Case OM
Case OM
uk
Provided by CSCanada.net: E-Journals (Canadian Academy of Oriental and Occidental Culture, Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures)
YUAN Jia[a],*
[a]
School of Management and Economics, University of Electronic in LP. It produces miniature standard surface mount
Science and Technology of China, Chengdu, China.
* semiconductor consisting of transistors and diodes. The
Corresponding author.
products are used in electronic equipment, automotive
Received 11 April 2013; accepted 10 June 2013 industry, communication systems, broad band data
technology, computer and consumer electronic products,
etc. Operation management is the management of all the
Abstract resources and activities necessary to provide the market
This case illustrates the operations management with tangible goods and services (Chase, 2004). This
improvement journey of LP Semiconductor Co. Ltd. includes the systems and operations which creates and
What the teaching case describes includes strategic thrusts delivers the firm’s or the supply chain’s primary product
and priorities of improvement, design of operations, of services. It also includes the activities of planning,
managing of operations, and adaptation of operations. organizing, and controlling as well as the system design,
With the information provided by the case, participants operation and improvements in order to maximize the
could discuss the current situation and action for relationship between demand and supply. This case will
continued improvement from all dimensions of operations analyze the current situation and improvement areas of LP
management. From the teaching case, participants could Semiconductor Co. Ltd from all dimensions of operations
learn how to use the theories and methods of operations management.
management in actual business practice in order to
achieve the ultimate goal of manufacturing excellence. 1.2 Value Creating System of Industry
Key words: Case study; Operations management; Raw
Assembly Testing Wholesales
End product
Joint venture; Performance materials maker
Figure 1
YUAN Jia (2013). Manufacturing Excellence: A Case Study on the The Value Creating System in Semiconductor Industry
Improvement Journey of Operations Management. Management Science
and Engineering, 7 (3), 111-117. Available from: URL: http://www.cscanada. Regarding to LP, it is in Assembly and Testing, and the
net/index.php/mse/article/view/j.mse.1913035X20130703.2554 internal value creating system is:
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3968/j.mse.1913035X20130703.2554
Raw Assembly &
QA Inside shipping
materials testing
Figure 2
The Internal Value Creating System of LP
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction of LP Semiconductor Co. Ltd 1.3 Transformation Systems
LP was found on March 1st 1995. It is a joint venture LP is a manufacturing plant in semiconductor industry,
invested by ON Semiconductor and Ls Radio Company. which can be categorized as material processor, not as
As one of the most excellent semiconductor centers in an information processor or service processor. The plant
China, the company has been invested by more than produces semiconductor products, such as audion, diode
500 million dollars. There are two Final Assembly- and IC for manufactory of automobile and electronic
Test plants and one wafer fab in the company. Till product. In the process of producing, the WIP physical
now, there are more than 2000 employees are working goods are transferred from assembly to testing, then to
111 Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures
Manufacturing Excellence: A Case Study on the
Improvement Journey of Operations Management
QA, shipping warehouse, finally deliver to customers, engineer recourses and better geographical positions to
who are composed of companies of automobile (Delphi), attract technical talents. At the same time, they also have
electronic equipment ( Motorola, Nokia) and computer lower transport cost. The entry of local competitor triggers
appliance (Haier, Changhong), all of them are physical more fierce competition than before. Many competitors
properties. continue to develop new products and introduce new
technology on their products, such as using copper wire
1.4 Products & Services
instead of gold wire, producing in large amount on lead-
LP’s products are semiconductor components with the free components and provide total solution with lower
following characters: tangible, can be stored, production cost and high quality and reliability. It will be difficult
precedes consumption, low customer contact, can to attract new customers and retain current customers
be transported, quality is evidence. So we can think without new technology. Finally, it is hard to recruit
it produces “pure” goods, the operation output from qualified talents with high skills and retain them.
process is product. It also provides the service according
to demand by customer, such as quality issue analysis, 1.6.2 Dynamics
production line control system audit, etc. It is highly recommended to develop products with better
reliability and environmental protection to improve
1.5 Topology in Terms of 4Vs’ competition ability, which will challenge the internal
Regarding to the 4Vs (Volume, Variety, Variation and ability of R&D. It is hard for the competitors to enter the
Visibility), all dimensions have implications for the cost threshold of semiconductor, so the quantities of companies
of creating our products and services. The 4Vs analysis of participating in competition do not impact uncertainty a
LP is shown below, and the graphical analysis method is lot.
according to Slack (2001). From the technological perspective, inventions are
developing fast. Some competitors rapidly put into a large
amount of manpower and materials and strengthen new
Low Volume High development of products in order to introduce their new
technology on production line.
High Variety Low More and more international semiconductor entered
Chengdu, which is the capital of the Sichuan province.
Leshan is just a small city, so some skilled talents leave it
High Variation in demand Low
and search for more job opportunities in Chengdu. It has
already brought high level management’s attention to find
High Visibility Low a way to reduce brain drain and retain the talents.
1.6.3 Uncertainty
Since China joins WTO, local companies have more
Figure 3
The 4Vs Analysis of LP choices to select the suppliers from domestic and
international market with fair price. International
From the figure above, currently, it has high volume, companies can choose Chinese companies as their
low variety, low variation and low visibility to keep supplier as well, so the chance and risk coexist together.
processing cost down. Volume is high because of its high More and more multinational semiconductor
repeatability and systemization; variety is low because it companies are successful in China now, and the other
is routine and standardized; variation in demand is low international companies which do not enter Chinese
because it is stable and high utilization; visibility is low market may start to establish their local factories. In the
for the standardized manufacturing. meantime, the companies which already had production
lines in the developed regions of China may setup new
1.6 External Environment of the Organization
plants in the southwest of China due to low production
1.6.1 Complexity cost.
More and more customer in automobile, electronic/ The current customers may lose and it will be difficult
communication equipment and computer focus on to develop new customers if the competitors release new
environment-friendly product, small volume, and small high-tech products, because new technology introduction
power consumptive products, not merely quality. It is under high uncertainty.
requires that this type of products to meet the requirement Since China’s reform and opening-up in 1978, people
of customer should be introduced by strong R&D support. change their jobs more frequently than before, especially
Before, the primary competitor is outside of China, the after the reform of state-owned enterprises. The primary
advantage is lower cost comparing with the competitor; reason is that they continue to look for job opportunities
but right now, some semiconductor plant were established with higher salary, which will be in conflict with cost
to produce the same products in China with better reduction of manufacturing plants.
Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures 112
YUAN Jia (2013).
Management Science and Engineering, 7 (3), 111-117
Table 1
Characterization of External Environment
Item Customers Competitors Technology Labor Communities and other
stakeholders
Complexity Moderate High High High Moderate
Dynamics Moderate High High High Moderate
Uncertainty High High High Moderate Moderate
Volume
100 Remark: I—Important rating; P—Performance rating
80
Variety Efficiency (cost) The importance-performance matrix
60 Current
40 Future Good 1
20 Better than 2 Excess? B E A
3 C ^
Dependability 0 Functionality (quality)
Performance 4 Appropriate F
against Same as 5
competitions
6 +
7 D
Reliability Flexibility 8 Improve G Urgent action
Worse than 9
Bad 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Speed
Remark:
should know what the competitive factors are, what the D indicates “Flexibility”
E indicates “Cost”
competitor influences are, and then we can determine the F indicates “Quantity”
priorities to improve. G indicates “Innovation”
113 Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures
Manufacturing Excellence: A Case Study on the
Improvement Journey of Operations Management
From the above, we can see that quality, speed, A. High volume/ low variety: LP produces
dependability, quantity and cost fall into “Appropriate” semiconductor components of over 100 million one week,
area, flexibility falls into “Improve” area and innovation and different varieties of products do not affect the basic
falls into “Urgent Action” area. So “innovation” should production process, so the variety is low.
get the highest priority, especially when compared with B. Repetitive: It produces one type of package on a
others. production line.
C. Large predictability: The output is based on the
capacity of production line.
3. DESIGN OF OPERATIONS
3.3 Design of Operations Network
3.1 Design of Products/Services 3.3.1 Forward/Backward Integration
Current Situation Current situation:
It currently focuses on producing common The following figure shows the current direction,
s e m i c o n d u c t o r c o m p o n e n t s b a s e d o n d i ff e r e n t extent and balance of vertical integration for LP.
requirements from customers.
A. Concept generation stage Domestic
At this stage, the ideas are basically from research and
development (R&D) engineers. R&D is responsible for
Raw material Assembly and Wholesales End customers
developing new knowledge and ideas in order to solve suppliers testing (internal)
particular problems or to grasp an opportunity. Narrow process span
B. Concept screening stage International
At this stage, it will detect whether the idea could be Wide process span
Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures 114
YUAN Jia (2013).
Management Science and Engineering, 7 (3), 111-117
D. Transportation Cost: Both raw materials and finish E. Community Factors: Since LP gets strong support
goods must be transported from or to Chengdu airport, from the local government, some preferential policies are
and the cost is high. published for LP specially, such as low tax rates.
Table 3
The Comparison Table with Chengdu
Land Cost Labor Cost Energy Cost Transportation Cost Community Factors
Leshan low low low high normal
Chengdu high high normal low good
115 Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures
Manufacturing Excellence: A Case Study on the
Improvement Journey of Operations Management
Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures 116
YUAN Jia (2013).
Management Science and Engineering, 7 (3), 111-117
JIT is a pull system basically. LP has deployed LSS (Lean Expectation in Future
Six Sigma) in the whole plant, and there are over twenty Trainers could learn new ways to make the class
project teams to focus on lean production in order to interesting and fun, and more on-job training could be
improve productivity and reduce cost. Managers simply provided.
process with lean tools to make internal and external
satisfaction. It not only makes effective process, but also
has a good inventory control. At the same time, activities CONCLUSION
of CI teams help to improve the productivity in the The teaching case uses the theory and methodology
production lines. regarding to operations management to analyze the current
Expectation in Future situation, and then come up with the corresponding
JIT activities could not be limited to the manufacturing solutions to the existed problems for improvement.
department, but be deployed in other departments as well, Future discussions could focus on the areas of managerial
especially in supplier chain. Poor inventory will cause coherence (leadership, decision making) and formulation
unpredictability in an operation, and unpredictability of operations strategy.
causes waste.
REFERENCES
5. ADAPTATION OF OPERATIONS Anderson, J. C., Schroeder, R. G., Tupy, S. E., & White, E. M.
(1982). Material requirements planning systems: The state
5.1 Knowledge Management of the art. Production and Inventory Management, 23(4),
Current Situation 51- 66.
LP pays more attention on knowledge management. Cachon, G. (2004). The allocation of inventory risk in a supply
A committee named T&E (teaching and education) is chain: Push, pull and advance-purchase discount contracts.
responsible for knowledge introduction, which is directly Management Science, 50(2), 222-238.
managed by HR manager. Some technique courses related Chase, R. B., Jacobs, F. R., & Aquilano, N. J. (2004). Operations
to product are introduced for production engineers and management for competitive advantage (10th ed.). New
technicians, such as technical ladder, TPM introduction, York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
and technical paper forum. Special training lab is Hahn, G. J., & Kuhn, H. (2012). Value-based performance and
established for the operators, such as general electronic risk management in supply chains: A robust optimization
knowledge training, and some excellent operators could approach. International Journal of Production Economics,
design the training courses to share their experience. 139(1), 135-144.
Basic management skill training courses are designed to Hambrick D. C., & Mason. P. A. (1984). Upper-echelons: The
train managers, such as how to do a presentation, how organization as a reflection of its top managers. Academy of
to manage a meeting, how to manage a project and how Management Review, 9(2), 193-206.
to communicate with their team and boss. Knowledge Kimura, O., & Terada, H. (1981). Design and analysis of
sharing and introduction of the company about culture and pull system, a method of multistage production control.
the industry standard is designed for all employees. For International Journal of Production Research, 19(3), 241-
example, when an audit is started, the trainings about the 253.
requirements and procedures are provided to employees to Slack, N., Chambers, S., & Johnston, R. (2004). Operations
know the details. Management (4th ed.). London: FT Prentice Hall.
Expectation in Future Sugimori, Y., Kusunoki, K., Cho, F., & Uchikawa, S.
In the post-industrial era, the success of a corporation lies (1977). Toyota production system and Kanban system
more in its social assets—its corporate IQ and learning materialization of just-in-time and respect-for-human
capacity—than in its physical assets (Zohar, 1997). It system. International Journal of Production Research, 15,
should pay more attention on the feedback to improve 553-564.
knowledge introduction. T&E committee should help Wikner, J., Naim, M. M., & Rudberg, M. (2007). Exploiting
introducer to update knowledge to the team level and the the order book for mass customized manufacturing control
organization level. systems with capacity limitation. IEEE Transactions on
Engineering Management, 54 (1), 145-155.
5.2 Motivate Learning & Sharing of Information Zohar, D. (1997). Rewiring the corporate brain: Using the new
Current Situation science to rethink how we structure and lead organizations.
Currently, most of the training courses force employees San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
to participate, and it is difficult to achieve the objective of
the training. On the other hand, in order to develop good
training courses, LP awards good trainers every year.
117 Copyright © Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures