Remote Pipeline Monitoring Using Wireless Sensor Networks: March 2017
Remote Pipeline Monitoring Using Wireless Sensor Networks: March 2017
net/publication/316722669
CITATIONS READS
11 364
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Khawar Rehman on 08 May 2020.
Abstract— Identification and localization of anomalies in vehicle to physically examine and repair them as needed.
pipeline structure is an essential requirement in many Remote monitoring is the latest trend for pipeline
industries. There are numerous reasons that can lead to monitoring. Different architectures are proposed and
pipeline damage and impairment. In chemical and petroleum deployed for reliable and long term monitoring of aging,
industry this damage is directly connected to the safety of corrosion, leakages, cracks and physical damages from third
assets as well as humans. Hence, continuous monitoring and
parties. In Kingdom of Saudi Arabia hundreds of kilometers
timely response is expected. This paper provides an insight
into different leakage problems that may arise in various of underground pipelines are laid to connect the cities with
pipeline industries. Wireless Sensor Network (WSN) solutions the Arabian Gulf through the desert. Maintenance and
that may be applied to these problems are deliberated and monitoring of such large infrastructure is a challenging but
evaluated. Based on this comparison recommendations and essential task. Russia is a renowned exporter of crude oil. In
solutions are specified. 2007 Russia exported almost 1.3 million barrels of crude oil
per day via underground pipelines. The oil traveled from
Keywords- Wireless Sensor Network, Pipeline monitoring, Russia all the way to Ukraine, Germany, Poland, and other
leakage detection, leakage localization method. destinations in Europe [2] . Underground pipelines are
I. INTRODUCTION considered as the safest way to transport liquids and gases
far across the globe. However statistical observations have
Pipelines are the primary mean to transport various goods proved that large pipelines experience at least one harmful
from one point to another. Liquids, gases, chemicals, oils, leakage every year. Junior, et al. [3] reported that pipeline
bio fuels and many other important assets of a county are leakage can cause economic loss, and environmental
usually shipped using pipelines. Water pipelines are one of pollution problems. Risk of human injuries is also increased.
the most vital structure for transporting water for drinking Thus, the security and monitoring of pipeline infrastructure
or irrigation over long distances. This transportation can be becomes a major challenge [4]. Some of the factors
from over hills, canals or other cities [1]. This long distance contributing to leaks are old and weak pipeline construction,
transportation must be carefully and remotely monitored poorly maintained valves and not enough corrosion
against security threats, pollution problem, environmental protection [5]. Economic losses caused by leakage
impact and leakage loss. Oil and gas pipelines are made increases annually and cause accumulating losses [6].
from steel or plastic which are usually buried under the soil Pipeline monitoring system can be wired, wireless or a
or exposed to temperature pressure loads. Some of the combination of both to transfer data from pipelines to
pipelines are operated at high pressure and temperature, control station. Since pipeline networks are in line,
which can often result in pipelines breakdown, causing connectivity always remains a critical feature. Pipeline
severe damage to humans and unwanted interruption of oil, inspection can be classified into three major categories
gas or water supplies. Hence there is a need for active and
remote monitoring system for these pipelines. However, the • Using smart moveable sensors.
system should remain scalable and cost effective. Pipeline • Using standalone monitoring system or device.
inspection and repair presents a number of challenges that • Using resident pipeline sensors.
are quite unique. Pipelines extensive deployment, high cost,
high risk and often hard to access conditions require Smart movable sensing devices are robots, pigs, or crawlers.
uninterrupted monitoring as well as an optimization of These are intelligent robotic devices that can move inside or
maintenance interventions. Active monitoring is an above a pipeline to inspect the interior/exterior conditions.
expensive process using traditional maintenance systems, Standalone inspection systems utilize phased array
especially in a hazardous environment and elevated ultrasonic technology. They are usually mounted on the
temperature and pressure load. It is also a time-intensive outer surface of pipelines where they use the
procedure that involves workers covering large areas by electromagnetic waves to detect corrosion and defects at a
33
PIPE is a project based on magnetic induction based transmitting coil. A time-varying magnetic field is produced
pipeline monitoring. The system consists of two types of in the near field of the transmitter. Another sinusoidal
sensor placement i.e. inside the pipeline or outside the current is induced at the receiver because of this time-
pipeline. Both these types provide the following varying magnetic field resulting in successful
functionality communication. The basic principal is show in figure 3.
34
plates in nuclear power plant using MFL. In case there are ii. HALL Sensor
no defects in the wall, uniform magnetic field is distributed. Hall-effect is created by placing a thin electric conductor/
As soon as a defect appears, the sensor is capable of semiconductor in a magnetic field which results in
detecting the MFL and hence revealing the defect. This producing an electric field. The standard technique used in
technique can detect cracks, welding scars and various leaks CMOS Hall sensors is spinning current method in which the
very efficiently. The working principle of MLF is shown in offset voltage is reduced [19]. MFL Monitoring systems
figure 4. using Hall-effect sensors are increasingly becoming popular.
As they are capable of measuring the magnetic field
directly, and convert it to an output voltage. Flux density
and field are related by a constant and the output voltage of
a hall sensor is directly proportional to the flux density[15].
Authors in [20] have presented a low cost and high speed
hall sensor for motor applications. The circuit of the
proposed sensor consists of a Hall plate, Hall bias block and
spinning timing control. Hall bias is used to introduce a time
delay in the signal path by using the spinning current
method. The proposed sensor is especially designed in view
of automotive and industrial field.
Figure 4: Principle of MFL
D. Acoustic emission based monitoring
As shown in figure 4, the sensors are placed in between the Acoustic emission (AE) based monitoring is gaining
north and south poles to detect the magnetic field leakage. considerable attention as it is a nondestructive examination
The placement of sensors is in the form of a row. Various method. Most commonly AE leakage detection is performed
level of detection sensitivity can be chosen according to using dynamic pressure sensors. These sensors are inserted
testing needs. Standard low resolution is the most typical into the pipelines for efficient leak noise detection. The
form of MI based detection. High resolution or extra high escaping liquids and gases produce friction or a noticeable
resolution are the newest generation MI based systems in impact which results in acoustic emission as it passes
which high number of sensors are used. Following are the through the leak hole of a pipeline. As soon as the leak gets
most common types of sensors that can be used in MFL stable the acoustic signal also gets continuous and stationary
based detection. [21]. The escaping material from the pipeline produces an
acoustic emission signal that can be observed for remote and
i. COIL sensor timely monitoring of pipelines[21, 22]. Figure 5 depicts a
Induction coil based sensors are most frequently used in commonly used leak detection arrangement in gas pipelines
MFL tool. Steel coil sensors can be ideally used for using AE sensors. The AE sensors are placed apart on the
detecting corrosion in pipelines. This type of sensor is pipeline where the leak is suspected. The sensors are
created using a coil resonator upon which voltage is applied. mounted on the outer surface of the pipeline. A data
The change in resonant frequency due to the applied voltage acquisition unit is used to collect and process the obtained
can be monitored by a coupled coil [17]. Authors in [18] information. A computer is also used for signal processing.
have successfully used Rogowski coil sensor for detecting A leak can easily be localized by using simple algebraic
open circuit fault and short circuit faults. In this work the relationship as stated in equation (3)
sensor can capture the inductor current derivative and hence
can realize the faults. Whenever there is a change in the !!!!!
magnetic field across the coil of a sensor, voltage is !! (3)
!
induced. The coil can be designed in a variety of shapes and
sizes to improve the performances in various ways. The Where T is the time delay and d is the distance between two
output voltage of the moving coil can be calculated as in (2). sensors.
35
observed. This pulse is reflected back and the time travel
difference of ultrasonic wave is used to measure the
corrosion and thickness of material. In [28] also, authors
used an ultrasonic detection method to detect the submarine
pipeline corrosion. In another research the authors used a
unique arrangement of octagonal cells using ultrasonic
sensors for pipeline monitoring [29]. In [26] an ultrasonic
sensor based fiber directional coupler was used to detect the
discharge from pipelines. The sensors based on the
directional coupler were fabricated and the acoustic
emissions of partial discharges were detected. Table 1
describes and compares the most recently proposed pipeline
monitoring systems.
!
Fig 5. Leak localization and monitoring system Table 1: Comparison of various pipeline-monitoring techniques
Authors in [21] used the principle of over-coupled fused Authors Year Type of Parameter Result
coupler (OCFC) for the detection of acoustic emission in sensor measured
power transformers. AE sensors are also used in detecting Abdulaziz 2014 Mobile Leakage Non real time leakage
the fault in the planetary gearbox. In[23] heterodyne S.A et al.[ 7] sensors Medium detection
technique is used to sample the AE signals (heterodyning is level
a radio signal processing technique which down shifts the Jong H.K, 2010 Mobile Leakage cost effective and
et al. [9] sensors scalable system
frequency of AE signals so their sample rates are
comparable. The sampled AE signals are then processed Zhi Sun, et 2011 Pressure, Leakage Real time, high
using empirical mode decomposition to extract faults. al. [2] Acoustic reliability
sensor
E. Ultrasonic Based Monitoring Ian F. A, et 2015 Acoustic Underwater Low signal
al.[ 13] sensor localization propagation delay,
Ultrasonic technique (UT) is a family of non-destructive high bandwidth.
technique that can effectively observe corrosion problems in Yang 2009 Coil sensor, Leakage Greater sensitivity
pipelines. It is also commonly used for thickness Lijian [15] Hall sensor detetction
monitoring. In most UT application a very small ultrasonic Ebrahim 2016 Rogowski Fault low cost,
Farjah, [18] coil sensor diagnosis compactness, higher
pulse wave is used, the wave is transmitted into the accuracy
pipelines to be monitored, with a central wave frequency of Shuaiyong 2012 Acoustic, Leakage Reduce location error
0.1-15 MHz. Authors in [27] used an ultrasonic flowmeter Li, et al. Pressure high reliability
for liquid monitoring. They measured the liquid flowrate by [24] sensor
Ma Yifan , 2014 Acoustic Leakage Mean error < 5% ,
installing two transducers on the wall of pipe. These et al.[ 22] sensor high efficiency
transducers can transmit and receive the ultrasonic Bin Yang, 2012 Multi-crystal Corrosion Higher feasibility and
alternatively. Figure 6 shows the mechanism of ultrasonic et al.[ 25] ultrasonic reliability
wave based detection. wave
Fengmei 2015 ultrasonic Leakage Exponentially
Li, et al. sensor enhances strain
[26] response
III. CONCLUSION
Fluid leakage is a worldwide hassling matter that needs to
be dealt with effectively; otherwise it will cause huge
economic and raw materials losses. In this paper, we
introduced four WSN technologies for detecting leaks.
Magnetic induction based WSN for underground pipeline
leakage detection and localization was discussed. This
solution provides low cost monitoring system and power
! consumption for underground wireless communications that
Figure 6. Ultrasonic wave detection seems to be effective due to its low attenuation. MI-based
sensors can be utilized both inside and outside the pipes for
Authors in [25] used ultrasonic pulse echo to detect and better leakage detection. Despite introducing the theoretical
measure the corrosion of pipelines. A probe is used to structure for MI-based monitoring, deploying this system in
launch an ultrasonic pulse through the pipeline to be real life application needs much work. Mobile sensors move
36
with the fluid inside the pipe and detect and localize the leak [12] Z. Sun and I. F. Akyildiz, "Magnetic induction communications for
wireless underground sensor networks," Antennas and Propagation,
burst but in non-real time. MFL based stress testing
IEEE Transactions on, vol. 58, pp. 2426-2435, 2010.
provides low-magnetization level detection and speed [13] I. F. Akyildiz, P. Wang, and Z. Sun, "Realizing underwater
compensation however it requires high-performance sensor communication through magnetic induction," Communications
equipment. AE sensors are another important class of Magazine, IEEE, vol. 53, pp. 42-48, 2015.
[14] X. Tan, Z. Sun, and I. F. Akyildiz, "Wireless Underground Sensor
sensors used for pipeline monitoring as they can efficiently
Networks: MI-based communication systems for underground
detect and localize a gas leak. Remote pipeline monitoring applications," IEEE Antennas and Propagation Magazine, vol. 57,
using wireless sensor system has great potential for efficient pp. 74-87, 2015.
leakage detection and localization. However, there is still a [15] Y. Lijian, L. Gang, Z. Guoguang, and G. Songwei, "Sensor
need to improve its communication radius, efficiency and development and application on the oil-gas pipeline magnetic flux
leakage detection," in 2009 9th International Conference on
reliability. Electronic Measurement&Instruments, 2009.
[16] H. Kikuchi, K. Sato, I. Shimizu, Y. Kamada, and S. Kobayashi,
Acknowledgment "Feasibility study of application of MFL to monitoring of wall
thinning under reinforcing plates in nuclear power plants,"
We are thankful to COMSATS institute of information
Magnetics, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 47, pp. 3963-3966, 2011.
technology, Attock, Pakistan for providing the research [17] S. Bhadra, G. Bridges, and D. Thomson, "Coupled coil sensor for
facilities. We are also obliged to Higher Education detecting surface corrosion on steel reinforcement," in Antenna
Commission (HEC) Pakistan for providing Startup Research Technology and Applied Electromagnetics & the American
Electromagnetics Conference (ANTEM-AMEREM), 2010 14th
Grant Program (SRGP) funding to support this research
International Symposium on, 2010, pp. 1-4.
work. [18] E. Farjah, H. Givi, and T. Ghanbari, "Application of an efficient
Rogowski coil sensor for switch fault diagnosis and capacitor ESR
References monitoring in non-isolated single switch DC-DC converters," 2016.
[19] M. Crescentini, A. Romani, and E. Sangiorgi, "Physical simulations
[1] M. E. Stoica, L. Avram, I. Onutu, A. Barbulescu, C. Panaitescu, and of response time in Hall sensor devices," in Ultimate Integration on
T. Cristescu, "Time behaviour of hydrocarbon pollutants in soils Silicon (ULIS), 2014 15th International Conference on, 2014, pp.
polluted with oil and salt water," Revista de Chimie, vol. 67, pp. 89-92.
357-361, 2016. [20] T. Chang and K.-C. Juang, "CMOS SC-spinning, current-feedback
[2] Z. Sun, P. Wang, M. C. Vuran, M. A. Al-Rodhaan, A. M. Al- Hall sensor for high speed and low cost applications," in SENSORS,
Dhelaan, and I. F. Akyildiz, "MISE-PIPE: Magnetic induction-based 2014 IEEE, 2014, pp. 527-530.
wireless sensor networks for underground pipeline monitoring," Ad [21] J. Wang, L. Min, H. Qi, and C. Wang, "An over-coupled fused
Hoc Networks, vol. 9, pp. 218-227, 2011. coupler based acoustic emission sensor for detecting partial
[3] C. A. V. Junior, J. L. De Medeiros, and O. D. Q. F. Araújo, "ARX discharges," in Photonics and Optoelectronics (SOPO), 2012
modeling approach to leak detection and diagnosis," Journal of Loss Symposium on, 2012, pp. 1-4.
Prevention in the Process Industries, vol. 23, pp. 462-475, 2010. [22] M. Yifan, C. Xiwang, Y. Yong, M. Lin, and H. Xiaojuan, "Leakage
[4] A. Ostfeld, J. G. Uber, E. Salomons, J. W. Berry, W. E. Hart, C. A. detection in a CO 2 pipeline using Acoustic emission techniques," in
Phillips, et al., "The battle of the water sensor networks (BWSN): A Signal Processing (ICSP), 2014 12th International Conference on,
design challenge for engineers and algorithms," Journal of Water 2014, pp. 78-82.
Resources Planning and Management, vol. 134, pp. 556-568, 2008. [23] J. Yoon and D. He, "Planetary gearbox fault diagnostic method
[5] G. Oren and N. Stroh, "Antileaks: A device for detection and using acoustic emission sensors," Science, Measurement &
discontinuation of leakages in domestic water supply systems," Technology, IET, vol. 9, pp. 936-944, 2015.
European Journal for Young Scientist and Engineers, vol. 1, pp. 10- [24] S. Li, Y. Wen, P. Li, J. Yang, and L. Yang, "Leak detection and
13, 2012. location for gas pipelines using acoustic emission sensors," in
[6] A. Lambert, "International report: water losses management and Ultrasonics Symposium (IUS), 2012 IEEE International, 2012, pp.
techniques," Water Science and Technology: Water Supply, vol. 2, 957-960.
pp. 1-20, 2002. [25] B. Yang, M. Li, Q. Li, and Y. Lu, "Ultrasonic monitoring system for
[7] A. S. Almazyad, Y. M. Seddiq, A. M. Alotaibi, A. Y. Al-Nasheri, oil and gas pipeline corrosion," in 2012 Fourth International
M. S. BenSaleh, A. M. Obeid, et al., "A proposed scalable design Conference on Multimedia Information Networking and Security,
and simulation of wireless sensor network-based long-distance 2012, pp. 381-383.
water pipeline leakage monitoring system," Sensors, vol. 14, pp. [26] F. Li, Y. Liu, L. Wang, and Y. Chen, "Analysis of the coupling
3557-3577, 2014. optical fiber ultrasonic sensor for partial discharges detection," in
[8] X. Chen and P. Yu, "Research on hierarchical mobile wireless 2015 IEEE 11th International Conference on the Properties and
sensor network architecture with mobile sensor nodes," in Applications of Dielectric Materials (ICPADM), 2015, pp. 991-994.
Biomedical Engineering and Informatics (BMEI), 2010 3rd [27] Y. Wang and S. Li, "Non-destructive Testing of Pipeline Liquids
International Conference on, 2010, pp. 2863-2867. Using Ultrasonic Technology," in Optoelectronics and Image
[9] J.-H. Kim, G. Sharma, N. Boudriga, and S. S. Iyengar, "SPAMMS: Processing (ICOIP), 2010 International Conference on, 2010, pp.
A sensor-based pipeline autonomous monitoring and maintenance 43-46.
system," COMSNETS, vol. 10, pp. 118-127, 2010. [28] S. Qi, J. Liu, and G. Jia, "Study of submarine pipeline corrosion
[10] W. Gong, M. A. Suresh, L. Smith, A. Ostfeld, R. Stoleru, A. based on ultrasonic detection and wavelet analysis," in 2010
Rasekh, et al., "Mobile sensor networks for optimal leak and International Conference on Computer Application and System
backflow detection and localization in municipal water networks," Modeling (ICCASM 2010), 2010, pp. V12-440-V12-444.
Environmental Modelling & Software, vol. 80, pp. 306-321, 2016. [29] N. Nordin, M. Idroas, Z. Zakaria, and M. Ibrahim, "Tomographic
[11] L. Perelman and A. Ostfeld, "Operation of remote mobile sensors image reconstruction of monitoring flaws on gas pipeline based on
for security of drinking water distribution systems," Water research, reverse ultrasonic tomography," in Intelligent and Advanced
vol. 47, pp. 4217-4226, 2013. Systems (ICIAS), 2014 5th International Conference on, 2014, pp. 1-
6.
37