Dplad Project
Dplad Project
IGNOU REGIONAL
STUDY CENTRE/CODE:
OFFICE, BBSR/ 2100
READER
POLITICAL SCIENCE
EKAMRA COLLEGE
BHUBANESWAR
I the undersigned solemnly declare that the project report “Local Self Government in
Odisha Special Reference to Panchayat Raj System in ‘Ganjam’ District” is based
on my own work carried out during the course of our study under the supervision of Mr.
Bijoy Kumar Sahoo. I assert the statements made and conclusions drawn are an outcome
of my research work. I further certify that:
I. The work contained in the report is original and has been done by me under the
general supervision of my supervisor.
II. The work has not been submitted to any other Institution for any other
degree/diploma/certificate in this university or any other University of India or
abroad.
III. We have followed the guidelines provided by the university in writing the report.
IV. Whenever we have used materials (data, theoretical analysis, and text) from other
sources, we have given due credit to them in the text of the report and giving their
details in the references.
This is to certify that the project report entitled “Local Self Government in Odisha
Special Reference to Panchayat Raj System in ‘Ganjam’ District”, submitted to
the IGNOU Regional Office, BBSR/2100, in partial fulfilment for the award of the
degree of Diploma in Panchayat Level Administration, is a record of bona fide work
carried out by Ms. Shrimayee Debasmita, Enrolment No. 195711096, under my
supervision and guidance.
All help received by her from various sources have been duly acknowledged.
No part of this report has been submitted elsewhere for award of any other degree
Zilla Parishad
(District Level)
The term ‘Panchayati Raj’ came into acceptance after the acceptance of the recommendations
on Democratic Decentralization of the Balwant Rai Mehta Study Team. Earlier the terms used
were ‘village panchayat’, ‘district board’ or ‘subdistrict board’, which meant the self-governing
bodies at the village or regional levels. Panchayati Raj indicates the creation of local
government institutions at the village, block, and district levels. The Institutionalization of
democratic decentralization in the form of statutory Panchayati Raj thus opened a new chapter
in history and gave a new turn to the evolution of rural local self-government institutions in
India (Maithili, 1995).
Panchayati Raj comprises a three-tier structure of democratic institutions at districts, block,
and village levels, namely Zila Parishad, Panchayat Samiti, and Village Panchayat respectively.
These institutions are considered as a training ground, or democracy and political education.
Rural development plans and programs are implemented at this level so that the fruits of
development can accrue to the community directly. These institutions were established in 1959
based on the philosophy of decentralization and Gram Swaraj. The philosophy of development
that emerged in India after Independence emphasized the involvement of the people in a
structure that would enable them to actively participate in the process of decision-making. To
bring democracy to the grassroots level and involve people in decision-making, an experiment
was made with the devolution of power to the elected representatives and allocation of
responsibility and financial resources as it was felt that this would be a major institutional
device for the development of rural areas.
The father of the nation had his heart and mind applied to the concept of ‘village India’. His
partner in Odisha was ‘Utkalamani’, Sri Gopabandhu Das, who had unshakable interests in the
panchayat system. The term ‘Utkalamani’ means excellent locomotion. It is a metaphor that
denotes Orissa (now spelled as Odisha) as much does Kalinga, which means cleaver and
intelligent. The history of the Panchayat movement in Odisha predates that of the pan India
story. The elections are held under the eagle eye of the State Election Commission. It has all
the three tiers of the panchayat systems in all her 30 districts (elected). And Odisha has
conducted a series of elections under various chief ministers and political hues in the past. The
case of Odisha is that of a lead story, a success story, and a story of the will to devolve power
to the people in the villages.
It is as if Odisha lives in its villages – so progress must flow out from there. It now has a
department enviably called, ‘The Panchayati Raj’. It has an independent fiscal layout
(budgetary), an array of powers, a crisp list of duties, and sterling per-functionaries. It has
cross-linked powers-&-functions with other departments. It is not a loner nor a case of a
dressed-up doll. The evolutionary process path indicates that the department is trying its level
best to bring an overall development in its rural villages. The state’s natives during the same
period came out with flying colors in yielding power, responsibilities in their exercises.
Wholeheartedly, they have participated in elections and post-election for as and forums as if
they are determined to set examples for all others. Not indolent, it is a patient indulgence for
democracy. Time and places, they rejected the bullet and even answered it with the ballot.
There is much room for refinement extending to correction, which shows that the panchayat
movement in Odisha has a very wide spectrum that needs time, money, and experience to
unravel and that we have not been able to do justice in these presents.
In the above background, this project report analyses the role of local governments in Odisha.
The specific objectives are: ·
To bring out the merits of decentralization;
To sketch the evolution of panchayats in India; and
To evaluate the rural decentralization in Odisha state.
The study is based on quantitative information and secondary sources. It is both descriptive
and analytical in nature.
4. STUDY AREA
Odisha, formerly Orissa, is an Indian state located in Eastern India. It is the 8th largest state
by area and the 11th largest by population. The state has the third-largest population of
Scheduled Tribes in India. It neighbours the states of West Bengal and Jharkhand to the north,
Chhattisgarh to the west, and Andhra Pradesh to the south. Odisha has a coastline of 485
kilometres (301 mi) along the Bay of Bengal. The region is also known as Utkala and is
mentioned in India's national anthem, "Jana Gana Mana". The language of Odisha is Odia,
which is one of the Classical Languages of India.
The ancient kingdom of Kalinga, which was invaded by the Mauryan emperor Ashoka (which
was again won back from them by king Kharavela) in 261 BCE resulting in the Kalinga War,
coincides with the borders of modern-day Odisha. The modern boundaries of Odisha were
demarcated by the British Indian government when Orissa Province was established on 1 April
1936, consisting of the Odia-speaking districts of Bihar and Orissa Province. The first of April
is celebrated as Utkala Dibasa. Cuttack was made the capital of the region by Anantavarman
Chodaganga in c. 1135, after which the city was used as the capital by many rulers, through
the British era until 1948. Thereafter, Bhubaneswar became the capital of Odisha.
The main parties active in the politics of Odisha are the Biju Janata Dal, the Indian National
Congress, and Bhartiya Janata Party. Following the Odisha State Assembly Election in 2019,
the Naveen Patnaik-led Biju Janata Dal stayed in power for the sixth consecutive term, he is
the 14th chief minister of Odisha since 2000. The Odisha state has a unicameral legislature.
The Odisha Legislative Assembly consists of 147 elected members, and special office bearers
such as the Speaker and Deputy Speaker, who are elected by the members. Assembly meetings
are presided over by the Speaker, or by the Deputy Speaker in the Speaker's absence. Executive
authority is vested in the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister, although the titular
head of government is the Governor of Odisha. The governor is appointed by the President of
Odisha has been divided into 30 districts. These 30 districts have been placed under three
different revenue divisions to streamline their governance. The divisions are North, South, and
Central, with their headquarters at Sambalpur, Berhampur, and Cuttack respectively. Each
division consists of ten districts and has a Revenue Divisional Commissioner (RDC) as its
administrative head. The position of the RDC in the administrative hierarchy is that between
that of the district administration and the state secretariat. The RDCs report to the Board of
Revenue, which is headed by a senior officer of the Indian Administrative Service.
Each district is governed by a Collector and District Magistrate, who is appointed from the
Indian Administrative Service. The Collector and District Magistrate is responsible for
collecting the revenue and maintaining law and order in the district. Each District is separated
into Sub-Divisions, each governed by a Sub-Collector and Sub-Divisional Magistrate. The
Sub-Divisions are further divided into Tahasils. The Tahasils are headed by Tahasildar. Odisha
has 58 Sub-Divisions, 317 Tahasils, and 314 Blocks. Blocks consist of Panchayats (village
councils) and town municipalities.
The capital and largest city of the state is Bhubaneswar. The other major cities are Cuttack,
Rourkela, Berhampur, and Sambalpur. Municipal Corporations in Odisha include
Bhubaneswar, Cuttack, Berhampur, Sambalpur, and Rourkela.
Other municipalities of Odisha include Angul, Balangir, Balasore, Barbil, Bargarh, Baripada,
Belpahar, Bhadrak, Bhawanipatna, Biramitrapur, Boudh, Brajarajnagar, Byasanagar,
Chhatrapur, Deogarh, Dhenkanal, Gopalpur, Gunupur, Hinjilicut, Jagatsinghpur, Jajpur,
Jeypore, Jharsuguda, Joda, Kendrapara, Kendujhar, Khordha, Konark, Koraput, Malkangiri,
Nabarangpur, Nayagarh, Nuapada, Paradeep, Paralakhemundi, Phulbani, Puri, Rajgangpur,
Rayagada, Sonepur, Sundargarh, Talcher, Titilagarh and Umerkote.
5. STUDY REPORT
Rural development is the main pillar of state development. Rural Orissa has lagged in
development because of many historical reasons. The thrust of policies and programs of the
Panchayati Raj department is on all-round economic development and social justice through
empowerment. Orissa Grama Panchayat Act was enacted in the year 1948. Subsequently, in
the year 1961. A 3-tier system of Panchayati Raj Institutions was introduced in Orissa. Over
the last 50 years, Panchayati Raj Institutions have emerged as powerful institutions in bringing
about rapid and sustainable development and socio-economic transformation in rural Orissa. It
has an integrated perspective towards improving the quality of lives of rural people and
ensuring equity and effective peoples’ participation. 73rd Amendment of the Constitution has
conferred constitutional status to Panchayati Raj Institutions. The Provisions of Panchayats
(Extension to Scheduled Areas) The act aims at empowering Panchayati Raj Institutions in
Scheduled areas for economic development and social justice. In the year 2002, the election to
3 tiers of Panchayati Raj Institutions held in conformity with 73rd Amendment and PESA
thereby empowering tribal people as envisaged under the PESA. The Government has the
obligation to bring up Panchayati Raj Institutions as Institutions of Self Government as per the
73rd amendment of the Constitution of India 1992. 73rd Amendment marks a new era in the
federal set up of the country. The prime objectives of the three tiers Panchayati Raj System
are to eradicate poverty, uplift standard of the living of people in rural areas, and bring about a
healthy society by creating awareness for hygiene, sanitation, and eradication of illiteracy. The
state has established a State Election Commissioner to conduct the election of PRIs. The 73rd
amendment of the Constitution mandates the Government to endow the Panchayati Raj
Institutions with such powers and authority as may be necessary to enable them to function as
institutions of self-Government. It also provides that powers and responsibility shall be
devolved upon PRIs subject to such conditions as may be specified therein, concerning the
preparation of plans for economic development and social justice and implementation of
schemes for economic development and social justice as may be entrusted to them including
those listed in the 11th Schedule. Panchayats at village levels are expected to perform certain
obligatory functions to provide basic services to all the people living in the area. Gram
Panchayats in Orissa have been empowered to levy taxes and manage community assets created
out of different poverty eradication and area development schemes. They as constitutional
bodies represent the model of community participation and social empowerment. Basic
services among others include:
Primary education
Primary health
Safe Drinking water
The dept. has two composite directorates (i) Director Gram Panchayats in charge of all works
related to panchayat administration and functioning of the three tiers, this includes all excluding
special projects (ii) Director, Special Projects. He monitors the District Rural Development
Agency (DRDA) for the implementation of poverty eradication programs. The system due to
its wide-spread effect apparently has a cumbersome set-up cum file movement mechanism,
which surely shall of the years become more and more straightened.
Following are the main sources of revenue of the Grama Panchayat. It raises money through
taxes, fees, and Government taxes.
a) Vehicles tax,
b) Latrine or conservancy tax,
c) Water- rate where water is supplied by the Gram Panchayat.
d) Lighting taxes, where the lighting of public streets is provided. Drainage tax, Fees on
private markets, cart sheds.
e) Fees on animals sold in a public market controlled by a Grama Panchayat, Fees for
regulating the movement of cattle for the protection of crops.
f) Fees for use of any building, shops, stalls, pens of stands in the market, rent from
contractor's temporarily occupying open grounds or any building maintained by the
Grama Panchayat.
g) Any other tax, fee as may be decided by the Grama Panchayat subject to the approval
of the State Government.
2. Panchayat Samiti
The panchayat samiti is the middle rung of the Panchayati raj. Its CEO cum chief financial
officer (draw & disbursement officer) is the BDO. Since 2000 such chair has been seeing
Class-I officer(s) of the State cadre (normally of the status of sub-collector and or additional
dist. Magistrate). The Collector cum District Magistrate (super time scale – central cadre
officer) is the CEO and also the chief financial officer cum chief electoral head of that district.
This apart there are Directors and Project Directors many of who are central cadre officers.
They are officially known as the ‘Field Officers’ of the Panchayati Raj Dept. Thus, come in
the India’s Steel Frame (bureaucracy) in an effective manner in myriads of ways from the 2nd
tier onwards. When such officers conduct office the arm of the law is at attention in and around,
all the while. Odisha panchayat election 2012 has proven that such mechanism can unite the
ultra & the altruistic in the service of the nation (may be with limps & jumps). The meeting
grounds being the offices in the dist. HQ & Block offices.
Tenure:
The samiti is elected for five years and is headed by a chairman and deputy chairman elected
by the members of the panchayat samiti. One sarpanch samiti supervises the other gram
panchayats. It acts as a coordinating body between district panchayat and gram panchayat.
Each Committee consists of few samiti members including samiti president. The samiti
president is the chairman of all the committees. These committees provide guidance and
direction for panning, implementation and evaluation of various programs and activities related
to the mandates of the committee.
Main Functions:
Planning, execution & supervision of all works within the block; supervision over the GPs;
education; management of trusts and endowments (coastal rural Odisha has plenty – to her long
independent history); Budget.
3. Zilla Parishad
The top most tier is that of the Zilla Parishad having umbilical connection with the ‘Orissa Zilla
Parishad Act - 1991. The term ZP denotes ‘district council’. Its seat is the dist. H.Q., that is
same as that of the seat of the Collector cum Dist. Magistrate. All parishad members being
elected people. The head and the dy-head being known as President and as Vice President,
respectively. One of the either incumbent has to be a lady. Women participation in the
panchayat movement has been a hallmark ever since. The President is elected by the elected
members of the new parishad in its 1st meeting.
Composition:
The Parishad shall consist of the following members, namely:
1. one member elected directly on the basis of adult suffrage from every constituency
within the [Parishad area];
2. Chairman of each Samiti situated within the district.
3. every member of the House of the People and of the State Legislative Assembly
representing constituencies which comprise wholly or partly the area of the Parishad;
4. members of the Council of States who are registered as electors within the area of the
Parishad.
Tenure:
Members of the Zila Parishad are elected from the district on the basis of adult franchise for a
term of five years. Zila Parishad has minimum of 50 and maximum of 75 members. There are
seats reserved for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes and women.
Main Functions:
New areas being, hospitals, dispensary, minor education. Operation Black Board; Kendu Leaf
Matter; etc. Debate & discuss the laws, rules, orders, implement and supervise. All central;
state and finance commission sponsored scheme.
Every Standing Committee shall consist of Five members in case of a Samiti having
twenty or more elected members; or
Composition of the Standing Committee – three members in case of a Samiti having
less than twenty elected members.
The Chairman and members of the Standing Committees shall be elected by and from
among the elected members of the Samiti Provided that in case of Standing Committee
as referred to in Clause (d) of Sub-rule (1) of Rule 3, the Chairman or Vice-Chairman
whoever be woman shall be the Chairman and only woman members shall be elected
to such Standing Committees.
The Block Development Officer shall be the ex-officio Secretary of all.
Standing Committees
The respective Standing Committee of the Samiti shall deal with the matters for which it has
been constituted.
Functions of the Standing Committee –
Every Standing Committee
a. shall review the matters placed before it in relation to the subjects or schemes as
assigned to it and prepare plans and projects thereof and furnish its recommendations
to the Samiti
b. shall ensure proper implementations of the plans and projects prepared by them and
shall be responsible for the financial and physical achievements in respect of the
schemes and programmed assigned to them
v. Election Aspects
Article 243-K of the Indian Constitution envisages that the superintendence, direction and
control of the preparation of the electoral rolls for, and the conduct of, all elections consisting
of a State Election Commissioner to be appointed by the Governor. State Government
published the Orissa Panchayati Raj Election Commission Rule 1994 (Appointment Condition
of Service and Miscellaneous Provision) in the extraordinary issue of Orissa Gazette on January
31st 1994. Mr. D.K. Mishra, was the First State Election Commissioner. It is not known as to
whether similar exercise (election under State Election Commissioner – party based support –
multi-angular contest, approved symbol based; etc.) is done in Kerala & Karnataka 1 Rule
2(d) of the Orissa Grama Panchayat Election Rules-1965, Rule 2(e) of Orissa Panchayat
Samiti Election Rules-1991 and Rule 2(f) of Orissa Zilla Parishad Election Rules-1994 declares
<40 years
Number
Women
Level
Total
Sl.
OBC
Post
SC
ST
No.
30
President,
Zilla 30
1. Vice-President
6 12 8 11 30 Nk Nk
Parishad 7948
Member
54
Chairman, 314
Panchayat Vice- 314
2. 39 147 57 124 314 Nk Nk
Samiti Chairman 55996
Member 227
Sarpanch, 6234
Gram Naib- 6234
3. 729 2388 2698 2213 6234 Nk Nk
Panchayat Sarpanch 8131393
Ward Member 781
TOTAL 100862 837 2547 2763 2213 xx xx xx
Table 1.1 provides the pan Odisha scenario post panchayat general election 2012.
Nk – Not known, yet information about such status must be the records.
Other demographic human geography-based indicators show Ganjam as a good choice for
comparative studies
No. of
District BJD INC BJP CPI CPM
Contestant
Ganjam 69 60 4 2 2 1
Table 1.3 Ganjam: Party based strength/position of the ZP
Source: Odisha’s Panchayati Raj website
Elected Vice
District Zilla Parishad Elected President
President
Surath Chandra
GANJAM GANJAM Sujata Rani Pali
Pradhan
Table 1.4 Ganjam ZP (Ganjam district is a ZP for the whole of the district – HQ: Chhatarpur.)
Source: Odisha’s Panchayati Raj website
No. of
Name of No. of No. of
Female Male
Naib Female Male
the PS GP Sarpanch
Sarpanch
Ganjam 14 14 5 9 14 5 9
Ganjam PS has 14 GPs and one of the GP is by the name of Ganjam
Table 1.6 Ganjam GP
Source: Odisha’s Panchayati Raj website
Jhodia community of Koraput District boycotted the polls on the demand that they should be
declared as a Scheduled Tribe. No election could be held in three zones of this tribal block. No
force, no force majeure, no police action, no central forces, no para-military, nothing is noted.
It is the referendum. This is the beauty of the panchayat system. Elsewhere, the anti-POSCO
movement candidates of Jagatsingpur lost fared miserably, though the election was held
peacefully. Through the ballot, the villagers said ‘we need industry, employment, etc.’
However, the election for the Dhinkia panchayat, the epi-center was deferred (held now).
People celebrated grass-root democracy.
Abduction
The Odisha govt., could not keep its word of permitting one Naxal member as the vice-
president (we are not aware of the compulsions). This led to the long period abduction of the
local MLA (Laxmipur-Koraput), Mr. Jinna Hikka. The Naxals relented at last.
Huge Success
The fact that Naxals adopted the electoral way to participate at the village-to-dist., levels
tantamount to a paradigm shift from their earlier stands. That they have come out in the open
reposes faith in the system administered by the election commission system/mechanism. It may
be likened to the event of an armistice with Brigadier Silo and or with Laldenga.
Such events tell us that our founding fathers were so very right. Deriding such a democratic
and pluralistic process is an exhibition of guile loaded vehemence and abysmal ignorance. It is
a huge success of the state bureaucracy and the state home dept. In the end, democracy won.
The trust of the founding fathers in the federal form got vetted. The year 2012 is a red-lettered
one in the annals of the Panchayati raj movement and grass-root democracy in India. All these
are bound to make changes in the social and economic aspects of the Odisha societies and India
at large.
2009
2010-11 2011-12 2012-13
-10
Incremental
Incremental
Incremental
Rank on DI
Cumulative
Cumulative
Cumulative
Rank on
Rank on
Rank on
Rank on
Rank on
Rank on
States
DI
DI
DI
DI
DI
DI
West
4 4 9 7 NA 6 NA
Bengal
Kerala 1 1 2 1 NA 3 9
Karnataka 2 2 4 2 4 2 1
Gujarat 7 NA 11 10 NA 10 NA
Odisha 12 15 17 13 NA 11 4
Table 1.7 Comparative statement of ranking of states on devolution index (Di) for the last 4 years.
Source: Ministry of Panchayati Raj website
7. REFERENECES
www.panchayat.gov.in
odishapanchayat.gov.in
https://www.researchgate.net