SLJMS Final Version - 5th Paper
SLJMS Final Version - 5th Paper
S.S. Pattiyagedara
Faculty of Management
Uva Wellassa University, Sri Lanka
P.I.N. Fernando
Faculty of Management
Uva Wellassa University, Sri Lanka
[email protected]
Abstract
Tourism is one of the main economic sectors as well as a foreign exchange earner to
Sri Lanka. Rural tourism is one of the niche markets catered to rural lifestyles and
events. The study investigated the rural tourism destinations; Hiriwadunna Village
Track, Meemure, and Heeloya Knuckles Valley village, which conduct rural tourism
activities on a regular basis as one of their main livelihood. The objectives are to
identify the impact of destination attributes on visitor satisfaction and assess the
contribution of rural tourism initiatives on the household economy and socio-culture
of tourism stakeholders. Purposive sampling method was conducted with dual sets;
100 foreign and local visitors and 12 tourism stakeholders from a rural community.
Data were gathered through the survey, and structured interviews and study adopted
mixed methods; descriptive and multiple regression with destination attributes (6A’s)
model as quantitative analysis and thematic analysis as the qualitative analysis
method. Findings exhibited a significant influence on the visitor satisfaction of all
destination attributes (6A’s), and ancillary services have highlighted as the most
influential attribute on rural tourism destinations. Further, the thematic analysis
revealed, rural tourism is positively influenced by socio-economic benefits on
residents’ livelihood. As recommendations, (a) promoting sustainable tourism
concepts catering to the niche market of “rural tourism”, (b) folk culture with the
rural tourism experience, (c) mechanism on safety and security of the rural tourism
destinations, (d) strategies to popularize the events catering rural lifestyle and
activities and (e) marketing programmes on sustainable tourism segments, are
provided.
- 87 -
Introduction
Tourism is ranked as the number one industry in the world as compared to its
proportion in the world economy. Tourism is the only service industry to represent a
positive balance of trade with the flow from first world countries to developing
countries exceeding those in the opposite flow by US$66 Million( Dipietro and
Condly, 2007). It is identified as one of the largest and fastest-growing industries in
the globe, and it is high growth and development rate, a considerable volume of foreign
currency inflows, and infrastructure development actively effect for the various sector
of the economy. Besides, it will be affected by the socio and economic development
of the country (Nayomi and Gnanapala, 2015). Currently, Tourism is one of the
booming industry and a major economic contributor in many developing countries,
including Sri Lanka. Sri Lanka is known as a major traveler destination with a variety
of resources. Its unique characteristics and strategic placement play a vital role in
tourism development. According to the Sri Lanka tourism development authority
(SLTDA), Tourism arrival to Sri Lanka during the year 2017 amounted to 2,116,407.
It was the third-largest foreign exchange earner in 2017 amounted was 598,356
Million. In the current scenario, new tourism concepts are far beyond traditional
tourism concepts, while tourists’ preferences have moved from mass tourism to niche
tourism. Rural tourism is an emerging trend in Sri Lanka, one of the niche tourism
sectors.
- 88 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
selected rural tourism destinations were identified as (a) what is the impact of tourism
destination attributes on visitor satisfaction in rural tourism destinations? (b) whether
there is a community contribution to rural tourism initiatives? The research objectives
have been formulated by catering to the selected rural tourism destinations;
Hiriwadunna village track, Meemure, and Heeloya Knuckles valley tourism village.
1). Identify the impact of destination attributes on visitor satisfaction in rural tourism
destinations.
2). Identify the community contribution of rural tourism initiatives.
Literature Review
- 89 -
Rural tourism as a niche-market
Tourism is the generic term to cover both demand and supply and has been
adopted in various forms and used throughout the world. Niche tourism highly vital in
the sector, as a destination with specific niche products, will be able to establish
themselves as a niche tourism destination. Among the niches, rural tourism is a niche
market based on visitor preferences and needs especially focusing on experiencing
rural livelihood (Novelli et al., 2005). Further, tourism in rural areas will increase the
benefits for rural residents from rural tourism activities and ensure the relationship
between rural tourism development and biodiversity conservation (Aziz, 2018).
According to the broader definition of rural tourism, its range of activities, service,
and amenities provided by farmers and rural people attract tourists to their areas in
order to generate extra income for their business. The niche segment, cover not only
farm tourism which is touring in rural areas, but also accommodation plus events,
festivals, gastronomy, outdoor recreation products and sales of handicrafts and
agricultural product (Aslam and Awang, 2015);( Fernando, 2015). Past literature
related to rural tourism (Verbole, 2000; Wilson,2001) suggested rural tourism should
be initiated in rural landscapes by the rural community incorporation with other
stakeholders in rural areas. According to Buhalis (2000), travelers desire to go back to
nature and experience some authentic agricultural process, and agricultural facilities
are transformed into leisure activities. Tourism is considered as the development
strategy where agricultural activities decline steadily. Scholars Alipour and Kayaman
(2011), Randelli et al (2014), Eruera (2008) discuss that rural tourism takes place
within the socio-culture and environment of the rural community. According to Okech
et al (2012) rural areas are heterogeneous with; spaces where human settlement and
infrastructure occupancy only small patches of the landscape. Further, dominated by
fields and pastures, woods and forests, water, mountain and desert, places where most
people spend on farms, abundance and relative cheapness of land, high transaction
costs associated with long-distance and poor infrastructure and geographical
conditions that increase political transaction costs and magnify the possibility of elite
capture of urban bias. Therefore, the novel tendency among tourists to experience
nature and traditional livelihood might create the avenue for this niche market, both
foreign and domestic tourism.
- 90 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
destinations as places where people travel and choose to stay for a while in order to
experience certain features or characteristics a perceived attraction of some sort. As
Buhalis cited Cooper et al. (1998), define destination as the focus of facilities and
services designed to meet the tourists. Successful destinations combine diverse
services, which can be structured as the 6 A’s of tourism destinations: Attractions of
natural (e.g. mountains, lakes, beaches), artificial (theme parks, amusement parks), or
cultural (ritual places/events). Accessibility refers to both the transport to the outside
and within a certain destination. Amenities characterize all services facilitating a
convenient stay, accommodation, gastronomy, or leisure activities and Available
packages refer to the availability of service bundles to direct the tourists’ attention to
certain unique features of a respective destination. Activities refer to the tourists’ travel
motives available within the destination both active (hiking, swimming, skiing) and
passive (sunbathing, wellness). Ancillary services are not primarily associated with
tourism (Opaschowski, 2002; Althof, 2001; Buhalis, 2000). According to Chi (2005),
destinations showcased a mix of attractions and support services with a number of
common features. Destination components categorized into four A’s Such as natural
and artificial sites or events, amenities including accommodation, food, and beverages.
Accessibility such as local transportation and transport terminals, ancillary services
informs of a local organization. Elements of the tourist’s destinations classified into
primary and secondary sources. Climate, ecology, cultural traditions, and architecture
are identified as primary sources and developments, such as hotels, catering,
transportation, and amusements identified as secondary resources (Chi and Qu, 2008).
- 91 -
2012;Fernando, 2012 ) have shown the positive relationship between tourists’
satisfaction, revisit intention, and destination attributes, while less number of studies
on the negative relationship between destination attributes and visitor satisfaction
(Boit and Doh,2014). Further, staff hospitality and friendliness, activities offered in
the area, and natural attractions influenced visitor satisfaction positively. According to
Ghose and Johann ( 2019), tour package features show a positive impact on visitor
satisfaction and high impact attractions; culture, and monuments. Further, nature and
countryside show a negative effect as a result. According to the Chi, (2005),
destination attributes consists of sightseeing (Attraction), price of accommodation
(Accommodation), variety of entertainment (Activities), cleanliness, availability of
parking (Accessibility).
- 92 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
Independent Variables:
Dependent variable
Destination Attributes
Attraction
Accessibility
Available package
Activities
Methodology
The study focused on three main rural tourism destinations in Sri Lanka,
namely, the Hiriwadunna village track, Meemure, and Heeloya Knuckles valley
tourism village. The population of this study is the community and visitors of rural
tourism destinations in Sri Lanka. In order to achieve research objectives, 100 local
and foreign visitors, and 12 tourism stakeholders were selected purposively for the
sample. The study has been conducted during mid-2019, and due to the Easter Bomb
attack in April 2019, tourists’ arrivals drastically dropped down. Therefore, the sample
size was limited to 100 tourists and 12 stakeholders. A pilot test was conducted with a
sample of 50 respondents from each destination. The interview was conducted to gain
stakeholder’s perceptions regarding the economic and socio-cultural impact of rural
tourism and thematic analysis used to express stakeholder’s perceptions. Primary data
was collected through a structured questionnaire filled by the respondents and
conducted interview sessions. The questionnaire is comprised of three sections.
Demographic analysis, independent variable analysis, and dependent variable
analysis, which are based on a five-point Likert scale to capture visitor satisfaction
towards rural tourism in Sri Lanka have been used.
- 93 -
Further, thematic analysis has been performed to assess the contribution of rural
tourism initiatives to the household economy. Therefore, both quantitative and
qualitative methods have been adopted to achieve research objectives developed.
The sample consisted of males (63%) than the female respondents (37%) ranging from
26-35 years of age category. The majority of the respondents were from Europe and
the main purpose of the visit was pleasure and vacation (69%). Visitors used online
sources and Social media to gain information than the word of mouth marketing
(WOM) and Travel agents. Unique and novelty experience was the main objective of
respondents (36%) on rural experiences, and the majority opted for village house
accommodations (41%) as their favorite.
Descriptive analysis
During the data analysis process, descriptive statistical analysis has been conducted
for the sample. Therefore, Table 1 and 2 present a summary of descriptive statistics.
- 94 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
Source: survey
The results of the descriptive analysis imply that all the destination attributes
positively influence on visitor satisfaction towards rural destinations. Accordingly,
attraction, accessibility, amenities, available services, ancillary services, and activities
accounted for mean value are 4.0925, 3.7533, 4.8800, 4.0660, 4.1133 , and 4.9600,
respectively. The visitors have almost agreed with the overall activities of rural
destinations with a positive perception of rural tourism destinations.
- 95 -
Visitors showed a positive perception regarding the destination attributes as
the mean value of the dependent variable is 4.6971, which implies an overall positive
perception of the visitors with the dispersion of 0.12256 values.
Regression Results
During the data analysis process, to analyze the impact of the destination
attributes, the multiple regression has been conducted after testing the reliability of the
data and four assumptions. Table 3 presents the summary details of models, Table 4
presents the coefficients of independent variables, and Table 5 presents the summary
of the Regression analysis.
Figure Value
R .938
R Square .880
Adjusted R Square .872
Standard error of estimate .04389
Model Sum of Mean DF F Sig.
Square Square
Regression 1.308 .218 6 113.196 0.000
Residual .179 .002 93
Total 1.487 99
Source: Survey
- 96 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
Regression Model
Source: Survey
Thematic analysis
Thematic analysis has been conducted to achieve the second research objective on
community contribution from a stakeholder perspective. Table 6 illustrates the
summary of the thematic analysis.
- 97 -
Table 6 Summary of the thematic analysis
Negative impact
Poor quality job
Seasonality of tourism-related
business
Negative impact
Cost of living
Women employment
Negative impact
Cultural influences
Drug abuse
Misbehavior
Living standards
Social empowerment
Source: Survey
- 98 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
With regard to the economic and socio-cultural impact, both positive and
negative responses have been provided by the respondents. From the economic
impacts (a) economic growth (b) income generation and (c) women employment
creation were highlighted. From the negative impacts, the cost of living has been
highlighted. According to Scheyvens (1999), the importance of tourism's impact on
the economy has resulted in the personal economic benefits from tourism to become
one of the most consistent predictors of residents' support for tourism. In addition to
economic impact, socio-cultural impacts in both directions have been highlighted.
The study highlighted the rural tourism destinations of Sri Lanka namely,
Hiriwadunna village track, Meemure, and Heeloya Knuckles Valley Tourism village
as destinations and focused on identifying the impact of destination attributes on
visitor satisfaction. The vacuum of less research work on rural tourism might fill out
- 99 -
from this study. Two research objectives have been developed, and a mixed-method
approach has been adopted to the conceptual model developed by aligning 6
Destination attributes on rural tourism destinations with visitor satisfaction. The
findings endorsed all six destination attributes positively impacting on visitor
satisfaction towards rural tourism and ancillary services illustrate the highest
coefficient with (0.549), highlighting a clear strategy for policy developers. The study
attempts to assess the holistic perception of the residents in terms of economic and
socio-cultural benefits from rural tourism. Herein the community contribution of rural
tourism initiatives to the household economy and socio-cultural betterment of rural
tourism stakeholders is highlighted, and perception leads to positive impacts. Hence,
future studies might focus on identifying prominent factors other than the destination
attribute.
All three rural tourism destinations are highlighted as places that could be
developed further as rural tourism destinations. Safety and security of the tourists,
service quality by registering tour operators combined with Agro-tourism with
traditional Sri Lankan life, and popularize events such as harvesting festivals and
camping sites in agricultural fields within the area had been highlighted.
Sri Lanka, as one of the famous tourism destinations, could be more popularized with
the image among the global market by catering more to authentic rural tourism
experiences by popularizing rural tourism destinations. Further, as the main outcome,
rural community livelihoods might economically and socio-culturally enrich on
adopting win-win strategies.
References
Aslam, M.S.M. and Awang, K.W., (2015), Enterprising rural tourism for sustainable
rural development in Sri Lanka, International Journal of Economics and Financial
Issues, 5(1), 27-33
- 100 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
Boit, J. and Doh M. (2014), The role of destination attributes and visitor satisfaction
on tourists repeat visit intentions, the case of lake Nakuru national park, Kenya, NERR
Proceedings.
Department of Census and Statistics (2016), Household Income & Expenditure survey
- 2016 final report, Sri Lanka: Ministry of Finance & Planning
- 101 -
Ghose, S., & Johann, M. (2019), Measuring tourist satisfaction with destination
attributes, Journal of Management and Financial Sciences, (34), 9-22
Lewis, J.B., (1996), A case study of the process of tourism development in rural
communities in the state of Indiana (Doctoral Dissertation, Indiana University).
Novelli, M. et al., (2005), Niche Tourism: Contemporary Issues, Trends and Cases,
Edited Book, Butterworth-Heinemann Publishers, ISBN 075066133 x
Randelli, F., Romei, P. and Tortora, M. (2014), Land use policy an evolutionary
approach to the study of rural tourism : The case of Tuscany, Land Use Policy, 38,
27-6281.
- 102 -
Sri Lanka Journal of Management Studies, Volume 2 – Issue 1, July 2020
Verbole, A., (2000), Actors, discourses and interfaces of rural tourism development
at the local community level on Slovenia: Social and political dimensions of the rural
tourism development process, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 8(6), 479-490
- 103 -