Research Project Managment Ver 2
Research Project Managment Ver 2
net/publication/297974506
CITATIONS READS
0 827
1 author:
Salem Alsuwaidan
King Fahad Medical City
24 PUBLICATIONS 216 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Salem Alsuwaidan on 23 May 2017.
It is with great pleasure to introduce this project entitle “Research Project management” to
contribute ideas for the enrichment of clinical research with well-being management. This
book will be an ideal tool to find a systemic approach for the management of clinical research,
and to maintain with the right path of good clinical practice and the ethical principles stated in
the Declaration of Helsinki. This book aimed to encourage all health researchers to work with
utmost professionalism and according to good clinical practice (GCP) in conducting of scientific
research.
Clinical trials involves trial subjects, their safety, rights, integrity, confidentiality and respect on
one hand and research team and how to conduct a clinical trial, planning, executing, managing
and controlling on the other hand. A combination of clinical research care with the main
principles of professional project management will justify the potential research outcome,
therapeutic value for the patient and to produce significant health care improvement.
Further, this book will explain the guidelines for conducting a clinical research which in
principles to increase the ethical awareness and improve clinical research management, in
addition to improve the quality standards. Moreover, it will promote the concept of the
clinical trials in the community and increase the number of participants as trial subjects. This
book is also could serve as a guideline for the scope of work for all health researchers to work
1
professionally according to the good clinical practice. It could be a reference textbook in all
universities with health school to show how to manage clinical research activities and to know
how to plan a clinical research in simple way. Indeed this book serves as example for applied
It is the first book ever (up to my knowledge) using the combination of both, clinical research
and professional project management, to produce a useful tool to all health researchers to do
their research in a professional way and according to the GCP standards. It is expected to be
utilize by most if not all health schools (and universities) including medical, pharmacy, nursing,
public health, epidemiology, and other. This will also embrace Food and Drug Administration
(FDA), and all drug regulatory authorities in the world which recognize practicing health
research according to GCP–ICH Harmonized tripartite guideline. Most if not all of the clinical
research organization such as SCT “Society for Clinical Trials”, SOCRA “the Society of Clinical
Research Organization” and many others are giving courses about GCP as “A standard for the
clinical trials” and “that provides assurance that the data and reported results are credible
and accurate, and that the rights, integrity, and confidentiality of trial subjects are protected”.
Author
Salem Alsuwaidan
2
Research Project Management
“A clinical research with
professional project management approach”
By
Salem Alsuwaidan
3
Preface
Up to my knowledge and after a lot of research during preparation of this book, this is the first
research project using project management for professionals as a tool to manage research
activities. In this book there is a combination of project management for professional and
The reader of this book may go to the exact terms which have been used in project
management for professional, yet it reflects a systematic account on what is happening in the
management of research. Utilization of this book is quite easy for all those who have a little
concern about research, student for any health colleges, and of course any researcher may use
it as a manual to guide for best research practices. It also can be utilize to draft policies and
procedure for any new institution would start doing research whether if it is clinical or non-
clinical research.
This book also could be used as a core material to teach how to be a research coordinator or
research assistant. The material of this book will teach all research coordinator on how to do
their work on day-to day business. Moreover, it will explain what any researcher should do to
conduct a clinical research whether if it is simple or very complicated and this research will be
conducted according to the good clinical practice. Lastly this book will unify the standard of
our research activities. This book explains the research life cycle and how is the processes to
conduct a clinical research from writing the proposal until writing a manuscript with a similar
4
process to project management this process was similar to the process of project
management.
Sequentially, a similar steps were taken for this book to conduct a clinical research project and
project management one by one. Five steps were taken to conduct any project and here it is
used five steps for research life cycle to conduct a clinical research project.
Initiation: that is to create a new idea and define the research project and identify the
Planning that is to establish the scope of clinical research project, define and refine the
objective, when where how to develop road map to conduct a clinical research.
Executing that is the long step to process the methodology and to perform a good
Monitoring and controlling that is to review and track the progress of research and how
Closing that is the final step in research life cycle to show how to perform the final steps
in a clinical research and how to submit a comprehensive budget analysis report , how
5
to submit the final report to the sponsor and a work breakdown structure on how to
write a manuscript.
Certainly, conducting of clinical research in compliance with international standards and the
guideline of good clinical practice is the greatest approach to promote clinical and research
Salem Alsuwaidan
Director of operation
Prince Naif Health Research Center
King Saud University, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
[email protected]
[email protected]
6
TABEL OF CONTENT
Chapter 1. Introduction 9
Introduction 10
Related references 17
Research Life Cycle 19
Reference 24
Glossary 25
Appendices
WHO Consent Form 30
Case Report Form 36
Chapter 2. Initiation 61
Initiation 62
Financial Aspects 69
Appendices
Research Fund Application 73
Checklist for CRM Responsibility 74
Questions and Answers 75
Chapter 3. Planning 79
Planning 80
How to draft a work plan 83
Definition of goal, aim, objective and purpose 84
Identify how to process the research methodology 85
Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) 85
Consider ordering your work plan by "SMART" objectives 86
Ghant Chart 89
Draft a work plan after changes 90
Reporting system 91
List of resources 94
Write a manuscript 94
Reference 96
Questions and Answers 97
Appendices
Work Breakdown Structure for research proposal (Excel sheet) 101
Work Breakdown Structure for research proposal (Tree model) 103
Ghant Project Planner 104
7
Chapter 4. Research Methodology/ Execution 105
Research Methodology/ Execution 106
General Consideration 107
Professional Responsibility 107
Research Integration Management 108
Research Scope Management 111
Project Time Management 112
Research Project Cost Management 115
Research Quality Management 117
Project Human Resource Management 120
Research Communication Management 127
Research Risk Management 129
Research Procurement Management 131
Research Team Management 133
Reference 135
Questions and Answers 137
8
Chapter 1.
Introduction
Research Project Manager
9
Introduction
The scenario of this project came from amalgamation of both good clinical practice (GCP) the
project management for professional (PMP); since all research studies and clinical trials are
considered as research project then we have to prepare and formulate a “Research Manager”
for research projects with specific job description for what are the steps to follow to get a
successful and completed clinical trials. In-fact, writing this book depends on two main
references articles namely: “A guide to the project management body of knowledge: (PMBOK
guide)” project management for professional and “Clinical Trials Requirement Guideline
(version 1.3)”, Drug sector, Saudi Food and Drug Authority, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Clinical researchers may be characterized with someone who have a clinical background and is
able to apply his/her knowledge, skills, and technique to manage clinical research activities.
They are individuals who can lead the research team to complete the process of a research
project in the right direction. Compromising project management skills together with good
clinical practice will meet stakeholder needs, wants and expectation. More importantly, they
should possess the knowledge and skills to identify project management processes with
information needed to initiate, plan, execute, monitor and control and close a single research
10
project in a timely manner that will enhance the success over a wide range of research
projects.
patients and other volunteers) in order to discover or verify the effects of and/or identify any
metabolism and excretion of the products with the object of ascertaining their efficacy and
safety. Projects may include industries, information technology, and businesses, such as
product manufacture, transport and infrastructure, and building and construction. While
research project for clinical studies involved human subject to discover or verify the
medical device. Subjects involved in clinical trials may be patients or healthy people, or both.
Project management is the application of knowledge, skills, tools, and techniques to project
activities to meet the project requirements. The primary challenge of project management is
to achieve all specific goals and objectives and meet specific success criteria; while the primary
constraints are scope, time, quality and budget. Project management is accomplished through
the appropriate application includes a number of elements, which are categorized into five
process groups.
11
Monitoring
Initiating Planning Executing and Closing
Controlling
There are several types of research management (RM) structures in organizations, each varying
in the degree of control and influence they have on projects within the organization, such as:
Project management is aimed at producing an end-product that will effect some change for
the benefit of the organization that instigated the project. It is the initiation, planning and
control of a range of tasks required to deliver this end product, which could be a physical
product, it could be new software or something less tangible like a new way of working. The
control imposed by a formal approach is essential when there are complexities such as new
where teams are located in different parts of the world; all common occurrences in many
12
business projects.
A key factor that distinguishes project management from just management is that it has this
final deliverable and a finite timespan, unlike management which is an ongoing process.
Because of this, a project manager needs a wide range of skills; often technical skills, certainly
• Identifying requirements;
deliverables;
There are standard project management processes used to plan and control tasks, budgets
and schedules, to communicate between the different people involved and deal with risks.
These processes are usually ongoing throughout the project. Also, there are various phases of
a project that will have a defined start and end within the overall project lifespan. For
instance, the requirements gathering phase often occurs in the early part of the project. So a
project has a range of processes that occur throughout it life (monitoring, controlling,
communicating etc.) and a range of phases (initiation, requirements, planning etc.) that occur
roughly chronologically.
Research manager should know the strategies to manage research project and how to
facilitate relationships between the research team and others in all phases of the research
projects from writing proposal to publication. Also to know and describe every step in the
project life cycle in depth, so the research project manager will know exactly which tasks to
14
complete, when and how. Whether they are experts or novices, it helps to complete tasks
Research Project Managers should have overall understanding of all aspects of clinical
research and how is the research team familiar to their jobs. This understanding helps
sponsors and funding agencies to communicate seamlessly with the clinical researchers and
project team members to ensure that project objectives, work plans, and priorities are met.
Effective project managers require a balance of ethical, interpersonal, and conceptual skills
that help them analyze situations and interact appropriately. Also requires important
Leadership
Team
Coaching
building
Conflict
Management
Motivation
Interpersonal
Trust
Skills
Communication
building
Negotiation Influence
Political
and Decision
Cultural Making
awareness
15
The ability of a Clinical Research Project Manager (CRM) to manage all aspects of a clinical trial
significantly impacts the time and cost taken to develop a drug or medical device. It is
important that a Research Project Manager is a well-rounded individual. These CRMs will be
required to have a high set of skills, tools and knowledge that is proficient in clinical research.
This allows research project management to efficiently lead the trial outcome from the start of
the project. A Project Manager must also have the ability to appropriately act, respond and
adapt to developing situations during a clinical trial. The project manager is the person
assigned by the performing organization to lead the team that is responsible for achieving the
project objectives.
Feasibility assessments for a research study is likely to be with potential benefit. That is if the
investigator achieve the goals of the clinical study represent a common sense that will be
converted in sharing the development and innovation. The second choice that if the
investigator identify possible problems in the worst case scenarios that will be another
achievement to keep away from this treatment. The feasibility assessment focuses on the
degree significant of the clinical research technically, within the budget, and on the planned
time frame.
16
References
1. Clinical research associate: Job description | Prospects.ac.uk. Available at
www.prospects.ac.uk/clinical_research_associate_job_description.htm
3. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Clinical Trials and Human Subject Protection
www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RunningClinicalTrials/ May 28, 2015 - Good
Clinical Practice in FDA-Regulated Clinical Trials.
10.A guide to the project management body of knowledge: (PMBOK guide) – Fifth edition
2013. Project management Institution, Inc. 14 Campus Boulevard, Newtown Square,
Pennsylvania 19073-3299 USA.
11.A project managers guide to successful projects. Brent W. Knapp, PMP. Aligned with
PMBOK Guide Sturgeon Publishing 2005.
12.Practice Standard for Work Breakdown Structures 2nd ed. 2006. Project management
Institution, Inc. 4 Campus Boulevard, Newtown Square, Pennsylvania 19073-3299 USA.
13.Points to consider when assessing the feasibility of research. The Association of Medical
Research Charities (AMRC) and NIHR Medicines for Children Research Network
17
14.who.int/rpc/research_ethics/informed_consent/
15.A Project Management Primer or “a guide on how to make projects work”. Nick Jenkins,
2005.
18
RESEARCH LIFE CYCLE
This book is offering an archive containing a combination materials of good clinical practice or
clinical trials requirement and project managers for professional. Most if not all previous work
related to research project management have breakdown their work to small divisions or
stages. For a typical research proposal, the stages include development of the research
proposal; its peer-review; carrying out of the experiment; and processing, analysis and
interpretation of the data which is eventually reported and published in various forms as
research outputs. In addition to these familiar phases, we have incorporated several idealized
stages to cater for the long-term management and availability of scientific data; these include
appraisal and quality control; documentation including metadata and contextual information;
storage, archive, preservation and curation; and IPR, embargo and access control [1].
There is no specific definition for research life cycle, but I don’t agree with “Research data
management covers all phases of the research lifecycle” because research data management
does not include research operation where budget, procurement and logistics and human
resource play a major part in research life cycle [2, 3]. Most of the universities and research
institutions have similar approach (more or less) for the steps of life cycle such as:
1. Initial concept
19
Review of existing data sources, determine if project will produce new data or
3. Project Start Up
4. Data Collection
6. Data Analysis
7. Data Sharing
20
8. End of Project
Research life cycle is a model trying to explain individuals on how is the research project to be
conducted. The research life-cycle implies the steps of whole clinical trial or research study,
and to search for what are the keys to manage this research. Project management is the how
to carefully project or plan, organize, motivate and control resources to achieve specific goals
Clinical project management is to achieve all of the project aims and objectives and to find
alternative plan for constrains and obstacles [5]. This objective is similar to research project
manager.
Research life cycle is an overall meaning for the preparing the initial concepts, planning,
research methodologies and analysis until closing. The appropriate application and integration
of a research project management processes are categorized into five Process Groups.
These five Process Groups may called steps of research cycle identified as:
21
Initiation: Those processes performed to define a new research project or a
new phase of an existing clinical trial or project by obtaining authorization to
start the project or phase.
22
Executing: Those processes performed to complete the work defined in the
project management plan to satisfy the project specifications.
23
References:
1. I2S2 Idealised Scientific Research Activity Lifecycle Model; www.ukoln.ac.uk/.../I2S2-
ResearchActivityLifecycleModel-110407.
24
Glossary
Project: a Project is a temporary endeavor design undertaken to create a unique product,
service or result. Temporary means having a definite beginning and end (usually time-
constrained, and often constrained by funding or deliverables) undertaken to meet unique
goals and objectives. The end is reached when the project’s objectives have been achieved, or
if the project is terminated for any reason.
Project Manager Operational Manager
Role ends with project Routine
Temporary team Stable organization
Many different skills Specialist skills
Work not done before Work repeatable
Time, cost and scope constraints Annual planning cycle
Unique goals and objectives Multiple purposes
Difficult to estimate time and budget Budgets set and fixed events
Protects the deliverables (time, cost, Protects the Service (capacity, budget,
Quality) availability
Tasks are specific for that for that project Tasks are repetitive, routine and cyclical
and have never been done before
Implement revolutionary change Implement evolutionary change
Teams are formed to implement projects Teams are consistent
and then disbanded once the project is
completed
Teams consist of team members from Teams frequently consist of team members
different departments , different skill sets with similar technical skill sets
Examples: Example:
- A university hospital designs and
constructs a new clinic (s). - Caring for patients at the
- A diabetic structured self- bedside in a hospital or
management program using prolongation of hospital stay.
monitoring devices that - Day to day follow-up activities
electronically send blood sugar that a physician and his/her
level and blood pressure directly patients engage in on a daily
to physician. In the beginning it basis for the purposes of
is a project after implementing providing a good care.
the program it will be an - Ongoing research
operation because it will be a
routine activity.
- Clinical Trials
25
Operation: An ongoing work effort is generally a repetitive process because it follows an
organization’s existing procedures. The ongoing execution of activities that produce the same
result or product repetitively is what operations is all about.
Operations are permanent initiatives that produce repetitive results, with resources assigned
to do the same set of tasks and produce a standard output. In the life of a product, there will
be many projects to improve the product, add new features etc. and these projects will come
and go as required. The underlying production of the product will continue as usual, although
there will be refinements done and included in the product over the period.
Projects require project management, while operations require business process management
or operations management. Projects and Operations will interact with each other at key points
in a product’s life cycle.
Research Team: is one or a group of workers that have the impact to execute the
methodology according to the instruction of the PI. This team constructed from (PI+ co-PI +
sub-PI).
Research consulting Team: Consultants individual that have the ability to provide a
consultation to a research project such Biostatistician, Epidemiologist, consultant or professor
from the same field.
Research support team: is one or a group of coworkers that have the impact to execute the
methodology according to the instruction of the research team such as Technologists, Nurses
phlebotomists, etc.
Sponsor: A sponsor is the person or organization who provides financial resources and support
for the research project and is accountable for enabling success. The sponsor may be external
or internal, individual or group, government or private sector, to the project manager’s
organization.
Research Project Manager also known as clinical research project manager (CRM): The
research project manager is the person assigned by the organization to lead the team that is
responsible for achieving the research objectives. CRM is reporting to the principle
investigator while the research is conducting and after completing the clinical research will
report to the research organization. CRM has responsibilities for over-seeing all aspects of the
day-today activities in pursuit of a project, including coordinating staff, allocating resources,
managing the budget, and coordinating overall efforts to achieve a specific, desired result.
26
Research Technician: To perform and report a variety of laboratory procedures as assigned
and as needed for research and diagnostics.
Research Coordinator: To coordinate and facilitate various assigned clinical research projects
to ensure its compliance of the institutional policies and procedures according to GCP and the
international standards.
Main investigator (MI): is the scientific leader for a multi-center research project, should have
the main responsibility to select the research center, principle investigator(s), in a multi-center
study in addition to all aspects concerning a clinical research project.
Principle investigator (PI): is the lead scientist for a particular well-defined research project,
such as a laboratory study or clinical trial.
Co-Principle Investigator (Co-PI): is the person who takes direct responsibility next to the PI
for completion of a research project.
Sub-investigators: one or a group of scientists working together to complete a research
project under the leadership of the PI.
Clinical Trial (CT): is a prospective biomedical, pharmaceutical or behavioral research studies
on human subjects that is designed to answer specific questions about biomedical,
pharmaceutical or behavioral interventions and to discover or verify the effects of these
products on a volunteer subjects or patients.
Contract Research Organization (CRO): is the business partners are external organizations
provide specialized expertise regarding the CT agreement that have a special relationship with
the enterprise.
Saudi Food and Drug Authority (SFDA): is to regulate, oversee, and control food, drug,
medical devices, as well as to set mandatory standard specifications thereof, whether they are
imported or locally manufactured. The control and/or testing activities can be conducted in
the SFDA or other agency's laboratories. SFDA what we used to call Saudi regulatory
authority.
Institutional Review Board (IRB), also known as an independent ethics committee (IEC),
ethical review board (ERB) or research ethics board (REB), is a committee that has been
formally designated to approve, monitor, and review CT involving humans. Three main
concerns for the IRB, Ethical concepts, scientific merits, and applicability.
27
Good Clinical Practice (GCP), is an international ethical and scientific quality standard for
designing, conducting, recording and reporting trials that involve the participation of human
subjects. A standard for clinical studies which encompasses the design, conduct, monitoring,
termination, audit, analyses, reporting and documentation of the studies and which ensures
that the studies are scientifically and ethically sound and that the clinical properties of the
pharmaceutical product (diagnostic, therapeutic or prophylactic) under investigation are
properly documented. It is also a standard for clinical trials that provides assurance that the
data and reported results are credible and accurate, and that the rights, integrity, and
confidentiality of trial subjects are protected.
Standard Operating Procedures (SOP): To provide a general framework enabling the efficient
implementation and performance of all the functions and activities for a particular trial as
described in this document.
Informed consent: is a process for where the PI should obtain permission before conducting a
healthcare intervention on a human subject. Informed consent is collected according to
guidelines and standards of the GCP where the investigator should have the IRB written
approval of the written informed consent form and any other written information to be
provided to subjects. In cases where the subject is considered unable to give informed consent,
another person is generally authorized to give consent on his behalf, e.g., parents or legal
guardians of a child (the child may be required to provide informed assent). Informed Consent
Form (example from WHO is attached) has two parts:
Information Sheet (to share information about the research with you)
Certificate of Consent (for signatures if you agree to take part)
Case Report Form (CRF): A printed, optical, or electronic document designed to record all of
the protocol required information specifically used in clinical research to be reported to the
sponsor on each trial subject. The sponsor is responsible for designing a CRF that accurately
represents the protocol of the clinical trial, as well as managing its production, monitoring the
data collection and auditing the content of the filled-in CRFs. There is no specific size for a CRF
so that it can range from a handwritten one-time 'snapshot' for one participant in the clinical
trial to hundreds of pages. CRFs can be electronically captured data obtained over a period of
weeks or months. It can also include required check-up visits months after the patient's
treatment has stopped. (Example attached).
Work Breakdown Structure (WBS): It is a tree structural view that shows a subdivision or
breaking elements to a deliverable-oriented decomposition of a project into smaller
components. It is an essential tool for planning and executing the project. A work breakdown
structure is a key project deliverable that organizes the team's work into manageable sections.
28
The work breakdown structure can be displayed in two forms one in form of a table with
subdivision of tasks two in form of an organizational chart. (Examples attached).
Ghant Chart: It is a diagram to illustrate the start and finish dates of the terminal elements.
This diagram shows the process of analyzing research activity sequences, durations, and
resource requirements. It summarize the relationship of planning and work breakdown
structure (duration and responsibilities) of the research project. (Example attached).
Goal, Aim, Objective and Purpose by Merriam-Webster
Goal: something has been achieved or to achieve the terminal point, the end toward which
effort is directed.
Aim: something achievable that you hope to achieve (so it is an attempt to direct to a target).
Objective: something that you plan to achieve, expressing or dealing with facts or conditions
as perceived without distortion by personal feelings, prejudices, or interpretations.
Purpose: the aim that someone wants to achieve, or that something is intended to achieve.
29
Research Ethics Review Committee
Informed Consent
(Language used throughout form should be at the level of a local student of class 6th/8th)
Participant selection
State why this participant has been chosen for this research. People often wonder why they have been chosen
to participate and may be fearful, confused or concerned.
Voluntary Participation
Indicate clearly that they can choose to participate or not. State, what the alternative - in terms of the treatment
offered by the clinic - will be, if they decide not to participate. State, only if it is applicable, that they will still
receive all the services they usually do whether they choose to participate or not. This can be repeated and
expanded upon later in the form as well, but it is important to state clearly at the beginning of the form that
participation is voluntary so that the other information can be heard in this context.
30
2) provide as much information as is appropriate and understandable about the drug such as its manufacturer
or location of manufacture and the reason for its development.
3) explain the known experience with this drug
4) explain comprehensively all the known side-effects/toxicity of this drug, as well as the adverse effects of all
the other medicines that are being used in the trial
In this template, this section has been divided into two: firstly, an explanation of unfamiliar procedures and,
secondly, a description of process.
A. Unfamiliar Procedures
This section should be included if there may be procedures which are not familiar to the participant.
If the samples are to be used only for this research, then explicitly mention here that the biological samples
obtained during this research procedure will be used only for this research, and will be destroyed after (3) years,
when the research is completed. If the tissues/blood samples or any other human biological material will be
stored for a duration longer than the research purpose, or is likely to be used for a purpose other than
31
mentioned in the research proposal, then provide information about this and obtain consent specifically for
such storage and use in addition to consent for participation in the study - (see last section)
Duration
Include a statement about the time commitments of the research for the participant including both the duration
of the research and follow-up, if relevant.
Side Effects
Potential participants should be told if there are any known or anticipated side effects and what will happen in
the event of a side effect or an unexpected event.
Risks
Explain and describe any possible or anticipated risks. Describe the level of care that will be available in the
event that harm does occur, who will provide it, and who will pay for it. A risk can be thought of as being the
possibility that harm may occur. Provide enough information about the risks that the participant can make an
informed decision.
Benefits
Mention only those activities that will be actual benefits and not those to which they are entitled regardless of
participation. Benefits may be divided into benefits to the individual, benefits to the community in which the
individual resides, and benefits to society as a whole as a result of finding an answer to the research question.
Reimbursements
State clearly what you will provide the participants with as a result of their participation. WHO does not
encourage incentives. However, it recommends that reimbursements for expenses incurred as a result of
participation in the research be provided. These may include, for example, travel costs and money for wages
lost due to visits to health facilities. The amount should be determined within the host country context.
Confidentiality
Explain how the research team will maintain the confidentiality of data, especially with respect to the
information about the participant which would otherwise be known only to the physician but would now be
available to the entire research team. Note that because something out of the ordinary is being done through
research, any individual taking part in the research is likely to be more easily identified by members of the
community and is therefore more likely to be stigmatized.
32
Sharing the Results
Where it is relevant, your plan for sharing the information with the participants should be provided. If you have
a plan and a timeline for the sharing of information, include the details. You should also inform the participant
that the research findings will be shared more broadly, for example, through publications and conferences.
Alternatives to Participating
Include this section only if the study involves administration of investigational drugs or use of new therapeutic
procedures. It is important to explain and describe the established standard treatment.
Who to Contact
Provide the name and contact information of someone who is involved, informed and accessible (a local person
who can actually be contacted. State also that the proposal has been approved and how.
This proposal has been reviewed and approved by [name of the local IRB], which is a committee whose task
it is to make sure that research participants are protected from harm. If you wish to find about more about
the IRB, contact [name, address, telephone number.]). It has also been reviewed by the Ethics Review
Committee of the World Health Organization (WHO), which is funding/sponsoring/supporting the study.
33
PART II: Certificate of Consent
This section should be written in the first person and have a statement similar to the one in bold below. If the
participant is illiterate but gives oral consent, a witness must sign. A researcher or the person going over the
informed consent must sign each consent. The certificate of consent should avoid statements that have "I
understand…." phrases. The understanding should perhaps be better tested through targeted questions during
the reading of the information sheet (some examples of questions are given above), or through the questions
being asked at the end of the reading of the information sheet, if the potential participant is reading the
information sheet him/herself.
I have read the foregoing information, or it has been read to me. I have had the opportunity to ask questions
about it and any questions that I have asked have been answered to my satisfaction. I consent voluntarily to
participate as a participant in this research.
If illiterate
A literate witness must sign (if possible, this person should be selected by the participant and should have no
connection to the research team). Participants who are illiterate should include their thumb-print as well.
I have witnessed the accurate reading of the consent form to the potential participant, and the individual has
had the opportunity to ask questions. I confirm that the individual has given consent freely.
34
A copy of this ICF has been provided to the participant.
35
CASE REPORT FORM
Short Title/Acronym
Protocol Number:
Name of site:
Site number:
Subject Number:
Subject Initials:
36
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
SUBJECT ELIGIBILITY
INCLUSION CRITERIA
Participants should meet the following criteria and MUST be answered YES for
participant to be included in the trial. (Yes or No) Yes No
1
2
If any of the above criteria is answered NO, the participant is NOT eligible for the trial and must not be included in the study.
Please list reason(s) for ineligibility for screen failure on Participant Eligibility Review page.
EXCLUSION CRITERIA
The following criteria will exclude potential subjects from the study or MUST be
answered NO for the participant to be included in the trial. (Yes or No) Yes No
1
2
If any of the above criteria is answered YES, the participant is NOT eligible for the trial and must not be included in the study.
Please list reason(s) for ineligibility for screen failure on Participant Eligibility Review page.
INFORMATION SESSION
Date of Information Session
Did the subject attend the Information Session? Yes No
Comments (if any):
37
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
Informed Consent:
Date of Birth: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / MMM / YYYY)
White Illiterate
Mixed race Primary
Asian Secondary
Black Graduate
Hispanics Highly graduate
Other ethnicity Other:
38
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
39
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
Not Comment
System Abnormal Normal
done (if abnormal)
General Appearance
Skin
Eyes, Ears, Nose &
Throat
Head, Neck & Thyroid
Cardiovascular
Respiratory
Abdomen
Extremities
Genitalia
Anorectal
Lymph Nodes
Muscular-Skeletal
Neurological
Others (please
specify)
40
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
Weight Kg
41
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
RBC
Hb
HCT
MCV
MCH
PLT
NEUTROPHILS
LYMPHOCYTES
MONOCYTES
EOSINOPHILS
BASOPHILS
RETICULOCYTES
42
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
POTASSIUM
CHLORIDE
BICARBONATE
UREA
CREATININE
TOTAL PROTEIN
TOTAL BILIRUBIN
ALBUMIN
ALK PHOS
ALT
AST
CALCIUM
43
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
__ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
Date of Sample:
(DD / MMM / YYYY)
________:_______
Time of Sample
HH:MM
44
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
1. ____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
2. ____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
3. ____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
4.
____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
5. ____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
6.
____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
7. ____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
8.
____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
9. ____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
10.
____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
45
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
46
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
I have reviewed this CRF and confirm that, to the best of my knowledge, it accurately reflects the study
information obtained for this participant for visit#1. All entries were made either by me or by a person under
my supervision who has signed the Delegation and Signature Log.
__________________________________
ONCE SIGNED, NO FURTHER CHANGES CAN BE MADE TO THIS PART OF CRF WITHOUT A
SIGNED DATA QUERY FORM.
RANDOMIZATION / ENROLMENT
__ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
Date of Randomisation/Enrolment:
(DD / MMM / YYYY)
47
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
Visit Checklist:
Yes No
Add further assessments required at each visit, amend the following pages to fit your
3.
requirements
4.
48
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
System Changed
Skin
Cardiovascular
Respiratory
Abdomen
Extremities
Genitalia
Anorectal
Lymph Nodes
Muscular-Skeletal
Neurological
49
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Blood Pressure supine/standing/seating : ___ ___ ___ / ___ ___ ___ mmHg
__ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __ ________:_______
Date & Time of ECG: (DD / MMM / YYYY)
HH:MM
_____________________________________________________________
50
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
VISIT X <INSERT VISIT NAME> VITAL SIGNS & ECG
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
RBC No Yes
Hb No Yes
HCT No Yes
MCV No Yes
MCH No Yes
PLT No Yes
NEUTROPHILS No Yes
LYMPHOCYTES No Yes
MONOCYTES No Yes
EOSINOPHILS No Yes
BASOPHILS No Yes
RETICULOCYTES No Yes
51
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
POTASSIUM No Yes
CHLORIDE No Yes
BICARBONATE No Yes
UREA No Yes
CREATININE No Yes
ALBUMIN No Yes
ALT No Yes
AST No Yes
CALCIUM No Yes
52
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
__ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __ ________:_______
Date & Time of Sample:
(DD / MMM / YYYY) HH:MM
No Yes, Complete below
Was laboratory sample taken at different hospital to
Laboratory name / Location:
<insert investigator’s site lab name>?
__________________________________________
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
No Yes
53
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Start date of dosing Stop date of dosing Dose Comment ONLY if dose delayed, interrupted,
(DD/MMM/YYYY) (DD/MMM/YYYY) (including units) reduced or altered
____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
____/_____/_____ ____/_____/_____
INFUSION
Date of Infusion Start time of Stop time of Dose Comment if dose delayed,
(DD/MMM/YYYY) infusion infusion (including units) interrupted, reduced or altered
DISPENSING
Date of Dispensing IMP Quantity Dispensed (no. <Daily> Dose Comment ONLY if dose delayed,
(DD/MMM/YYYY) tablets/ pens/patches) (including units) reduced or altered
____/_____/______
Note: add more rows depending on how IMP is dispensed and returned
RETURNS (add to subsequent visit)
Date of Returning IMP Quantity Returned (no. Comment on compliance
(DD/MMM/YYYY) tablets/ pens/patches)
____/_____/______
54
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
55
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Date of Assessment: __ __ / __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
(DD / M M / YYYY)
I have reviewed this CRF and confirm that, to the best of my knowledge, it accurately reflects the study
information obtained for this participant for visit#1. All entries were made either by me or by a person under
my supervision who has signed the Delegation and Signature Log.
__________________________________
ONCE SIGNED, NO FURTHER CHANGES CAN BE MADE TO THIS PART OF CRF WITHOUT A
SIGNED DATA QUERY FORM.
56
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
TRIAL COMPLETION
__ __ / __ __ __ / 2 0 __ __
(DD / MMM / YYYY)
__ __ / __ __ __ / 2 0 __ __
(DD / MMM / YYYY)
Early Withdrawal: please tick most appropriate reason for participant not completing the trial:
Adverse Events related: please state related AE: ____________________________________ (add details
to AE page)
Sponsor’s decision
Lost to follow up
Patient deceased
57
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
Relationship to
Study Drug Outcome
Event Serious? Study Drug
Severity Action 0 - Resolved
Name If serious, Con- 0 - Definitely
0 - Mild 0 - None 1- Resolved
AE (Please Start date Stop date please comitant 1 - Probably
1- Mode- 1 - Temporarily with
No give (DD/MM/YY) (DD/MM/YY) complete Medication 2 - Possibly
rate Interrupted sequelea
Diagnosis if a JRO SAE given 3 - Unlikely
2 - Severe 2 - permanently 2 - Not
known) form 4 - Not related
withdrawn resolved
5 - Not assessable
No No
1 ___/___/___ Yes Yes
___/___/___
No No
2 ___/___/___ ___/___/___ Yes Yes
No No
3 ___/___/___ ___/___/___ Yes Yes
No No
4 ___/___/___ ___/___/___ Yes Yes
No No
5 ___/___/___ ___/___/___ Yes Yes
No No
6
___/___/___ ___/___/___ Yes Yes
I have reviewed the AEs on this page and have assessed them for seriousness, causality, severity and outcome and confirm that, to the best of my
knowledge, it accurately reflects the study information obtained for this participant
PI signature _______________________________ _________________ Date:_________________________ Please check box if this is the
last page used
58
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
1. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
2. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
3. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
4. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
5. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
6. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
7. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
8. ____/_____/___ ____/_____/__
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
59
Centre (Site) No. Subject No.
Screening No. Patient Initials
I have reviewed this CRF and confirm that, to the best of my knowledge, it accurately reflects the study
information obtained for this participant. All entries were made either by me or by a person under my
supervision who has signed the Delegation and Signature Log.
__________________________________
__ __/ __ __ __ / __ __ __ __
Date of Signature:
(DD / MMM / YYYY)
Principal Investigator’s Name:
________________________________________
ONCE SIGNED, NO FURTHER CHANGES CAN BE MADE TO THIS CRF WITHOUT A SIGNED
DATA QUERY FORM.
60
Chapter 2.
Initiation
Research Project Manager
61
Initiation
start the project or phase. Steps for initiation process will be:
Define and writing a research proposal for a worthwhile idea provides a detailed
Ensure the commitment of the sponsor regarding financial aspects such as:
b. The way of payment to the research team, research support team and others.
Ensure the commitment of the sponsor, IRB concerns, and/or Good Clinical Practice
standards.
Ensure the submission of all essential documents for the conduct of a clinical trial.
It will be imperative for research project management professionals to work with researchers,
scientists, developers, and consultants to facilitate new product development and quality
initiatives. Within the Initiating processes, the primary and secondary (if any) aim of the
62
research project is defined and committed. Performing the Initiating processes at the start of
research project helps to keep the project focused on the main aim needs that the project to
address.
A research proposal is intended to convince others that you have a new idea. Generally, a
research proposal should contain all the key elements involved in the research process and
include sufficient information. The successful criteria are verified, and objectives of the
A research project manager must be appointed to sort out and management of the following
responsibilities:
1. Responsibility for clinical research project manager (CRM) with PI and Research team.
c) Define the scope of work, then create work breakdown structure (WBS).
g) Define how to monitor the quality of the output and closing remark.
63
2. Responsibility for clinical research project manager with regard finance processes.
(example attached)
a. Draft a budget for the clinical trial includes the following aspects:
6. Others (specific)
7. Miscellaneous (nonspecific)
3. Responsibilities for clinical research project manager with other sections/ department to
assign members for research supporting team (Pharmacy, Laboratory, other sections such
i. Pharmacy.
64
a) Liaise with principal investigators and/or research team to establish pharmacy’s role,
and accountability at the trial site, yet the CRM should share this responsibility.
c) Together with the PI, they should be ensure that the code is disclosed only in
d) Communicate with, and trains staff from pharmacy anticipated to participate in any
schedule, and any other relevant materials for each investigational trial.
investigational drug trials; orders, replaces and returns study materials, as required.
ii. Laboratory.
65
iii. Other section such as radiology, information technology, administration etc..
Check all documents before the clinical phase of the trial commences (listed in Clinical
Financial aspects of the trial to document the financial agreement between the
66
5. Communicates any concerns regarding ethical issues or deviation from established
a) Before recruiting any patient for the clinical trial, PI and CRM should have written and
dated approval from the IRB for the trial protocol, written informed consent form,
inclusion and exclusion criteria, subject recruiting procedure, and any written information
to be provided to subjects.
b) During the trial, the PI and CRM should provide to the IRB/IEC all documents subject to
review.
c) The PI and CRM should conduct the trial in compliance with the protocol agreed to by
the sponsor and, if required, by the regulatory authority(ies). The PI and CRM and the
d) The PI and CRM should not implement any deviation from, or changes of the protocol
without agreement by the sponsor and prior review and documented approval/
eliminate an immediate hazard(s) to trial subjects, or when the change(s) involves only
telephone number(s)).
67
e) The PI and CRM should document and explain any deviation from the approved
protocol.
f) The PI and CRM may implement a deviation from, or a change of, the protocol to eliminate
As soon as possible, the implemented deviation or change, the reasons for it, and, if
(see example)
68
FINANCIAL ASPECTS
The Principal Investigator has primary responsibility for developing a preliminary initial
1. Personnel
PI should have estimate number for all subjects will participate in the trials and
estimate number of hours will be spend with, number of visits for each subject.
Professional fee schedule containing charges and fair market value costs for
physician’s professional fees per subject related to services rendered as part of the
study not as a part of standard care. Then fees will be counted according to:
advices.
69
Editor, to review document for publication(s).
minor service.
Entry Clerks; Administrative assistants and Others, not mentioned above but
he/she spend a considerable time during the conducting of the research study.
2. Equipment
Principle investigator should have full idea about list of the equipment needed to be
purchased for the purposed research. Also, the PI should have idea about the fate of
the equipment including confirmation document provided from the chairman of the
section of the PI to secure the fate of this specific equipment. Medical or laboratory
It is preferable if the PI to place a bid to show the cost of the equipment and ascertain if
there are other options or alternative(s) for such equipment with similar description
70
and/or function. The main difference between equipment and supplies that supplies
are disposables while equipment need to be under the control of the property of the
same institution.
3. Supplies
disease(s) or other conditions. Supplies are disposable products which may be used
within or on the body, usually used as adjunct for the provided equipment. Supplies
disposable gloves, etc. to advanced devices such as computers and related spare parts
It is also preferred if a quotation for the needed supplies is attached with the research
protocol.
4. Others
This budget category include known needed services not mentioned within the above
4.10. Shipments.
4.11. Advertisement(s).
5. Miscellaneous expenses
Indirect costs on Study charges usually 10- 25% of the total budget. Miscellaneous used
as a loan expenses to the PI to be given from sponsor as a petty cash to be used only for the
same research project (not even for another research project of the same PI).
72
RESEARCH FUND APPLICATION
Principal Investigator: __Xxx Yyy Zzz Protocol Number: __Res Prot. No. 2___
Duration: __Two (2) Years (24 months) Expected Starting Date: ____1/1/2016
Sample Size: __200 Patients (4 visits)___ Expected Completion Date: _31/12/2017_
Budget Category First Year Second Year Total Remarks
Quantity Unit Cost Quantity Unit Cost
Principal Investigator 1 20,000 1 20,000 40,000
Sub-Investigator(s) 4 50,000 4 50,000 100,000
Travelling 30,000
Accommodation 20,000
Others
Advertisement 10,000
Publication cost 10,000
Miscellaneous
50,000
73
Checklist for CRM Responsibilities
74
Initiation questions
1- The processes preformed to define a new idea for a research project is
a) Initiation
b) Planning
c) Executing
d) Closing
7- Which one of the following sentences is NOT true regarding responsibility of CRM with regards finance
processes?
a) Draft a budget for honorarium for PI , co-PI , sub investigator and research team
b) Draft a budget for research support team
c) Determine exact cost for the miscellaneous
d) Determine sheet for income and expenditure
9- You are the CRM and you need to check all documents to get the IRB approval of the clinical study, which of
the following is NOT essential documents
10- To document qualifications and eligibility to conduct trial or provide medical supervision of subjects we
need to have……. As essential documents
a) CRF
b) CVs of investigator and sub investigator
c) Sample of Informed consent form
d) Investigator's brochure
11- The PI and CRM should submit to the IRB /IEC all documents related to recruit subject to review
a. PI and Sponsor
b. Sponsor and CRM
c. Sponsor and IRB
d. PI and CRM
13. Who is primarily responsible to develop preliminary initial budget that includes personnel, equipment,
supplies, other expenses directly or indirectly related to the conduction of the research study?
a. Principal Investigator
b. Clinical Research Project Manager
c. Sponsor
d. Research Support Team
14. Who among the following is not part of Research Consulting Team?
a. Consultant
b. Research Associate
c. Statistician
d. Editor
77
Answers
1- The answer is (a) because this step is the initial step to start any project then we jump to planning then
executing then monitor this project and at the end closing
2- The answer is (c) because all the other answers is for initiation part except recognize the changing
which is for planning that come after initiation
3- The answer is (c) because in initiation processes we start to write the proposal and define our aim of
this project the primary or even secondary then we move to planning processes where we start to plan
to reach our aim
4- The answer is (a) Always we need to do this process at the starting of research project to keep the
project focused on the main aim need that the project to address
5- The answer is (b) in the beginning of any research the CRM need to review the protocol of
investigational drug with PI and research team
6- The answer is (d) the protocol of code broken and communicate and train staff are responsibilities of
CRM with pharmacy and determine sheet of income and expenditure is responsibility of CRM regard
finance processes
7- The answer is (c) because it is important to have a budget for equipment even if they are not
disposable
8- The answer is (a) we always need a sheet regarding income and expenditure in finance processes as a
responsibility of CRM
9- The answer is (a) as CRM you need to be sure that all your papers is ready and signed including
protocol and amendments
10- The answer is (b) It is essential to have CVs of investigator and sub investigator in order to document
qualifications and eligibility to conduct trail or provide medical supervision of subjects
11- The answer is (b) During the trial the PI and CRM should provide to the IRB /IEC all documents subject
to review
12- The answer is (d)
13- The answer is (a)
14- The answer is (b)
15- The answer is (d)
78
Chapter 3.
Planning
Research Project Manager
79
Planning
It is a fundamental property of intelligent behavior on how to create and maintain future
research projects. Making assignments and solving problems is a natural tendency of human
being. Taking time to think about what you are trying to do, how, when, and by whom,
characterizes of successful research projects. One of these early tasks is defining the
customer's needs. Recognizing patients requirement give the researchers the opportunity to
define the needs and how to make changes and, how to find and drive ways to solve these
needs.
Planning though is knowing how to arrange the needs in one scope to view the future of the
research in specific time and how to solve changes attributed to the main scope.
Planning in clinical research refers to the contract or agreement that the sponsor or the CRO
from on one side and clinical project manager and/or the site institution together with
principle investigator from the other side use to agree on the initial vision of the project
(scope, baseline, resources, objectives...) at a high level. The research project plan is the
document that the clinical project manager builds to describe in more details the planning of
The main objectives of a research project plan is to define the needs and scope of the research
3. Recognize that there will be changes to your research project and the scope of the work
The main goals of processing project management is to achieve the project objectives within
the constraints of scope, resources, time and budget. If the goals are the terminal
requirement, aim is the hope to achieve, then the objective is how to plan to achieve the goal.
Project management is the discipline of planning and organizing a project, and securing and
managing resources to achieve the goals of the project, project management thus involves a
set of skills, a suite of tools, and a series of processes. The elements of project planning and
In order to make a plane for a classic research project, a similar stages for a research protocol
Scope is the sum of products and services to be provided by the research project in one frame.
A written scope statement has to be developed including the research project problem and
justification, the major deliverables and research tools and the project objectives.
Major deliverables need to be decomposed into smaller using a work breakdown structure
the scope of a research project that give a guide to carryout in conducting research. Scope
change control also has to be put in place early, covering: submission of change requests, their
evaluation, incorporating the approved changes in the plan and monitoring progress.
Activity definition is next, whereby the specific activities that must be performed in order to
produce the project deliverables are specified. Their sequencing and duration are determined,
producing a schedule. Resources required are now estimated and costs can be assessed.
• Project communications, who should get what data, how, when and where.
research project.
82
• Risk, determining if there is a side events are likely to affect the research project and
deciding how to handle them, and determine the way of reporting system.
All these planning pieces are now put into one consistent, coherent research project plan
which will guide the research project manager on how to execute and control a clinical
research project. Ideally new thoughts may be added only after changes in scope. Baseline
means the original plan before adding a change. Plan management is enable the CRM to
develop and execute theories, administrative and controlling all related aspect to the research
project. CRM is responsible for conducting clinical research project and service delivery and
A research project schedule is an outline of a set of aims and objectives for how to reach the
goals and processes by which a research team can accomplish those goals.
A work plan can be drafted to offer a better understanding of the scope of the research
83
1. Identify the aims and objectives of your research and how to reach the goals.
3. Make WBS to achieve deliverables and more manageable components to provide better
control.
5. Draft a Gantt chart to illustrate the start and finish dates of the main elements of the
research project.
Goal is something has been achieved. It is a desired result(s) has been achieved as a terminal
Aim is something that you hope to achieve (so it is an attempt to direct to a target). This word
usually used in clinical trials since the principle investigators would like to get it.
Objective is something that you plan to achieve, expressing or dealing with facts or conditions
extremely useful in helping to define and establish a research objectives to reassess while on
Purpose is the aim that someone wants to achieve, or that something is intended to achieve.
84
Identify how to process the research methodology.
Research methodology is the method applied to conduct the research project. The main
principles for the research methodology are: location, equipment and supplies and
In general research methodology that outlines the way in which research is to be undertaken
and, among other things, identifies the methods to be used in it. The next step for
methodology is how to collect data and how to analyze it. Research methodology could be
monitoring, or measuring chemical results etc.), could a clinic visit or performing operation.
planning and executing the project. A work breakdown structure is a key project deliverable
that organizes the team's work into manageable sections. The work breakdown structure can
be displayed in two forms one in form of a table with subdivision of tasks two in form of an
85
Use the WBS to define the work for the project and to develop the project's schedule. Work
Breakdown Structure Template with more detailed information on each component of the
WBS provides a common framework for the natural development of the overall planning and
control of a research project and is the basis for dividing work into definable increments. A
WBS can be developed by starting with the end objective and successively subdividing it into
subsystems, components, tasks, sub-tasks, and work packages), which include all steps
Consider ordering your work plan by "SMART" objectives to guide the research project
Specific: What methodology are the researchers going to perform for whom, what is the
direction for improvement, and is it significant? In order to reach a specific goal, it should
be clear and unambiguous. A specific goal will answer the following questions:
quantify change. If a goal is not measurable it is not possible to produce or to know whether a
team is making progress toward successful completion, in-fact if a goal is not measureable that
mean this project have no aim. Quantify meaningful results or at least suggest an indicator of
progress. Measuring progress is supposed to help a team stay on track, reach its target on to
continued effort required to reach the ultimate goal. A measurable goal will answer questions
such as:
How much?
How many?
Assignable: Specify who will do it in the time allotted with the available resources. It is
important that this criterion to be realistic and also attainable. Attainable goals are neither out
of reach nor below standard performance, which may be considered meaningless. Make
priority for the appropriate goals that are achievable and simple to come true. An achievable
resources. Make sure your objectives and methods have a clear, intuitive relationship.
Relevant goals (when met) drive the team, department and organization forward. A goal that
• Time bound: Specify when this result will be accomplished, and to specify a hard end date
for the research project. Stipulate within a time-frame which, if any, outcomes would cause
your project to come to a premature end, with all outcomes having been achieved. A
commitment to a deadline helps the research team focus their efforts on completion of the
research project on or before the due date. This part of the SMART goal criteria is intended to
prevent goals from being overtaken by the day-to-day crises that invariably arise in an
88
When?
Ghant Chart
Draw a Gantt chart to illustrate work plan. It is a diagram to illustrate the start and finish dates
of the terminal elements. This diagram shows the process of analyzing research activity
and work breakdown structure (duration and responsibilities) of the research project.
(Example attached).
1. Identify aims and objectives for a research project and how to achieve the goals.
4. Specify duration for each task (in days, weeks and months).
5. Specify one or more of the research team (as responsible) to achieve a task in specific
duration).
89
6. Make order for the sequence of events.
7. Draw a diagram on excel sheet showing start and finish date for each task.
through compromising the work breakdown structure of the research project in achievable
tasks with specific duration under the responsibility of the research team. Three main
elements to draw a Gantt chart namely, WBS, duration and responsibility. Through a work
plan, a Gantt chart will illustrate small pieces of the research project with achievable tasks able
Constraints are obstacles that may get in the way of achieving your goals and objectives. Scope
change, incorporating the approved changes in the plan and monitoring progress. Planning
though is the process where to organize a research project to achieve aims and objective of
that research. Changes are planning in the original processes that researchers don’t recognize
their needs that was none defined earlier, however, in case of research projects, it is
important to put in consideration that clinical research deals with human subjects therefore, if
any changes in a clinical research to keep in mind the reporting system to IRB, regulatory
90
In case of changes or variance in the baseline (plan before adding changes), researchers should
do the followings:
1. Define and refine the aims and objectives for the research project to achieve the new
goals.
3. Draft a Gantt chart to illustrate the start and finish dates of the main elements of the
research project.
Reporting Systems
Reporting systems for a research project could be referred to those data gathering efforts
which get information on clinical trials. Reporting systems should constitute procedure for
gaining reliable and valid information about what is happening in each segment of the
research.
The CRM should provide PI and research team with the information they need to know the
status of the research project and how to proceed with the same plan. Recite details or
statistics from recent reports, identify problems that need to be addressed, or build off of
recommendations or feedback. The CRM also responsible to conduct meetings with all the
91
research team so often. Agenda of each meeting should be written in collaboration of the CRM
and the PI (previous meeting between CRM and PI to specify the agenda).
The main reporting tools in clinical research studies is a clinical report form (CRF) which could
be printed format as a hard copy, optical, or electronic document designed to record all of the
Section 2: Screening (Screening No. can be added to the header in this section if
Reports and communication is also a main task for the CRM, reporting in clinical trial such as:
The investigator should submit written summaries of the trial’s status to the institution,
The investigator should promptly provide written reports to the sponsor, the IRB and,
significantly affecting the conduct of the trial, and/or increasing the risk to subjects.
92
All serious adverse events (SAEs) should be reported immediately. The immediate and
follow-up reports should be with more detail. The investigator should also comply with
requirements and within the time periods specified by the sponsor in the protocol.
For reported deaths, the investigator should supply the sponsor and the IRB with any
additional requested information (e.g., autopsy reports and terminal medical reports).
If the trial is terminated prematurely or suspended for any reason, the investigational
institution should:
Upon completion of the trial, the investigator should, where required by the applicable
regulatory requirements, inform the institution, and the IRB with a summary of the
trial’s.
93
Essential documents should be retained until at least 3 years after the last approval of a
marketing application and until there are no pending or contemplated marketing applications
or at least 3 years have elapsed since the formal discontinuation of clinical development of the
investigational product. These documents should be retained for a longer period, however, if
List resources.
Include anything that will be necessary to achieve your goals and objectives. Resources can be
any things within the financial budget including, personnel, equipment, supplies, etc. whether
events.
Write a manuscript.
Use your resources and overcome your constraints in order to reach your goals and objectives.
List specific action steps for your methodology. Verify your data, then do analysis, draw
conclusions by evaluating your research questions, research objectives and research aim.
To prepare a manuscript, you may breakdown each step to minor and achievable task then use
94
Read the Guide for Authors: to think where you should submit your publication and
Decide what type of the manuscript to write and decide a target journal.
Write the Materials and Methods, Describe your results, Discuss your findings, Write the
95
References:
1. (https://federation.edu.au; 7.0 Project Planning and Management).
2. Essential Guide to Leading Your Team : How to Set Goals, Measure Performance and
Reward Talent. Pearson Education. pp. 37–39. ISBN 0273772449. Retrieved 2013-07-05.
Yemm, Graham (2013).
3. Successful Management by Motivation : Balancing Intrinsic and Extrinsic
Incentives. Springer. p. 234. ISBN 3540424016. Retrieved 2013-07-11. Frey, Bruno S.;
Osterloh, Margit (2002).
4. Social Work Management and Leadership : Managing Complexity with
Creativity. Routledge. pp. 84–85. ISBN 1135247056. Retrieved 2013-07-14. Lawler, John;
Bilson, Andy (2013).
5. http://www.elsevier.com/connect/six-things-to-do-before-writing-your-manuscript Six
things to do before writing your manuscript In this new series — “How to Prepare a
Manuscript for International Journals” — a seasoned editor gives advice to boost your
chances of acceptance By Angel Borja, PhD Posted on 12 May 2014.
6. A Step by Step Guide to Writing a Scientific Manuscript; Volker Wenzel, M.D., M.Sc.,
Martin W. Dünser, M.D.*, Karl H. Lindner, M.D.
96
Questions and Answers
1. The need to have enough ……………………In planning step of research project management is an
important issue to come with successful plan.
a) Money
b) Time
c) Scientists
d) Customers
4. Scope is the sum of products and services to be provided by the project, also needs careful attention.
And a written scope statement has to be developed that includes:
a) Major deliverables
b) Project justification
c) Project objectives
d) All of above
5. Project communications, quality assurance and risk management all need a good:
a) Planning
b) Executing
c) Control
d) Initiation
97
7. Gant chart take place in:
a) Initiation
b) Planning
c) Executing
d) Controlling
11. In planning process you must list your resources which are anything that will be necessary for you to
achieve your goals and objectives and the most important thing to be included is:
a) Financial budget
b) Personnel
c) Equipment
d) Supplies
15. When writing work plan we should consider "SMART" objectives which stands for:
a. Speed, Motivation, Art, Reliable, Time
b. Specific, Methodology, Achievable, Relevant, Time bound
c. Specific, Methodology, Attractive, Recruitment, Tables
d. None of the above
99
Answers
1. B. taking time at planning carefully to think about what you are trying to do, how, when, and by whom,
characterizes successful projects.
2. D. It is normal that the customer does not recognize his needs and cannot articulate them. Moreover,
needs will almost certainly change as the project moves forward.
3. C. the classic research project stages take place in planning process of research cycle and start with
identify a research problem.
4. D. a written scope statement has to be developed that includes the project justification, the major
deliverables and the project objectives
5. A. Project communications need planning to know who should get what data, when. Quality need
planning to identifying quality standards relevant to the project and determining how to satisfy them
and Risk need planning to determining which risks are likely to affect the project and deciding how to
handle them.
6. B. Baselines are the original plans, plus or minus approved changes; e.g., cost-baseline, schedule
baseline.
7. B. Gant chart take place in planning process
8. D. Gant chart take place in planning process to illustrate a work plan. A Gantt chart illustrate the start
and finish dates of elements of a project
9. A. most work plans are for a certain period of time (i.e., 6 months or 1 year) so that is will help the
individual keep track of his/her goals and progress.
10. C. SMART objectives refer for Specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time bound.
11. A. financial budget so that you can determine your overall research budget
12. B. Constraints are obstacles that may get in the way of achieving your goals and objectives. Scope
change (plan B) can be made with incorporating the approved changes in the plan and monitoring
progress and no need to end the project.
13. D
14. A
15. B
16. B
17. C
100
Work Breakdown Structure for writing a Research Protocol 1/2
101
Work Breakdown Structure for writing a Research Protocol 2/2
102
103
104
Ghant Project Planner Period Highlight: 10 Plan
PLAN PLAN PERCENT
ACTIVITY START DURATIONCOMPLETE PERIODS
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8 Q9
Project summary 8 1 0%
Rational and background information 1 2 0%
References 1 2 0%
Study goals and objectives 1 2 0%
Study Design 3 2 0%
Methodology 3 7 0%
Safety Considerations 3 2 0%
Follow-Up 5 2 0%
Data Management and Statistical Analysis 6 3 0%
Quality Assurance 3 6 0%
Expected Outcomes of the Study 3 2 0%
Dissemination of Results and Publication Policy 3 2 0%
Duration of the Project 3 2 0%
Problems Anticipated 3 2 0%
Project Management 3 2 0%
Ethics 3 2 0%
Informed Consent Forms 3 2 0%
Budget 3 2 0%
Other support for the Project 3 2 0%
Curriculum Vitae of investigators 3 2 0%
Other research activities of the investigators 8 1 0%
Financing and Insurance 8 1 0%
Chapter 4.
Methodology/
Execution
Research Project Manager
105
Methodology/ Execution
The project methodology or project execution phase is the third phase in clinical research
project management and it is the longest phase in the research life cycle. During this phase,
the principle investigator together with clinical research manager will execute the tasks
described in the plans, processes, and implement procedures. Both PI and CRM will oversee
and manage the research resources as the detailed in the research protocol including all tasks
The PI and CRM must ensure that the observations and findings are recorded correctly and
completely in the case-report forms (CRFs) and signed by the responsible person designated in
the protocol. They have overall responsibility for ensuring the accuracy and completeness of
data entry. They must also ensure that the routine requirements for recording of data in the
source documents (e.g. hospital and laboratory records, consultation files) are met,
particularly those relating to the treatment given to the subject. Moreover, variation in the
research protocol or if there is an adverse event(s) should be reported in accordance with the
GCP standards.
If trial data are entered directly into a computer, there must always be an adequate safeguard
to ensure validation, including a signed and dated print-out and back-up records.
106
Computerized systems should be validated and a detailed description for their use be
5. Provides direct and/or functional supervision; maintains overall responsibility for other
Professional responsibility
Professional responsibility is the area of ethical and moral duty of a researcher to what has to
be done, how and when to do it, in ways that encompasses the duties of attorneys to act in a
107
professional manner, obey the law, avoid conflicts of interest, and put the interests of clients
ahead of their own interests. Professional responsibility as applied to researchers refers to the
These standards relate to patient care, collaboration with other medical professionals,
3. The propriety of the professional's conduct in view of the profession's self-image and
defined interests.
These codes are implications about the subject matter development of the profession, skills
Research integration management includes the processes and activities to review, identify,
define, combine, unify, and coordinate the various processes of research proposal.
108
research methodology so that the needs and expectations of all research team are equitably
satisfied by the best use of all resources. Research management should ensure to select or
create a research environment to manage the interdependencies in order to achieve the goals
Research project integration management is how to perform the research activities effectively
and efficiently under the GCP standards and after the IRB or ethics committee approval. It is a
commitment from all research team including the CRM to foster honesty and integrity, and to
respect for human research participants, animals and the health environment. It also ensures
that the research support team, equipment and supplies (resources), processes that are in
place, in use and will perform when required over the whole lifecycle of the research.
1. Collect all essential documents: Essential Documents are those documents that
individually and collectively permit evaluation of the conduct of a trial and the quality of
the data produced. These documents serve to demonstrate the compliance of the
investigator, sponsor, and monitor with the standards of GCP and with all applicable
regulatory requirements. All of the documents addressed in the clinical trials are
2. Develop project management plan: The process of defining, preparing, and coordinating
all subsidiary plans and integrating them into a comprehensive research project
109
management plan. The project’s integrated baselines and subsidiary plans may be
included within the project management plan. The research plan may presented in a
3. Direct and manage project work: The process of leading and performing the work
the research objectives. Patient recruitment according to the inclusion and exclusion
4. Monitor and control project work: The process of tracking of all essential documents
reviewing changes and reporting project progress against the performance objectives
5. Perform integrated change control: This process is under monitoring and controlling
processes. If changes get raised in the executing process, the CRM and PI should
6. Close project or phase: The process of finalizing all research activities across all of the
ensure that all aspects of the research has been done properly and in the right
path. Also to assure that the research have a clear end-point. A research project that is
110
Research scope management
Project Scope Management includes the processes required to ensure that all the work
service.
Project scope—the work that must be done in order to deliver a product with the
1. Plan Scope Management: The process of creating a scope management plan that
documents to describe how the project scope will be defined, managed, validated, and
research team needs and requirements to meet project objectives. All requirements
should be gathered ahead of time which will ensure that it will meet the research team
expectation. Eventually this will show a professional attitude and will enhance research
development.
111
3. Define Scope: The process of developing a detailed description of the project and
product. Getting the scope just right on a project is one of the most-important elements
deliverables and project work into smaller, more manageable components. A traditional
WBS for a research projects is usually divided at its highest level into phases of analysis,
design, coding, testing, and deployment activities. Each of these phases is then
5. Validate Scope: The process where research flow is suitable, and acceptable with all
research team (one hand) and sponsor. The assurance of understanding of verification
where it means the data outcomes comply with the methodology and validation means
the data outcome and results analysis meets the aim of the research project.
6. Control Scope: The process of monitoring the status of the research project and product
scope and managing changes to the scope baseline. Control scope is to compare the
baseline and requirements of the research methodology with the current actual results.
Research Project Time Management is the processes required to complete the research
project in the time allocated. The main concern is the time of the whole research team and
112
research support team not just the time of the clinical research project manager. There is a
need to estimate all resources shared directly or indirectly in the research project. The CRM
should play a vital role in time management since most of the researchers do not plan or
manage their time. The Steps of the Time Management Process are as follow:
1. Plan Schedule Management: This step should be done upon the experience of the PI and
CRM. It should be done during the process of establishment of the research protocol.
This process will show hoe this project will be developed, managed, executed and how
2. Define Activities: The process of identifying and documenting the research protocol to
represent the work necessary to complete the work package. These deliverable tasks
components), duration (time allocated), and responsibility (who will do the activity).
dependencies that need to be included in the research project activities. After defining
the research proposal, a list of activities will be designed and created within the
113
research proposal, and then arrange this list of activities in a logical sequence showing
estimating the type and quantities of material, human resources, equipment, or supplies
required to execute the research project. Estimation of type and quantity of resources
dependencies found for each activity will make the estimate cost process easy hence
5. Estimate Activity Durations: The process of estimating the number of work periods
needed to complete the research project within the available resources. Resources are
include manpower (research support team), logistics (equipment and supplies), and site
where the research to be conducted. This is the main output from this process. It is not
right to assume that all activities will have one estimate as there are many techniques
and tools helping to give a range of estimates for each task. The knowledge, skills, sense
and experience in a CRM will improve the accuracy of such estimates. It might be
noticed that the sequence of events in time management process is to first define the
activities, then estimate the activity resources and then go on to estimate the activity
durations.
114
6. Develop Schedule: The process of analyzing activity sequences, durations, resource
requirements, and schedule constraints to create the project schedule model. The
project schedule (such as Gantt chart) is the tool that to show what work needs to be
performed, who is the responsible to perform the work and the timeline in which the
work needs to be performed. The schedule is the best tool for the work to be followed-
up by the CRM.
7. Control Schedule: The process where the CRM should monitor the status of project
activities and control the schedule and to update project progress, also the CRM should
verify changes to the schedule baseline to achieve the goal. The CRM should ensure
that the time spent on activities lines should match the schedule baseline. The CRM will
spend effort in controlling harder than planning the schedule because it requires one-to-
one management.
Research Cost Management includes the processes required to measure the cost of the
research during all research life cycle processes including planning, estimating, budgeting,
financing, funding, managing, and controlling costs so that the research project can be
completed within the approved budget. The success of research cost control and
115
management of depends on the CRM and the PI. The guidance of the PI and the management
of the CRM for the research project on how to do cost saving and to be in accordance with the
GCP and international standards. Cost management activities aimed at structural cost
1. Plan Cost Management: The process that establishes the research budget with all the
miscellaneous. This process will provides guidance and direction on how the CRM will
manage the research costs throughout the research project. CRM will meet the PI
and/or the research team to present and review the cost performance every month and
also to report to the sponsor on quarterly basis (or according to the contract with the
2. Estimate Costs: The process to make estimation for the cost of every criteria listed in the
budget. Cost estimation is to give approximate cost of the monetary resources for each
activity of the research. There is no definitive estimate for the research cost, however,
creating a cost estimate depends on the CRM experience and also depends on the
sponsor’s rules and regulation. The estimate cost must be as accurate as possible so that
116
3. Determine Budget: The process of collecting the estimated costs of each research
activity to present it in one sheet. Cost estimates are the estimated costs for each
research activity, whereas the budget allocates the costs over the life of the research
4. Control Costs: The process of monitoring and controlling changes in research project
budget. During this process, the CRM could have the capability to present and/or report
the status of the research budget and expenditures at any time. The report should show
real values with the approved cost base line and determining corrective actions. Both
cost estimates and budget are needed in order to determine the cost performance
Quality Management includes the processes that determine policies, objectives, and
responsibilities to be followed to ensure that the project will satisfy the needs for which it was
undertaken. Quality management is a key element to achieve and sustain high quality output.
Research Quality Management works to ensure that the research project requirements are
met and validated. Most clinical research centers are encouraged to conduct clinical trials in
117
accordance with the ethical principle of Declaration of Helsinki and GCP standards and it
In terms of Research Quality Management, there is no clear cut or indicator to measure the
research outcome.
1. Research Plan Quality Management: The process of define the scope of quality
requirements for a research project and its deliverables and documenting how the
managed throughout the lifecycle of the research project. It may include the processes
and research methodology for ensuring quality planning, assurance, and control are all
conducted. All research team should be familiar with how quality will be planned,
Good clinical practice possesses a research project standards such as research project
118
The Quality Management Plan for a clinical research documents the necessary
information required to effectively manage the research project quality from research
standards and operational function to meet the organizational standards and their
quality requirements.
The quality manager will provide day to day quality management and conduct process
audits on a weekly / monthly basis, monitor process performance metrics, and assure all
variance, the quality manager will meet with the Project Manager to review and verify
3. Control Quality: The process of monitoring and recording results of executing the quality
control is a procedure or set of procedures to ensure that the research outcome should
adheres to a defined set of quality criteria or meets the requirements of the research
project. Monitoring and recording results of executing the quality activities must be
119
ongoing to ensure that remedial efforts have produced satisfactory results and to detect
A suitable validated method for solving the problem will exist and may be in regular use.
The degree of associated staff training, calibration and quality control used with the
Research Project Human Resource Management includes the processes that organize, recruit
(part time), manage, and lead the research project support team from the operation
prospective not from the scientific. Generally, human resources management consider the
following aspects: human resource planning, reception or organizational entry, selection, job
research needs some modification since most of the research team members are assigned
part-time with variable skills and may there will be addition or removing from the team as the
research progresses.
120
The whole research team are consisting of the following groups:
These are the research investigators which they should have recognized qualifications
(education, training and experience). Research team main purpose is providing scientific
information and theories for the purpose of discovery, innovation, and interpretation or
1. Principle investigator (PI): is the lead scientist for a particular well-defined research
project. PI is the leader for the whole research project from all meanings, and is the
most responsible person in the research team. PI should comply with all institutional
2. Main PI: is the leader for multicenter research study, have similar definition for the
Scientific: preparing the research proposal and making full scope for the
research project.
Technical: Identify the needs, request and approve all the agreements.
Financial: proposing budget, preparing expenditure log sheet and approve all
121
Administrative: Ensure all regulatory requirement issues are completed,
3. Co-Principle Investigator (Co-PI): is the person who takes direct responsibility next to
the PI for completion of a research project. CO-PI have almost similar authorities to
research project under the leadership of the PI. The main responsibility for the sub-
PI is patient recruiting
It is worth to mention that one or more of the investigators should be a qualified physician to
These are one or a group of coworkers that have the impact to execute the methodology
according to the instruction of the research team such as Technologists, Nurses, Pharmacists
Phlebotomists, etc. Their aim is to facilitate the research processes as possible. Recruiting the
research support team through part-time is more reliable and convenient for both parties,
however, there are support team which are usually working in research institution and
1. Research Project Manager also known as clinical research project manager (CRM): The
research project manager is the person assigned by the organization to lead the team
that is responsible for achieving the research objectives. CRM is reporting to the
principle investigator while the research is conducting and after completing the clinical
research will report to the research organization. CRM has responsibilities for over-
coordinating staff, allocating resources, managing the budget, and coordinating overall
efforts to achieve a specific, desired result. CRM is the operation manager for a
research project, therefore, CRM is responsible for preparing everything to the PI except
scientific information (some PI recruit CRM with good clinical background which also
prepare literature review and provide scientific information and this this very possible
2. Clinical Research Coordinator (CRC): To coordinate and facilitate various assigned clinical
research projects to ensure its compliance of the institutional policies and procedures,
the International Conference on Harmonization for Good Clinical Practice and the
123
To provide a leadership role in research protocol development and evaluation of
Implement the practice of the regulatory frameworks and legal requirements associated
Provide comprehensive advice and guidance on matters relating to research ethics and
governance.
Supervise the collected data inserted the data in the proper Case Report Form (CRF) or
3. Research associate will assist the Research team in administration and supervisory
immediate supervisor.
124
4. Research assistant (RA) is responsible for performing, assisting, participating and
compliance with the institutional policies and procedures. RA is with higher level
compared with CRC or RT, yet is less than research associate in the HR ladder.
Research consulting team are consultants individual that have the ability to provide a
from the same field. These individuals have minor impact(s) on the research project yet their
value is very high. It is important to list their fees in the budget preparation and if there is a
staffing management plan. PI and CRM will assign roles and responsibilities to research
team, research supporting team and research consulting team. CRM will work as a team
resource availability and obtaining the right people working on the research project till
complete research activities. Right people mean individuals with the right knowledge
skills and experience that are available to carry out the work assignments within a given
time frames.
3. Develop Research Project Team: The process of team building and overall team
presumed that research support team are the right people (above) where they should
have excellent information and experience yet this is a research project where most
things are for discovery and innovation which should be need training for the tools or
126
4. Manage Research Project Team: The process on how to track research team member
how is their performance, how to provide feedback, and resolving and managing
changes to get precise performance for the research project. CRM must be sure that
the research support team perform exactly according to the research project
management plan.
information between one or a group of the research team and the others in a subject related
to the research project. This process needs appropriate planning, collection, creation,
distribution, storage, retrieval, management, control, monitoring, and the ultimate disposition
of research information.
Effective communication creates a bridge between research team who may have different
perspectives and interests. Research Communications have an influence upon the research
1. Plan Communications Management: The process to find how and when the research
team receive information, and communicate with each other based on research team
127
needs and requirements. Plan Communications process involves determining what kind
of information should be shared with or between the whole research team. The
standard methods of communication that are widely used across the world are either
The communication activities involved in these processes may often have many potential
• Internal (within the research team) and external (customer, vendors, other research org);
• Formal (reports, minutes, emails, memos) and informal (briefings, ad-hoc discussions);
• Vertical (up and down the organization) and horizontal (with peers);
• Official (newsletters, annual report) and unofficial (off the record communications); and
• Written and oral, and verbal (voice inflections) and nonverbal (body language).
128
3. Control Communications: The process of monitoring and controlling communications
throughout the entire research life cycle to ensure the exchanged information of the
research team are met. Effective management is to document the issues and monitor
its resolutions
Research Risk Management includes the processes of conducting risk management planning,
identification, analysis, response planning, and controlling risk on a research project. The main
objectives for risk management is to identify, assess, and prioritize of risk. The objectives of
research risk management are to increase the likelihood and impact of positive events, and
decrease the likelihood and impact of negative events in the research project. The impact of
positive effect in the clinical trials show the pharmaceutical product efficacy, while the
negative impact is the adverse drug reaction of the same pharmaceutical product.
1. Plan Risk Management: The process of defining how to establish risk management
2. Identify Risks: The process of determining which risks may affect the research project
and documenting their characteristics. Identifying risks may depend on the product,
practice and patient compliance. The identification methods for most of adverse event
129
came from nurses and confirm by the responsible physician. All adverse drug reactions
(ADRs) that are both serious and unexpected are subject to expedited reporting.
unexpected ADRs occurring in clinical investigations qualify for very rapid reporting.
writing) as soon as possible but no later than 7 calendar days after first knowledge by
the sponsor that a case qualifies, followed by as complete a report as possible within 8
additional calendar days. This report must include an assessment of the importance and
implication of the findings, including relevant previous experience with the same or
4. Perform Quantitative Risk Analysis: The process of numerically analyzing the effect of
identified risks on overall research objectives. Many terms and scales are in use to
describe the degree of causality between a medicinal product and an event, such as
5. Plan Risk Responses: The process of developing options and actions to enhance
reactions (ADRs) that are not fatal or life-threatening must be filed as soon as possible
but no later than 15 calendar days after first knowledge by the sponsor that the case
monitoring residual risks, identifying new risks, and evaluating risk process effectiveness
throughout the research project. Information for final description and evaluation of a
case report may not be available within the required time frames for reporting outlined
above. Nevertheless, for regulatory purposes, initial reports should be submitted within
the prescribed time as long as the following minimum criteria are met: an identifiable
outcome that can be identified as serious and unexpected, and for which, in clinical
products, services, or results needed from outside the institution to perform a research. It
involves considering whether to procure, how to procure, what to procure, how much to
procure, and when to procure. Research Procurement Management includes purchase orders,
the contract management and change control processes required to develop and administer
Research Procurement Management also includes controlling any legal contracts issued by an
131
that will require outside resources, services, products to be able to meet the research
decisions, specifying the approach, and identifying potential sellers. Procurement officer
needs to have skills in understanding social, political, legal, and financial implications to
manage procurement process; also should have direct communication with the CRM.
2. Conduct Procurements: The process of obtaining seller responses, selecting a seller, and
awarding a contract. Direct procurement occurs in should be consider all the research
responsibility of the CRM to keep all manuals, invoices, and records until the end of the
research life cycle. Closed Procurements involves reviewing the payment invoices,
132
contract, and providing a formal written intimation to the seller. Department of
property should record all purchased equipment during the research processes as assets
to the organizational. The CRM should ensure that all payment were received by
vendors.
Research Team Management includes the processes required to be able to administer and
organize the whole research team. CRM should have the impact to analyze research team
expectations and their impact on the research project, and to how develop appropriate
management strategies for effectively engaging research teams in research project decisions
and execution. Principle investigator and CRM are also focus on continuous communication
with research teams to understand their needs and expectations, addressing issues as they
occur, managing conflicting interests and fostering appropriate research team engagement in
research project decisions and activities. CRM will first evaluate the objective of the research
team to understand what is needed to accomplish the task. Then, the CRM should identify the
strengths and weaknesses and to ensure that all research team members know what each
communication.
133
For a clinical research, the principle investigator and CRM processes that include the following:
1. Identify Research teams: The process of identifying the people, groups, or organizations
project; and analyzing and documenting relevant information regarding their interests,
strategies to effectively engage research teams throughout the research life cycle, based
on the analysis of their needs, interests, and potential impact on research success.
3. Manage Research team Engagement: The process of communicating and working with
research teams to meet their needs/expectations, address issues as they occur, and
4. Control Research team Engagement: The process of monitoring overall research team
relationships and adjusting strategies and plans for engaging research teams.
134
References:
1. Robert S. Redmount; New Dimensions of Professional Responsibility: The Journal of the
Legal Profession 43-56.
2. Stephanie Reid, Demand Media; What Is Professional Responsibility in Nursing?
3. Ian Dalling “Integrated Management Definition”, Chartered Quality Institute Integrated
Management Special Interest Group, Issue 2.1 (2007:3).
4. Harald A. Mieg, Wilfried Endlicher, and Hadia Köhler; Four types of knowledge
integration management in interdisciplinary research on cities and the environment.
Cities and the Environment 1(1):2008
5. Paul Newton. Managing Project Scope - Free Management eBooks, 2015 www.free-
management-ebooks.com/dldebk-pdf/fme-project-scope.pdf
6. Cynthia Snyder Stackpole; Validate Scope Basics and the Flow of Deliverables for the
PMP Certification Exam, from PMP Certification All-in-One For Dummies, 2nd Edition.
7. Project Time Management – TutorialsPoint
www.tutorialspoint.com/management.../project_time_management.htm
8. Robin Henderson; Research Project Management Key Concepts
[email protected] ; My consultant, 2010
9. Shannon W. Managing Costs and Cost Structure throughout the Value Chain: Research
on Strategic Cost Management. In: Chapman, C., Hopwood, A. and Shields, M. (2006)
Handbook of Management Accounting Research. Vol 2. Oxford: Elsevier.
10.Qun Gao; Research on Cost Control and Management of Real Estate Project.
International Journal of Business and Management. Volume 4, No. 12 December, 2009.
School of Business Administration, Nanjing Institute of Industry Technology Nanjing
210046, China
11.Vinod Kumar, Dong-Young, and Uma Kuma; Quality management in research and
development.
12.International Journal of Quality and Service Sciences Vol. 4 No. 2, 2012 pp. 156-174.
13.Barbara B. Flynn, Roger G. Schroederb, and Sadao Sakakibara. A framework for quality
management research and an associated measurement instrument. Journal of
Operations Management 11 (1994) 339-366.
14.Quality Management - Harvard School of Public Health
www.hsph.harvard.edu/clarc/quality_management.pdf
135
15.Adams C, Cammann K, HA Deckers, et al. Quality Assurance for Research and
Development and Non-routine Analysis. October 1998 . www.citac.cc/rdguide.pdf
16.Project Human Resources Management -
www.free-management-ebooks.com/dldebk-pdf/fme-project-hr.pdf
17.Fabi B and Pettersen N; Human resource management practices in project management.
International Journal of Project Management. Vol 10 No 2 May 1992 .
18.Communication: - Project Management Institute
https://www.pmi.org/~/media/.../Communications_whitepaper_v2.ashx
19.Mary Young, and James E. Managing to communicate, communicating to manage: How
leading companies communicate with employees.
20.Pritchard CL; Risk management: concepts and guidance, fifth edition. 2015 CRC Press
Taylor & Francis Group.
21.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 2008. Defining Team Roles and
Responsibilities. [Instructor Guide]. Pennsylvania: Human Resource Development
Quarterly.
22.Research Team: Gemma Moss Jacqui MacDonald Sophie Covey-Crump Penny Clarke
(External Consultant). Good Practice in Leading and Supporting a Research Team: A
Guide for Research Staff and Project Managers. 2009 A Staff Development Publication,
Second Edition.
136
Questions – Methodology/ Execution
3. It is defined as the ethical and moral duty of a researcher to what has to be done, how and when or an
ethical consideration permitting the researchers to work according to specific standards.
a. Professional Manner
b. Moral Integrity
c. Professional Responsibility
d. Moral Responsibility
4. The terminology that can be defined as incorporating the effective direction of research methodology
so that needs and expectations of all research team are equitably satisfied by the best use of all
resources is called ____________________________________?
a. Research Integrated Management
b. Professional Responsibility
137
c. Research Project Integration Management
d. None of the Above
5. What process in the research project integration management pertains to the process of tracking all
essential documents, reviewing changes & reporting project progress against the objectives?
a. Collect all essential documents.
b. Direct and manage project work.
c. Monitor and control project work.
d. Perform integrated change control.
6. What process in the research project integration management that process is defined, prepared, and
coordinated all subsidiary plans and integrated them into a comprehensive research project
management plan?
a. Monitor and control project work.
b. Develop project management plan.
c. Direct and manage project work.
d. Close project or phase.
7. The following processes are included in Research Project Scope Management, EXCEPT:
a. Evaluate Scope
b. Plan Scope Management
c. Control Scope
d. Define Scope
8. In the creation of work breakdown structure (WBS), what do you call each of the phases that are
decomposed into tasks or groups of tasks?
a. Work Breakdown Structure
b. Deployment Activities
c. Research Project Phase
d. Research Work Packages
138
9. What should be the main concern to be considered at the Research Project Time Management phase?
a. The time of the whole research team , of the research support team and of the Clinical
Research Project Manager
b. Just the time of the Clinical Research Project Manager
c. The time of the Principal Investigator and Clinical Research Project Manager
d. None of the above
10. What is considered as the main output of the Time Management Process?
a. Deliverable Tasks
b. Estimate Activity Durations
c. Sequence Activities
d. Control Schedule
11. What do you call the costs over the life of the research project that determines the quarterly and total
funding requirements?
a. Cost Performance
b. Cost Estimates
c. Budget
d. None of the Above
12. Who should be familiar with how quality will be planned, assured and controlled in a research project?
139
13. What should the quality manager do during occurrence of discrepancy or variance in a research
project?
a. Meet with the Project Manager to review and verify the identified discrepancy.
b. Meet with the Principal Investigator to review and verify the identified discrepancy or variance.
c. Meet with the Research Team to review and verify the identified discrepancy or variance.
d. Meet with the Project Manager to set procedures to ensure compliance.
14. Which of the following aspects is not being considered in Human Resources Management of a research
study:
a. Human Resource Planning
b. Estimate Activity Resources
c. Job Analysis
d. Performance Assessment
15. The following team made up the complete research team, EXCEPT:
a. Research Team
b. Research Support Team
c. Administration Team
d. Research Consulting Team
16. How does an occurrence of serious but non-fatal adverse drug reaction should be handled?
a. Report to the regulatory agencies as soon as possible or not later than 7 working days.
b. Must be reported as soon as possible but not later than 15 working days after first knowledge
by the PI that the case meets the minimum criteria for expedited reporting.
c. Must be reported as soon as possible but not later than 15 working days after first knowledge
by the research team that the case meets the minimum criteria for expedited reporting.
d. Must be reported as soon as possible within 15 calendar days after first knowledge by the
sponsor that the case meets the minimum criteria for expedited reporting.
140
17. What do you call the document that provides the product description, acceptance criteria, delivery and
constraint about the project?
a. Legal Contracts
b. Purchase Orders
c. Scope Statement of Procurement
d. Procurement Management
18. Who should have the skills in understanding social, political, legal and financial implications to
management the procurement process?
a. Principal Investigator
b. Procurement Officer
c. Clinical Research Project Manager
d. Vendor
19. The following are the reasons why Principal Investigator and Clinical Research Project Manager should
also focus on continuous communication with research team, EXCEPT:
a. To convey the demands and expectations of the sponsor
b. To understand their needs and expectations
c. To address issues as they occur
d. To manage conflicting interests and to foster appropriate research team engagement
20. What phase of this chapter that has influence on the execution and outcome of the research study?
a. Research Quality Management
b. Research Risk Management
c. Research Cost Management
d. Research Communications Management
141
ANSWERS
1. b. Project execution phase is the third phase, it is the longest phase in the research and will execute
the tasks described in the plans, processes, and implement procedures.
2. d. One of the research support team should do the recording in the CRF.
3. c. Professional responsibility.
4. a. Research Integrated Management.
5. c. The process tracking all essential documents is Monitor and control project work.
6. b. The process defined, prepared, and coordinated all subsidiary plans and integrated them into a
comprehensive research project management plan is Develop project management plan.
7. a. Evaluate Scope.
8. d. Research Work Packages.
9. a. The time of the whole research team is the main concern.
10. b. The main output of the Time Management Process is to Estimate Activity Durations.
11. c. Budget is the costs over the life of the research project.
12. d. All research team should be familiar with how quality will be planned, assured and controlled in a
research project.
13. a. The quality manager should meet with the Project Manager to review and verify the identified
discrepancy.
14. b. Estimate Activity Resources.
15. c. Administration team.
16. d. An occurrence of serious but non-fatal adverse drug reaction must be reported as soon as possible.
17. c. Scope Statement of Procurement provides the product description, acceptance criteria, delivery and
constraint about the project.
18. b. Procurement Officer should have the skills in understanding social, political, legal and financial
implications to management the procurement process.
19. a. To convey the demands and expectations of the sponsor.
20. d. Research Communications Management.
142
Chapter 5.
Monitoring and
Controlling
Research Project Manager
143
RESEARCH PROJECT MONITORING AND CONTROLLING
The Monitoring and Controlling is the process to confirm that all tasks of the research project
that was approved by the IRB and regulatory authorities and getting authorized for conduction
should be within scope, on time, and on budget so that the research project proceeds with
minimal risk. This process encompasses comparing tangible performance with planned
performance baseline and taking corrective action to get the desirable research. Monitoring
and Controlling process is continuous assessment throughout the life cycle of the research
project. It aims to provide the sponsor with early detailed information on the progress or
The research project control is a key member of the project management and works directly
with the research project manager (CRM) to help define the project's goals and objectives;
create and maintain a project's budget and schedule, analyze progress reported against the
work schedules; and recommend actions to improve progress. Planning and control are at the
opposite sides of the same coin. In order to ensure accurate documentation and reporting on
a consistent basis, many organizations are positioning the project manager and project
144
Monitoring and controlling processes is to observe research project execution in order to
identify any problem or variance from the proposed methodology and find ways for corrective
action. The key benefit of monitoring and controlling is that project performance is observing
and measuring regularly to identify variances from the project management plan. The
monitoring and control process should implement corrective or preventive actions to bring the
project into compliance with the project management plan. Monitoring the research project
variables against the project management plan and the project performance baseline is
Project monitors should ensure that the clinical trial is conducted and documented properly,
including laboratories. Project monitors should also ensure that equipment are adequate to
safely and properly conduct the trial throughout the trial period. Moreover, verifying that the
investigational product(s) are supplied and stored in acceptable conditions. Project manager
on the other hand, pays particular attention to unacceptable variances in the protocol and
those that cannot be tolerated, such as in case adverse drug reaction for an investigational
drug. Important question(s) should always be asked in clinical trials involving drugs, such as:
Can we live with a side effect of a medication? Or: Can we live without this medication? This is
exactly similar to the argument of the IRB committee to make their decision to eliminate an
145
Project monitors should has an ongoing responsibility for the ethical conduct of research, and
therefore must be informed of all subsequent amendments to the protocol and if there is any
serious adverse events occurring during the trial, or other new information likely to affect the
safety of the subjects or the conduct of the trial. Monitors should convey their opinion(s) and
advice(s) in writing to the IRB within a reasonable time, clearly identifying the trial protocol,
duration of the study, supporting staff and available facilities and to comply with the
2. The suitability of the protocol including the objectives of the study and the justification
of predictable risks and inconveniences weighed against the anticipated benefits for the
3. To ensure the way of recruitment used as subjects and how appropriate information will
4. Provision, if any, for compensation or treatment in the case of death or other loss or
indemnity (a source of legal and financial support) to cover the liability of the
safety of the clinical trial subjects or to control the conduct of the trial.
6. To ensure that the investigator should promptly report to the IRB in case of:
Deviations from, or changes of, the protocol to eliminate immediate hazards to the
trial subjects.
Changes increasing the risk to subjects and/or affecting significantly the conduct of
the trial.
All adverse drug reactions (ADRs) that are both serious and unexpected.
New information that may affect adversely the safety of the subjects or the conduct
of the trial.
The monitor should assess the trial site prior to the clinical trial to ensure that the
facilities (including laboratories, equipment and staff) are adequate, and that an
adequate number of trial subjects is likely to be available for the duration of the trial.
The monitor should also assess the trial site during and after the trial to ensure that the
investigator complies with the protocol and that data are handled in accordance with
147
2. Staff education and compliance
The monitor should ensure that all staff assisting the investigator in the trial have been
adequately informed about and will comply with the details of the trial protocol.
3. Data management
The monitor should assist the investigator in reporting the data and results of the trial to
the sponsor, e.g. by providing guidance on correct procedures for completion of case-
4. Case-report forms
The monitor is responsible for ensuring that all case-report forms (CRFs) are correctly
filled out in accordance with original observations. Any errors or omissions should be
clarified with the investigator, corrected, and explained on the CRF. Procedures should
initials or similar method. All procedures for ensuring accuracy of CRFs must be
148
5. Investigational product
The monitor should confirm that procedures for the storage, dispensing, and return of
6. Communication
The monitor should facilitate communication between the investigator and sponsor. The
monitor (or some other responsible person designated by the sponsor and known to the
investigator) should be available to the investigator at all times for reporting of adverse
The monitor should assist the investigator in notifying the drug regulatory authority of
8. Reports
The monitor should submit a written monitor report to the sponsor after each site visit
and after all relevant telephone calls, letters and other contacts with the investigator.
The report should include details of the findings and any actions taken and should
149
include a summary of what the monitor reviewed and the monitor's statements
Monitor is the key element that keeps the research projects on-track, on-time and within
budget. Monitors begins early in the project with planning and ends late in the project with
Research projects may be audited or reviewed while the project is in progress. The main
difference between monitor and auditor is that auditor is independent of, and separate from
routine monitoring or quality control functions, should also evaluate clinical trial conduct and
compliance with the protocol, a standard operating procedures (SOPs), GCP, and the
Formal audits are generally risk or compliance-based and management that will direct the
objectives of the audit. Each research project should be assessed for the appropriate level of
control needed: too much control is too time consuming, too little control is very risky. If a
research project control is not implemented correctly, the cost to the sponsor should be
clarified in terms of errors and fixes. To preserve the independence and value of the audit
function, the regulatory authorities (such as SFDA) should not routinely request the audit
reports. Applicable regulatory authorities may seek access to an audit report on a case-by-case
150
basis, when evidence of serious GCP noncompliance exists, or if there is a violation to the
Change in research plan is a normal and expected part of the research process. Changes can be
the result of necessary design modifications, methodology, differing site conditions, material
availability, sponsor-requested changes, and impacts from third parties. Hence documentation
is essential to the IRB, and regulatory authorities whether if it is inside or outside the
institution. From a regular point of view, the PI or CRM should submit a final or updated
records to show any changes that modifies the research process until the research life cycle is
getting completed.
Variance is a set of procedures explaining how official project documents can be changed.
Keep in mind that no deviations from, or changes of, the protocol should be initiated without
prior written IRB approval of an appropriate amendment, except when necessary to eliminate
immediate hazards to the subjects or when the change(s) involves only logistical or
If there is a change during the research process, the practicability of the research project
needs to be reassessed. If the changes accumulated, the objective of the research project
could not be predicted as planned in the original proposal. Tracking and controlling the
151
research process is a fundamental process to conduct a research progress so as to stay within
time and budget frames already outlined at the commencement of the project.
project management. It implements verification and controlling function during the processing
of a research project in order to reinforce the defined performance and formal goals and in
the meantime to ensure the protection of the rights and welfare of human subjects
participating in clinical trials. The tasks of research project controlling are also:
Project controls is defined as process on how to do data gathering, management and analytical
processes used to predict, understand and constructively influence the time and cost
152
Control systems are needed for cost, risk, quality, communication, time, change, procurement,
and human resources. In addition, auditors should consider how important the projects are to
the financial statements, how reliant the sponsors are on controls, and how many controls
exist. Auditors should review the development process and procedures for how they are
implemented. The process of development and the quality of the final product may also be
assessed if needed or requested. A sponsor may want the auditing firm to be involved
throughout the research process to catch problems earlier on so that they can be fixed more
easily. An auditor can serve as a controls consultant as part of the development of the
Reference:
Project/programme monitoring and evaluation (M&E) guide. International Federation of
Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, Geneva, 2011.
www.ifrc.org/Global/.../monitoring/IFRC
153
Questions about Monitoring and Controlling
2. The research project controller is a key member of the project management team and in the following
tasks, EXCEPT:
a. To help define the project’s goals and objectives
b. To create and maintain a project’s budget and schedule
c. To recommend actions to improve the progress of the research
d. To analyze progress report against the financial schedule
3. Who is responsible in giving attention to variances, which are unacceptable, those that cannot be
tolerated, such as in case adverse drug reaction for an investigational drug?
a. Project Manager
b. Principal Investigator
c. Monitor
d. Sponsor
154
4. Who is responsible for the ethical conduct of a research?
a. Principal Investigator
b. Clinical Research Project Manager
c. Monitor
d. Sponsor
5. Monitor should consider ensuring that the investigator should promptly report to the IRB the following
cases, EXCEPT:
a. Some adverse drug reactions (ADRs) those are unexpected.
b. Changes increasing the risk to subjects and / or affecting significantly the conduct of the trial.
c. Deviations from, or changes of, the protocol to eliminate immediate hazards to the trial
subjects.
d. New information that may affect adversely the safety of the subjects or the conduct of the trial.
6. What responsibility of Monitor where they should assist the investigator in reporting the data and
results of the trial to the sponsor?
a. Case-report forms
b. Communication
c. Investigational product
d. Data Management
155
8. Which among the below statements in the communication responsibility of a monitor is CORRECT?
a. Sponsor should facilitate communication between the Clinical Research Project Manager and
Monitor
b. Monitor should facilitate communication between the Investigator and Sponsor
c. Monitor should facilitate communication between the Clinical Research Project Manager and
Sponsor
d. NONE OF THE ABOVE
a. Monitor report should be verbally discussed to the sponsor after every other site visit and includes
monitor’s statements concerning all findings only.
b. Monitor report should be written and submitted to the Investigator after each site visit and all
communications with the Sponsor, which includes the details of the findings and any action taken
and the summary of what the monitor reviewed and his statements concerning the significant
findings/facts, actions taken or to be taken and/or recommended actions to secure compliance.
c. Monitor report should be written and submitted to the Sponsor after each site visit and all
communications with the Investigator, which includes the details of the findings and any action
taken and the summary of what the monitor reviewed and his statements concerning the
significant findings/facts, actions taken or to be taken and/or recommended actions to secure
compliance.
156
10. Who is known as the element that keeps the research projects on-track, on-time and within the
budget and part in the early and post-implementation review of the project?
a. Monitor
b. Sponsor
c. Investigator
d. Auditor
11. Applicable regulatory authorities may seek access to an audit report on case-by-case basis or on
the following circumstances, EXCEPT:
12. The following conditions suggest change in research project plan, EXCEPT:
a. Differing site conditions
b. Material Availability
c. Convenience of the Investigator
d. Design Modifications
13. What is the most important requirement for any deviations from or changes of the protocol?
157
14. Which of the below statements define Research Project Controlling?
b. Tasks of research project controlling includes the creation of in infrastructure for all procurement
for a research project, variance analyses and generate for potential project changes regulations,
creation of transparency among the project parameters and review amendment and follow-up for
an appropriate project structure, project workflow organization, project control and governance.
c. Research Project Controlling implements verification and controlling during the processing of a
research project in order to reinforce the defined performance and formal goals and in the
meantime to ensure the protection of the rights and welfare of human subjects participating in
clinical trials.
15. Who should perform the review of the development process and procedures for how they were
implemented and may serve as controls consultant as part of the development of the research
team?
a. Auditor
b. Monitor
c. Investigator
158
ANSWERS
1. c. Monitoring and Controlling process is continuous assessment throughout the life cycle of the
research project.
2. d. To analyze progress report against the financial schedule
3. a. Project Manager is responsible in giving attention to variances.
4. c. Monitor
5. a. Some adverse drug reactions (ADRs) those are unexpected.
6. d. Data Management
7. a. Throughout the course of the clinical trial
8. b. Monitor should facilitate communication between the Investigator and Sponsor
9. c. Monitor report should be written and submitted to the Sponsor after each site visit and all
communications with the Investigator.
10. a. Monitor.
11. d. Applicable regulatory authorities may seek access to an audit report on case-by-case basis,
when evidence of serious GCP noncompliance exist.
13. b. The most important requirement for any deviations from or changes of the protocol is Prior
written approval of IRB
15. a. Auditor should perform the review of the development process and procedures.
159
Chapter 5.
Closing
Research Project Manager
160
RESEARCH PROJECT CLOSING
Research closing is the process that include all final activities in the research project
management which mean that the research project is ending thereof. All technical and clinical
across all of the processes are completed. All administrative activities include the archiving of
the files and documentation are finished. It also includes the process of writing article(s) and
manuscript(s) and doing final touches. Final technical report to the sponsor, IRB and regulatory
Payment to research team and research support team have been made.
performed; and to ensure that payment have been made (if any).
Close all part-time contracts with research support team or personnel reassignment.
All equipment purchased during the research processes were received by the property
department (even if it is still in the PI research laboratory) as assets for the institution.
161
Turnover of project deliverables to the property department to be assets to the
institution.
3. Sponsor:
All case report form (CRFs) are completed and send to sponsor.
4. Writing manuscript
162
5. Final remarks
Giving credit to the research team through formal recognition and celebrating the
Transfer successfully research outcome information for the use of future research
projects.
The minimum list of essential documents that has been developed for every phase during the
research processes. The various documents are grouped in three sections according to the
A description is given of the purpose of each document, and whether it should be filed in
either the investigational institution or sponsor files, or both. It is acceptable to combine some
Closing is the final phase in which gives the chance to capture and transfer successfully
research project information for the use of future research projects. Also included in closing
163
phase is the Post Implementation Review. This is a vital phase of the research project for the
project research team to learn from experiences and apply to future projects. Normally a post
implementation review consists of looking at things that went well and analyzing things that
Put in mind that operational process is not similar to a project process. A project such as a
clinical research, should has a definite start and end date whereas, an operation process does
not have definite end date. Whether the project has been successful or is not, a project needs
to be closed! Although it is important to ensure that the research production is with the
desirable outcomes, it is normal to have negative expectation, or loose ends at the end of a
research project. The fact is there is no loose ends in research whether if the research
Outcomes research is applied clinical and population based research that seeks to study and
optimize the end results of healthcare in terms of benefits to the patient and society. The
intent of ant particular research is to identify shortfalls in practice and to develop strategies to
improve care.
Outcomes research seeks to provide evidence about which interventions work best for which
types of patients and under what circumstances. However, the evaluation methodology of
outcomes research may include both experimental and non-experimental designs: further, the
"intervention" being evaluated is not limited to medications or new clinical procedures, but
164
may also include the provision of particular services or resources, or even the enforcing of
specific policies and regulations by legislative/financial bodies. Also, while traditional clinical
trials focus primarily on therapeutic efficacy and safety, outcomes research may consider
Clinical trial where the use of human as subjects are prone to adverse drug reaction or events
that could be endanger the health of the subjects, therefore it is important to ensure the
protection of the rights, safety, and well-being of human subjects involved in a trial. Efficient
trials is essential. “The Closing Process Group consists of those processes performed to
conclude all activities across all Project Management Process Groups to formally complete the
165
References:
1. Project Close-Out Practices Guide
www2.cdc.gov/.../CDC_UP_Project_Close-Out_Practices_Guide.pd
2. Post Implementation Evaluation Report (PIER); Health and Human Services Agency,
Office of Systems Integration Project Management Office. August 2008
3. PROJECT MANAGEMENT GUIDELINE; SECTION 5 – PROJECT CLOSEOUT PHASE, 2006
166
Research Study closeout “checklist”
Protocol ……………………
Sponsor ……………………..
Investigator …………………..
Date ……………
167
168
Name of Research Institution
RESEARCH GRANT FINANCIAL REPORT
Protocol No: Res protocol No 1 P.I. : Dr. Xxxx Yyyy Zzzz
Title: Title of the Research Project Duration: 12 Months
APPROVED BUDGET ACTUAL DISBURSEMENTS
INV.NO / CASH FROM CASH DIRECT Special BALANCE
BUDGET ITEMS AMOUNT REF # DATE DATE PAYEE DESCRIPTION TOTAL
RECEIPT NO. ADVANCE ADVANCE PAYMENT Purchase
Principal Investigator 40,000 40,000
Sub-Investigator(s) 100,000 100,000
Scientific Consultant 25,000 Ref/fin/12 01/06/2016 Dr John Scientific consultaion 25,000 0
Biostatistician 15,000 Ref/fin/14 15/06/2016 Dr Hasan 1st Payment 5,000 10,000
Research Nurse 40,000 Ref/fin/17 01/09/2016 XX YY ZZ Payment for 6 nurses 12,500 27,500
150 patients (total of 250vists)
Technician 20,000 Ref/fin/15 01/08/2016 150 patints x50 7,500 12,500
Interviewer 48,000 Ref/fin/21 01/10/2016 150*12*10 18000 30,000
SUB-TOTAL 288,000 - - - 68,000 220,000
Continuous Gluco-monitor 200,000 Ref/fin/3 01/03/2016 Glu/M 06 01/04/2016 X Y Gluco manufacture SPR # 1234 200,000 0
Laptops 10,000 Ref/fin/5 01/017/2016LP/221 01/03/2016 Lap top and devices SPR # 1235 8500 1,500
Glucometers Free
SUB-TOTAL 210,000 - - - 208,500 1,500
Strips 240,000 Ref/fin/2 01/03/2016 Glu/M 05 01/04/2016 X Y Gluco manufacture SPR# 1233 120,000 120,000
SUB-TOTAL 240,000 - - - 120,000 120,000
Travelling 30,000 Ref/fin/6 12/04/2016 12400 17,600
Accommodation 20,000 Ref/fin/7 15/04/2016 6500 13,500
Advertisement 10,000 Ref/fin/13 14/06/2016 8000 2,000
Publication cost 10,000 10,000
SUB-TOTAL 70,000 - - - 26,900 43,100
Miscellanous 50,000 31900 18,100
Transportaion Ref/fin/9 15/05/2016 3400
Shipment Ref/fin/18 22/08/2016 1500
Training Ref/fin/21 27/09/2016 15,000
Meeting Ref/fin/23 03/10/2016 12000
SUB-TOTAL 50,000 - - - 63,800 18,100
GRAND TOTAL 858,000 487,200 402,700
Work Breakdown Structure for writing a manuscript 1/2
manuscript title
authors and affiliations
Level
1 Abstract
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Method
1.3 Result
1.4 Conclusion
2 Introdcution
2.1 Project Summary
2.2 Background information
2.2.1 Reason for conducting Research
2.2.2 Current Situation
2.2.3 Definition of Key Concept
2.3 Litrature Review
2.3.1 Problem that basis of the Project
2.3.2 Cause of the problem
2.3.3 Possible Solution
2.4 Study Goals
2.4.1 Aims
2.4.2 Objective
2.4.3 Purpose
3 Methodology
3.1 Study Design and Participant
3.1.1 Type of the Study
3.1.2 Population
3.1.2.1 Participant Recruitment
3.1.2.2 inclusion criteria
3.1.2.3 exclusion criteria
169
Work Breakdown Structure for writing a manuscript 2/2
4 Results
4..1 Participants demographic characteristics
4.2 Outcomes
4.2.1 tables
4.2.2 figures and graphs
5 Discussion
5.1 Summary of results
5.2 comparison with similar literatures
5.3 strengths and limitations
5.4 implication in practice
5.5 recommendations
6 conclusion
7 Acknowledgments
8 conflect of intrest
9 source of funding
10 references
10.1 primary refrences
10.2 websites
10.3 books
11 appendices
170