Water Treatment IN Boilers: Dew Speciality Chemicals (P) LTD K-47, UPSIDC Site-V, Kasna, Greater Noida-201306, India
Water Treatment IN Boilers: Dew Speciality Chemicals (P) LTD K-47, UPSIDC Site-V, Kasna, Greater Noida-201306, India
TREATMENT
IN
BOILERS
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Increased need for maximum operating efficiency and optimum fueland water
usage with modern boilers has given new dimensions to today's water treatment
practices. The objective of this booklet is to outline the recommendations for
water treatment practices to provide troublefree, efficient boiler operations with
minimum risk of tube failures.
Based on the pressure rating, boilers can be classified as high pressure, medium
pressure and low pressure boilers. Generally, boilers operating above 22 Kg/cm2
are considered as high pressure boilers. Those operating below 10 kg/cm2 are
considered as low pressure boilers. Medium pressure boilers are those operating
between these values.
c) Super Heater : Boilers operating with super heaters can tolerate lesser
dissolved solids as compared to boilers operating without the same.
f) Heat Flux : The tolerance limit for dissolved solids is lower for having
high heat flux compared to a boiler operating at the same pressure, but
with lower heat flux.
Treatment used for the removal or reduction of calcium, magnesium, silica and
other impurities (with the use of plant treatment) before water reaches the boiler.
Treatment by which water treatment chemicals are added in the boiler feed water
to prevent scaling, corrosion, priming and foaming in the boiler.
For modern boilers for their trouble free operation, a combination of both internal
and external treatments have to be practised.
b) To prevent scale and deposit formation, corrosion and other water related
problems.
Generally the first step in water processing involves coagulation and removal of
suspended solids. Natural settling will remove only relatively coarse suspended
solids. This process is generally speeded up by coagulation. Coagulation is the
process by which finely divided materials combined by chemical means to
produce larger particles capable of repid settling. Typical coagulant chemicals
used are alum and ferrous sulphate. The preliminary treatment sometimes
includes aeration and chlorination. Aeration is used for removal of
undesirable gases and volatile impurities (e.g. hydrogen sulphide, carbon dioxide,
volatile organics) and iron and magnese if present are oxidised and precipitated
for subsequent removal by coagulation and filtration.
4.3. Filtration
a) Reaction is slow.
This is the simplest ion exchange process wherein calcium and magnesium in the
water are removed and replace by sodium. Nothing else is changed so that the
solids remain the same when the resin is exhausted it can be regenerated with the
saturation solution of sodium chloride. Calcium and magnesium are discharged to
waste.
DEALKALISATION
DEMINERALISATION
This process uses two types of resins either in separate units or as mixture in a
single unit. One resin removes all metal ions (calcium, magnesium and sodium
etc.) and the other removes all the acid ions (sulphate, chloride, bicarbonate,
silica etc.). The result is a water virtually free of dissolved solids.
EVAPORATION
REVERSE OSMOSIS
This is a more recent method which in effect means pumping the water at high
pressure through a special membrane which allows only the water through
trapping the dissolved solids. This process is very efficient and can also be
used as treatment preceeding ion exchange demineralisation. When used
ahead of the demineraliser, the regeneration cost is substantially reduced and the
resin life is extended.
DEAERATION
Dissolved oxygen in water produces corrosion and pitting in the boiler system.
Oxygen removal is accomplished in deaerators which are of two types viz,
pressure deaerators and vacuum deaerators.
Pressure deaerators break up water into spray or film then sweep the steam across
and through it to force out the dissolved gases. In this process, oxygen content
can be reduced to a level of 0.007 ppm. close to the limit of chemical
detectability.
Vacuum deaertors use mechanical pumps to create required vacuum. The degree
of vacuum depends on the water temperature. The oxygen residual from these
deaerators is usually of the order of 0.2 ppm.
To chemically adjust or balance water inside the boiler to prevent scale formation,
inhibit corrosion, steam contamination and embrittlement.
Even with sophisticated external treatment plants. Some impurities always enter
the boiler either through feed or condensate. Therefore, there is a need for the
internal treatment in some from to practically all boilers. The amount and type of
chemicals used depends on plant operating conditions and the feed water analysis.
6.0 Corrosion
Corrosion can take place in the pre-boiler system (feed water heaters and piping),
the boiler (boiler drums and tubes) and the post boiler system (steam-condensate
equipment and piping).
Oxygen acts by accelerating the reaction of iron and water. It can react with iron
hydroxide to form a hydreated ferric oxide or hematite. This action is generally
localised and forms a pit in the metal. When the pit becomes progressively
anodic, severe corrosion results. At the cathodic surface oxygen reacts
with hydrogen and depolarises the surface permitting more iron to dissolve at
the anode creating a pit.
Hydrazine reacts with iron oxide to form passive magnetite and reduces cupric
oxide to passive cuprous oxide. Magnetite acts as barrier against further corrosion
and metal pick up by the condensate is generally reduced. Demonstrates ability of
catalysed hydrazine to reduce ferric to ferrous iron. In order to be effective the
dosage of oxygen scavenger in the feed water must be such that it results in the
recommended reserve of the chemical in the boiler water. This reserve of
Carbonic acid in the condensate causes corrosion in the past boiler section. For
neutralising carbon dioxide in the condensate addition of alkaline salts such as
caustic soda in the feed water does not help since the salt does not volatalise and
go into steam phase.
For this purpose organic chemicals known as neutralising amines which can
volatalise and go into the steam phase and can react with carbondioxide instantly
when the condensate is formed are used.
Distribution Coefficient
Distribution Coefficient is the ratio of amine in the steam phase to that in the
condensate. An amine having a distribution coefficient of less than 1 can protect
only the nearest hot section, while one having distribution coefficient of greater
than 1, can protect only farthest cold section in the condensate system. In order to
offer the maximum protection to all parts of condensate system, it is essential to
use products that have a broad spectrum distribution coefficient.
Filming amines offer protection against both oxygen and carbon dioxide by
forming a thin, protective water repellant on the metal surfaces in the condensate
system.
Either of these may contribute to carryover of boiler water into the system. This
reduces efficiency, as water contains only sensible heat and will reduce the heat
content of the system. Damage to the post boiler equipment, particularly turbines
and damage to process may also result.
Priming is the ejection of boiler water into the steam take off and in general
results from factors associated with boiler operation. There are several possible
causes.
Foaming is due to the chemical composition of the water. Pure water does not
foam and in a boiler steam bubbles are large, rising quickly to the surface, and
bursting quickly. In the presence of certain dissolved or suspended substances,
the surface is altered and the steam bubbles remain small. Therefore, they do
not rise quickly and in effect expand the water foam over into the steam off
take. Common cases are :
All these water conditions can be adjusted by blowdown or varying the addition of
water treatment chemicals and it is usual to limit the dissolved solids in the boiler
to a point where it is known that carryover will not occur. The maximum limit is
stipulated by the boiler manufacturer but not be too low, as blow down represents
loss of heat and chemicals.
7.1 Antifoams
At high temperature silica is volatile and will enter the steam in the vapour phase,
forming deposits on turbine blades as it cools. This phenomenon commences at
about 40 Kg/Sq.cm. g and becomes increasingly serious as the pressure increases.
If the silica content of the steam is kept below 0.02 ppm, there is usually no
problem and this is assured by limiting the boiler water silica content, the value
depending on the pressure and alkalinity.
9.0 Conclusion
Scaling and corrosion in boiler internal heat transfer surfaces are the major
problems faced by the industry. With the result, conventional treatment accepted
for boiler feed a decade ago can no more be applied for the modern boilers. Water
is the blood line in every boiler. Water treatment specialists are the best doctors
who can help in providing sound health to the boilers. Even those boilers
operating trouble fee and smoothly need annual check up by the water doctors.
This will prevent boiler tube failures and sudden break-downs.
Needless to say long term troublefree operation demand, periodic control test on
feed water, boiler water, steam and condensate return. Therefore, every effort
should be made to scrutinise claims for cure all treatment and miraculous gadget
before deciding on a treatment or making a change in the existing treatment.
Drum Operating Pressure psig 0-300 301-450 541-600 601-750 751-900 901-1000 1001-1500 1501-2000
(1) (11) (MPa) (0-2.07) (2.08- (3.11- (4.15- (5.18- (6.22- (6.90- (10.35-
3.10) 4.14) 5.17) 6.21) 6.89) 10.34) 13.79)
Feedwater (7)
Dissolved oxygen ppm (mg/l) O2 measured <0.007 <0.007 <0.007 <0.007 <0.007 <0.007 <0.007 <0.007
before chemical oxygen scavenger addition
(8)
Total iron ppm (mg/l) Fe <0.1 <0.05 <0.03 <0.025 <0.02 <0.02 <0.01 <0.01
Total copper ppm (mg/l) Cu <0.05 <0.025 <0.02 <0.02 <0.015 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01
Total hardness ppm (mg/l) CaCO3 <0.3 <0.3 <0.2 <0.2 <0.1 <0.05 ND ND
pH range @ 25°C 8.3-10 8.3-10 8.3-10 8.3-10 8.3-10 8.8-9.6 8.8-9.6 8.8-9.6
Chemicals for preboiler system protection NS NS NS NS NS VAM VAM VAM
Nonvolatile TOC ppm (mg/l) C (6) <1 <1 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.2 <0.2 <0.2
Oily matter ppm (mg/l) <1 <1 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.2 <0.2 <0.2
Boiler Water
Silica ppm (mg/l) SiO2 <150 <90 <40 <30 <20 <8 <2 <1
Total alkalinity ppm (mg/l) CaCO3 <700 (3) <600 (3) <500 (3) <200 (3) <150 (3) <100 (3) NS (4) NS (4)
Free hydroxide ppm (mg/l) CaCO3 (2) NS NS NS NS NS NS ND (4) ND (4)
Unneutralized conductivity µmhos/cm (µS/cm) 5400- 4600- 3800- 1500- 1200- 1000- <150 <80
25°C (12) 1100 (5) 900 (5) 800 (5) 300 (5) 200 (5) 200 (5)
NS = Not specified
ND = Not detectable
VAM = Use only volatile alkaline materials upstream of attemperation water source (10)
NOTES TO TABLE
(1) With local heat fluxes >1.5 x 105 Btu/hr/ft2 (>473.2 kW/m2), use values for at least the next higher pressure range.
(2) Minimum hydroxide alkalinity concentrations in boilers below 900 psig (6.21 MPa) must be individually specified by
a qualified water treatment consultant with regard to silica solubility and other components of internal treatment.
(3) Maximum total alkalinity consistent with acceptable steam purity. If necessary, should override conductance as
blow-down control parameter. If makeup is demineralized quality water and boiler operates at less than 1000 psig (6.89
(4) Not detectable in these cases refers to free sodium or potassium hydroxide alkalinity. Some small variable amount
of total alkalinity will be present and measurable with the assumed congruent or co-ordinated phosphate-pH control or
volatile treatment employed at these high pressure ranges.
(5) Maximum values are often not achievable without exceeding maximum total alkalinity values, especially in boilers
below 900 psig (6.21 MPa) with >20% makeup of water whose total alkalinity is >20% of TDS naturally or after pre-
treatment by lime-soda, or sodium cycle ion exchange softening. Actual permissible conductance values to achieve any
desired steam purity must be established for each case by careful steam purity measurements. Relationship between
conductance and steam purity is affected by too many variables to allow its reduction to a simple list of tabulated
values.
(6) Nonvolatile TOC is that organic carbon not intentionally added as part of the water treatment regime.
(7) Boilers below 900 psig (6.21 MPa) with large furnaces, large steam release space, and internal chelant, polymer,
and/or antifoam treatment can sometimes tolerate higher levels of feedwater impurities than those in the table and still
achieve adequate deposition control and steam purity. Removal of these impurities by external pretreatment is always a
more positive solution. Alternatives must be evaluated as to practicality and economics in each individual case.
(9) Achievable steam purity depends on many variables, including boiler water total alkalinity and specific conductance
as well as design of boiler steam drum internals and operating conditions [(Note (5)]. Since boilers in this category
require a relatively high degree of steam purity for protection of the superheaters and turbines, more stringent steam
purity requirements such as process steam restrictions on individual chemical species or restrictions more stringent
than 0.1 ppm (mg/l) TDS turbine steam purity must be addressed specifically.
(10) As a general rule, the requirements for attemperation spray water quality are the same as those for steam purity.
In some cases boiler feedwater is suitable; however, frequently additional purification is required. In all cases the spray
water should be obtained from a source that is free of deposit forming and corrosive chemicals such as sodium
hydroxide, sodium sulfite, sodium phosphate, iron, and copper. The suggested limits for spray water quality are <30
ppb (µg/l) TDS maximum, <10 ppb (µg/l) Na maximum, <20 ppb (µg/l) SiO2 maximum, and it should be essentially
oxygen free.
(11) Low pressure boilers frequently use feedwater that is suitable for use in higher pressure boilers. In these cases the
boiler water chemistry limits should be based on the pressure range that is most consistent with the feedwater quality.
(12) Conversion from ppm (mg/l) TDS values in the ABMA standards [12] used a factor of 0.65.