Chapter 1
Chapter 1
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
For Amigo Bob Cantisano, who inspired so many through his commitment
to organic farming and viticulture. This publication would not be what it
is without his knowledge. We are so thankful we had the o pportunity to
meet you, Amigo.
Keywords
green wine; organic viticulture; biodynamic®; sustainable farming;
natural wine; Napa county; Sonoma county; wine country
Contents
Acknowledgments�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������xi
Foreword by Jean-Charles Boisset����������������������������������������������������������xiii
Introduction����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� xv
I had the great fortune starting from birth to experience first-hand the full
grape-to-wine cycle at my grandparents farm in Burgundy. This intimate
connection and my grandparents’ careful teaching was a methodology of
learning through ancestral demonstration.
When I visited California I saw that people were willing to try new
approaches to farming and winemaking, and really, that’s what brought
me to transplant my roots to Northern California. I was inspired to create
quality-driven wines, with a lot of expression, affected by every part of
the terroir. By finding that rhythm of nature—a principle of Biodynamic®
farming—I was guided to create wines that demonstrate the difference in
the wines produced.
Also, the opportunity to create wines from better soil—and the New
World vineyards do have newer, better soil. People in the region picked
up on these new ideas of having the “whole vineyard” dynamic and
understood that the long term needs to be prioritized because great fruit
makes great wine.
As a vintner and human being I grieve for Mother Nature. I say
“thank you” to the bees. Most of all we need a steady path to respect the
environment. Perhaps Organic should be the rule. As Voltaire said, “we
must cultivate our garden”.
xiv Foreword by Jean-Charles Boisset
Our bodies were created to eat seasonally, consume the foods where
we live, and drink our local wines. That makes our system—our bodies—
stronger, which in turn makes the whole world better.
My motto is taste it, feel it, sense it, and enjoy.
To your health, Sante!
Jean-Charles Boisset
Sonoma, January 2021
Introduction
The inspiration for this book came when we were establishing the
Sonoma Sustainable Tourism Observatory for the International Network
of Sustainable Tourism Observatories (INSTO), an affiliate of the United
Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO).
As we looked at the economic and conservation drivers in the Sonoma
and Napa regions, it became apparent that the two dominant industries
are wine and tourism. The number of jobs, the amount of money they
bring into the counties, and the amount of land devoted to these indus-
tries, are significant. Wine and tourism are closely aligned, with wine
tasting and other related activities enticing visitors to come from near
and far. Knowing that Napa and Sonoma are vying to be the nation’s
first 100 percent sustainable winegrowing region only added fuel to
our energy for this book—a natural follow up from our last book on
sustainable travel.
What we set out to do with this book was to get boots-on-the-ground
information from real, practicing winemakers and organic leaders. At
the first winery we visited, Martorana Family Winery in the Dry Creek
Valley, we were given the name and contact information for “Amigo Bob”
Cantisano, the consultant responsible for guiding Martorana through
their conversion to organic farming. Over the next few months, we con-
ducted a series of interviews with Amigo, who lives in the Sierra Nevada
foothills near Grass Valley. From him, we received thorough and tested
methods in sustainable viticulture, which became our chapters entitled
“Farming Techniques and Practices” and “Organically Treating Common
Vineyard Issues”. He gave us a detailed history of his involvement in
farming, in establishing California’s strong organic tradition, and some of
his specific experiences over his long career.
We interviewed Martorana in late August of 2017, and just over a
month later, on October 8th, fire broke out in both Sonoma and Napa.
Homes and wineries burned, evacuations were ordered, schools closed,
and smoke filled the skies for weeks. 43 lives were lost. For all of us in
the San Francisco North Bay, this conflagration snatched our attention
xvi Introduction
and disrupted our lives for months. That year, we thought the fire was
a one-off disaster, like an earthquake. A year later, on N ovember 8th,
2018, Northern California saw yet another fire, which this time razed the
city of Paradise, CA to the ground, tragically taking with it eighty-five
lives. Smoke filled the skies once more and we knew then that this may
very well be the new normal. 2019 and 2020 saw immense fires as well,
confirming that new normal. Climate change is real, and this is what it
looks like.
We knew we needed a perspective on how climate change is affecting
viticulture, and how winegrape growers can adapt to this warmer, cli-
mate. A whole book could be devoted to this subject, but we wanted to
keep our focus on organic and sustainable viticulture and how to practice
it. Some of our included properties, such as Matthiasson and Enterprise
Vineyards, are already taking measures for the changing climate in their
varietal choices, and Deerfield Ranch Winery was within the burn zone
and shared their experience with us during the interview with proprietor
PJ Rex.
The second half of the book is a series of case studies of various
wineries and vineyards, each of whom practice sustainable, natural,
organic, or Biodynamic® viticulture beginning with a series of outstand-
ing women-led, natural wine producers. Examples from the SF North
Bay follow, each of which is based on an in-person visit and interview
conducted with the owner, winemaker, or vineyardist.
Following the case studies is a guide on how to make wine as a home
winemaker and a terroir-focused look at one of Sonoma County’s newer
viticulture areas, the Petaluma Gap and the process for that AVA to be
recognized. For definitions of terms used throughout the text, see the
glossary after Petaluma Gap AVA.
This book is a concise and well-researched overview of the types of
sustainable wines and how to nurture healthy vines, particularly in the
Sonoma and Napa regions today. It includes the accounts of more than
a dozen diverse voices and fascinating individuals—all of whom share
a common love for the land, the grape, and the joy of bringing vibrant
wines to life!
We hope you enjoy reading the case studies as much as we enjoyed
preparing them.
CHAPTER 1
1
Biodynamic Wines & Vines. n.d. “Biodynamic Wines & Vines Exclusive,
Insider Info on the Wines + Wineries.” Biodynamic Wines & Vines | bd.wine,
https://bd.wine/certification
2
Sustainable Agriculture Network. January 2007. “History of Organic Farming
in the United States.” SARE, https://sare.org/publications/transitioning-to-
organic-production/history-of-organic-farming-in-the-united-states/
2 Healthy Vines, Pure Wines
For wine to be sold as organic, both the growing of the grapes and their
conversion to wine must be certified. This includes making sure grapes
are grown without synthetic fertilizers and in a manner that protects the
environment and preserves the soil. Other agricultural ingredients that go
into the wine, such as yeast, also have to be certified organic. Any nonag-
ricultural ingredients must be specifically allowed on the National List of
Allowed and Prohibited, and can’t exceed 5 percent of the total product.
And while wine naturally produces some sulfur dioxide (sulfites), they
can’t be added to organic wine. Sulfites are commonly added to wines to
stop the fermentation process, preserve the flavor profile, and keep the
wine from oxygenating.
Wines that are sold as “made with organic grapes” have different
requirements than organic wine. When a wine is labeled as being made
with organic grapes, 100 percent of those grapes used must be certified
organic. Yeast and any other agricultural ingredients aren’t required to
be organic, but have to be produced without excluded methods (like
genetic engineering). As for nonagricultural ingredients, these have to be
specifically allowed on the National List. Finally, sulfites may be added
to wines that carry the “made with organic grapes” label, up to 100 parts
per million.3
Organic certification is generally focused on prohibiting the use of
nonsynthetic materials on plants and soil, while sustainable certification
includes issues like energy use, waste management, water conservation,
and human resources.
The Sonoma County certification program does include a prohibition
of certain red listed pesticides and other materials, and a yellow list of
discouraged but allowed materials.4
3
Miles McEvoy and National Organic Program Deputy Administrator. Febru-
ary 21, 2017. “Organic 101: Organic Wine.” www.usda.gov, https://usda.gov/
media/blog/2013/01/08/organic-101-organic-wine
4
Sonoma County Winegrowers. 2020. “Certified Sustainable Wine | Sonoma
Co Sustainability Program.” Sonoma County Winegrowers, https://sonomawine-
grape.org/growers/sustainability/
Standards and Certifications 3
www.demeter-usa.org, https://demeter-usa.org/certification/
6
Morethanorganic. n.d. “Biodynamic Viticulture.” morethanorganic.com,
https://morethanorganic.com/biodynamic-viticulture
4 Healthy Vines, Pure Wines
Sustainability Certifications
While organics mainly concerns a focus on products used, sustainability
certifications are concerned with water and energy efficiency in the
vineyard and winery. They vary greatly because of the environmental
needs of differing regions and how organizations have decided to measure
efficiency.
7
The California Sustainable Winegrowing Alliance (CSWA). n.d. “California
Sustainable Winegrowing Alliance.” www.sustainablewinegrowing.org, https://
sustainablewinegrowing.org
Standards and Certifications 7
Napa Green
According to their website, Napa Green Land is currently an umbrella
program that recognizes growers with validated environmental compli-
ance and verified Farm Plans as meeting our standards for watershed
stewardship. These vineyard owners and managers develop custom,
whole-property Farm Plans to:
Sonoma Sustainable
In 2014, Sonoma County’s Winegrowers made a bold commitment: to
become the most sustainable winegrowing region in the world, and to that
end they created Sonoma Sustainable, a label supporting a countywide
effort to reach 100 percent sustainability in Sonoma County. The first phase
of this effort focuses on helping winegrowers assess their sustainable vine-
yard practices through trainings and educational sessions. Over 200 best
management practices are taken into account, such as land use, canopy
management, energy efficiency, water quality assessments, carbon emis-
sions. Vineyard acres are then assessed, and phase two involves the Sonoma
County Winegrowers working with vineyard owners to achieve certification.
8
Napa Green. n.d. “Napa Green—Caring for Nature Elevates Quality &
Experience.” Napa Green, https://napagreen.org
8 Healthy Vines, Pure Wines
Salmon-Safe
Focused on areas with fragile riparian areas, Salmon-Safe works with
West Coast farmers, viticulturists, developers, and other environmen-
tally innovative landowners to reduce watershed impacts through
rigorous third-party verified certification. In particular, rainwater run-
off, long-term soil conservation and a “whole farm,” approach which
includes nonvineyard crops and any noncropped areas, all aimed to
support salmon populations. Most recently, Salmon-Safe and Demeter
have harmonized standards so that West Coast vineyards that achieve
Biodynamic certification also earn Salmon-Safe certification.10
9
Patsy McGaughy. June 23, 2016. “LandSmart Program Offers Additional
Path to Napa Green Land Certification.” napavintners.com, https://napavint-
ners.com/press/press_release_detail.asp?ID_News=3621812
10
Salmon-Safe Inc. n.d. “Salmon-Safe Protects Rivers, Native Salmon and
Watersheds in the Pacific Northwest.” Salmon-Safe, https://salmonsafe.org
Standards and Certifications 9
On Label Clarity
Different wineries and vineyards featured in this book have chosen
to pursue various standards in line with their own personal goals.
For instance, there is a distinction between Certified Organic Wine,
Certified Organic Grapes, and Farmed Organically but not certified,
each of which tells the consumer how the grapes are grown and how the
wine is made.
Under the USDA National Organic Program, sulfites are classified
as a synthetic food additive and therefore are not allowed in organic
wine. Because of this, many winemakers do not pursue an organic wine
certification as they cannot guarantee a quality final product without
the addition of sulfites. Instead, many have chosen to farm their grapes
organically and use certified organic grapes in their winemaking.
Some have chosen to farm organically or Biodynamically but not go
through the certification process with reasons behind that choice as varied
as the winemakers themselves.
11
SIP Certified .n.d. “Sustainable Vineyards, Wineries and Wines | SIP
Certified.” www.sipcertified.org, https://sipcertified.org
10 Healthy Vines, Pure Wines