Challenges and Opportunities of Expansion of Islamic Banks in Ethiopia: Case of Commercial Bank of Ethiopian Dire Dawa Interest Free Branch
Challenges and Opportunities of Expansion of Islamic Banks in Ethiopia: Case of Commercial Bank of Ethiopian Dire Dawa Interest Free Branch
org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
Abstract
This study assessed the challenges and opportunities of expansion of Islamic banks in Ethiopia in case of
commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch. For sake of obtaining sufficient data, the researcher
mainly used primary data that would be collected through open ended and close ended questioner from
employees of commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch. In addition to questioner, interview
was conducted with branch manager of Dire Dawa interest free branch and higher officials of Islamic banks in
the process of establishment. The secondary data also would be gathered through document review to support the
primary data. To analyze the questioner SPSS soft ware would be used. Based on the analysis and interpretations
the main findings of this study was an Islamic bank have both opportunities and challenges in their expansion.
The main challenges are higher computation from conventional banks that open interest free banking service in
branch and window level, lack of awareness of the society regarding Islamic banks, professional skill gap
regarding Islamic banks operation and lack of awareness of the society regarding Sharia based financing. The
main opportunity of Islamic banking expansions are there is high demand in the market, the banking industry in
Ethiopia is in growth stage and Islamic banks can mobilize more addition deposits from Muslim society which
was out banking industry.
Keywords: Islamic banking, Conventional banks and Interest free banking
DOI: 10.7176/RJFA/11-3-05
Publication date: February 29th 2020
1. Introduction
The economic development of any country depends on the existence of well-organized financial system.
Financial institutions are one important components of financial system of a given country.
(www.envestopedia.com). As Ethiopian financial system is bank dominated, banks are a part of those institutions
which accept deposit from economic agents and then lend this funds to make direct loans or invest in security
like stocks and bonds (Cambel Harvey, 2010). Banks operates by charging interest as well as operates without
charging interests. Interest is fee paid for usage of others money. To the borrowers it is the cost of renting money
to the lender it is income for lending the money. Islamic banks operate without charging interests (Islamic
finance.com). Islamic banks are derived from Islamic world, it is fundamental concept it operate primitive
professional and ethical investing while elimination of interest in all its forms is an important future of the
Islamic financial system (Islamic finance.com).
According to National bank of Ethiopia Interest free banking service mean a system of banking or financial
activity that is compliant with Sharia principles and guided by Islamic economics which prohibits the collection
and or payment of interest as well as engaging in activities forbidden by Sharia. Interest free banking provides
profit-sharing investment accounts to the depositors (www.nbe.gov.et). As National bank of Ethiopia allows for
banks to provide interest free banking services with directive No-72 (2019) in branch level or as fully fledged
operation, Islamic banks like Hijra bank, Zamzam Bank, Zad banks starts their formation to play their own role
for development of saving and investment of the country.
Islamic banks expansion may have both opportunities and challenges and different researchers try to
identify the opportunities and challenges. According to Tsion sisay (2017) Interest free banking operation has
challenges like lack of sheria advisors boards, lack of awareness of customers regarding interest free banking,
Lack of confidence by customers, unavailability of the service in all branches are challenges of interest free
banking operation (Tsion sisay , 2017). Kerima Ali Mohammed’s (2016) also stated that the challenge faced by
banks to provide interest free banking service are unmet demand of users, awareness of customers and capacity
of bank.
Currently both conventional banks and fully fledged Islamic banks started to establish their branches in the
major cities or town of the country. In previous years according to interest free banking proclamation No. 592-
2008 at sub article 22(2) allows interest free banking business by window level to all commercial banks. Based
on this directive almost all private and governmental banks are provides interest free banking service by window
level starting 2008 G.C. Starting from 2019 G.C a new directive on interest free banking No-72 coming to
operation. The new directive allows interest free banking service with full fledged Islamic bank and in branch
34
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
level. Based on this directive conventional banks like Commercial bank of Ethiopia, Awash bank and oromia
international banks started to provide this service in branch level. On the other hand fully fledged Islamic banks
like Zamzam bank, Hijra bank and Zad banks are in the process of formation to provide interest free service in
bank level.
Therefore as interest free banking service is started to be delivered by both conventional banks in branch
level and Islamic banks in bank level, there may be new opportunities and challenges. So that the researcher
interested in investigating the challenges and opportunities of expansion of Islamic banks by taking commercial
bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch as case study.
35
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
To examine the societies motivation regarding saving and investment after establishment of branch
level or full-fledged Islamic banks in Dire Dawa.
To assess effect of expansion of Islamic banks on conventional banks
4. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
For this study, the researcher would apply descriptive analysis used the fact that a descriptive research design
will used to describe the data and characteristics about what will done. Descriptive survey will also enable to
obtain the current information. It will also use in fact findings studies and help to formulate certain principles
and give solutions to the problems concerning local or national issues. The study will use qualitative research
approach. The reason for using qualitative research approach is to answer why peoples are interested on interest
free banking service and this approach will be used in exploring and understanding the meaning individuals or
groups ascribe to a social or human problem. The process in this approach involves emerging questions and
procedures, data typically collected in the participants setting, data analysis inductively building from particular
to general, and the researcher making interpretations of the meaning of data.
The researcher would collect data from employees of commercial bank of Dire Dawa interest free branch.
In addition to the employees of commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch, data would be
collected from higher officials of the new full-fledged Islamic banks. The researcher would use census method to
collect questioner from employees of commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch. The number
of employees of commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest branch is 20. The researcher prefers census
method because the number of target population is less than 30. To get data from interview the researcher
conducted interview with branch manager of Commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch and
higher officials of the three full - fledged Islamic banks under formation i.e. Hijra, Zamzam and Zad are selected
purposely
The researcher used mainly primary data collected from questioner and interview as source of data.
Questionnaires were distributed to employees of commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch
and interviews were conducted with manager of Dire Dawa interest free branch and higher officials of the three
fully fledged Islamic banks. In Addition to primary data, secondary data was collected from available source of
commercial bank of Ethiopia and other selected banks. The researcher used descriptive method of data analysis
to draw conclusions and inferences. This descriptive type data analysis would be preferred due the nature of the
analysis requires to use table, percentages are used to make comparisons and interface.
4. Literature reviews
Interest rate is the price paid or charged for the usage of others money. An interest rate is often expressed as
annual percentages of the principal. Interest rates send price signals to borrowers, lenders, savers, and investors.
Interest rate measures risk lenders demand additional compensation for lending to riskier to earn a primitive that
is higher than the rate of inflation to make any transaction worthwhile (Campbell Harvey, 2012). Economic
development of a given country partially depends on the financial system to help transfer of money to area of the
economy that needs most (Rodney Wilson 1986).
Bank plays vital role in the development of an economy. It is a special type of organization where the
credit and capital are supplied (Reilly brown, 2005). Conventional banks operate by collecting deposit from
individual, business and government to pay interest and gives loan to individuals, business and governments with
higher interest rate. This shows that the main source of income for conventional bank is interest income (spread
between lending interest rate and deposit interest rate). Over the last forty years, there has been a rapid
expansion of financial institution that can be characterized as interest free banking. Interest free banking, the
more general terms, is expected not to avoid transaction based on interest but also to participate activity in
achieving the goals and objectives of financial system (Rodney brown, 2005).
Financial dealing in compliance with Sharia law date back the early century of Islam, but this traditional
money lending and money changing rather than commercial banking as practiced today. Modern commercial
banking introduced in the majority of Muslim country with the spread of European trade during the 19th century
(http//www.finance in islam.com). There are economic and religious reasons, which have contributed to the
emergence of private limited banking as an alternative to its interest charged counterpart. The economic reason
derived from providing inspiration to devise an interest free financial system has been substantiated in the way
that interest concentrates wealth in the hands of few. It is the prohibition of interest which traced to religious
reason. The basic intention behind establishing interest free bank was desire of Muslim to recognize their
financial activity in an away that do not contradict the principle of Islamic law and enable them to conduct their
financial transaction without connection into interest. Thus interest free banking emerged as a response to both
economic and religious factor (Taqi Usmani M. 2005).
The following countries are can be taken as exemplary for their successful Islamic banks or interest free
banking operation.
36
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
Iran
The processes of transformation of interest free banking in Iran have proceeded in the three distinct phase.
Nationalization restructuring and re -organization of entire banking system characterized phase one taking
place between 1979 and 1982. External and internal developments did not allow the policy makers to develop
coherent plan for interest free banking system although various piecemeal attempts were made towards this
objectives. The second phase began in 1986,it was a phase primary characterized by adoption of legislative and
administrative steps in order to implement a clear articulated model of interest free banking The third phase
which continue until now, began in 1996.This phase define the roll of interest free banking system differently
from the earlier phases .The banking sector has been used an instrument to restrict Iranian economy the
restriction was essentially direct the shifting financial resources from services and consumption to the production
sector in four ways. First credit to the service sector second, it creates incentive for the development of
cooperative sector planning agriculture industry and trade. Third the banking system in partnership with the
government under takes to finance large industrial project and investment in social overhead capital. Fourth
using all available model of finance to help farmers to improve and expand production encourages growth of
agriculture sector (http//www.financeinislam, com).
Pakistan
Pakistan adopted a policy of gradual transformation of its banking system from February 1979, after several
years of study and preparation by the government appointed council of ideology. The process started when the
president of Pakistan announced that interest was to be removed from the economy with in period of 3 years.
Three of specialized credit institutions are the house building corporations, national investment trust and mutual
trust funds of Investment Corporation of Pakistan where to remove interest from their financing operation
immediately. In June 1984 the government announced discontinuation of dual window of operation on the
banking and financial system, except the foreign currency deposit which continue to earn fixed interest, where
brought under non interest based modes of financing. Interest free banking in Pakistan appears to be cross road
and if there to be further progress the regulatory and legal condition must be such that system will have a fair
chance to perform as expected (http//www.finance in Islam .com).
South Africa
The Muslim population in South Africa is relatively small but both affluent and influential. Interest free bank
was introduced in South Africa in 1989 by Alabama Antioch bank operating with a limited branch foot print.
This only interest free offering until 2002 when first national bank in the country launched an interest free
finance product followed by an interest free cheque account most recently interest free banking started offering
its service compliant products through its branch in Botswana in 2006, Absa the largest retail bank including
group in south Africa launched, the first comprehensive interest free bank offering the services like cheque
account vehicle finance ,transactional saving account and interest free wills. This offering was supported by the
full range access support from the ATM and branch network in the country, as well as sale phones and internet
banking (http//www.finance in Islam .com).
Nigeria
Nigeria with population of 140,000,000 people is not only the most populous country in Africa but it is also the
largest economy in west Africa.60 percent of Nigerian Muslims and in response to their demands to have a bank
that meets their religious moral and ethical aspirations the efforts are in progress by a number of corporate
bodies, individuals and Islamic organization to achieve these goal and with their regulatory frame work of
interest free banking by the central bank of Nigeria in feb.2009,all is now set for jazz, the first interest free bank
in Nigeria to commence full commercial operation(http//www.finance in Islam .com).
37
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
treat and started to open interest free banks in branch level to maintain their customers and to get addition
customers. The above theoretical literatures and banking history shows that Ethiopia as country uses both
interest charged and interest free system co-existed like Indonesia, Malaysia, Pakistan and United Arab Emirates
(Zamzam bank s.c, 2019)
38
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
customers, unavailability of the service in all branches are challenges of interest free banking operation. In
addition Robel Demissie (2019) conducted a research on factors affecting implementation of interest free
banking service in Ethiopia: the mediation role of customer involvement. The result of this research showed that
awareness, comparability, complexity, observability, perceived risk; religious beliefs and customers involvement
were significant on the implementation of interest free banking service.
Literature Gap
Even though the above researches are conducted in Ethiopia in different corners of the country, they did not
show the challenges and opportunities of Islamic banks expansion in Ethiopia. In addition the above researches
are conducted at the time interest free banking is allowed by National bank of Ethiopia only at window level. As
currently National bank allows full-fledged Islamic bank, there may be new challenges and opportunities. So that,
this research is designed to fill the above stated gaps by assessing the challenges and opportunities of expansion
of Islamic banks in Ethiopia with special focus on commercial bank of Ethiopia Dire Dawa interest free branch.
39
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
The newly established Islamic bank becomes small in size and unable to compute with other convention
banks.
There will be higher computation between Islamic banks and other commercial banks that have interest
base operation.
lack of awareness of the society regarding Islamic banks operation and the types of products and services
is one challenges of expansion of Islamic banks in Ethiopia(Dire Dawa)
Most of the customers have wrong perception regarding Islamic banks are established only to Muslim
communities.
Lack of enough awareness regarding sharia based financing is one of the challenges of expansion of
Islamic banks in Ethiopia (Dire Dawa).
Professional skill gap regarding Islamic banks operatio is another challenges of expansion of Islamic
banks in Ethiopia(Dire Dawa)
The expansion of Islamic banks have affect on the profitability of conventional banks because customers
may shift to use Islamic.
Based on the research findings of the study possible recommendation were made as follows:
The newly opened Islamic banks and interest free branches should prepare different awareness creation
programs and advertisement packages to create good awareness regarding Islamic banks operation and
their products and services.
To increase the society’s awareness and knowledge regarding Sharia based financing and Islamic banks
usage, there should be strong Sharia board and each Sharia boards should advices the bank
managements to prepare different awareness creation programs and should follow proper
implementation each programs.
Banks themselves, Various higher institutions and training centers should prepare short term and long
term trainings to fill Professional skill gap regarding Islamic banks operation in Ethiopia(Dire Dawa)
The newly established Islamic banks should make maximum effort to mobilize enough capital and to
make their banks big enough to compute with existing conventional banks
To bring unbanked Muslim societies resource to banking industry both conventional banks and fully
fledged Islamic banks should open branches with detail investigations and enough feasibility studies.
As Islamic banking industry can contribute its own role to increase saving mobilization, loan provision
and increasing of investment in the country, National banks of Ethiopia should gives enough focus
regarding the supervision of this sector.
7. REFERENCE
1. Abdulmajid et.al (2015), efficiency in Islamic banking and conventional banking: an international
comparison, university of Kebangsaan Malaysia
2. Abraha S.L & Imam S.H. (2005), Dashen Bank as an Information Infrastructure, First Deliverable:
INF5210.
3. Akmel Hailu (2015). challenges and prospects of Islamic banking for resource mobilization in Ethiopian
commercial banks (unpublished project paper)
4. Cambel Harvey, 2010,Hypertextual finance glossary, University of Duke
5. Debebe Alemu (2015). Factors Affecting Customers’ to Use Interest Free Banking in Ethiopia (unpublished
project paper)
6. Hanudin Amin, (2013), Some Viewpoints of Islamic Banking Retail Deposit Products in Malaysia, Lecturer,
University Malaysia Sabah
7. Ismaeil, et al. (2015), Conventional bank and Islamic bank as institutions: similarity and difference,
university of Kebangsaan Malaysia\
8. Kerima Ali (2016). Challenges on Interest Free Banking Services: The Case of Commercial Bank of
Ethiopia (unpublished project paper)
9. Mohammed, M (2012), “Islamic banking: Prospects, opportunities and challenges in Ethiopia‟, An MBA
Thesis submitted to Addis Ababa University, Department of Accounting and Finance.
10. Mufti Mohammed Talisman (1998), introduction to Islamic finance.
11. National Bank of Ethiopia, (Various years’ Annual reports),www.nbe.gov, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
12. National Bank of Ethiopia (2016). Annual Report NBE 2015/16.
13. Nobel Demissie (2019), factors affecting the implementation of interest free banking service in Ethiopia: the
mediation role of customer involvement. Thesis submitted to Addis Ababa university college of business
and economics department of MBA
14. Reilly Brown (2005), interest free microfinance
15. Roddney Wilson, (2010), Islamic banking and finance in European union , university of Durham and
INCEIF
40
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
16. Rondney Wilson, (1986), challenges and opportunities of Islamic banking and finance, university of
Durham and INCEIF
17. Taqi Usmani, M. 2005 Introduction to Islamic Finance Pakistan: Maktaba Ma’Ariful Qur’an.
18. Tsion sisay (2017), Challenges and opportunities of interest free banking in Ethiopia .A Thesis submitted to
the Department of Accounting and Finance for the fulfillment of the requirements of the Degree of Master
of Science in Accounting and Finance
19. Yewubedar Getachew (2018), Assessment of prospects and challenges of interest free banking in Ethiopia
in the case of commercial bank of Ethiopia, north addis district
20. Zamzam bank s.c, 2019, Zamzam Bank foundation and challenges passed, feasibility study prepare with
higher officially of ZamZam bank.
Electronic references
1. http//: www.finance in islam.com
2. http//www.orointbank.net
3. http//: www.envestopedia.com
8. Appendix
Questioner for employees of Commercial bank of Ethiopia Dira Dawa interest free branch
Part one: Background Information
Dear respondents, please label a characteristic that correspondent to your background data by using “˩” mark.
1.1 Educational Level:
Diploma and below First degree Masters Degree and above
1.2 Current Job Position in the bank:
Customer officer assistant Branch manager Accountant and Auditor
1.3 Banking Experience in number of years:
Up to 5 years 6-10years More than 10 years
1.4 Exposure to Interest frees banking:
Before 1 year 1-5 year More than 10 years year
Part Two: Opportunities, challenges and awareness
This part is divided in to three sections; in each section three statements which address issue about the bank’s
opportunity of Islamic banks, challenges of Islamic banks and Awareness of the society regarding Islamic banks.
Therefore, please read each of the statements in each section and rate your level of agreement or disagreement
with each statement by using a tick mark “˩” one of the five alternatives.
1. Opportunities of Islamic bank expansion
Strongly Dis- Neutral Agree Strongly
dis-agree agree agree
1. There is higher opportunity for expansion of Islamic
banks in Ethiopia (Dire Dawa)
2. There is higher Demand for interest free banking
service in Ethiopia(Dire Dawa)
3. Interest free banking service provided by full
banking operation is more preferable than interest
free service provided in branch or window level
4. Islamic banking industry is the matured business in
Ethiopia (Dire Dawa)
5. The establishment of full-fledged Islamic banks
motivates the society for saving and investment?
2. Challenges of Islamic bank expansion
1. Newly established Islamic banks unable to mobilize the required minimum capital by selling
share to the market
2. Newly established Islamic banks becomes small banks and unable to compute with other
commercial banks that provide interest free service in branch level and window level
3. Lack of awareness of the community regarding Islamic bank may have negative effect on
expansion of Islamic banks
4. There will be higher computation between the new Islamic banks and other commercial banks
that provide interest free service in branch and window level
5. The establishment of full-fledged Islamic banks affect the conventional banks profitability
6. Professional skill gap regarding Islamic bank operation may effects their expansion
41
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online)
Vol.11, No.3, 2020
3. Customer awareness level about Islamic banks and Interest free banking products and services
1. Customers have awareness about the major types of interest free banking products.
2. The customers Knows that Interest free banking products are offered to Muslim and non
Muslim users.
3. Customers know clearly regarding sheria’s based financing
Part three: Open ended question
1. Please list down the type of products that are frequently requested by customers but not provided by your
branches?
______________________________________________________________________________________
2. What are the challenges that interest free banking product users face?
__________________________________________________________________________
3. Do you think your bank (branch) has challenges to provide interest free banking services?
Yes No
4. If you answer for question no 3 is yes, please list some of the challenges
_______________________________________________________________________________________
5. Do you think your bank (branch) has good opportunities to become profitable by providing interest free
banking services?
Yes No
6. If you answer for question no 5 is yes, please list some of the challenges
______________________________________________________________________________________
7. If you have any opinion or comment regarding the opportunity and challenges of Islamic banking expansion
in branch level and as fully fledged Islamic banks in Ethiopia (Dire Dawa)?
_____________________________________________________________________
Thank your co-operation
42