Incorporating Weather Statistics in Determining Overhead Line Ampacity
Incorporating Weather Statistics in Determining Overhead Line Ampacity
(
R AC = R AC ,293K 1 − α (Tc − 293) ) (1) which the air surrounding the conductor is “refreshed”. The
mechanism of forced convection is described by the following
in which
equations:
RAC is the AC resistance of the conductor at the temperature of
Pc = πλ f Nuδ (Tc − Ta ) (4)
interest [Ω/m]
RAC,293K is the AC resistance of the conductor at room with
λ f = 2.42 ⋅ 10−2 + 7,2 ⋅ 10−5T f
temperature [Ω/k]
Tc is the conductor temperature of interest [K]
α is the temperature coefficient of resistance [K-1]; its value
Nuδ = Nu90 ⎛⎜ 0.42 + B (sin δ ) m ⎞⎟
varies between different types of conductor material ⎝ ⎠
The dissipation losses can now be calculated using the well 0.471
known equation ⎛ ⎞
⎜ vw D ⎟
Nu90 = 0.641⎜ ⎟
Pd = R AC I c2 (2) ⎜ 1.32 ⋅ 10− 5 + 9.5 ⋅ 10− 8T ⎟
⎝ f ⎠
in which
Pd are the dissipation losses [W/m] ⎛ T + Ta ⎞
Tf =⎜ c − 273 ⎟
Ic is (the RMS value of) the conductor current [A] ⎜ 2 ⎟
⎝ ⎠
B. Irradiation in which
The amount of sunlight absorbed by the conductor depends Pc is the heat transfer due to forced convection [W/m]
on the sunshine, the conductor diameter and the absorption λf is the heat conductivity of air [Wm-1K-1]
coefficient of the conductor surface. The following equation Tf is the temperature of the air film immediately surrounding
applies: the conductor [K]
Ps = α s SD (3) Ta is the ambient temperature [K]
δ is the angle of attack of the wind [°]
in which Nuδ is the Nusselt number for a given angle of attack δ
Ps is the absorbed sunlight [W/m] Nu90 is the Nusselt number for an angle of attack of 90°
αs is the absorption coefficient of the conductor surface vw is the wind speed [m/s]
S is the irradiation perpendicular to the conductor surface B and m are dimensionless constants, for which applies
[W/m2] - 0°<δ<24°: B=0.68 and m=1.08
D is the conductor diameter [m] - 0°<δ<90°: B=0.58 and m=0.90
C. Convection D. Radiation
Two sources of convection exist, namely natural The heat emitted from a conductor by radiation depends on
convection and forced convection. Natural convection is the temperature difference between the conductor and its
caused by the heating of the air around the conductor by the environment, the conductor diameter and the emission
conductor itself. This reduces the air’s density. The heated air coefficient of the conductor surface. The following equation
rises, making room for “new” air that can also be heated by applies:
the conductor. On the other hand, forced convection is caused
by the wind that “refreshes” the air around the conductor Pr = πDεσ B (Tc4 − Ta4 ) (5)
much more quickly than the mechanism of natural convection in which
would do. Therefore, at wind speeds above 0.5 m/s, natural Pr is the heat transfer due to radiation [W/m]
convection does hardly play a role, because the air is moving ε is emission coefficient
more quickly due to the wind than it can be heated by the σB is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant, 5.67·10-8 Wm-2K-4
conductor.
The investigation reported in this paper was carried out for E. Heat balance
the Netherlands, and in the Dutch climate, wind speeds lower As stated above, in steady state the heat supplied to the
than 0,5 m/s hardly occur. Therefore, only the effect of forced conductor and the heat it transfers to the environment are
convection will be taken into account here and the effect of equal:
natural convection is neglected. However, the equations Pd + Ps = Pc + Pr (6)
describing the effect of natural convection, which is important By assuming that the conductor temperature Tc in eqs. (1, 4, 5)
when studying line ampacity in climates where complete equals the maximum operating temperature for the conductor
calms occur more regularly or inside buildings, can be found of interest (limited by either sag or degeneration) and by
in [2]. substituting eq. (2) in eq. (6), the current leading to the
The heat transfer from the conductor to the surrounding air maximum operating temperature, i.e. the conductor ampacity,
depends on the temperature difference between the two, the can be calculated with the following equation:
heat conductivity of the air and the conductor diameter. The
wind speed and the angle of attack determine the speed at
4
100 100
80 80
60 60
Angle between
conductor-axis and
40 northern wind direction [°]
40
0
45
20 90
20
Summer
Winter
0 0
600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 600 800 1000 1200 1400
Physical ampacity (A) Physical ampacity (A)
Fig. 3 Physical ampacity of St/Al 23/259 conductor during summer (red) and Fig. 4 Dependence of physical ampacity of St/Al 23/259 conductor on wind
winter (blue) for a maximum temperature of 80°C direction (summer situation) for a maximum temperature of 80°C
off-peak line overloadings is negligible. Taking into account ampacity will be in this region, as otherwise the probability of
irrelevant data for the off-peak period would just distort the overloading will become far too high. In this region, the wind
picture. direction only has a small effect, which can be explained by
From figure 3, it can be concluded that the investigated realizing that wind speed is low anyway. Line orientation will
conductor can always carry at least 600 A, even under the therefore not be taken into account any further.
“worst” atmospheric conditions (high temperature and D. Effect of Redundancy
irradiation, no wind). In other words, the minimum physical
As mentioned above, the probability that the actual line
ampacity of the conductor is 600 A. When the practical
current exceeds the physical ampacity of the line on the one
ampacity is set higher than the minimum physical ampacity,
hand depends on the chosen practical ampacity, but on the
the line could be overloaded. The probability of overloading
other hand also on the degree of redundancy. When a network
can, however, not be derived from figure 3.
is highly redundant, the probability that a circuit becomes
This can be seen as follows. When the practical ampacity
overloaded is very low, because therefore a number of other
would be set at 1050 A, there is a probability of 50% that
circuits would have to fail simultaneously.
practical ampacity will exceed physical ampacity. However,
When a network is completely (n-1) safe, only (n-2)
the probability that the line will indeed be overloaded also
contingencies can lead to overloadings. There exist three types
depends on the probability that the actual current exceeds the
of (n-2) contingencies, namely:
minimum physical ampacity. Periods with low physical
- Failure of one circuit while another circuit is unavailable
ampacity do not necessarily correlate with high currents.
for maintenance
However, generally spoken, the higher the practical ampacity
- Failure of two circuits independently, i.e. failure of a
(which guides system planning and operation) is set, the
second circuit while the first circuit is still unavailable due
higher the chance that at some time the actual current exceeds
to reparation after failure
the physical ampacity and a line becomes overloaded.
- Failure of two circuits due to a common cause
C. Effect of Line Orientation When a network is only (n-1) safe, or partly but not
As can be concluded from eq. (4), not only the wind speed completely (n-2) safe, the following contingencies can lead to
vw, but also the angle of attack δ determines the heat transfer overloadings as well:
from the conductor to the air by forced convection. However, - Maintenance of one circuit
in practice high voltage lines are oriented in all directions and - Failure of one circuit
therefore a given wind direction leads to different angles of Both for (n-1) and (n-2) safety, of course only circuits that are
attack on different lines. In order to investigate whether this redundant to each other are relevant.
effect should be taken into account or not, the orientation of By multiplying the probability of occurrence and the
the conductor depicted in figure 3 was varied for the summer duration of each of the above situations, the fraction of the
situation. The results are given in figure 4. time that the network is in a state in which overloading could
It can be concluded from figure 4 that wind direction occur can be calculated. The probability that the network is in
mainly plays a role at higher physical ampacities. This can be a state in which overloading could occur can then be
explained by realizing that the wind itself is the main cause of combined with physical ampacity graphs, such as figure 3, in
the observed high physical ampacity. However, for the order to find the practical ampacity that leads to the allowed
analysis in this paper, particularly the region with low overloading probability, i.e. the probability that high load,
physical ampacity is of interest, because the practical unfavorable atmospheric conditions and a relevant
6
VIII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Our colleagues Sjoerd Talsma, Gerard Sleumer, Ronald
van Dalen en Koos Swart are acknowledged for their efforts
in the FLI-MAP® project and for making available figures 6
and 7 .
IX. REFERENCES
[1] NEN-EN 50341-3, Bovengrondse elektrische lijnen boven 45 kV
wisselspanning - Deel 3: Verzameling van nationale normatieve
Fig. 6 FLI-MAP® screenshot showing a 110 kV overhead line (purple) aspecten, November 2001 (in Dutch).
entering a substation; the red part is a road below the line [2] Thermal behaviour of overhead conductors, Cigré Technical Brochure
No. 207, 2002.
[3] Rapport inzake de belastbaarheid van stroomgeleiders voor
hoogspanningslijnen, N.V. Samenwerkende Elektriciteits-
produktiebedrijven, Werkgroep belastbaarheid verbindingen, oktober
1971 (in Dutch).
[4] Kostenbesparing binnen handbereik; Gereedschap dynamisch netbeheer
voor bedrijfsvoering en lange termijn-netplanning, KEMA, rapport
PREGO 15, april 2004 (in Dutch).
[5] www.satel-light.com
[6] www.knmi.nl
[7] R. Billonton, R.N. Allan, Reliability Evaluation of Power Systems,
Springer, 1996.
[8] G.J.M.B Clemens, Zuverlaessigkeitsorientiertes Zusammenwirken von
Netz- und Kraftwerksbetreibern im Verteilungssektor, Aachener Beiträge
zur Energieversorgung (ABEV), Band 60, 1st ed., 1999. ISBN 3-
934318-00-2 (in German).
Fig. 7 FLI-MAP® screenshot showing a road (red) and dike forming a local
surface clearance bottleneck in a 110 kV overhead line circuit
8
X. BIOGRAPHIES