5.2 Thesis - The Dream Weaver - Reimagining A Stimulating Environment For The Children (Sunnydale School at Bashundhara R/A, Dhaka)
5.2 Thesis - The Dream Weaver - Reimagining A Stimulating Environment For The Children (Sunnydale School at Bashundhara R/A, Dhaka)
BACHELOR OF ARCHITECTURE
Spring – 2020
Department of Architecture
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents Page
Title………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..1
I. Certificate of Originality……………………………………………………………………………………….3
II.. Dedication……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 3
III. Acknowledgement……………………………………………………………………………………..........3
IV. Abstract……………………………………………………………………………………………………....4
V. Discussion with Client……………………………………………………………………………………….5
1. RESEARCH BACKGROUND…………………………………………………………………
1.1. Historical Context ……………………………………………………………………………………….....6
1.2. Geographic Context …………………………………………………………………………………....6--9
1.3. Social Context………………………………………………………………………………………........10
1.4. Demographic Context ………………………………………………………………………………..11-14
2
I. CERTIFICATE OF ORIGINALITY:
This is to certify that I am responsible for the work submitted in this thesis and that this is an
original work of my own except as specified in acknowledgements or notes, and that neither the
thesis nor the original work contained therein has been submi tted to this or any other institution for
degree.
II. DEDICATION:
III. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
At first, I am grateful to Almighty for blessing me with the opportunity to complete this research
work. I am thankful to my studio mentor Abu Sayeed Mostaque Ahmed, Dean & Professor and also
supervisor Muhtadin Iqbal, Department of architecture, UNIVERSITY OF ASIA PACIFIC (UAP) for his
immense support and guidance throughout the process, which gave me the triggered power to work
hard in every step. My endless gratitude goes towards sir Ziaul Islam, Associate Professor & Proctor,
Mehrab iftekhar, Assistant Professor for always believing in mind provoking me to go further and
beyond.
I am also grateful to the Dept. of Architecture, University of Asia Pacific, for technical support.
Thanks to my honorable all teachers at the Department of Architecture, UNIVERSITY OF A SIA PACIFIC
(UAP) for providing a stimulating academic environment, inspiration, and guidance
3
IV. Abstract
It is undoubtedly said that the children are our future of the nation. Now-a-days children are seen
engaged in watching online based movies – cartoons etc. playing online games, watching YouTube
and browsing in online websites. For these reasons though the children can learn a lot of things from
the virtual media they are getting mechanized and losing to nurture their inherent creativity that
means spontaneous quality. This is a concerning issue for the children as well as the parents. So it is
high time for making our future children to be more creative simultaneously to be more advanced in
science & technology. We want to provide an inclusive environment that fulfills each child’s social,
emotional, physical and intellectual needs. Our focus is on their environment, because children are
the principal influence in a creative development, so that children, parents and teachers can work
together as a team. We are committed to the community, bringing families, teachers and community
members together to teach our children the value of cooperation, respect, responsibility, creativity &
potentiality. It is an opportunity to locate those problems of this important sector and come out with an
architectural solution. In this thesis, an innovative and effective architectural program which is based
on rational explanation is to create a suitable child-friendly stimulating environment in a school. So by
designing Sunnydale School imaginably can play important role in this aspect.
4
5
6
1. RESEARCH BACKGROUND
Bashundhara is situated in a residential area of Vatara Thana in Dhaka, Bangladesh. This area
is developed by Bashundhara Group. It is recognized as one of the most significant planned
housing areas in Bangladesh.
In the 1980s, the project was started. In 2011 segments of the housing project was declared
unauthorized as they were in considerable flood flow zone areas. In 2014 a cabinet committee
held a meeting to rechange the Dhaka Detailed Area Plan (DAP) map to make the project
legalized. The project was established on the area filled up low-lying marshland areas. The
project has been sold over 10,000 as of 2005 for the residential purpose with all other
amenities.
Bashundhara is located just opposite to Baridhara and a few minutes short drive from the
Gulshan 2 area. For the Dhaka dwellers, they have to access Bashundhara by the Kuril
Bisshow Road. Actually there is a 300 ft high way just beside the neighborhood (which goes by
the name ‘300 ft’ itself) is for the people who live outside Dhaka. Though the area is a little bit
far from the current commercial hubs like Motijheel and Gulshan areas, people still find it
suitable due to the peace, serenity, and security of the area.
7
2003 2006
2008 2009
2010 2011
2012 2013
2014 2015
8
2016 2017
2018 2019
2020
9
1.3. Social Context
etc .
Educational:
Health Facilities:
10
1.4. Demographic Context
Green Areas
11
/ Hospital
12
13
14
15
2. CONTEXTUAL ANALYSIS & PROGRAMMATIC UNDERSTANDING
2.1. Site & Context
16
LAND USE PATTERN
SITE
17
2.2. SITE ANALYSIS
ZOOM IN VIEW
18
AIR FUNNELING
19
20
CONTEXT LAYOUT PLAN WITH FOCAL POINTS
21
22
23
TREE MAPPING
24
25
26
27
28
2.3. PROGRAM ANALYSIS:
I. GIVEN PROGRAM
Administration
Reception Area With Entry lobby
Principal Room
Secretary Room
Meeting Room
Visitors Waiting Lounge
Accounts Room
Commercial Room
Students Counselor Room
Library
Librarian Room
Cloak Room (Lockers)
Stack Area
Visitors Waiting Lounge
Book Stacks
Reading Space
Canteen
Dining Area
Kitchen
Storage (Food, Utensils & Crockeries)
Washroom Facilities
Counter
Loading-Unloading Bay
Multipurpose Hall
Reception Area
Entry Lobby
Seating Area
Back Stage
Washroom Facilities
Green Room
Lockers in Changing Room
Gymnasium
Lockers
29
Gym Area
Assembly Area
Assembly Space
Class Rooms
Teachers Room
Labs
Physics Lab
Chemistry Lab
Biology Lab
Computer Lab
Car Parking Facilities
& Other Supporting Services
Administration
Guardians Waiting Lounge
Elevator Facilities for The Differently Abled Persons
Library
Green Lounge
Canteen
Green Lounge For Dining Purpose
Multipurpose Hall
Used As Exhibition Space
Connected With Outdoor Space
Used As Examination Hall
Gymnasium
Pool Table
Table Tennis Table
Carom Board
Lockers
Assembly Area
Plaza Like Situation
Outdoor Learning Space
Dias
Class Room
Modular Class Rooms in 2 Modules
30
Connected with Open Terrace
Music & Dance Room
Art, Craft & Sculpture Room
Gaming Class Room (Common Room)
Open Terrace Connected Workshop Room
Outdoor Studio
Stimulating Environment
Informal Learning Space
Break Out Space
Breathing Space
Interactive Space (Plaza Like Situation)
Green Bridge Connection
Bridge Connected Open Stairs
Teachers Room
Teachers Open Lounge
Coffee Corner
Lockers
Guest Teachers Open Lounge
Child Specialists Rom
Parents Waiting Lounge
Visiting Counter
Child Counselors Room
Child Researchers Room
Medical Facilities
Prayer Room
Storage
Physics Lab
Dark Room
Lockers
Computer Lab
Photocopier & Printer Zone
Lockers
Teachers Room
Shoe Rack
Play Field
Football Field
Cricket Field
Outdoor Seating Area For The Spectators
31
Gallery Space
Play Court
Basketball Court
Handball Court
Outdoor Seating Area For The Spectators (Under The Banyan Tree)
Gallery Space
Parking Facilities
Bus Parking
Drop Off Area
Canopy Like Drop off Area
Other Supporting Services
Ayas Waiting & Resting Zone
Guards Waiting Zone
Washroom Facilities (Male & Female)
Lockers / Shelves in Changing Room (Male & Female)
Storage
Emergency Exits (Fire Stairs)
Janitors
Duct Room
Rooftop Gardening
32
PROGRAMS SPACE INFORMATIONS Total With
No. of
Sections Functions Number Users SFT/Person Net Circulation
ADMIN Admin Block Person SFT SFT SFT
Principal 1 1 150 150
Attached Rest Room 1 1 60 60
Attached Wash Room 1 1 40 40
Secretary 1 1 250 250
Meeting Room 1 15 35 500
Students Counselor Room 1 1 160 160
Visitors Waiting Lounge 1 12 25 300
Accounts Department 1 2 80 160
Commercial Department 1 2 75 150
Guardians Waiting Lounge 1 30 10 300
Sub Total 2071 2071
TEACHERS Teachers Room 1 60 35 2000
Teachers Open Lounge 1 20 30 600
Guest Teachers Open Lounge 1 16 32 500
Coffee Corner 2 84 2 100
Sub Total 3200 3200
CHILD SPECIALISTS Specialists
Child Counselor Room 1 4 40 160
Child Researcher Room 1 4 40 160
Medical Facilities 1 4 40 160
Parents Waiting Lounge 1 12 16 200
Visiting Counter 1 1 50 50
Prayer Room 1 10 10 100
Storage 1 50
34
a) Librarian Room 1 1 144 144
b) Cloak Room 1 144
c) Stack Area 1 1 144 144
d) Visitors Waiting Lounge 1 16 22 350
e) Book Stacks 14 105
f) Reading Space 11 50 40 2000
Sub Total 2887 2887
Canteen
a) Dining Area 2 50 40 2000
b) Kitchen 600
c) Crockery & Utensils Storage 1 70
d) Food Storage 1 120
e) Washroom Facilities 2 100
f) Counter 1 300
g) Loading-Unloading Bay 1 200
Sub Total 3390 3390
Gymnasium 1 25 80 2000
Sub Total 2000 2000
35
Washrooms 2 144
Changing Room 2 150
Storage 1 150
Sub Total 8968 8968
GRAND TOTAL 78990
Sl. NO.
A. Main Programs Sft SFT
Admin Block 2071
Teachers s Block 3200
Chi l d Speci a l ist 880
Junior Class 10340
Middle Class 14588
Senior Class 11956
Lab Facilities 10800
Multipurpose Hall 2400
Library 2887
Canteen 3390
Gymnasium 2000
Supporting Services 8968
Sub Total 78990 78990
B. Circulation
Lobby & Circulation Area 2000
Parking (13 Cars) & Busing (5 school
buses) 5000
Canopy Like Drop Off Area 1300
Entry Lobby in Multipurpose Hall 1000
Others Transport Movement 8700
Sub Total 19010 19010
C. Green Area
Football Field 7000
Informal Learning Space (Green
Surface) 3000
Outdoor Seating Area for the
Spectators 7000
Green in Bus parking Area 3000
Green Lounge in Library Area 224
Green Lounge in canteen Area 800
Set Back green 2500
Canopial Green in Car Parking Area 4000
Green Area ( Back Side Assembly Area) 2000
Play field Set Back Area 1400
Miscellaneous 2000
36
Sub Total 32670 32670
37
38
39
3.1. LITERATURE REVIEWS
40
Pag
e
41
42
3.2. STANDARD ANALYSIS (FINDINGS & RESEARCH)
43
3.2.1. STANDARD ANALYSIS (INDOOR CLASS ROOM LAYOUTS)
44
45
3.2.2. STANDARD ANALYSIS (INDOOR-OUTDOOR STUDIO LAYOUTS)
46
3.2.3. STANDARD ANALYSIS (BREAK OUT SPACES)
A break out means any space which is open to the end users that is different from their usual
working area. It can be a place for the users to relax, eat their lunch and even hold informal meetings.
Basically schools, institutions, office areas etc. there are seen this type of space.
47
48
3.2.4. STANDARD ANALYSIS (OUTDOOR SPACES)
49
3.2.5. ANALYZING CHILD-FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT
50
51
52
3.2.6. RESEARCH ABOUT THE CHILDREN
53
54
3.2.7. INFOGRAPHICS ANALYSIS
55
3.2.8. ANALYSIS ABOUT EXISTING SUNNYDALE SCHOOL
Sunnydale was established in 1985 by its founding members spearheaded by its late Chairman Abdul
Mannan Khan. Based on the syllabus published by the UK Education Board this institution is aimed at
providing quality education to the society. Dr. Tanvir Ahmed Khan is the Chairman of this school .
Tazeen Ahmed is the principal of this school. At present, Sunnydale is housed in different locations
with classes ranging from Playgroup to Grade Twelve. The future plans include the construction of
school facilities on its own land at Bashundhara. The students are obligated to help those who are
less fortunate. The school believes in the motto ‘Each one for everyone’.
56
57
58
CLASS ROOM LAYOUTS
59
3.3. PRECEDENCE ANALYSIS
3.3.1. (LOCAL)
An English medium educational system is one that uses English as the primary medium of
instruction --- particularly where English isn’t the mother tongue of the students. As a result of
this, in many states throughout the world where English isn’t the predominant language.
There are many English medium schools.
60
61
A) SUNBEAMS SCHOOL AT UTTARA
62
63
64
65
B) SCHOLASTICA SCHOOL AT UTTARA
Th e p r o j e c t w a s o n e o f t h e m o s t l e a d i n g E n g l i s h m e d i u m s c h o o l s a t D h a k a . Th e
s c hool func t i on ed in s c at t ered res ident ial hous es unt il 1999. Th e newl y
c o n s t r u c t e d b u i l d i n g c o m p l e x a t U t t a r a s i t e d 1 a c r e h o u s e s c l a s s f i ve t o A l e ve l
c l as s es wi t h am pl e open s pac e for t he s t udent t o i nt erac t and c i rc ul at e out s i de
t h e c l a s s r o o m s . Th e b u i l d i n g d e s i g n e d b y A r c h i t e c t J a l a l A h m e d a n d h i s
a s s o c i a t e s c o m p r i s i n g i n d o u b l e h e i g h t e d m a i n e n t r a n c e w i t h e l e va t e d g r o u n d
l e ve l , s t a i r c a s e s a n d c o r r i d o r s o f d i f f e r e n t s i z e a n d s h a p e s , i n t e r c o n n e c t i n g
di fferent l e ve l s around t he c ent ral c ourt wi t h c hangi ng panoramic vi e w s .
B e a u t i f u l g r e e n p l a n t s a n d b a r e b r i c k s a t d i f f e r e n t f l o o r l e ve l s a s s u m e t h e
c o u r t y a r d s i d e c o r r i d o r s . P l a y o f e ve r c h a n g i n g s u n r a y s t h r o u g h w i d e a n d
p e r f o r a t e d o ve r h a n g i n g p a r a s o l s .
66
67
68
69
2. SOS Type:
SOS type schools basically a commitment to child- centred care like a mother, a
house, siblings, a village. In the following decades, SOS Hermann Gmeiner’s
(Austrian) life was inseparably linked with his commitment to a family based care
concept with the four pillars of a mother, a house, brothers and sisters, and a village.
70
71
72
3. APTITUDE BASED
The English version school is a system of education in Bangladesh that follows the national
curriculum and based upon textbooks translated from the Bengali language into English. The
academic year is from January to December.
Key Features
73
Fulki is a child’s paradise. It started its journey on 1st January, 1976 as an open type aptitude
institute. The objective was to unfold human qualities, to develop creative faculties and to nurture
intelligence-oriented merit among the children. Simultaneously, it is conducting the cultural activities
for students of other science 2001 that includes literature, music, fine-arts, biographies of great men,
history of civilization and science. Today almost 800 children as direct students of the two centres and
20,000 students of different districts through IECP are linked with Fulki. Fulki is one such private
institution that takes a cultural view of education in its most varied and comprehensive sense with
particular emphasis on cultural inputs essential for proper blos soming of a child’s mind, soul and
individuality. Based in Chittagong, the creators of Fulki thought of the school as “children's cultural
world,” where children are blessed with the right nutrients for mental and intellectual growth.
74
75
76
77
78
4. VOCATIONAL LEARNING TYPE:
Vocational education and training (VET), called Career & Technical Education (CTE),
prepares learners for job that are based in manual or practical activities, traditionally
non-academic and totally related to specific trade, occupation or vocation, hence the
term – vocational education is education that prepares a child to work as a technician
or to take up employment in a skilled craft or trade like tradesperson or artisan.
Vocational education is sometimes referred to as childlike career and technical
education. Vocational goals could include skills needed to find a job, maintain a job,
or perform specific tasks required for the job. The technical and vocational education
and training (VET) for the children is particularly important for promoting economic
development, expanding employment size and improving the quality of employment.
79
80
81
3.3.2. PRECEDENCE ANALYSIS (GLOBAL)
Montessori education involves free activity within a `prepared environment’, meaning an educational
environment tailored to basic human characteristics, to the specific characteristics of the children at
different ages, and to the individual personalities of each child.
“Education should no longer be mostly imparting of knowledge, but must take a new path,
seeking the release of human potentialities.” - Maria Montessori (An Italian child physician,
Founder of Montessori Conceptual Schooling System)
Fuji Kindergarten is a place where young children know how to learn, meet, and discover, but most of
all play their way toward personal development. The Philosophy The oval ring shaped timber roof
floating over interior spaces that mingle with the central atrium area in one unique entity. The concept
is very simple: Children are not forced to stay indoors rather than outdoor or semi-outdoor areas.
82
83
84
85
B) MONTESSORI KINDERGARTEN AT CHINA
immediately become trees and bridges. Continuing staircases and slides spiral up around the "trees",
connecting and activating spaces. "Treehouses" provide private spaces for children to read and do
handwork. So Montessori Kindergarten art China is a iconic kindergarten for the children to have
better interactive and also creative environmental situations. The design of the kindergarten has been
drawing on the Montessori concepts and principles. The third floor provides a combination of indoor-
outdoor activity areas connected by a plastic track. The track is an extension of the centralized atrium
and detaches out various thematic activity areas. Children can move freely and safely.
86
87
88
Page
89
C) EDUARD BALCELLS, DANIEL TIGGES EL TIL·LER SCHOOL AT SPAIN
The school proposing a contemporary spatial expression of the Waldorf-Steiner pedagogy adapted to
a Mediterranean climate. Thus, there are no interior corridors, and access to the classroom follows a
gradual exterior spatial sequence: rambla – courtyard – porch - receiving hall – classroom. The
buildings have no closed hallways, encouraging students to explore the natural surroundings freely.
The volumetric compactness, the semi prefabrication of structure and facades, as well as the direct
expression of the materials, without coatings or claddings, have made it possible to build this school
for a cooperative of parents and teachers within a budget lower than to the average for a public
school with equivalent characteristics.
90
91
92
6. Mixed Type (Montessori & English Medium):
The School has been great blessing for thousands of students as the education here focuses on
moulding the child-body mind and spirit. ... The teaching methodology implemented here is Child
Oriented, the discipline implanted is Nation Oriented and the morality imparted is God Oriented.
Montessori English Medium Primary School. Affiliated to CBSE. Award Winning School.
The school building, distributed into two halves with different heights on the east and west,. The
general plan is an inter-linking mirrored and E-shaped. The West Half uses the obligatory spacing
between classroom rows to create a “valley” courtyard with two curved boundaries. The courtyards
sinking to the underground level, combined with the greenery slope garden, strives for the
underground cultural/sport facilities and canteen space fully illuminated and naturally ventilated.
93
94
95
B) Marlborough Primary School At UK:
Marlborough is a well established, inclusive and welcoming primary school with a full time nursery
with excellent facilities in a very new building. Marlborough is larger than the average-sized primary
school. The proportion of disabled pupils and those with special educational needs supported through
school action is slightly below the national average. The school serves a diverse community; far more
pupils come from minority ethnic backgrounds than is the case nationally. At least 12 different ethnic
groups are represented in varying proportions. Nearly two thirds of pupils speak English as an
additional language, which is far higher than the national average.
This is a good school. They make progress from low starting points to reach the national average in
reading, writing and mathematics by the end of Year 6. The training needs of staff are very well . The
development of their teaching skills assists pupils do well. Pupils in Years 1 and 2 develop a solid
understanding of phonics (the sounds letters make), which helps them become confident readers and
writers as they get older. Pupils are courteous and respectful and play and work well together.
96
97
98
99
C) Summit Elementary School At USA:
Summit Elementary School in far north Austin serves more than 800 students who represent a diverse
population, with more than 20 languages spoken in students’ homes. Interacting with students
globally and learning about different cultures prepares students as world citizens and leaders.Summitt
is part of the Anderson family of schools, which focuses on world languages and cultures. First-
through fifth-graders are exposed to Spanish, German, French and Latin at each grade level as part
of the school’s focus on world cultures. In addition to a rich basic curriculum, the school offers
diversified enrichment activities, including a robotics program with National Instrument as mentors.
Meet and Greets are only for students starting the school year in the face-to-face and purple/gold
models. Students starting the school year in the Ocon Virtual Learning Community will receive
separate back to school information.
100
101
102
3.4 SUMMARY OF RESEARCH:
14 years old
The Age of Consent in Bangladesh is 14 years old.
The United Nations (UN) Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) defines a child as an
individual less than 18 years old, where The Children Act of 1974 defines children as less than 16
years old individuals.)
From the above all precedent studies and standard analysis there has been learnt -
103
104
4.1. CONCEPT FORMULATION (UNDERSTANDING WITH SCHEMATIC
DIAGRAMS.SKETCHES & 3D):
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
5.1. Design Proposal:
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
5.2. Conclusion:
It is undoubtedly meant that the universe acts as our teacher. We can learn a lot of things from the
universe as well as our surroundings. By birth a child should have attitude of exploring the universe in
many ways. Because when a child is born, he/she has a tendency of exploring anything by doing,
learning, understanding and involving in all senses. He /she can have a quest for knowledge and
generates many overwhelming questions. So a child can have access to have thirst for knowledge to
discover the whole universe.
In Bangladesh context, school is recognized as a second home that because when turning from the
greater social institution (Family) a child recognized school just like it. The school always also governs
the children just like a family and trains up them with proper manners in a homely environment.
So in thesis the issue of child friendly stimulating environment in the school has been attempted to
focus that because a good number schools lack that type of environment to nurture the children
properly. Different types of spaces are explored by designing much architectural point of views that
can be favorable to the children to be stimulated. But there is many more limitations to explore the
things physically because of Covid-19 issue. So the thesis is an exercise as an exploration. However
it remains open to the others with different types of aspects and many more new generated ideas.
136
Index:
Discussion 5 Infographics 55
137
Index:
Mixed 93 Solid 53 - 58
OLS 20 Toddler 43
Quiet 49 Zoom 6 - 11
https://www.bproperty.com/blog/bashundhara-residential-area/
https://www.tripadvisor.com/LocationPhotoDirectLink-g186337-d2499942-i442884587-
Chicken_Bazooka-Liverpool_Merseyside_England.html
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/apr/23/creative-schools-revolutionising-
education-from-the-ground-up-ken-robinson-lou-aronica-review
https://www.bashundharahousing.com/
https://wenr.wes.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/WENR-0817-Country-Profile-
SriLanka.png
https://www.facebook.com/groups/123795576316/permalink/10151633119616317/
https://www.adek.gov.ae/en/Education-System/Private-Schools/Curriculum/Bangladesh-
Curriculum
https://www.metalocus.es/en/news/el-tiller-school-eduard-balcells-ignasi-rius-tigges-
architekt
https://mpschool.co.uk/
https://www.oasd.org/page.cfm?p=8951
http://sdgarchitects.com/blog/importance-of-design-in-building-schools
https://educateachild.org/our-partners-projects/projects/children’s-learning-centers
https://www.sos-childrensvillages.org/where-we-help/asia/bangladesh/dhaka
https://educationinnovations.org/topics/out-school-children
https://www.fulki.org.bd/mission_and_vision.php
https://qz.com/1474796/letting-young-kids-play-is-the-best-way-to-prepare-them-for-
school/
https://www.architectmagazine.com/design/the-future-of-school-design_o
https://www.sycol.com/the-most-innovative-schools-in-the-world/
https://www.innovaschools.edu.pe/
https://mmu.ms/montessori-education-vs-traditional-education/
139
140