GraphicalComparisonsof Interferences in ClinicalChemistryInstrumentation
GraphicalComparisonsof Interferences in ClinicalChemistryInstrumentation
Instrument-and analyte-specificinterferencescan be pro- ences, we present a method for measuring and reporting
ducedby addingknownconcentrationsof potentiallyinterfer- interference data, and have begun assembling a “user’s
ing substancesto serum from healthyvolunteers.Analytical guide” for those who wish to compare results from various
resultsare expressedas a percentageof the original(unaf- clinical chemistry instruments. Here we describe the tech-
fected) result. Graphical displays of the transformeddata niques used to generate the graphical displays we shall refer
document the conditions under which erroneous results to as “interferographs,” and discuss the potential usefulness
would be probablefor specimenscontainingthe additive. If of the information these graphs contain (9, 10).
several analyticalsystems are available, one can make an
informedchoice of which to use for a particularanalysisby MaterIals and Methods
comparing the appropriategraphical information.Compari- Serum was obtained from freshly clotted blood drawn
sons of such displays of data from newer systems being from the authors, who were in good health and had used no
consideredfor purchase may facilitatedecisions regarding drugs, including alcohol, for at least 48 h before phlebotomy.
laboratoryinstrumentation. To evaluate the effect of in vitro hemolysis, turbdity, and
bilirubinemia on currently available clinical laboratory
AddItIonalKeyphrases:variation,source of discrete analysis instrumentation, we prepared a series of 20 supplemented
hemolysis .Iipemia turbidity . bilirubinemia
.
sera, as described below. The wide range of concentrations
economicsof laboratoryoperation ‘inferferograplis” for the added substances was chosen during pilot studies,
and by considering the variety of specimens received in our
The ubiquitous nature of interfering substances in clinical hospital laboratory. Aliquots of the supplemented aera were
chemistry assays is generally appreciated by laboratory frozen (-20 #{176}C)and were vigorously mixed after thawing
personnel and, to a lesser extent, by physicians using and immediately before use.
clinical chemistry laboratory data. Extensive lists of inter- Addition of biirubin: We suspended 6 mg of bilirubin
fering compounds (1,2) indicate the widespread effects of (reference standard; Pfanstiehl Labs, Inc., Waukegan, IL
certain drugs and serum constituents; other reports have 60085) in 0.1 mL of dimethyl sulfoxide (ACS grade; Fisher
focused on factors affecting either a specific analysis (3,4), a Scientific Co., Fair Lawn, NJ 07410), then added 0.2 mL of
particular instrumental system (5), or the interfering effect sodium carbonate solution, 0.1 mol/L. This solution was
of a selected drug or class of compounds (6). Reviews added slowly, with continuous mixing, to 9.4 mL of serum;
describing the quantitative effects of interfering substances then 0.2 mL of a 0.1 mol/L HC1 solution was added. We also
have necessarily been limited in scope (7). added proportional amounts of dimethyl sulfoxide, sodium
Technical disclaimers by the manufacturers about the carbonate, and HC1 to another aliquot of the same serum;
potential effect of an interferent are often frustratingly thus producing a “diluent serum” that was similar to the
vague or couched in such general terms as to be almost bilirubin-enriched serum in pH, ionic composition, and
meaningless-e.g., “... hemolysis should be avoided .. other characteristics. These sera were then mixed to make
“... lipemia may cause a falsely increased result ...“ specimens with added bilirubun concentrations of 9,19, 38,
Unfortunately, the unique nature of specimen collection 75,150,300, and 600 mg/L. Bilirubin concentrations were
sometimes makes it impossible to reconstruct the patient’s confirmed by analysis of the diluted serum (11).
original condition or to obtain a specimen that is free from Addition of lipid.s: The turbidity of lipemia was simulated
potential interfering substances. In these circumstances it by adding Intralipid#{174}
20% (Cutter Laboratories, Inc., Berke-
would be useful to have specific information available about ley, CA 94710) to serum. The msrimum concentration, lOg
both the qualitative and quantitative effect of an unterferent of Intralipid per liter of serum, was attained by adding one
on the analytical system, in order to obtain information volume of hntralipid to 19 volumes of the serum. To an
unavailable otherwise. The product labeling of reagents is aliquot of the same serum we added an equal proportion of
not always a reliable source of information about interfering water, to simulate the dilution from the added lipids.
substances, or at best is not in a format that is easily used in Admixture of the supplemented and diluted sera produced
the laboratory (5). Although the subtle differences among specimens containing added hntralipid in concentrations of
similar clinical chemistry analyses are not always appreci- 0.67, 1.25, 2.5, 5, and 10 g/L. The most turbid of these
ated, these differences can account for dramatically different specimens caused a triglyceride readout of 25 g/L in the
assay results when an interfering substance is present (8). Hitachi 705 analyzer.
To encourage standardization in the reporting of interfer. Addition of hemolysat#{233}: Fresh hemolysate (hemoglobin
content at least 200 g/L) was prepared by washing erythro-
cytes (from the same volunteers who were the source of
Department of Pathology, Indiana University School of Medicine, serum) four times with cold isotonic saline solution. After
Wishard Memorial Hospital, 1100 W. Tenth St., Indianapolis, IN eachresuspension of cells and eachrepacking by centrifiiga-
46202.
Presented in part at the 35th and 37th national meetings of the tion, we discarded the supernatant solution and leukocytes.
AACC in New York, NY, July 1983, and Atlanta, GA, July 1985. After the final centrifugation and removal of all possible
Received October 21, 1985; accepted December 16, 1985. saline solution, we lysed the erythrocytes by adding distilled
Creatinine 80 mg
LDH 136U
AST 31U U,
ALT 15U
4
Bilirubin(total) 9 mg z
Billrubln(direct) 2 mg 0
Calcium 91 mg 0
*AST
180 - *AMYLASE
*UREA NITROGEN
180
* CK
* LOU
* LIPASE
* CALCIUM
acaTM
GE GE
* PH OS PHORUS
0 140
0
S * URIC ACID
* ALBUMIN
* CHOLESTEROL
I-
120 - *ALT PHOSPHASE
0I A,
B B
4 4 ROTEjpj......
::
2 C
0 0
B B
0 0
4 4
C C
40
20
I I I I I I I I I
.05 .10 .15 .20 .25 .30 .35 .40 .45 .50 .55 .60
LIPEMIA NTRALIPID ADDED, giLl BILIRUBIN ADDED (gill
Fig. 2. Effect of added turbidity (left) or bilirubin (right) on clinical chenilstiy analyses with the ace
Left: billiubin assayed as described in the legend to 19g.1. C. bHritfn, direct bitrubin; ALT, alanine aminoiraneferase; AST, aspeftate aminotransferase; LDH,lactate
dehydrugenase.Other abbreviations as listed for FIg. 1
200
IHO
lb *500400
S *P0TA* HITACHI’
IOU U 705
to *40,
ID
LEETSN0L4ft****** CO LOB IDE.
ALOALNEp0 so
HO *GLuc001m
0 *CNEAI1NINE
*000IUM
So *POTAISIUM
,urncAao
*PHOEPOOHOS
HITACHI#{174}
*1DB
40 SAlT 705
* ALT
Sd
20
1111111111
1 2 3 4 5 0 7 0 5 tO
OOMOLYSATE ADDED IHEMOOLOSIN. B/LI LIPEMIA IINTOAUPID ADDED. g/Ll DUDSIO 000IDIWLI
Fig. 3. HItachi 705 readout as a function of added hemolysate (left), turbidity (center), and bilirubin (rht)
Abbreviationsas for Figs. 1 and 2. M-E, Htachi bltnln assay by the Malloy/Evelynmethod. Two differentglucose methods were used: T, Trinder’s;H, hexoidnase
200
SOLUCOIB
100 0 US IA
0 AMMONIA
*CHLO*IDU
#{149}AMYLA*E
‘SO S CALCIUM
*UBOTEIN
U * ACT
45 SALT
if ifTM “OH
‘CI
EKTACHEM#{176}
120 SIIUNUSIN 700
*CSIATININE
I
*HICASSOAATE
10 00REI$#{176}
J)sIc..*SeD-.0oIUM’
.uer
00
#{149} EKTACHEM”
700
40
20
Fig. 4. Ektachem 700 readout as a functionof added hemolyeate (lef, turbidity (center), and bilirubin (right)
Abbreviationsas for Figs. 1 and 2
upwardly-sloping line should result when one evaluates the showing that the added contaminant is actuaUy being
effect of added hemolysate on valuesfor potassium concen- detected. Although viewed as an interference and a contra-
trations. This (predicted) response would be reassuring, indication to the use of hemolyzed serum for potassium
ISO
/
7
4t
if 140 if
120
,fl,_C C
MVL*UO_
if
S 00
I SO
0
20
I I I I” ‘s., 11111
2 3 4 5 0 7 0 9 10
OEUDLYU*TD ADDED IIIEMDGLDHIN. i/LI UPEMIA IINTSAUPIO ADDED. 4/LI SIUBUBOE ADDED 1,/ti
Fig.5. Readoutfrom the Demand AU-500 analyzerafter additionsof hernolysate(left), Intralipid (center), and bilirubin (fight)
GOT (La, unbianked (I.e.,no serum blank) for gamma gkitam’,l tranepeptidase resufts were lagged” with a warning code, indicating absorbance limits were
exceeded. Abbreviationsas In FIgs. 1 and 2
I
0.05