1.0 Introduction: World Recognition
1.0 Introduction: World Recognition
Brodrick Report:
“According to the evidence received the basis of forensic pathology is the small
amount of work which, although it is carried out on behalf of the coroner, is
particularly the concern of the police. Every police force needs to be able to
call on the services of a specially experienced pathologist to help in the
investigation of murder and other serious crimes against the person. Ideally,
this person should be a pathologist with a sound training in morbid anatomy
who has added to this general knowledge some additional skills, most notably
the ability to detect, and give authoritative testimony about, unusual features
of a dead body and the surrounding circumstances which may well be of
evidential value. He should be able to command the facilities of a well
equipped pathological laboratory, be readily available on call to police and
courts, and be prepared to travel at short notice anywhere in the area which
he serves.”
Do the police need the services of a special kind of pathologist who can for the
most part be distinguished from a clinical pathologist in a hospital? Do coroners
need the services of the same kind of pathologist as the police? Our answer to
both questions is an unequivocal
1
Pathology is the study and diagnosis of disease. The word pathology is from
Greek πάθος, pathos, "feeling, suffering"; and -λογία, -logia, "the study of".
Pathologists are biological or medical scientists who study the nature, causes,
and effects of disease in plant and animal life. Pathology is a broad field that
concentrates on the changes in organs, tissues, and cells that are caused by
disease.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathology)
2
physicians who have received specialized training in pathology. They are sometimes
called medical pathologists or are classified according to their subspecialty, such as
oral pathology.
3
observation when they investigate injuries or deaths. Pathologists also do scientific
research into drugs and disease. Laboratories developing new drugs need
pathologists to study their safety. Pathologists use microscopes, radioisotopes, and
other equipment to study the cause of disease. They also use scientific methods and
computerized data as they test theories about disease processes. Cancer,
atherosclerosis, allergies, and birth defects are among the many diseases being
studied by medical pathologists.
4
improving our food, fiber, and lumber supplies and in preserving the ornamental
plants and trees that make our environment more healthful and attractive. Plant
pathologists use many of the same kinds of laboratory equipment and scientific
methods that medical and animal pathologists use. Plant pathologists teach and do
research in colleges and universities. They work for government agencies and
private firms involved in agriculture, horticulture, forestry, and related fields.
(http://careers.stateuniversity.com/pages/412/Pathologist.html)
5
about the processes of disease and death. Specialists in this field do everything from
examining biopsy samples taken by surgeons to determine whether or not a growth
is cancerous to examining the bodies of murder victims to determine the cause of
death and collect evidence which could be used in investigation and prosecution.
The term “pathology” translates into “the study of suffering,” and this medical
discipline is focused on examining the nature, course, and resolution of disease. In
order to become an anatomic pathologist, someone must attend medical school and
complete a residency in general pathology, followed by a focus in anatomic
pathology. The other main area of focus in the field of pathology is clinical pathology,
in which samples of body fluids are examined in the laboratory.
There are a number of subspecialties within the anatomic pathology field. For
example, someone could focus on neuropathology, the examination of brain tissue,
or cytopathology, the study of samples of cells. When a doctor takes a Pap smear
from a woman, the examination of the tissue is often performed by a cytopathologist.
Other specialties include molecular pathology, gynecological pathology, endocrine
pathology, dermatopathology, cardiac pathology, osteopathology, and autopsy or
forensic pathology.
One of the more unique specialties within the field of anatomic pathology is
autopsy pathology, which involves the study of deceased individuals to learn how
they died. Autopsies are routinely requested in cases where a death is suspicious, or
when the cause of death is unclear. In forensic pathology, the pathologist studies the
body to learn not only how the person died, but when. This branch of pathology also
focuses on the collection of legal evidence.
Work in the field of anatomic pathology can be varied and quite rewarding.
Candidates interested in working in this area of medicine need to have excellent
attention to detail, along with great descriptive skills which will allow them to
6
communicate clearly in pathology results. It can also help to have a high tolerance
for unpleasant sights and strong odors, as these frequently crop up in pathology
laboratories.
(http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-anatomic-pathology.htm)
7
Forensic pathology is a branch of the field of pathology which applies the
principles of pathology to the legal profession. Forensic pathologists specialize in
examining bodies and evidence such as body fluids and tissue samples for the
purpose of gathering information which can be used in criminal investigation and
court trials. They are sometimes known as medical examiners, coroners, or simply
pathologists, depending on the region where they work.
Some people think that the term “forensics” refers to forensic pathology, which
generates considerable confusion when forensic accountants, forensic document
examiners, forensic psychiatrists, and other forensics professionals are discussed.
“Forensic” actually comes from the Latin forum, and it means “pertaining to a trial.”
The field of forensics was developed in the 1800s, when people began applying
scientific methods to criminal investigation and legal trials.
The field of pathology in general is focused on the study of disease and its
processes. A specialist in forensic pathology has training in this field, with additional
skills which can be applied to the legal field. For example, he or she can examine a
body to determine the cause of death, but the pathologist can also look for other
clues and information, such as defensive marks on the hands which might indicate
that the victim fought back while being attacked.
8
witness stand in some cases, and in some instances, a specialist in forensic
pathology may be retained by the defense for the purpose of refuting claims made by
the specialist who works for the government or the prosecution.
(http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-forensic-pathology.htm)
2.3 SUMMARIZING
Pathology 9
as specialist
The doctor that practices both
Clinical Pathologist Anatomical
is called Pathologist
GENERAL PATHOLOGIST
Sub-specialities
Dermatopathology Neuropathologist
10
Clinical pathology is a medical specialty that is concerned with the
diagnosis of disease based on the laboratory analysis of bodily fluids such as
blood and urine, and tissues using the tools of chemistry, microbiology,
hematology and molecular pathology. Clinical pathologists work in close
collaboration with medical technologists hospital administrations and referring
physicians to ensure the accuracy and optimal utilization of laboratory testing.
Whilst it is certainly true that the difference between a clinical pathologist and
a forensic pathologist is in the nature of the person performing the task as well as the
nature of the work, it is not true to say that forensic pathology can be carried
out only by medical practitioners with a certain type of personality. Instead, this
personal aspect of the difference between clinical and forensic pathologists is
accounted for by training and experience. The forensic pathologist has to be
trained in, and develop an understanding and aptitude for, the legal process of
investigation in conjunction with their knowledge of the scientific process of
investigation. These two approaches to investigating matters are quite distinct and
few medical practitioners have any real understanding of or feel for the legal
investigative method. It is a knowledge of the role that legal systems play in
society, as well as an understanding of the legal process and legal method, that
distinguish forensic pathologists from their clinical counterparts. Certainly there are
11
areas of specialist factual knowledge that forensic pathologists are familiar with
that their clinical counterparts are not.
12
In order to examine the role of the forensic pathologist, it is essential to
understand the development of death investigation systems including the role the
coroner plays in such jurisdictions. The office of coroner has its roots in Norman
times where death investigation had associated with it important political and
financial considerations. Coroners were associated with the collection of a number
of fines and taxes that could be levied by the Crown in association with certain types
of deaths. Deodands comprised taxes paid to the Crown that were based on the
financial value of the implement or object that had caused a person's unnatural
death, so that if a person was run over by a cart, the cart or its value was forfeited to
the Crown as a tax and the coroner was responsible for ensuring that the tax was
paid. Similarly the fine of presentment of Englishry was payable by a local
community if the coroner found that a deceased person was not of English blood.
The role of the coroner in criminal matters relating to death was limited,
although the coroner had the ability to ensure that potential criminal matters
were brought within the criminal justice system. Their main function in relation to
crime was to keep a check on the sheriff and to ensure that revenues such as
fines reached the King. With regard to the prevention of deaths, the coroner had
little or no direct function, although some early coroners made attempts to
highlight hazards in the community and to reduce their impact.
Over time, the coroner's role diminished and the office became an onerous
one with the coroner having to pay many of the fees associated with the work out of
his own pocket. Early coroners were not necessarily medically or legally trained, and
many of the early coroners’ appointments were essentially political rather than
professional.
13
involved only with the investigation of suspicious deaths that may have a criminal
connotation. Instead, the forensic pathologists role has been widened to include a
wide range of natural and unintentional deaths, investigation of which, can lead to
improvements in the health and safety of the community. In conjunction with the
coroner, the forensic pathologist is a watchdog who maintains a constant
surveillance on potential fatal hazards in our society and ensures that preventable
deaths are recognized and the issues surrounding them addressed.
14
You need advanced training to become a pathologist. As an undergraduate,
you should major in premedical studies, a biological science, chemistry, or a related
field. It generally takes four years to earn a bachelor's degree and another one or
two years to obtain a master's degree.
Medical pathologists usually go to medical school for four years after they
graduate from college. They receive the degree of doctor of medicine (M.D.). In
some cases they spend six years in medical school and earn a doctoral degree
in pathology in addition to their medical degree.
(http://careers.stateuniversity.com/pages/412/Pathologist.html)
15
5.1 SURGICAL PATHOLOGY
Surgical pathology is the most significant and time-consuming area of practice for
most anatomical pathologists. Surgical pathology involves the gross and microscopic
examination of surgical specimens, as well as biopsies submitted by non-surgeons
such as general internists, medical subspecialists, dermatologists, and interventional
radiologists. Surgical pathology increasingly requires technologies and skills
traditionally associated with clinical pathology such as molecular diagnostics.
5.3 CYTOPATHOLOGY
Cytopathology is a sub-discipline of anatomical pathology concerned with the
microscopic examination of whole, individual cells obtained from smears or fine
needle aspirates. Cytopathologists are trained to perform fine-needle aspirates of
superficially located organs, masses, or cysts, and are often able to render an
immediate diagnosis in the presence of the patient and consulting physician. In the
case of screening tests such as the Papanicolaou smear, non-physician
cytotechnologists are often employed to perform initial reviews, with only positive or
uncertain cases examined by the pathologist. Cytopathology is a board-certifiable
subspecialty in the U.S.
17
5.6 DERMATOPATHOLOGY
Dermatopathology is a subspecialty of anatomic pathology that focuses on the skin
as an organ. It is unique in that there are two routes which a physician can use to
obtain this specialization. All general pathologists and general dermatologists are
trained in the pathology of the skin; however, the dermatopathologist is a specialist in
this organ. In the USA, either a general pathologist or a dermatologist can undergo a
1 to 2 year fellowship in the field of dermatopathology. The completion of this
fellowship allows one to take a subspecialty board examination, and becomes a
board certified dermatpathologist.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomical_pathology)
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathology)
18
6.0 FAQS : PATHOLOGY & FORENSIC PATHOLOGY
3 Q. Wow! Thirteen to fifteen years after high school before you can get a
job? To hell with that!
A. It's not as bad as it sounds. Of course you have to pay tuition and living
expenses for the eight years of college and med school, but residents and
fellows earn a decent living wage (about $26,000/yr to start). From what I've
seen, the people who get in trouble financially are those that insist on starting
families while still in school and borrow a lot of money to finance a middle-
class, American-dream lifestyle. When they finally finish training, they are
beset with the payback of onerous loans. On the other hand, if you're single,
live in not-the-best neighborhoods, and split expenses with housemates, med
school is very affordable, even fun.
4 Q. What do forensic pathologists do at work?
A. Forensic pathologists split their time among
1) performing autopsies,
3) testifying in court.
Occasionally they may visit scenes of crimes or accidents, but I think this is
uncommon for most.
5 Q. What personality characteristics are required in a good forensic
pathologist?
A. Varying combinations of the following ingredients:
A talent for and interest in science. This should include not only
biology, but physics, chemistry, and the social sciences (anthropology
and psychology). For the bread-and-butter technical part of your work,
19
you should especially have a good grasp of spatial relationships.
Good communication skills. You will not only be interacting with law
officers, but you'll be trying to convince judges and juries that your
findings are valid.
Strong stomach. You'll be routinely dealing with dismembered and/or
rotting bodies. From a pure visceral standpoint there is no job more
disgusting than forensic pathology.
Thick skin. You will be periodically raked over the coals by the local
media, who apparently cannot to resist the urge to armchair-
quarterback your work. You will also make many enemies among the
citizenry. For instance, when you determine that Daddy killed himself,
and he wasn't poisoned by that blond bimbo who was only interested in
his money, you are going to have some very angry children buzzing
around you.
The mind of a detective. You will have to constantly be on guard
against being fooled by malefactors smarter and more focused than
you. You will have to have some insight into the heart and mind of a
criminal.
The choice of college is a little more important. I am going to tell you right off
that I have a strong bias against two-year colleges (from which you could
theoretically transfer to complete your premedical education at a four-year
college). These are cold, dismal places populated by desperate students
whose joie de vivre was left behind years ago. At eighteen, you don't need
this.
This leaves four-year liberal arts colleges, which I highly recommend. Believe
me, twenty years later, you'll be happy you made this choice. I think the
college education is the single most important (but least appreciated) part of
20
one's education. Its value is subtle, though, and it may take decades for its
promise to flower.
Medical school is an easy choice: go to the cheapest one you can get into.
The quality of education is the same in every U.S. school. You have the same
textbooks, the same human bodies with the same diseases, and the same
quality of faculty. Unfortunately, faculty members in med schools are not hired
or promoted based on their teaching skills, but on their practice skills and
research accomplishments. Don't get me wrong; there are plenty of excellent
medical educators, but you never know where they'll turn up.
You have the satisfaction of not only helping to put criminals away, but of
comforting grieving families, thus, "It was over very quickly. She did not
suffer."
(http://web2.airmail.net/uthman/forensic_career.html)
21
7.0 BIBILIOGRAPHY
22