N. Barton / International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences 39 (2002) 185-216 187
N. Barton / International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences 39 (2002) 185-216 187
Barton / International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences 39 (2002) 185–216 187
The first two quotients RQD=Jn and Jr =Ja are often development of the Q-parameters. This was in order to
used in a stope design method in the mining industry, calibrate and re-calibrate the ratings, to match the final
but their representation of ‘relative block size’ and Q-value with the support and reinforcement needs.
‘inter-block shear resistance’ are not sufficient descrip- Parameter ratings needed successive fine-tuning, to
tions of the degree of instability. The possible presence bring the ‘all-encompassing’ Q-value into reasonable
of water and of faults or adverse stress (both too high or correspondence with the necessary level of rock re-
too low) also needs to be included, at least when these inforcement (fully grouted rock bolts) and with the
are present [2]. The original difficulty of matching necessary level of shotcrete or concrete support for
support needs when using only four or five of the the excavated perimeters (arch, walls and sometimes
original parameters were used, is also recalled. the invert as well).
The development of the Q-system in the early 1970s The early set of 212 case records were derived from a
[3], followed a period of pre-occupation with the shear period (approximately 1960–1973) when plain shotcrete
strength of rock joints and of clay-filled discontinuities. (S), or steel-mesh reinforced shotcrete, termed S(mr), or
Perhaps for this reason the three rock-to-rock contact cast concrete arches, termed CCA, were used for tunnel
categories of Jr and Ja (seen in Tables A3 and A4 in the and cavern support, together with various types of rock
appendix) seem to ensure a sensible weighting of this bolts. Since the 1993 update of support recommenda-
most important of rock mass parameters, namely the tions with 1050 new case records [5], the superficial
shear resistance of the least favourable joints or filled support has undergone a revolutionary improvement to
discontinuities. The potentially dilatant character of mostly steel-fibre reinforced sprayed concrete, termed
many joints, and the often contractile character of filled S(fr) in place of S(mr). Cured cube strength qualities
discontinuities, is captured in the ratio Jr =Ja ; which of 35–45 MPa or more are now readily available
resembles a dilatant or contractile coefficient of friction. with wet process, microsilica-bearing, and non-alkali
The original 212 case records of tunnels and caverns accelerated sprayed concrete. The updated Q-support
from 50 different rock types [4], were each analysed chart is shown in Fig. 1. The new case records were
several times, during the six month period needed for collected over a period of several years by Grimstad