Strategic Thinking and Planning
Strategic Thinking and Planning
Mintzberg et al (2002)
What is Strategy?
1. Assess Situation
2. Formulate Goals and Strategies
3. Evaluate Strategies
4. Implement Strategy
5. Manage Performance
Assess
Analyze Review Vision Set Objectives,
Strategic
Environment & Mission KPIs & Targets
Choices
Manage
Budget and Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
Manage Empower
Resources Staff
Guide Promote
Decisions Accountability
Source (*) Strategic Performance Measurement & Management, Bus. Intelligence, Renaissance Worldwide
PARC1 Framework
Architecture Routines
People Culture
Organization
Talent
Architecture Routines
Motivations and fears
Structure
Architecture Routines
Boundaries
Decision-making
Assess
Analyze Review Vision Set Objectives,
Strategic
Environment & Mission KPIs & Targets
Choices
Manage
Budget & Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
• Segmentation
Customers • Income level
• Disruptive technologies
Competitors • Prices, distribution, location..
• Cost structure
Costs • Profitability
• Market structure
Context • Market forces
We aim to create value, and capture some of it. Porter’s 5 Forces help
us analyze the environment when:
1 2 3 4 5
Buyers
Value
Value YOU Captured
Created
YOU
Suppliers
Rivals, Entrants
Buyers
Buyers
Value YOU
YOU Value
Created YOU Captured
Suppliers
Suppliers
Substitutes
What
Developed by Albert Humphrey in the ‘60s & ‘70s
Why
Allows complex information to be presented
systematically
Cheap to implement
Who
SWOT analysis can be implemented at different levels:
Individual
Project
Business Unit
Company
Environmental
Analysis
Internal External
Environment Environment
Examples:
• Abundant financial reserves
• Strong brand equity
Strengths • Economies of scale
• Superior talent
Examples:
• Inefficient distribution
• Outdated technology
• Poor product image
Weaknesses • Under-trained employees
Examples:
• Rival firms are complacent
• Changing customer needs
• Economic boom
• Government deregulation
Opportunities
M02: Analysis of the Environment 15
What External Threats Loom over the Organization?
Examples:
• New product innovations
• New market entrants
• Changing customer needs
• Political instability
Threats
M02: Analysis of the Environment 16
SWOT Tips
Dos Do Nots
• Be specific • Disguise weaknesses
• Record all thoughts and • Lose sight of influences and
ideas trends
• Be selective in final • Allow SWOT to become a
evaluation blame-laying exercise
• Involve the right people • Ignore outcomes at later
• Communicate purpose and stages of strategic
benefits managament process
• Choose a suitable facilitator
• Be open to change
Strengths Weaknesses
Internal
High retention among management team Over dependent on debt
Key customer account acquired Lack of awareness amongst prospective
Diverse product portfolio customers
Impeccable safety record for past 3 years Small premises
Reliable IT infrastructure Absence of strong sales/marketing expertise
Strong connections with government No succession plans in place
Flat hierarchy allows quick decision-making High turnover among technical staff
Opportunities Threats
External
Market segment is poised for rapid growth Major player may enter market segment
Export markets offer great potential New technology may make products obsolete
Distribution channels can support new Economic slowdown could reduce demand
products Euro/Yen may weaken against $
Scope to diversify into related markets Market segment's growth could attract major
Increased government spending competition
Strengths Weaknesses
Internal
Experience, knowledge Gap in experience, knowledge
Unique characteristics Financial aspects
Resources Reliability and trust
Location Loss of key staff
Competence, capabilities
Quality, reputation
Opportunities Threats
External
Strengths Weaknesses
Internal
Internatinoally recognized brand High staff turnover
Global operations Minimal focus on organic foods
Prime store locations Limited variation in seasonal products
Lean operations Quality consistency concerns due to
Grade A ingredients franchised operations
Strong supplier relations Focus on products regarded as unhealthy
Opportunities Threats
External
PEDESTL Framework
Present to class.
Assess
Analyze Review Vision Set Objectives,
Strategic
Environment & Mission KPIs & Targets
Choices
Manage
Budget and Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
Vision Hallucination
“Dubai will be one of the leading business and tourist locations in the world”
- Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum (1990s)
“We should commit to landing a man on the moon and returning him safely
to the earth” - John F Kennedy (1960s)
Constituents of a mission:
Values should…
Support Be Worded
Vision/Mission Uniquely
Intangibles Number 4 to 7
Vision
To be the Middle East and Asia’s leading performer
In refining and petrochemicals with a passion for
the environment
Mission
Maximize added value and meet our
stakeholders’ expectations by:
• Building and operating a full conversion
refinery.
• Being reliable and cost efficient in our
business.
• Conforming to the highest safety, health,
environment and quality standards.
M03- Strategic Planning 16
SATORP 4-P Values
People
• We respect the diversity of our people and fully support their welfare. We
are committed to the development of our work force
Pride
• We take pride in what we do. We are committed to excellence, safety,
quality and environment.
Professionalism
• We conduct our business with competence in an ethical, responsible and
accountable manner.
Partnership
• We synergize with our stakeholders to build productive, collaborative and
trusting relationships. We adopt team spirit and openness to achieve our
business.
In 4 areas: Financial,
S.W.O.T. People, Process &
Customer
Measurability Scale
Analysis
Organizational
Strategic Training Needs
Goals
Performance
Appraisal
Strategic Core Corporate
Low Criteria
Plan Values Culture
Assess
Analyze Review Vision Set Objectives,
Strategic
Environment & Mission KPIs & Targets
Choices
Manage
Budget and Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
Competitive Advantage
• Something that gives the organization
advantage over its rivals in the market
• Technical competency, talented employees,
economies of scale etc.
• Give examples of specific firms
Cost Advantage
• Strategy to secure a cost advantage of some
kind
• Lower fixed cost, lower average cost per unit,
lower labor cost etc.
• Give example of specific firms
Market Dominance
• Internal growth
• Acquisitions and takeovers
• Give examples of specific firms
Contraction/Expansion
• Focus on what you are good at
• Seek to expand in a range of markets
• Give examples of specific firms
Price Leadership
• Through dominating the industry
• Others will follow you
• Give examples of specific firms
Global
• Seek to expand globally
• Give examples of specific firms
M02- Strategic Managment 7
Types of Strategy
Restructuring
• Complete re-thing of the way the
business is organized
• Give examples of specific firms
Guy Laliberté
CEO
Street
Net Worth
Performer Value Innovation = USD2.6 Billion
(Fire Eater)
Manage
Budget & Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
Company
Objectives Key Result Areas
(KRAs)
Department
Objectives
Key Performance
Indicators (KPIs)
Individual
Objectives
Performance
Reward
Monitoring
Strategic Objective
Strategic Objective
Vision Mission
Strategic KPIs (SKPIs) Targets
Strategic Objective
No Rules
How Many
Range from 4 to 12
Objectives?
The fewer, the better
Long Term
Broad Scope
Criteria Converts Mission to Action (All 4 Perspectives)
Consistent and Aligned
Sustains Strategy (Competitive Advantage)
Enhance localization
Financial
Perspective
How Do We Look To
Resource Providers?
Vision
Customer Internal Process
Perspective Mission Perspective
How Do Customers Are We Efficient and
See Us? Effective?
Are We Competent?
M5 - Strategic Objectives, KPIs & Targets 8
Balanced Scorecard – A Strategic Tool
Financial
KRAs KPIs TARGETS INITIATIVES
Results
Competencies
Values
Percentage
Number
%
Index Score Ratio …
KRAs KPIs
• # of Customer Complaints
Service Quality • # of Quality Initiative Introduced
• Defect Ratio
KRAs KPIs
Cost effective
Owned by one
to monitor and Verifiable
individual
report
KPI: Percent
increase in Company’s strategic
KPI: Percent
quarterly objective: “Achieve
increase in
customer Profitable Growth”
gross margin
subscriptions
Lead Lag
Customer
Internal
Learning
Assess
Analyze Review Vision Set Objectives,
Strategic
Environment & Mission KPIs & Targets
Choices
Manage
Budget & Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
Definition of Initiative
Ask “How do we
2+ Initiatives Focus on
Achieve a Finite Time Line
per KPI Outputs
Target?”
KPI/Target Initiative
Identify Optimal Routes
KPI: % increase in distribution
channels Upgrade Infrastructure
Target: 20%
Overhaul Information Systems
Tracks progress
Assess
Analyze Review Vision Set Objectives,
Strategic
Environment & Mission KPIs & Targets
Choices
Manage
Budget & Create Action
Performance/
Implement Plans
Refresh
Monthly Measure
Quarterly
Bi-Annually
Annually
Performance
Management
Year: 2010
Participants: +1,000 HBR
Only
23%
...blamed economic conditions for
limiting their ability to execute strategy
ONLY
53% ...of
implementers
cannot state
the company’s
strategy in full
+
Not Making Strategy
Weak Leadership Meaningful
Importance of obstacle
Resistance to Change
_
Popularity of response +
M06: Developing Operating Plans 18
Survey Conclusion