and it serves as a model for the future National Skills
Development Fund
Result 3: see SSU- Belgian contribution only
Result 4:
Quality of training and qualification processes in Karamoja is
improved and the access to quality BTVET provision is enhanced
2
The four districts in Western Uganda (Kabarole, Hoima, Masindi and Kasese) are covered by Belgian Funding under the SSU-
intervention.
8
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
with special attention to the needs and potentials of females.
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
1 SITUATION ANALYSIS3
Uganda has put forward an ambitious reform agenda for the skills development sector. This reform
agenda, as described in the BTVET strategic plan 2012-2021 “Skilling Uganda”, has the ambition to
move from a “supply driven” school-based SD-system towards a modern “demand driven” and flexible
skills development system, with a main role for the private sector on policy setting, governance of the
system, funding and training delivery. In doing so, Skilling Uganda aims at “unlocking our productivity
potential”. The reform process is currently led by a Reform Task Force (RTF) to spearhead these
reforms, both on the institutional level, on the instrument level and on the training delivery level.
To break down the readiness to roll out the Skilling Uganda strategy in the context of Karamoja, it is
important to investigate both the supply side of skills development (BTVET-providers) and its demand
side (economic sectors generating a need for skilled labour).
- Skills Supply: there are only a few formal training providers in Karamoja, often performing
below standard. Most of the formal training providers are badly situated (isolated), badly
equipped, with poor infrastructure and poor training facilities and training practice. Some good
practice in skills development in Karamoja can be found with non-formal training providers, often
ran by faith-based local and international NGOs.
Skills Demand: the economy in the Karamoja region is underdeveloped. The main economic
activity of the Karamojong is agropastoral, with a high percentage of economic activity on
livestock. Economic diversification is mainly found in some of the district capitals, where
construction and trade are emerging sectors. Ongoing and planned top-down investments by
government, donors, mining companies and some hotel chains could boost the local economy
and local employment, if the local workforce is equipped with quality vocational skills.
3
This chapter has been summarized for certain sections, to avoid overlap / unnecessary repetitions with the SSU TFF (annexed
to this document). Furthermore, details on the Karamoja context can be found in the attached “assessment study on labour
market and TVET provision in Karamoja”.
10
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
image: Karamoja region: 7 districts
Given the high population growth, an increased pressure on the education and training system is
imminent. The youth of Uganda desire to receive quality education and vocational training, in order to
find or create decent jobs and to have a decent income.
4
Ugandan Bureau of Statistics (UBOS), Kampala 2007
11
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
Furthermore, the region has an acute shortage of skilled personnel across all sectors. Given its
distinctive characteristics, it cannot attract skilled personnel from other regions. Karamoja is poorer,
more underdeveloped and characterized by more consistent failure of several development initiatives
than any other region in Uganda. The majority of Karamojong pursue a blended, dual subsistence
strategy, meaning they combine livestock management and opportunistic cultivation, along with a
diversity of activities including foraging, casual labour and seasonal migration.
Karamojong livelihood activities5
Karamojong livelihood activities compared to National average
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Agriculture Unskilled wage Livestock Brewing Commercial Petty trading Wage labour Skilled labour
labour management activity
Traditionally, Karamojong social and economic life was structured around the maintenance of
livestock. Cattle are households’ most important assets, followed by sheep, goats and poultry6. These
animals are a critical source of food, but are also maintained as a safety net, a means of social exchange
and a form of investment.
Some Karamojong today also engage in different forms of casual labour in urban and peri-urban areas.
The revenue generated from the sorts of activities listed above allows individuals and households to
acquire—through barter or purchase—supplemental foodstuffs, such as maize, sugar and oil, in an
otherwise limited diet.
Compared to the national average, Karamojong are more dependent on casual labour and other income
generating activities (mainly brewing and charcoal production) to ensure their livelihood. Agricultural
activities are clearly less developed in Karamoja compared to the national average. According to the
World Food Programme (May 2014), the agricultural productivity in Karamoja is low, despite relatively
high land access (over 90 percent of sampled Households reporting access to land - average size of
1.3 hectares per HH). The WFP-data also show that income derived from sale of crops is not a main
source of income by households in any of the 7 districts in Karamoja. The low agricultural productivity
is related to a multitude of factors such as the lack of access to key agricultural inputs (seeds, tools,
skilled labour, fertilizers) further exacerbating the effects of lack of rainfall due to climate change.
Though the above is being studied in more depth to understand the full scope of the underlying factors;
the bottom line is that Karamojong are increasingly depended on cash for purchase of food.
Households find it difficult to meet their food needs primarily due to insufficient employment opportunities
5
For detailed information, see the study on TVET provision and labour market scan for Karamoja in annex.
6
In Abim sub-county, some communities also raise camels, although these are uncommon elsewhere in the region.
12
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
and the low number of income earners, on average, per household.
As a result, households rely on debt as a continuous coping mechanism with over 30% of households
taking debt, and many households still rely on food aid.
Women in pastoral areas in East Africa have long played important livelihood roles in caring for animals,
particularly ruminants, young offspring, and the milking herd left near the home. As pastoral livelihoods
have gradually transformed in Karamoja, women have decreased their involvement in animal husbandry.
The traditional kraals have not fully returned to southern Karamoja since the partial disbanding of the
protected kraals. Women have taken on more responsibility for household food security to counter the
decreases in animal proteins and income (Stites, E., et al, 2007). This gap has been exacerbated by
gendered shifts in livelihood roles, whereby women are taking on increased responsibility for household
survival as traditional pastoral livelihoods erode. Household subsistence was previously based on
livestock products (milk and blood), but has moved towards resources collected by women and
exchanged for cash, bartered for food or local brew residue in urban markets, or consumed (in the case
of wild fruits and vegetables).
Employment in towns is experienced differently by men and women. According to a study by Care
International in 2013, very few women have steady jobs with regular and reliable payments -- most do
causal work to string together enough small jobs to cover the daily expenses. Most women live with
other family members, and are responsible for their on-going domestic duties while also engaged in their
new livelihood activities.
Women who commute to urban areas on a daily basis can face problems with their husbands at home
if they are unable to procure enough work to feed their family in a given day. “Domestic violence is a
major problem in the household when a woman fails to get something for feeding in the household that
day. Women reported a greater number of violent incidents the further they ventured into the bush.
Incidents of gender-based violence against women and girls are part of the overall rise in insecurity. The
nature and prevalence of gender-based violence varies from one area to the next. In Moroto, rape and
sexual assault occur primarily when women go to the bush in search of natural resources.
Several empowerment programmes are being deployed in Karamoja, to improve the socio-economic
situation of women, based on these facts and analysis (Care International, KAWODI, Oxfam, …).
13
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
1.1.2.2 Overview of livelihood interventions
While the factors and trends listed above help highlight some of the obstacles faced in livelihood
recovery, it is crucial to review the formal livelihood interventions. Karamoja is still considered to be very
fragile in food security. In addition, there is increased government and donor support focus in Karamoja
at present, especially as there is a government move away from food aid towards livelihood-style
interventions.
Government-led interventions
On a structural level, a number of government bodies and institutions have been established to support
livelihood recovery in Karamoja by encouraging greater development, peace building and poverty
reduction. The most prominent include the Peace, Recovery and Development Plan for Northern
Uganda (PRDP) and the National Development Plan (NDP). The NDP is the overall national planning
framework and specifically highlights the livelihood recovery needs of Karamoja as a region. In addition,
there are the Karamoja Development Agency (KDA), the Northern Uganda Social Action Fund (NUSAF),
and the Karamoja Action Plan for Food Security (KAPFS) and the Plan for the Modernisation of
Agriculture (PMA). A dedicated Ministry for Karamoja Affairs was established in 1998 and it has
implemented several strategies that include KIDDP.
KIDDP is a medium term development framework specifically tailored to address the unique context and
development challenges in Karamoja region. The overall goal of the KIDDP is “to contribute to human
security and promote conditions for recovery and development in Karamoja”. KIDDP takes cognizance
of the National Development Plan and the Peace, Recovery and Development Programme (PRDP). The
KIDDP harmonizes the various development interventions by Government, bi- lateral and multi- lateral
development partners, international and national NGOs.
Agency-led interventions
Aid-agency led interventions are the most documented in the literature. They include both large-scale
programmes (including food aid) and specific interventions to address a focused aspect of livelihood
recovery. e.g, THE UK-aid –enhancing resilience in Karamoja Uganda (GB1-203603), the UNDP
Karamoja Hazard, Risk and Vulnerability etc.
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
1.1.2.3 Potential Sectors / Employment / Development / Trades7
Based on more than 87 interviews conducted over three weeks of research in the seven districts of
Karamoja (Abim, Amudat, Kotido, and Kaabong, Moroto Nakapiripirit and Napak), and two weeks in
Kampala, as well as meetings and correspondence with government officials and development partners8
in Kampala working in Karamoja, the sectors below are considered to have potential to grow in the
next 5 years and will definitely translate into various jobs and occupations that will require skills
development in the region especially targeting Karamojong youths, men and women in the region.
It is important to note that all districts officials (DEO and CAO) stressed the importance of skills training
for youth (m/f), to be able to integrate in the socio-economic tissue and to improve their livelihood. Some
of the DEO’s were especially underlining the need to strengthen the quality of training providers, and to
need to address the negative attitude of some Karamojong towards education and labor9.
Further literature review, reveals that in the next 5 years, Karamoja region will receive investment
worthy billions of shillings from both government and development partners (for 2016, over 50m $) and
private investment too (based on the Karamoja Integrated Disarmament and Development Programme
(KIDDP). These investments in basic infrastructure such as education facilities, water and sanitation,
energy and in productive sectors such as agriculture and tourism, are a true potential for job creation
and form thus a good basis to analyse training needs. Currently these sectors and/or projects are mostly
relying on work force from outside Karamoja.
When triangulating these investment data with data gathered with District Administrators (6), District
Planners (6), District Production Officers (5) and District Education officers (7), Private Sector and
elders; the priority sectors and potential trades for the whole region are the following:
7
Details can be found in annex 2: labour market assessment study, Bachu Mubarak.
8
Irish-Aid, UNDP, FAO, USAID, WFP and a series of INGOs
9
See also report in annex for references to District officials’ opinions on Skills Development and employment opportunities.
15
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
Construction-
Hospitality
But also other sectors are growing or have a potential of creating job opportunities, such as
▪ Mining- Gold (South Africa), Limestone (Tororo cement to open branch, Moroto cement to
start), Marble stones.
▪ Agriculture: both crops, livestock and derived production
▪ Build upon traditional skills (agro pastoral, arts and crafts).
To understand the potential economic growth sectors and the related skills gap, a deepened analysis of
16
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
employment opportunities will be carried out twice in the lifespan of the intervention. Based on this
analysis, and on the ‘learning approach’ of the intervention, new sectors and trades can appear.
Employment should also not be interpreted as formal employment, but as any income generating activity
based on (semi-skilled and skilled) labour, either in formal employment, through informal economic
activities or as self-employed.
Primary enrollment
School enrollment in Karamoja remains a challenge, for several reasons mentioned above. On average,
10
For the national system, institutional setup and data, see technical and financial file of the SSU-intervention
17
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
only 40% of 6-year old children enroll in the first year of primary education 11. Also the quality remains a
big challenge, as the pupil/teacher ratio and pupil classroom ratio are very high.
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
11
The data for Abim seem to be incorrect, as net enrolment cannot be higher than 100%.
18
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
1.3 SD – skills provision in Karamoja
The overall structure of the Ugandan Education System can be divided in 6 levels:
6 University Education, 3 to 8 years, with the three levels Bachelor, Master and Doctorate
5 Non-University Higher Education, 2 to 3 years, Diploma
4 Upper Secondary, 2 grades, grade 1 and grade 2 = A-Levels = Higher Education entry level
3 Lower Secondary, 4 grades, from grade 1 to grade 4 = O-Levels
2 Primary, 7 grades, from grade 1 to grade 7
1 Pre-school, Kindergarten
The non-formal skills provision is not integrated in this table, as youth can often enroll without any pre-
condition on diploma-level.
The chart on the next page shows a scheme of the education sector, with a division between the different
levels of education, and with a division between general education (blue color) and technical and
vocational education (yellow color). For each education level, the corresponding Ugandan (Vocational)
Qualification Framework (UVQF) – level has been indicated (green color). This UVQF is a labor-market
oriented qualification scheme, which corresponds with the level of complexity for each (job) profile.
This chart clearly shows the complexity of BTVET provision and how it is anchored within the overall
education sector. On each level, there are public, private not for profit and private for profit training
providers.
19
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
Chart 3
The Technical and Vocational Education and Training System in Uganda and the relation Education – Training - Employment
7 years
P1
5 years
20
TFF SSU-Karamoja (16 033 1T) after Validation Committee – update oct. 2016
1.3.2 Assessment of training provision in Karamoja and enrollment in SD
The analysis of the data gathered through the questionnaire, field visits and secondary data review
shows that few students enroll into VTI in the whole of Karamoja regional technical Institutes, with a high
dropout rate (50%). In all public and private institutions visited, there was less than 10% of Karamojong
students, most of which are boys and in some institutions there are no Karamojong girls at all. Most
students are from neighboring districts, on probing further as to why, according to the districts’ and
institutions’ authorities the reasons are varied including (1) lack of freedom to movement (2) lack of
interest by Karamojong’s to take TVET training (3) preference for short courses as compared to long
term training.
An assessment14 of training providers in the intervention area focused on all 7 existing formal SD
institutions (VTI) and 2 major NGO Skills training providers (ADP and C&D 15). The ambition of this study
was to identify potential beneficiary institutions and to provide a concise analysis of their performance
(and needs).
The analysis of the institutions focused on the following criteria:
1) Student enrolment and performance per trade for the last three years
2) Number of Instructors per trade and establish capacity gaps
3) Infrastructure and equipment to facilitate skills development and transfer; Availability of land
for future expansion
4) Proximity to local economy/economic actors
Assessment Parameters SCORES
12
Awaiting gender disaggregated figures from baseline
13
Awaiting institute & gender disaggregated figures from baseline, incl UNDP, DFID/VSO and ADP sponsored trainees
14 Assessment of Training Supply in Karamoja region comprising of Abim, Amudat, Kaabong, Kotido, Moroto, Nakapiripirit and Napak Districts, by Bachu Mubarak, Kampala.
15
ADP- Arid Land Development Program, C&D – Cooperation & Development an Italian NGO.
21
Public Private NGOs
Maximum score 4
NAKAPIRIPIRITI
KAABONG TI
MOROTO TI
St. DANIEL
KOTIDO TI
COMBONI
ABIM TI
C&D
ADP
Student enrolment and performance per trade for 4 3 2 2 2 3 3 3 3
the last three years
Performance per trade for the last three years 4 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3
Availability of qualified instructors 4 3 2 2 2 3 3 4 4
Availability of power/electricity 4 1 2 2 2 2 2 4 4
Availability of equipment 4 1 1 1 1 2 3 3 4
Availability of Tools 4 2 1 1 2 2 3 4 4
Availability of ICT Labs 4 0 1 2 1 2 3 0 0
Availability of IT network coverage 4 0 0 0 0 0 2 4 3
Availability of land for future expansion 4 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Proximity to Business centre & Relation to Private 4 1 2 2 1 3 4 4 3
sector
Total 40 16 16 17 17 23 29 32 31
KEY
0= ZERO, 1= POOR, 2= FAIR, 3= GOOD, 4=EXCELLENT
NB= Give Priority to those with 50% and above
Based on the above parameters, each of the institution has been assessed and in summary:
1.3.2.1 Abim technical Institute
Scored 16 points only, based on the lack of electricity, no internet connection, no ICT lab, little to no
available equipment for practical work, no fencing on school compound and complete isolation from
private sector activities. Abim technical institute is 25 KM from Abim town. Where the town is now
connected to electricity grid, the institute is not. All trainees who complete their course are assessed by
UBTEB.
22
at 15 KM from Moroto Municipality and 10 Km from Kangole Trading centre. All trainees who complete
their course are assessed by UBTEB.
SWOT
Based on the context analysis, the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats of the TVET &
employment sector in Karamoja are as follows:
Strengths Weaknesses
SSUs position within the MoESTS and RTF, Absence of quality formal training providers
supporting SD reform and improving Quality (VTI) in the region, with weak management,
and Relevance of TVET, allowing to link skills infrastructure and equipment capacities
development to the SU-strategy and reform
Current non-formal trainings are not always
agenda,
accredited and seldom certified. Mostly
SDF setup cater for different funding for TVET traditional trainings provided, with no
of different target groups and to guarantee innovative content nor approach
quality assessment of training providers and
Absence of work based learning components
of training programme and methodology.
Entrepreneurship not fully integrated, but
Pockets of good NGO training centres in the
24
region: mostly included in starter kits/grants
- some of the TVET programmes also Absence of a skilled labour force
cater for starter kits and/or grants
- scholarships for non-formal short
training programmes with existing
training providers
Opportunities Threats
Recommendations
Based on the context and SWOT, the intervention should diversify its approach, to limit the risks, and to
allow a flexible learning approach with a continuous feedback loop to ensure swift adaptation of activities
and approaches.
As it is a challenging region, the intervention should act on all elements of and factors that influence the
Skills Development sector. Therefore, it should support and strengthen the governance of the sector
and the quality and relevance of skills provision, it should act on certain thresholds (funding, duration of
training, illiteracy, counselling & guidance) that hamper enrolment of Karamojong in skills development,
and should search for a smooth integration and coordination with ongoing development activities in
either livelihood sector or larger scale development sector.
In short, it should adopt innovative, low cost and efficient skills development model which will provide
an opportunity for the youth. The development of new courses in order to respond to employment
opportunities (green jobs, construction, hospitality, …) is paramount.
26
2 STRATEGIC ORIENTATIONS
The current intervention will be embedded in the Belgian funded Support to the Implementation of
Skilling Uganda Strategy (SSU) intervention, a 16m€ support to the Ugandan government to fast track
the Skills Development Reform Process on a national and systemic level, and on the local level (Western
Uganda).
Taking into account the Karamoja context, the intervention strategy will follow a differentiated approach,
to avoid unsustainable or unsound investments. It will concentrate on a limited geographical area, and
on a few economic sectors, providing long term comprehensive support to two formal VTIs, but at the
same time providing - through non-formal, short term trainings - skills development opportunities for
Karamojong youth, related to the economic context and prospects of the region. It will build upon existing
experiences and effective skills development providers in Karamoja, ensuring a better coordination
between all stakeholders and a full integration of these approaches in the national Skills development
system.
The intervention will support the Skilling Uganda reforms in order to strengthen the economic
development of Uganda, especially in the targeted Karamoja region, through a better access to and an
increased quality & relevance of skills development. Therefore, the project will
• Support the establishment and functioning of a regional skills and employment platform –
coordination structure, with tripartite representation, with an explicit strengthened role for the
district education officers;
• Support the three components of the SD system: (1) policy and coordination; (2) instruments
and (3) training provision;
• Strengthen the capacity of stakeholders, at the national and regional level (public sector - DEO,
private sector, trade unions, NGOs);
• Implement on a regional scale the rolling out of the Skills Development Fund, a new model for
financing SD delivery in Uganda;
• Adopt a flexible approach, linking up with other SD and livelihood projects and stakeholders in
the Karamoja region;
• Feed SD experiences of Karamoja back to into the national reform strategy of Skilling Uganda.
The project will act following a set of guiding principles or entry points, to ensure that the risks and
specific characteristics of the Karamoja region are well taken into account.
These guiding principles are briefly presented in the following paragraphs and translated into result
areas and activities in the following chapter.
As a future member of the KDPG, BTC will – as an implementing agency for the EoI – advocate for and
continuously search for coherence with ongoing and future initiatives in the Karamoja region:
- Close coordination on the Irish funded programme in Karamoja (implemented by different actors), to
avoid overlap and ensure economy of scale
- close coordination with other donors and national partners to ensure sustainability and coherence
27
- close cooperation with all actors to ensure a full integration of SD as a theme in the KDPG.
The institutional support component will focus on strengthening stakeholder’s capacity to spearhead
and implement reform related to the BTVET strategy. The main objective of this support will be to move
from the current model of SD in Uganda, to the proposed model (new system).
• strengthening M&E systems for the SD sector, with a special focus on capitalizing the
Karamoja experiences and ensuring their integration in the policy work at national level
• ensuring that relevant institutions at central and decentralised levels are empowered to
implement their mandates. At local level, the District Education Officer (DEO) oversees
public and private formal BTVET. The district education staff operates under the control and
supervision of the Chief Administrative Officer (CAO), who is the accounting officer. Key will
be to include the DEO as a key-operator in the regional coordination structures, and to
provide the DEO’s with sufficient support and capacity building to empower the DEO in the
BTVET subsector.
• the set-up of a Karamoja basket of a skills development fund as a new funding instrument
for SD provision, and new system for pooling funds from different sources), and the
modalities on attracting private sector contributions to the new fund (training levy, direct
contributions or hybrid models)
28
• supporting the accreditation of training providers and standardisation and certification of
short and medium-term training programs
• supporting SD coordination mechanisms, with a key-role for the DEO, private sector
representatives and NGO’s/civil society.
2.1.3 The training provision level: improve training provision and upgrading of
training providers
The third entry point will be the provision of support to 2 selected public and private (not for profit) SD
service providers in Karamoja, being Nakapiripirit VTI and Saint Daniel Comboni in Moroto. This support
will be based on SD service provider’s potential to provide quality trainees relevant to the livelihood
activities & emerging labour market for Karamoja, while at the same time contributing to the achievement
of the project (and “Skilling Uganda”) objectives by piloting new initiatives (such as the SDF), sharing
lessons learnt from their practical experiences and developing solutions to the problems and challenges
identified, as well as feeding the practical experience from pilots and lessons learned back to the policy
level! The two training providers were selected out of 7 existing VTOI in the Karamoja region.
The two institutions were ranked first and second out of the 7 VTI in the region, based on an assessment
looking into following criteria: (1) Student enrolment and performance per trade for the last three years,
(2) Performance per trade for the last three years, (3) Availability of qualified instructors, (4) Availability
of power/electricity, (5) Availability of equipment, (6) Availability of Tools, (7) Availability of ICT Labs, (8)
Availability of IT network coverage, (9) Availability of land for future expansion and (10) Proximity to
Business centre & Relation to Private sector. As the available budget for this intervention is limited, not
all institutions can be targeted, but moreover, in order to pilot reforms and ensure quality outputs,
proximity of support and expertise can only be provided for a smaller sample of institutions. As Comboni
(and Nakapiripirit VTI as a runner up) has the most potential for success, these two institutions were
16
BTVET strategic Plan – p21 to p23
29
shortlisted, having 1 private and 1 public institution in the sample.
Both institutions have been supported by donors, but support has mainly focused on infrastructure and
equipment, without a clear support process starting with the development of sound contextualized
business plans.
The selection of the thematic focus areas is based on the critical skills identified by the “Skilling Uganda”
strategy 2012 - 2021 and on a specially commissioned analysis of the Labour Market in the Karamoja
region. Though given the specificity of the Karamoja economy further livelihood and labour market
analysis will be needed to update growth scenarios, identify upcoming investments and forecast
subsequent skills gaps.
As described in chapter 1, the sectors construction and hospitality have been identified as areas of
potential growth that can be successfully supported through demand-driven skills development.
30
In analysing the actual ‘trades’ required within the construction sector, it is clear that there is a strong
opportunity to support skills developed for semi-skilled labour in construction trades. These can be
broadly categorised as the first thematic focus.
The second thematic focus sector will be the hospitality sector. With ongoing construction of new
hotels in the area, there are indications of some employment opportunities though providing hospitality
related services for both business travellers and tourists in the area.
A third thematic focus is relating to the livelihood, lifestock and agriculture sector. This sector will be
mostly supported through short term non-formal vocational trainings adding up to classic livelihood
activities, supporting productive activities (and skills) for a diversification of family incomes. Here both
livelihood and market research should indicate the priority trades and most prominent skills gaps in close
coordination with livelihood actors through joint forecasting. This could lead to joint implementation
through matching funds (where this interventions will chip in to ensure quality skills development in
livelihood activities executed by other partners.
Within the specific context of Karamoja, the following ‘innovative’ opportunities are identified:
• Production of low environment impact bricks, of energy efficient stoves
• Alternative construction techniques to lower the impact on deforestation
• Solar panel maintenance, installation and repair; mobile phone repair
• Solid waste management and treatment, water pump maintenance
• Husbandry and livestock related occupations
• Food processing, innovation in leather and other traditional crafts.
A series of supporting trades such as mechanics, welding, electricity can be clustered in a fourth
thematic focus, depending on continuous monitoring of economic developments and investments
including industrialized mining, motor vehicle maintenance, etc.
• create the necessary linkages with relevant ministerial departments and districts
education officers to ensure accreditation and quality of training programmes;
• strengthen the linkages between trainees and the private sector and maximize the
opportunities for work-based learning (internships, apprenticeships) where feasible.
31
Therefore, lobbying is needed towards Gov. of Uganda, donors and implementing
agencies for f.i. social clauses to integrate SD-students and graduates as
trainees/apprentices in small and large investment programmes
• Promote the Skills Development Fund, a funding mechanism of the Skilling Uganda
reform strategy for SD, as a vehicle for implementing the reform agenda. For this
intervention the Karamoja Skills Development Fund (a separate basket in the SDF) will
be set up to cater for the skills development of Karamojon;
• Include lessons learned from this component in the M&E system of the MOESTS/RTF
in order to capitalize the Karamoja context. To ensure the local relevance of SD in
Karamoja, given its specific context, it will be of the utmost importance to discuss
these specific features (poverty, lack of formal employment opportunities, weak
private sector, high illiteracy rate, weak BTVET-service providers) on both a political
and administrative/technical level, in order to cater for necessary adoptive approaches
for similar regions and similar target groups in Uganda. Such localisation of the
Skilling Uganda agenda could include:
o As an example, the results and impact of formal training should be compared
with those of short term training courses, what might lead to an adaptation of
existing training programmes, and what could illustrate the need for a more
decentralized approach and planning of BTVET, to allow local planners and
stakeholders to incorporate characteristics of the region and its population in
TVET-planning and - implementation.
o Another example could be the approaches on work-based learning (WBL),
which might be difficult to mainstream in the Karamoja context, as private sector
is weak and underrepresented. New approaches that could be introduced by
this intervention (simulation workshops, the creation of mini-enterprises in
TVET-institutions), could form good alternatives to a national policy and
guidelines.
o A third example is off course the social targeting through the skills development
fund, as a means for affirmative action for specific groups of concern (girls,
vulnerable youth, orphans, …).
As a means, the intervention will support enhanced donor and agency coordination in skills
32
development in Karamoja through
(1) the “Skilling Uganda” Reform Task Force (RTF), to ensure alignment of Karamoja BTEVET
provision to the Skilling Uganda strategy,
(2) coordination with other relevant SD departments at MoESTS (BTVET, DIT, etc.), and with
deconcentrated services on a district level, especially with the DEO.
(3) increased coherence with relevant skills development activities in Karamoja such as work-
based learning, instructor upgrading, etc. through the relevant channels such as the Sector
Skills Councils and the Skills Development Fund,
(4) contribution to improved information exchange and coordination on skills development of the
Karamoja development coordination platform, such as the Regional Support Centres.
Within the specific context of Karamoja, the following opportunities are identified:
o Production of low environment impact bricks, of energy efficient stoves
o Alternative construction techniques to lower the impact on deforestation
o Solar panel maintenance, installation and repair; mobile phone repair
o Solid waste management and treatment, water pump maintenance
o Food processing, innovation in leather and other traditional crafts.
Furthermore, the intervention will invest in two (at the beginning and midterm of the intervention) labour
market and livelihood assessments, to identify new niches, opportunities and needs in the intervention
area.
But it especially will invest in close coordination and information exchange between the humanitarian
and livelihood programmes, to allow a continuous identification of skills needs within the target groups
and of employment opportunities (emerging markets).
These coordination mechanisms will also cater for sensitization and lobby campaigns to convince
government, donors and implementing agencies to include social clauses (first employment
opportunities for Karamojong graduates and absorption of Karamojong apprentices/students) in
tendering for implementation of activities & investments through third parties (contractors, service
providers, …). This principle will also be adhered to by BTC in all investments and infrastructure support.
Finally, this guiding principle should ease a smooth and swift transfer and transition of the beneficiaries
of the livelihood and humanitarian programmes to the skills component.
34
2.7 Guiding principle 7: Operate the Skills Development Fund in
Karamoja
In Palestine, BTC is running a WBL-fund to promote work – based learning in TVET. Through a system
of calls for proposals, TVET-institutions and private sector enterprises (or associations) are stimulated
to introduce joint proposals to increase the WBL-practise in the training programmes, adapt the
curriculum, ensure coaching, guidance and follow – up and quality of the ‘apprenticeship’ component.
Next to these necessary measures to increase the relevance and quality of apprenticeship schemes
(WBL), these bottom up initiatives allow for including necessary investments in the workplace.
“Social targeting” proves to be a success.Through this WBL-fund, Aa scholarship component of this
WBL-fund ensures affirmative action measures, to attract more girls to TVET (last year, 47% of the
scholarships were granted to girls in this WBL-fund).
As from 2016, BTC and GIZ (with additional funding from EU and Switzerland) are now engaged in
discussions with the Palestinian Ministries of Education and of Labour to assess the feasibility of
17
For more background on the principles and on assessments of training funds, please see:
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/SOCIALPROTECTION/Resources/SP-Discussion-papers/Labor-Market-DP/0922.pdf
www.cedefop.europa.eu%2Ffiles%2F5189_en.pdf&usg=AFQjCNFIc6qQQl7ntduLFyychiM8-csM8A&bvm=bv.123325700,d.ZGg
https://dfat.gov.au/about-us/publications/Documents/tvet-financing-overview-paper-sustainable-financing.pdf
http://www.adeanet.org/sites/default/files/afd-financement-formation-professionelle-afrique.pdf
18Establishing a Pooled Funding Mechanism. Irish Aid, Kampala, 2012. Page 17 of the report notes that “Belgium
has indicated an interest in contributing to and leading the pooled funding mechanism”
35
upscaling the WBL-fund to a pooled TVET-fund to provide important invetsmentsinvestments and
means aligned with sector strategies.
2.7.2 Training Funds: the general concept, ambitions, operating and fianncing
modalities
A ‘training fund’ is a dedicated stock or flow of financing outside normal government budgetary
channels for the purpose of developing productive skills for work. The overall purpose of training funds
(TFs) is to raise the productivity, competitiveness and incomes of enterprises and individuals by
providing them with needed skills. Many TFs are financed by levies on enterprises, but may also be
based on public contributions and donor financing. National training funds are an increasingly common
vehicle for financing training. They are a central instrument for financing training in many countries
worldwide. TFs provide an institutional framework for collecting and allocating funding to training
providers.
Training funds are often linked to payroll levies from companies for further or/and initial education.
On this account a NTF provides companies with the opportunity to have a say in steering the national
TVET system. Through a better channelled and strategically more aligned funding policy, it will improve
skill creation and therefore raises the productivity, competitiveness and income levels of enterprises and
individuals.
The design of the training fund varies depending on its aim and general framework. In general it might
serve the following objectives (Johanson 2009, p. 5):
1. Unify and coordinate various sources of revenue, i.e. pooling of income from different sources;
2. Mobilize resources and increase revenue available for training;
3. Build pre-employment training systems and capacities;
4. Expand the volume of employer-based training by encouraging enterprises to invest more in
worker training;
5. Provide equality of opportunity for access to training services by disadvantaged populations;
6. Improve the relevance of training, e.g. allocate funds according to employer priorities and
market needs;
7. Raise the quality of training, e.g. through accreditation and certification of training providers and
specification of performance conditions;
8. Use training resources efficiently, e.g. lower the unit costs of training;
9. Develop competitive training markets; and
10. Foster involvement by employers and collaboration among stakeholders.
36
Despite these different functions the following graph shows the general framework for training funds:
Income:
Government budget
Training levies
Donor funding
Other sources
Disbursement
Levy reimbursements
Special groups
Grants/Loans
Government
Vouchers
Budget Allocation
Mandate/Aim
Secured income
Autonomy/Governance
Stakeholder ownership
While the fund will follow BTC regulations in terms of financial management, contracting (grant
agreements) and monitoring, a specific committee will be set up for the Karamoja basket to oversee the
policies, selection and operations of this basket of the SDF. As the fund will work with call for proposals,
it is a ‘lean’ and ‘light’ instrument to fund skills development, and to cater for specific needs and target
groups.
The use of the SDF as a funding instrument in the region of Karamoja, should also contribute to the
sustainability of both (1) the SDF and of (2) the funding of the skills provision in Uganda. By adding
38
another earmarked basket in the SDF for skills development for a specific region, proof of feasibility and
flexibility of the SDF, and of multi-donor funding of such an instrument for skills development in Uganda
is given. If three donors (within 1 year of operations of the Belgian funded BTC – MoESTS SSU-
intervention) are putting in considerable funds in this instrument, both other donors and the Ugandan
partner (MoESTS, Ministry of Finance, the OPM, the RTF) can but recognize the advantages of this
instrument (economy of scale, flexibility, handiness, rapid response).
This also confirms the strategic choices (creating a skills development fund) Uganda has made
in its ten year BTVET strategic plan. A seed fund is set that later on could convince other donors
to channel their funding for SD in Uganda through the skills development fund, either earmarked
(regional, thematic, sectoral, beneficiaries) or not earmarked (overall contribution to SD).
19
Targets on sustainability related actions are presented in the logframe
39
mainstream SD provision for the region into the regular Skills Development policy in Uganda.
40
3 INTERVENTION FRAMEWORK
The employability of youth is improved through better quality of instruction and learning in skills
development
The quality of skills development is enhanced and responsive to labour market needs in20
Karamoja in line with the Skilling Uganda reforms
3.3.1 Activities under Result 1: The BTVET and employment sector has a
coordinated and formally agreed governance structure, vision and
medium-term strategy (est. budget for R1: 393,000€)
The actions under Result 1 are a translation of part of the 1st guiding principle, being the “Institutional
Support” component and of the 4th guiding principle, being mainstreaming of Skilling Uganda reform
processes for Karamoja based SD provision.
Most of these activities are already foreseen in the TFF of the SSU-intervention, and will be
implemented by the Project Management Team (PMT). Some actions and budget are here added
to the initial SSU-intervention.
The institutional support component will focus on strengthening the stakeholders’ capacity to guide and
implement the reform process of the “Skilling Uganda” strategic plan 2012 - 2021. This is mainly a
“policy” function. The intervention will
• Ensure an improved coordination to include skills development actions under
humanitarian and livelihood support targeting the Karamoja region, into the national SD
reform process and national SD system
• Ensure that relevant institutions at central and decentralised levels are empowered to implement
their mandates with an appropriate level of autonomy that facilitates the best use of their
expertise and local knowledge. Special attention will be given to the DEO, and in strengthening
his capacity to ensure a coordination role in BTVET –provision in the district.
• Support the quality of assessment and examination systems
• Support SD coordination mechanisms.
The capacity strengthening component, addressing private sector associations, employers and other
representative bodies, concentrates on their technical capabilities to identify the skills, that are required
20
The four districts in Western Uganda are covered by Belgian funding
21
For a full description of activities, see SSU technical and financial file. In this document, only the Karamoja specific activities
are described.
41
by employers and which reflect economic opportunities in the selected areas (thematic and geographical
focuses).
3.3.1.2 Activity 1.2 Establish a Monitoring & Evaluation & Learning System
This activity will allow the project stakeholders (MoESTS, Govt. of Uganda, BTC, RTF, Govt of Belgium,
Embassy of Ireland and other donors,…) to closely monitor, learn and adjust the intervention and its
achievements. It will lead to a comprehensive project steering instrument, and thus facilitate
communications between all stakeholders.
Task 1.2.4 expand M&E system to Karamoja, conduct baseline and ensure capitalisation of good
practices.
3.3.1.3 Activity 1.3: Implement a Capacity Building Programme for all key stakeholders
in Government and private sector
This activity will strengthen the capacities of public and private stakeholders on the national level, to
ensure an improved piloting of the SD sector.
Task 1.3.3 build the capacity of public and private key-actors in the Karamoja region
22
See SSU TFF for a full description of the actions and activities
42
needs analysis, implementation modalities, who-is-doing-what-where in terms of SD, to avoid
duplication and seek to enhance mutual cooperation and joint implementation of SD activities.
This activity will also lead to the establishment of regional public-private SD and labour market
coordination structures, to enhance demand driven SD delivery, provide technical steering etc.
The project establishes its own office in Karamoja (Moroto), and “incubates” the Karamoja basket of the
competitive skills development fund (SDF). The project establishes its own office in Karamoja (Moroto),
and that amongst others provides technical assistance on relevant SD in Karamoja, “incubates” the
Karamoja basket of the competitive skills development fund (SDF), and . The project office in Karamoja
will host – besides its functions as an administrative office.
Once the SDA is operational, this office could function as a second decentralised / regional office of the
SDA. The Skilling Uganda Project Team calls on the regional-local stakeholders and helps them in
establishing administrative coordination structures at the District level, with the DEO in a key-role,
starting with Moroto & Nakapiripirit.
Task 1.4.1 Establish a District-based SD and Labour Market “council” facility in Moroto and Nakapiripirit
Task 1.4.2 Establish a Labour Market Observation and Intermediation capacity in the selected SD
Institutions, the district and relevant partners (Business Membership Organisations and
companies (human resources officers).
Means: Transport, lump sum for funding activities and general means of the council
3.3.1.5 Activity 1.5 Undertake Action Research in the field of PPP, results based
financing, demand driven training provision, etc.
This activity is initiated by the project and the main stakeholders from public and private sector, with the
support of a professional organisation giving advice and providing coaching. It will link Action Research
with innovation activities under Result 3 and with the SDF, and thereafter inject the results of the Action
Research in the Learning from good practice experiences under Result 1, Activity 1.2
Means: Action research budget, consultancies
3.3.2 Activities under Result 2: The Competitive pilot skills development fund
is established and operates in the Project Area and serves as a model for
the future National Skills Development Fund (est budget for R2: 203,000€).
As described in chapter 2 under the eighth guiding principle, the Skills Development Fund will be
extended to the Karamoja region. As described in the SSU-TFF, the fund will go through 3 distinct
phases, whereas one could consider it is already growing towards the phase of pooled funding (Belgium,
Ireland and EU).
For each package of actions and submission of proposals, the Project Management Team will have to
prepare a “Tender”. For this purpose, it will have at its disposal a specific budget for studies, analyses
43
and preparatory services (Studies and Services Facility) 23.
3.3.2.1 Activity 2.1 Design at the central level, the competitive skills development fund
and test its pilot locally
Task 2.1.1 Design the project competitive pilot Skills Development Fund with national partners.
The project will support the partners in the design and development of the overall
“architecture” of the national SDF and of its pilot.
Task 2.1.2 Circulate a first draft among the stakeholders (Government ministries, Business membership
organisations, Trade Unions, Donor agencies)
Task 2.1.3 Integrate experience from the project area into the national SDF concept
Task 2.1.4: integrate the experience from Karamoja region into the national SDF.
Means: consultancies, workshops
3.3.2.2 Activity 2.2 Build capacity and elaborate the Manual of Operations for the
Competitive pilot skills development fund
The SDF has to be operated by a team of Ugandan and International experts. A clear manual of
operations, and training of the future SDF staff (and selection / grant committee), is planned for in this
activity.
Task 2.2.7: Select and train the professional staff operating the Fund in the Karamoja area
Visits to countries where Skills Development Funds run successfully
Invite staff from one or two of these countries for on-the-spot advice
Recruit competent consultancy to coach staff
3.3.2.3 Activity 2.3 Operate the Competitive pilot skills development fund –
Administration and Finance
Under this activity, the management structure/staffing of the SDF/Karamoja earmarked basket is
included.
Task 2.3.1 Test-run the fund with Tenders to be introduced by networks formed by SD institutions
Task 2.3.2 Target each tender of the SDF on specific objectives responding to Skilling Uganda and
project objectives
Technical support will be provided to SD institutions in the development and implementation
of Tender as follows:
• The project will locate 1 National Technical Assistant (NTA), 1 National Assistant SDF
manager and 1 National field coordinator in Moroto, Karamoja. They will assist the SD
stakeholders in planning and implementing activities for the functioning of the SDF;
23
See 3.4.3
44
• The Karamoja PMT will support the monitoring and supervision of the selected SD
partners. They will give their agreement to transfer the money from the SDF. They will
be supported by the project team based in Kampala to ensure transparency and to
evaluate the initial SDF model;
3.3.2.4 Activity 2.4 Document, transfer and capitalize on the experience gained while
operating the Competitive pilot skills development fund, to the National Skills
Development Fund
During the whole project duration, the lessons learned of the SDF should be captured,
documented and shared with the stakeholders (MoESTS, Ministry of Finance and Planning,
other donors, RTF, …) on a regional and national level. Capturing the experiences, is one of the
main tasks of the Fort Portal team. They can recruit external expertise (e.g. for capitalisation
studies) to assist in documenting the experiences, and organize regular evaluation missions
and meetings with stakeholders. The lessons learned should then be reintegrated in activity 2.1.
Means: Consultancy, Workshops, Visits
3.3.4.1 Activity 4.1 Upgrade the two selected Training Providers: equipment,
infrastructure improvements, instructor training and upgrading24
Based on evidence from the labour market (making use of the labour market study and the skills supply
study), the project will initiate necessary investments actions to improve the learning environment
through the rehabilitation and extension of buildings and infrastructure in two SD institutions, partly
organised through school practice projects planned and implemented by Teacher-Student Teams under
professional supervision.
This activity includes also the upgrading of the equipment of the selected SD institutions in priority
trades, based on livelihood and labour market intelligence. Finally, it will also support the development
and trial implementation of practical competence-based, flexible training modules adapted to the needs
24
See annexes for detailed scenarios for budgeting of infrastructure and equipment needs. Given the limited budget,choices will
have to be made based on the ‘business plans’ of the two institutions.
45
of Karamojong, combined with technical and pedagogical training for trainers, technicians, instructors
and master-craftsmen.
The two selected SD institutions are:
- Saint Daniel Technical Institute – Comboni (Moroto)
- Nakapiripirit Technical Institute (Nakapiripirit).
Task 4.1.1 Invite the 2 targeted SD Providers to present their business and institutional development
plan. The needs have to be marked as priority areas in their institutional development
plans.
Task 4.1.2 Identify, control and launch tender for construction, rehabilitation and equipment provision.
Provide supervision.
For each tender, include social clauses for internships/apprenticeships of SD graduates
and SD students. Fix a percentage of workers and/or subcontractors that are to be
recruited regionally. Include decent work clauses in each tender.
Task 4.1.3 Identify capacity building needs of technical teachers / instructors / workshop assistants (=
skilled workers) and of technical staff in collaborating companies.
Task 4.1.4 Organise initial training and upgrading, constitute mixed groups or twins of technical teachers
/ instructors of SD institutions and master-craftsmen / technicians of companies
3.3.4.2 Activity 4.2 Upgrade the management capacities of all public and private
formal Training Providers in Karamoja: Principals, Registrars, Accountants and
Heads of Department
Besides an important investment in infrastructure and equipment, the management staff of the targeted
SD institutions will be provided with training, coaching and other types of capacity building activities. As
SD school management is crucial for quality training, the Karamoja field officers will provide day-to day
coaching and support to the targeted SD institutions. This is closely linked to activity 4.1 and 4.3.
Means: trainings, consultancies, coaching, equipment
Task 4.2.1 Identify capacity building needs of management (Principal, Registrar, Accountant, Heads of
Department). Provide for packages of Personal Computers with stabilizers etc.
Task 4.2.2 Organise management training and coaching, transfer financial, academic and materials
management including maintenance to simple standardised IT tools
Task 4.2.3 Introduce standardised reporting to management and Supervisory Board of the institutions
Task 4.2.4 procure management-related equipment, follow up and supervise delivery
46
Task 4.3.3 Implement the “Production Unit” approach in the selected SD institutions through capacity
building and coaching
Task 4.3.4 Control the reporting in the targeted SD institutions and coach management and support
staff on making use of the provided information
47
3.3.4.3 Activity 4.4 Establish - in collaboration with the National Instructors’ Colleges
Abilonino/Nakawa/etc. – a continuous Instructor Training programme.
In the region, no continuous training is offered for SD instructors and technicians. It is considered more
effective and efficient to establish a training offer and a specific training offer in one of the targeted SD
colleges, than having all trainers and instructors move to Kampala or Lira for short term upgrading
courses.
Upgrade instructors of the selected SD institutions technically and pedagogically in the following trades,
according to the graphic of trades in key economic sectors.
Task 4.4.1 Develop needs assessment tools
Task 4.4.2 Conduct needs assessment in the priority trades, following the Training Programme
methodology described above
Task 4.4.3 Develop a Master Training Plan with costing
Task 4.4.4 Design in-service courses (including teaching aid’s), which are complementary to NIC
Abilonino and case by case with the Instructor Training at Nakawa VTI (in-service training),
Jinja VTI (pre-service training), etc.
Task 4.4.5 Organise intensive training and skills exposure programmes for SD instructors and master-
craftsmen in national industry, in collaboration with partner institutions such as SYNTRA
Belgium, VDAB, ILO and similar organisations in other countries
Task 4.4.5: provide means for twinning between the VTI’s and Abilonino, Nakawa, Jinja, etc.
3.3.4.5 Activity 4.6: Launch training and skills development tenders through the SDF –
48
Karamoja Basket to improve training provision and improved access to training
The Karamoja basket of the SDF will mainly support the access to short and medium term quality
vocational training and enhancement of entrepreneurial skills for youth, women and girls. As the
capacities of SD institutions in the Karamoja region are weak, the fund will mainly channel its funding
through third parties with local expertise in Karamoja, in a joint venture with SD operators. They will be
selected through a series of competitive calls for proposals. A management mechanism will be put in
place which will be led by a ‘SDF committee’ composed of representatives of relevant stakeholders.
Eligibility and selection criteria will be drafted, based on based on livelihood and labour market
information.
Mainly operators already operational in the region will be targeted, as they have the necessary
experience and relevant knowledge to reach out for the target groups. It allows also to build their
capacities and to ensure continuity for targeted youth (see guiding principle 7).
Grant agreements and/or contracts will be signed between BTC and the implementing third party, after
assessment of the beneficiary operator. To this end, BTC will put the necessary checks and balances in
place to ensure technical quality control and financial management. Some of the “instant” short term
trainings under window 3, will be tendered according to public procurement rules.
Means: tenders, tendering, execution agreements
Task 4.6.1 Define specific focus for each tender, based on specific and clear ToR (and for the tenders
once the SDF is running). Both initial vocational education and training and continuing
vocational education and training will be eligible. Cross cutting themes as gender,
environment, HIV and any other judged opportune by the project team, should be an integral
part of each tender, either in separate windows, or integrated in the ‘regular’ tenders.
The Karamoja basket in the Skills Development Fund (SDF) will have three specific “Windows”, to cater
for different activities and target groups in Karamoja:
The 3 “Windows” of the Karamoja earmarked skills development fund
2. Window 2 will cater for “Increased absorption of youth, women and girls in existing skills development
training programmes through provision of scholarships, followed by entrepreneurial skills coaching and
start-up kits”
Through scholarships or capitation grants the intervention will facilitate the access of disadvantaged
youth, women and girls will to existing long term and short term, non-formal Skills Development training
programmes and formal SD programmes in the targeted region or –exceptionally – within the country25.
The scholarships will be granted to cater for tuition fees and any related costs for those beneficiaries
that will attend existing and official training and education programmes, accredited by the MoESTS or
any other Ugandan Ministry.
1. The scholarships will be disbursed to the training institution through an intermediate NGO
or development actor.
2525
Coherence of this component with the existing Irish scholarship facility, will be developed during the inception phase to
ensure linkages and avoid overlap and double funding.
50
2. The demand for the scholarship will be confirmed in an agreement between the beneficiary,
the training provider and third party implementing agency.
3. While priority will be given to 2-6 months short term, non-formal but certified training
courses; a maximum of 2 years schooling can be funded (crafts 1 and Crafts 2).
4. The SD training providers will be subject to a pre-selection through a (non-exhaustive) list
of trustworthy training providers and/or after a quality check by BTC/MoESTS
5. In addition to scholarships, the third party is expected to also foresee the necessary
pedagical & social support (literacy & numeracy training accelerated learning programs),
quality control of training, career guidance, entrepreneurship skills development, provision
of starter’s kits & coaching and/or access to MFI.
6. Exceptionally, based on a clear justification, the enhancement of the capacity (equipment,
tools, …) of the TVET institutions can be considered to absorb increased numbers and
specific needs of the targeted groups, while keeping a minimum standard of Skills
Development.
3. Window 3 will cater for “Increased provision of instant, qualitative, tailor made, innovative and gender
sensitive skills development responding to identified skills gaps for the green economy, livelihood &
market development and settlements service delivery”.
Groups of beneficiaries can benefit from this grant, based on an identified need (through a livelihood
and labour market scan) by a third party implementer or SD institution providing “instant courses” (of
10-100 hours) in specific skills.
Priority will be given for instant training programmes catering for a skills gap identified by other actors
working with the youth, women and girls in Karamoja, facilitating a smooth transfer and transition
between beneficiaries of livelihood and humanitarian programmes and SD and entrepreneurship
training.
Four specific categories of “instant SD training courses” (10-100 hours) are considered here:
a. Green skills for the green economy in Karamoja, such as sustainable construction
of shelters/homes (eco-friendly brickmaking), energy efficient cooking instruments,
solar energy, etc.
b. Matching a Skills Development component with ongoing livelihood or other social
protection activities provided by NGOs and other actors in livelihood and integrated
support programs (e.g. cattle, poultry, agri-business, veterinary services, bicycle
repair, mobile phone repair, sandal-making, etc.)
c. Specialised skills required by operators accommodating Karamojong in the
“emerging local economy” including e.g. WASH such as water and sewage pump
maintenance; recycling of solid waste; shelter-infrastructure; health, first aid, HIV-
awareness and nursing; etc.
d. Facilitate exposure of primary & secondary pupils/students to Skills Development
through visits and short term skills training during holidays. This vocationalisation
can function both as a teaser for youth to engage in skills training at a later stage,
and as a first layer of productive skills for any livelihood and income generating
activity (IGA)
51
General guiding principles of the fund
1. Targeting specific needs groups:
a. At least 80% of the trainings should be provided for youth (aged between 15-35,
referring to the Ugandan definition),
b. At least 30% of the beneficiaries should be women and girls
c. Overall a ratio of 70% Karamojong and 30% non-Karamojong will be adhered to in
all direct beneficiary ratios. For indirect beneficiaries calculation the same ratios will
be taken into consideration, in indicative, overall manner.
2. The skills training should not exceed 9 months, focusing on practical skills (with the
exception of scholarships and activities for absorption in formal SD).
3. Provision of Life Skills can be considered through a) a pre-training (maximum of 3 months),
b) in parallel or c) preferably integrated in to the skills development training components
(including literacy and numeracy training, additional language and general life skills) based
on specifically identified needs of the candidates (only if not already provided through
NGO’s or other actors).
4. The skills training will focus on technical profiles, based on livelihood and labour market
needs that prepare for a true job opportunity for the beneficiaries.
a. Local and regional, formal and informal economy: a livelihood and labour market
scan will be executed during of the intervention
5. The training should at least partly be provided by renowned local training providers that are
certified/accredited by the MoESTS or any other Ugandan Ministry (e.g. Ministry of Gender,
Labour, Social Development, etc.). Even short term training and training for the informal
economy should lead to certification through e.g. “workers pass”.
6. Each training should encompass a work-based learning component, either in a company
through internships or apprenticeships, either in a “simulated” work environment provided
by the training institution or another partner of the training institution.
7. Each candidate should be subject to an intake interview, where prior learning should be
recognized as well as personal background is appraised (and special needs for
personalized career guidance and/or psycho-social support is verified: potentially to be
outsourced)
8. Each training should take into account entrepreneurship training component and start-up
guidance of the beneficiaries:
a. The entrepreneurship training should be according to national or international standards
and instruments (ILO or others)26, and a minimum of 6 hours of individual or small group
coaching and advise must be included.
b. The provider will have to ensure a smooth transfer of the trainees / graduates to MFIs
26Such as the National youth entrepreneurship training package developed by the Ministry of Gender, Labour and
Social Development and ILO.
52
(Micro-finance institutions). MoU between the provider and the MFI will have to be
attached to the proposals. No collateral will be funded through this intervention.
c. Trainees that have successfully passed the vocational skills training and the
entrepreneurship training, can be granted a “start-up kit” with basic tools and equipment
(mechanism to be developed and validated by project Steering Committee).
53
3.3.4.9 Activity 4.10 provide international and national expertise
Staffing of the Karamoja / Kampala based project team (see chapter 4):
54
3.4 Indicators and means of verification27
27
The indicators, baseline values and targets are indicative at this stage. They will be validated or adapted and further defined / refined during the start-up phase (inception) and after a
participatory process, including a theory of change (TOC) workshop.
28
No targets are put at the level of the general objective, as attribution of results can only be indirect.
55
Objectively Verifiable Indicators Baseline values Targets28 Means of Verification
56
Objectively Verifiable Indicators Baseline values Targets28 Means of Verification
57
Objectively Verifiable Indicators Baseline values Targets28 Means of Verification
INDICATORS At the national level: see SSU Not available within 12 Concept and
months after Manual of
project start- Operations of the
up SDF design Skills
& Manual of Development Fund
At the local level: timely availability of SDF design, Manual Operations are Minutes of SDF
N/A (no SDF in selection
of Operations, establishment of a multi-actor selection available and
place) committees
committee and launching of call for proposals the first call for
Project records
proposals has
been launched Project records
58
Objectively Verifiable Indicators Baseline values Targets28 Means of Verification
59
Objectively Verifiable Indicators Baseline values Targets28 Means of Verification
60
Objectively Verifiable Indicators Baseline values Targets28 Means of Verification
61
3.5 Description of beneficiaries
The direct beneficiaries of the project are people who have gone through training funded through the
SDF-Karamoja Basket (mainly young Karamojong/women & girls) and in SD institutions supported by
the project, including relevant internships and apprenticeships in enterprises and other collaborating
entities.
Other beneficiaries are
• ‘Clients’ of SD training institutions (graduates 29, employers and actors in livelihood activities).
• The members of the Reform Task Force for Skilling Uganda (RTF), and its Executive Secretariat
(ES), and at a later stage the SDA
• The heads and staff members of directorates and departments at MoESTS, in particular SD
department and DIT, and district staff (CAO, DEO, …)
• Human Resources officers and technical staff engaged in enterprises, business organisations
and trade unions
29
As mentioned in chapter 1, most of the students in VTI are non-Karamojong
62
3.6 Risk Analysis
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Risk for not achieving the Project Flexible implementation
Objective: structure, large project team,
· the Large scope of the project could lead education programme SC
to scattered activities approach with coordination
· Scattered and only partial administrative structure
responsibility of the relevant departments in Political attachment of the
the Ministry of Education, Science, project to the overarching
Technology and Sports could lead to policy body promoting the
internal competition SC
reform and to the department
· Non-existence of administrative and of planning to ensure
coordination structures in the project region, coherence
could lead to lack of ownership and weak Independent project office in
feedback Medium the project region with a large
· Unclear future of SDA could slow down DEV Low High autonomy of action. Project
Risk PMT
reforms office will function as a pilot
regional RTF/SDA office
63
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Document and spread the
statements by the President,
the Prime Minister and sector
Ministers, and of international PMT +
The Skilling Uganda Strategy has been and national investors who RTF
formally approved by the Government and stress the importance of skills
signed by the President. However, the for development
Medium
institutional structures have not been put in DEV Medium Medium
Risk Technical support to RTF and PMT +
place, and if political will is lacking,
implementation of the proposed reform will SDA RTF
be slower Organisation of field
achievements independently
PMT
from the creation of the Skills
Development Authority
64
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Active presence on the political
and the technical level,
sustained by the Belgian and
Irish Embassy and the BTC RR
Resident Representative of
BTC, support for a specific
Sector Table “SD-Employment”
Continued dialogue with
RTF/SDA to advocate for the
creation of a basket Skills
Development Fund (and a
nationally owned SDF), for PMT +
which the Competitive pilot RTF
If other donors are not eager to support a skills development fund
future Basket Skills Fund, and/or if a collects experiences. This will
Medium
nationally owned SDF is made dependent DEV Medium Medium allow for adapting and fine-
Risk
from the training levy; the SDF will probably tuning the national fund to the
remain a pilot specific conditions
PMT +
RTF
Active support to RTF for the
creation of sustainable multi-
source funding mechanims for
SDF/SDA
65
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Participatory approach strategy
of the Project: pro-active and
continuous communication with
District and Municipal PMT
If companies and business organisations authorities are the first priorities
don’t see the benefit of cooperating with for the Project and its staff
training providers, they will not be eager to
formulate their needs and neither Set up and coach Sectors
DEV Low Medium Low Risk PMT +
participate in regional coordination Skills Councils & Regional
RTF
structures (Consultative Committee) with Support Centres
District and Municipal authorities and SD Enquiries with potential
institutions employers, search for
champions, negotiation with PMT
management of SD institutions
to seek PPP alliances
66
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Targeted capacity building
measures addressing staff of
relevant MoESTS departments PMT +
(incl.SD Department and
RTF
Department of Industrial
Training)
67
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Flexible management, learning
by doing, transparency of
operation, giving the local PMT
Coordination Committee insight
Develop the Manual of
PMT +
Operations while test-running
RTF
the Fund
If SDF Procedures and management are Technical committee to be
too complicated and rigid, its Medium included as reflection body in
OPS Medium Medium
implementation and its scaling up risks to Risk project activities with PMT
become a failure international and local
expertise
Ensure maximum participation
from the local business
community and from District PMT
and Municipal authorities.
68
Construction & equipment
delivery is implemented under
‘Own Management” & enough PMT
capacity is foreseen for
management of procurement
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
A communication strategy
which shows cases of
“champions” who have
invested in training and who
are rewarding quality. This PMT +
strategy has to be planned and RTF
implemented in alliance with
employers and trade unions at
the national level and in the
project region
An excessive belief in certificates and A sensitisation campaign which
diplomas and the attitude of employers who explains that it is rewarding to
do not honour hands-on competences with Medium set and reach international
DEV Medium Medium
better pay (the “low skills equilibrium”) may Risk qualification standards. This
render improvements brought about by the PMT +
will marginalise assessment RTF
project irrelevant bodies which are separating
practical competence at work
from achieving formal
standards.
69
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
focussing on “quick wins” in the
first two years PMT
reach communication among
key stakeholders (Ministries of
the Economy, Labour and
Education; Employer
Organisations, Trade Unions, PMT +
Donors) in the medium term RTF
(three to five years) and reach
systemic structures in a long-
term perspective (five to 10
years)
The project is not understood as an actor cooperate with other actors
and agent for 'systems' building. The Skills supporting the change process PMT + SC
Development Authority would function as an of the SU strategy
DEV Low Medium Low Risk
administrative body without marking a clear
difference from the current set-up (SD-DIT-
UBTEB)
70
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Communication strategy
addressing employers and the PMT +
local media, including radio RTF
broadcasts
Participatory approach
(regional-local Coordination
Committees, participation of
business representatives on
management boards of SD
institutions) giving employers a PMT
say and bringing productivity
and innovation gains to
Skills mismatch: non-responsiveness of the companies and businesses
local labour market, could lead to
unemployed youth & if SD institutions are
DEV Low Medium Low Risk Pro-actively seeking
overloaded with students in order to
increase income for the institutions and its cooperation with development
staff, training quality, will suffer partners & livelihood actors to
seek sector specific &
pragmatic collaboration on
matching economic support &
addressing skills gaps
71
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
A baseline (organisational
audit) will be established in
order to adequately assess the
management approach of the
PMT
SD institutions
72
Identification of risk or issue Analysis of risk or issue Deal with risk or issue
Potential
Risk description Category Likelihood Total Action(s) Resp.
impact
Given the cultural and educational Communication strategy
background of Karamojong youth, the addressing Karamojong and
enrolment and retainment of Karamojong in Medium local leaders. PMT +
DEV medium Medium
SD provision can be problematic. This could Risk RTF
lead to a low ratio of Karamojong in skills
development activities
Working closely with livelihood
and humanitarian agencies and
actors, to ensure a smooth
transfer of beneficiaries
between different programmes
Provision of short term training,
to take into account the
specificities of the local context
and the real skills needs of
Karamojong
Provision of parallel socio-
professional counselling and
guidance, including possibilities
to include in SD-provision
through the SDF short
numeracy and literacy courses
73
74
4 RESOURCES
Budgeted under
Absolute value Estimated . activities
INTERNATIONAL Project Contracting
and Irish percentage31 Number of months
Staff Party
Contribution in
Euros
Intervention Change Manager,
54 MOEST
national , part time, appointed
30
He will jointly work with the MoESTS and the SSU-team on themes such as the reform process, the setup of the skills
development fund, capacity building of stakeholders etc.
31
This percentage is indicative
75
by MOEST32
35,640€ X
SDF MANAGER 54 BTC
33%
108,000€ X
Financial Officer 54 BTC
100%
0 0%
Accountant35 BTC
0 0%
NTA architect36 BTC
0 0%
Secretary37 BTC
0 0%
Driver38 BTC
32
No salary will be paid to the MoESTS manager. Reimbursement of additional costs can occur and are budgeted.
34
Financed 100% by DGD SSU intervention
35
ibidem
36
ibidem
37
ibidem
38
ibidem
76
X
81,000€
Education Programme Manager (BTC) 54 months (10 %) BTC
40,500€
International Architect 54 months (5%) BTC
121,500€
International Administrative and Finance Officer (RAFI) 54 Months (15%) BTC
40,500€
International Procurement Officer 54 Months (5 %) BTC
0
National Procurement Officer BTC
39
Financed 100% by the DGD SSU intervention
40
The % are indicative and resource sharing will be done according to a key allocation that will be mentioned in the
Service Level Agreement.
77
78
79
5 IMPLEMENTATION MODALITIES
80
5.5 Implementation and follow-up structures
• Project staff at central level located within MoESTS in the RTF offices
41
Non exhaustive list
81
Specific responsibilities of this team concern project activities in karamoja:
• Overall planning of the project Karamoja activities and adjustments within their areas of
responsibility (assumed to be results 2 and 4 for now) on quarterly basis. It is noted that responsibility
for activity 2.1 may be allocated to the national Project Team. The Karamoja team works under the
management of the Intervention Manager and Intervention Change manager..
• Organizing, coordinating and supervising the implementation of project activities in accordance
with the approved project work plans (for results 2 and 3 activities only);
• Ensuring that all result 2 and 4 activities outputs are linked to the results and specific objective
through a close monitoring based on pre-defined indicators
• Providing timely compilation of progress reports and budgeted work plans (results 2 and 4
activities only) for the following period to the PCU for consideration by the Steering Committee;
• Supporting sub-national Beneficiary Institutes in designing, implementing, monitor and evaluate
their HR development plans
• Providing high level technical guidance on project methodology and strategy for results 2 and 3
• Promoting capitalization, and specifically sharing experiences and lessons from the
implementation of results 2 and 4
• Preparing tender/solicitation documents for the procurement of works, goods and services for
results 2 and 4 in conformity with applicable regulations
• Managing Contracts at the sub-national level
82
mandatories of the accounts, in accordance with BTC internal rules
BTC mandate structure is applied.
In terms of signature, the double BTC-signature is compulsory.
This bank account will be used for expenses incurred in Uganda,
General means expenses shared between DGD SSU intervention and Irish Aid SSU, will be
paid out of the DGD SSU intervention (bank account) and a reallocation will occur on a semi-
annually basis. The reallocation of operating expenses will be done according to the
participation of each donor in the general means budget of the SSU program. This also applies
for activities shared within result 1 and 2.
83
5.8.2 Funds transfer
Irish Aid will transfer annual instalments to BTC according to the signed Memorandum of
Understanding.
Funds are transferred from the IS-HQ account to the specific main account open in Uganda for this
intervention (see 5.7.1) for expenses incurred locally.
Transfer to the local BTC account will be done according to BTC internal procedures (see SSU TFF for
more information)
Budget Change
Budget change will be done in accordance with article 4.3 of the memorandum of understanding and
with BTC internal procedures.
84
Monitoring office
Results Results Report Project Team BTC Annually Project team,
Monitoring partner, PSC,
BTC rep office, BE
embassy, Irish ….
Mid-term MTR report BTC HQ BTC Unique BTC HQ, project
review team, PSC, donor,
…
End-term ETR report BTC HQ BTC Unique BTC HQ, project
review team, PSC, donor,
…
Final Final Report Project Team BTC Unique PSC, Partner,
Monitoring BTC rep office BE
embassy, Irish….
5.9.1.1 Baseline
Establishing the baseline in the beginning of the project is a BTC system requirement. The project M&E
framework will be aligned with existing frameworks and methodologies already used by the partner.
The Baseline Report needs to be established by the PCT at the beginning of the project (ideally within
the 9 months after the first project steering committee (start-up PSC).
The Baseline Report will be presented to the Project Steering Committee (PSC). The PSC takes note
of the Baseline Report and validates the way the intervention will be monitored. The main goal of the
JLCB should be to assure that the Baseline Report is good enough to guarantee sound monitoring.
85
steering committee. The follow-up of this plan will be included in each progress report.
An external End Term Review (ETR) shall be carried at the latest 6 months before the end of the
intervention. The ETR will focus on the intervention’s achievements as well as on its lessons learned.
This mission will perform a check of compliance with results listed in this TFF and will capitalize lessons
learned.
These exercises will be conducted under the final responsibility of BTC as part of its M&E policy. To
strengthen mutual accountability, coordination with similar Vietnamese procedures will be seeked if
possible. This will be assessed during the set up phase.
Final Monitoring
The purpose of final monitoring is to ensure that the key elements on the intervention’s performance
and on the development process are transferred to the partner organisation, the donor and BTC and
captured in their “institutional memory”. This enables the closure of the intervention (legal obligation for
back-donor of BTC), the hand-over to the partner organisation and the capitalisation of lessons learned.
It can be considered as a summary of what different stakeholders might want to know at closure or some
years after closure of the intervention.
86
5.10 . Financial and procurement audit
Project audit
Project audit will be organized as per BTC internal rules. Two audits are budgeted. One will be
organized in 2018 and one at the end of the intervention. Those audits will be organized
according to BTC internal rules.
BTC and the Steering Committee may request additional audits if necessary.
Audits will be handled according to BTC internal procedures
BTC Audit
The College of Commissioners will yearly audit BTC accounts. They also audit the projects at
that moment. BTC Audit Committee can also request that BTC internal auditors audit this
project.
Irish Aids may directly commission an audit if deemed necessary (not included in project
budget).
87
6 ANNEXES
6.1.1 Environment
88
negative environmental impact, and likewise when selecting furniture and equipment 42. During
demolition, special care will be given to the removal of asbestos roofs and their proper treatment. It has
to be taken care, that all these guiding principles are included in the terms of references and tender
documents for work contracts.
42
The BTC construction guide and publication on renewable energy will be used as a main source to guide the works.
89
Thirdly, for SD in particular, occupational health and safety, waste minimisation, recycling, handling of
hazardous substances etc. are particularly important. Moreover there will be issues and concerns that
are relevant for specific occupations. An electrician, for example, should not only know the dangers and
hazards associated with the profession, but should ideally also be able to choose and advise customers
on the most energy-efficient solutions.
6.1.2 Gender
In the Ugandan Constitution, men and women are considered equal before the law in all aspects of
political, social and cultural life. However, in reality, opportunities for men and women are not equal. On
average, women in Uganda only earn between 40% and 50% of a man’s income. The incidence of youth
unemployment for girls and young women is double as high as that of males. Promoting gender equality
and women’s empowerment, (as also emphasized in MDG no. 3) is necessary for a number of good
reasons, not least because it is key to economic development and poverty eradication.
The overall strategy outlined in the Gender in Education Policy is ‘gender mainstreaming’, a conscious
approach to take into account gender equality concerns in all policy, planning, programme,
administrative and financial activities as well as organizational structures and procedures. At the lower
level of implementation, this entails amongst others that each institution in the system providing
education and training must:
• Ensure that gender responsive methods of teaching, learning and assessment of learners are
applied
• Ensure that the school environment is gender sensitive and conducive to the learning of both
sexes.
In the SD Sector, the participation of girls and young women is very limited. It is much lower than in the
primary education (grades 1 to 7) segment and in general secondary education. One explanation is the
types of trades offered in SD, which are mainly male-dominated, with the exception of health sector
occupations, administrative occupations and occupations in the hospitality sectors.
There are some exceptions in the transport and construction sectors, but they are irrelevant in
quantitative terms. The underrepresentation of girls and young women in SD reflects in some way the
underrepresentation of women in the workforce of many economic sectors. Women represent the
majority of workers in agriculture, but there they are mainly working in the subsistence agriculture
segment, where no salaries are paid.
The MoESTS “Girls in Education Strategy 2015-2019, proposes strategies to overcome the gender
imbalance in education in general. Its Goal is to “Promote girls’ education as an integral part of efforts
to create gender equity and equality in the education system in Uganda.”
This strategy outlines some actions for improved gender balance (on access, quality and learning
90
outcomes) in SD, but these are less developed than f.i. the ones for basic education and secondary
education. The proposed actions are:
• to construct facilities in SD institutions that have minimal or less facilities for girls,
• to engender the curriculum and include girls\female friendly courses and, employable skills
for the youth
91
As educators of teachers and tutors of children and adolescents, it is particularly important that the
colleges are at the forefront of the battle, linking to relevant national initiatives.
92
6.2 Chronogram
93
6.3 List of agencies and donors in TVET in Karamoja
1.
Woord & Daad (Through Livelihood & Skills Training Vulnerable, Youth and
ADP) in Abim Education Women ABIM, KOTIDO
and KAABONG
2.
Restless Development Livelihood and Vocational Training Youth (Napak, Moroto
& Kotido)
3.
Cooperation & WASH, OVC, Health and Youths Children, Youth and
Development (C&D) Skills Training other people
4.
VSO Youths Skills Development The Youth
5.
Save the Children Constructions, Child Protection, School Children, ABEK
International Early Childhood ,Education and facilitators and Youths
Support to ABEK and Skills training
6.
UNICEF Donated tools and equipment to Regional
Vocational training Institute
7.
UNDP Donated tools and equipment to Regional
Vocational training Institute
(Computers)
8.
Save the Children in SMC Training, ECD and ABEK, Regional
Uganda sponsorship of skills training
9.
Church of Uganda Community education programme Regional
(COU),Karamoja including skills training for the
Diocese Development youths
Services (KDDS)
10.
ZOA Uganda Sponsoring youths for skills training Amudat, Karita, Loroo
S/C
11.
BRAC Early Childhood Development, Town Councils
Youth Development Programme, for
youths
12.
UGAPRIVI Assessment & Certification Regional
13.
DIT Assessment & Certification Regional
14.
UBTEB Assessment & Certification Regional
15.
OPM Sponsorship Regional
16.
Ministry of Education Formal & Non Formal Regional
17.
European Union Non- State Actors (NSA) Calls Most NGOs, have
benefited from EU Calls
- Regional
94
6.4 Detailed indicative budget & scenarios for upgrading two VTI’s
95
96