Chapter 14-Performance Measurement, Balanced Scorecards, and Performance Rewards
Chapter 14-Performance Measurement, Balanced Scorecards, and Performance Rewards
Rewards
TRUE/FALSE
1. An organization’s values statement identifies fundamental beliefs about what is important to the
organization.
7. The most common external performance measure used for all organizations is financial in nature.
10. The segment margin of a profit or investment center includes allocated common costs.
11. The segment margin of a profit or investment center does not include allocated common costs.
13. Profit margin indicates management’s efficiency with regard to sales and expenses.
14. Asset turnover measures the effective use of assets relative to revenue production.
15. Economic value added (EVA) applies the target rate of return to the market value of the capital
invested in a division.
16. Economic value added (EVA) applies the target rate of return to the book value of the assets invested
in a division.
17. Economic value added (EVA) is a more appropriate performance measure when there is a large
difference between the market value of invested capital and the book value of assets.
21. Non-financial measures are generally more indicative of productive activity than are financial
performance measures.
22. Non-financial measures are generally less timely than are financial performance measures.
23. Non-financial measures are generally more appropriate for gauging teamwork than are financial
performance measures.
ANS: T PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-6
24. The number of good units or quantity of services that are produced and sold by an organization within
a specified time is referred to as process quality yield.
25. Total units produced during the period divided by the value-added processing time is referred to as
process productivity.
26. The balanced scorecard approach complements measures of past performance with measures of the
drivers of future performance.
27. Hourly compensation provides a definite link between performance and reward.
28. In a pay-for-performance plan, defined performance measures must be highly correlated with an
organization’s operational targets.
29. Tax deferral is the most desirable form of tax treatment for employee compensation elements.
30. Expatriate workers should receive a compensation package that reflects cost of living factors and
currency fluctuations.
31. Cultural differences between countries may make performance evaluation in multinational settings
more difficult.
COMPLETION
1. A statement that identifies fundamental beliefs about what is important to an organization is referred to
as a ________________________________.
2. Performance measures that provide a focus on the efficiency and effectiveness of production processes
are referred to as ________________ measures.
ANS: internal
PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-2
3. Performance measures that reflect an organization’s ability to satisfy customers better than rival firms
do are referred to as ________________ measures.
ANS: external
8. Profit earned in excess of an amount charged for funds committed to a profit center is referred to as
______________________________________.
10. An indicator that reflects the results of past decisions is referred to as a(n)
________________________________.
11. Statistical data about the steps that will create the results desired as referred to as
__________________________________________.
12. The number of good units or quantity of services that are produced and sold by an organization within
a specified time is referred to as _________________________.
ANS: throughput
13. Total units produced during the period divided by the value-added processing time is referred to as
_________________________________________.
MULTIPLE CHOICE
1. Which of the following statements is true about the values statement of an organization?
a. It is used to formulate the mission statement.
b. It reflects the organization’s culture by identifying beliefs about what is important to the
organization.
c. It focuses on long-range plans for the organization.
d. The values contained in the statement must be quantifiable.
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-1
4. Which of the following responsibility centers may be evaluated on the basis of residual income?
a. investment center
b. revenue center
c. profit center
d. cost center
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
7. A company has set a target rate of return of 16% for its investment center. An investment center
manager in this company would
a. acquire assets that would increase divisional income by more than 16%.
b. sell all assets that do not generate divisional income of more than 16%.
c. acquire assets that would increase sales by more than 16%.
d. acquire any technologically advanced assets that would cause costs to be reduced by 16%
or more.
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
9. The Statement of Cash Flows may be superior to the cash budget as a performance evaluation measure
because
a. cash flows are shown on the accrual basis on the cash budget.
b. the cash budget does not include capital investments.
c. cash flows are arranged by activity.
d. of all the above reasons.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-4
10. The Statement of Cash Flows indicates the cash inflows and outflows from
a. investing, financing, and borrowing activities.
b. operating, investing, and sending activities.
c. merchandising, financing, and investing activities.
d. operating, investing, and financing activities.
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
11. Division A's investment in a new project will raise the overall organization's return on investment if
a. the return on investment on the new project exceeds the target return of the overall
organization.
b. the return on investment on the new project exceeds the return on investment of Division
A.
c. the return on investment on the new project exceeds the overall organization's return on
investment.
d. Division A's return on investment exceeds the return on investment of the overall
organization.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
13. Perry Corporation is composed of three operating divisions. Overall, the Perry Corpation has a return
on investment of 20%. Division A has a return on investment of 25%. If Perry Corpation. evaluates its
managers on the basis of return on investment, how would the Division A manager and the Perry
Corporation president react to a new investment that has an estimated return on investment of 23%?
a. accept accept
b. accept reject
c. reject accept
d. reject reject
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
Profit Margin
Asset Turnover on Sales
a. Yes Yes
b. Yes No
c. No No
d. No Yes
16. Return on investment (ROI) is a term most often used to express income earned on assets
invested in a business unit. A company's return on investment would increase if sales
a. increased by the same dollar amount as expenses and total assets increased.
b. remained the same and expenses were reduced by the same dollar amount that total assets
increased.
c. decreased by the same dollar amount that expenses increased.
d. and expenses increased by the same percentage that total assets increased.
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-4
17. A sub-unit of an organization is evaluated on the basis of its ROI. If this sub-unit's sales and expenses
both increase by $30,000, how will the following measures be affected?
18. Which of the following would be an appropriate alternative to the use of ROI in evaluating the
performance of an investment center?
20. Presently, the Comic Book Division of Anderson Publishing Corporation has a profit margin of 30%.
If total sales rise by $100,000, the net result will be
a. an increase in the profit margin ratio to above 30%.
b. a decrease in the profit margin ratio to below 30%.
c. no change in the profit margin ratio.
d. a change in the profit margin ratio that cannot be determined from this information.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-4
28. A prospective project under consideration by the Internet Division of Communications Corporation.
has an estimated residual income of $(20,000). If the project requires an investment of $400,000, the
a. project generates a negative return on investment.
b. project's return on investment is zero.
c. project's return on investment is 5% less than the company's target rate.
d. company's target rate is 15%
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-4
33. Residual income is used as a performance measure in which of the following types of centers?
a. yes no yes
b. yes yes yes
c. no yes yes
d. no yes no
35. All other things being equal, an increase in sales price would increase
a. asset turnover.
b. profit margin.
c. residual income.
d. all of the above.
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
36. If sales and expenses both rise by $100,000, profit margin will
a. decrease and asset turnover will decrease.
b. increase and asset turnover will decrease.
c. decrease and asset turnover will increase.
d. increase and asset turnover will increase.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-4
38. The information below relates to costs, revenues, and assets anticipated in the Shoe Division of BVD
Footwear Corporation:
Sales $ 4,000,000
Variable costs 75% of sales
Average assets employed $12,000,000
Fixed costs 0
How would each of the following measures be affected if sales rise by $5,000 in the Shoe Division?
ROI Asset turnover Profit margin
39. A division of Watters Corporation reported a return on investment of 20% for a recent period. If the
division's asset turnover was 5, its profit margin must have been
a. 100%
b. 4%
c. 25%
d. 2%
ANS: B
ROI = Profit Margin x Asset Turnover
.20 = PM x 5
PM = ROI/Asset Turnover
PM = .04 or 4%
40. Which measure is limited by the fact that it uses accounting income?
a. ROI
b. RI
c. EVA
d. All of the above
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
41. The Candy Division of Confections Corporation has the following segment information:
ROI = $(450,000/1,800,000)
= 25%
The Block Division of United Toy Company had the following financial data for the year:
42. Refer to United Toy Company. What was the Block Division’s segment income?
a. $150,000
b. $100,000
c. $250,000
d. $ 50,000
ANS: A
Segment Income = ROI * BV of Total Assets
= 0.15 * $1,000,000
= $150,000
43. Refer to United Toy Company. What was the target rate of return for United Toy Company?
a. 10%
b. 15%
c. 25%
d. 5%
ANS: D
Net Income - (Target Rate x Asset Base) = Residual Income
$150,000 - (Target Rate x $1,000,000) = $100,000
(Target Rate x $1,000,000) = $50,000
Target Rate = 5.0%
44. Refer to United Toy Company. If the manager of the Block Division is evaluated based on return on
investment, how much would she be willing to pay for an investment that promises to increase net
segment income by $50,000?
a. $ 50,000
b. $ 333,333
c. $1,000,000
d. $ 500,000
ANS: B
$50,000 / 0.15 = $333,333
45. Refer to United Toy Company. If expenses increased by $20,000 in the Block Division,
a. return on investment would decrease.
b. residual income would increase.
c. the target rate of return would decrease.
d. asset turnover would decrease.
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-4
Boston Company
Illinois Division of the Boston Company has the following statistics for its most recent operations:
46. Refer to Boston Company. Compute EVA assuming the cost of capital is 10% and the tax rate is 40%.
a. $ 90,000
b. $ 150,000
c. $0
d. $ (60,000)
ANS: D
EVA = After Tax Net Income - (Cost of Capital x Market Value of Assets)
EVA = (($2,000,000 * .25) x .60) - (.10 x $3,600,000)
EVA = $(300,000 - 360,000)
EVA = $(60,000)
47. Refer to Boston Company. What is the target rate of return in Boston Company?
a. 25%
b. 20%
c. 15%
d. 10%
ANS: C
Net Income - (Target Rate of Return x Total assets) = Residual Income
$500,000 - (Target Rate of Return * $2,000,000) = $200,000
Target Rate of Return * $2,000,000 = $300,000
Target Rate of Return = 15%
48. Refer to Boston Company. If Boston Company evaluates its managers on the basis of return on
investment, the manager of Illinois Division would invest in a project costing $100,000 only if it
increased net segment income by at least
a. $10,000.
b. $15,000.
c. $20,000.
d. $25,000.
ANS: D
$100,000 * .25 = $25,000
50. The Vinyl Division of Plastic Products Company is considering an investment in a new project. The
project has an estimated cost of $1,000,000. If Plastic Products Company has a target rate of return of
12%, how large does the return on investment on this project need to be to generate $150,000 of
residual income?
a. 15%
b. 12%
c. 25%
d. 27%
ANS: D
(ROI x Total Assets) - (Target Rate x Total Assets) = Residual Income
(ROI x $1,000,000) - (0.12 x $1,000,000) = $150,000
(ROI x $1,000,000) = $270,000
ROI = 27%
51. In the North Division of Orient Company, segment income for the most recent year exceeded residual
income by $15,000. Also, return on investment exceeded the target rate of return by 10%. What was
the level of investment in the North Division for the most recent year?
a. $ 15,000
b. $100,000
c. $150,000
d. An answer can't be determined from this information.
ANS: C
$15,000/0.10 = $150,000
ADR Company
ADR Co. has established a target rate of return of 16% for all divisions. For the most recent year,
Division D generated sales of $10,000,000 and expenses of $7,500,000. Total assets at the beginning
of the year were $5,000,000 and total assets at the end of the year were $7,000,000.
52. Refer to ADR Company. In the most recent year, what was Division D's residual income?
a. $ 960,000
b. $1,380,000
c. $1.540,000
d. $1,700,000
ANS: C
Residual Income = $(10,000,000 - 7,500,000) - ((.16) * $6,000,000)
= $(2,500,000 - 960,000)
=$1,540,000
53. Refer to ADR Company. For the most recent year, what was Division D's return on investment ?
a. 20.83 %
b. 35.71 %
c. 41.67 %
d. 50.00 %
ANS: C
ROI = Net Income/Average Total Assets
= $(2,500,000/6,000,000)
= 41.67%
54. The Movie Division of Media Company reported the following results for a recent year
Sales $8,000,000
Expenses 6,250,000
Total assets (1/1) 5,000,000
Total assets (12/31) 5,400,000
55. The Movie Division of Media Company reported the following results for a recent year
Sales $8,000,000
Expenses 6,250,000
Total assets (1/1) 5,000,000
Total assets (12/31) 5,400,000
56. Wrigley Division of Chicago Delights, is evaluated based on residual income generated. In the most
recent year, the Wrigley Division generated a residual income of $2,000,000 and net income of
$5,000,000. The target rate of return for all divisions of Chicago Delights is 20%. What was the return
on investment for the Wrigley Division?
a. 40%
b. 13%
c. 20%
d. 33%
ANS: D
(Net Income) - (Target Rate x Total Assets) = Residual Income
($5,000,000) - (0.20 x Total Assets) = $2,000,000
(0.20 x Total Assets) = $3,000,000
Total Assets = $15,000,000
ROI = (5,000,000/15,000,000)
ROI = 33%
58. Relative to qualitative performance measures, quantitative performance measures are less
a. subject to manipulation.
b. dependent on accounting information.
c. effective in the pursuit of organizational goals.
d. subjective.
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-6
59. Improved effectiveness and efficiency of a product is considered a ______ performance measurement?
a. subjective
b. financial
c. quantitative
d. qualitative
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-6
60. Non-financial performance measures (NFPMs) are better than financial measures in that NFPMs
a. provide a better indication of customer satisfaction.
b. may better predict the direction of future cash flows.
c. directly measure how well an organization does those things that create shareholder value.
d. all of the above
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-6
61. In selecting non-financial performance measures managers should choose measures that reflect
a. qualitative characteristics that point out sub-optimization activities and throughput
bottlenecks.
b. both short-term and long-term measures related to critical success factors.
c. long-term supplier satisfaction levels.
d. short-term financial viability.
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-6
63. Which type of financial measure better predicts the direction of future cash flows?
a. yes yes
b. yes no
c. no no
d. no yes
64. Which of the following would be classified as a non-financial critical success factor?
a. no no no yes
b. yes no no no
c. yes yes yes yes
d. yes yes no yes
65. Which of the following is necessary for any valid performance measurement?
a. It must be part of the financial accounting system in use.
b. It must be quantifiable.
c. Goal congruence must be promoted by its use.
d. It must be financial in nature.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-3
71. When inventory sits idle in a department, this would not affect the department's
a. processing time.
b. throughput.
c. process quality yield.
d. dollar days.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-7
73. Holding total production in units constant, as the proportion of defective units to total units declines,
all of the following measures will be affected, except
a. total unit sales.
b. throughput.
c. process quality yield.
d. process productivity.
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-7
75. Which of the following would not be an appropriate cost driver to measure internal failure?
a. design error
b. product failure
c. machine reliability
d. operator error
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-7
76. When assessing performance, one way to compensate for differences among divisions of a
multinational organization would be for the parent company to
a. use different target rates of return to compute residual incomes.
b. modify the return on investment calculation so that foreign currency fluctuations are
removed from all financial statement figures.
c. classify all domestic divisions as investment centers and all foreign divisions as profit
centers.
d. use financial performance measures for units whose records are kept in the domestic
currency and non-financial measures for units whose records are kept in a foreign
currency.
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Moderate OBJ: 14-10
Laredo Company
x x = 1. units
PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-7
a. 50%
b. 75%
c. 80%
d. 125%
ANS: C
= 80%
Beaumont Company
One of the products manufactured by Beaumont Company is a plastic disk. The information below
relates to the Disk Production Department:
79. Refer to Beaumont Company. What is the process quality yield in the Disk Production Department?
a. 75%
b. 44%
c. 80%
d. 125%
ANS: C
= 80%
80. Refer to Beaumont Company. What is the throughput per hour in the Disk Production Department?
a. 470 units
b. 500 units
c. 625 units
d. 667 units
ANS: B
x x = 500 units
= 833 units
a. yes no no yes
b. no yes yes no
c. no yes no yes
d. yes yes yes yes
87. On a balanced scorecard, which of the following would be most appropriate to measure customer
service?
a. Rapid time-to-market of new products
b. Corporate financial profits
c. On-time delivery
d. Decrease in reworked products
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-8
88. On a balanced scorecard, which of the following would be most appropriate to measure production
process integrity?
a. Rapid time-to-market of new products
b. Corporate financial profits
c. Low employee turnover
d. Decrease in reworked products
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-8
89. On a balanced scorecard, which of the following would be most appropriate to measure innovation:
a. Rapid time-to-market of new products
b. Corporate financial profits
c. On-time delivery
d. Manufacturing cycle efficiency
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-8
90. On a balanced scorecard, which of the following would be most appropriate to measure financial
performance?
a. Market share
b. Customer retention
c. Percentage of sales from new products
d. Investment in intellectual capital
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-8
92. Which of the following would not normally affect the compensation strategy of a firm?
a. organizational goals
b. location of firm
c. competition
d. number of subsidiaries
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-9
95. Which of the following steps in the performance reward plan model comes before the others listed?
a. set performance rewards
b. identify performance measures
c. determine reward
d. identify critical success factors
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-9
100. Which of the following pay plans encourages the improvement of the overall company's well-being?
a. monthly salary
b. cafeteria plan
c. profit sharing
d. pensions
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-9
102. Which performance plan best promotes quality of the product or service?
a. piece rate
b. health insurance
c. pensions
d. profit sharing
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-9
104. A pay plan that gives an employee cash or stock equal to the difference between some specified stock
price and the quoted market price at some future time period is
a. stock appreciation rights.
b. an ESOP.
c. profit sharing.
d. merit pay.
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-9
108. A pay plan that does not encourage the overall company good is
a. profit sharing.
b. an employee stock option plan.
c. contingent pay.
d. monthly salary.
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Easy OBJ: 14-9
SHORT ANSWER
ANS:
a. The purpose of EVA is to more directly align the interests of common shareholders and
managers.
b. EVA = A/Tax profit - (market value of invested capital x cost of capital %).
c. EVA uses after-tax profit, cost of capital and market value of assets invested. RI uses segment
income, target rate of return and book value of assets invested.
d. EVA is a better performance measure than RI, because it recognizes that there may be a
significant difference between book value and market value of assets. The market value of a
company is reflected in stock prices which are another measure of performance evaluation.
e. EVA includes the increased investment immediately even though significant income may not
occur until sometime in the future. Most investments will show decreased short-term
performance (EVA) and may cause a company to refuse projects that are profitable in the long-
term (similar to shortcomings of the payback method).
2. What items affect comparability of different divisions within the same company on the basis of EVA,
ROI and RI?
ANS:
a. Each measure is based on accounting income which can be manipulated in the short-term by
accounting methods used, which can differ between investment centers.
b. The measurement of the asset base is affected by the choice of what to include, and may
include items that relate to decisions made by prior managers.
c. All measures focus primarily on how well the segments do in isolation with results compared
to prior years for the same segment, rather than relative company-wide objectives.
3. Why is it likely that a subordinate manager would be more attentive to certain performance measures
than overall corporate objectives to guide his decision making?
ANS:
Managers are evaluated based on how their actual results compare to specific measures of
performance. These performance measures are intended to be surrogates for the overall corporate goals
as they apply to specific managers. Thus performance measures are selected by the extent to which
they are good proxies for corporate goals (that is the extent to which they operationally define, and are
consistent with, corporate goals) and are intended to be major focal points for managers.
4. What are some of the major problems associated with accrual-based accounting performance
measures?
ANS:
There are two major problems with accrual-based accounting numbers. The first problem is that they
can be easily manipulated by managers. For example, the timing of end of period transactions can be
accelerated or delayed to affect performance measures. Secondly, accounting measures cannot capture
all corporate goals. Accounting measures are particularly inappropriate to measure qualitative changes
in the workforce, qualitative changes in products, and achievement of social and non-monetary
objectives. Additionally, accounting measures reflect only a short-term perspective of operations rather
than a long-range goal orientation.
ANS:
The advantage of ROI measure over RI is that ROI facilitates a comparison of organizational sub-units
of differing sizes. Because ROI is a performance measure that automatically scales for size, large and
small sub-units can be compared to each other (subject to all the factors that should be considered
when two units in different industries, different geographical areas, etc. are compared).
6. How can return on investment result in sub-optimization when it is used as a performance measure?
ANS:
Because performance measures are used to reward performance, managers use them as decision
criteria when they evaluate alternative courses of action. For example, if ROI is the performance
criterion, a division manager will only invest in new projects that will result in an increase in his/her
division's ROI. This is sub-optimal if the overall organization would be better off by the division
manager's investment in available projects with lower ROIs.
ANS:
Residual income is the remainder of net profit once a target cost of capital has been taken into
consideration. Residual income is determined by deducting from net income a prescribed or imputed
interest charge on assets. This method allows an organization to use different rates of interest for
various organizational assets. A main advantage of using RI is that it overcomes some limitations of
ROI (sub-optimization).
ANS:
Net income and investment involved can both be calculated several ways. Multiple calculations are
often presented to show the different factors that affect ROI, changes in sales, expenses, and capital
investments.
ANS:
Flexible budgets are important to managers in performing a variety of functions. Formulating budgets
commits certain activities agreed to during the planning process to specific monetary amounts. The
flexible budget provides the means to estimate costs at various levels of activity. The control function
is undertaken to assure that actual operations meet planned operations. Through this function,
deviations are determined and variances can be ascertained. Managers also use flexible budgets in
performance evaluation. Evaluation is more meaningful with valid and accurate data to make the
process of evaluation beneficial to all involved.
ANS:
The steps are in the following order:
1. set strategic goals
2. identify the critical success factors
3. set the compensation strategy
4. identify performance measures
5. set performance rewards
6. measure/monitor performance
7. determine rewards
ANS:
Employees should be encouraged by compensation plans to perform and be loyal to the organization.
Performance measures should be related to a company's operational targets. These performance
measures do not have to be evenly weighted. Management can assign higher weights to more
important performance measures as they are related to the corporate goals.
12. Discuss the rethinking taking place regarding the time frame used in American business performance
systems.
ANS:
Historically, American time frames for performance has been short term, often only one year.
Presumably management tries to do what is best for the firm and its owners. Thus, shareholder wealth
maximization should be the primary focus of management. Short term profit maximization does not
necessarily result in long-run shareholder wealth maximization.
To encourage this different attitude, employees and management are being asked to take a longer run
perspective. This is enhanced with employee stock ownership in their firm.
13. Deferred compensation techniques are currently used in the American work place. What are they and
how do they benefit the employer and the employee?
ANS:
Deferred compensation is pay that was earned on current performance but is paid later to the
employee. The compensation may include profit sharing plans, pensions, and stock-based plans like
ESOPs. The payment by the employer can be deducted currently for tax purposes but the employee
does not recognize it as income until it is received. In stock option plans, earnings in the plan are not
taxable to the employee until the plan is distributed. Size of the plans are affected by the firm's stock
value and encourage employees to take a more positive attitude about the company's future.
ANS:
1. The measures should be established to assess progress toward the organizational mission
and its related goals and objectives.
2. The persons being evaluated should be aware of the measurements used and have some
input in developing them.
3. The persons being evaluated should have the appropriate skills, equipment, information, and
authority to be successful under the measurement system.
4. Feedback of accomplishment should be provided in a timely and useful manner.
5. The system should be flexible to adapt to new conditions in the organizational environment.
15. What are five advantages that nonfinancial performance measures have over financial performance
measures
ANS:
Answers will vary on this. The major advantages are listed below:
PROBLEM
Cake Division
The Cake Division is one of the operating units of Baking Solutions, Inc. The following operating
data of the division is presented below:
Sales $3,000,000
Profit margin 10%
Target return 15%
Residual income $ 60,000
1. Refer to the Cake Division. What was the segment income of the Cake Division for the year?
ANS:
Segment income = Profit Margin * Sales = .10 * $3,000,000 = $300,000
2. Refer to Cake Division. What was the return on investment for the Cake Division?
ANS:
ROI = Segment Income/Assets
Segment Income = $3,000,000 * .10 = $300,000
Assets = ($300,000 - $60,000)/.15 = $1,600,000
ROI = $300,000/$1,600,000 = 18.75%
Eastern Division
The Eastern Division of Illinois Chemical Co. produced the following operating results for the
previous year:
Sales $10,000,000
Segment income 1,500,000
Assets 6,000,000
The Eastern Division is considering a $1,000,000 investment in a new project. The Eastern Division
estimates that its return on investment (for all of its operations) would be at 22% with the new
investment.
3. Refer to Eastern Division. How much net segment income is the new project expected to produce?
ANS:
the total of the new segment income = .22($6,000,000+$1,000,000) =
.22($7,000,000) = $1,540,000
the portion of the total segment income that is produced by the new project =
$1,540,000 - $1,500,000 = $40,000
4. Refer to Eastern Division. If the manager of the Eastern Division is evaluated on return on investment
alone, will the manager invest in the new project? Explain.
ANS:
The manager would not invest in the new project because the new project would lower the Division's
ROI from the current 25% ($1,500,000/$6,000,000) to 22%. The new project only generates an ROI of
4% ($40,000/$1,000,000)
a. Compute the sales level that would generate a 20% return on investment.
b. Assuming the rate of return is 15%, determine the level of sales that would generate $200,000
of residual income.
ANS:
a. The required net income = 20% x $4,000,000 = $800,000.
6. The following information is given for Apple and Banana Divisions of Fraternity Corporation.
Apple Banana
Sales $600,000 $300,000
Var. cost of goods sold 200,000 150,000
Fixed manufacturing costs 50,000 40,000
Variable selling 30,000 5,000
Fixed admin. (50% allocated) 20,000 4,000
Fixed selling (20% allocated) 50,000 30,000
Assets at book value 600,000 500,000
a. If Fraternity Corporation uses income to evaluate division managers, compute net income that
should be used for that purpose given the limited data above.
b. If Fraternity Corporation uses ROI to evaluate division managers and uses historical cost as the
investment base, compute the ROI for Apple and Banana.
ANS:
a. Apple Banana
Sales $600,000 $300,000
CGS (250,000) (190,000)
Gross Margin $350,000 $110,000
Variable selling (30,000) (5,000)
Fixed admin (10,000) (2,000)
Fixed selling (40,000) (24,000)
Controllable income $270,000 $ 79,000
b. Apple Banana
$270,000 / $800,000 $79,000 / $600,000
= 33.75% = 13.17%
Fruit Vegetable
Net income $ 60,000 $100,000
Capital investment $400,000 $500,000
a. If Wholesome Foods Company charges each division 12% for capital employed, compute
residual income for the Fruit and Vegetable divisions.
b. Compute the ROI for each division.
ANS:
a. Fruit Vegetable
Net income $60,000 $100,000
Interest charge (48,000) (60,000)
Residual income $12,000 $ 40,000
8. Integrated Furniture Systems (IFS), a division of Adams Corporation buys and installs modular office
components. For the most recent year, the division had the following performance targets:
Actual information concerning the company's performance for last year follows:
Required:
a. For IFS, compute the segment margin and the average assets for the year.
b. Based on segment margin and average assets, compute the profit margin, asset turnover and
ROI.
c. Evaluate the ROI performance of IFS.
d. Using your answers from part b., compute the residual income of IFS.
e. Compute the EVA of IFS. Why are the EVA and RI levels different?
f. Based on the data given in the problem, discuss why ROI, EVA and RI may be inappropriate
measures of performance for IFS.
ANS:
a. Sales $9,000,000
Variable costs (3,650,000)
Direct fixed costs (4,770,000)
Segment margin $ 580,000
c. The target ROI for the division was 2.5 x 6 = 15%. The division generated an ROI of only
13%. Thus the division did not achieve its target rate of return. The poor performance resulted
from the divisions failure to achieve its targeted asset turnover.
EVA and RI differ for three reasons. First, RI is based on pre-tax rather than after-tax income. Second,
RI is based on the book value of investment, whereas EVA is based on the market value of investment.
Third, the target rates of return differ between the methods.
f. ROI, RI and EVA are measures of short-term performance. These measures may be particularly
inappropriate for divisions that have long-term missions (such as high growth). In this case, the
relatively large growth and assets of IFS from the beginning of the period to the end of the
period may indicate this division is oriented to growth. If so, the ROI, RI and EVA measures
will provide an incentive contrary to the growth mission.
9. The Cute Corporation produces small plastic dolls in its Florida manufacturing plant. The company is
currently evaluating ways to improve productivity. The accountant of the firm's parent organization
suggested that management implement a new compensation plan based on throughput performance
measure as an incentive to increase productivity. To demonstrate how such a measure might work, the
accountant gathered the following production data for a recent month:
ANS: