Unit 3: Written By: Dr. Muhammad Ajmal Chaudhry Reviewed By: Dr. Naveed Sultana
Unit 3: Written By: Dr. Muhammad Ajmal Chaudhry Reviewed By: Dr. Naveed Sultana
STUDENT MOTIVATION
79
Unit Contents
3.1 INTRODUCTION
3.2 OBJECTIVS
3.9 EXERCISE
3.11 REFERENCES
80
3.1 INTRODUCTION
In an ideal classroom, students pay attention, ask questions and want to learn. They do their
assignments without complaint and study without being persuaded and flattered. But, teachers
often have students who don’t seem motivated to work on the classroom tasks set out for them.
“They aren’t successful with every student, but with a positive approach to motivation, they can
influence many.” (Kauchak & Eggen, 2004) Therefore, teachers contribute a great deal to students’
desires to learn and to take responsibility for their learning.
Motivation is a crucial element to the learning process. Many researches clearly show a
positive correlation between motivation and achievement. Some students are highly motivated to
learn, and this interest continues throughout their years at school. Some other students, particularly
adolescents, see what happened at school as having no functional relevance to their lives. They
become increasingly bored, particularly with academic task and are generally uninterested in
anything that happens in the classroom. Teachers should recognize that there is tremendous
variation in the level of energy and interest students bring to the classroom activities.
“Some students are easy to teach because they are excited about learning and responsive
to the teacher’s idea. While, the others are completely unmotivated by what happens in the
classroom and have no interest in schoolwork.” (Krause, et. al, 2003)
Therefore, it is important for a teacher to be truly effective to help their students feel
motivated to learn and to achieve. A teacher must go beyond the materials and processes typically
used to stimulate and understand the underlying elements involved in the motivation to learn.
Teachers explain the differing motivational level among their students in ways that reflect
their own personal philosophy of learning and teaching. Some focus on the place of reward and
punishment in motivating students to learn. Other teachers are more concerned with students’
expectation of success, or the way in which they attribute failure.
“Factors that can also influence students’ motivation to learn include their observation of
peer achieving success or failure, their ability to regulate their own behavior and their need for
personal fulfillment.” (Krause, et. al, 2003)
81
3.2 OBJECTIVES
After the completion of the unit you will be able to:
Define and clarify the concept of motivation.
Identify the types of motivation.
Describe difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation.
Explain different theories of motivation.
Explain strategies that can increase motivation
“The term motivation refers to the arousal of tendency to act to produce one or more
effect”Allport (1935 )
82
The word motivation refers to getting someone moving. When we motivate ourselves or
someone else, we develop incentives or we set up conditions that start or stop behavior.
In education, motivation deals with the problem of setting up conditions so that learners
will perform to the best of their abilities in academic settings. We often motivate learners by
helping them develop an expectancy that a benefit will occur as a result of their participation in an
instructional experience.
Motivation is concerned with the factors that stimulate or inhibit the desire to engage in
behavior. It involves the processes that energize, direct and sustain behavior. It can be thought of
as an internal process that activates guides and maintains behavior overtime.
According to Krause, K.L, Bochner, S, & Duchesne, S(2003): “The concept of motivation
is linked closely to other constructs in education and psychology such as constructs of attention,
needs, goals and interests which are all contribute to stimulating students’ interest in learning and
their intention to engage in particular activities and achieve various goals.”
Baron, and Schunk, (1992) stated that “The definition of motivation is the force that energizes and
directs a behavior towards a goal.”
Tan O.S., Parsons, R.D., Hinson, S.L, & Brown, D.S, (2003) stated that “The concept of
motivation as applied when a person is energized to satisfy some need or desire. The person will
engage in, or be attracted toward activities that are perceived as having the potential to meet this
need or desire.”
3.4 Types of Motivation
Following are the types of motivation: extrinsic motivation and intrinsic motivation
Positive Motivation
This brings about positive response to the action that one needs to undertake in order to achieve
these goals.
Negative Motivation
It is being reinforced with fear, anxiety and such negative feelings in order to have tasks
and goals achieved.
83
Negative and Positive motivational forces could include coercion, desire, fear, influence is
framed, they could be either negative or positive forces that act as actuators. For instance a fear
(negative force) of bodily injury could be a motivation to implement the use of safety equipment
(positive force).
Extrinsic Motivation
Motivation is concerned with the factors that stimulate or inhibit the desire to engage in
behavior. Teachers use extrinsic motivation to stimulate learning or encourage students to perform
in a particular way. It is one of the most powerful motivations. It is operative when an individual
is motivated by an outcome that is external or somehow related to the activity in which she or he
is engaged. In other words, “Extrinsic motivation refers to rewards that are obtained not from the
activity, but as a consequence of the activity.”(Morris &Maisto, 2002)
This motivation arises from the use of external rewards or bribes such as food, praise, free time,
money or points toward an activity. These incentives are all external, in that they are separate from
the individual and the task.
Example: a child may does chores not because he enjoys them but because doing so earns an
allowance and students who are extrinsically motivated may study hard for a test in order to obtain
a good grade in the course.
Extrinsic motivation refers to motivation that comes from outside an individual. The
motivating factors are external, or outside, rewards such as money or grades. These rewards
provide satisfaction and pleasure that the task itself may not provide.
An extrinsically motivated person will work on a task even they have little interest in it
because of the anticipated satisfaction they will get from some reward. The rewards can be
something as minor as a smiley face to something major like fame or fortune. For example, an
extrinsically motivated person who dislikes math may work hard on a math equation because he
wants the reward for completing it. In the case of a student, the reward would be a good grade on
an assignment or in the class.
Extrinsic motivation does not mean, however, that a person will not get any pleasure from
working on or completing a task. It just means that the pleasure they anticipate from some external
reward will continue to be a motivator even when the task to be done holds little or no interest. An
84
extrinsically motivated student, may dislikes an assignment, may finds it boring, or has no interest
in the subject, but the possibility of a good grade will be enough to keep the student motivated in
order for him or her to put forth the effort to do well on a task.
Intrinsic motivation
The motivation arises from internal factors such as a child’s natural feeling of curiosity,
exigent, confidence and satisfaction when performing a task. People who are involved in a task
because of intrinsic motivation appear to be engaged and even consumed, since they are motivated
by the activity itself and not some goal that is achieved at the end or as a result of the activity.
Intrinsic motivation is the ultimate goal in education at every level.
Example: Children play game for no other reward than the fun they get from the game itself or
students who are intrinsically motivated may study hard for a test because he or she enjoys the
content of the course.
Attribute their educational results to internal factors that they can control (e.g. the amount
of effort they put in),
Believe they can be effective agents in reaching desires goals (i.e. the results are not
determined by luck),
Are interested in mastering a topic, rather than just rote-learning to achieve good grades.
85
3.5 THEORIES OF MOTIVATION
Different psychological perspectives explain motivation in four different ways. Let us
explore four of these perspectives; behavioral, humanistic, cognitive and social.
The Behavioral Perspective
According to the behaviorist view of learning, when children are rewarded with praise and
a gold star for doing their job correctly, they will look forward to the next mathematics lesson,
anticipating another rewards. At some time in the past, they must have been rewarded for similar
achievements and this experience acts as a motivator for future learning of a similar type.
For behaviorists, motivation is simply a product of effective contingent reinforcement.
So, they emphasize the use of extrinsic reinforcement to stimulate students’ task engagement. The
reinforcement can take the form of praise, a smile, an early mark or loss of privileges such as
missing out on sport.
“Almost all teachers use extrinsic reinforcement in some form to motivate students,
although they may not realize they are doing so and may not always use such reinforcement
effectively.” (Brody, 1992 in Krause, et. al, 2003)
The Humanistic Perspective
The humanist theory of motivation is interesting because it is not only linked to
achievement and education, but also has implications for students’ wefare and well-being through
its concern with basic needs. It stresses on students’ capacity for personal growth, freedom to
choose their destiny and positive qualities.
There are two theories of motivation from humanistic perspective:
86
Figure No. 2: Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
On the other hand, Krause described: “Students who have a need to avoid failure, rather
than a need to achieve success, will look for tasks that are either very easy and have little risk of
failure, or very difficult so that failure is not their fault.”
Motivation in education can have several effects on how students learn and how they behave
towards subject matter. It can:
88
Because students are not always internally motivated, they sometimes need situated motivation,
which is found in environmental conditions that the teachers create.
Based on four perspectives discussed earlier, we can apply the theories of motivation in
classrooms to promote students’ motivation to learn and to achieve. There are several things that
teachers should emphasize in order to apply those approaches:
Behavioral approaches
Remember that reinforcement to increase desired behavior motivates further learning of
this types.
Recognize that student motivation is shaped by previous reinforcing experiences.
Know that students’ maladaptive attribution of success andfailure, including learned
helplessness, can be modified.
Cognitive approaches
Understand the underlying factors in students’behavior, studying students’ carefully and
using a variety of information sources to discover why students behave as they do.
Accept that students are not always motivated to be successful, and that the risk of
attempting to succeed may be overwhelmed by the need to avoid failure.
Realize that motivating students by focusing on increasing mastery in more effective
than emphasizing performance goals.
Be aware of their own biases and how these might affect the way they attribute success
and failure in individual students.
Humanist approaches
Become more concerned with the wider implication of student welfare, not just with
student’s education.
Be aware that some studentsare more concerned with feelings of safety, belonging and
self-esteem than with the demands of the school curriculum.
Understand that students who feel a strong need for group belonging will experience
difficulties and lack motivation to learn if teacher acts in ways that conflict with group
mores.
Acknowledge that teachers’ own beliefs and values can have a major impact on students’
motivation.
3.7 STUDENT MOTIVATION
Make it Real
In order to foster intrinsic motivation, try to create learning activities that are based on the
topics that are relevant to your student’s lives. Strategies include using local examples, teaching
with events in the news, using pop culture technology (iPods, cell phones, you tube videos) to
teach, or connecting the subject with your students’ culture, outside interests or social lives.
Provide Choices
Students can have increased motivation when they feel some sense of autonomy in the learning
process, and that motivation declines when students have no voice in the class structure. Giving
your students options can be as simple as letting them pick their lab partners or select from
alternative assignments, or as complex as “contract teaching” wherein students can determine their
own grading scale, due dates and assignments.
90
sense that the teacher believes the student is not capable of better work. A task that is too difficult
may be seen as unattainable, may undermine self-efficacy, and may create anxiety. Scaffolding is
one instructional technique where the challenge level is gradually raised as students are capable of
more complex tasks.
91
Example of supportive-style teacher behaviors
o Listening- carefully and fully attended to the student’s speech, as evidenced by verbal or
non-verbal signals of active, contingent, and responsive information processing.
o Asking what students want; such as, “which problem do you want to start with?”
o Allowing students to work in their own way
o Allowing students to talk
o Using explanatory statements as to why a particular course of action might be useful, such
as “How about we try the cube, because it is the easiest one.”
o Using praise as informational feedback, such as “Good Job” and “That’s great.”
o Offering encouragements to boost or sustain the student’s engagement, such as “almost”
“you’re close,” and “you can do it.”
o Offering hints, such as “Laying the map on the table seems to work better than holding it
in your lap” and “It might be easier to work on the bottom of the map first.”
o Being responsive to student-generated questions, such as “yes, you have a good point” and
“yes, right, that was the second one.”
o Communicating with empathic statements to acknowledge the student’s perspective or
experience, such as “yes, this one is difficult” and”I know its sort hard to tell.”
o Talking
o Holding or monopolizing learning materials
o Giving the solutions or answers before the students had the opportunity to discover the
solution themselves.
o Uttering directive or commands, such as “Do it like this,” “Start this way,” or “Use pencil.”
o Making statements that the student should, must, has to, got to, or ought to do something,
such as “you should keep doing that” and “you ought to….”
o Asking controlling questions, such as “can you move it like I showed you?” and “Why
don’t you go ahead and show me?”
o Making statements communicating a shortage of time, such as “We only have a few
minutes left.”
92
o Using praise as contingent reward to show approval of the student or the student’s
compliance with the teacher’s directions, such as “you’re smart” or” you are really good at
playing with blocks.”
o Criticizing the students or the student’s lack of Compliance with the teacher’s directions,
such as “No, no, no, you shouldn’t do that.”
93
School’s wide goals, policies, and procedures also interact with classroom climate and
practices to affirm or alter students’ increasingly complex learning-related attitudes and beliefs.
Developmental changes comprise one more strand of the motivational web. For example, although
young children tend to maintain high expectations for success even in the face of repeated failure,
older students do not. And although younger children tend to see effort as uniformly positive, older
children view it as a “double- edged sword” (Ames). To them, failure following high effort appears
to carry more negative implication—especially for their self-concept of ability--than failure that
results from minimal or no effort.
According to Carol Ames (1990, 1992), there are six areas that can influence students’
motivation to learn:
Task students are asked to do.
The strength of our motivation in a particular situation is determined by our expectation
that we can success and the value of that success. To understand how an academic task can affect
student’s motivation, we need to analyze them. Tasks can be interesting or boring for students.
And tasks have different value for students.
Grouping Practices.
Motivation can greatly influenced by the ways we relate to the other people who are also
involved in accomplishing a particular goal. When the task involves complex learning and problem
skills, cooperation leads to higher achievement than competition, especially for students with low
abilities. The interaction with peers that the students enjoy so much becomes a part of learning
94
process. The need for belonging described by Maslow is more likely to be met and motivation is
increased.
Evaluation Procedures.
The greater the emphasis on competitive evaluation and grading, the more students will
focus on performance goals rather than mastery. Low-achieving students who have little hope of
either performing well or mastery the task may simply want to get it over with.
How can teachers prevent students from simply focusing on the grade or doing the work “just to
get finished”? The answer is to de-emphasize grades and emphasize learning in the class. Students
need to understand the value of the work or how the information will be useful in solving problems
they want to solve. One way to emphasize learning rather than grades is to use self-evaluation.
95
Pre-action phase (preparing for task)- take a reasonable risk, work toward goals that are
challenging but attainable, work in manageable, bite-size pieces, take responsibility for
your actions, believe In your own effort and capability, set a plan and work from it.
Action phase- search the environment, ask questions, visualize it (?)
Reaction phase (after one task, preparing for the next one) - use feedback from prior
tasks; monitor your own actions, giving yourself instructions.
3.9 EXERCISE
Read the statements carefully and encircle the correct option.
4. Which of the following are considered to be activities that are intrinsically motivating?
a. Activities perceived as challenging.
b. Activities in which learners feel like they have a sense of control.
c. Activities in which learners feel like they’re likely to be reinforced
d. Activities that have novel or surprising results.
Q3: What are the different factors that influence student motivation?
Q5: Review the key concepts in motivation such as extrinsic and intrinsic motivation and
consider how these apply to you.
Q6: Compare the behavioral and humanistic perspectives on motivation.
Q7: How can teacher’s expectations affect students’ motivation?
Q8: What strategies a teacher can use in the classroom to motivate students?
97
3.11 REFERENCES
Ames, Carole A.(1990). “Motivation: What Teachers Need to know.” Teachers College Record
91,3 (Spring 1990): 409-21..
Condry, J., and J. Chambers.(1978). “Intrinsic Motivation and the Process of Learning.In The
Hidden Costs of Reward, edited by M.R. Lepper and D. Greene. 61-84. Hillsdale, New
Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Krause, K. L., Bochner, S., & Duchesne, S.( 2003). Educational psychology for learning and
teaching. Australia:Thomson.
Lepper, Mark R.(1998) “Motivational Considerations in the Study of Instruction.” Cognition and
Instruction .289-309.
Maehr, Martin L., and Carol Midgley.(1991). “Enhancing Student Motivation: A School wide
Approach.”.
98
Stipek, Deborah.(1988) Motivation To Learn: From Theory To Practice. Englewood Cliffs, New
Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Web links
www.googlescholar.com
www.google.com
www.motivation-tools.com
www.motivation-for-dreams.com
www.wikipedia.org
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motivation
http://www.ehow.com/list_7223299_benefits-extrinsic-motivation_.html#ixzz17og6zjlj
99