Themes With RRL
Themes With RRL
Figure 3. Safeness of
According to the statement of the participant, SARS-CoV-2 viral RNA test provides safety to her and to
her family. This negative result provides security and protection that she can go home to her family and
“This negative result provides me safety and security that I am not a carrier of the virus,
and at the same time, it also provides safety for my family and also a passes that I can still go
home and be with my family despite being an ER nurse who attends to different kind of patients”
ER1
“This picture will provide opportunities by voicing that every front liner should be tested for
which we can provide holistic and better care for our patients. And at the same time, it will give
us frontliners inner peace that we don’t have in our system the COVID-19 RNA.” ER1.
ER1 also mention that every frontline should be tested to give inner peace that they are not a carrier of
the virus. Because we all know that even if they are wearing complete Personal Protective equipment
handling and dealing with different patient they did not know who is positive or not. They did not know
if they obtain a virus or not. In addition, it also become a challenge to our nurse’s in the midst of
pandemic that they are scared and worried about their families and children that they might get
In the paper of [ CITATION Emm20 \l 13321 ] Hospitals, like most workplaces, have a say in what their
employees do on the job, but less of one when it comes to what they do once they leave. But in the case
of Covid-19, what health care workers do during their shifts impacts the people they interact with when
they're done.
The American Hospital Association’s director of quality policy. According to [ CITATION Dan20 \l 13321 ],
division chief of pediatric infectious disease at Seattle Children’s Hospital, management has also been
reinforcing that health care workers should be monitoring their health closely and getting tested for
coronavirus. Still, the smallness of these measures in contrast with the enormity of the problem has left
some workers anxious, especially since Covid-19 tests and personal protective equipment aren’t always
available.
Employers are not entirely at fault for the stress that health care workers are undergoing, and the risks
they are bringing home to their families. “The most important thing we can do to keep providers and
their families safe is doing everything we can to give workers the supplies and PPE they need to protect
themselves,” says Demehin. “Wider availability of rapid testing and increased PPE are both necessary for
keeping our health care workers and their families safe.” Hospitals can’t materialize those supplies on
their own—they need cooperation from manufacturers and, most importantly, from state and federal
governments. That has been hard to come by. As hospitals struggle to get their staffs what they need,
the lack of Covid-19 testing and protective equipment doesn’t just put health care providers at risk—it
Participants ER8 described figure 4 as “This is home. A place where me and my family live with peace,
joy and love. A place where you feel that you are well-secured and safe. .” ER8.
Figure 4. Safeness of the Family (HOME) ER8
home. I took this photo because this is the only place that I want to stay at. This place has to be
the safest place but because of me, coming here after my duty made me realize that this place
“By this photo, future readers might realize that becoming a nurse during this time isn’t
easy. Even though COVID19 get over soon, future readers would realize how a nurse like me
struggled during the pandemic especially knowing that I am also risking the safety of my
family”.ER8
HOME
Based on the statement of the participants “there’s no place like home” He’s also stated that home is
the place where his family feels safe and secured. But, when this pandemic started he realized that
going home will be dangerous to his whole family because maybe he is a carrier of the virus.
This is another challenges to our nurses. There are lot of changes in the family, community and
workplace due to pandemic, because of their responsibilities as a nurse doing their job became risky to
the nurses itself and to their family. There are circumstances that nurses choose not to go home for the
According to the report by [ CITATION Ben20 \l 13321 ] This new homework is as stressful as it is
tedious. A misstep could mean spreading a coronavirus infection to a loved one. “Even with 30 to 45
minutes of prep, coming back home and doing all this, I still am worried I screwed it up in some way,”
said Sun, who shares an apartment with his mother, who has Parkinson’s disease.
Across the country, exhausted health-care workers have changed the rhythms of their daily lives —
sleeping away from their families and performing meticulous cleansing rituals — to protect family
members and roommates and keep the pathogen contained behind hospital doors.
Some avoid going home altogether because they live with elderly or immunity-compromised relatives.
About 200 doctors, nurses and other medical personnel are staying at the Four Seasons Hotel New York,
for instance, which has pared down its thousand-dollar-a-night rooms to function as a medical dorm,
said a spokesman. Hotel staffers check the temperature of each clinician entering the hotel. Instead of
dining on room service, guests take boxed meals to their rooms. Bathrobes, extra pillows and throw
blankets were removed to reduce the number of items that could be touched.
Theme Two: LOW MORALE
fingers)
ER4 Describes the Figure1 as Nurses in the photo raising six (6) fingers to show the number of
days they are working. She added “Despite the years of experience I’ve earned or the degree I
have, we are still striving having a same difficulty with novice nurses. This picture proves that
we are the hired to face the current pandemic we are all in today in the short term”
ER4 also said “it allows me to talk of how I truly feel about being a frontline in this pandemic
knowing that we are hired for a short term and work for long hours” ER4
Six Fingers
Based on the statement of the participants “they are just hired temporarily” Participants also
described long hour of works. As one of the challenges of the nurses on the midst of pandemic
they are bearing the burnt as they put in long hours and consecutive shifts to help patients. taken
for granted and work overload has shown to have effect on the nurses in terms of giving quality
care to the patients and less eager to give her best because she knows she is only being hired in
On the article by [ CITATION Bro20 \l 13321 ] The U.S. Occupational Safety & Health
Administration (OSHA) describes a normal work shift as “a work period of no more than 8
consecutive hours during the day, 5 days a week with at least an 8-hour rest.” Nurses whose
work environment demands 12-hour shifts are working what OSHA describes as an extended or
unusual shift that “incorporates more continuous hours, requires more consecutive days of work,
or requires work during the evening.” These shifts may be more mentally, physically, and
emotionally taxing to employees, leading to increased fatigue, stress, and lack of concentration,
which in turn may result in a heightened risk of error, injuries, and accidents. To put this into
perspective, Petrov and colleagues equated the traditional night-shift schedule of two or three
sequential 12-hour shifts from 7 pm to 7 am followed by 2 to 5 days off to the jet lag experienced
when flying roundtrip from San Francisco to Tokyo every few days.
What does this mean for nurses required to work 12-hour shifts? A study conducted by Rogers
and colleagues concluded that work duration, overtime, and the number of hours worked per
week significantly impact errors made by nursing staff. The authors made a bold statement:
“Routine use of 12-hour shifts should be curtailed and overtime, especially that associated with
12-hour shifts, should be eliminated.” A systematic review by Di Muzio and colleagues
concluded that adverse event frequency increases when nurses work on an inadequately staffed
unit and then work more than 12 hours in a shift and more than 40 hours in a week. They also
found that nurses who work night or rotating shifts, compared to their peers who work day or
evening shifts, struggle to stay awake and are twice as likely to make a mistake. Despite this
evidence, most nurses who provide direct patient care continue to work 12-hour shifts and
experience fatigue.
(Personal Protective
Equipment’s)
“they feel not appreciated because of the low quality of personal protective equipment being
equipment and other protective equipment so each and every frontline can serve and perform
According to the statement of the participants because of the low quality of personal protective
equipment there are hesitation of rendering the good quality of care to the patient because they
are also afraid to contracting the virus while taking care for the patients. Personal Protective
Equipment’s is very essential for protecting our Healthcare workers in battling on COVID-19 but
with the low quality of personal protective equipment they are worried on acquiring the virus.
On the news reported by [ CITATION Iff20 \l 13321 ] Four of their fraternity testing positive at the
Victoria Hospital, the nurses have complained to the hospital authorities about the poor quality
of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) kits and even went up to Medical Education Minister Dr
K Sudhakar in this regard. So far there have been 13 positive cases of frontline workers at
Victoria which include doctors, nurses, group D staff and lab technicians.
Among the 13 positives, four were nurses. Speaking to TNIE, a nurse said, “We are the frontline
workers and need to be provided with good PPE kits. The ones provided were damaged. We
believe that this could be the reason for the positive cases. Ideally, the inorganic or organic fluids
should not enter the PPE. But this was not the case with the kits we were provided. That is why
we decided to raise our voice and even spoke to minister Sudhakar about it.”
Low morale
Low morale has become a challenges to the nurses in this current situation and also has
negative impact to them. A nurse dissatisfaction of the current situation by being neglected by
the government in terms of the support delivery and it is no secret that nurses work long and
strenuous hours. Because of this factors nurses can possibly increase risk of errors and not
rendering better care to the patients. Due to the nature of work and low quality of personal
protective equipment the safety of the nurses become secondary in this midst of pandemic.
According to (Roberts et al., 2007) This caused panic and fear among HSCFWs as they could not
envisage the extent COVID-19 pandemic was going to cause. It also brought a feeling of
uncertainty among them leading to low morale and coordination in the workplace (Aronson &
Smith, 2011). In light of the above assertions, it is important that health and social care
workplaces have viable pandemic control and management policies to protect both workers and
According to [ CITATION Hug20 \l 13321 ], The ethical dilemma facing them was that not going on
strike would compromise patient safety due to workforce shortages and low morale. There were
reports in the media of nurses crying, not because of the care that they were giving, but because
It is clear that in order to be successful, healthcare facilities must continue to focus on keeping
morale high. Human resource departments should work directly with nurse leads and even risk
management consultants to identify issues as they arise and remedy potentially negative
situations by implementing the correct processes for positive change. In the end, taking the time
to develop and enact morale-boosting strategies will create a more productive, healthier and safer
environment – for both nurses and their patients.[ CITATION Bet17 \l 13321 ]
Figure 9. Sunrise
ER3 took a photo of sunrise (figure 9) after saying, that “as a frontliner having a rough duty
does not mean that you should give up.” That the sunrise always reminds us to “take a break,
breathe and then fight again.” She also added that the photo should encourage everyone. That
there is always another day to face another battle. That during this pandemic, countless of us
want to give up.” But ER3 always remembers that “here is another beautiful day ahead to fight
again.
Sunrise
As a more frontline battling every single day in this time of the pandemic, ER3 remains
encouraging towards the situation we are in today. She took the photo of sunrise after having her
12-hour duty emphasizing that it is a sign of another day to live. That “every single day is a
blessing to every one of us.” The sunrise made her thought that it is a symbol of hope for the
pandemic to end. As we face this challenge with COVID-19, countless indeed want to give up.
But ER3 found optimism in this sunrise that every one of us should try to be.
Based on the literature, optimism was found to be helpful both in daily medical work and in
cases of medical emergencies. Optimism was also revealed one of the key components of
through initiative programs. Obtaining optimism can be included in toolkit preparedness for
health care workers in order to confront the complications in the aftermath of disaster. These
programs, together with appropriate information, social support, professional trust, and leaders
modeling behavior, will raise the well-being and enhance coping skills of the health care workers
Photo in figure10 was submitted by ER5 telling us that after transferring all admissions around
the hospital like the operating room, labor room and ICU, “my body couldn’t help but get
drained.”
She stated that people expect them to do everything. “In this of pandemic, you are not allowed
to complain nor take a break because it is your job.” However, ER5 stresses that her profession
of being a nurse in this pandemic “makes our physical body tired but it doesn’t mean giving up.”
She just “needed a break” so that she can “be more efficient and give more quality care to my
patients.”
Break
Based on the statement of ER5, she lays emphasis on the word “break” as it is the one she
needed the most. “It’s ok to take a rest.” That “It’s not always other people you should
prioritize.”
As for her, her profession is a challenge to her physical body. She gets worn-out by the number
of patients they receive each duty. Despite all that, a little break would mean excessive power for
her.
“Although the healthcare providers carried on with their duty, they undergo lot of physical and
“They took this pandemic as a challenge. They wanted to give out their best possible care to the
patients.”
In certain days, frontline workers were burnt out, when the cases went high. They had to deal
with many patients at a single stretch. The healthcare providers felt guilty when they remained
helpless. They expressed grief and strong sense of powerlessness about patients suffering and
“Wearing PPE’s on our duties, handling COVID patients.., It does not guarantee that we will not
be infected with the virus.” She also added that having a positive result “does not mean that I
The photo “will serve as a voice” to people as well as the government that they are at risk of
acquiring COVID-19.
Positive
Doing the standard precaution such as wearing face masks, face shields, and even personal
protective equipment did not exclude ER1 from getting the virus COVID-19. She intensifies that
the photo of her swab result would awaken the government and her hospital administration to
However, being tested positive for the virus was already a challenge for ER1. Although she said
that she will not lose heart of her duties as a nurse, she was still hopeful with the desire that they
The organizations in which the staffs are employed play a keen role. Necessary and supportive things
have to be provided for healthcare professionals working in Covid ward. It is seen that to a large extent,
all staff face distress but do not seek professional support. Therefore, constant monitoring of their mental
health has to be taken, rapid access to counselling should also be provided. Reinforcement should be
given as it can increase willingness to work. Safe travelling to and from work also should be provided
which can reduce anxiety. Measures such as rest facilities, providing food, drinks, regular
acknowledgements, a dialogue of suggestions and ideas from state, formal and informal psychological
support during the pandemic can improve the healthcare workers willingness to work.
Following the death of one of their own, health workers stood united in a rally outside the JRRMMC
on Monday. They wanted to amplify calls to bring justice to Suerte and all those who died because of
the “negligence and failure” of the DOH and the Duterte government in handling the coronavirus
outbreak.
“Hindi kami prayoridad ng gobyerno. Kaya nakakalungkot, kasi kada pasok namin sa trabaho, isang
paa namin nasa hukay na. Pagod na pagod na kami,” Donguines said.
(We are not the government’s priority. It is very sad, because every time we go to work, it’s like one
ER6 describes his photo as “a person who is tired after rendering an eight-hour service for our
country.” He chose this one for us “to realize that even though we are being considered heroes
they need a rest for “we can able to fight for our fellow countrymen.”
Worn Out
They are being considered “heroes” today because of the pandemic. However, as ER6 said “we
are only human and need to protect ourselves too.” He considers this as an opportunity to voice
out the demand for a break in this pandemic because every break is considered a preparation.This
pandemic is an immense challenge to all of us, not only frontliners. Hence, this challenge taught
ER6 “the reality of life.” And reflects on strengthening the “promise I need to live up to.
A number of front-liners demur, saying: “We are just doing our jobs, we are not heroes.”
But to COVID-19 survivors they are heroes, God-sent angels in protective suits.
Situational Optimism
Optimism is a general tendency to regard the world as a positive place accepting challenges.
Optimism improves the level of functioning, patient’s satisfaction and thus the results. Due to the
increased risk of exposure to virus, our frontline healthcare workers fear feeling of uncertainty
and threat to life, symptoms of anxiety and psychological distress. Optimism heavily influences
physical and mental health, as well as coping with everyday social and working life. Worker’s
feel less pressure, focus on practical problem solutions, and seek social support.
Researchers have proven that optimism has the power to improve morbidity outcomes and
enhanced performance during crisis. According to Seligman (2008), “optimism is the way we
explain events and outcome to ourselves and it is a learnable approach to life and an invaluable
motivator”
Gaining the skill of optimism can assist in confronting stress or set back, can help to overcome
failure in particular event and strengthen self-efficacy and resilience. This will increase the
Health Care Worker’s overall sense of wellbeing, helping them to be more beneficial to their
society. One research focusing on optimism was conducted by Prateepko et al. It showed that
staffs who were considered to be optimistic felt the threat to be of less severity and less
Positive emotions such as optimism, life satisfaction and tranquility, are active elements of
resilience, and they were found in the aftermath of crises, such as the 9/11 trauma, as a buffer
improving the resilience of people against depression (19). These findings were supported by a
study, which demonstrated that positive feelings, such as optimism, resilience, spiritual and
social support might predict the behavioral responses to an avian flu outbreak. It also found that
to a problem (20).
said that “Even there’s no patient, we need to be careful and we should wear personal protective
equipment, knowing that we are going to attend any patient that may be a Covid-19 positive.”
She also added that the photo reminded her to keep calm and just do her responsibilities because
she’s a nurse, and the patients need her help even she is not comfortable wearing PPE’s for the
On the other hand, she alleged said that “It is a stepping stone in my life that a frontline like me
may look brave in front of other people who look protected and safe but deep inside this frontline
ER Soldier
Based on the testimony of the participant, even they are facing a lot of challenges, regardless of
wearing uncomfortable sets of PPE’s and still, she is doing her best to do her calling and
responsibilities. Moreover, she continuously assured that, she is attentive and focused on her
duty to render the optimum quality care she can provide to the patient as well as to herself, so she
wear personal protective equipment (PPE), including goggles, N95 mask and protective suits
when they were caring patients. However, working with and in these equipment for a long time
is exhausting, for example, when wearing a N95 mask nurses needed to speaking loudly to make
sure patients could hear. Some of the nurses’ skins and facial features were temporarily
disfigured because of wearing N95 masks for a long time. They wore diapers and tried their best
to have less food and water while working in order to save PPE supplies. Many nurses cut their
long hair and even shaved their heads to reduce the risk of contamination between patients and
“Being on the frontline is indeed heroic, but then, it's part of our profession to do what's beyond
our credibility as a nurse, and it’s a rare moment to take look back when pandemics arise and we
stand up like a brave warrior to fight for the virus that affects our health and country.”
He also adds that he took the photo to have an evocation that once he’s been part of the
pandemic crisis in our country and it is indeed a great privilege for him to do what is beyond on
his oath.
In addition to that, he describes that the photo will show braveness in spite of the pandemic crisis
and that it will encourage his colleagues to stand and fight for this crisis.
Genuine Heroes
Based on the said statement, it is full of encouragement for his Co health workers to fight against
the crisis we are facing. He also considered his duty as an enormous profession and
responsibility to fulfil. The modern heroes are still showing humbleness despite of challenges
and saving so many lives. He’s brave enough still look for the affirmative side of the situation we
are facing.
The significant spread of Covid-19 around the globe has affected people of all nations, races, and
socio-economic groups. Moreover, the severity of the disease’s symptoms have dramatically
increased and challenged the duties of healthcare providers for protecting the health of their co-
citizens.
Most nurses do not believe they have the right to refuse to treat certain patients during the
COVID-19 outbreak. In correlation with their strong commitment to care for patients during this
time, the participants did not agree with ideas such as not embarking on the nursing profession
after graduation (i.e. nursing interns), changing to a different position within the nursing
profession, or increased burnout, as a result of the stress associated with their providing
healthcare during the pandemic. While provision of care at this time is highly stressful and is
accompanied with personal risk, they do not regret choosing nursing as their profession. They
seem highly motivated and are mostly influenced by their obligation to treat patients, and,
interestingly, also by their obligation to provide the Israeli society with help. These findings are
in line with previous research on the willingness of Israeli nurses’ to work in times of
emergencies.
While experiencing significant personal risk and emotional burden, nurses conveyed strong
dedication to providing care, and did not regret working in the nursing profession, yet they did
ER nurse, emergency cart should be complete so that when we have an emergency patient the
medication and other equipment is ready so, when we attend to that kind of patient we don’t need
The participant also added “This picture is telling us nurses that like an e cart we should be
prepared to cater different kinds of patients whether its positive negative or regular patients like
this medications we should be strong and careful so that the patients and ourselves are not at risk
ER 7 also said that just like this picture we should be ready and complete in terms of medication
Cart of gold
Based on the data above, being one of the front-liner is precisely challenging what more when
you’re working in the emergency department. They should be ready and equipped when
attending any case whether covid19 positive patient. Also, armed nurse is necessary so that they
internationally. As we reflect on what 2020 has been, most of us think about the global pandemic
additional disasters both before COVID-19 and also while dealing with COVID-19.
Whatever emergency arises, you will find emergency nurses there taking on the challenge. This
year, emergency departments have responded to disasters that have ranged from wildfires,
earthquakes, and volcanoes to tornadoes and floods, to name just a few. We have always known
that the world can change in a second in the emergency department and that we must be prepared
for the unexpected. However, 2020 has certainly made this more apparent.
When we talk about disasters, we talk about the lifecycle of a disaster, which includes 4
categories: mitigation, preparedness, response, and recovery. The mitigation phase of a disaster
is the phase in which we attempt to minimize the exposure/impact of the event. Preparedness is
when we plan for the event from a training perspective and gather the list of supplies that we will
need during the event. Response is the phase when the disaster has hit, and our normal operations
have stopped. Recovery is the last of the 4 phases and is when we resume our “normal”
operations. The cycle however is a circle, and so it continues, and we go right back to the first
As I reflect on 2020 and what we have faced from a disaster perspective, I believe we all have
gone through or are in the process of going through all 4 phases. Hospitals that receive
government funding from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services must have certain
communication plan, policies and procedures, and training and testing.1 , 2 These requirements
are necessary for addressing the mitigation and preparedness phase. Whatever the volume of
COVID-19 cases has been in our area, we all have had training on our new protocol(s) with
isolation, what equipment we are using for personal protection equipment, and how/where we
This year was designated to be the Year of the Nurse and Midwife by the World Health
Organization and is also the 50th Anniversary of the Emergency Nurses Association. This year,
we knew, was to be a big year for our celebrating; what we could not have envisioned was how
the role of the nurse would be displayed this year to the public, and how the public would get a
glimpse into what we face. As emergency nurses, we are always ready to answer the call from
the communities in which we serve. I challenge us all to ensure that we are not forgetting about
the mental health and well-being of our colleagues and ourselves as we face these unprecedented
times. We must also not forget that the cycle of disaster continues, so we must continue to strive
to be prepared and to face the next challenge that will present itself to us. I am confident that as
She also specified “That day we promised to do our profession in any situation, time, and day.
And This photo reminds me of what oath I made that day, that in any situation, we, front liners,
have duties and responsibilities to render care to those patients in need even if there is a
pandemic.”
In addition to that, she said the image should motivate the future nurses to stand by their oath and
do their duties and responsibilities because being a nurse knows that there are no boundaries in
Nurse Vow
Based on the said testimonial, as a registered nurse they should take any risk even it is very
challenging because they took the oath of the profession. They should do their calling as well as
their duty to take care and to deliver quality care to the patient even it is not pandemic.
Nurses and midwives play a key role in caring for people everywhere, including in times of
outbreaks and settings that are fragile or in conflict. During the COVID-19 outbreak, nurses,
midwives and all health workers have been in the frontlines of the response. They also continue
“I cannot fathom the emotions that I feel especially in handling COVID-19 patients. They are in
psychological distress because they are not allowed to have watchers or significant others to visit
them to prevent infection. So, you are not just dealing with an unseen enemy, but you need to be
a patient advocate and supporter. It is my duty as a nurse to respond to our calling. Our oath is to
care for the sick and devote ourselves to the welfare of those committed to our care. Despite
what is happening to our world nowadays God is in control all this pandemic shall disappear
sooner or later.”
PROFESSIONAL COMMITMENT
Commitment to a profession requires doing the best for that profession. In the case of the nursing
profession, professional commitment gains greater importance in times of crisis, like the
COVID‐19 pandemic.
All healthcare professionals, especially nurses, have been seriously affected by the
workloads, longer working hours, a more stressful working environment, and insufficient
medical and protective materials (de Pablo et al., 2020; Jun et al., 2020). Healthcare
professions working in hospitals where individuals infected with Covid-19 are admitted
and providing care to those individuals increase their risk of infection (Moazzami et al.,
2020)
commitment to life-long learning. The future of nursing will be determined by nurses who are
committed to the profession. Nurses must demonstrate strong professional commitment in order
to defend patients’ rights and to perform their job in the best way (Gauthier, 2011). The
qualitative study by Kalateh et al. (2020) on the experience of nurses during the Covid-19
pandemic included the comments of nurses who fulfilled their duty despite the heavy working
conditions and many risks. One of the nurses commented, “Look, if I don't want to come, who
will come? Who will care for people? These are our citizens. We have a professional
commitment and responsibility”; showing that professional commitment is one of the main
factors affecting nurses’ jobs during the pandemic (Kalateh et al., 2021).