A Synthesis, ESP
A Synthesis, ESP
Table of Contents
8. “To ELF or not to ELF?” (English as a Lingua Franca): That’s the --------------15-16
question for Applied Linguistics in a globalized world.
0
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
ENGLISH AS A LINGUA FRANCA: THEORY AND PRACTICAL
IMPLICATIONS
English as a language of the many, serves a lot of functions, not only for
communication but for all the daily activities that we are engaged in. From the
moment we log-in to our computers and cellphones, using those applications like
social media over the web or internet, down to buying some important stuffs, or
even going to somewhere else that we do not know, it is indeed evident and
functions, described English as a lingua franca of the humanity, play a vital role
for survival, especially me, an alien persona, living, working and striving in a
key to effective and efficient tool for communication among countries, and an
essential enigma to end war (which I believed that the root of wars is due to lack
(L2), which has been mentioned in this study that, Thailand according to
learns English as a second language and come from countries that have not
1
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
given English any primary status but use English to a great extent for
international communication.
Based on the result of this study, many students have a background idea
or information that English is the lingua franca of the world. And if I am going to
Language Speakers (L2), only 3 out of 10 students whom I have had handled
before knew that it is the English language viewed as the tongue of the many.
This is because of the three main reasons which I think very evident and
accustomed to their cultures and traditions, which English holds no place for
that, and third is their idea for nationalism. The third reason sounds controversial
to me, at first, I thought it was just of being patriotic but in the wider picture
among Thai students, not all, their idea of learning English is just for
is a dead language, so why they should study it if they have their own unique
style of communication.
important as it is, but for some, it is just a small piece of the whole that makes
2
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
Accent plays a vital role and a key towards better understanding and to
make utterances more comprehensible and intelligible. Every speaker around the
stress and intonation, also plays apart. Deviations from a familiar accent in any
of these features can cause difficulties for the listener, although evidence
grammatical complexity, familiarity with the topic and with a particular speaker.
listeners with negative attitudes towards an accent tend to rate the speaker as
3
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
must be aware that students or learners are diverse, means came from different
attained over one night. It took patience and perseverance. Acquiring new
takes place. My students can hardly learn English especially when it comes to
basic macro skills-listening, reading, writing and most especially in speaking with
correct pronunciation with accent. I still remember when I first stepped-in the
because for them, they cannot really understand what I teach. I tried to reflect
on myself especially in the way I deliver my lesson and it seemed that everything
is all right. And I only realized after a week, that it was my accent then that
mutually incorporated in their Thai accent, but I always try to make them use
flexible enough to look for some alternatives to bridge the gap between native
and nonnative accents. Let us bear in mind that in every county or nation, they
have their own sets of rules and accent identity that makes them different from
4
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
one another. Respect with diligence is a key to harmonize “accent wars” among
learners of English.
A Synthesis
commerce, trade and travel, and has been a key factor in the speed of
globalization in the 20th Century. For this reason, its learning has become
mandatory in many countries and Thailand has not been the exception. This is
reflected by the fact that in the late 2000’s, the Thai government Ministry of
language teaching and learning in the basic education learning programs. This
Thailand.
Having said that, many teachers coming from different regions come to
Thailand to work and live as a Teacher. There we have from British, Americans,
teachers who find their way and luck of finding schools to teach English. But
5
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
there is a huge question mark from the government and especially from some
schools, about the hiring and choosing of the right candidate for the English
Teaching positions, and I am glad to adhere those few here. First, I believed that
there is a racial discrimination in hiring a right candidate. You have a low chance
the teacher of their child, because they thought that all white colored-skin
teachers are good enough to teach their kids. Second, in relation to previous
point, let us talk about qualifications. Even you hold outstanding qualification and
you came from Asia, I refer to the teacher candidates from Philippines, still some
hiring committees will choose and prefer candidates from the western regions.
Why? Again, because of your skin color. They will still prefer western candidates
even if they are high school graduates and don’t have any teaching experiences.
And third, salary. Filipino teachers are still less compensated as compare to other
graduated but still received lesser than a white high school graduate.
Those key points I had laid out above are very likely similar to what the
author of this study pointed out. One of the reasons why Thailand is still ranked
mismanagement of the hiring process. What boils down here is that, right
teachers play a vital role in teaching English. Right teacher does not mean you
came from English Countries but teachers who are qualified and dedicated to
6
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
teach English not only as a subject but an important factor for student’s personal
A Synthesis:
longer for communication mainly, but rather, there is a hidden agenda behind
the struggling to learn and attain a new language. Research indicates that the
group. Cultural identity is mainly influenced by language therefore, the new class
that is formed by the proficient second English language speakers in the third
world countries like Africa and Asia is mainly influenced by the English language.
7
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
outshined due to various reasons, like Thailand and the neighboring countries?
longer for communication alone, but more on economic and tourism purposes.
But what made it difficult among Thai students to learn this specific language?
Let us clarify some points to consider in order to decipher this issue or point.
the conservative cultures among cultures. People speak their native tongue as a
prerequisite to the community. Some Thai family are not open to learning new
indeed evident that government heavily rely extra efforts in urban communities
than the rural ones. Which should be balanced and compulsory to all levels. And
last, cultural mindset. I would say that some of my students are close minded
when it comes to learning English. They prefer to use their mother tongue than
Thai Culture that dictates the peak of its English Development. A very
With regards to the presented study, it was mentioned that English plays
the second language. This is a very challenging efforts to the whole Thai
8
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
community to really accept that world and our community is changing. And part
mission among Thai students, and that is to be a global students who can
globe.
A Synthesis:
since past. There is a growing trend of learning and using it with an assumption
condition of teaching English has not been improved as is expected. One of the
learning of the English language should start from the beginning or foundation.
they can write a paragraph. In the context of Thai, learners at the higher level
who are supposed to have reached a certain developmental level are found to be
far below that level. This is due to the fact that learners are promoted to upper
9
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
levels without having the required level of proficiency at their lower level. In
other words, they are promoted to the next level without assessing what they
are supposed to learn. One of the factors behind this is the faulty examination
system. For example, in our examination system students can make fair guesses
of the questions that are to be asked in the exam by looking at the list of the
questions asked previously. They may learn them by heart and reproduce them
in the exam.
So, based on the points I laid down above, English as a lingua franca is
still a story of a fairy tale that takes too long to have a “they live happily ever-
after” ending. Children take this subject for granted and they do not even
franca is for temporary and diminishing. This is true because our world today is
tongue of the many, but learning your own language and other more languages
Thailand alone, many immigrants are starting to settle down for good because of
some personal conditions. Almost a half of the population living and working in
the capital are most likely coming from the neighboring countries, Myanmar,
10
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
for many and a bane for some conservative countries. Boon for economic
purposes and bane due to cultural identity. English as a lingua franca is also
diminishing, this is true by the fact that our community is diverse. Our fast-
should also to be considered and observed because the more languages you
knew the more the chance you understand other cultures, perspectives and
dispositions.
A Synthesis:
Teachers are the key to achieve the goals of English as a lingua franca.
The global demand for English has broad implications for teacher preparation in
lingua franca settings. Given that more than 50% of all English teachers globally
and their degree of language proficiency are key issues. Teachers of English
11
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
What students need most from their language classes affects how we
pronunciation? How often do we stop to consider the needs of students who are
people who do not share the same native language. So, their needs are quite
different to students who go to the UK, for example, and want to integrate
within that culture and so may want to sound as much like a native speaker as
possible. The priority for students using ELF, on the other hand, is to be as
intelligible as possible to the people they are communicating with. This does not
necessarily mean sounding like a native speaker. This is very true in the
the correctness in sounding but due to cultural barriers and structure of their
This study which focuses on the qualifications among EFL teachers, which
coined the need of recalibration and modification when it comes to training and
Let say in my present ground, if you are nonnative English teacher, you have the
low chance of teaching English as a subject, rather you will be given subjects
that not required technical skills in teaching it, like Science, Maths, and PE. But,
12
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
if you are white-toned skin, and you were born from the west, though you have
the color of your skin. Instead, teacher trainings must be given the spotlight.
Trainings for both native and nonnative speakers are very crucial towards the
A Synthesis:
application in Thailand has a very common topic for discussion over the years.
The reason this persists as a topic of discussion is simply that very little
improvement has been noted in overall English ability among Thai students
One time, he found out that his freshman college student was not able to read
and comprehend one single sentence in English. What he did was that, he
13
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
blamed the teachers from the senior high where the student graduated and
asked them what happened to their instructions? Why they weren’t able to make
this student read and learn English. Then this teacher was amazed on the
responses of the senior high teachers. They said that it was not their fault but it
was a mistake from the Junior High school teachers. Teachers from the junior
high responded and they said that it was not actually their fault, but the fault of
the grade 6 teachers. According to them, why theses teachers from elementary
marked the student “passed’ even though he cannot read and comprehend
English. Then the elementary grade 6 teachers reacted, they said it was not their
fault too. It was actually a fault from the kindergarten teachers where the true
actually it was not their fault. The persons who should be blamed of this problem
are their TEACHERS from the college. They said that, their College Instructors or
university professors did not train them well when it comes to proper training
teachers and their instruction. It is true that the main reason why there is a need
Teachers must be given enough exposure and training to the field. The
government shall focus on giving support and enough budget for the
improvement of all the possible trainings and programs for student-teachers that
14
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
will enhance their skills in their chose field. It is the best time to recalibrate
The study presented in this paper mentioned that teachers have a great
and improve them to become efficient and effective. Filipino teachers are the
best teachers around the world. Many countries prefer Filipino teachers to be
their knowledge-feeder for their local kids because aside from being smart and
versatile, Filipino teachers are passionate, desirable and have a strong sense of
that we, Filipino teachers are one of a kind, but still needs to be trained,
A Synthesis:
teachers than the native ones. Nonnative teachers have a different way of
pronunciation.
15
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
don’t mind their grammar or even the way they construct patterns. I just want to
make sure that they were able to express something base on their own and send
effectively the message they wanted to give and receive/perceive the message
from the other speaker. But sometimes, I find it so hard to teach them the
board, and even use all the possible signals, gestures and bodily movements just
for them to understand and get what I am trying to say or teach. And there
comes one day, I found out one big mistake that I never recognized before, the
sure that I will be producing sounds that are perfect and correct so then they will
learn the right way. My first month of teaching, I tried to copy their accents, Thai
accents, and I found it so hard. And that is one of the mistakes that I have done,
standards.
But as a language teacher, it is not the grammar and soundings that really
matter. It is the ability of the students to send and receive the message so thus
16
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
are inseparable to teaching English as a Lingua Franca. But in the broader sense,
A Synthesis:
LANGUAGE TEACHING
17
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
If we want to bridge the gap, we must begin in the core. Teachers are
very important for the learning process, and their key roles are needed to make
these expected outcomes into place. They are undeniably the major player in the
We all know the fact that educational systems vary depends on the goals
of one specific country. It is indeed, the government, who fulfills and enacts laws
thru its prescribed curriculum to all levels and areas. But how far the government
achieve its goals when it comes to educational programs? This is a very question
that all teacher-education program seeks to advice and ask for the answer from
the government.
As a language teacher, I would say that this study is very timely, when it
comes to the educational goals of the government. There is a need for the
trainings and developments among pre-service teachers. History will tell us that
impractical and unstable. Our curriculum, in fact, faced a lot of challenges and
curriculum revisions, which I think a big mistake from the history. From then, our
UBD, Kto12, which took a lot of confusions, not only in the students, but mostly
18
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
exposed to many materials that will enhance their skills and abilities to teach
English as a lingua franca. Teachers must be secured and equipped with proper
And also, teacher educational institutions must provide programs that will
techniques and approaches. These institutions must be focused more on the field
and not more on the concepts. Teacher graduates should be given focused to be
fully equipped, because in return, they could produce quality education for all
students.
A Synthesis:
new subject. There has been extensive research into its effects on recruitment
19
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
(both of staff and students), teaching and learning methods, and its impact
lingua franca of higher education is met with more positive response than
negative.
It is true that English is very important for higher studies as with the help
available today in English language only. So, it is a must for everyone to have
complete knowledge of this. When someone goes for higher studies English is
the most common language used everywhere, if one does not have good English
skills, he/she cannot opt for higher studies. Today, most of the publishing
companies are publishing books in English language only for students who are
studying for higher education. So, it is vital for every student to learn this as
without this it would not be possible to study at a higher level. One can achieve
success in any field because of English as the vocabulary and terminology used
from schooling many competitive exams also reflect importance of English. The
reasons for this are simple. On the one hand, the globalisation of trade relies on
the widespread use of English. It’s the language of business, that we sometimes
part of the educational baggage of those who want to participate in this very
connected world. “Globish” is very often mocked for its linguistic poverty; at the
end of the day, if it were taught at university, thus improving its general level
20
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
maybe this would enable a more subtle and beneficial level of communication
that would increase mutual understanding, not only benefiting global trade!
A Synthesis:
21
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
Today the significance of multilingualism has spilled over its local and private
roles into having a much broader, global importance and it is one of the most
serves as the lingua franca for education, trade and employment, and is an
21st century. English offers enormous opportunities, and language policy rightly
rather than exclusive, open to all socioeconomic groups. But English is not
enough.
education policy which both respects mother tongue heritage and also prepares
young people for a globalized world with English as a lingua franca. This has
implications for teacher education and curriculum design for state education at
and it is clear that more research is needed to discover how to accelerate the
new pedagogical models that avoid the low spoken proficiency outcomes of
22
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
since I am teaching now here in Thailand, people and community might think
lingua franca does not override any languages or dialects but only serves as a
one country, especially here in Thailand to be more progressive and can go with
the flow and changes in these fast-changing communities in the global stage.
23
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
It might not surprise you to know that English is the most widely spoken
language in the world. This means that the ability to speak English comes with
many advantages that may make your life easier. A significant advantage of
international business. Thus, it might be a good idea to take the time to invest in
markets. But this demands in English might affect one job sector, translation job.
Since many of the people right now speak English, it is hard for the translation
One of the most famous shows around the globe and in the Universe, The
Miss Universe Show, where beautiful and phenomenal women around the globe
compete for one title. And one of the segments there is the Preliminary Speech
and the “question and answer” portion. Candidates have to answer the questions
correctly to impress the judges and to win the crown. But the problem there is
that, the questions are written and asked in English. So, what will happen to the
24
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
ladies who cannot speak English and came from non-native English-speaking
countries? Yes, of course, they will ask for an interpreter. And that service that
the interpreter gives to that candidate will help her to win the crown by
translating her answer into the target Language which is English. But what will
happen if all those ladies speak English? Of course, translating as their job will
world may affect translation services or industry. The more the people able to
speak the target language the lesser their income will be.
25
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
a Foreign Language
technology and education reform envisaged by the new Thai Constitution are key
determinants for new developments for English language teaching and learning
of my students. They find it hard and difficult to understand what they listen
from me. Every day is a challenging task to instill in their minds the lessons that
strategies, for God’s sake and for the teaching-learning process, I made my
One of the experiences that I will never forget in teaching here is that the
English word (in Filipino word, since I am almost came from being Visayan, I
pronunciation is wrong. I asked them how do they know, since it is a new word
26
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
to them. And they replied, their farang teacher (refers to native English teachers)
What I realized after this is that, my students believed more on the native
speakers rather than the nonnative ones. It also implies that students prefer
native speakers (as mentioned on the study) when it comes to teaching. But
what made me also realized to them is that, it doesn’t matter how you
that, l told them that there are a lot of accents around the globe. We have
Filipino accent, German accents, British Accents and many more. I added that,
the more the accents they know the more intelligible they are to communicating
other nationals. And also, the end-goal of studying English is not the grammar
per-see, but how you effectively send and receive the message and how good
27
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
teachers the additional skills needed to successfully teach students with diverse
elsewhere if teachers acquired this knowledge from their preservice training. Pre-
service teacher education programs are the first form of professional study that
individuals complete to enter the teaching profession. This training could present
educational needs in the classroom. Teachers are increasingly faced with the
challenge of teaching English as a subject. There are many different views about
and foundations of English language, without knowing how to utilize this target
structure and not on purpose, grammar over communication and content over
28
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
context. I must say that I am blind how to teach effectively the English as a
Same thing happened when I was in the public schools. Teachers were
are expected to use the target language effectively and transpire that skills to
their students. They are focused more on structure and not so much on purpose.
As teachers, we must teach the target language to impress, but it should be use
grammar and technicalities. Students must feel that its okay to commit errors in
grammar as far as they are able to send and receive the message clearly,
29
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
COMMUNICATION
enables them to send and receive the message, by both parties, and vice versa.
communication, by all means. In the classroom, since Thai kids rarely use the
target language at home, there is a bit difficulty in teaching the target learning
outcomes. There must be a varied selection of methods and techniques that will
their culture and identity. Perhaps for them learning English is for compliance,
(just my thoughts) it is vital to understand them. And just like other non-native
30
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
and achieve specific main goal, in: economy, education, government policies,
31
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
This paper mainly focused on the similarities and differences among ELF,
IEL and WE. The author tentatively concluded that, WE and ELF are similar in
sociolinguistic realities, of the range and depth of English language use in Outer
features that serve to identity that variety of English which is used as a language
language teacher here in Thailand, (as one of the countries that belong to the
outside circle according Kachru circle of English). In here, the usage of English is
education focused more on teaching their learners to speak and use the
language for communicating others, since English is the language for tourism,
pronunciations, unlike in the other countries like Philippines, faulty grammar and
improper soundings of words are a mortal sin, instead Thai kids are taught how
32
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
to effectively send and receive the message during the conversation. Kids were
33
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
A Synthesis:
million times. Just like English language, constantly changing and evolving,
Englishes. It empathized that non-native speakers try to imitate the native ones,
or British accents, since these two accents are predominant and ideal accents.
That is why some schools, especially here in Thailand, prefer to hire teachers
coming from those nations, to teach their kids the accent that they thought ideal
and correct.
tend to behave and react about “accents”. Countries from the outer circle
(Kachru’s Circle) tend to copy and imitate accents from those countries,
should teach kids how to communicate well regardless of accents what they
have. Each county has their own accent and it builds and signifies identity.
34
Rey Mark M. Cabrera MAEd-ELT March 19, 2021
the countries and not to brag one’s identity just because of faulty soundings of
words or pronunciation.
35