CHAPTER 6

Elijah
Summary: Having considered the place of the Blessed Virgin Mary within Carmel, we now
turn to the Order’s other foundational figure, the Old Testament prophet Elijah. Like Mary,
Elijah is considered Patron of the Carmelite Order, and whereas she is Mother and Sister,
Elijah is revered as ‘Father of All Carmelites’. In this chapter we consider some of the reasons
why this is so, and some of the implications for us as Carmelites today. Early Carmelites wove
a mythology which spoke of Elijah as founding a ‘brotherhood of prophets’; this mythology
still speaks to us Carmelites today because Elijah’s example has much to teach us about our
own vocation as contemplatives and prophets.

Window of Elijah at the Carmelite-run National

Shrine of St. Thérèse at Darien, Illinois, U.S.A.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 113 17.8.2010 17:08:17

 114 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

Get prepared: Before reading this chapter, have to hand any materials you might need,
Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

such as writing materials; you might like to summarise each section in your own words,
or to write down your reactions and thoughts on the blank page at the end of the chapter.
Perhaps access to the internet or reference books would help you to follow up points that
interest you. Since Elijah is a biblical figure, it would be helpful to read this chapter with
a copy of the Bible to hand; any translation will do, though the New Revised Standard
Version is widely recommended. Why not begin with the following prayer inspired by
Elijah’s example:

O Lord, the God of Abraham, Isaac and Israel,

you alone are God.
Your servant Elijah lived in your presence,
and acted on your Word.
Help us to drink from the well of his wisdom.
Shelter us in Cherith, and lead us to Carmel,
luring our hearts away from all false gods.
Open our eyes to the needs of those suffering.
Open our mouths to speak comfort and justice.
Open our hearts to your voice in the silence.
Send angels to strengthen us.
Send the rain of your grace to quench our thirst.
Let us break bread with the starving
and bring life to places of death and despair.
Send us as prophets to herald your Gospel.
Allow us to rise to you in paradise.
Those who met your son Jesus saw in him
the spirit of Elijah.
May Elijah lead us to your son.
We ask this in Jesus’ name. Amen.

A ma n li ke us?
‘Elijah was a man just like us’; so says the letter of James (5:17). Anyone who reads the
story of Elijah in the Old Testament’s two Books of the Kings may find that rather hard to
understand, given the dramatic events of his life.
Elijah was the great prophet in the Northern Kingdom of Israel in the ninth century
before Christ, during the reign of King Ahab. Ahab, influenced by his wife Jezebel, had
introduced into Israel the worship of a false God, Baal. This idolatry brought with it the
suffering and repression of the common people. In fighting against the worship of Baal,
and the unjust actions of the king, Elijah – on a mission from God – called a drought
to befall the nation, called down fire, rebelled against the authorities, and stood in the
presence of God himself. Yet Elijah was also a man who ran away from his mission,
terrified of Queen Jezebel’s retribution, who laid down wanting to die, and who hid in a

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 114 17.8.2010 17:08:17

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 115

cave. Elijah was, like us, capable of extremes.

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
As we might say nowadays, Elijah lived life
‘at the edge’.
So what is it about this great man of God
that has drawn Carmelites to adopt him as
one of our patrons? Why did the medieval
friars feel able to enrol him as the first
Carmelite? Was it significant that the first
Carmelite hermits settled in the Wadi ‘ain
es-Siah, a valley on Mount Carmel watered
by the Fountain or Well of Elijah?

Did you know? Elijah is sometimes referred

to by his Latin name Elias, and his disciple
Elisha is likewise sometimes referred to as
Eliseus.

A p a tro n a lon gside Mar y,

the ‘ La d y o f the P l ace’
In the last chapter we read how the
Carmelites had adopted Mary as Patron of
their Order. When a group adopts a patron it
is for a variety of reasons. In part, they want
the protection of having that person ‘on the
board’, someone who will give the group
credibility and an identity. But we Carmelites Many traditional depictions of Elijah – such
wanted more than that when we chose to as this window at St. Edward’s Church,
have Elijah as patron alongside Mary. We Dringhouses, in the English city of York
wanted to trace our origins way back to Old – show the prophet being fed by ravens
during his time in the desert because God
Testament times and to the great prophets
commanded them to do so (1 Kings 17:2-6).
of Israel. We are the only religious order in
the Roman Catholic Church to claim such a
strong relationship with a biblical figure who
predates Christ himself, and the only group
in the Western Church to keep his feast.
We have learned already that the
Carmelite Order over the centuries has
produced Constitutions that help its members
to articulate its identity and mission in a
particular time, and interpret the Rule of
Saint Albert for the present age. The earliest
surviving Carmelite Constitutions date from

An aerial photograph
of Mount Carmel in modern times.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 115 17.8.2010 17:08:21

 116 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

1281, and in that text our predecessors in Carmel traced a line from themselves back
Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

to Elijah and his follower Elisha. In the introduction to the 1281 Constitutions, known
as the Rubrica Prima, the medieval Carmelites explained that they were simply carrying
on the tradition of the ‘brotherhood’ or ‘company of prophets’ (mentioned in 2 Kings 2)
whose original leaders were Elijah and Elisha:

Since some young brothers in the Order do not know how to reply
truthfully to those who wish to know how and where our Order
originated, we want to provide them with a written account of
how to respond to such demands. We say that, on the evidence of
trustworthy witnesses, that from the time of the prophets Elijah and
Elisha, the holy fathers of both the Old and New Testaments have
lived devotedly on Mount Carmel, true lovers of the solitude of that
mountain for the contemplation of heavenly things. There, near the
fountain of Saint Elijah, without any doubt, they lived praiseworthy
lives, and their successors continuously thereafter.

Of course, historians tell us that it is extremely unlikely that there was a physical line
of succession of men living on Mount Carmel from the time of Elijah down to the
thirteenth-century. The Rubrica Prima and the Carmelite traditions that grew up about
Elijah afterwards are myths. But myths are not to be dismissed lightly; they may not be
factually true about the past, but they still contain important truths about the present.
Why bother to construct such a mythical history in the first place?

Stop for a moment: Before reading on, why do you think the medieval Carmelites
claimed to have descended directly from the prophet Elijah and the ‘brotherhood of
prophets’?

The Well of
Elijah in the
Wadi on
Mount Carmel,
photographed
in 2008.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 116 17.8.2010 17:08:24

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 117

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
Te lli ng o u r s tor y
There are two main reasons why the first Carmelites developed a mythical history about
descending from the prophet Elijah.
The first is that they wanted someone whose lifestyle and characteristics we could
emulate. We wanted to be able to say to people “Elijah and Mary are authentic examples
of what a true Carmelite is like.”
The second reason for the medieval Carmelite friars constructing the myth of our
Elijan heritage was that all the major religious orders in the medieval Church had a
founder. Saints Francis, Benedict, Dominic and so on were real people who put their
names to various orders, and to whose memory those orders could turn when they needed
to discern their future direction, wondering whether they were being true to the founder’s
vision. We Carmelites had no such founder. We had also rejected the various religious
regulae (‘rules’) that were around at the time in favour of a formula vitae (‘way of life’)
written by Albert, the Latin Patriarch (Roman Catholic Bishop) of Jerusalem. Having
no founder left us without a figurehead. “Who are these Carmelites?” people asked of us.
So although they aren’t mentioned in our Rule of Saint Albert, we Carmelites chose Elijah
and Mary as our inspirations, referring to Mary as our Mother and Sister, and to Elijah
as ‘Father of All Carmelites’.
And that makes sense when you look at the geographical and historical context in
which the Carmelite tradition developed. There was a long practice of men and women
going off into the deserts of the Holy Land
to seek God in solitude and silence. One of
the first was St. Anthony who lived in the
deserts of Egypt in the third century. Many
followed him in a radical decision to forsake
all and seek the face of the living God in
solitary prayer. They are collectively known as
the ‘Desert Fathers and Mothers’. They had
always regarded Elijah as their great exemplar,
as the ‘first monk’, the template upon which
they drew their own lives. Because Elijah was
seen as the first monk it was only natural that
he be chosen by the Carmelite hermits to be
their patron, particularly since they themselves
lived on Mount Carmel, the place where Elijah
had carried out his great contest against the
prophets of Baal.
It was Elijah’s mythical role as ‘founder’
of the first community on Carmel that the
medieval Prior Provincial of Catalonia, Felip
Ribot, wrote about in his Ten Books on the Way
of Life and Great Deeds of the Carmelites (often
called The Book of the First Monks, after the first
followers of Elijah).
A map of Elijah’s many journeys.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 117 17.8.2010 17:08:25

 118 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

C o nt e mp la tives: s t andin g in the prese n ce o f Go d

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

Of course, we are all called by our Rule of Saint Albert to live a life ‘in allegiance to Jesus
Christ’. But there are a variety of ways in which that can be done, just as there are a
variety of temperaments. What unites all Carmelites, however different they may be
in other ways, is that we are contemplatives by our very nature. Being contemplative
is part of who we are. Contemplation is the unifying element at the heart of Carmel.
Contemplation cannot be earned; rather, it is a gift of God to Carmelites and others who
seek to be open to that gift, and given when and how God wills.
But what is contemplation? Contemplation is often spoken of synonymously with
praying, but that is not the Carmelite understanding of the term. Contemplation is simply
standing in the presence of God with an open heart. And that is exactly what Elijah did.
Come hell or high water, he tried to make his heart always open to the presence of God.
‘Standing in the presence of God’ was Elijah’s catchphrase. He would come up to the
idolatrous King of Israel, Ahab, and say ‘As the Lord lives, before whom I stand, there
shall be neither dew nor rain these years, except according to my word” (1 Kings 17:1).
We should note in this phrase that the first truth Elijah declares is that ‘the Lord lives’.
Elijah then puts himself in second place, in relation to God, ‘before whom I stand’. As
Carmelites our mission, inherited from Elijah, is to declare first the truth that ‘God lives’,
and secondly, that we stand in God’s presence, that is, we are in relationship with God.
Every action and thought of Elijah was done whilst standing in the presence of God.
Elijah thus had a contemplative attitude, and encountered God when he prayed, when
he engaged with his community, and when he served that community. According to the
1995 Carmelite Constitutions, Elijah represents for us Carmelites ‘the solitary prophet
who nurtured his thirst for the one and only God, and lived in his presence’ (§26). All
our Carmelite saints throughout the ages have attested to the fact that contemplation is
the foundation and core of our spirituality. Arising from that contemplation comes our
prayer, our building of community, and our service to the Church and the World.
The task that was before Elijah, and that is facing us as Carmelites today, is to cooperate
with God in becoming contemplative. We can’t achieve it by our own efforts, nor does
God force contemplative grace on us; rather, it is a collaboration between us and God. In
a spirit of vacare Deo (openness to God), we offer God a loving and pure heart (remember
Mary’s purity of heart discussed in the previous chapter), and our heart is filled with God’s
love as a pure gift. This two-way relationship is at the heart of the Carmelite way of life,
as expressed beautifully and simply hundreds of years ago in The Ten Books on the Way of
Life and Great Deeds of the Carmelites (better known as The Book of the First Monks):

The goal of this life is twofold. One part we acquire by our own effort
and the exercise of the virtues, assisted by divine grace. This is to offer
God a pure and holy heart, free from all stain of sin ... The other goal
of this life is granted to us as the free gift of God, namely, to taste
somewhat in the heart and to experience in the mind the power of
the divine presence and the sweetness of heavenly glory, not only after
death but already in this mortal life.
(translated by Richard Copsey, p. 9)

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 118 17.8.2010 17:08:25

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 119

Did you know? In many cultures standing is a mark of respect. Elijah stood in the

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
presence of the Lord, and his words remind us of the Eucharistic Prayer: ‘we thank you
for counting us worthy to stand in your presence and serve you.’ In many Carmelite
communities around the world it is common practice to stand during the Eucharistic
Prayer. This is because before the reform of the liturgy around the time of the Second
Vatican Council, the Carmelite Rite was not Tridentine but rather that of the Holy
Sepulchre in Jerusalem, where standing (which is symbolic of Christ’s Resurrection) is
the tradition, as is common in the Eastern Rites.

Wha t e f f e c t does con t em pl ation ha ve o n us?

We have said that contemplation is simply standing in the presence of God with an open
heart. It is not possible to spend your life standing in the presence of God with an open
heart and not be filled with love. That love touches the world. It is that love which we are
called to show in order to set the world on fire with God’s love.
It is not possible to spend your life standing in the presence of God with an open heart
and not be transformed, albeit gradually, from one degree of glory to another. It is that
transformation that is called ‘divinisation’ – that process whereby women and men realise
their roots in the divine nature because they have been made in the image of God, a God
who became a man and who died for love of us. The journey of formation on which you
are engaged is all about this transformation, this divinisation.
Elijah’s experience of being in the presence of God transformed him, and made him
full of ardent enthusiasm. Elijah’s declaration ‘With zeal I have been zealous for the
Lord, the God of hosts’ (1 Kings 19:10) is the motto we Carmelites have adopted. It is
displayed in Latin on our crest alongside the hand and the fiery sword which indicate the
passion of Elijah whose word ‘burned like a torch’ (Ecclesiasticus 48:1) for the one true
God. Like Elijah, Carmelites carry ‘the sword of the spirit, which is the Word of God’
(Rule of Saint Albert, Ch. 19).

T he S hi e ld of th e Order of Car m el
It is worth taking this opportunity to explore the
symbolism of the Carmelite shield or crest. The
Carmelite historian, Fr. Emanuele Boaga, O.Carm., tells
us that the shield appeared for the first time at the end
of the fifteenth century, on the cover of a book about the
life of Saint Albert dated 1499. The symbol appears in
the form of a vexillum, that is, a sign, standard or banner.
With the passing of time this was modified until the
present form of a heraldic shield was reached. There
has never been an official explanation of the shield’s
symbolism, and therefore different interpretations of it
have been given.

Stop and look at the crest over the page: What do

you currently understand about the symbolism on the Elijah with his flaming sword,
Carmelite shield? set against the Order’s crest.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 119 17.8.2010 17:08:25

 120 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey
Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

At the centre is a stylised mountain whose peak points towards heaven; it has rounded
sides and three gold six-pointed stars, one in the centre of the mountain, the others in
the sky on either side of the mountain. With regard to colours, white and brown appear
together and correspond to the colours of the Carmelite habit.
We can safely presume that the mountain is symbolic of Mount Carmel, where the
Order originated. Thanks to the writings of the Carmelite saints, and the liturgy of the
Order, the mountain has itself become a symbol of Christ.
The lower star is often interpreted as representing the Virgin Mary, Star of the Sea.
The two higher stars flanking the mountain perhaps represent the prophets Elijah and
Elisha. Seen in this way, the stars symbolise the Marian character of the Order and its
Elijan origins.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 120 17.8.2010 17:08:26

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 121

A more recent interpretation is that the two upper stars represent Mary and Elijah,

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
whilst the white star represents us – the Carmelites of today – ascending the mountain
that is Christ. The fact that the stars are six-pointed perhaps is a reminder of the roots of
Carmel (and indeed Christianity) in Judaism.
In the 16th century the shield began to appear bearing a crown above, from which the
arm and sword of Elijah emerge, surrounded by a semicircle of a dozen stars. The stars
are a typical depiction of Mary that recall the apparition of ‘the woman clothed in the
sun, with the moon under her feet and on her head a crown of twelve stars’ (Revelation
12:1). The crown can likewise be seen as symbolising Mary’s queenship, but could also be
a symbol of the Kingdom of God with Jesus the sovereign Lord of Carmel. It is common
also for the Order’s motto – the words of Elijah from 1 Kings 19:10 – to appear above
or below the crest: Zelo zelatus sum pro Domine Deo exercituum (‘I am full of zeal for the
Lord God of Hosts’).
A cross has sometimes been depicted on the summit of the mountain, and is often
associated with reform movements within Carmel. Though this originated within the
‘Ancient Observance’ of the Carmelite Family, a cross on top of the mountain is now
more commonly associated with the Discalced Reform. The Ancient Observance in
Sicily places a Jerusalem cross above the mountain.

Eli j a h: exa mpl e of prophecy an d pro mo t e r o f jus t ice

Returning to the figure of Elijah, he bears witness to the fact that it is not possible to
spend your life standing in the presence of God with an open heart and not be filled with
a deep longing for justice, peace and love to abound in this world, because it is what God
desires. This awareness is what made Elijah a prophet. Prophecy is not so much about
foretelling the future but is rather about telling the truth of the present and speaking out
that truth in the name of God. As it says in the Creed, God the Holy Spirit ‘has spoken
through the prophets’.
Elijah inspires Carmelites to be prophetic. That is why Carmel is dedicated to pursuing
justice, building peace, and upholding the integrity of God’s created world. Elijah is very
much an inspiration to Carmel’s apostolate, including the Order’s presence at the United
Nations as a Non-Governmental Organisation (NGO). We will return to the Carmelite
vocation to work for justice, peace and the integrity of Creation in Chapter 17. Such
work is not simply something we do, but is part of who we are as descendents of the
prophet of Carmel.
Elijah’s prophetic voice on behalf of God’s people was heard not only on Mount
Carmel, but in his condemnation of the king’s possession of Naboth’s vineyard (1 Kings
21). Urged on by his wife Jezebel, King Ahab plotted to have Naboth killed so that
he could take possession of his subject’s property. Elijah was charged by God with the
mission of denouncing this injustice and calling the king to repentance.

Stop and ponder the Scriptures: Read the account of Naboth’s vineyard in 1 Kings 21.
What can Carmelites learn from Elijah’s prophetic stand against corruption?

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 121 17.8.2010 17:08:26

 122 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

Eli j a h: b ri d g e be tween the Ol d and N ew L a ws

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

According to the prophet Malachi, Elijah – who was taken up to paradise in a fiery chariot
– would return to the Earth before the day of the Lord (Malachi 4:5-6). Because John
the Baptist and Jesus spoke with the spirit of prophecy, many contemporaries thought
they might be Elijah come back (see the descriptions of this in Mark 6:15, 8:28, 9:12;
Matthew 16:14). Elijah is an Old Testament personality who figures very prominently in
the New Testament, and he is a bridge between the two.

Did you know? Because Jesus associated his cousin John the Baptist with the prophet
Elijah, and because John dwelt in the desert like Elijah, John the Baptist has a particularly
important place in the Carmelite tradition. We know that some Carmelite statues of
John the Baptist in medieval England depicted him wearing the Order’s habit.

Elsewhere in the New Testament, Elijah is closely linked to Christ in the gospel accounts
of the Transfiguration (Matthew 17:1-6; Mark; 9:1-8; Luke 9:28-36), when Jesus’ divinity
shone through his humanity, and he engaged in
conversation with Elijah (representing the Prophets)
and Moses (representing the Law). In this episode
Jesus is seen as the fulfilment of the Law and the
Prophets. In Jesus everything God wishes to say is
spoken; in Jesus the new Law of God’s Love find
perfect expression. The Covenant of the Old Law
finds its perfection in the New Covenant in Christ,
brought about by his transforming life, death and
resurrection.

Eli j a h: fo re seer of Mar y?

Carmelites have also associated Elijah with Mary.
As we read in the last chapter, the ‘cloud, small as
a man’s hand, rising from the sea’ which Elijah’s
servant saw from the top of Carmel announced
the end of the drought that Elijah had foretold to
Ahab (1 Kings 18:41-46). Many have interpreted
the cloud as a symbol of Mary, arising as pure water
from the salty sea of sinful humanity, bringing rain
( Jesus) so that the land and the people can live again.
Carmelite legend says that Elijah was so moved by
his ‘vision’ of Mary that he ‘founded’ the first hermit
community on Mount Carmel in her honour. There
is no historical evidence for this claim, but it shows
how Carmelites have always given special honour
to Mary and Elijah as patrons of the Order and as This sculpture at Aylesford Priory in
living embodiments of Carmel’s values. Through England depicts Mary and Christ,
such interpretations the medieval Carmelites sought Elijah and Elisha, Simon Stock and
to weave the Order into the history of salvation. John the Baptist.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 122 17.8.2010 17:08:29

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 123

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
El i jah : man o f pure h e ar t
We have already considered Mary’s purity of
heart (puritas cordis). We can also recognise in
Elijah a man of pure heart. When confronting
the prophets of Baal on Mount Carmel, Elijah
asked the Israelites: ‘How long will you go
limping with two different opinions? If the Lord
is God, follow him; but if Baal, then follow him.’
(1 Kings 18:21). As Fr. John Welch, O.Carm.,
observes: ‘A perennial theme in Carmel’s
spirituality is the need to decide which God
to follow. Our tradition was born on Mount
Carmel, the scene of the struggle between the
followers of Yahweh and the followers of Baal.
Elijah encouraged the people to be clear about
their choice of the one, true God. The Carmelite
community as well as individual Carmelites
have had to continually wrestle with the forces
of disintegration and fragmentation brought
about by the pursuit of idols.’

Elijah’s ‘vision’ of Mary in the cloud El i ja h : pro ph e t o f f ire

arising from the sea, depicted
One of the enduring symbols associated with
in a woodcut from the Speculum
Elijah is that of fire. He called down fire that
Carmelitanum (‘Mirror of Carmel’)
published in 1680.
set light to his sacrifice on Mount Carmel (1
Kings 18). Elijah’s worship proved that the
God of Israel is the one true God and that
Ahab and the prophets of Baal had led the
people astray, promoting false notions of who
God is and what God is all about. Looking
through the Bible we see that fire is a symbol
of the presence of God: the burning bush which
Moses was not allowed to approach without
taking off his sandals (Exodus 3); Daniel’s vision
of God whose ‘throne was a blaze of flames, its
wheels were a burning fire’ (Daniel 7:9); John
the Baptist who told the people that the one
coming after will baptise ‘with the Holy Spirit
and with fire’ (Luke 3:16). Jesus himself said that
‘I have come to bring fire to the earth, and how

Elijah’s victory over the prophets of Baal, depicted

in ceramic by Adam Kossowski at The Friars,
Aylesford, England.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 123 17.8.2010 17:08:32

 124 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

I wish it were blazing already!’ (Luke 12:49). The Holy Spirit descended on the Apostles
Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

in what appeared to be ‘tongues of fire’ at Pentecost (Acts 2:3).

There is an ambivalence about fire. It is one of the most destructive forces on earth and
yet it purifies, giving us light and heat. According to the 2003 Rule for the Third Order of
Carmel (RTOC), ‘every Lay Carmelite is like a spark of love thrown into the forest of life:
they must be able to enflame anyone who approaches them’ (§44). This fire gives light
and heat and love, but it also burns away the dross. In St Teresa: Her Life and Times, G.
C. Graham quotes a visitor to Avila speaking of the Carmelites there: ‘Sir, in the eyes of
the flesh they are mad; in those of faith, angels and ministers of fire in fantastic bodies, so
that we, the weak, may see something of the flame which burns in them.’

O h s ti ll s ma l l voice of cal m
Although Elijah is a character associated with fire, with decisive action, and with zeal for
God, he is also someone who realised that God is encountered in silence and stillness.
On Horeb, the mountain of God (also known as Sinai where the Lord’s presence was
manifested in the burning bush), Elijah realised that God does not only reveal himself
through dramatic earthquakes, fires, and winds, but primarily through ‘the sound of
sheer silence’ (1 Kings 19:12). This episode has inspired Carmelites, and others, over the
centuries, to seek God in silent prayer, and to find God in absence.

Stop and ponder the Scriptures: Read the passage from 1 Kings 19 in which Elijah
encounters the Lord in silence. What does this episode mean to you?

In his book on Elijah, The Sound of Silence, the former Prior General of the Order, Fr.
Joseph Chalmers, O.Carm., offers the following reflection on the prophet’s encounter
with God in silence:

The meeting between God and Elijah on Mount Horeb in ‘the sound
of a gentle breeze’ or in ‘the sound of sheer silence’ or in ‘the light
murmuring sound’ has been much used for prayer and meditation
over the centuries. This experience must have been very difficult
for the prophet Elijah because God came to meet him in a totally
unexpected way. God did not come in the earthquake or in the fire
or in the mighty wind, all the ways that God had used previously to
announce the divine presence, but instead God came in silence.
Through the gift of faith we can know something about God but
God always goes beyond our human concepts. The contemplative way
leads to the complete transformation of the human person whereby our
human ways of seeing, loving and interacting with the world, which
are always limited, become divine ways. This is naturally the work of
God but we must do everything in our power to facilitate and accept
this personal and structural transformation. We must learn gradually
who is God. An intellectual knowledge of the fundamental truths of
the faith is important. However, it is one thing to intellectually grasp
what love means, and another thing to know love by experience. The

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 124 17.8.2010 17:08:32

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 125

experience of God helps us to grasp theological concepts in a new way.

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
Often God will surprise us and act completely outside our limited
possibilities. Little by little we have to learn to see everything from
another perspective. Everything may remain the same but may in fact
appear totally different because we have a different way of seeing.
Prayer is in some way relating to God, and so every prayer is good,
and every method of prayer that helps us to grow in our relationship
with God can be helpful. Just as in a human relationship, so also in the
relationship with God, it is very normal for it to become simpler with
the passage of time. We become less and less surprised when God
approaches us in a way that we are not used to. We learn to accept that
we are always at the beginning of the spiritual journey and that God
is always ahead of us.
All prayer, if it is authentic, must be open to contemplation in the
sense that it must encourage the transformation of the human heart.
The Christian tradition gives various suggestions regarding methods
of prayer that have proved their worth over the centuries. After the
liturgy, which is the prayer of the whole Body of Christ, head and
members, comes Lectio Divina, the prayerful reading of the Word
of God. Then we have many devotions approved by the Church. All
these devotions or methods of prayer must be directed toward the
contemplation of God and our own transformation.
(Sound of Silence, pp. 107-08)

Stop and reflect: Elijah’s approach to life was grounded in reality, as was his relationship
with God. When his pursuit by Jezebel and being the only faithful prophet left in Israel
was too much for him, Elijah cried out to God that he wanted to die. He went to sleep
(1 Kings 19:1-8), and in Elijah’s utter desolation, God sent an angel with food. Are we
this honest with God? Do we recognise the angels who come to help us?

Eli j a h i n the Order toda y

Much work is being done to interpret the message that Elijah brings to our world in the
21st century. Since the Second Vatican Council called for religious communities to go back
to their founding documents, and for Christians generally to return to the Scriptures, we
are rediscovering the richness of our ‘Elijan heritage’. In recent years scholars such as Jane
Ackerman have produced excellent studies on Elijah in the Carmelite tradition (listed
in the bibliography below). Other books have encouraged Carmelites to rediscover our
Elijah heritage, such as Richard Copsey’s translation of The Ten Books (Book of the First
Monks) from Latin into English, and Joseph Chalmers’ reflection on the Elijah narratives
in The Sound of Silence.
Not everything Elijah is reported as doing in the Bible (such as the slaying of the
prophets of Baal) makes comfortable reading today, but understood in the context of
his times he can be upheld as a man for all times. An interesting recent development
within Carmel is the way that devotion to him has encouraged interfaith encounter
and dialogue, because Elijah is revered by the three monotheistic religions: Christianity,

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 125 17.8.2010 17:08:32

 126 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

Judaism and Islam. The 1995 Constitutions of the Carmelite Order take this fact as the
Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

starting-point for engaging in dialogue:

In the Scriptures and in Carmelite tradition, the prophet Elijah

is respected as the one who in various ways knew how to read the
new signs of the presence of God and who was able, not least, to
reconcile those who had become strangers or enemies. As Carmelites,
heartened by this example and by our strong desire to put into practice
our Lord’s teachings of love and reconciliation, we shall take part in
the ecumenical movement and in inter-religious dialogue, promoted
by the Second Vatican Council. Through the former we shall promote
relationships with the Orthodox and other Christians. Through
the latter we shall promote dialogue at various levels with Jews and
Muslims, with whom we share devotion to the prophet Elijah as a
man of God. (§96)

Children of the one God, and inspired by Elijah: Carmelite laity and religious meeting with
Muslims at the mosque in the English city of York.

Pa s s i ng o n El i jah ’s m antl e
Elijah was not part of the priestly hierarchy, he spoke his mind, he was zealous for God,
and he did not tolerate half-measures. He was a friend of God, a confidante of the
almighty. Elijah is one of the keys to unlocking the Carmelite charism, and well worth
studying and getting to know as a friend, not only in our initial formation but throughout
our lives as Carmelites. He shows us all how to be contemplatives: people of prayer who
are active in the midst of the world. He was solitary but not confined to any one spot, and
drawn out of solitude to engage with God’s people, such as the widow at Zarephath (1
Kings 17:7-16), Obadiah (1 Kings 18:1-6), and Elisha (1 Kings 19:19-21).
Elijah’s relationship with Elisha is particularly important for Carmelites. We read
in the First Book of Kings that God told Elijah ‘You must anoint Elisha son of Shaphat,
of Abel-Meholah, as prophet to succeed you’ (1 Kings 19:16). Elijah made Elisha his
successor symbolically by throwing his mantle or cloak over him (1 Kings 19:19-21). With

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 126 17.8.2010 17:08:34

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 127

this gesture Elijah transferred to Elisha

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
his spirit, his gifts and his mission as a
prophet. When Elijah finally ascended
to paradise in a whirlwind accompanied
by a fiery chariot (2 Kings 2:1-13) he
again threw his mantle down to Elisha,
confirming his prophetic vocation.

Did you know? Before the Carmelite

cloak became plain white in the late 1200s
(symbolising Mary’s purity of heart and
Christ’s Resurrection), the cloak worn by
the hermits on Mount Carmel used to be
striped. Some medieval commentators
interpreted the stripes as the different
virtues of the hermits. Others said the
stripes were burnt into the cloak when it
fell from Elijah’s fiery chariot!

Carmelites celebrate Elijah and Elisha

with liturgical feasts on 20th July and
14th June respectively. Our tradition
tells us that their gifts have been passed
on through the ‘company of prophets’
who have inhabited Mount Carmel
– physically and spiritually – through
the generations. Living with Elijah
as an inspiration for Carmel, we can
be confident that there will always be
someone who can pass on the Carmelite
tradition to the next generation.

Stop and think: As a Carmelite you are

part of an ongoing tradition, and you
have a responsibility to pass that tradition
Elijah passing on his mantle to Elisha, depicted on to others. How can you encourage
in ceramic by Adam Kossowski at The Friars, someone to consider a vocation within
Aylesford, England. Carmel?

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 127 17.8.2010 17:08:37

 128 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

Conclusion: In this sixth chapter we have considered the role of Elijah the prophet as
Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

an inspiration for Carmelites over the centuries. With Mary he is a model for living
contemplatively, open to God’s word and will in our lives. Elijah is regarded as ‘Father of All
Carmelites’; our appreciation of Elijah is based primarily on what we read about him in the
Bible, and secondarily on the Order’s own traditions.

You might like to conclude your time of study and reflection with a prayer, perhaps in silence,
or pondering a passage from Scripture that relates to Elijah.

In the next chapter we will consider another man who can be considered foundational to
our Carmelite Family, Saint Albert of Jerusalem, whose way of life is a touchstone for all of
us in Carmel.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 128 17.8.2010 17:08:37

 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey 129

I d e a s fo r Ref l ection, Discussion an d A ct io n

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah
yy Reflect – either individually or as a community – on any passage in this chapter
that has stood out for you as significant. There’s much more that could be said about
Elijah, but space in this book is limited; is there anything in particular that you think
should have been included but wasn’t?
yy How would you summarise the chapter and its key points in one or two paragraphs?
yy Do you see any similarities between yourself and Elijah? What do you find attractive
about him? What bothers you about his story?
yy Is Elijah ‘a man just like us’? Would you like to meet him?
yy What ‘false gods’ do we recognise in our lives that weaken our resolve to stand in the
presence of the living God?
yy Why is the link between the Old and New Testaments so important for Christians,
and especially for Carmelites?
yy In what ways is it possible to live Elijah’s radical lifestyle today?
yy Find out what Jews and Muslims say about Elijah. Perhaps make contact with a
local synagogue or mosque and ask if you can visit to learn more about that faith
community.
yy Identify someone you think might appreciate knowing more about Carmelite
spirituality and invite them to a meeting of your community.
yy Who are the prophets speaking God’s truth in today’s society? Do you see yourself as
a son or daughter of the ‘company of prophets’?
yy The work of the Carmelite NGO and other groups within the Carmelite Family are
inspired by Elijah’s example. Consider finding out how you can get involved in their
work.
yy Mendelssohn’s oratorio Elijah is often performed in different places; attending a
performance or listening to a recording might be an entertaining way of enhancing
your appreciation of the prophet.

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 129 17.8.2010 17:08:37

 130 Climbing the Mountain: The Carmelite Journey

Re c o mme nd ed Fur th er Resources

Chapter 6 ❙ Elijah

A number of good resources relating to Elijah have become available in recent years,
which you will find in most Carmelite libraries, or from Carmelite and other Christian
bookshops.

Jane Ackerman, Elijah: Prophet of Carmel, (Washington D.C.: ICS Publications, 2003).
This is an excellent study of the role that Elijah has played in the Carmelite Family over
the centuries.
Emanuele Boaga, O.Carm., Come pietre vive ... nel Carmelo, (Rome: Institutum
Carmelitanum, 1993). This is a very good introductory history of the Carmelite Order,
but unfortunately is not available in English at present.
Joseph Chalmers, O.Carm., The Sound of Silence: Listening to the Word of God with Elijah
the Prophet, (Faversham: Saint Albert’s Press, 2007). In this beautifully illustrated book,
the former Prior General of the Carmelite Order considers all the Bible passages that
relate to Elijah and what we can learn from him today.
Kilian Healy, O.Carm., Prophet of Fire, Carmel in the World Paperbacks 5, (Rome:
Edizioni Carmelitane, Reprinted 2004).
Eugene Kaboré, O.Carm., ‘From Mount Carmel to Mount Horeb: a journey of
transformation’, in In obsequio Jesu Christi: Praying and prophetic community in a changing
world, Proceedings of the 2007 General Chapter of the Carmelite Order, (Rome:
Edizioni Carmelitane, 2007), pp. 25-35.
Fenella Matthew, ‘Living in the Presence of God: Carmelites in the Footsteps of Elijah’,
Mount Carmel: A Review of the Spiritual Life, Volume 57 Number 4, October-December
2009, pp. 9-13.
Tony Mazurkiewicz, O.Carm., ‘The Biblical Elijah: A Model for Spirituality’, Carmel in
the World, Volume XLVIII Number 2, 2009, pp. 90-106.
James McCaffrey, O.C.D., ‘The Heritage of Elijah’ in The Carmelite Charism: Exploring
the Biblical Roots, (Dublin: Veritas Publications, 2004).
Wilfrid McGreal, O.Carm., At the Fountain of Elijah: the Carmelite Tradition (London:
Darton Longman and Todd 1999), particularly chapters 3 and 9.
Craig Morrison, O.Carm., ‘Elijah on Horeb’, Carmel in the World, Volume XLIV Number
3, 2005, pp. 185-191.
Peter Slattery, O.Carm., ‘Elijah’ in The Springs of Carmel, (Homebush: St. Paul Publications,
1990).
Felip Ribot, O.Carm., The Ten Books (The Institution of the First Monks), translated by
Richard Copsey, O.Carm., (Faversham: Saint Albert’s Press, 2005).
The website of the Carmelite NGO: www.carmelitengo.org

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 130 17.8.2010 17:08:37

 N ot es and ref l ectio n s o n C h ap t e r 6

SAP-Formation-ENG-CHP05-06.indd 131 17.8.2010 17:08:37